Как же понять стих из Иезекииль 18:20? Душа согрешающая та умрет
Asked on November 15, 2026
Answer
The verse in Yechezkel 18:20 teaches us a fundamental principle: HaNefesh HaChote'et Hi Tamut - the soul that sins, it shall die. This means that every person is responsible for their own sins and will face the consequences directly. The son does not bear the iniquity of the father, nor does the father bear the iniquity of the son. The righteousness of the righteous shall be upon him, and the wickedness of the wicked shall be upon him. Chazal explain this verse to teach us two critical truths. First, there is no death without transgression. When a person dies, it is not random - it is because of sin. Whether it is an intentional sin or an unintentional sin, every death has a spiritual cause. The car accident, the disease, the coronavirus - these are merely tools that Hashem uses. The real reason someone dies is because of their aveirot. Second, this verse establishes the principle of measure for measure. A righteous person gets rewarded, and a wicked person gets punished. Each person stands alone before Hashem with their own deeds. You cannot rely on your father being a rabbi or your grandfather being a tzaddik. As long as you are alive, you must continue growing spiritually, learning more Torah, and doing teshuva. The past will not carry weight if you stop being righteous now. The deeper meaning is that when the verse says the soul shall die, it is talking about both this world and the next. For someone who dies without doing teshuva for serious sins like being mechalel Shabbat, wasting seed, or idol worship, this death extends beyond the physical - their soul faces eternal consequences in Gehinnom. This is why we must take every sin seriously and do teshuva immediately, not waiting until tomorrow.