BeEzrat HaShem

Last Minute TeShuva Before Rosh HaShanah

2 months ago

Rabbi Yaron Reuven tells a story about TeShuva during Elul and the blessing of a Tzaddik that was fulfilled in an unexpected way. Nearly 200 years ago Jew was fired from his job and went off the derech, and became a missionary for the christian church. After many years he realized his enormous sin and decided to do TeShuva during the month of Elul. He sat in a room in his daughters home and cried every night. One night he came to her and told her the story of how it all happened. Full Shiur: Stump The Rabbi 278 https://youtu.be/AzUm14sAzeE Want to support our KIRUV work? Please partner with us to help Am Yisrael keep Shabbat and more! https://www.beezrathashem.org/donate Rabbi Yaron Reuven's short Torah Clips channel – Please Share The Video To Help Others Do TeShuva. AI RABBI by BeEzrat HaShem Inc. https://www.AIRabbi.org Answers To Jewish Torah Life Questions In 30 Languages. Discover Jewish Wisdom at Your Fingertips, Rabbi Reuven's AI Rabbi offers wisdom and guidance in multiple languages, drawing from trusted, reliable sources. #Torah #Jewish #RabbiYaronReuven 00:00:00 Intoduction 00:00:01 Hogar's Deceptive Heresy 00:01:34 Rabbinic Response and Refutation 00:02:59 The Author's Hidden Identity 00:04:30 Tragic Fall: Lashon Hara's Impact 00:05:58 Driven by Revenge: Missionary Work 00:07:29 Hogar's Teshuvah and Family Reconciliation 00:09:26 Deep Repentance and Deathbed Revelation 00:10:26 Ancestral Blessing Turned Curse 00:13:17 Machloket vs. Kampf: A Vital Lesson

Transcript

0:01And she says, every single night, we would hear my father crying to Hashem, asking for mercy, apologizing for what he did. Every single night. A person by the name of Stanislav Hogar. Who is the Stanislav Hogar? In the year 1833, Stanislav Hogar published a heretical sefer named Nativot Olam, which is the same name as the holy book of the Maharal miPrague. In fact, this Stanislav Hogar did not actually write this entire book, rather,

1:03He took the Christian missionary Alexander McCall's book that was called The Old Paths, and he rewrote that book with rabbinic lingo in such a way that they put it in different bookstores. They saw the name is the same name as Nativot Olam of the Maharal miPrague. They expected something holy in there. only to find out that this book is preaching idolatry. It's preaching Christianity. It's preaching things that are against the Torah. This was published in Hebrew, in English, in London, and it caused a lot of noise. When one of the Torah leaders of the generation, Rabbi Moshe Montefiore heard about this and the outcry that's happening in the community and how many people are falling into the trap of this horrific book. He went on a task to find a Chacham who is going to write a response book. And he found one in Russia.

2:28named the Ribal of Kamenitz. The Ribal of Kamenitz wrote a sefer called Zerubbabel to show the beauty of the Torah, to show the lives of the Christian missionaries. And things calmed down for a while. Years later, in the city of Oradea, A wealthy Jewish woman arrives at the Beis Din of Rabbi Benjamin Diskin. Rabbi Diskin was the father of the famous Rabbi Yehuda Leib Diskin. And this woman asked to see the rabbi so she could tell him a very important story. She told him, I am the daughter of the author of Netivot Olam.

3:30He's my father. Now, everyone knew that this Stanislaw Hoga was a Jew. What many didn't realize is that Stanislaw Hoga was not only not his real name, he was born Yechezkel Aryeh. In fact, his father was a Talmid of the Chachmei Lublin. And this Yechezkel Aryeh was born into a Hasidic family. He was a prodigy already at an early age. At the age of three years old, he already mastered the Hebrew language. He was an expert in language. He was an expert in Talmud. And he taught. He had a little school, a little yeshiva for kids in Lita. Until one day, something happened, and he left his wife and kids, he left the Jewish community, he left God, he converted to Christianity, became a Christian missionary, and wrote this book. So the daughter is telling Rav Dessler, this is what happened.

