BeEzrat HaShem
Back to Q&A

What does the Torah say about making deals with terrorists who return to attack us?

Asked on November 17, 2026

Answer

Audio Answer

The Torah explicitly forbids redeeming captives for excessive value (Mishnah Gittin 45a), as this incentivizes future terror—a pattern proven by the Gilad Shalit deal's link to Oct 7th. While some consider immediate danger, the Torah warns that "peace" agreements with terrorists like Hamas, whose faith mandates killing Jews, only allow them to rearm. As David HaMelech and Yeshayahu confirm, their goal is destruction; "there is no shalom for the wicked." The Torah mandates killing terrorists immediately, an obligation for self-defense, not jailing or negotiating. Modern Israel's anti-Torah policies—releasing terrorists and jailing defenders—are illogical, dangerous, and directly cause repeat atrocities. We must follow Hashem's commands over political expediency.

BH Headquarters