BeEzrat HaShem
Back to Q&A

but is the whole dancing gig totally wrong or does it have a place in the ideology?

Asked on November 11, 2026

Answer

Listen, you're asking a very important question because there's massive confusion today about what Breslov really is. Let me be very clear with you: Rabbi Nachman of Breslov was kodesh kodeshim, a holy tzaddik and grandson of the Baal Shem Tov. His writings, especially Likutei Moharan, are authentic Torah at the highest level. But what you see today with people breakdancing in the streets, driving around in vans with club music, wearing funny hats and dancing around - that's not Rabbi Nachman. That's not what he taught. That's a complete misrepresentation. One of the Gedolei HaDor actually called these versions "the lost tribes of India that have somehow found themselves in Israel." Rabbi Nachman himself said very clearly in Likutei Moharan that his talmidim can learn his sefer as much as they want, but they cannot forget or avoid even a single letter in the Shulchan Aruch. You have to learn Shulchan Aruch, you have to learn Gemara, you have to learn Chumash, you have to learn all the basics of Torah even before you learn Likutei Moharan. That's what he said. Real Breslov is learning Torah, working on your brit, working on your mitzvot, working on your closeness to Hashem. The serious Talmidei Chachamim in Breslov are nothing like these street dancers. They're serious Talmidei Chachamim like everyone else. You wouldn't even know they were Breslov. Now, regarding halacha and mixed dancing specifically - this is absolutely forbidden. Men and women dancing together in public is considered giluy arayot, one of the three cardinal sins. The Sefer Chassidim says clearly that anytime people have mixed dancing events, there are demons created in those places that go home with those people and cause all types of tragedies in their lives. A man is not allowed to show affection to his own wife in public - even holding her hand in public is forbidden according to halacha. Needless to say, dancing with his wife or anyone else's wife in public is completely forbidden. This applies to weddings, bar mitzvahs, any event. Many people today, unfortunately, think Breslov is just about being happy all the time and dancing. But they pick and choose what they like. In Sichot HaRan, Rabbi Nachman says very clearly that the main key of serving Hashem is fear of punishment. That's the foundation and beginning before you talk about anything related to emunah or about Hashem. The lowest level of fear - meaning the foundation - is fear of Gehenom. He even said hopefully the tzaddikim in his generation would reach fear of Hashem. He wasn't even talking about love of Hashem. So if someone is doing everything else - learning halacha, learning Gemara, working on their middot - and using Chassidut to elevate themselves higher, that's beautiful. But if they're just growing peyot and dancing and laughing, thinking that's all there is to it, they need to wake up. That's not what Rabbi Nachman of Breslov said.

BH Headquarters