The Hard Truth, CHANGING CUSTOMS, Noahide Teachers, KNOWLEDGE Vs.BELIEF IN GOD - STUMPTHE RABBI (88)
Rabbi Yaron Reuven explains how changing customs can be dangerous when it comes to following the Torah's laws. He emphasizes that it's essential to stick to the customs of one's forefathers. Additionally, Rabbi Reuven highlights the importance of truthfulness and honesty in Jewish teachings, contrasting it with the falsehoods often found in modern society. https://www.tikkunhabrit.live TIKKUN HaBRIT The Movie: THE MOST IMPORTANT FILM IN HISTORY!!! PRAYERS ARE NOT ENOUGH FOR THE TIKKUN HABRIT EPIDEMIC SO WE MADE A MOVIE YOU CAN BE PARTNER IN!! To Support our KIRUV and Torah Teachings work please DONATE at www.BeEzratHaShem.org If you'd like to invite Rabbi Yaron Reuven to give a lecture at your synagogue, home or office please email Info@BeEzratHaShem.org Rabbi Reuven is based out of Florida but travels to give lectures to different groups. Join one of our interactive "Interesting Torah" Whatsapp groups to get daily updates and short Torah clips that can uplift your day by texting 1.917.468.2324 or +91 93236 69880 Available on Apple iTunes Store, Amazon App Store and Android Play Store https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.beezrathashem GOOGLE App https://apps.apple.com/us/app/beezrat-hashem/id1279094981?uo=4 APPLE App https://www.amazon.com/Hosttec-Solutions-BeEzrat-HaShem/dp/B07QST1294/ AMAZON App Click here https://soundcloud.com/yaronreuven/sets/daily-chidush To Listen to our very popular "Daily Chidush" short audio series on SOUNDCLOUD or the Podcast Channel at https://beezrathashem.jewishpodcasts.org Born in Netanya, Israel, Rabbi Yaron Reuven began his American Dream as a little boy, when his family immigrated to the United States. He went from a newspaper boy at the age of 10, to a well-known self-made Wall Street multimillionaire by the age of 23. During his time in Wall Street, he owned his own private brokerage firm, a hedge fund, and an international insurance agency. He was featured on CNBC, Bloomberg and Chinese NDTV due to his success in the financial industry. At age 26 he faced a 7-year battle for his life when a simple surgery went wrong. From that moment his life would never be the same. This moment marked the start of a series of miraculous events and an exciting pursuit of truth, ultimately resulting in Rabbi Reuven renouncing his lofty position and success in Wall Street, after 16 years, to become a full-time KIRUV rabbi. His Teshuva story is sure to catch the heart of every listener. Rabbi Reuven’s shiurim are in English and Hebrew. His classes are focused on spreading the truth and divinity of the Torah through MUSSAR, scientific proofs, and many other methods to reach each individual listener. Rabbi Reuven is the leading educator on the topic of wasting seed in the English language with over 30 hrs of content published online. Rabbi Yaron Reuven is a proud member of the Igud HaRabbonim (The Rabbinical Alliance of America), a national rabbinic organization founded in 1942. Today, our 900+ members are congregational leaders, religious teachers, chaplains, heads of Jewish organizations and communal leaders united in their commitment to traditional Orthodox Judaism. For more information please visit: https://rabbinicalalliance.org/ #TheHardTruth #ChangingCustoms #NoahideTeachers #KnowledgeVsBeliefInGod #StumpTheRabbi #Judaism #Jewish #RabbiYaronReuven #OrthodoxJudaism #JewishWisdom #Chizuk #Shiur #Torah #Divine #Wisdom #Inspiration
Transcript
0:34We are back here on our Wednesday night program of Stump the Rabbi, where after a little bit of Divrei Torah, you guys will ask questions, then B'ezrat Hashem HaKadosh Baruch Hu will give us the answers. I'm sure everyone has quite a few questions that they've saved up and B'ezrat Hashem, we will get to them as well. Tonight's shiur will be for Ilui Nishmat Moshe Yisrael ben Yosef Aryeh and also for a Refuah Shlema for Rabbanit Levana bat Sara, Rabbi Efraim ben Shulamit, Rabbanit Sara bat Anat, Orit bat Ilana, Yitro ben Avraham, Talia bat Sarah, Stefan ben Katerina, and also for the Hatzlacha Rabah of Marsha bat Julie, Ayla bat Marsha, Samuel ben Marsha, Alexander ben Marsha, Shaul ben Farzaneh, Yitro ben Avraham, Oshri ben Doris, Gabi ben Doris, Elad ben Doris, David ben Esria,
1:50and Reuven Chaim ben Pala Parel and also Sarah bat Sheina. God bless them and bless them in every way. May they live a long and complete life with Torah and mitzvot. Gemilut Chasadim, them and all of the other supporters that we have, whether it's ones that support us with their financial ability or ones that support us with their time or their skills, anyone that can support us, Baruch Hashem, we need as much as we possibly can get. A lot of times I tell people that, you know, don't think for a moment that just because HaKadosh Baruch Hu hasn't blessed you with enough parnassah to donate money that, you know, you're patur from this mitzvah, that you're absolved from this mitzvah. because the reality is that you may not have money, but surely you know somebody else who has money, whether it could be a cousin, a brother, a sister, a parent, and so on. You should try to encourage them to donate, like a few people do, but not enough. The reason why is because what a lot of people don't know is the teaching from Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai,
3:01who were about to celebrate the hilula of Rabbi in a couple of weeks, he said, "Greater is the one that enables another person to do a mitzvah than the one that is doing the mitzvah himself." Meaning, you'll actually get more reward for getting other people to donate than even the merit that you'll get from your own donation. This is one of the greatest gifts that HaKadosh Baruch Hu gave to Yisrael. because, in essence, he allowed everybody to become millionaires as far as their donations. Even if it's not your money that you've worked for, you could still earn even more merit by getting other people to donate and support. Also, for those few people that have asked me about Tikkun HaBrit flyers and other things that we're going to have in the store, B'ezrat Hashem, we're working on it. We're going to have it in the store, hopefully, B'ezrat Hashem, by tomorrow. And certainly, I believe, before the end of the week.
4:03The flyers, Baruch Hashem, are so far a big hit. People like them and like the idea. They like to do it. We're going to come up with some other ideas. The car magnets also are going to be there as well. And aside from that, there are a couple of other ideas, some stickers and different things that we're going to use to try to flood the world with the message that they have the ability to learn the truth. of the Torah and to learn about their Tikkun HaBrit to overcome all of these awful desires that lead to even, you know, other horrible things. So, one of the things we discussed last night, and as we do in our way of teaching Torah and Kedusha... is that it's extremely important for a person to pick the right rabbi. Many times, people cannot really tell the difference between the right rabbi and the wrong rabbi. Every single time we have exposed one of these wicked people who has the job of a rabbi but is obviously the furthest thing from being a rabbi, there's always at least a few people that say, "Oh, that's my rabbi! I can't believe you talked bad about him," and so on and so forth.
5:20And the truth is that we don't do this for our health. We don't do this for amusement. We tell people about, warning people about these different rabbis because obviously these people are causing damage to Am Yisrael. The guy Riskin that we mentioned last night and a few times in the past, He's not only the same guy that has students like Ephraim Goldberg and another guy from New York who bring Christian speakers, missionaries to their synagogues. But aside from that, he himself has caused more damage than probably any of his students by going against the Rabbanut in many different ways. One of them is when it comes to the issue of the get. which we discussed last night where he's telling people that you can simply divorce your husband, and if he doesn't want to give you a get, you can just ask the rabbi to declare you as divorced. and therefore you are divorced, which is 100% heresy and against the Torah, against the Halacha. And in last night's video that we posted today, we included the clips of him saying these nonsensical things. Other nonsense that he mentioned is that when he sees the Mashiach, as if he's going to see the Mashiach,
6:41and not be destroyed instantly. But nonetheless, when he sees the Mashiach, he's going to ask him, is this the first time or the second time that you're here? Meaning, referencing the Christian false god, Yeshu. and if that wasn't enough, he's also risking going against the Rabbanut and presenting the image of an Orthodox Rabbi, but he's going against the Rabbanut. How? By saying that it's time to unite with the Reform... ...and to allow public transportation on Shabbat. So, when somebody does things like this and, you know, I bring this information to my Rav and to other great talmidei chachamim and just ask them, "What do you think we should do about this? What do you say about this?" Each and every single time, they say, "Well, these are Reform people; don't bother with them." I said, "No, he's Orthodox." They're like, "What do you mean Orthodox? There's nothing Orthodox about this guy." You sure he's Orthodox? Every time the same thing. Same thing. Are you sure he's Orthodox? Because they don't look at the image. They simply hear the words. This is a Reform person.
7:52So it's very important to warn people. But when you give out a warning message to people that are either too connected to the world of lies, many times it makes people cringe. It makes people concerned. Wait a minute, are you saying lashon hara? are you saying, "How could you speak bad about people? Why don't you say good things?" Like one nice person sent me a message yesterday or today asking me if I could make a lecture about all the nice things that the Zionists have done because Eretz Yisrael is a place where there's a lot of Torah. So isn't that thanks to the Zionists? No, it's not thanks to the Zionists whatsoever. It's thanks to the righteous Jews that sacrificed their lives. for the sake of the Torah. If it were up to the Zionists, they would destroy the Torah, and it would be a completely Christian state. But nonetheless, many people would like to believe that their heroes, whether it be the Zionists or some heretical rabbi or some superstar or celebrity, are good people because, as Shlomo HaMelech teaches us, each person is judged based on who he praises. So if you praise someone that is
9:14been exposed and shown as a wicked person, it says a lot about you. Now, what is it to say that if somebody looked like he was good but in reality he was bad? There's always a little bit of footsteps. It's never really so surprising when you see a lot of these things if you really pay attention. But the point being is that each person has to know The Torah is not a rule book full of political correctness or really even a concern about your opinion of what the law is. There is really no concern whatsoever about what your opinion of the law is or my opinion of the law is, but rather there is the law, and the law is the law. And when people don't understand that, they have a hard time with the law and try to reason with it. That's where you get people like Dennis Prager or his wicked students like Asher Meza, and the rationalist like Slifkin, and all these other wicked people who come in with their own version of Torah.
10:26due to their wicked and distorted common sense. But yet, when they speak and when they deliver their messages in different formats, it seems genuine. It seems like something that they really mean well, but a person needs to understand that looks can be deceiving first and foremost. And second of all, it doesn't really make a difference how it looks. It doesn't really make a difference how it looks because you have to understand that we know who knows. We know who knows and we rely on them. Who's that? We know that the sages know. Now who do you think knows more? Goldberg or Weinberger or Manis Friedman or Droka Souto or Prager or any of those people or all of them put together or the sages of the Gemara. Who knows more? know who knows. We know who knows and we rely on them. Who's that? We know that the sages know. Now who do you think knows more? Goldberg or Weinberger or Manis Friedman or Droka Souto or Prager or any of those people or all of them put together or the sages of the Gemara? Who knows more? Who knows more, all of those wicked people that we've exposed over the years, or who do you think knows more? Who do you think knows more about what Hashem wants? This is what I'm saying; who do you think knows more about what Hashem is expecting of us, commanding us, those wicked people or the sages? Who do you think knows more?
