BeEzrat HaShem

This Gentile is like a Kohen Gadol

6 months ago

Can a non-Jew reach the same spiritual standing as the Kohen Gadol? In this powerful lesson, Rabbi Yaron Reuven dives into the complex Halachic boundaries of Torah study and religious observance for Gentiles. The Jewish Sages in Sanhedrin 59a, bring what seems to be two conflicting statements: Rabbi Yochanan says, an non-Jew that learns Torah is liable to death penalty, but Rabbi Meir says, he deserves respect like a Kohen Gadol. So, who's right? Full Shiur: Era of MaShiach 28 - https://youtu.be/GYSbk1WTLKI In this video, we discuss: The "Inheritance" of Torah: Why certain parts of the Torah are considered a private heritage for the Jewish people. The Path of the Noahide: Which areas of study—such as Tanakh and Mussar—are not only permitted but essential for a righteous life. The Danger of the "Overly Righteous": Why religious innovation and "stealing" Jewish practices (like the Sabbath) can lead to spiritual ruin. Rambam's Ruling: Analyzing the Mishneh Torah (Hilchot Melachim Chapter 10) to understand the practical law for non-Jews today. Whether you are a member of the Jewish community or a gentile following the Seven Noahide Laws, this video provides essential clarity on how to connect with the Creator authentically—without overstepping the boundaries set by the Sages. Want to support our KIRUV work? Please partner with us to help Am Yisrael keep Shabbat and more! https://www.beezrathashem.org/donate Rabbi Yaron Reuven's short Torah Clips channel – Please Share The Video To Help Others Do TeShuva. AI RABBI by BeEzrat HaShem Inc. https://www.AIRabbi.org Answers To Jewish Torah Life Questions In 30 Languages. Discover Jewish Wisdom at Your Fingertips, Rabbi Reuven's AI Rabbi offers wisdom and guidance in multiple languages, drawing from trusted, reliable sources. #Torah #Jewish #RabbiYaronReuven #Noahide #SevenLaws #Spirituality #Rambam #Talmud #KohenGadol 00:00 Introduction 00:56 Two extremes in Sanhedrin 59a 03:59 What Torah is permitted for a Noahide? 08:36 Torah learning In the Process of Conversion 00:00:00 Intoduction 00:00:04 Bnei Noach & Torah Study Prohibition 00:01:27 The Apparent Contradiction: 'Kohen Gadol' Status 00:03:39 Reconciling Conflicting Views on Study 00:04:55 Rambam's Halacha: Forbidden Study & Consequences 00:06:10 The Forbidden Act of Innovation & Sabbath Observance for Bnei Noach 00:07:41 Defining Permissible Noachide Study 00:08:34 Torah Study for Converts-in-Process 00:09:24 The Dangers of Self-Deception & False Piety

Transcript

0:04We are currently delving into the intricate halakhic framework concerning the Bnei Noach, specifically examining their responsibilities and limitations within Jewish law. It is crucial to understand that while they have their own Divine commandments, there are also areas that are strictly prohibited for them, and unfortunately, some began doing things that they are forbidden to do. One of those things is engaging in limud Torah, which is strictly forbidden to them. What kind of Torah is that? Let us see, let us see... in Masechet Sanhedrin, page 59A, or perhaps 57A? Yes, Masechet Sanhedrin 59A, to be precise. The Gemara there explicitly brings down the words of Chazal, illustrating the profound implications for a non-Jew who attempts to delve into Torah subjects beyond the scope of their Seven Noahide Laws. My dear talmidim (students), we've been delving into the profound concept of Klal Yisrael's unique relationship with the Torah. We learned from the pasuk (verse) in Devarim (Deuteronomy) chapter 33, pasuk 4, that 'Moshe commanded us the Torah; it's an inheritance for the congregation of Yaakov.' This pasuk teaches us a fundamental principle: the Torah is an exclusive inheritance for us, the Jewish people, and not for the nations of the world. So, what does this imply? How far does this exclusivity go? This leads us to a fascinating and somewhat startling statement from our Sages. The Gemara in Sanhedrin tells us, "Rabbi Yochanan said, an idolater who engrosses himself in Torah study is liable to the death penalty. This means a heavenly death penalty, not one carried out by a human beit din (court). This applies even to a righteous Noahide." Now, you might be asking, "What does this mean for a righteous Noahide who genuinely seeks truth?" The Sages are teaching us a profound distinction. While a Noahide is encouraged to learn the seven Noahide laws and aspects of Torah relevant to their observance, the in-depth, all-encompassing study of Torah, the lishma (for its own sake) study that is the lifeblood of Klal Yisrael, is our unique inheritance. It's a privilege and a responsibility given specifically to us at Har Sinai (Mount Sinai). This doesn't diminish their spiritual path; rather, it highlights the distinct roles and covenants assigned to different peoples by HaKadosh Baruch Hu (the Holy One, Blessed be He).

