Jewish HaShkafa (Ideology) is Not a Buffet
Join this channel to get access to perks: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCi-fAdFBv83gUzBgKm3PAyw/join BUILD WITH US (Who Is BeEzrat HaShem Inc) http://www.BHYESHIVA.com BeEzrat HaShem YESHIVA & BEIT MUSSAR BUILDING BUILD A JEWISH COMMUNITY THAT WILL CHANGE THE WORLD #JewishHaShkafa #Judaism #Jewish #RabbiYaronReuven #Torah #KIRUV #TeShuvah 00:00:00 Intoduction 00:01:41 Hashkafa vs. Halacha: Introduction 00:02:40 Rav Yaakov Shapira's Perspective 00:03:16 The Danger of Individual Hashkafa 00:03:59 Modern Orthodox and Heretical Views 00:04:52 Hashkafa as Heresy and Torah Mandate 00:05:44 Moses Mendelssohn and Modern Interpretation 00:06:42 Torah Ideology vs. Individual Interpretation 00:07:30 Halachic Debates vs. Core Hashkafah 00:09:51 Importance of Mesorah for Hashkafah 00:12:39 Following Torah Giants, Not 'Pikachus'
Transcript
1:41And you're going to say, listen, sometimes you're going to have a different strategy in your community because you're saying, listen, it doesn't say that I'm not allowed to do certain things. I'm not allowed to behave in certain ways. And the Shulchan Aruch doesn't even talk about this. So therefore, this is a hashkafic issue. This is an ideological issue. And since the ideology of Judaism is not codified... There isn't one specific book that tells you hilchot anger, you know, how to deal with your anger. Hilchot of, you know, doing... No, there isn't. It wasn't codified like the other laws. So therefore, you would think, oh, since there is no specific codification for the hashkafah, for the ideology, therefore, all I have to worry about is yes, allowed, no, not allowed. Wrong. A very well-known Talmid Chacham, by the name of Rav Yaakov Shapira, has an extraordinary write-up that a friend of mine sent to me recently, and it's definitely worth our time to learn what he says word for word. He has an extraordinary write-up that a friend of mine sent to me recently, and it's definitely worth our time to learn what he says word for word.
2:50because he deals with this topic in a very, very extraordinary way. Generally, I love to highlight Talmidei Chachamim that are alive, not just the ones that have passed, especially since the issues of ideology, of Hashkafa, are typically the most confused ones. People have no idea what to do with it. So he says the following, He says there was a question that came up. The question is, if you don't have to follow a single posek in halacha, and you don't, then surely you don't have to follow a single person's hashkafah or da'at Torah when there's a disagreement. And he says, the simple answer is, this is wrong. Wrong ideology. Thinking that you don't have to follow a single person for hashkafah is wrong. Why? Why? It's wrong, and it unfortunately represents the common view in many modern Orthodox circles that when it comes to halacha, you have to listen to your rabbi.
3:59But Hashkafa, they're simply opinions that are more subject to individual preference. That's the ideology of today. That Hashkafa, that ideology is simply your opinion versus my opinion. You are modern Orthodox. I am Haredi. You are Hasidic. I am this. I am that. People think that just because you are this and I am that, therefore, we don't have the same Torah. Wrong. Or sometimes people will go even further. They'll even distort Halacha. where they'll say, listen, I'm inviting such and such to my house for Shabbat. Oh, that person is going to sleep at your house also? No, no, no, he's Conservative, so he drives, it's okay. As if just because he follows the heretical views of the Conservative Jews or the Reform Jews or sometimes, unfortunately, the Modern Jews, it's allowed for him to drive because he's Conservative. There's nothing more wrong with it, but this has to do more with Hashkafa than it does with Halakha. And the reason is as follows: It first starts with a person needing to know that this type of thought, Rav Shapiro says, is plain Kefirah, is heresy. Just as there is correct Halakha, there's also correct Hashkafa. As mandated by the Torah, that you have to have them.