11:52Many people like to say, "Yeah, but times have changed, and you can't really apply these things to this generation," and so on. Well, anyone that says that is 100% a heretic because that's a heretical statement according to the 13 principles of faith, one of which is that the Torah will not change. Now, to make sure that people understand what is the stance of the Torah when it comes to heresy, when it comes to heretics, I brought you a few new sources that I would like for everyone to understand the magnitude of the opinion here. It's not the magnitude of the Halacha here, it's the magnitude of the Torah's opinion. not my opinion, the Torah's opinion when it comes to dealing with heretics or even people that have abandoned the Torah. They married goyim, they're desecrating Shabbat openly, and so on and so forth. Now, of course, everyone would like to believe that the whole world of Jewish people that are not keeping Shabbat
12:57are all "tinokot she'nishbu," or as it's called in Torah terms, and everyone would like to believe that and rely on it. But the reality is, everyone knows that's simply not true. Anyone with eyes and a little bit of common sense knows it's simply not true. You may find an occasional one here and there, and I myself have even met a few, but the overwhelming majority of Jews today are simply not, you know, by anybody's definition. Nonetheless... The reality is that the halacha deals with everyone from the time of Moshe Rabbeinu until today. Of course, when HaKadosh Baruch Hu wrote the Torah, He took all of the people of this generation into consideration. When the Tannaim and the Amoraim of the Gemara i put together the Gemara. They took into consideration everything that they knew about the Torah in accordance with all generations, no matter where we will be. And don't think for a second that this is the first generation of weakness. We've had weakness throughout all of the generations. We had Am Yisrael turn into complete idolaters, turn into completely wicked people at certain times, desecrating Shabbat, intermarrying.
14:13Pretty much all the things that you see today, it's nothing new. It's happened throughout all of history. Needless to say, the wicked goyim, that were and are idolaters throughout all of the generations. But nonetheless, when you look at the world today and you understand what has happened throughout history, you see that people have not changed. People have not changed. That's number one. Number two, neither has the Torah. So, who is the winner here? Those that stick to the unchanging Torah. Those that stick to the unchanging Torah, they're the ones that are winners. If the world had continued its modernizing and heretical behavior at any point throughout history, we would not have a world. We would not have Jewish people in the world. neither has the Torah. So, who is the winner here? Those that stick to the unchanging Torah. Those that stick to the unchanging Torah, they're the ones that are winners. If the world had continued its modernizing and heretical behavior at any point throughout history, we would not have a world. We would not have Jewish people in the world. If the generation of the Tower of Babel was allowed to continue, or the generation of Noah was allowed to continue, or the generation of Sodom and Gomorrah was allowed to continue, or the generation of the first or second Beit HaMikdash was allowed to continue making all of their sins, we would have a completely secular world, which means that Hashem would have had to destroy the world altogether.
15:31So, it is not due to the Zionist or secular mentality or idolaters' merits that the world exists, but rather the world stands on the merits of those few righteous Jews that stick to the unchanging Torah. And that unchanging Torah is not sentimental to people who are not careful with the Torah itself. It does not care about people who do not care about it. It is not something that takes into consideration your feelings and your pressures from society. The Torah is the Torah. Those who comply with it and follow it will win both in this world and the next. This is the law as clear as day. But to give you an even clearer message, I brought you a couple of halachot so you understand because this is an issue that we all deal with. Every one of us knows or has a family member
16:32or friend, or someone even that we care about, or at the very least has heard about, that is completely off the derech, doesn't keep Shabbat, or is intermarried, or both. Obviously, someone that's not celebrating the Torah in any way, shape, or form, but rather is someone that's living as if the Torah is not an important document at all, it's not something that God gave, and even if it is, it's not necessarily something that applies to them. In so many words, someone secular—what does the Torah say? What does the Halacha say, I should say, about such a person, once, if they die? If they die, what happens if they die? Should we mourn them? Are we able to? I mean, technically, Jewish mourning is part of the religion itself. It's not part of the civil law. There's no mourning obligation by your local government.
17:32Your local government doesn't obligate you to cry for three days, to bury the body a certain way, or to say Kaddish. It doesn't matter where you live, whether it's Israel, America, the UK, Australia, Istanbul, or Indonesia. It doesn't make a difference. The civil law does not obligate you to mourn anyone who has died, even if that person was the most important person in your life. In fact, it cares less whether you mourn them or not. And when you do, they find you strange. Needless to say, the Torah cares about mourning, cares about mourning very much. And in fact, when the Gemara says that if you do not mourn the death of a kosher Jew, it can bring a very serious curse on the person, very serious punishment on the person who doesn't mourn a kosher Jew. Needless to say, if a Talmid Chacham dies, it's a very, very serious disaster that you could bring to your life. So much so that Chachamim say this is one of the reasons why Hashem brings a major destruction to the world, because when Tzaddikim die, not enough people mourn them. it's a very, very serious disaster that you could bring to your life. So much so that Chachamim say this is one of the reasons why Hashem brings a major destruction to the world, because when tzaddikim die, not enough people mourn them.
18:50uh, so the point being is because when a tzaddik dies, when someone that's righteous dies, that’s really not bad for the tzaddik—they're going to heaven. It's bad for the world because there's less holiness in the world. So, if the world doesn't understand that, if the Jewish world doesn't understand that a righteous person that dies is a major loss, then Hashem has to give the rebuke in a different way. But the point being is, what happens if your brother, sister, father, mother, whoever it is, is... desecrate Shabbat, intermarried, completely careless of the Torah. He's like a Dennis Prager or an Asher Meza heretic or any of these other people that we've mentioned. And I keep mentioning their names over and over again in every shiur to keep giving you the same warnings over and over in case you haven't watched the previous shiurim. Or you thought that for some reason we changed our mind. So the point being is, what does the Torah, what does the halacha think of such people? So this question was asked of Rav Ovadia. Rav Ovadia answers to people that asked him about their brother, a brother that died, but this brother was married to a non-Jew. Should they mourn him? Should they mourn him? In a sefer Ma'ayan Omer, Rav Ovadia writes, chas v'shalom, baruch haMakom sheharago.
20:17Rav Ovadia says, mourning someone that's intermarried, chas v'shalom, God forbid. Blessed is the Omnipresent that killed him. That's what Rav Ovadia wrote about someone that died and his family asking if they should mourn him or not. Now, the Sefer Tzitz Eliezer finds a leniency that if you see that they are mourning someone Someone who is not an observant Jew, you don't rebuke them. You let them mourn, even though it's really not appropriate. But nonetheless, real halacha says no, you don't mourn them. Now, maybe you think this is a chiddush from Rav Ovadia. Maybe people think this is a chiddush from Rav Ovadia, but it's actually not. It's not a chiddush at all. In fact, it's paskened l'halacha in the Shulchan Aruch. the laws of dealing with people that have died, Siman 345, say the following: All of those people that have left the way, have gone off the derech, have left the community
21:40that have abandoned the mitzvot and are not considered as part of the community of Am Yisrael in their actions, meaning they're not fulfilling mitzvot, they don't keep Shabbat, they're not married to Jewish people, they don't keep Pesach and all the holidays and so on and so forth, or do not honor the mo'adim, they don't honor the holidays, meaning honor by observing them, not by saying, "Oh yeah, I honor Yom Kippur," while he's eating on a fast day and does not honor the Beit Knesset or the Beit Midrash, doesn't go to shul, doesn't go to learn Torah. They're considered as if they are part of the gentile nations and not part of us. And just like those that are outright heretics, and those that are people who go to the government, to the police, to the IRS, or to all types of government bodies to report on Jewish people to hurt them.
22:57So, these people that are, in so many words, secular, don't keep anything, perhaps intermarried, violate Shabbat openly, regularly—they're no different than the heretics or even people that report on Am Yisrael to the government to hurt us. They're considered in the same class, the Shulchan Aruch says. Kol elu, all of these people, he says, ein onenim ve’ein mit'avelim aleihem. We do not mourn them in any way, shape, or form. but rather when these people die, their brothers and their relatives should wear white and cover like a celebration, and eat, drink, and be happy.
23:59Now this, I know, hurts some people's emotions, hearts. Maybe you've actually already shut off this lecture at this point where you're not going to listen to the rest. You're angry. You're going to go to your rabbi and tell on me. Whatever it is that people are going to do. But this is halacha, meaning nothing anybody can do about it. That's what halacha is. That's what halacha is. So, like I said, there are poskim that say that if they do mourn, you don't rebuke them; you let them mourn. But nonetheless, there's no obligation to mourn them, and, in fact, you should be happy. Why? Why should we be happy? Why should, why? Rabbi Ovadia, who loved Am Yisrael, Rabbi Yosef Karo, who loved Am Yisrael, all of these tzaddikim, all of the tzaddikim, from Chassidut, from the Ashkenazi world, the Sephardi world, the Mekubalim, all of the biggest tzaddikim in history, they all pasken like this. So how could they all say, when a secular person dies, you wear white and celebrate?
25:01Doesn't add up to the person. Why? Because they had a very clear understanding of what the truth is while we are struggling to get it. What is the truth? The truth is, Rabotai, they're happy that those people died because now that they died, blessed is Hashem that took him because now He has stopped them from sinning, which is hurting them. In essence, if you knew that someone is killing himself by taking drugs, by drinking alcohol, by doing all types of horrible things, and you saw that he's bringing a lot of damage to himself, to his wife, to his kids, to society—awful, awful damage to the world—and one day you found out that he died... surely, in your heart, in the honest part of your heart, you would say, "Thank God he died." Why? Because of all the damage that he caused to himself, to his wife, or to her husband, and to the children, and to the parents, and to society—all the damage they were doing. Thank God they died. That's, in essence, what Rabbi Yosef Karo is saying, or what all of the tzaddikim that understood the purpose of our world are saying.
26:15and the purpose of us in the world, that's what they were asking. That's why they said, Baruch Hashem. Baruch HaMakom that did this. Now, many times, Rabotai Yekarim, We think that the stories that you hear in lectures and in different videos and so on are always, if they make sense to you, you like them and it's good, but if they don't make sense to you, perhaps there's something wrong with them, or sometimes you think maybe times have changed. Nothing has changed. Nothing has changed. People are the same. People have the same desires. People have the same sins as opportunities and the same mitzvot as opportunities. Now, although our generation is weaker in their Torah observance, nonetheless, the opportunity to grow is even greater today than it was in the past because of how accessible Torah is today. So, there is... pros and cons on both sides. There is a benefit to this generation also of having so much access to Torah where you could literally learn the entire Shas without even having a book, by simply listening to specific videos that go over Daf Yomi. You can learn Mussar and fix your entire life, your marriage,
27:35...your relationships, your business, by simply watching good videos of real Mussar and start applying them to your life. There's an extraordinary amount of information available in the world today that can help people fix their lives. uh, and they don't necessarily need to go and start at the age of zero. They can start at any age because even if they've missed out on yeshiva education for the first 10, 20, 30, 40, or 50 years of their life, they can still catch up relatively quickly because of how accessible Torah is today. But the point being is, when you look at... Artois, you see that Artois doesn't really think like us as far as the reasons that we use and the excuses that we use not to learn Torah. Many times people say, "No, I don't agree because the sages, they maybe they're too strict, maybe this, maybe that." Well, they're only strict if you think that the law is not divine. But when you know that the law is divine, there is no such thing as strict or not strict. This is the obligation. You can do it or choose not to. Simple.
