BeEzrat HaShem
Back to Q&A

What was Rav Shteinmann position on men joining the army?

Asked on November 11, 2026

Answer

Rav Shteinman's position on men joining the army was nuanced and changed based on circumstances. Initially, he supported the idea that young men who were not truly learning Torah - those wasting time in yeshiva, smoking cigarettes, playing on their phones, or getting into trouble - should go to the army rather than fill up spots in yeshiva. He felt that if they weren't dedicating themselves to Torah study, the army would at least provide them with structure and keep them from sinning. However, his position evolved when he saw what was actually happening. When the reality became clear that the army's agenda was not about defense but about secularizing religious Jews - about changing them, exposing them to immodesty, and pulling them away from Torah - he changed his stance completely. Later in his life, Rav Shteinman became firm that yeshiva students should not be drafted at all. He even had all his bachurim sign papers stating they were willing to die for the sake of Torah rather than be drafted into the army. This was based on what the Gedolei Yisrael observed: that the army had become a tool for spiritual destruction, not protection. The key point is this: if someone is truly toiling in Torah, even if they're of average or below-average intellect, they should be left learning. Their Torah learning is what protects Am Yisrael, not weapons. But someone just filling a seat and doing nothing should find productive work or yes, even the army, rather than waste time and bring a bad name to the yeshiva world.

BH Headquarters