5:18As it says, that you should not follow the ways of your heart. The Gemara says this is referring to heresy, that following the ways of your heart is the heretical beliefs that a person has. Any idea that disagrees with the opinions of the Torah, which is the Da'at Torah, as the Sefer HaChinuch, a work written about 800 years ago, discusses, and also the Mishnah. The Mishnah says that this type of behavior is heretical. This foreign concept, this mentality of thinking that you can just have your opinion of what hashkafah (Jewish worldview) should be, and I'll have my opinion of what hashkafah should be, is the heretical thinking or the heretical brainchild of Moses Mendelssohn. He said that Judaism doesn't matter as long as far as what you believe, but rather how you behave. a free-for-all is a modern-day stigma, a strain on the Mendelssohn and Pico suit. It was really the product of the masculine Enlightenment movement. The truth is that Torah and Torah values are both the possessions of those who have Torah knowledge and those who only claim to have it. This, you'll see, is also the type of belief system that's preached by Meza and his teacher, Prager, and all the people who are like them. All these so-called rationalists—in essence, they are saying: Follow Hashem, but as far as the details of how, who, what, and when—those are all subject to personal interpretation. The reality, as Rav Shapiro says, is that the idea of hashkafa
6:42a free-for-all as a modern-day strain on the Mendelssohn approach, which was really the product of the maskilim, the enlightenment movement. The truth is that Torah and hashkafah are both the possessions of those who have Torah knowledge and those who possess only that Torah knowledge. So, a violation of Torah Hashkafah, even if it doesn't violate any specific halakha, is a sin and is punishable in the same way. This is because the Torah demands, al pi halakha, if you will, that you have the Torah's hashkafah. In essence, the Torah itself is obligating you to have a Torah ideology. And what I understand someone to mean when he says that there are more options in halakha is not that halakha is per se less authoritative, chas v'shalom, but rather that new halakhic questions arise almost every day, and therefore you have the contemporary Torah authorities debating and disagreeing over them. These new halakhic questions have not been discussed by predecessors, and are first being dealt with today. Therefore, there's no explicit precedent or prior authoritative decision. In essence, the responses that you see today or the debates that you see today among the poskim.
7:54and are first being dealt with today. Therefore, there's no explicit precedent or prior authoritative decision. In essence, the responses that you see today or the debates that you see today among the poskim, it's not rediscovering the wheel. It's not new things that are being created as far as by new innovations, if you will, that are changing the original law, but rather things that weren't discussed in the past. weren’t discussed in the past because there are new innovations in the world. There are Shabbat timers, electricity, automobiles, and various medical equipment. There’s the question of how you treat medicine, as certain things are considered less of a life risk today than they used to be. So the Poskim [halachic authorities] delve into these topics today that weren’t discussed in the past because they weren’t relevant back then. So that new responses, new halachot, and so on are not saying that the previous halachot, the previous teachings, are less meaningful or of less value. But rather, it's simply telling you that right now there is a debate over how to apply the pre-existing law into the current reality.
9:15Torah Hashkafah, though, the ideology on the other hand, although there are sometimes questions of how to apply and establish Torah Hashkafah to individual situations, the core Hashkafah What the Rambam and the Rashba believed hashkafically applies to us today, and the Mesorah is much more clear when it comes to proper Torah beliefs than proper halachic decisions, since new technology and circumstances do not necessitate a new evaluation of hashkafah. Here, Rav Shapiro is saying that unlike halachah, which may address new things, new technologies, new circumstances for people, and so on, the ideology, if you will, didn't really change. The Da'as Torah, the opinion of the Torah, of the Rashba, of the Rambam, of Moshe Rabbeinu, is the same then and it's the same now. Nothing has changed.
10:20Few circumstances from time to time that are completely new would need a further review, but those are few and far in between. Meaning that the actual hashkafah that the Rambam had is the very same one that we have to apply to our lives today. And even more so, he says, the Torah hashkafah depends much more on the mesorah than halachah does. The Rambam's 13 principles of faith are nowhere to be found in the Gemara and nowhere brought down in the Shulchan Aruch. Yet, the Rambam, on which the entire Shulchan Aruch is based, forms 99% of the Shulchan Aruch. The Rambam says that if you do not believe in one of the principles, or you even have a doubt regarding one of them, you are considered an apikores, a heretic. And for all practical purposes, you're not considered part of Am Yisrael.
11:23So for all of those people who say, "No, listen, I don't need to believe in the 13 principles of faith because it wasn't codified into law by the Shulchan Aruch," this is completely apikorsut. This is heretical in every aspect known to a person who knows what Torah is. When somebody tells you that you don't need to believe that Mashiach can come every single day because they don't see a specific verse according to their understanding in the Five Books of Moses, or that you don't need to believe in the resurrection of the dead, understand that this is not in line with authentic Jewish belief. Our sages have made it clear through the Gemara and other sacred texts that these principles are foundational to our faith. Such claims of disbelief undermine the core tenets of Judaism. because they don't see a specific verse in the Five Books of Moses, this is apikorsut. Many times you will see those very same rationalists, those very same heretics that we've called out in the past, be the very same people that preach this nonsense even though there's a Gemara. Specifically, it says that if you don't believe in the resurrection of the dead, then you're obviously not going to be resurrected yourself. It's a very severe punishment. The Rambam calls such a person a heretic, where they are literally not considered part of Israel anymore. Their Judaism is on suspension. Now, some might say, "Wait a minute, how could that be? It's not a halacha in the Shulchan Aruch or in the Five Books of Moses that you have to believe it." It doesn't have to be a halacha for it to be something that you must apply to your life.