28:48That's, there's no strictness. Like maybe, oh yeah, a lot of people said, "You're a strict rabbi." I don't understand what that even means. Am I adding to the law? No. Am I changing the law? No. I'm telling you what the law is. I'm telling you what Hashem said. I'm telling you what the sages said. Whether you choose to follow it or you don't follow it, that's your business. But at the very least, you'll be well informed. Now, if you prefer someone to lie to you, then of course you can go elsewhere. You're not going to get lies over here. But to say that this is strict or stringent or any of those silly words that people use is completely ludicrous because, again, look at how the sages were. And you're going to say, wait, maybe, but just the way you deliver it, it's harsh. You know, maybe you raise your voice. Maybe you say again, no. OK, so let's see how the sages communicated to each other. let's see how the sages communicated to each other, and then we'll go, and you tell me whether I am strict and the Torah that we teach is strict, or if I am, as I've always mentioned to you, a little puppy, a little baby puppy, next to the sages and how they spoke to each other. I'll give you several examples.
30:00The Gemara in Masechet Berachot, page 5b, has an extraordinary and well-known story of Rav Huna. Rav Huna had 400 barrels of wine that he used in order to make a living, where it was a good way to make a living for him because it allowed him to make few transactions a year, and that would give him enough time to learn Torah the rest of the year. But as you would have it, His 400 barrels of wine soured and they turned to vinegar, which surely, as no one needs to educate you about this, when wine turns to vinegar, it's obviously an extraordinary loss. Instead of each barrel being worth thousands of dollars, now each barrel is worth only a few hundred dollars. So, an extraordinary loss. So Rav Yehuda, the brother of Rav Sala Hasida, as well as other sages, went to visit Rav Huna. And some also say that another sage visited him as well. Anyway, they heard about his loss and they came to talk to him.
31:05Now, you would think, let's say for example you are a successful person. You have gathered a nice nest egg: two, three, four, five million dollars. You know, you're able to give tzedakah, you're able to learn Torah, you're able to do a lot of things, and you figured, you know what, let me give it to Bernie Madoff. Let me give it to some financial manager that's just gonna keep me above water, and that way I can live on my nest egg for the rest of my life. And as you would have it, one day you find out, oh... Ponzi scheme, all the money is gone, right? All the money is gone. So your friends find out. They call you. "Hey, Steve, I heard you lost everything." "Yeah, yeah, yeah. Okay, I'm coming. I'm coming." Okay, so now your friend is calling you. He says, "I'm coming. And I'm bringing friends over." What are you expecting your friends to come and tell you? "Ah, sorry to hear about it, man. You know, listen, you can do it. You're still young. You've got your whole life ahead." all types of encouraging messages. That's generally how society works. You expect your friends to give you encouraging messages. What did the sages do when they heard Rav Huna, one of the fellow sages who was able to resurrect the dead, a giant chacham,
32:17he lost his money. What did they do? Did they act the same way we do in society today, or did they do something a little different? Now again, I'm telling you what the sages did in different circumstances, not necessarily to go tell you to do the same thing because we're not necessarily on their level, or the audience that we have is not on their level. Even if you understand it, your audience may not understand it, so I don't necessarily recommend... this type of behavior for anybody to do with anybody. But nonetheless, to understand what the truth is because the midah of emet, the trait of emet, is the signature of Hashem. And we're going to learn today how truthful the sages are, and to what extent, because Because surely they're still human. Surely it hurts. Surely it's not always convenient. But nonetheless, they always tell the truth. And I'll show you multiple circumstances of truth being told in our teachings and how different it is from the truth that people think they hear today. The sages come and they see him, and they said to him,
33:28Why doesn't Rav Huna, why doesn't the master examine his affairs to determine the cause of this loss? Meaning, why don't you do some self-accounting to see where you sinned? We are not here to say, "We're sorry to hear, too bad." No, no, no. Rav Huna, you lost all your money. Why don't you now do a cheshbon nefesh to see why Hashem took your money? You do that today. Somebody just lost all of his nest egg and you tell him, listen, Why don't you check yourself? Maybe it's good for you that Hashem took all your money. That person is going to lose the money. That person has told you that he's going to lose the money. What? He's going to disappear. No one's ever going to find him because you're going to bury him exactly where he stands. No one wants to hear that kind of truth. But that's the reality. That's what the Chachamim say. Why don't you do cheshbon nefesh, Rav Huna? Rav Huna says to them, Am I a suspect in your eyes? You suspect me of being a sinner. And they said to him, "Is the Holy One, blessed be He, a suspect of punishing without justice?" And he said, "What? I'm a sinner?" And they say to him, "What? Is Hashem a sinner? Is Hashem making mistakes? What? You think that Hashem punishes somebody for no reason? Is such a thought in your head?"
34:57At that moment, I understand that they know something, and they're trying to give me a message because surely Hashem doesn't make mistakes. They're not telling me to check myself for no reason. He says to them, "If there is anyone who heard something about me that I must fix, let him speak now." they responded to him, "This is what we heard about you: the master did not give branches of his vineyard to his sharecropper. Rav Huna had some crops, and a certain relative of his was working for him. Usually, some people would leave some of the remains and give it to them." they said, "We heard that you're not giving it to him. Perhaps that's the sin, that it's not really a sin but a lack of generosity, a lack of generosity. So they said maybe that's the reason why you're getting punished, because you're not generous and it took away your money." He responded to them, "Did he leave me any of them?"
36:19He stole all of them from me. That is, he took far more than his rightful share. Meaning, Rav Huna is saying to them, I don't need to give him anything that's left. He's stealing from me a lot more than I pay him. Listen to this, Rabotai. The sages respond to him. And they said, Rav Huna, this is an example of a popular adage: "Steal from a thief and feel the taste of stealing." said to them, "I accept upon myself to give him his share of the remaining branches. You guys are right. You say you are not giving him what's traditionally given because he's stealing from you, but in reality..." you're still doing something wrong. Why? You're a tzaddik. You're a kadosh. You know that Hashem is the one that runs the world and no one can take a dollar from you if Hashem didn't decree it. So either way, even if he's stealing, you should still give him what is usually traditionally given. And the fact that you're not giving it to him is as if you are stealing. You're getting a little taste of it, and that's why someone's stealing from you. Someone is stealing from you.
37:41Where if you, because you in essence stole on your level, it's not really considered stealing, but on your level, it's considered like you stole. You are going to feel the pain of stealing yourself, in essence. So Rav Huna says, you're right. You're right. I accept it. I accept what you said one hundred percent. And the Gemara says that by the time he got home, by the time he got back to where his barrels were, however long that journey was—20 minutes, an hour, however long it was—miraculously, the vinegar turned back to wine. Some say no, it didn't turn back to wine, but rather the price of vinegar shot up through the roof, where he ended up making as much money as he would have made if it was wine. Either way, Hashem gave him back all the money that he lost because he got the message. the bigger message here is for us, which is that rather than just pacifying the guy with "No, everything's gonna be okay, poor you, don't worry, Hashem knows," and all this nonsense that people tell each other, just pacifying them with meaningless, empty words, you see how the sages talk to each other. We'll go to another example. Another example of midat hadin.
39:13Chachmei Yisrael. Chachmei Yisrael, the Jewish sages, in Gemara Masechet Pesachim, page 94b. The Jewish sages say that by day the sun travels below the vault of the firmament, and by night it travels above the firmament. But the Gentile experts say that by day the sun travels below the vault of the firmament, and by night it travels below the ground. Meaning there's a disagreement between what the Jewish sages were saying versus what the Gentile scientists or experts at the time were saying. And this is written in our Talmud, right? So you would think if it's, let's say, false religions like Christianity and Islam and all this other stuff that see no fault in themselves, what would they say? Surely the sages won, right? Full of emet, says Rebbe, brings a proof to the view of the gentile sages, saying Rebbe says their words, the gentiles, appear more reasonable than our words. For consider that by day the wall springs are cold, while at night they're hot. Rebbe says, listen, based on the proofs that we have versus the proofs that they have.
40:36They have a reasonable case. Some say he actually, he's saying that they are actually right here. But Rabbeinu Tam comes and says, no, he's not saying that they're right, but he's saying that they have a good case. They have sufficient proof, something that we have to consider. Either way, why is this written in the Gemara? You should say, no, the Jewish people won, the sages won, they're always the smartest. No, that's not the way it is. That's not the way it is. Torah is objective. we're right, we're right, we're wrong, we're wrong. When something, when information was given to us by God, surely there's no dispute. There's no dispute with the sages. We know what's right. But when it's information that we evaluated ourselves through our own intellect by using different things that we've learned, and we're wrong, and a Gentile is right, no problem. But why mention it in the Gemara? Because that's the emet. That's the emet. comes Rabbi Avraham ben HaRambam, the son of the Rambam. He writes, the reason why Rabbeinu HaKadosh, Rabbi Yehuda HaNasi, his name was Yehuda. Why is he called Rabbeinu HaKadosh? Now, of course, the Zohar says because he protected his brit.
41:52Did the whole world know about protecting his brit? Everybody kept their brit, all tzaddikim. What's that? No, look at this. He was a kadosh. Because when he saw in his greatness, in his greatness, he saw he was wrong, even if it was in front of everybody, he not only admitted it, he wrote it in his own Mishnah, in his own Talmud. Yeah, yeah, I was wrong over here. Why? That's the emet. That's the emet, rabotai. That's the emet. Another example. Gemara, Masechet Sanhedrin. We have a very interesting, well-known story. When Rabbi Eliezer ben Horkenos, the rabbi of Rabbi Akiva and many other great sages, became sick, When Rabbi Eliezer took ill, four sages came to visit him: Rabbi Tarfon, Rabbi Yehoshua, Rabbi Elazar ben Azariah, and Rabbi Akiva. They came to see their rabbi, from whom they had learned a lot.
43:16And they see that Rabbi Eliezer ben Hyrcanus is sick. So Rabbi Tarfon spoke up and said to Rabbi Eliezer, "You, my dear teacher, are better for Am Yisrael than a drop of rain, for a drop of rain is beneficial in this world, whereas my master, by teaching us Torah, benefits us both in this world and the world to come." Rabbi Yehoshua then spoke and said to Rabbi Eliezer, "You are better for Am Yisrael than the very orb of the sun. For the orb of the sun provides light in this world, whereas my master provides light in this world and the world to come." Then Rabbi Elazar ben Azaryah spoke up and said, "You, my master, are better for Am Yisrael than a father and a mother." For a father and a mother create life in this world, whereas my master creates life in this world and the world to come. So far, three out of four are giving compliments to their rabbi. Baruch Hashem. Great. Comes Rabbi Akiva, his dear student, and speaks: "Precious are sufferings." What? What?
