Йезекииль 18:20 почему этот стих христианский мир понимает как со смертью человека умирает его душа и прощаются его грехи? ответьте пожалуйста на русском
Asked on November 15, 2026
Answer
Christianity has a fundamentally distorted interpretation of Ezekiel 18:20 that completely contradicts what the Torah actually teaches. The verse in Yechezkel clearly states: "The soul that sins, it shall die. The son shall not bear the iniquity of the father, nor shall the father bear the iniquity of the son. The righteousness of the righteous shall be upon him, and the wickedness of the wicked shall be upon him." This pasuk explicitly teaches individual responsibility – every person is accountable for their own sins, period. Nobody gets punished for someone else's actions, and nobody can take away your sins for you. But Christianity took this principle and turned it completely upside down. They claim that their man died for everyone's sins – not just for the people of his generation, not just for past sins, but for sins that people would commit thousands of years into the future. This is absolutely against the Torah. They're saying he died so that anyone today can commit any sin they want – murder, theft, immorality, anything – and as long as they believe in him, they won't be punished. It's a "get out of jail free" card to destroy society. The difference is critical: The Torah does teach that when a tzaddik dies, it can bring atonement for the sins of that generation – the people alive at that time, for the sins they already committed up to that point. This encourages people to do teshuva and change their future actions. But Christianity says their idol died for future sins of future people. That's completely fabricated and against everything the Torah stands for. As for sins being forgiven at death – this is another area where Christianity and Judaism are worlds apart. In Judaism, death itself does provide a certain level of atonement, but it absolutely does not automatically wipe away all sins. The level of atonement depends entirely on the severity of the sins and what the person did during their lifetime. The Gemara in Masechet Shabbat teaches us clearly: there is no death without transgression. Everyone who dies, dies because of sin, with only four exceptions throughout all of history – Amram, Yishai, Binyamin, and Keilav. These four died only because of the original sin of Adam HaRishon, not their own sins. For a regular person, death can be part of the atonement process, but it works differently depending on the type of sin. Some sins only require you to say you're sorry to Hashem and do proper teshuva. Other sins require teshuva plus waiting for Yom Kippur. More severe sins require teshuva, Yom Kippur, and suffering in this world. And there are certain sins where even all of that is not enough – death begins the process of atonement, but it doesn't complete it instantly. Chilul Hashem is a special case. For desecrating Hashem's name, teshuva alone is not enough, Yom Kippur is not enough, and suffering is not enough. All of them together only suspend the punishment, but the actual purging and forgiveness only begins with death. As it says in Yeshayahu chapter 22, verse 14, Hashem says this sin will not be atoned for you until you die. Now, there are certain severe sins where if a person dies without doing teshuva, the consequences are permanent and eternal. If someone desecrates Shabbat their entire life and dies as a mechalel Shabbat without teshuva, they go to the seventh level of Gehinnom and don't come out. Even when Mashiach comes, even after resurrection of the dead, such a person remains in Gehinnom forever. The same applies to someone who dies without teshuva for wasting seed. This is not temporary punishment. The soul burns in Gehinnom for millions of years until it's completely destroyed. The only thing that remains is the part of Hashem that He placed in it, and that part returns to Him, but the soul itself is destroyed forever. This is why teshuva must happen during life. While a person is alive, they can do teshuva. If they do teshuva, they don't need to worry. But if they don't do teshuva, they have a very serious permanent problem. Christianity's fairy tale that you can sin your entire life and then be forgiven automatically at death because someone else died for you 2,000 years ago is completely against the Torah and against basic logic. It's spiritual nonsense designed to give people permission to be wicked. The Torah teaches personal responsibility, measure for measure judgment, and the absolute necessity of teshuva while you're still alive.