Reply to the messianic jews #1- You Were Caught Lying by Rabbi Efraim Kachlon W/English Subtitles
תגובה ליהודים המשיחיים #1- נתפסתם בשקר! W/English Subtitles תגובות ליהודים המשיחיים https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLTe2tsB0UUym1T7Rc1_gyhmaWfamPgUyE To Support our KIRUV and Torah Teachings work please DONATE at www.BeEzratHaShem.org If you'd like to invite Rabbi Yaron Reuven to give a lecture at your synagogue, home or office please email Info@BeEzratHaShem.org Rabbi Reuven is based out of Florida but travels to give lectures to different groups. Join one of our interactive "Interesting Torah" Whatsapp groups to get daily updates and short Torah clips that can uplift your day by texting 1.917.468.2324 or +91 93236 69880 Available on Apple iTunes Store, Amazon App Store and Android Play Store https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.beezrathashem GOOGLE App https://apps.apple.com/us/app/beezrat-hashem/id1279094981?uo=4 APPLE App https://www.amazon.com/Hosttec-Solutions-BeEzrat-HaShem/dp/B07QST1294/ AMAZON App Click here https://soundcloud.com/yaronreuven/sets/daily-chidush To Listen to our very popular "Daily Chidush" short audio series on SOUNDCLOUD or the Podcast Channel at https://beezrathashem.jewishpodcasts.org Born in Netanya, Israel, Rabbi Yaron Reuven began his American Dream as a little boy, when his family immigrated to the United States. He went from a newspaper boy at the age of 10, to a well-known self-made Wall Street multimillionaire by the age of 23. During his time in Wall Street, he owned his own private brokerage firm, a hedge fund, and an international insurance agency. He was featured on CNBC, Bloomberg and Chinese NDTV due to his success in the financial industry. At age 26 he faced a 7-year battle for his life when a simple surgery went wrong. From that moment his life would never be the same. This moment marked the start of a series of miraculous events and an exciting pursuit of truth, ultimately resulting in Rabbi Reuven renouncing his lofty position and success in Wall Street, after 16 years, to become a full-time KIRUV rabbi. His Teshuva story is sure to catch the heart of every listener. Rabbi Reuven’s shiurim are in English and Hebrew. His classes are focused on spreading the truth and divinity of the Torah through MUSSAR, scientific proofs, and many other methods to reach each individual listener. Rabbi Reuven is the leading educator on the topic of wasting seed in the English language with over 30 hrs of content published online. Rabbi Yaron Reuven is a proud member of the Igud HaRabbonim (The Rabbinical Alliance of America), a national rabbinic organization founded in 1942. Today, our 900+ members are congregational leaders, religious teachers, chaplains, heads of Jewish organizations and communal leaders united in their commitment to traditional Orthodox Judaism. For more information please visit: https://rabbinicalalliance.org/ 00:00:00 Intoduction 00:01:06 Introduction: Refuting Messianic Jews' Claims 00:02:21 Criticizing Video's Presentation & Content 00:04:03 Addressing Claims About Oral Torah & Niddah 00:06:39 Debate Invitation and Refusal 00:08:54 Seeking Truth vs. Creating Spectacle 00:10:08 Positive Developments & Bypassing Gatekeepers 00:11:10 Jewish Messiah and Refusal of Recognition 00:12:02 Exposing Misrepresentation of Rabbi's Words 00:14:55 Chazal's Wisdom vs. Modern Interpretations 00:18:24 Torah Shebe'al Peh's Unchanging Tradition
Transcript
1:06Shalom and blessings to everyone. We are starting our series against the Messianic Jews. The Messianic Jews made a video, an explanation, more correctly, an interpretation, as they like to do, about all the claims that we made about the absolute proofs of the Torah she-be'al peh (Oral Torah). We proved the authenticity of the Torah she-be'al peh from a number of proofs; there are many evidences that it exists and is authentic. and made a real logic to believe that there is a Torah she'be'al peh. Faith is not just emunah peshutah, simple faith, no. Faith from da'at. And we did some of the mitzvot in the Torah, and they, of course, not only did not understand our points, but also made such foolish claims, such narishkeit, proved every sentence they said, and we will prove it, so that they will call me immediately to the brothers.