1:00So, we're discussing a very severe transgression, one that, chas v'shalom, if someone violates, the halakha states that one is liable to the death penalty. What? Don't worry, we'll explain why this carries the death penalty. We learn from the verse in Devarim (Deuteronomy), chapter thirty-three, verse four: "Moshe commanded us the Torah, it's an inheritance," which implies for us it's an inheritance, and not for them—meaning, the goyim. This foundational teaching from the Torah defines our unique relationship with HaKadosh Baruch Hu and our unique responsibility. As we discussed earlier, the Gemara in Sanhedrin (daf Tzadi-Gimmel, amud Alef) brings a profound teaching. Menayim she'afilu oved kochavim she'osek b'Torah, she'hu k'Kohen Gadol? She'ne'emar 'asher ya'aseh otam ha'adam v'chai ba'hem' - from where do we learn that even a non-Jew who engages in Torah study is like a Kohen Gadol? Because the verse says, 'which ha'adam (the human) shall do, and live by them.' Not kohanim, not Levi'im, not Yisraelim, but ha'adam – 'the human.' This teaches us the incredible power and universal reach of Torah. Now, some might mistakenly think that this lofty status applies only to the very top echelon of learning. So, for example, on one end, we have a giant among giants, say, a talmid chacham who delves into Dinei Nefashot. All of a sudden, people might be thinking, 'No, no, this is the Torah's demand to shut off all other aspects of life!' Don't misunderstand! Don't diminish the Torah's light! Don't discount the life of Torah itself! Relax, I'll clarify. We are on the same page. I am not a ba'al ga'avah [one who is arrogant or dismissive of others]. Rather, the Torah's blessing is for everyone, at every level. Even the simplest study, performed with sincerity, elevates a person tremendously. It's about connecting to the Ribono shel Olam (Master of the World) through His sacred words, and that connection is open to all.

1:53My dear talmidim, we've just discussed the profound concept that even for a Goy, transgressions carry severe consequences, sometimes even a death penalty. This makes the next Gemara quite startling, and indeed, many ask, how can we reconcile it? The Gemara states: "Where do we know that even an idolater who engrosses himself in Torah study is worthy of respect like a Kohen Gadol?" You might be thinking, "Rabbi, just a moment ago you spoke of death penalties, and now you're telling me they're like a Kohen Gadol? What's going on here?" Don't worry, it's not a machloket; it's a common opinion among our Chazal. They aren't presenting contradictory views, but rather different facets of truth. There is a distinction, and understanding it is crucial. So, from where do our Sages derive this incredible concept? Me'ayin she'afilu oved Kochavim she'osek ba'Torah, hu k'Kohen Gadol? She'ne'emar: "asher ya'aseh otam ha'adam v'chai ba'hem." Lo ne'emar "Kohanim," "Levi'im," o "Yisraelim," elah "ha'adam." U'le'ma'aseh, she'afilu oved Kochavim she'osek ba'Torah, harei hu k'Kohen Gadol. This demonstrates the universal power and sanctity inherent in Torah study, even for those who are not commanded in its entirety. The pasuk intentionally uses the term "ha'adam" – "the man" – encompassing all of humanity, not just Kohanim, Levi'im, or Yisraelim. While the halachot and the complete scope of Torah apply differently to a Goy than to a Yisrael, the fundamental respect and spiritual elevation gained through engaging with Torat Hashem is profound. This isn't a contradiction, but rather a deeper insight into Ribbono shel Olam's wisdom and justice. Now, what then is the difference between this profound respect and the consequences we discussed earlier? Let's delve into that next.

