Understanding Divine Judgement, BOOK OF ENOCH, Baby Names, ARTSCROLL TALMUD -STUMP THE RABBI (144)
Transcript
0:16We are back here on our Stump the Rabbi Wednesday shiur after a few divrei Torah. You guys will ask some questions and b'ezrat Hashem HaKadosh Baruch Hu will give us the answers. Tonight's shiur will go to a refuah shlema. And also for that, for Marsha bat Julie and all of Am Yisrael, all the righteous Noahides. All the wonderful people that are looking to do teshuva and are watching our shiurim and are contributing to help us get these shiurim to as many people as possible, whether it's by donating money or their time or skills or everything else. Tonight we have a really interesting shiur.
1:20uh... trying to understand the Divine judgment. There are many questions that people ask me about it, uh... you know, different things in regards to judgment and, uh... b'ezrat Hashem, we'll try to use different aspects of it to really, truly understand. Uh... before that, just to give you guys an update, we are a week away from the Gehenom Shiur, the Gehenom movie that's coming out, there's still room for anyone that wants to contribute to the movie to help us share it everywhere, market it in different places. Anyone that donates $1,800 or more will also get USBs once they come out in about six months or so. You'll get a bunch of USBs that you can give out. In essence, you're getting your money back. But more importantly, you'll be part of an endless amount of people that are going to be able to watch this film in different ways, not just on the internet. So just to encourage people to contribute, you can go to gehenom.org. This is our new website specifically for the movie. Gehenom is spelled G-E-H-E-N-O-M.
2:33gehenom.org. You can go over there, and you can contribute, or you can go to the campaign specifically at gehenom.com. One of the things we're doing tonight, just for everybody that's watching tonight and until the movie, we'll... we'll pick whoever is actually going to donate. We'll enter them into a raffle that we have where one person will win a brand new tallit. This is the special talleisim that we have on our website from Israel. These are not just regular talleisim; these are $500 talleisim that have beautiful designs on them with diamonds and blue. There are different colors. So this is something that certainly anyone that's familiar with talleisim knows are very special. All of them are obviously brand new. They also come with our own new Be'ezrat Hashem tallit bags and tefillin bag.
3:38So, one person will win a free tallit over this next week that will contribute to this campaign. In fact, the announcement will be made over the next week, but the winner is going to be anybody that's watching it over the next 24 hours, meaning between now and Shabbat. Whoever donates to the campaign will enter that raffle. And Be'ezrat Hashem, we will choose one and let them know that they won this brand new tallit. Just to give you guys, I guess, let me just undo the whole thing. It's a big tallit. Also, one of the reasons why it's more expensive than a lot of talleisim that you'll buy in the store is not just because of the atarah, but also because of the fabric and how it doesn't fall off your shoulder, which many people find annoying. So this is one of those special talleisim that I found for myself. a few years ago, and I figured that I might as well try to make it available because I couldn't find it anywhere here in the States. So, one person will win it, and we're looking forward to letting you guys know who won it. Again, it doesn't matter how much you donate, whether you donate fifty dollars or five thousand dollars, you'll enter that raffle. Of course, those that donate more will be able to...
4:57be a bigger part of the move, but nonetheless, each person will be included in the raffle. We know we don't want to exclude anyone, so that's one thing that is understood. We also have, as I mentioned the other day, a new campaign that we're starting for a free gift for subscribers to our channel on YouTube each time we reach a new thousand subscribers. we're going to announce a free gift for somebody, one of those thousand people or one of the many thousands of subscribers that we have. It doesn't have to be the last thousand subscribers. It could be the first 35 or 36,000 that we already have. So anybody that subscribes now will enter that raffle and we'll announce different gifts. One of the gifts that we have is a free Chumash. A free Stone Chumash. This is about $50 or $60 or so. This is one of the gifts. We also have the Pirkei Avot book. That is one of them. And we also have the Tallit that I just showed you. And a few other things that, b'ezrat Hashem, are going to be the gifts that people get. So each one of these gifts is not...
6:07you know, a bubble gum. Each one is a substantial gift that somebody will get just for being part of our kiruv and our, you know, watching our shiurim. So, with that being said, we have a title for the issue of Understanding Divine Judgment. Now, the Sefer Bereishit, the Book of Genesis, is full of stories about our patriarchs and our matriarchs and the extraordinary lives and difficult tests that they overcame, that they went through all together, and an endless amount of Mussar lessons about... The Sefer Bereishit, the Book of Genesis, is full of stories about our patriarchs and our matriarchs and the extraordinary lives and difficult tests that they overcame, that they went through altogether, and an endless amount of Mussar lessons about can be learned from them. This is actually the reason why the Sefer Bereishit is also called Sefer HaYashar, which is the Book of the Upright, because our patriarchs and matriarchs were very upright people, and all of them were glued to the emet of the Torah, no matter what the sacrifice had to be.
