BeEzrat HaShem
Back to Q&A

Is freewill in conflict with Divine omniscience?

Asked on November 16, 2026

Answer

No, free will is not in conflict with Divine omniscience. This is one of the most fundamental questions people ask, and I'll explain it in a way you can understand. Hashem knows the past, present, and future - but for Him, they're all the same. He exists outside of time. We humans are bound by time, so we see past, present, and future as separate. But Hashem created time, so He's not limited by it. Here's how to understand it: Let's say I wrote down on a piece of paper everything you're going to do for the next week. I seal it in an envelope, put it in a safe, and you don't open it until the week is over. When you open it and see I predicted everything correctly - did my knowledge change your choices? No. You still did what you wanted to do that whole week. The same applies to Hashem. His knowledge of what you will choose does not force you to make that choice. You still choose independently. If Hashem forced your choices, then reward and punishment would make no sense - why would He punish you for something He made you do? Why would He reward you for something you had no choice in? This is why the Gemara teaches: "Hakol bidei Shamayim chutz miyirat Shamayim" - everything is in the hands of Heaven except the fear of Heaven. Whether you're born or die, rich or poor, tall or short - Hashem decides. But whether you will follow His Torah and fear Him - that choice is entirely yours. The Rambam himself writes that the complete understanding of free will is beyond human comprehension - you would have to be God Himself to fully understand it. But what I've explained is enough for us to grasp: Hashem's knowledge doesn't interfere with our choice. He sees all possibilities and all outcomes simultaneously, but He doesn't tamper with which path we choose. This is not just philosophy - it's the foundation of everything. Without real free will, there's no justice, no accountability, no purpose to creation. This is one of the thirteen principles of faith: Hashem rewards the righteous and punishes the wicked. If we had no free choice, this entire system would collapse. So yes, Hashem knows what you will choose, but you still make that choice freely. And you will be held accountable for it.

BH Headquarters