2:20So, the Gemara states: "Where do we know that even an idolater who engrosses himself in Torah study is worthy of respect like a Kohen Gadol?" You might be thinking, "Rabbi, just a moment ago you spoke of death penalties, and now you're telling me I'm like a Kohen Gadol? What's going on here?" Don't worry, it's not a machloket; it's a common opinion among our Chazal. They aren't presenting contradictory views, but rather different facets of truth. There is a distinction, and understanding it is crucial. So, what is that difference? We are delving into a profound teaching from our Sages concerning the unique status of a non-Jew who dedicates himself to Torah study. The Gemara, in Masechet Sanhedrin, refers to this concept, and it says that a non-Jew who learns Torah, specifically an idolater who engrosses himself in Torah, is worthy of respect and considered like a Kohen Gadol. Where do we learn this principle? We learn it from the Torah itself, from the command regarding the Mitzvot: "asher ya'aseh otam ha'adam v'chai bahem" – "which a person shall do and live by them." This is found in Sefer Vayikra, Perek Yud-Ches, Pasuk Heh (Leviticus chapter 18, verse 5). This powerful assertion, that the Torah's commandments are for "a man" – meaning any man, regardless of his background – and that living by them brings such spiritual elevation, leads us to a significant philosophical and Halachic question. We must then ask ourselves: ...how do we reconcile this profound teaching with other Halachot? ...look, the pasuk doesn't say Kohanim live by them, or Leviim live by them, or Yisraelim live by them; rather, it says 'a man.' So, from there, we learn that even an idolater who engrosses himself in Torah is like a Kohen Gadol. So why did Rabbi Yochanan say that an idolater is prohibited from learning Torah? This seems like a direct contradiction, does it not?

3:39My dear friends, we're discussing a profound question today, touching upon the very essence of Torah study for all of humanity. We often hear about the special obligation of Bnei Yisrael to delve into the depths of Torah, but what about the Bnei Noach? What are they permitted, or forbidden, to learn? This leads us to a seemingly stark contrast in our holy texts. What happens, for instance, when a Ben Noach studies certain forbidden topics? The Gemara is clear: the answer is very simple. That refers to a Ben Noach who studies Torah which is forbidden to him—that is, he learns that which is not permitted to him. That is why he is chayav mitah, he deserves the death penalty. Whereas, the one who merits great honor—that is a person who learns that which is permitted to him. So, what is the fundamental difference? This, my friends, is the profound distinction. The Torah, in its infinite wisdom, delineates clearly what is appropriate for each individual, according to their covenant and spiritual station. It is not about limiting, but about guiding each soul on its path to Avodat Hashem. So we're discussing the scope of study for a Ben Noah. What exactly is a Noahide permitted, and in fact obligated, to delve into? We know that one of the core principles of the Noahide Laws is to know God, to understand His unity, and to refine one's character. Thus, if he is a Noahide, he is only allowed to learn the things that are relevant to a Noahide, which are the Tanakh and commentary about the Tanakh from the Midrashim, Rashi, things of that nature, and Musar. This is not a simple matter, as the Me'iri points out. People often mistakenly think the Seven Noahide Laws are just seven simple rules to follow. But no, as we've learned, one of those very rules is to know who God is, to grasp the unification of God, which intrinsically necessitates learning not only the Tanakh itself and its commentaries, but also intensive Musar study. This dedicated study is essential for character development, enabling one to truly become a better quality human being, in consonance with the Divine will.