7:09Now, of course, this is also a place where, through their lives, through the things that they went through, we could also learn more about how the divine judgment works, the logic behind it, if you will, because the logic of God is not the logic of man. So certainly a person can't just assume that just because something makes sense to them, that's exactly what God is going to do. Because many times we've seen in our own lives that what made sense to us was not necessarily what Hashem decided was going to be. So one of the places that you can actually learn more details about the divine judgment is throughout Sefer Bereishit. from the lives of our sages, from the lives of our patriarchs and matriarchs, but also from the teachings of our sages about those particular times. And if you look at the Gemara in Masechet Sanhedrin, it gives us a little bit of a small understanding that is going to be more clear after we finish this shiur, once you see the stories. Where the Gemara in Masechet Sanhedrin, Daf Ayin Alef, Amud Bet (71b),
8:25has the Mishnah. It's a new Mishnah that talks about the Ben Sorer U'Moreh, which is a wayward child. Why is there this wayward child? How he's judged very harshly, with this 13-year-old boy that did a few things that were terrible, is judged with a death penalty. Now, without going into all of the details of the Ben Sorer U'Moreh, the Mishnah says that the reason why he is judged this way is to let him die while he's innocent and not let him die while he's guilty. Meaning that the way he is going already with his actions, the way he's behaving already at this age, which is a relatively short period of time. It's a three-month period of time. The way that he's behaving, certainly this kid is going to be a criminal that's going to murder people, and therefore it's better to kill him already than to let him live. And then the Mishnah goes into the part that I want to discuss, which is the divine logic behind all of it. For the death of the wicked is beneficial to them and beneficial to the world.
9:34Meaning that when the wicked people die, they actually benefit from that death and the world benefits from them dying. But the death of the righteous is detrimental to them and detrimental to the world. When the righteous people die, it's not good for them. It's certainly not good for the world. The explanation for that is that when the wicked die, it's better for them because they can't sin anymore. So whatever judgment they have, it stops over there, more or less, unless they left a lot of bad fruits that are going to continue causing more people to sin. But the world also benefits from their death simply because they're not causing more harm to people. So whatever judgment they have, it stops over there, more or less, unless they left a lot of bad fruits that are going to continue causing more people to sin. But the world also benefits from their death simply because they're not causing more harm to people. The opposite is the case with the righteous. The righteous who are collecting good deeds every day, when they leave this world, they can no longer collect more good deeds like they did when they were alive. Certainly, if they left good fruits in this world, they collect more good deeds. But again, it's not as much as when they're alive, when they're able to pray, when they're able to learn more, and so on.
10:36So it's a detriment to them when they die, and also it's a detriment to the world where their merit protects the people. When a righteous person is alive, his merit actually protects the world, protects the people. Further, the Mishnah goes on to say, wine and sleep for the wicked are beneficial to them and beneficial to the world, but for the righteous, it's detrimental to them and detrimental to the world. dispersal for the wicked is beneficial for them and beneficial to the world, but for the righteous, it's detrimental to them and detrimental to the world. assembly, meaning gathering together, for the wicked is detrimental to them and detrimental to the world, but for the righteous, it's beneficial for them and beneficial for the world. Tranquility for the wicked is detrimental to them and detrimental to the world, but for the righteous, it is beneficial for them and beneficial for the world. Now, of course, we're going to get into the details
11:39of why it's this case. But the first thing that a person would say, when they look at this superficially and have not learned, is they're gonna say to themselves, "Wait a minute, but the wicked people, if they die now, they can't do teshuva anymore." it's a, how could it be positive for them? How could it be beneficial for them? You know, the righteous people, if they die, they go to Heaven. Why would that be detrimental? So the common logic would literally be the opposite of what the Torah actually says. So it's important for a person to understand that the common logic is the opposite of the Torah. Unless a person has glued themselves to the Torah, to the Talmidei Chachamim, their natural logic will be the opposite of the Torah. So this is the reason why also when we hear different things and see different heretical behavior, whether it comes from rabbis or it comes from other people, and we rebuke it, there are always going to be a few people that rebuke us instead, telling us, "Oh, how can you say lashon hara about this rabbi that is bringing a Christian missionary to his shul? It's not nice. He's just looking for unity. How can you say lashon hara?"