44:35They're all complimenting him. And he's telling them, he sees his teacher, Kodesh Kodashim, a living Sefer Torah, who had more Torah knowledge than the whole world put together. If all of the ocean were ink, and all of the trees were pens, and all of the land were paper, it would not be enough to write the Torah that Rabbi Eliezer ben Hyrcanus knew. And that's what he said. And he says that my Torah is not even a drop of water in comparison to the Torah of my Rebbe, Rabbi Yochanan ben Zakkai. And he is suffering in pain. Three out of four of his students are giving him compliments and saying, "Rabbi, we love you. You're important to us. Keep pushing." Rabbi Akiva comes and gives a little bit different news: "Precious are the sufferings that you have." In so many words, it's good you're suffering. Rabbi, it's good you're suffering. Baruch Hashem. It comes from Rabbi Akiva, not some gangster. Rabbi Akiva is saying, Rabbi, it's good you're suffering. Baruch Hashem. Precious are your sufferings. Why? It's a kapara for you. It's a kapara for you. It's good. It's atonement for you.
45:57Now, somebody came to somebody's house, came to the hospital, visited him. Everybody's saying, no, listen, keep pushing. So the sham surgery is going to work out. Don't worry, you've got another 120 years to go, all that stuff. And then somebody comes from left field and says, ah, listen, good for you, you're suffering. Baruch Hashem. What are they going to do to this guy? They're going to throw him headfirst out the window. Get out of here, you pessimist, you crazy... I curse under the sun. What are you going to do? Don't try this at home, by the way. You're not at that level and neither is your audience. But again, this is the emet. Why is this the emet? Listen to this. says to the others, "Give me a hand, give me support. I want to get up, and I want to hear the words of my student who said, 'Precious are sufferings.' I want to hear it; I want to hear what he said."
47:03Get him up. He wants to hear. He pays attention to this. Why? This is important. This is Torah over here. What are you saying? What are you saying over here? Precious are sufferings? Why? Akiva, where do you get this? Where did you get this opinion of yours? This chidush that you bring to me? Rabbi Akiva responds. He says, I have verses from Torah that say it. You look at the book of Melachim II, chapter 21, verse 1 and 2. where Menashe was 12 years old when he became king, and he reigned 55 years in Jerusalem, and he did evil in the eyes of Hashem. And it's written elsewhere that there too, there are proverbs of Shlomo HaMelech, which the men of Chizkiyahu, king of Yehudah, wrote down. So in so many words, he's saying that Menashe was a rasha, did a lot of bad things, but his father was a big tzaddik. What did he do? He took the Torah, he wrote it down, made sure everybody learned Torah. Now he says, is it possible that Chizkiyahu, the Kadosh Kadoshim, whom Hashem wanted to make Mashiach?
48:21Chizkiyahu, the king of Yehudah, taught Torah to the entire world, but he didn't teach Torah to Menashe, his son, and that's why he became a rasha. Obviously, that's not the case. Rather, for all the trouble that Chizkiyahu took with Menashe to teach him Torah and the paths of righteousness, none of that effort made Menashe do teshuva. What made him do teshuva? What elevated him finally? When suffering came upon him. That's what elevated Menashe to do teshuva. As it is written in the book of Divrei HaYamim 2, chapter 33, verses 10 and 11. Hashem spoke to Menashe and to his people, but they did not pay heed. So Hashem brought upon them the commanders of the king of Assyria, and they captured Menashe with hooks, bound him with copper fetters, and transported him to Babylonia.
49:22In the next verse, it says that when Menashe was in distress, he entreated Hashem his God. He did teshuvah and humbled himself greatly before Hashem, the God of his fathers. prayed to Him and Hashem was entreated by him, and He heard his prayers and returned him to Yerushalayim, to his kingdom, by making a miracle. He made the pot that the cannibals were about to cook and eat Menashe in fly in the air all the way from there to Yerushalayim. It was the first UFO. ...making a miracle. He made the pot that the cannibals were about to cook and eat Menashe in fly in the air all the way from there to Yerushalayim. It was the first UFO. What saved him? His suffering saved him. And from here we learn, Rabbi Akiva says to his teacher, Rabbi Eliezer ben Hyrcanus, that suffering is precious, for it is these afflictions, not the Torah studies of his youth, that inspired Menashe to turn to Hashem in sincere teshuva, and then regain his throne. That's why it's precious that you have suffering. It's good for you. What saved him? His suffering saved him. And from here we learn, Rabbi Akiva says to his teacher, Rabbi Eliezer ben Hyrcanus, that suffering is precious, for it is these afflictions, not the Torah studies of his youth, that inspired Menashe to turn to Hashem in sincere teshuva, and then regain his throne. That's why it's precious that you have suffering. It's good for you.
50:48Somebody says that in today's world, the first thing that happens to them is, uh, you call him because the person is not going to be there anymore. But that's the truth. That's the truth. Another example, this one for sure, don't try at home. Page 38a, his daughter died. Rabbi said to Ulla, "Come, let us go console him." Ulla said to them—Ulla was one of the Gedolei HaDor at the time—Ulla said to them, "What do I have to do with this consolation with you Babylonians? The way you console is like heresies, blasphemy against the Holy One. Because when you console somebody..." say, "Oh, what can be done? You know, maybe if you would have done this, maybe if you would have done that, maybe you could have saved her." That's the way you console people, and that's how people do today, unfortunately. Many times, somebody loses something, whether he loses a loved one or he loses money.
52:01or anything else. What did everybody do? Yeah, maybe if you would have done it another way, it could have happened. Maybe if you didn't go, maybe if you would have gone, maybe if you would have called, maybe I could have thought about it, maybe if I would have paid attention. That's how people console each other and that's how people think. And Ulla says that is blasphemy against Hashem. So I'm not going to console him with you guys because you are heretics in the way you console. I'll console him. I need to console him. But I'm not going to do it with you people. I'll just sell them dreams that something else could have happened. Because this type of consoling implies that there was something that could have been done to reverse Hashem's decree. This is blasphemy. Instead, Ula went to Rav Shmuel bar Yehuda alone. And he says to him, there's a verse in Deuteronomy 2:9. He's coming there to console him. Take a look at how he consoles him. He's not going to console him like the heretics, but he's going to console him in a different way. How does he console him? Obviously, you think, oh, he's going to console him by giving him a hug. What is he going to say to him? This is how he consoles him. Listen to this.
53:23He gives them a Dvar Torah. We learn from the book of Devarim, chapter 2, verse 9. What do we learn? And Hashem said to Moshe, "Don't oppress Moav, the nation of Moav, and do not incite war against them. Don't go to war against them. Why? Because He said that the Moav... is a descendant of Lot, and Hashem says, "I decided to give them a certain amount of land because of the merit of Lot. Therefore, don't go and try to conquer their land." Now, Ulla says, why would it have arisen in Moshe Rabbeinu's thought to go to war against Moav without asking Hashem's permission in the first place? Did Moshe Rabbeinu ever go and do something and think, "Oh yeah, I'm going to declare war against somebody else?" Let's say, "Oh, you can ask Hashem," right? Why would he want to go to war with Moav? Especially go to war with them without asking Hashem's permission.
54:33Because Moshe Rabbeinu, Hashem knew his thoughts, and he reasoned to himself with a kal vachomer, meaning he rationalized things with something where it makes sense that this is what should be done. So Hashem had to interfere and tell him, no, no, no, even though it makes sense to you, don't do it. Don't do it. Why? There are certain reasons why I want them to stay alive. What were the reasons? He says, look, there are the Midianites, who came to war against Am Yisrael, the Kozbi and all the other women over there, they enticed and the whole issue what happened with Moav and, I'm sorry, with Pinchas killing them and so on. That whole thing, that was Midian and Moav. So the Midianites, the Midianites that Moshe Rabbeinu ended up killing, they really just came to help the Moabites. The Moabites are the ones that started the whole thing.
55:34so he figured, if we were commanded to go kill and take revenge against the Midianites, where Hashem commanded us in the book of Numbers, chapter 25, verse 17, "Oppress the Midianites and smite them, destroy them," then regarding the Moabites themselves that actually instigated the whole hostile behavior against Am Yisrael, it's certain that Am Yisrael should wage war against them. It makes a hundred percent perfect sense. That's what Moshe thought. And what did the Holy One, blessed be He, say to Moshe Rabbeinu? He says to Moshe Rabbeinu, what you're thinking, Moshe, is not what I'm thinking. I don't desire the destruction of Moav, nor its sister nation, Ammon. Why? Because there are two fine pigeons that I must first draw forth from them.
56:36Two things, two diamonds coming out of these two nations that first have to come out before anything—they get destroyed. What are those? Ruth the Moabite and Naamah the Ammonite. These two need to come into the world first. They need to come to the world first. Ruth, of course, being the grandmother of David. Mashiach and Naamah was one of the wives of Shlomo HaMelech, who was a big tzaddekes. So these two tzaddekes will ensure the emergence of the future descendants of Moav and Ammon. And God forbid Moshe Rabbeinu to wage war against these nations. So comes back Ula to his friend and... That Rav Shmuel bar Yehuda, whose daughter just died, is telling him this whole thing. And he says, look what we learn from this story. We learn from this story that this matter is not a basis for kal v'chomer regarding your daughter. Meaning, look at what Hashem did.
57:58these two pigeons, these two tzadikot, decided to show mercy to two entire nations. Why did these two entire nations get the right to exist? Because tzadikim are going to be born from them one day. So likewise, my teacher's daughter, meaning your daughter, Rav Shmuel's daughter... If she was really that much of a tzadika, worthy of having tzadikim descendants emerge from her, how much more so is it certain that Hashem would have kept her alive. In so many words, nothing good would have come from your daughter, that's why Hashem killed her. Because if anything good would have come from her, like Ruth the Moabite or Na'amah the Ammonite, Hashem would have surely saved her. if He took her out of the world, that means that nothing would have come from her. So that's how we console him; that's what he was consulted about. Don't try this at home, but nonetheless, is it a mitzvah? 100% of it, 100% of it. A couple of small examples, and we're going to get to your questions. This is a little bit of a different shiur, I think, than all the other ones we've done in the past here.
59:30Oh, Gemara, Masechet Shabbat, has a guy who is Talmid Chacham, guy who is Talmid Chacham, dies early, dies young, dies young. In Gemara, Masechet Shabbat, page 13b and 13a, end of 13a, beginning of 13b, before the Mishnah. And, uh, this guy was a good guy, dies, dies young, which is a, uh, it's a, it's a punishment. It's a punishment if somebody dies young; it's a punishment many times. But to get clarity, the wife, who's a big tzadika, comes to the Beit Midrash and asks the tzadikim, "How could it be? If the Torah promises a long life if you learn, if you're a tzadik, if you're this, if you're that, how could my husband die so young? What happened here?" And no one has any answers for her. No one has any answers for her. And she goes to a different Beit Midrash. No one has any answers. What Beit Midrash is she going to? She's going to the Beit Midrash of the biggest tzadikim in the world. The people that were able to, the people of the Gemara, the people that were able to resurrect the dead. And they don't have any answers for her. Why? Nobody knows the details of what happened here. Because that's the accounting of Hashem.