4:25which is character development. Why is this so crucial? You need to know the Tanakh. You need to know what happened, and who God is. The Me'iri actually points out that people often mistakenly think the Seven Noahide Laws are very simple—just seven simple rules to follow. No! As we've learned, one of those very rules is to know who God is, which is to grasp the unification of God. This intrinsically requires you to learn not only the Tanakh itself and its commentaries, but also intensive Musar study, to develop your character and become a better quality human being in order to understand the unification of God, the elevation of God, and so on. The Gemara is clear, rabosai (gentlemen), that there are distinct pathways for Klal Yisrael (the Jewish people) and for the Bnei Noach (Children of Noah). Each has their unique spiritual service. When a goy (non-Jew) delves into areas of Torah that are specifically for us, it's considered a profound trespass, spiritually akin to 'stealing' a crown meant for another. Because his path, his spiritual obligation, is not... ...to understand the unification of God, the elevation of God, and so on. It's not, uh, one-two-three, "you're righteous." It doesn't work that way. So, when he learns such a thing as a tzaddik (righteous) Noachide, that's perfect, perfect. But when he starts to learn things that are not relevant to him, such as the laws of Shabbat, the laws of Shemittah, different areas, in general, the Oral Torah, the Gemara... ...these are areas of Torah Sheba'al Peh that are given specifically to Am Yisrael (the Jewish nation). A non-Jew's path to spiritual perfection lies in diligently observing the Sheva Mitzvot Bnei Noach (Seven Noahide Laws) and striving for Yiras Shamayim (fear of Heaven) within that framework. To deviate from that path, to learn what is not intended for him, is a profound misunderstanding of his unique spiritual service and the divine wisdom that ordains specific roles for all of humanity, baruch Hashem (blessed be God).

5:25So now, what is the actual halakha on this matter? We must turn to the venerable Rambam, may his memory be a blessing, in his Mishneh Torah, specifically in Hilkhot Melakhim U'Milhamoteihem, chapter eight, halakha ten. There, the Rambam explicitly rules that if a goy studies Torah beyond what is permitted for him—which is primarily the Seven Noahide Laws and their practical implications for righteous living—then he deserves the death penalty, chas ve'shalom, the death penalty! Why? Because it is considered as if he is stealing; yes, it is considered as if he is stealing! This isn't merely a minor transgression, rabosai, but a severe offense against the Divine decree itself, infringing upon the unique spiritual inheritance of Am Yisrael. And furthermore, when a gentile deviates from this prescribed path and attempts to delve deeper into our sacred Torah, there are profound and serious concerns that arise. Also, there's always a fear that he's learning this Torah because he is not adhering to what the Sages have said, which limits their study to only what is permitted to them. It is always a concern that he is learning this Torah for his own sake, perhaps to mock Jews, or to discourage or dissuade them, and so on and so forth. So now, what is the actual halakha? We must turn to the Rambam. His teachings will illuminate the definitive halakha on this critical matter. Indeed, the Rambam, in his monumental work, Mishneh Torah, clearly delineates this matter for us. In Perek Yud, halakha number nine, he states that a gentile who studies Torah is chayav mitah. Just as it says in the Gemara, Masechet Sanhedrin, page 59a. They are permitted to study only the Seven Mitzvot, the Seven Noahide Laws. That's what they are allowed to study. Similarly, a gentile who rests even on a weekday, observing that day as a Shabbat, is chayav mitah. This means it is a death penalty from Heaven (mitat Shamayim), not one carried out by a human Beit Din. A Jewish court would not execute such a person, but the point is that when...