12:58about this Santa Claus rabbi, Manis Friedman, who has interviews with zonot on a regular basis and says things against the Torah. He's just looking to be friends with everybody. He's welcoming. How can you say this, and how can you say that? Now, of course, for those of you who have been watching my lectures for a long time, You already know the logic behind it, and of course, you realize there is no din of lashon hara when you're speaking against wicked people in order to protect the public. But needless to say, the common logic out there is the opposite of that. The common logic out there is simply in line with the wicked people. Whether it's intentional or unintentional is irrelevant. The key is to understand that the common logic of a person that's not glued to the Torah is going to be the opposite of the Torah. And this is one of the things that a person needs to understand, and we'll learn it through this week's parasha, Parashat Vayishlach. First and foremost, in Parashat Vayishlach, we see, "Vayishlach Yaakov malachim lefanav el Esav achiv artzah Se'ir, sedeh Edom." So, Yaakov Avinu leaves the house of Lavan finally, after 20 years of suffering and difficulty. He leaves the house of Lavan, and he's now going towards his brother Esav. And it says, he's...
14:18He sends malachim; he sends angels. That's what Rashi says—mamash, angels—that he's actually sending to go and check out the situation. And Rashi says angels; Onkelos says he sends ministers. But there's no machloket between them; it's just that Yaakov Avinu sent both regular people and angels to go check out the situation. So then, after that, we see that these angels and ministers that Yaakov sent come back. We came to your brother, to Esav. They returned and came back to the brother. So obviously we see here there's a superfluous word. There's an extra word here. Why do I need to know that his brother's name is Esav? I mean, obviously we already know that.
15:18It's not only do we know from the previous parashot, but we also know from this parasha, as the first verse in the parasha says that he sent them to Esav. So the first thing that we hear is this is to teach us that later on in the next couple of, next few verses, Yaakov Avinu prays to Hashem. He prays to Hashem and he says, and he says, again the same type of language where Yaakov prays to Hashem and says, "Please Hashem, save me from the hand of my brother, save me from the hand of Esav." Why this again? This seems to be extra words. Very simple. First, you have to learn that just because he's your brother doesn't mean he's your friend. In fact, in this particular case... it's to remind you that Esav is your brother, but he's also your enemy, and he's much more dangerous when he's pretending to be your brother than when he shows his true colors. This is like, for example, the Christian missionaries of the world today.
16:23the Hebrew Israelite movement of today, and all the other types of people that are trying to say that they are looking for the better good of the Jewish people, the better good of even their own communities, by pretending to act as if they are the savior, they are Yaakov, they are coming representing God, but in reality, all that pretending has to go in line with what our tradition is. Our tradition has specific teachings, but also has specific laws. And one of the laws that we have, that Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai says to us, is there's a halacha that Esav soneh et Yaakov. This is a klal gadol baTorah. This is a very big rule in the Torah. So long as he is connected to Esav, meaning he acts in accordance with what Esav's laws are, not according to our Torah, He's not observant of the seven Noahide laws. He's observant of some new religion that was created over the last couple of thousand years or the last hundred years. He's not observant of what the Torah is. He is connected to Esav. He is connected to something that hates Yaakov.
17:37So, even if he acts like Yaakov, always be reminded he is Esav. Despite the fact that he'll call you "my brother," "my friend," or whatever he wants to call you, it's important for a person to know that this is the case: Esav is an enemy. If he's a Christian missionary, if he's a religious person from the church of any kind, if he is coming from that account, he doesn't want your better good. He may be a nice person to his own people. He may even be nice in certain ways to you. But the ultimate agenda of Esav is to destroy Yaakov by converting him to his other religions and, of course, destroying him spiritually. So the question that we have is, first and foremost, why is Yaakov scared? I mean, technically Yaakov is a righteous person, and in fact, Yaakov is as righteous as it can get. So much so that Hashem took the image of Yaakov.
18:38actually looked like Adam HaRishon and He put it as one of the four images on the Throne of Glory, where you have Yaakov's image, the image of an eagle, the king of the birds, a bull, and a lion—the four kings, if you will. So you have Yaakov was something extraordinary. And that's why when it says in last week's parasha that the angels were going up and down the ladder, the Midrash explains that the angels could not understand how Yaakov could be in this world as well as on the Throne of Glory. Because the image on the Throne of Glory is not like an image that you can... get some sculptor to make you here. Literally, it's an image that's lifelike. And they could not understand how he could be in two places at the same time. That's why they were going up and down. So here we have a question: Yaakov is extremely righteous, but yet Yaakov is afraid of Esav. He's asking Hashem for special help, divine help from Esav. And he's, in essence...
19:54Trying to do whatever is possible to get Hashem's mercy. Next, we see, well, of course, we're going to try to answer all of these questions. Then we see that there is an angel that's sent that represents the angel of Esav to fight Yaakov, to fight Yaakov on his way. Now, of course, the Midrash says that this is the representative of Esav, but it's because Yaakov went back to get a few small things that he left that weren't worth very much. which is to show that tzaddikim, because their money is kosher, are very particular about their possessions. They don't want to lose them; they don't want to waste them. So here, it seems there's almost a divine rebuke of Yaakov being careful about not wasting his money, not wasting his possessions, by sending him a battle with, nonetheless, an angel, an angel representing Esav. So what is the purpose of this? What is the purpose of this issue?