1:00:49HaKadosh Baruch Hu sees this, sees that she means well. She's not coming to complain against Hashem. She genuinely wants to find an answer. It's not like people today where as soon as something goes wrong, they complain against Hashem and become heretics. No, she wants to know, please give me insight into how I can understand what happened here. Because the Torah says one thing and something else happened. Can somebody give me an answer on this? Hashem sees that she's means well, He sends Eliyahu HaNavi. Eliyahu HaNavi, He sends him to a house. Eliyahu HaNavi comes to this woman and he says, "My dear daughter, when you were nida, what did your husband do with you?" She says, "Oh, chas v'shalom, God forbid, he didn't touch me. Even my little finger he didn't touch." how on the bed, sister, what about the days that you were counting? She says, "During the time that we were counting, he ate together with me, he drank together with me, he slept with me without clothing in the bed. That's how people used to sleep in those days, without clothing."
1:02:12But he didn't even think about anything else, meaning he didn't think about touching me. We're never intimate. It's just that since we're counting and already, you know, I'm about to go to the mikveh the next day, a few days later and so on, depending on where the count is. So we already started, you know, coming back to normal things. But he didn't touch me. We weren't intimate because he knows I'm not allowed, not permissible yet. When I was still bleeding, he didn't even touch my finger. But once I already started counting, we slept in the same bed. We ate together on the same plate. Eliyahu HaNavi zachur latov says to the woman, "Baruch HaMakom sheharago." Blessed is God who killed him. What? I'm asking for answers. I'm asking, what? Blessed is God who killed him? Yes, blessed is God who killed him because your husband did not show respect towards the Torah.
1:03:22But the Torah says that not only should you not touch your wife when she's nidah, but the Torah says in Leviticus, chapter 18, verse 19, "Ve'el isha benidat tum'atah lo tikrav." Torah says you shall not approach a woman, nor get close to a woman in her time of niddah, an unclean separation. Don't even get close to her. Forget about touching her. That's obvious. Don't even get close to her. Sleep in the same bed. Handing stuff to each other. Eating from the same plate. Habibi, you have no respect for the Torah with all the Torah that you learn. Baruch Hashem that He killed you. That's what Eliyahu HaNavi says to the woman, says to the widow. And that's the emet. That's the emet, rabotai. That's the emet. That is the emet that people have a hard time understanding. Why? It doesn't jive with their common sense of humans. The Gemara, Masechet Chullin, page 116b. If you look at the Rashi, Rashi over there,
1:04:43says because I made a mistake in regards to this issue, which is related to the whole issue with regard to milk inside the cow and so on. We're not going to get into the subject because you guys have to ask questions. But nonetheless, Rashi says, "I made a mistake." this is the only time in the entire Shas Rashi says, "I made a mistake." Now, if you're writing a thesis paper, if you're writing a report, if you are writing a book, are you gonna write, "By the way, I made a mistake here"? No. If you made a mistake, don't write it. If you made a mistake... don't make believe you didn't make a mistake. Why do you want to present yourself in a way that you're infallible? That's not Torah. Rashi says, "I made a mistake" one time. Why? It's the only mistake he made. But what about it? Was it something that Rashi didn't know? Was it something that Rashi didn't know in the Gemara?
1:05:59page 25b Rashi says, "I don't know, I don't know, I don't know." This comes from hundreds of years later in a sefer, one of the... says this lo yadati, this Rashi saying he doesn't know, is one of 43 times in the entire Shas that he says he doesn't know. Anyone who understands the size of the Shas, how huge it is, it's literally incomprehensible how big the Shas is. But Rashi writes one time, "I made a mistake," 43 times, "I don't know." When I don't know, I don't talk about it. When you don't know, you pretend you know. That's the way people are. Rashi? Sages? I don't know. I don't know. Why? You want to be chacham? Learn to say, "I don't know." That's what chachamim say. Learn to say, "I don't know," when you don't know. Learn to say, "I made a mistake," when you make a mistake. Why? That's the emet.
1:07:23so why go about it and write a whole book about it? He says we need to know. We need to know what he doesn't know—43 things, 43 things he didn't know. That's it. Everything else he knows. Why did the Sages delve into these 43 things instead of the million and a half things that he didn't know? Because we need to know both. That's taught. that's it, that's the holiness, that's the beauty. When a person understands Torah is not an opinion, and that opinion that you have may or may not disagree with the Torah, you have to always remember: you listen to the Torah, you're going to win. Whether it's apparent right away or not is irrelevant. You listen to the Torah, you're always going to win. When you start listening to your feelings, you're guaranteed to lose. You're guaranteed to lose. All types of people do whatever they feel. In the Jewish world, people decide they're going to keep whatever selective mitzvot they want.
1:08:38on Shabbat because they want to go to shul even though they live far away, thinking that it's more important to go to synagogue than to keep Shabbat. Why? Because their heart tells them that, or the rabbi, unfortunately. Or they're marrying somebody or they're with somebody they're not allowed to be with. "Oh Rabbi, please, please, he's such a good guy." So what if he's a good guy? You're not allowed to marry him. "No, but can't you like convince him to be Jewish?" No, no. I don't convince people to be Jewish. If he wants to be Jewish, it's on him. I'll help him if he wants to be Jewish. I'll guide him. I'll send him a syllabus or something. That's it. He wants to be Jewish. It's on him. She wants to be Jewish. It's on her. But people cry about it. "Oh, you're not sensitive." Not sensitive? What do you mean, sensitive? I don't have time to be sensitive. If I'm sensitive, I cry all day for all the disasters I deal with. Better yet, non-Jews decide, "I'm Jewish." What do you mean you're Jewish? Is your mom Jewish? No. No. converted? No! So why are you Jewish? I keep Shabbat. But you're not Jewish. You're not allowed to keep Shabbat. Rambam says if you're a non-Jew and you keep Shabbat, you are a thief. You're going to Gehinnom. But I like it. So what if you like it? Either become a Jew or don't. Don't act like a Jew without becoming a Jew. Now, if you're in the process of conversion...
1:10:02You should keep 99% of Shabbat, but specifically 99%. Why? To remind you that you're not allowed to keep Shabbat because you're still a goy. You are going to listen to your little feelings and go to Gehinom with those feelings. Why? Because you’re going against the Torah HaKedosha and its Chachamim and listening to your stupid feelings. Rabotai, take those feelings and throw them in the garbage. Why? It’s going to leave room for the Torah to enter, and that is what’s going to take you to Gan Eden. That's what's going to take you to Gan Eden. Torah is Kodesh Kodashim. It's 100% emet. Even when that emet has to be something that makes us look bad. Like, I'm wrong. Like, I don't know. Like, somebody died. Maybe you're a sinner. Like, nothing good would have come out of it. That's what happened. All types of things that today's society doesn't make any sense.
1:11:08but it only doesn't make sense to someone who's empty of holy Torah and Emet, someone that has Emet and a Torah to lead him in all directions. This is a one-way street. There are no branches, just a one-way street. And those fools that say there are 70 faces to the Torah, those 70 faces are all parts of the same diamond, all looking at the same center, which is the Emet, the Emet of the Torah. They can't be all looking in different directions, and he has his version, and he has his version. There are no versions. They're all facets of the same diamond, looking at the same center point, which is the Emet. That's the signature of HaKadosh Baruch Hu. With that being said, Rabotai, I know I took a little extra time today, but I think it was worth it for this very special shiur that I studied with my rabbi, Rabbi Ephraim. God bless him for giving us so many extraordinary chidushim. Nonetheless, Rabotai, there is a lot to say, but I think that it's time for you guys to talk. So, after I take a little bit of a drink, you guys can start asking questions.
1:12:44Leah is asking, for what if I forgot to say Ya’aleh V’yavo during Amidah or Birkat HaMazon, does she need to repeat the prayers since she's not obligated to mitzvot that are bound to time? Even though a woman is not obligated to do mitzvot that are bound to time, such as the mitzvah of, uh, in a specific time, putting on tefillin. ...uh, the mitzvah of the sukkah, the lulav, uh, she's not obligated to do all those things, but the mitzvah of Rosh Chodesh is also a mitzvah for the women. In fact, the mitzvah of Rosh Chodesh is a major issue for women, whereby it's actually supposed to be a day that the women are celebrated... really should not be working during that day or, at the very least, they should do fewer chores, have a nice meal, and perhaps spend some more time enjoying themselves during that time, connecting, because this is one of the reasons for it. Hashem made it as a time to celebrate the woman.
1:13:52So with that being said, a woman is obligated when she does her at least once-a-day prayer, because she can pray at any time that she wants, in the morning, in the afternoon, or at night. When she does the Amidah, uh, she has to say ya'aleh v'yavo or else the whole prayer is not valid. The same thing applies to Birkat Hamazon if she ate bread. It has to include ya'aleh v'yavo if it's applicable for that day. If she says Birkat Hamazon without ya'aleh v'yavo, then that Birkat Hamazon is valid but for a different day. For that day, it's not applicable; she has to go back and say it again. So, it is applicable to her. Next, a sensitive question by Shabtai: How can a Jew return to Hashem? I've been having nightmares of past traumas in my life, including the one where I was almost arrested at 13. I've changed for the better, but ever since the nightmares started, I became more irritable, feeling like I'm losing Hashem.
1:14:55There are different points of a person's teshuva where he's going to have easier times and more difficult times, both in his life and in his learning of Torah. In the beginning of doing teshuva, especially if a person is young, Hashem helps a person a lot, allowing him to learn a lot in a short period of time. he's able to comprehend more percentage-wise than a typical person understands in a shiur or in a sefer. Hashem helps a person a lot, but then, after a little while, Hashem starts taking off the training wheels. starts to just like when you were a little kid, you start learning how to ride a bike. You have training wheels on the side, and you're able to ride, but then eventually you have to take them off. In the beginning, you fall a few times because it's a little difficult; it's a new adjustment. And that's, in essence, what Hashem does. In the beginning, He helps a person a lot, but then He starts taking off the training wheels and starts giving the person a little bit more difficulty in order to strengthen them, in order for them to be able to overcome bigger obstacles.
1:15:59And that's, in essence, sometimes what happens with a person when they do teshuva. In the beginning, life goes grand, life goes great. They start making more money sometimes. They start doing all types of wonderful things in their Torah and their mitzvot. Everything goes well. But then that wonderful time stops. and all of it seems like things have changed, and it looks like they go into a period of difficulty. That difficulty is not because Hashem is going away from you, but rather Hashem is even closer to you. He's closer to you, but He wants you to overcome difficulties. How do I know He's closer to you? It's just like when a parent takes off The training wheels of the bicycle, when the little kid was riding the bicycle with the training wheels, the parent could let them go and not be worried. Why? Because there are four wheels on a two-wheel bicycle. So he's not worried that the kid is going to fall when you have training wheels. But as soon as he takes off the training wheels, especially if he takes off both training wheels off the bike, what does the parent do? Is the parent still sitting down? Absolutely not. The parent is standing right next to the little kid.
