What is the deal with Breslav in current times?
Asked on November 11, 2026
Answer
Look, Breslov Chassidut was founded by Rabbi Nachman of Breslov, who was kodesh kodeshim, a holy tzaddik and a descendant of the Baal Shem Tov. His teachings, especially in Likutei Moharan, are profound and authentic Torah. The problem is that today, many people who call themselves Breslovers are not actually following what Rabbi Nachman taught. They're wearing a costume. Rabbi Nachman himself said very clearly in Likutei Moharan that his talmidim can learn his sefer as much as they want, but they cannot forget or avoid even a single letter in the Shulchan Aruch. You have to learn Shulchan Aruch, Gemara, Chumash, and all the basics of Torah even before you learn Likutei Moharan. That's what he said. Today, many people think Breslov is about breakdancing in the streets, going to Uman, wearing certain clothing, and just being happy all the time. But that's not what Rabbi Nachman taught. Real Breslov is about deep Torah learning, working on your brit, working on your mitzvot, and developing genuine closeness to Hashem. In Sichot HaRan, Rabbi Nachman says clearly that the main key of serving Hashem is fear of punishment. That's the foundation and beginning before you talk about anything related to emunah or about Hashem. Not dancing around saying "emunah, emunah." The lowest level of fear, meaning the foundation, is fear of Gehenom. Rabbi Nachman himself said that hopefully the tzaddikim in his generation would reach fear of Hashem. He wasn't even talking about love of Hashem, because love of Hashem is not relevant to most people. There are serious talmidei chachamim in Breslov who are tzaddikim, and you should kiss their feet. But for every one talmid chacham I know from Breslov, there are a thousand that are problematic. Many are simply wearing the exterior, they have the peyot and the lingo, but they don't know how to keep Shabbat properly, or they're dishonest in business, or they're immoral. The reality is that authentic Chassidut means doing above and beyond the law. Real Breslovers, real Chabadniks, real chassidim are kodesh kodeshim. But when you go to a place with thirty or fifty thousand people pushing and shoving, those are not tzaddikim, those are not chassidim. Tzaddikim don't push and shove. If a person is following the halacha, learning Torah every day, keeping kosher, family purity, modesty, and everything else, whether they're Chabad, Breslov, Satmar, Sephardi, Ashkenazi, or Litvish, it doesn't make a difference. If they follow the halacha, it's good. But if they're not following the halacha, then it's not good. So Breslov has a proper role when it follows what Rabbi Nachman actually taught. But today, unfortunately, the further you are from the source with no leader, the further you are from reality. Many calling themselves Breslovers today are confused, and they need to wake up and start actually learning what Rabbi Nachman of Breslov really said.