21:05After this battle, which is really the bigger question, at the end of the battle, it says that Yaakov asks the angel, "What is your name? What is your name?" And the angel doesn't want to answer him. He says to him, "What difference does it make what my name is? What's it to you? Why do you need to know my name?" I told you that your name is no longer going to be Yaakov. You're going to be Yisrael and Yaakov. But my name is irrelevant. Why is the angel so particular about the name? Tell Yaakov to not tell Yaakov, and even more so, what's the significance of changing the name? Many people have issues when it comes to naming children. This is a very recurring and common problem among all Jewish communities where, when a new child is born, new fights are born. Why? Because the tradition is to name the child after one of the parents, whether it's on the wife's side or the husband's side.
22:10So, if there is peace among the couple where they already decide we're going to name this baby after the wife's side or after the husband's side, we see tradition in the Torah itself that usually the first baby is named after the wife's family. or she chooses the name, whereas the second baby is chosen by the husband. But again, this is not a law. You can do it the opposite way. You can simply have all of the names chosen by the wife or the husband, depending again, as long as it doesn't create fights. But many times the fights are not really between the husband and the wife, but rather the parents. the child, but rather the fights come from outside. They come from the parents, they come from the brothers and the sisters, who all of a sudden care about the naming as if it's Matan Torah, as if it's like the Torah being received from Mount Sinai. "Oh, how can you not call your son after Abba? How come you can't call your daughter after Ima? How come you can't do this?" how could you do that? Our parents are going to be so embarrassed. Our parents are this. I just heard that Ima was crying about it because she heard that you're going to name your daughter after your wife's, uh, uh, uh, mom. That's so disrespectful! You this, you that. And they create this, they bring this animosity into the couple's life, where instead of it being a time of happiness...
23:32It turns into a nightmare. And worse yet is when somebody decides, "Listen, I understand you guys decided on such and such name, regardless of what it is. You can't call him that name. You can't call it that name. Why? That name is cursed." Cursed? Why is the name cursed? Why is this name cursed? The Jewish name, why is the name cursed? Oh no, don't you remember that such-and-such had a daughter and her name was the same name that you want to pick, and she ended up marrying some goy? Oh, don't you remember that such-and-such, he has a son, and that son is a thief? So surely, if you name your son the same name as this guy, maybe your son is going to be a thief. Is there any validity to this? Are there good names? Are there bad names? Because, quite frankly, the angel is teaching us that there is significance in the name. So, of course, this is another question. Another question that we need to try to answer. We're going to get time to answer all these questions.
24:35Now, after this, we of course see that Yaakov sends the tribute to Esav. When Esav sees Yaakov, they hug. Some say that Esav really actually tried to kill him by biting him. that's why, uh, the, uh, the word for them, uh, kissing each other has the special dots on it in the Hebrew language, showing that really Esav bit Yaakov on his neck but his teeth broke. So he realized that Yaakov has become kodesh kodashim, holy of holies, that he is beyond the strength of Esav. Esav is powerless next to Yaakov. But nonetheless, the thing that happens after is most peculiar, most interesting to us, where we see that Esav offers himself, his busy, wealthy self, to accompany Yaakov, and says, listen, let me go along with you.
25:37Yaakov rejects it, saying, "My lord knows that the young ones are tender." Some say that he was referring to his children; some say he was referring to his sheep, many of which were very young. If we go and try to keep up with your pace... And what's going to end up happening is all of these weak children or weak sheep are going to end up dying. So, better that you go your way, and we'll catch up later. Why not just say to Esav, "Listen, I'll go with you, but you have to slow down because I have all of these sheep, all of the cattle, all of the kids, all of the wives. I've got everything else. Now, I'm not just by myself. Just realize, if you're coming with me, you have to comply." Why not do that? Why send them away and never see him again? The next question is the very big question, one of the biggest tragedies. One of the biggest tragedies in Am Yisrael's history happens in this week's parasha. Where it says, "Now Dinah, the daughter of Leah, went out to look at the daughters of the land. And Shechem, the son of Chamor, the ruler of the region, saw her."
