BeEzrat HaShem
Back to Q&A

is it correct to say that most decrees that we get here on earth are a mix of justice and mercy?

Asked on November 15, 2026

Answer

Yes, that's correct. Everything is both. Every single suffering that a person has in their life will have at least a little bit of both. Part of it will be for repentance for some sin they've committed, part of it will be to elevate them, and part of it to punish them. It's not black and white where this specific suffering is only to elevate them or only to punish them. Everything has a little bit of both. Hashem has different things that sometimes can begin as a punishment but also as an obstacle for us to overcome that could yield us an enormous reward that we would not be able to get any other way. You need to understand how HaKadosh Baruch Hu originally created the world. Initially, when He created the world, He created it with judgment alone. He saw that the world would not survive with just judgment, so He added mercy. And there was mercy for a very long time, bringing endless blessings to mankind to the point where they literally enjoyed heaven on earth. But instead of being grateful to Hashem, they said what do we need Hashem for. That's what brought them to many sins, and Hashem destroyed the world in the flood. Now He implemented the judgment again like in the beginning, meaning now it's a balance. The world now operates with both judgment and mercy together. In this world, HaKadosh Baruch Hu has mercy because He gives us time despite our sins. Despite our mistakes, we have more time, more opportunities, more chances. But once a person dies, there's simply judgment. In Olam HaZeh, the decrees we receive are a mixture of judgment and mercy. Hashem can postpone punishment, give us another year, more time to do teshuva. That's why we say Avinu Malkeinu, our Father our King, because as our Father He can act with mercy, and as the King He enforces the judgment. But understand this, in Shamayim, in the eternal world, there is no mercy, there is just judgment. If you did good, you get good. If you did bad, you get bad.

BH Headquarters