Back to Q&A
When tragedy strikes a tzaddik's family - their house burns down and then shortly after their child dies - how are we supposed to understand this through Torah eyes rather than saying it's just bad luck?
Asked on November 12, 2026
Answer
Audio Answer
There is no bad luck; everything is from HaShem's Divine Providence. The suffering of tzaddikim—even loss of home or child—is never random. It serves as an atonement for the generation's sins, or to spare them from witnessing tragedy. This atonement, however, only takes effect if we recognize it as a divine message for our collective wrongdoing and respond with teshuvah (repentance). Dismissing such events as "bad luck" negates their purpose and can lead to further misfortune. Instead, a Jew asks: "What teshuvah must I do?" recognizing that all events have HaShem's direct involvement and purpose.