12:39for it to be obligatory for you to apply it to your life. There is something called Hashkafah, which is based on Da'at Torah—the opinion of the Torah—that you have to treat no different than Halakha from Moshe MiSinai. Now, of course, the heretics will disagree with this, but that's because they're not willing to change their lives. But if you ask all of the Gedolim, both alive and those who preceded us, This is the way they've lived their lives. If you look at the lives of the Arizal, you look at the lives of the Gaon of Vilna, you look at the lives of all of the great rabbis among Am Yisrael, Rabbi Akiva Eiger, Rabbi Akiva himself, the Chazon Ish, the Chafetz Chaim, all of the giants of the past. And you compare their lives, their behaviors, if you will, to the current giants. Rav Shternbuch, Rav Kanievsky, Rav Yitzchak Yosef, Rav Mazuz, all of these giants. Because, of course, you can't compare it to some average Joe that works at a supermarket with a t-shirt on. No, you have to compare it to the people that have delved into the Torah, meaning they know the most about it.
13:47the experts of the past to the experts of today. You see how they live their lives, how they think about what our responsibility is. You see, it's the same thing. That's who we're supposed to learn from. We're not supposed to learn from some Joe Smith that decides that he knows better than the biggest rabbis in the world. That's not the way. You're not going to learn from some guy who claims he's a doctor just because he has a building and patients, but has a record of losing about 80 of his patients. You're not going to go to a doctor like this. You're going to go to a doctor who has a track record, who has a history, who has a resume to match it, who has integrity, who has some type of teaching that you can depend on because other experts agree with. Not someone who's a lone soldier or cowboy. So this is what... The modern mentality would like people to think, where they want you to think that if it comes to halacha, yes, you have to do it. But if it comes to hashkafa, not so much. And there's nothing further from the truth. There's nothing further from the truth. And this is, in essence, what Rav Shapiro is telling us. He says that, I'm skipping around a little bit here, that when it comes to the issues of hashkafa...
15:08Unlike the issues of halacha that were codified and specified and so on, these great things, these hashkafot, were left for great Torah scholars to decide. Same concept when it comes to the teachings of today. How do we know what's the right Hashkafah? We look at the leaders. We look at the leaders of Am Yisrael. What are they saying we're supposed to do if something changed? If nothing has changed, then we obviously continue what has always been the Mesorah of Am Yisrael. When a person disregards what the Mesorah of Am Yisrael is and simply decides that they know better than the Chachamim, then you have to ask yourself, what if they're wrong? What if they're wrong? What if, okay, so they're saying that they know better than all the big rabbis out there. We're not talking about your local rabbis and your average Joes out there. No, with all due respect to all the local rabbis out there, many of them being extraordinary, we don't learn from local rabbis as far as what the nation is supposed to do. We learn what the nation is supposed to do by the gedolim, by the gadol hador, by the leaders.
16:20So, if you're going to listen to some local person who doesn't care if you drive on Shabbat, who doesn't care if you are an adulterer, who doesn't care if you gamble, who doesn't care if you are involved in unethical businesses, as long as you give tzedakah, who doesn't care if you're doing all types of things that, in essence, are forbidden—sometimes halakhically, sometimes hashkafically—you're saying, no, but my rabbi told me to do it. This rabbi, however you might like him, however good his speech is, however clever he is, when you go up to Shamayim, do you think they're going to consider his opinion like they consider the Rambam, like they consider the Rosh, like they consider the Baal Shulchan Aruch, like they consider the Rishon LeTzion, Rabbi Yitzchak Yosef, or his father, the Maran, Rabbi Ovadia Yosef? Are they going to consider their opinion of the Ben Ish Chai like his? Are they going to consider the opinion of the Steipler Gaon like his? Are they going to place their opinion next to theirs? No. Which means what? If I follow the biggest rabbis in the world, the ones that are supporting the Torah like it always was, I am aligning myself with the true leaders and pillars of our tradition.