6:40As we learn from the words of the Rambam, the great Maimonides, in Hilchot Melachim U'Milchamot, a gentile who decides to innovate a new religion or create a new festival for himself, such as declaring a different day of the week as his personal 'Sabbath' — for example, refraining from work on Wednesday — or even observing the true Shabbat in the manner of a Jew, is liable for a severe punishment. This is because the Mitzvot of Shabbat are specifically given to the Jewish people, and a gentile is forbidden to add to the seven Mitzvot Bnei Noach (Noahide Laws) or invent new observances. Therefore, the Rambam states clearly that observing that day as a Shabbat, he is liable for Mita Bidei Shamayim. This means it is a death penalty decreed by Heaven; it is not that a Jewish Beit Din (rabbinical court) will execute such a person. A human court does not administer this punishment. The point, however, is that when a gentile takes it upon himself to create such a 'festival' or imitate the uniquely Jewish observance of Shabbat, he is transgressing a profound spiritual boundary, incurring a grave Heavenly judgment. This teaches us the importance of adhering to the specific Mitzvot assigned to each segment of humanity by Hashem, and not deviating from Torah truth. We've been discussing the fundamental principles of Sheva Mitzvot Bnei Noach, the Seven Noahide Laws. One of the crucial aspects of these laws, as articulated by the Rambam in Hilchot Melachim, is the prohibition for a goy to create a new religion or to invent new mitzvot for himself. This extends even to practices that might seem righteous at first glance. For instance, when a goy decides to keep Shabbat exactly like the Yidden, it's a death penalty. It's not a mitzvah for him to do so. Or, let's say he thinks, 'You know what? I'm not going to keep the Saturday Shabbat. I'm going to do Wednesday instead. I'm going to refrain from work, refrain from driving, refrain from writing – that's going to be my Sabbath.' The Rambam says, that's also a death penalty! Why? He writes, 'Needless to say, he is obligated for that punishment if he creates a festival for himself.' You see the extreme gravity here! It's not just about doing something wrong; it's about fundamentally undermining the divine order and the unique covenant Hashem has with Klal Yisrael. The Rambam is teaching us that a goy must adhere to the Sheva Mitzvot Bnei Noach as they were given, not as he imagines them to be, and certainly not by creating new religious practices or observances for himself.

7:23Good evening, dear students. We delve tonight into a profound topic, the very parameters of divine service for the Bnei Noach—the righteous gentiles. As we've learned, the Sheva Mitzvot Bnei Noach are the divine imperative for all mankind. But beyond merely fulfilling these seven commandments, there's a vital principle that distinguishes the Avodat Hashem of a ben Noach from that of a Jew. It's not merely about what they do, but how they are permitted to do it. The Torah specifies their obligations, and they are not to deviate. So, if you create a new holiday, you create a new religion – the general principle governing these matters, as the Rambam clearly states, is that they are not allowed to originate a new religion or create mitzvot for themselves based on their own decisions. This is a crucial distinction. For a Jew, Chazal – our Sages – have the authority to establish mitzvot de'Rabbanan, new enactments and decrees, as a fence around the Torah and to beautify the mitzvot. But for a ben Noach, this is absolutely forbidden. Their path to Avodat Hashem is circumscribed strictly by what was given at Sinai for them, and no more. Any attempt to innovate, to add even a well-intentioned new practice or holiday, fundamentally misunderstands the nature of their covenant with HaKadosh Baruch Hu. My dear friends, we continue our discussion on the profound teachings of our Sages, and today, we turn to the revered Rambam, in his seminal work, Mishneh Torah, specifically in Hilkhot Melakhim, the Laws of Kings. The Rambam meticulously clarifies the standing of the Bnei Noach, the Children of Noah, in our world. He explains that they have a clear path before them: they may either become righteous proselytes, gerim tzedek, and accept all of the mitzvot of the Torah, or they may retain their status as Bnei Noach without adding to or detracting from the Seven Mitzvot Bnei Noach that pertain to them. The Rambam then issues a stern warning: if a gentile studies Torah for any purpose other than understanding his own Seven Mitzvot, or observes Shabbat, or innovates a new religious practice for himself, a Jewish court, a Beit Din, must administer lashes to him and inform him that he is liable for capital punishment from Heaven, though he is not to be executed by human hands. This is precisely the principle that the Rambam emphasizes elsewhere, as we discussed: that a Noachide who wishes to remain a Noachide must strictly adhere to learning only those matters that pertain to their unique obligations. To delve into Gemara or other halakhot designated specifically for Am Yisrael—that, my friends, is not only outside their purview but, as the Rambam teaches, is not considered a mitzvah for them at all.