26:50And he took her and he lay with her and he afflicted her. So here we see that Dinah, the daughter of Yaakov, gets raped. Gets raped by this Shechem, by this disaster of a being. And of course, this is a nightmare and a half. Why does Dinah deserve all of this? I mean, after all, she's a tzaddeket. The Midrash says she was very, very beautiful. But it's not mentioned that she's beautiful; it's only mentioned in the Midrash. Whereas the beauty of Sarah, the beauty of Rachel, is mentioned in the Torah. Why? Why is Dinah's beauty, even though it was well known, and the reason why he was in love with her after raping her, which is usually the opposite of the psychotic mind of a rapist, he actually loves her and he wants to stay with her because she was so beautiful. Even more so, it says that he lay with her and he afflicted her. So the Torah also tells us, what does it mean? What do we learn from the fact that he afflicted her? Obviously, if he raped her, he afflicted her. What is there to learn from this? This is also certainly extraordinary.
28:02Details that are within the details. Why did Hashem allow this to happen? She's a tzaddeket. She's a good woman. Why did Hashem allow this to happen? Of course, we've spoken about this in the past to a certain extent. We'll try to cover it more, but even more so try to cover what ends up happening as a result of this, which is that her brothers, Shimon and Levi, end up murdering the entire people. of Shechem and Chamor. Everybody, the whole people, everybody. No exceptions. All of the men that were, including Shechem and his father Chamor, his grandfather, all of their soldiers, all of the people there, simply they murder everybody. Only the women and children are pretty much turned into slaves. What gives Shimon and Levi the right, especially since they're tzaddikim, they're righteous people, what gives them the right to do so? In fact, the Ramban asked the question: If what they did was the right thing to do, why did Yaakov not help them? In fact, he actually rebuked them. He rebuked them for doing it. But yet, at the same time, how can you say that what they did is wrong? They're tzaddikim.
29:23So we cannot question our tzaddikim. There obviously has to be an explanation for this. Why did God allow such a thing to happen? And again, after that, they say, we did it. Why? Should we allow our sister to be treated like a zonah, like a harlot? Again, we have to ask ourselves, why did Hashem allow such things in His Torah? These things happen based on the free choice of people, but nonetheless, why did He include all of these things? What can we learn from all of them? After this, it talks about how the fight and everything happened, and then Yaakov and his family continue. And it says that during the way, two major things happened. One, in chapter 35, verse number 5, it says that the nations of Canaan were petrified of Yaakov and his family. All of them were petrified of him.
30:40why do I need to know that? If you're going to tell me that they were afraid that they were going to kill them, they don't need to be afraid. Why? They just killed Shechem and Chamor because they raped his sister. That's it. They have no reason to kill the rest of the people. So why are you terrified of them? If you're going to tell me that this is before the battle with Shechem and Chamor, why would the nations be afraid when they have nothing to do with it? what do I need to learn from this? Furthermore, we see that Terach died. Terach, that's Avraham's father, he died. Why did Rachel die? She was a Tzadeket. Why did she die? And last but not least, with all of the ongoing teachings that we have in our Torah... where we talk about what we started the conversation with, the fact that Esav hates Yaakov. Esav hates Yaakov. It is well known that Esav was actually supposed to be one of the patriarchs. He had an elevated neshama that had the potential to be the fourth pillar, where it was supposed to be Avraham, Yitzchak, Yaakov, and Esav, where Esav was supposed to be the father of six of the tribes. But because of his bad choices, he ended up being the enemy of Yaakov, the enemy of Yisrael.
31:59and Esav, where Esav was supposed to be the father of six of the tribes. But because of his bad choices, he ended up being the enemy of Yaakov, the enemy of Yisrael. But yet the reality is that the Torah doesn't actually detail what those actions are. I mean, if you're going to make somebody into an enemy, an enemy of Am Yisrael, at the very least, let me know the details. What did he do? Now, of course, they're saying that before he sold the... He sold the firstborn rights. The Midrash says that he murdered someone that day. He raped someone that day. But that's behind the scenes. Is there something in the verses that shows how wicked Esav is? Because quite frankly, if you're going to be an enemy, and when you have the potential to be a brother, there obviously has to be something significantly different between Esav and Yaakov.
33:03These are some of the questions that we asked, Baruch Hashem, this week in this parasha. And with the help of Hashem, we're going to try to answer them. Now, of course, Parashat Vayishlach starts off with the rule, the law, that Esav hates Yaakov. After that, Yaakov cries to HaKadosh Baruch Hu, saying to HaKadosh Baruch Hu, please save me from my brother, save me from Esav. And quickly after, he... quickly after he obviously prays to Hashem even more so, but right before it, we get an answer, we get a hint from Yaakov where he says, so Yaakov says in chapter 32 um
34:05Verse 11: I have been diminished due to all of the kindness and due to all of the truth that You have done with Your servant. And with my staff, I crossed this Jordan, and now I have become two camps. Rescue me, please, from the hand of my brother, from the hand of Esav. So here we see that Yaakov is teaching us about the mindset of the righteous, where although he knows that he is not a murderer like his brother Esav, still he's not considering himself, like what we do, as the most righteous, as the most holy, as the greatest of the patriarchs. No, he is Yaakov. And in fact, he says, even if I was righteous person and I did mitzvot, certainly you've already rewarded me. I came here with nothing other than my staff in my hand.