1:17:07Why? He wants to make sure that if you fall, He will be there for you. He will be there to give you confidence. That's the essence of Hashem. So Hashem is going to put difficulties in your life at times, but that doesn't mean that He is away from you. In fact, He is closer to you, but He wants you to overcome this difficulty in order for you to reach an even higher level than you would have if you had stayed on training wheels. So overcome the difficulty and b'ezrat Hashem, you will succeed and attain even higher levels than you were before these challenges arose. Charlie, can you explain the difference between Mashiach ben David and Mashiach ben Yosef? It's a very extensive issue that requires an entire shiur, but in so many words I can tell you that Mashiach ben David is the final Mashiach. Mashiach ben Yosef comes before him. Mashiach ben Yosef is the one that's going to start the war of Gog u'Magog, and some say that it is... Possible for Mashiach ben Yosef to die during that war, but it's not certain. Meaning, he can die, but there are some tzaddikim in the world who pray every single day for Mashiach ben Yosef not to die. If he dies, then he will be resurrected with the dead later on. Nonetheless, he is going to be the beginning of the war, but that's going to be during Gog u'Magog and...
1:18:26Whereas Mashiach ben David, he's going to be the final Mashiach that is going to be the king. He's not going to fight with swords or anything. He's going to fight with words. He says one word and an entire country could be destroyed with his words. So Mashiach ben Yosef may die. Mashiach ben Yosef is the Nitzotz (spark). He's the... spark of his neshama comes from both Moshe Rabbeinu and David HaMelech, and he is going to be the king Mashiach that Hashem is going to make the king of the Jewish people and bring the salvation, and so on. But as far as more details, that requires a whole extensive shiur with sources and so on and so forth. Ethan, if a convert had children before converting and she has another male baby after conversion, would this count as her firstborn child? If so, do the parents have to do Pidyon HaBen?
1:19:33So, as far as the convert who has children before converting, that means those children have to convert if they are below the age of Bar Mitzvah and Bat Mitzvah, which means 13 for a boy and 12 for a girl, meaning the children that she already has are younger than that. then they just dip in the mikveh together with their parents who are converting. But if they're older than that, then they have to convert in essence on their own, dip in a mikveh by themselves, and answer the questions themselves. If they convert before the age of bar mitzvah and bat mitzvah, then they have to come back to the Beit Din when they are older, 12 and 13 like I said, and confirm that they want to remain Jewish. means that during all that time, let's say from birth until the age of bar mitzvah or bat mitzvah, they are Jewish but with a way out, in so many ways, with a back door. If they get the proper education, then surely they're going to want to be Jewish and say the right thing when they go face the Beit Din. But if they...
1:20:44don't get the right education, most likely they're not going to want to be Jewish, and therefore, it is better off if they wouldn't convert altogether. But that means that those kids are converts, and they're spiritually not considered the kids of the parents because they converted. Nonetheless... the mitzvah of pru urvu, some do consider it, some poskim do say that they have not fulfilled the pru urvu, and some poskim say that they did fulfill the pru urvu. Meaning there's a machloket on this issue, where some say that if they do have a... do have kids before converting, a boy and a girl technically did not obligate them to have any more kids. But, obviously, it's better to have more kids. Nonetheless, if they already had kids before conversion, a boy and a girl at least... Some say they have already fulfilled that mitzvah. But as far as doing the Pidyon HaBen, if they already have kids, I don't believe that they have to do Pidyon HaBen. But I'm sure you can find the opposite opinion somewhere. This would have to be reviewed further, I would say. But as far as the... What was the second? Oh, the second question is not related. If a Jew makes a product and a goy buys that product... Okay, let's say... I think it's a completely different question. Yeah.
1:22:07A Jew buys a product and a goy buys a product, buys that product from the Jew, although the Jew knows the goy will use it for avodah zarah, and the Jew sells this product to the goy. Ah, okay. So if a Jewish person makes, let's say, a cross... Knowing that the goy will buy this product, it's a cross. There are idolaters who, at the very least, believe in idolatry. And he makes crosses, and he wants to sell them. Can he do it? Halachically, there's no prohibition against making this cross, but it will bring a lot of problems to your life to sell things that you know will be used for idolatry. If you know for sure that it will be used for idolatry, then you're not allowed to sell it. But if it's only a possibility, you're allowed to sell it, but you should not. So, for example, a cross is not something that's always idolized. In fact, most of the time it's not idolized, but it's still not recommended to sell it. Still not recommended to sell it. Whereas a statue is always forbidden to sell. It's always forbidden to sell because in its existence altogether it's forbidden in the world.
1:23:25Rambam, Hilchot Melachim, Chapter 8:10, a Noahide must declare his acceptance of the Noahide laws in the presence of three trustworthy Jewish scholars. this a requirement, uh, if not declared does this mean that a person, no, a Noahide is by default a non-Jewish, by default a Noahide? What, uh, what the Rambam is referring to over there is people that are living in Eretz Yisrael at the time of the Beit HaMikdash, and they're going to be a Ger Tzedek. which has a few differences from a traditional Noahide. No, anyone who's not Jewish is, by default, a Noahide. Whether they're a righteous Noahide or not a righteous Noahide is determined based on whether they adhere to the Torah and the laws of the Noahides, which are according to the Torah. can you? Yes. Should you? No. Why? Because there are different customs, and it's better for a person to stick to his customs. Just like if a person goes and prays
1:24:43and a Sephardi person goes and prays in an Ashkenazi shul, he should only pray with a Sephardi Siddur. Even though he's praying with a bunch of Ashkenazim who are praying a much shorter prayer at times and faster, he still has to pray from a Sephardi Siddur. uh, why? Because that's your custom, that's your forefathers', that's what you have to stick to. Also, there are opinions that are relatively strong by some that are, you know, against the other customs, meaning that there is an opinion that thinks that both sides are wrong in so many words, meaning the Sephardi thinks the Ashkenazi is wrong, and the Ashkenazi thinks the Sephardi is wrong. Of course, they both have respect for each other, but they both, you know, say that their own people have to, their own communities have to follow their own ways. That's also the reason why Sephardim people that are Sephardi are not allowed to listen to even the tzaddikim among the Ashkenazi world that permit wigs. Even if, let's say, you found some kosher wig in the world, you're not allowed to wear that wig due to some Ashkenazi posek, even if he's the gadol hador. Why? He's the gadol hador for the Ashkenazim, not for you.
1:25:56You are a Sephardi. You follow based on the Beit Yosef, Rabbi Yosef Karo, and Rabbi Ovadia. That's who you listen to. Or Rambam. Bottom line is, all Sephardim, that's who you listen to. You can't listen to the Lubavitcher Rebbe. You can't listen to Rabbi Moshe Feinstein. Even though they are Gedolim, Kedoshim, Kodesh Kodeshim, and their students are praiseworthy, and their real students, their real followers... i i i could listen to them with uh eyes closed, no problem. But you, as a Sephardi, can't listen to them. Why? They're not your poskim. Same thing on the opposite end if you're Ashkenazi. You can't listen to the p'sak of Rav Ovadia and eat kitniyot on Pesach. You start eating rice. No, you can't. Why? You're Ashkenazi. You have to follow your p'sakim. You have to follow the Rema. You have to follow the Chofetz Chaim. You have to follow your Rav Moshe Feinstein, your Rav Elyashiv, your tzaddikim. You don't go away from them. That's your tzaddikim. You stick to them. You don't go somewhere else. Now, if somebody wants to change...
1:27:00Let's say someone born Sephardi wants to become Ashkenazi. Some say that you're allowed to change once in your life. If you're really serious, you can change once in your life. Yes, you can. But to go back and forth, you're not allowed. Going back and forth, you're not allowed. So, but either way, a person should stick to their traditions. And if they choose to change it, change it once and that's it. David Coleman is publicizing an article that was written about me by the heretic Nosson Slifkin. Thank you very much, David, for publicizing something that's against the Torah. I hope that HaKadosh Baruch Hu will reward you for it, for publicizing something that embarrasses me, that goes against me, and desecrates Hashem's name. He rewards you for doing such a service. Uh, yeah, people are amazing. Can you rebuke and teach Torah to Jews? Ah, very, very good question. The Midrash says, if you tell me that the goyim, the gentiles, have wisdom—they know mathematics, they know architecture, they know science—I believe you.
1:28:24I believe you. There are many, many smart people among the non-Jewish people. In fact, Aristotle was a genius that even the Rambam admired. The people of his day looked up to Aristotle and his wisdom. They literally stopped and didn't believe he came from a woman. He was a genius that was really incomprehensible to people. Anyone that thinks that Einstein is a genius, Einstein was like dust, dust that Aristotle stepped on one time. That's how much of a genius Aristotle was. And many of the non-Jews, like Sir Isaac Newton, are also geniuses. There are lots of geniuses in the non-Jewish world. So if you tell me the Gemara or the Midrash says something, you should know that there is a lot of wisdom in our tradition as well. stepped on one time. That's it. That's how much of a genius Aristotle was. And many of the non-Jews, like Sir Isaac Newton and others, are also geniuses. There are lots of geniuses in the non-Jewish world. So if you tell me the Gemara or the Midrash says something, you should know... that there is wisdom among the non-Jews, 100%. I believe you. Why? I know for a fact that there are smart non-Jews. There are smart non-Jews, but if you tell me that there is wisdom of Torah in the goyim, not possible. Not possible. What do you mean, not possible? The guy knows the entire Tanakh by heart. So what?
1:29:46That does not give him Torah knowledge. He knows text by heart. I know some people that know an entire phone book by heart. Does that mean that they are experts in phone technology? No. They know numbers. They know text. Torah is not just knowing text and remembering it by heart. Torah is something that has to do with the moral application of a person. Torah has to do with how a person behaves himself. Torah is something about how a person looks at the world. Torah is not just knowing text. Someone who knows text by heart, someone who knows Hebrew, doesn't mean he knows Torah. It doesn't mean he knows Torah. Torah is something that affects the neshamah. It changes the neshamah itself. That's what Torah does. And a non-Jew does not have the right equipment, the right neshamah to be able to absorb the entire Torah like a Jew. Not possible. Why? Torah was a gift to Am Yisrael. And therefore, even if you find me
1:31:06a very nice non-Jew that knows Hebrew, that knows the text, that loves the Torah, still can't learn Torah from him as a Jew. If you're a non-Jew, you're allowed to and you should learn Torah from him. But if you're a Jew, you can't learn Torah from him. Why? Because his equipment is not meant for you. His equipment is meant for him. And I know that there are some people that are dear to me, close to me, and I can even tell you I care a lot about them, who may be offended by this, but it's 100% emet. Why? Torah is not just knowledge of text. Torah is neshama. The neshama in a person, the neshama in a Jew, and the neshama, the soul, in a non-Jew are two different things. Two different things. So much so, I can tell you from experience with dealing with converts.