8:04My dear friends, talmidim and listeners, welcome to our shiur tonight. We've been discussing the profound obligation and privilege of limud Torah, Torah study. And a crucial aspect of this, particularly relevant in our times, is understanding who is permitted to learn what. The Rambam, in his Mishneh Torah, clarifies this matter with great precision, especially concerning those who are not born Jewish and are perhaps exploring a path towards Yiddishkeit. So, to elaborate on this, let's delve into what the Rambam teaches us. See here, the Rambam gives us a little bit more details about halakha. He says exactly what it is. He says, 'Listen, if you're planning on being a Noachide and remain a Noachide, you have to only learn things that are pertaining to you. If you learn more than what's pertaining to you, such as the Gemara, or different halakhot that are not pertaining to you, my friend, you are not doing a mitzvah.' This is a fundamental principle, my friends. The Rambam is teaching us that Kedushas HaTorah, the sanctity of Torah, requires that one approaches its study according to their current spiritual standing. For a Noachide, the focus must remain squarely on the Seven Mitzvos Bnei Noach and their details. Any deviation from this, learning material beyond their direct obligation, is not considered a mitzvah for them. This same principle extends to those who are in the process of conversion; their learning should be focused on the aspects pertaining to their conversion, until they formally become Jewish. It's a matter of respecting the divine structure of Torah and mitzvos.

8:34We have discussed the proper parameters for Torah study for a Ben Noach, a righteous gentile who observes the Seven Universal Commandments. Now, regarding your own situation, if you are in the process of converting, then you are permitted to study only those matters pertaining to your conversion. Why? Because, again, as long as you have not formally converted, for whatever reason – whether it be financial, geographical, marital, or simply a lack of readiness – you remain, from a Halakhic perspective, a non-Jew. Consequently, your engagement with Torah study is still restricted. My dear brothers, my dear sisters, it is of paramount importance that we understand the sacred boundaries of Torah study, particularly for those on the journey of conversion. The path to Yiddishkeit is one of profound commitment and deep learning, but it must be undertaken with the proper guidance and within the established framework of Halakha, and so, whatever the reason, so long as you have not yet converted, you are restricted in what kind of Torah you may learn. You have more room to learn than someone who is planning on staying a righteous Noachide and not becoming a Jew, but it has to be strictly things that pertain to your preparation for your conversion itself. Why is that the case? Because if you start learning other things, you run the risk of misinterpreting sacred texts, or adopting practices prematurely which are not meant for you at this stage. This caution is not to diminish your passion, G-d forbid, but to ensure that your path to Yiddishkeit is built on a solid foundation, guided by the wisdom of our Sages. As the Rambam himself emphasizes in his writings, deviating from the established masorah can lead one to follow their own misguided interpretations rather than the true derech (path) of Torah and mitzvos. We must guard against the danger of becoming overly wise in our own eyes, and instead humbly cling to the teachings passed down through generations.

9:24So, to reiterate what the Me'iri emphasizes, regarding the great respect for a Ger Toshav who diligently learns and observes his Sheva Mitzvot. If someone, G-d forbid, dismisses this or chooses to interpret the matter differently, I must say: you're not following the Sages; you're following your own mentality, your own logic, your own ideas. And that's going to be a mistake of a lifetime. Why? You're being overly righteous, you're being overly wise, and you're going to end up being alone. You're going to end up being alone. And here we see the Rambam has commentary here, which further elucidates this critical obligation. Indeed, the Rambam, in Hilchot Melachim U'Milchamot, Perek Shemoneh, Halacha Aseres, clearly states that Jews are tasked with instructing the Gentiles in the performance of their Sheva Mitzvot Bnei Noach. ...and this brings us to a crucial ruling by the Rambam himself on this very matter, for he says, also, in Hilkhot Melakhim uMilchamot, chapter eight, Halakha ten, that the Jews have an obligation to instruct the Gentiles in the performance of their seven Noachide Laws. And a gentile who is well-versed in the particular laws involved in the observance of his seven mitzvot is worthy of more respect than an unlearned Kohen Gadol. The Gemara discusses this point at length. Now, again, as I said, the Meiri emphasizes that this profound respect given to a knowledgeable gentile is not merely academic, but reflects the immense spiritual significance of their commitment to divine law, demonstrating that the very foundation of ethical living, even for a non-Jew, stems directly from the Will of Hashem. It underscores that...