2:21So there is no problem that it will continue to be. So that's how all their tastes are wind and clouds and rain. I mean, there is no significant thing in everything they said, in everything they said. There is maximum purity here, and we will come and prove along the way how they were wrong, wrong after wrong, and did not understand and did not know at all from any word of what we said. How did the video open? The video, how did it open? 00-01, in the first second of the video, we see two girls who... They say, thank you for thinking about it. Well, no. Moti and Eitan couldn't have said it, thank you for thinking about it. Always, in order to sell something in the world of the media, in the world of business, they take two girls, a little make-up, a little style, and they can also sell you money for scams. That's what they did. They came and took the two girls and used them as faces in order to come and make unnecessary claims.
3:25knowledge to answer questions that you can't even understand what they're saying, but that's the way it is. You can sell a box, if they're selling you chips that have 100 grams, but with a bag that can hold 250 grams, and you seem to be paying for air, no problem. So I'll also sell you a bag full of air, air from the Land of Israel. I'll sell you a video full of nonsense, I'll sell you a video full of insignificant things, empty content, and as we'll show you... how they didn't understand anything, how they didn't think about anything. Let's look at the video together. In... Second, at eight seconds in the video, one of the people says, "Rabbi Ephraim, it's not so bad that we're making fun of the Torah that's out there. It's a mistake. You're not making fun of it; you're trying to make fun of it. You're trying to come and make fun of it to confuse the mind in all kinds of ways and reactions, but you're making fun of it, and you don't understand that just to come and laugh and laugh about your utmost purity in everything that concerns it."
4:32to a Torah shebe'al peh, and as we said, we had to prove it. In the year 1951, One of the girls tried to refute the claim that we came and said that the simple view about the existence of the Torah on the mouth is the commandment of the Torah, which the Torah says in the book of Kohelet (Ecclesiastes), chapter 12, verse 7, about all the laws of the Torah. So there, these two girls come and say, like, wow, how do we know if a woman is in niddah? Really, we, wow, wow, there's no way to know, there's no way to know, we just have to have the Torah on our lips to guide us. So, well, girls, you didn't understand anything from what I said, and the problem is that both Eitan and Moti, these so-called great philosophers, didn't understand either. They just took you as dolls, expecting you to come and repeat everything they wrote to you, but you didn't grasp anything from the statement, from everything we discussed.
5:44And in order to understand what we said, we need to see the Gemara in Devarim (Deuteronomy) 1:2, which discusses the origin of a woman's tumah (ritual impurity) during menstruation. This tumah is contingent upon the blood that comes specifically from the womb, not any other type of blood. Even if other blood comes out of the womb, such as the blood of a child, it does not impart tumah. This is a halacha (law), not merely an assertion. So who determines that the Torah specifically addresses the blood from the womb? That's where it's written. No! I meant to say, where does it come from that a woman goes down in blood? No. No. No. It's nonsense to even think about such a thing. There's something else. The Torah discusses laws that must be followed. A person who has relations with a woman who is a nida must follow certain laws. Wait, wait. Where did you hear about this notion of going down in blood? That's not something the Torah says. And that's the Torah we have at face value. There's also a Chazal coming to explain the deeper understanding. in the Gemara in Niddah, in Devarim, and we bring a source, whoever wants to look there, to the Torah Shebe'al Peh, to the commandment of Niddah. Eitan, Moti, Anastasia, all the people, you have proven your innocence. You have never learned the masechet of Niddah. Well, I do not complain. You are only interested in mussar studies, right? This is what you all say in the film. Oh, he did not learn mussar, he did not learn mussar. But the wisdom of the Talmud is much greater than mussar studies.
7:10We will continue on, in a minute and 42 seconds. Eitan says, "I'm listening to you. For three years now, we've been looking for a rabbi who would agree to do a debate with us. Imut Pumbi Chai." And, I've already said in the lesson, why don't we do a live broadcast with them? Why don't we debate with them? They want to come and get recognition? From rabbis, from people that here you are now the representatives of the opponents. They don't want to look for the truth. Not only that, they declare "don't change us, we want to come and fight with you." I have a relationship with Eitan. Eitan, when he first came and told me that he wants to come and argue, you can see there how he doesn't understand the meaning of the word. Not bad; it's already his old problem. from rabbis, from people here who are now the representatives of the opponents. They don't want to look for the truth. Not only do they not want to look for the truth, they declare, "Don't change us. We want to come and fight with you." And I have a relationship with Eitan. Eitan, when he first came and sent me the message that he wanted to come and argue, you can also see there how he doesn't understand the meaning of the word. The misunderstanding of the word is not new; it's already his long-standing issue.