1:32:06My converts, I was gifted with many amazing converts. My converts tell me themselves, when I learned Torah before I converted versus the Torah that I learned after I converted, I feel like it's two different people. I feel like it's like a reincarnation, but I was alive. I remember it was three, four years ago, but I feel like it was a reincarnation. Like I'm a different person, but it's the same one. I said, yeah, exactly. It's the same person, but it's a different one. Why? Different neshama. The Torah that you learn, even if it's the same verse, And it's the same book. And it's the same time of the year. You learn it as a non-Jew versus learning it as a Jew. It is worlds apart. Worlds, worlds, worlds apart. Worlds apart. It's like looking at the Torah with dark glasses that you can barely see what's in front of you versus looking at the Torah with no glasses at all. Straight eyes. 20/20 vision. different worlds, two different worlds. About time, today, it's the same thing. Don't feel bad if you're a non-Jew and say, "Oh, that's not fair." It's also the same thing for a Jew that's married versus a Jew that's not married. The Gemara says the Torah that you learn before you get married is as if you didn't learn Torah in comparison.
1:33:25to the Torah that you're going to learn after you're married. How could that be? Before I got married, I had all day and all night to learn Torah. I was in the yeshiva. I was with the bachurim. I was with the rabbi. I was doing all the things. After I got married, I barely have two hours for myself. How could it be that the Torah after I got married is much more? That's how it works. Why? When you learn Torah by yourself, little bubbeleh, it was just a half a neshama. Once you got married, you now have a complete neshama. Your equipment changed. Your equipment can now absorb a lot more. The Torah that you learned a day before you got married is as if you didn't learn anything in comparison to the Torah that you're learning now that you're married. And even if you're a Jew, especially if you're a Jew. Why? That's what it is. That's what it is. There are different levels, Abutai. There are different levels. And I know this offends people sometimes. And everyone wants to be fair. And everyone wants to be equal. And women want to learn the same thing as men. And men want to learn the same thing as them. It doesn't work that way. There is no equality.
1:34:33Equality is for the heretics. Women are in one place, men are in one place, Jews are in one place, non-Jews are in another place, the righteous are in one place, and the wicked are in another place. That's the way the world works. You don't like it? Pick a different world. That's the way it works. All the people that are voting for equality, 100% heresy. 100%. Now, does that mean that the things that are unequal won't offend you? Sure, they'll offend you, but who cares? It only offends you because you're not in line with the Torah. Once you understand what the Torah is, there's nothing to be offended about. This is just simply what it is. When you call a horse a horse, does he get offended? Hey, what do you call me a horse for? You're a horse. But you are a horse. Oh, okay, fine. If somebody makes fun of you because you're Jewish, why are you getting offended? You're a Jew. If somebody makes fun of you because you're black, why are you getting offended? You're black. Is something wrong with you? People do not understand how to accept their own reality. Why? Because they're looking on the other side. They want to be somebody else.
1:35:41The guy wants to be a girl, the girl wants to be a guy, the Jew wants to be a non-Jew, the non-Jew wants to be a Jew, everybody wants to be somebody else. If everybody simply accepted their own role in the world, Moshiach would come. But that's why, Rabotai, a Jew is not allowed to learn Torah from a non-Jew. A non-Jew is allowed to learn Torah from a non-Jew, as long as he follows the Torah. And also learn from a Jew. A non-Jew is allowed to learn from a non-Jew, and he's also allowed to learn from a Jew. But a Jew is not allowed to learn from a non-Jew. Why? Simply, he does not have the right equipment to teach you. If you say, no, no, no, but I like what he says. I like what he says too. Doesn't mean you have to learn from him. I have students, dear, amazing tzaddikim. Can't wait for them to finish their conversion. Once they finish their conversion, I'm going to learn from them. But they haven't finished their conversion. They haven't finished their conversion. Until then, I can't learn from them. I can hear it. I can listen to it. I can't learn from them. Two different things. Hearing something, learning from something, two different things. Two different things. Did he say the truth? 100%. Did she say the truth? 100%. 100%. But, can you learn from them? No. Why? You're a Jew. They're not Jewish. Simple. Doesn't work. Doesn't work. Rabotai, that's what Chazal says.
1:37:00they're not concerned about the political correctness of 2021. And those that care about it are going in the wrong direction. Next, similarly observed that a person can go through his entire life without ever experiencing genuine Bitachon, merely speaking about it without internalizing it. disbelief. How do we properly internalize B'tachon? I have an entire series called the B'tachon Be'Hashem. I highly recommend everybody watch it at least once, twice, or a thousand times. simply because it takes the Beit HaLevi that you're mentioning, and it breaks it down into a simple format and also into an applicable format, answering your question extensively. But in a short, short way to answer your question, B'tachon, as we're actually also learning from, we already learned from the Chazon Ish series,
1:38:08about Jewish Hashkafah, there was a section about Bitachon. Bitachon is not having confidence in Hashem that everything will be okay. That's not Bitachon. That's not Bitachon. That's fantasy. ...is that everything that is happening already is the best possibility out of all of the possibilities that are available to you. Meaning, let's say, for example, I want to go from Florida to California. Okay, no, forget California. I want to go to Israel. If I'm going to dream, we're going to dream big, okay? I want to go from Florida to Israel. Okay, now... In reality, there are only one or two airlines that make that trip. But let's say, let's make believe that there are multiple airlines, multiple ship routes, and multiple ways to go there. So, I can go there using different planes, different... uh, boats, different types of vehicles, and so on and so forth, right? Meaning there are many ways for me to get from point A, being Florida where I am today, to Jerusalem to go learn Torah with my Rav. I'll find him in his study over there and never leave, right? That's where I can be, right? But I have many ways of getting there. Now, who
1:39:34has certain laws in the world where he says, you can take a lot of different ways, but there is a best way. There is a best way. Now you can go, the fastest way is to use a rocket, but most likely you won't survive. You'll get burned by the fire of the rocket. The slowest way is to swim there. Most likely, it’s not going to work out for you either. Okay? So the fastest, slowest, not necessarily—don't base your decision on fast or slow. There's the best way, the most efficient way. The safest way, for all intents and purposes, is a plane. Statistically speaking, the safest way is the plane. Now, it seems like it's not the safest way because you hear about crashes once in a while and so on, but if you understood how many planes fly in the air every single day, you know that actually a plane is safer than a car. So that's the best way of getting there, right? HaKadosh Baruch Hu has an infinite amount of ways of taking Yaakov from point A of where he is today to point B of where Hashem wants him to be.
1:40:42Hashem wants him to be. Lots of different ways. Now, why does Hashem want him to be at point B? Because the actions that Yaakov did bring him to that point. Bring him to that point. He did mitzvah number 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, skipped number 8 and 9, did number 10, skipped 13 and 14, 16 and 17, and so forth. He got a certain result, which, that result is, you're going to get to this destination. So, to get Yaakov from point A to point B, that is based on his actions, Hashem has an infinite amount of ways of getting him there. Infinite amount of ways. Not just the cars and the boats, but many, many other creative ways that HaKadosh Baruch Hu has. Bitachon is that the way that Hashem picks is always the best one. There are other ways that are faster, that seem more profitable, that are more exciting, that are safer. Everything appears; there's a lot of different things, but those are not available to you either because of the actions that a person made or because they're not the best.
1:42:02And the bitachon is having 100% knowledge, not belief, knowledge that whatever way Hashem took you from point A to point B is the best possible way available to you. There is no other better way. That is bitachon in a nutshell. Let's see... um, right, this video says he cites Al-Khan non-Jews by makom. I have no idea what you're talking about. Um, I guess you're mentioning a person that's either blocked or I can't see their information. Um, Mike, okay, I was wondering when exactly teshuvah occurs
1:43:13is it when a person firmly decides to never again commit a certain sin, or is it when a person speaks out loud, or must the opportunity to sin present itself Again for personal okay, so the Rambam writes that teshuvah is four different steps, four different steps. The decision to make teshuvah is the first step. The first step is to make the decision to stop the sin. That's the first step. So teshuvah begins with the first step. You can't go to the third or fourth step or even the second step without the first step. So the first thing is to stop sinning. The second thing is to make a fence, meaning to make sure that you are... doing something in order to distance yourself on a permanent basis from returning to that sin, which involves educating yourself about the sin so you're afraid to sin, so you're not interested in sinning, so you're even disgusted by sinning. For example, not going to certain places because that's where the sin took place, or by doing certain things. You have to put a fence, so to speak, in place.
1:44:18in your life in order to remove you further from the sin. After you've removed yourself from the sin for an extended period of time, you will start becoming more knowledgeable and more understanding of the damage the sin actually made. The initial damage that the sin made, a person does not really fully comprehend does not really fully comprehend how much damage his drinking caused the second he stops drinking, nor how much damage his infidelity caused as soon as he stops seeing that girlfriend that he had. He doesn't really understand the damage until later on. once he's removed himself from the sin and he started sticking to good things, once he stopped sinning for a while, he'll start being more remorseful about the sin and more apologetic to Hashem. That's when he has to say "I'm sorry" to Hashem even more so about sinning, because now he understands the magnitude of the sin. Just to say "I'm sorry" on day one. In reality, it's good and you need to do it, but it's not really 100% genuine. Why? Because if you violated Shabbat last week, and then on Monday, you decide, you know what? I'm not going to violate Shabbat anymore. In reality, you may decide to start keeping Shabbat because you think Shabbat is good. You think that violating Shabbat may be not good, but you don't really understand why.
1:45:39You don't really understand why. Really, you think it's okay, but it's better not to violate Shabbat. That's the way the human mentality is. Initially, when we stop doing something, we're not stopping doing it because we think it's bad, but rather because we think there's something better. It's better not to do it, or there's something better that you can do. So that's why remorse comes as step number three. After a person has stopped sinning for an extended period of time, distanced himself from the sin for an extended period of time, and was remorseful, Hashem will give that person a test. a test with the, in so many words, let's say if it's with the same woman in the same place. Meaning, he's going to get a test that Hashem is going to send him with similar features, if you will. And that's when he has to pass that test. Once he passes that test, then Hashem stamps his file—he is or she is a baal teshuva. But until they get to that fourth step, it's an incomplete teshuva.
1:46:43It's a partial teshuva only during the first three steps. It's an incomplete teshuva. It's only a complete teshuva after the person has passed the test that he failed in the past. And once he passes, he starts again. Even if he fails again, chas v'shalom, in the future, it's not going back to step number one. He's starting all over. It's as if it's a brand new sin. It's a brand new sin and he has to do a brand new teshuva. One is asking, what's the punishment for a person who finds good in wicked people? A person that sees good in wicked people, the "ish lefi mahala" Shlomo HaMelech says that a person is as he praises. And Rabbeinu Yonah in Sha'arei Teshuva says that a person is who he praises, meaning that if you praise wicked people, that means that you are wicked. So the punishment for a wicked person is very, very severe, and... One is asking, what's the punishment for a person who finds good in wicked people? A person that sees good in wicked people, the "ish lefi mahala" Shlomo HaMelech says that a person is as he praises. And Rabbeinu Yonah in Sha'arei Teshuva says that a person is who he praises, meaning that if you praise wicked people, that means that you are wicked. So the punishment for a wicked person is very, very severe and...