10:24So, when we speak about the obligations upon goyim, upon non-Jews, we understand that Hashem in His infinite wisdom gave them the Sheva Mitzvot Bnei Noach, the Seven Noachide Laws, as their path to serve Him. This isn't just a minimal set of guidelines; rather, these Sheva Mitzvot Bnei Noach include many of the fundamental principles of the Torah. For example, the prohibition against idolatry is obviously central. And, of course, this also requires a person to truly develop their middot (character traits) and learn mussar, and so forth, just like it does for us. But that does not mean that they can just pick and choose which halakhot they like. That's not how it works. These laws are binding, given by Hashem, and one cannot invent or disregard them at will. They must be observed as commanded, through the tradition of Klal Yisrael. Deviating from them, or attempting to establish a new religion based on them, is a grave transgression, as the Rambam explains. When a Noahide attempts to create his own path or his own interpretation of the mitzvot entrusted to him, he strays from the divine will. He is forbidden from innovating. furthermore, they are also not allowed to start anything new, because that is no different than Christianity. For example, Christianity and Islam are forbidden according to the Rambam and most poskim. Islam, even though it is monotheistic, is forbidden according to the halakha, and Christianity is forbidden because of idolatry. But nevertheless, they are considered a new religion, so it is an additional punishment for them. This is precisely why we emphasize that a Noahide must adhere strictly to the seven mitzvot Bnei Noach as they are given through the Torah and expounded upon by our Sages, without any deviation, addition, or subtraction, lo tosifu v'lo tigra'u.

11:15My dear friends, we have been delving into the profound topic of spiritual health, and what it truly means to serve Hashem. Often, we see individuals, perhaps with good intentions, acting in ways that appear righteous but are in fact based on their own flawed understanding. This can lead to a spiritual sickness, a denial of the true path. It is absolutely vital that a person needs to know that when it comes to mitzvot, when it comes to following Hashem and following what He says, you have to follow Him the way He said it. You have to follow His Sages the way He said it, not the way that you decide He said it. And when a Noahide follows the Torah the way he or she decides, they are fundamentally misunderstanding the spirit of the mitzvah. This self-deception, this idea that one can invent their own halakha, is a profound spiritual sickness, akin to the "overly righteous" behavior we've previously discussed. True yirat Shamayim requires humble adherence to the path laid out by Hashem and His Sages, without personal modifications or reinterpretations. Good evening, rebbe'lech. Tonight, we'll delve into a fundamental aspect of avodas Hashem – the journey of self-awareness. Often, in our earnest desire to serve HaKadosh Baruch Hu, we might find ourselves looking outwards, perhaps even judging others, rather than engaging in true cheshbon hanefesh. And sometimes, the very things we criticize in others can be subtle reflections within ourselves. Chazal teach us in Pirkei Avot, "Do not be a wicked rasha in your own eyes." The Ramchal, in Mesillas Yesharim, expands on this, highlighting how easily one can fall into the trap of ga'avah, even when attempting to do good. And this is precisely what we're discussing when you're seeing that they're acting overly righteous. And when a person acts overly righteous, you can expect a lot of bad things. He realizes he's sick. He's spiritually sick. There's nothing wrong with being spiritually sick. There's something wrong with denying it. This denial, my dear friends, is the greatest obstacle to spiritual growth, to achieving true simcha in our avodas Hashem. Only when we acknowledge our imperfections, our yetzer hara's subtle whispers, can we begin the real work, the avodah of refining our middos and drawing closer to HaKadosh Baruch Hu. As Rebbe Nachman teaches, "It is a great mitzvah to be happy, but also to recognize your own spiritual state truthfully, without pretense." May we all merit to approach our avodas Hashem with honesty and humility, always striving to improve.

BH Headquarters