8:13that I'm telling him I'm sending, of course, by one of the members of the organization, Eitan. I'm ready to come and sit with you and answer all your questions, one by one, without any pictures or any mess, one by one, and prove the truth to you. If I manage to prove it to you, If I didn't succeed, then I'm ready to publish everything you want. That we fought and we didn't succeed, and so on and so forth. But what? Eitan, Anali, you don't understand. I'm completely in my emunah. I'm completely in my emunah. I'm not looking to argue. I just want to come and present. That means you want to come and play a game and use me as your player. Not only that, I don't have money either. I don't have time for these nonsensical claims, I have time to come and save Jews. And therefore, every claim, and I will reveal even more, we made an initial response. We made an initial response on the same day the video came out. Three hours later, we made an initial response, and we sent the invitation to Eitan and Moti.
9:14And they came and saw. Apart from the distractions, improper speech, improper interactions with us, inappropriate jokes, it's all inappropriate, every kind of comment that we didn't allow. You can see on our Facebook page that we didn't allow them. Instead of coming and engaging with the comments and addressing them, here, you wanted a live broadcast, you wanted it together. I won't give you the platform, but I'm coming to you. Here, now, we have a lot of viewers, we have a lot of people. The video, this live broadcast, reached thousands. Please, come on. Tell me now what you think, and I will answer you for the sake of my life. They don't want to. They don't want to. What do they want? Dispute, cameras, a funeral service, that's what they call it in Arabic, right? That's what they want. And you won't get that from me. You won't get that from any rabbi who has wisdom and knowledge, that you are just looking for a reason to leave you in the range of your roles, that you took on yourself to do and guide Israel to believe in your mother's name and memory. So far, bad news, but here's some good news. Let's start with some good news. I think that we were able to find the missing key, the lost key.
10:34And it's actually pretty simple. It's Jewish and Arab Israelis explaining their beliefs to other Jewish and Arab Israelis in the Hebrew and Arabic languages. It's not something that comes from outside, foreign, or different. It's something that we do with our own people, and we do it by bypassing the gatekeepers. We bypass the Orthodox Rabbis. We no longer need their permission or approval. We go straight into their own children's phones now and computers. But here is something very important for you to understand. We do not share the blonde, blue-eyed, gentile Jesus who is dead on a Roman Catholic cross for 2000 years now. We share the Jewish, Israeli Messiah.
11:36You won't get that. You won't get that recognition, not from me, nor from any Rabbi in Israel. Not you, and not all the people around you—Eitan, Moti, Anastasia, and all this group, the entire crowd you've gathered here. At minute 2:51, Eitan says, and I read, Rabbi Efraim Kachlon wrote, that after a long debate with me, at the end of the day, I told him that I'm not healthy in my soul. And that, guys, is logic from the type of Ad Hominem. When the successors attack the argument, they attack the accuser. And by the way, not only am I pretty healthy in my soul, but I never even talked to Rabbi Efraim Kachlon. Well, Eitan, not pretty, but you were caught in a trap. It's not nice to say, but you were caught in a trap. Either you were caught in a trap, or you are a man with two faces. Because even in the post that you posted in the video, someone who will enlarge the screen a little bit will see that the answer I gave was for a completely different messianic person. His name is there. We will soon upload the post, and everyone will see.
12:58That yes, I spoke to another person, and that person told me that he was in the hospital, mentally ill, and he received psychiatric treatment, and that's why, because of all his thoughts. I thought to myself right after he told me that everything I say to you, I say to you with sincerity and care. So after he told me such a sentence, I reflected on the conversation. So I said to him, "Hello, you are not healthy in your soul. Who is talking about the concept of the Ruach HaKodesh today? You, you who have time to write comments on videos, you have the Ruach HaKodesh? What are you mumbling in your brain?" And he said to me, "Don't joke about a sick person." I didn't mean to joke, but that's what he said. "Don't joke about a sick person. I was in a hospital for a long time for a sick person." So here, Eitan, you saw there the name of that person. So why did you lie? Lama shikarta? Lama silavta? Elama, ata ratzita lavo v'lehat'chil et ha'sereton she'le'orech kol ha'derech l'harot kama kshalim log'im harav Efraim Kahlon over. Az matzata lecha kshalim log'im v'hitbakta lekol ma she'ata rotze. Aval ze lo mistader im ha'emet. Ze lo mistader im ha'metzuyut lo norah. Pur neshaneh et ha'metzuyut. Ma ba'aya? Kmo she'neshaneh et ha'metzuyut al...