1:47:50very severe. There's no way that the person is going to praise wicked people and not be wicked themselves. Now, do some wicked people have good traits in them? Yes, they could do good things, but we're not supposed to be praising them for even the good that they do, because if someone is wicked, you have to always speculate that even the good that they do is for a bad reason. So for example, if you saw Hitler, yimach shemo, come in the streets and start giving free food, you have to suspect him of having poison in that food. Why? Because he's a bad person. And therefore, everything that looks good indeed has something of an agenda. And that's why anyone that studies some of the things that I've talked about in the past, for example, the Nazi camps, the Holocaust camps, if you looked at the Jewish side, you would have seen a massive amount of death and destruction. But if you looked at the Nazi side where the Nazis were sleeping, where the Nazis were camped and so on, it looked like a traditional camp where they had singing, dancing, and music.
1:49:00uh, orchestra and uh, pictures, and you look at their pictures, and it looks like everybody's on vacation and it looks so happy and, and, and having fun, uh, so, uh, you say, well, if you listen to their music, you look at their pictures, it looks like nice people, but if you found out what happened as soon as the picture stopped when they went to the Jewish side and started massacring millions of people, then you say, oh, obviously, these people are sociopaths. So it's the same concept: a bad person does bad things. Admiring that bad person makes a person bad because that means that you admire the bad. Or even if you want to admire the good, that means that you don't understand the Torah, which tells us that even the good that the bad people do... is for a bad reason. He's only giving tzedakah for the sake of his own honor, for the sake of his own business, and so on. He's only, uh, you know, being generous because it may mean more business for him. In so many words, it's an investment, not a donation. So that's the way a person needs to understand.
1:50:01Whether you answered for the teacher, but where are the sources showing this? Yeah, I mean a lot of people like to answer, you know, because everybody likes to hear themselves talk. I'm just not really sure why people come listen to a shiur to socialize. I mean, it's better not to come, but for whatever reason or another, people love to come to my channel and debate. Like, why don't you debate somewhere else? Why do you have to debate on my channel? Oh, interesting, interesting? Ah, let's see. uh, Yaakov is asking: David says in Tehillim 37:25, "I have been young and I have been old, but I have not seen a righteous man forsaken and his children begging for bread." Rabbi Akiva asked, "Has there never been a righteous man who was poverty-stricken and his children never asked his neighbors for bread?" His response was that it was because they never felt... forsaken or disheartened. So the question is, why would Hashem allow a righteous person to go through poverty? Okay, so this question is asked by Moshe Rabbeinu as well. Why does the righteous person suffer and sometimes the wicked person prosper?
1:51:12So, the wicked person prospering, we have an answer from a pasuk in the Torah, where, in the second-to-last pasuk, it says that Hashem pays cash to His haters to their face. Hashem will reward the wicked people, cash to their face, giving them reward so that a person can get a lot of riches for the few mitzvot that he did, because Hashem wants to destroy that person and actually not have them in the next life. And as a matter of fact, they recently learned that the Arizal says that sometimes Hashem will actually reincarnate a wicked person, reincarnate a wicked person to bring them back to this world for them to get a reward in this world. to have money, to have success, to have everything, just so He could pay them everything here, and then take them to Gehinnom, know them permanently, and destroy them. So, it's, God is the God of vengeance, the God of vengeance has arrived.
1:52:16It is also so, paying the wicked is easy to understand. Paying the difficulty for the righteous is more difficult to understand. The Gemara gives seven different reasons why Hashem can make it difficult for the righteous. Sometimes it's to test them, sometimes it's to build them, sometimes it's in order for them to get rid of certain sins. Sometimes it's actually to help the generation itself of wicked people due to the righteous person. But there is one reason, which is Hashem's reason. What are those reasons? None of our business. That's what He told Moshe Rabbeinu. Moshe Rabbeinu asked Him this question, and he kept pushing, pushing, pushing. Hashem says, I'll do whatever I want. Why does the righteous suffer? Hashem responded to Moshe Rabbeinu, I'll do whatever I want. I'll do whatever I want. So, there are seven different reasons that the Chachamim came up with, and I think there's somewhere else even more. But the bottom line is, HaKadosh Baruch Hu says, "I'll do whatever I want."
1:53:20so we can rationalize it, we can listen to the sages we have that explain to us different reasons. But in reality, we are working like blind people looking for the small details in a building. It's meaning that And in the Sefer Maggid Meisharim, Rabbi Yosef Karo, the Gadol HaDorot, the giant of all giants as far as halacha, that's where we go. Rabbi Yosef Karo, all of Am Yisrael, goes to Rabbi Yosef Karo, Ba'al Shulchan Aruch. But Rabbi Yosef Karo, who was not a Kabbalist or anything like that, or at least wasn't known as one, he has a sefer called Maggid Meisharim, which is, in essence, a journal of his conversations with the angel that was learning Torah with him. He was learning Torah with an angel. And in that angel in that book tells him, "If you knew, if you knew all the things I could tell..." I'm sorry, that angel told him, "When you come back, I'm going to teach you. I'm going to teach you the secret for reincarnations," which is what the Arizal wrote extensively about, which he got from his rebbe, Rabbi Yitzchak Luria.
1:54:36uh, the Maggid Meisharim writes, he says, if you knew, if you knew all the secrets of the reincarnations, you would be baffled to no end, where you would see wonders of wonders in the creation around you. Well, I'm going to teach you the secret of how to do it, and so on, and uh, where you'd see... This guy just had a kid. He doesn't realize that kid used to be his father in the previous generation. Or used to be his mortal enemy. And now he's his kid. And he has to pay him back. And he has to do this. If you knew all the different things... That guy just married a wife. That wife used to be his sister. And he did this. And so all types of things that if you knew gilgulim, he tells them, you'd be... amazed at how precise the Creator is, how precise the Creator is when it comes to measure for measure, of why certain things happen, of who, what, when, how. So, in reality, any explanation that we give
1:55:46as far as this guy is poor because he made a sin, or this guy is poor because he's a tzaddik. In reality, that's only a small little facet of the endless diamond that Hashem has in His creation. Why? Because we're limited with knowledge, we're limited to a single dimension. Hashem has no end to His dimensions. So, when a person understands that the dollar that arrived in his pocket used to be a dollar that he actually had in a previous incarnation, or it's money that was owed to him from something, or the guy that he just gave a job to is someone that was deeply connected to him in a previous life... The point is that there's no end to the details of the creation, and that's why Hashem says, "I'll do whatever I want." Not in an arrogant way, but rather because there is no way that you can comprehend My world.
1:56:49And therefore, I have to do whatever I want because I'm the only one that can run it. I'm the only one that can run it, and it's not simply possible for you to understand how I'm running it and why I'm running it that way because you're simply a lowly little schnitzel, a little pita. That's what we are. We're all little schnitzels, little chicken sandwiches. That's what we are. We're nothing. So that's what a person has to understand. We're limited with knowledge. A kind of Jewish woman who is married but no longer lives with her husband, going through a divorce, plays games and talks to another guy online just for fun. She doesn't plan on making a relationship because she knows he is not Jewish, but she plays with him for fun. First and foremost, even if she was single and not even divorced, single, never married, she's not allowed to socialize with a non-Jewish man. uh, even if she was single, needless to say if she is still considered married according to halacha, she's not allowed to socialize whatsoever with a Jewish or a non-Jewish man. Why? Because she is a forbidden woman to both of them, so she's absolutely not allowed to socialize in that way with any man whatsoever.
1:58:08No, not Jewish or non-Jewish. It's even worse with a non-Jew, but nonetheless, it's a very, very big problem. She should stop doing it immediately with no questions asked and no explanation needed. Just change the phone number, delete, and block. uh, that's my recommendation because once you go into the explanation mode, people start getting emotional, people start getting, you know, antsy and annoying, and so on, and it just never ends. It's better to just disconnect, change the phone number, change the profile name, change everything as if you don't exist anymore, and start a new life because your old life is very, very problematic. uh, we're almost done. You know, let's see, Yaakov, okay, we'll take the last question. Okay, I know that wasting seed is forbidden, but is it one of the 613 biblical commandments, or is it a rabbinical prohibition? If it's a biblical commandment, where is it learned from the Chumash itself? If it's rabbinical...
1:59:14That's fine; I am not, uh, trying to find leniencies. It's 100% a biblical prohibition to, uh, waste seed, so much so that, uh, the Ramban paskens that it's the biggest sin in the Torah. The Zohar HaKadosh says that this sin of wasting seed is a sin that almost has no teshuva because of the amount of demons that it creates. It's not a rabbinical prohibition. It's 100% a biblical prohibition. To learn the details, watch my lectures about wasting seed. The Tikkun HaBrit movie has over 100 sources listed one after another. You could look them up one after another. ...and that way you could be an expert in the field. I have to go now, guys, because there's actually another lecture that I have to do in Hebrew for the Hebrew crowd in a couple of hours. I have to regain a little bit of energy... But b'ezrat Hashem, we will continue to learn more in the future. Thank you again for the wonderful questions that you asked me today and for learning with me. And b'ezrat Hashem, each and every single one of you will learn and apply everything that we've learned today to your lives, bringing blessings to your life, to your families, to Am Yisrael, to the righteous Noahides of the world, and bring nachat to HaKadosh Baruch Hu, bringing the pleasantness to HaKadosh Baruch Hu that He wants when He sees...
2:00:39His creation doing what's good for them. Just like when a father or a mother sees their child doing good for themselves, it's not that they benefit from the good that the child is doing for themselves. The child is benefiting. But the parent is happy and gets comfort from the child doing what's good for them. And that's, in essence, what it means that when Hashem gets nachat, He gets comfort from us doing good. It's not that He changes, it's not that He... uh, improves the status but rather he's, he's, uh, in essence, uh, gets comfort to see that we are doing what He said and thereby benefiting, uh, from, uh, from what He created for us. Each and every one of us will bring nachat to Hashem and learn His Torah, publicize it, and do all the good that He wants us to do for our own benefit. B'ezrat Hashem, we will succeed. Kol tuv to everyone.
2:01:55Seven years of lectures. Seven months of film editing. Countless hours of study by two rabbis. Information we received over 3,000 years ago. all for this moment. Takumi had agreed. The movie If you satiate it, you're never going to have enough. The sulfur plant, when it gets a hold of something, does not let go. Time for us to rectify what we have done. Normal numbers should be somewhere around 20 million or higher.
2:03:25You're never going to have control over it if you start it. You only feed it when it's permissible according to the Torah. Pornography is as addictive as crack cocaine. Baruch Adonai le'olam, amen ve'amen.
2:04:36Baruch Adonai le'olam, amen ve'amen.