BeEzrat HaShem
Back to Q&A

KAvod HaRav I have a Kasha, Kasha: Tosfos In Baba Basra 59a D"H Hachut, says: It's not the way to have the son mentioned before his father in a Torah Machlokes unless the son is the greatest in the generation (Like R'oshaya In Eruvin 53). Now, Tosfos In Kesubos 105a D"H Dchashuv says: If two Tannaim are arguing, then the one who's Yichus is greater or if he's a nasi, then he's mentioned first, even if the Tana he's up against is greater then him in Torah. So Lchorah it's a kasha - in a case where the father is a nasi and the son is greater then him in Torah, who would we say gets mentioned first??? Please elaborate on the answer & source it thank you.

Asked on January 17, 2021

Answer

Audio Answer

BH Headquarters
KAvod HaRav I have a Kasha, Kasha: Tosfos In Baba Basra 5 | BeEzrat HaShem