14:12Yoshke, and we will put all the good things on it so that it will be believed, as we did there, in all kinds of understandings. We will find out that it is not the same Yoshke of Chazal, and everything, in order to reveal the reality. You also did it here, Eitan, and you know that you did it. It is written there to whom the response is due, and that's a shame. You started on the left foot. We, through the truth, through the Torah that is written, and through the Torah that is spoken, are dedicated to uncovering the truth. They only search for the truth and present it, and prove it to no one. It's a shame that you were caught in the first round. In 3 minutes and 18 seconds, Moti says, Rabbi Efraim Kahalon did a shiur on Hora'at Sha'a as a response to our videos on Torah She'be'al Peh. In his shiur, he tries to prove that in addition to the Torah She'bichtav, Hashem also gave Moshe the Torah She'be'al Peh, and that only the rabbanim can understand and interpret it. Moti? Moti? Second chapter?
15:26Second chapter. I never said that the Rabbis of today can come and preach. You have fear of the Rabbis of today because they are the ones who fight for the knowledge to stop you from coming and trying with your typical faith in Yoshke to convince everyone. And none of us are standing on the edge, right? So, you have a problem. I never said that Rabbis... I said that Chazal, Chachmei Yisrael, the Talmud that was written more than 1,500 years ago, this Talmud, the Six Orders of Mishnah, the Mishnayot, and after that the Gemara, and after that, it is possible to add and increase the corrections and to invent other halachot. What are all the books that are behind me? It is a trial within the words of Chazal. Exactly what they meant, to go to the depths of the depths of the depths. And that's just a question. Eitan, Moti, Anastasia, all these guys, even if you end up with Gemara, as if you're learning Gemara, have you ever learned the Shas b'Iyun?
16:37Once, you sat and learned, not alone, because your head will not understand it alone. Go to a place, to a yeshiva, you sat for a few years, three years, four years, how do you come to teach me, that Baruch Hashem, I'm over 20 years old, sitting and learning the Talmud, and Baruch Hashem, we managed to finish it a few times. What is the Torah that is on the mouth? You will come to teach Einstein about the Torah of relationships? You will come to teach someone who is a mediator, someone who always has to do this, and tell him, "Hello, there are problems." On the contrary, what did you tell me? How did you come to talk about the New Testament? Yes, I also learned. I read the New Testament, in a place where it is allowed to read it, and the understanding will understand. I went through it, and apart from a story from Chassidut that I said, that whoever wants can also read Harry Potter. It doesn't make any sense. Imaginations, assumptions, thoughts, and the rest of it. Nonsensical things that can be read in the entire Haggadah. An experience to insert all kinds of verses from the Tanach. A difficult experience. But, Moti, Eitan, no. These are not the rabbis. These are not the rabbis. These are not the rabbis of today. But our sages, zikhonam livracha, remembered them blessedly.
18:03Shabbat Shalom, Shabbat Shalom, Shabbat Shalom. In all the generations, there were groups like this, even from the time of Hashem and after that. They and their methods became separate from the world. The Jewish people, including the Haredim who are Shomer Masoret, after a tradition spanning 2,000 years, returned to their land to be reborn. and proved that the Torah Shebe'al Peh will not be changed. It's not like your claims, Eitan, that everyone makes sushi. The Torah Shebe'al Peh is completely accurate. Within the Torah Shebe'al Peh, at the core of the halachot, there are divisions among them. We conducted a shiur and explained when the divisions emerged, and in what manner these divisions exist. But, fundamentally, in terms of halachot,
19:10The main halachot, our Shas, the Bavli Talmud, the Shulchan Aruch that was written 500 years ago, the piskei halachot, anyone who knows the tradition of the Torah knows exactly how it happened. Not you, a small group of people who are hiding behind a microphone and are making videos that usually have no way of giving an answer, try to change the tradition of Yisrael. No, just no. Well, We will continue to discuss all their claims, specifically for those individuals who believe there is nothing to discuss within the Torah. In the next lesson, we will explore the wisdom of Chazal, delving into the brilliance of their teachings. It is beyond comprehension to think of Chazal in their youth as anything less than sagacious, or to imagine them in confusion or doubt. Chazal were individuals of immense knowledge and wisdom, upholders of all facets of understanding. When they made their statements, they did so with great responsibility and insight. Join us for the next shiur.