4:59My father, alav hashalom, when he was in Lita, teaching little kids Torah, everyone loved him. Because he was a Torah scholar, he knew what he was talking about, kids would come out good. But then one day, somebody spread a false rumor about him. That he's not really Torah observant, he's not really respecting the mitzvot. And unfortunately, the rumors spread like fire and people believed it. And before you know it, everyone took their kids out of his school to the point where we did not have money to eat. He got so angry at the community and how everyone believed this false rumor that he left the family, he left the Torah, He left the country. He went to London. In London, he wanted to take revenge against the Jewish people. So he joined the church and he converted to Christianity and became friendly with the Christian missionaries. But the Christian missionaries that were anti-Semitic, that were trying to constantly do harm to the Jewish people, they didn't know how to debate them because they didn't know the language. They didn't know

6:28the rules. But now they have among them a Torah scholar, a former Torah scholar who knows not just the language, but is an expert in it. And within a few years, they raised him and they told him, 'Listen, you've got to start translating some of these works into rabbinic language.' And he did it because he was interested in taking revenge. to those people that hurt him. and eventually he took Alexander McCall's book that was called 'The Old Path,' meaning it was a book making fun of the Torah and the old ways, like they called the Old Testament. and he rewrote it in rabbinic language that everyone could understand, that everyone from the Torah world, that looks like it's authentic, that looks like it's from the Torah,

7:29And even changed the name from the old path to Nativot Olam, to confuse people further. As the daughter is telling the story to Rav Diskin, she's crying. She says, I was originally, initially raised alone by my mother. Eventually my mother married a German Torah scholar And we had a difficult past, but we grew. And we tried to forget that my father exists. But after many years, over 20 years later, I get a letter from my father. Shocked, I open up the letter and I see that my father is pleading for mercy.

8:32And he's saying to me, I know that I am despicable in your eyes and in every Jewish person's eyes because of the damage that I've caused as a result of that book. But I must tell you that my heart breaks from the regret that I have for what I did. And I beg you to please, now in my old age, to accept me back. to accept my teshuva and to have me live with you and your husband. After discussing it with her husband, they agreed, so long as he complied with the rules of the house, which is that he must look like a Jew, wear a beard again, Jewish clothes, grow his peyos again, cover his head. Stay away from things, if you will. Don't cause too much noise like the past, because at the end of the day, people still suspected him. Maybe he's trying trying a new way of doing Christian missionary. And she says, every single night, we would hear my father crying to Hashem, asking for mercy, apologizing for what he did.

9:57Every single night. But one day, right around the time of Elul, my father is lying in bed. And he calls my husband and me. And he says, "My time in this world is nearly over." And I want to tell you a story, a story that you don't know. You know about the book that I wrote that caused a lot of damage. You know that I've been trying to do teshuva for all these years, even writing articles against the missionaries, even publishing a book called The Controversy of Zion in 1845, highlighting all of the lies of the Christian missionaries and how they're antisemitic and they're arrogant and they're evil. But what you don't know that this started before you were born, in fact, before I even knew how to read or write years ago, there was a big makhloket between two Torah giants, the Yaavetz and Rabbi Yonatan HaIvshitz, and my father was a talmid of the Yaavetz

11:24even though his Rav was the Chozeh mi Lublin, still he was in the favor of the Yaavetz in this debate. And he saw how passionate the Yaavetz was, fighting against Rabbi Yonatan Eybeshitz, that he wrote a short book insulting Rabbi Yonatan Eybeshitz. And he published it on the day that was my Brit Milah. And he gave it as a gift to the Yavetz at the Brit Milah. The Yavetz was happy about this and blessed him and said, may this boy that just came into the world and had a Brit Milah be the exact opposite of Rabbi Yonatan Eybeschütz. So the Yavetz meant a blessing Years later when everyone realized that Rabbi Yonatan Eybeschütz was a tzaddik, that he wasn't following Shabtai Tzvi, that he was Kodesh Kodashim, it was already too late; the blessing of the tzaddik fell on me, and at the moment when I was tested by Hashem, I

12:47Poverty with insults, I fell, and I opened up the gate for haSatan to fulfill this blessing that ended up being a curse. And I became the opposite of Rabbi; he was a tzaddik. I became the ultimate rasha. I declared war against Judaism. From here we learn a bunch of things. Number one, we see that Chachamim, when they debate, it can get fiery, but it's called a machloket. Why? Because they're fighting for the truth and the truth is universal. Two, we see that sometimes a Chacham can make a mistake. They can make a mistake.

13:47Number three, we see that there's a very significant difference between a machloket and fighting evil. When this Yechezkel Aryeh left the Torah, left Judaism, named himself Stanislaw Hoga, There was no machloket there. They were simply fighting evil. Why? He was preaching a new religion. He was preaching a new God. He was preaching things that are against the Torah. And therefore there was no debating him. They were simply fighting evil. It's very important for a person to know the difference.

BH Headquarters