35:11And You gave me multiple wives, the 12 tribes, and a guarantee that my descendants are the chosen people. Nobody else can ever take that away. And even more so, You've given me 12 righteous kids that even my father and my grandfather And my forefathers like Noach and Adam HaRishon did not merit to have. Nobody ever had all of their kids righteous like Yaakov Avinu. Avraham had Yitzchak, but he also had Yishmael. Yitzchak had Yaakov, but he also had Esav. Noach had Shem, but he also had Yefet and Cham. So you had Adam HaRishon, who had Hevel, who died shortly after, and then Shet. But he also had Kayin, who was very wicked. So Yaakov says the type of gift that you've given me certainly has already superseded whatever merit was due to me. So now, for me to survive this battle against my brother is not something that I expect. That's why I have to pray.
36:28I have to pray. But at the same time, we know that Yaakov is strong. When he met Rachel, he lifted the huge stone off of the well because there was a shortage of water. So they would cover the well, and only once a day, when everybody finished work, all the shepherds would come and pick up this huge rock, this huge boulder covering the well for everybody to drink. So no one drinks all of the water and causes everybody else to die. But yet, when Yaakov comes over there, he lifts the entire boulder by himself. So we see that Yaakov is super strong. Not just strong. What are you scared of this Esav? I mean, even if he's strong, how much stronger could he possibly be? But then we learn again, the hints are in the verses, where we see that Yaakov... ends up fighting against this angel. So we see that the fight against Esav is not a regular fight.
37:28he's not worried about the physical fight, but rather the spiritual fight. Please Hashem, protect me from the spiritual damage that can come from Esav. That has nothing to do with physical strength. He could be bigger, he could be more muscular, that doesn't make a difference. If I have the truth, even if he kills my body, my soul goes to an eternity of good. My soul is still going to heaven. But if he affects my neshama and he causes me to worship some guy that died 2,000 years ago, or he causes me to worship some false prophet that spoke Arabic but didn't know how to read or write it, or he causes me to dress like some Power Ranger or some video game character, instead of worshiping Hashem, obviously this is going to hurt my neshama. And then I'm going to end up being a goy. So protect me from that. And I know You've already given me so much, and in fact, the reason why Yaakov is mentioning that Hashem gave him so much is because he's thanking Hashem.
38:35He's thanking Hashem. This is actually one of the reasons why the patriarchs received so much. Yaakov is trying to teach his children today that instead of complaining to Hashem about your problems, about the tests that you have, about the difficulties in front of you, first and foremost, count your gifts. Count the blessings that He already gave you. Okay, so you're short of money. You're looking for a shidduch. You want to have another child or a child for the first time. You have health issues. Whatever issue everybody has. Fine. I know it's easy to cry. It's easy to complain. It's easy to blame God for everything. But when was the last time you counted all the blessings you did have until now? All the good that God did give you until now. When did you actually count them, needless to say? When did you actually thank Hashem for them? Did you thank Hashem for the fact that He's allowed you to breathe for the last 20, 30, 40, or 50 years? Did you thank Hashem that He gave you vision? That you're able to see the beauty of His creation?
39:44When was the last time you thanked Hashem for being able to hear beautiful sounds? Whether it be kosher music, or the sound of your spouse, or your children playing, or learning Torah with the Rav. When was the last time you thanked Hashem for that beautiful gift? Because there are many people that don't have good hearing, or any hearing at all. When was the last time you thanked Hashem that you have taste buds that can still taste food? and in fact that there is good food available and we're not like the snake that everything is like sand. When was the last time that you thanked Hashem for the last 20, 30, 40 years that He gave you? The clothing on your back, the house that you've lived in, the car that you drove, the money that you had, the food that you ate. Now, of course, yes, you have issues now, but did you thank Him for what He already gave you before you're asking for this new salvation? because if you thank Hashem, that in itself gives you the merit that would warrant getting further blessings. But if you don't appreciate what He already gave you,
40:53then you are portraying one of the worst character traits that exist in the world, which is ungratefulness, being a kafuy tovah. The Gemara says there are certain people that God hates; one of them is a kafuy tovah, someone who is ungrateful. Because if you're ungrateful, then certainly you're a bad person. And of course, people think, yeah, yeah, no, I thank God all the time. Yeah, but that's not the only place you have to be grateful. Are you also grateful to people that have helped you? If you have your parents, they helped you. Are you grateful for the help they gave you? You have a rabbi, he helped you. Are you grateful for the help that he gave you? You have a spouse. She gave you, he gave you a piece of themselves, their life, their time, their money, their resources, their love, their emotions. Are you grateful for that? Yeah, yeah, I'm grateful. Do they know that you're grateful? Yeah, yeah, I told her one time. When did you tell her you're grateful? Yeah, when we got married five, ten years ago. Oh, so you told her then. So, what, if it changes, you'll let her know? No.