17:39I'm going to follow the biggest Dayanim in the world, the people that have delved into the Torah so much that they became Poskim, they became Dayanim, they became the leaders. Even if they're not popular and the world doesn't know them, and they don't necessarily have YouTube channels, the point is, they have done exactly what the Chazon Ish is saying, what the Gemara is saying, in that they've put themselves in a situation where the world exists for them. ...that's who they are, they're dayanim, they're poskim, and they're amazing... Right? Some are famous, some not so famous. But nonetheless, no one can question how extraordinary these people are. And not just one. I'm going to rely on Rav Kanievsky of the world, on the Rav Mazuz of the world, on all of the Rav Gidon, Ben Moshe, all the biggest guys in the world that are alive. And also their teachers, Rav Ovadia, Rav Mutzafi, the father of Rav Shalom, Rav Ben Zion Abba Shaul, his...
18:41uh, Rabbi, all of the great sages of the previous generation, and not just them, their teachers, and their teachers' teachers, going all the way back to the Rambam, to the... That's one way I can rely. Or I can rely on this one guy and perhaps maybe three of his friends, none of whom are internationally recognized as dayanim, none of whom are internationally recognized even as talmidei chachamim, none of whom are even internationally recognized as even rabbis, none of whom are internationally recognized as even decent people. But they say that they know better. than all of the biggest rabbis that we just mentioned? Which one do you want to rely on? Do you want to rely on the biggest, most important people that ever existed in the last 3,000 years? That all feed off of each other, learn from each other, and repeat what each other do for the last 3,000 years? Or do you want to learn from Uncle Scrooge and Gargamel? And perhaps maybe a few Pikachus in between that have a YouTube channel and maybe even a local shul that's 5,000 square feet. Which one do you want to learn from?
19:47That all feed off of each other, learn from each other, and repeat what each other has done for the last 3,000 years? Or do you want to learn from Uncle Scrooge and Gargamel? And perhaps maybe a few Pikachus in between that have a YouTube channel and maybe even a local shul that's 5,000 square feet. Which one do you want to learn from? This is what a normal person needs to evaluate before they follow the so-called modern way, the new way, the rational way. You have to be smart. If the guy that's telling me is right, okay, great, he's right. He's an innovator. He is something special. I'm going to follow him. And he's going to get me to Gan Eden, right? If the existing mesorah, the existing tradition, is right and I follow them, I also go to Gan Eden, right? Okay. But what if they're both wrong? What if the Uncle Scrooge of today and the Gargamel and a Pikachu, they're wrong? And whoever follows them, they're wrong? Versus the vision that Tzion has... If the existing mesorah, the existing tradition, is right and I follow them, I also go to Gan Eden, right? Okay. But what if they're both wrong? What if the Uncle Scrooge of today and the Gargamel and Pikachu are wrong? And whoever follows them, they're wrong, versus the lashon that Tzion has.
21:09Or Rav Gidon is wrong. Or Rav Ovadia is wrong. Or Rav Kaniewsky is wrong. Or all the biggest leaders in the world are wrong. Which one is HaKadosh Baruch Hu going to rebuke? Which one? Is He going to rebuke you for following the biggest leaders of the world? Or is He going to rebuke you for following the Gargamels and the Pikachus of the world? Which one? If you tell them, "Listen, I followed the biggest talmidei chachamim you have, the most popular rabbanim you have, the most devoted Torah scholars you have, the people that delved into your Torah day and night for 80, 90, 100 years." For 16 to 20 hours a day, that's who I followed. They made a mistake; it's not my fault—I followed them. Who says you're right? You are right! You did what was normal; you actually followed da'as Torah. Even if they're wrong, you're still right. You are right because you found out.
22:15If you follow the little pikachus of today from your local community that nobody knows and nobody cares about, that even when they know, they don't care about. In fact, people can't stand some of these people when they get to know them. You follow them, and they made a mistake. What are you going to tell them? "Oh, I followed that Torah." That's not that Torah. That Torah was millions of Jews who were following the same tradition since Moshe Rabbeinu, not that. He said he has a new doctor. They said they have a new doctor. You didn't follow that; you followed that. One of the main things in Judaism is that there is no dot, there's no individualistic opinion, or the opinion of the individual. No such thing, no such thing, unless you are a giant among giants. Who are these people? They're giving lectures in their cars or making stories up as they go. Who are these people? This is what a person needs to understand.
24:05Thank you.