41:57The reality is that most people do not realize that even if they are grateful, most of the time the people around them don't know. For some reason, people are not only stingy with their money; they're even stingy with their words. They're stingy with their gratitude. When was the last time they said thank you to someone who changed their life and helped them do teshuva? Whether it be a family friend, brother, sister, or rabbi, whoever it was. When was the last time they said thank you to their boss who gives them a job and a paycheck? I have certain employees who literally, every single check that they get every two weeks, they make sure to send me a thank you. I mean, this is something beautiful. I never had it on Wall Street when I paid people millions of dollars. But yet, here, running an organization of Be'ezrat Hashem, I have a few people that say thank you. But yet, there are certain people that you could literally give them a raise, you can give them a promotion, you can give them whatever they want, and gratitude is simply unbeknownst to them. They don't even know what it is. They expect it. There are certain people in your life that literally do not know what thank you is, and it behooves you to teach them.
43:12by showing them the shiur, by reminding them, not by being abrasive and saying, "Oh, you didn't say thank you," because that's not going to help. In fact, it will cause them to not want to say thank you. Rather, have them learn the Torah and show them the importance of gratitude. Because if a person learns how to be grateful to people, certainly he'll eventually realize that he has to be grateful to his Creator. But if a person is ungrateful to people, for sure, the Gemara says, he's ungrateful to his Creator. So Yaakov Avinu is going through a life test unlike any other, but he takes the opportunity to thank Hashem for all of the blessings. Because he says that all of these blessings already have superseded whatever merit that I have. I need to earn more merits. What's better than thanking You for what You've already given me? So here we see that this whole battle is another way for Hashem to teach us the nature of the patriarchs and why He loved them so much. How much they thanked Him.
44:19And if you calculate what did he really thank Him for, from our perspective, oh, he had a wife. Okay, well, other people have wives. Oh, he had kids. Well, naturally, if you have a wife, typically you'll have kids. Oh, yeah, well, he had a job. You call that a job? Working for some criminal for 20 years? That's a job? He cheated him of millions of dollars? That's a job? Well, technically it was enough to eat. Wait, you're telling me I have to be grateful for a job that just pays me enough to eat? Grateful? You owe that job your life. Anyone that watched one of my shiurim in the series that we had years ago, "Amazing Questions About God," knows that we had a whole shiur about gratitude. When a person understands the importance of gratitude, they'll realize that literally for just somebody lending you a pen, a pen, you owe them a life of gratitude, a pen. Needless to say, someone that gives you a job. Needless to say, a million and a half times, someone that gives you an opportunity to go to eternal heaven. But the average person doesn't delve into what they already have. They delve into what they need. Hence the reason why they're miserable. So here, the Torah is trying to tell us that this judgment is one of the ways that Hashem can show us the beauty of our patriarchs. Later on, we actually go into the fight between the angel and Yaakov.
45:48teaching us that this battle between Esav and Yaakov did not end 4,000 years ago. In fact, it's still going on and it's the ultimate war of good versus evil until this day. This is the explanation behind why Kayin killed Hevel This is why Hashem allowed Hevel to die because Hevel wasn't alive for long enough to sin. There's an ultimate battle between Kayin versus Hevel. And that's in essence good versus evil. But after they die, that battle transforms into the next generation and the next generation. And there's a power of Kedusha and power of Tumah, of evil, of impurity in the world. That will culminate at the end when the evil will be eliminated at the time of Mashiach. But before that, evil will have the power. And only people that sanctify themselves will be able to withstand it without falling into its trap.
46:53So here we see that this battle is not something that ended and, in fact, the ultimate power of evil, say the Chachamim, say the Mekubalim, was given to Esav. The ultimate highest level of impurity in the world is in the hands of Esav, which means the father of Amalek. This means this is Christianity; this is the idolatry that started off as my brother, a fellow Jew. that strayed away from God and decided to turn himself into some idol. A person that some people call Mashiach, but in reality, they mean that he's a deity called Mashiach. So, the highest level of impurity, according to some of the greatest Chachamim that we have, is in the hands of Esav. This battle is still going. It's a spiritual battle, nonetheless. It's not something we have to fight with guns, knives, or fists. No. It's a spiritual battle. This is why the Christian church is willing to spend every penny it has to convert Jews to Christianity.
48:10But yet, the Jews are not even willing to spend a single dollar to convert the Christians to Judaism. If the Christian wants to convert, they're welcome, but they have to become Jews. They have to leave Christianity in the garbage. But they're on their own. There's no special fund to convert Christians to Judaism. You want to convert? Welcome. Why? Because, again, this is a spiritual battle. If you've left the church... You have to prove it by abandoning everything and sacrificing everything for the sake of the truth. There's no way that we would know that you're willing to do that if there's a special fund and a promotion to proselytize everywhere. Certainly, we should help converts that are genuine once they've shown, once they've proven that they're genuine and real after they convert. But beforehand, you're very limited with what you can do. Why? Because there is a spiritual battle. There is a spiritual battle. Now, the church, on the other hand, is willing to spend every single penny to recruit a Jew to say that he believes in Yeshu. Now, at the end of this battle, which is still ongoing, but the end of the battle that happened almost 4,000 years ago, the angel is telling Yaakov that his name is going to be Yisrael. And when Yaakov asks him his name,
49:38he says, "What difference is my name? What difference?" Rashi on the pasuk says that what the angel meant is that The angels don't have fixed names, with the exception of a few of the major ones, such as Gavriel or Micha'el and a couple of others, Malach Metatron, these great angels. The rest of the angels don't have specific names. They have names that are based on their mission. If he has a mission to go heal somebody, he's called Refa'el. If he has a mission to do something else, he's called something else. So from there, we learn something significant. We learn that the name of a person has a lot to do with what their role in the world is. In fact, the Midrash Rabbah in Parashat Vayetze says that there are
50:49People in the Torah that have a good name and some that don't. People that have good names and good deeds that follow. People that have good names and bad deeds. And he gives examples. Midrash Rabbah. Parasha 71 section 3. It says Rabbi Chanina says there are four categories mentioned regarding names of people: Those whose names are admirable and their actions are admirable; those whose names are loathsome and their actions loathsome; those whose names are loathsome but their actions are admirable; and those whose names are admirable, but their actions are loathsome. He gives examples and... An example of someone who had a good name but loathsome actions is Esav. Esav had a good name. Yishmael had a good name. Esav's name means someone who performs good deeds. Yishmael's name means "God will hear," meaning that God heard his name.
52:12meaning that he obeys God. But both of them violated the laws of God. On the other hand, there are people that have ugly names, loathsome names, but their actions were admirable. During the Babylonian exile, the Torah tells us that the children of Bakbuk, the children of Hakupha, and the children of Harhur, this is in Ezra, chapter 2, verse 51. These names are not exactly the most beautiful names, but these were tzaddikim who merited to ascend from Bavel to Eretz Yisrael and build the Beit HaMikdash. Then you have those that have ugly names, loathsome names, and loathsome actions. Who is that? The spies, the meraglim. They were called Sessu, Setu. Each one is referring to someone that goes off the path—destruction. These were the spies. They were actually leaders before they became wicked and spoke against the land and against Moshe and against Hashem. And the Gemara in Masechet Sanhedrin says in Perek Chelek, they have no share in the World to Come. They died an unusual death, and Shem Yishmor.
53:38Then there are people that have names that are admirable and their actions are admirable. Good names and good actions. Who are those? The 12 tribes. Reuven, Shimon, Levi, Yehuda, and the rest of the brothers. All of those names are beautiful names in the eyes of Hashem. and their actions were beautiful. What can that do to help me? What can I do to help me? Certainly, the name of a person is significant. This is why, for example, there are certain tzaddikim who would add a name to people who were going through difficulties, like a health issue. They would add a name to them because once you have a certain name and there is a certain decree on that person... There's a possibility that if you add a good name, not just any name that you saw on the internet, but some good name that a tzaddik gives you, that name can actually change the decree because the mission has changed.
54:50The mission has changed. And this answers the question of those parents, those poor parents that have trouble every time they have a kid. There's family fighting because both sides of the family want the name. This kid needs to be named after our family, not your wife's family, not your husband's family because we did this, and we did that, and did this, and did that. Or... The people that are afraid to call somebody a certain name because there's some wicked person in the family or that you know about that has that name, this answers those questions. How? First and foremost, don't name your kids after wicked people. Now, if the wicked person happens to have the same name as your kid, that has no effect on you. There are plenty of people that were called Yishmael throughout history in the Jewish world, even in the Gemara, even at the time of the Beit HaMikdash. But yet, there are Yishmaelim that are terrorizing Israel today. So just because there is a Yishmael that's bad doesn't mean that all Yishmaelim are bad.
56:06Certainly, if you call your kids the names that are praiseworthy in the Torah, names of righteous people in the Torah, and you name them after that person, you name them after Reuven, you name them after Sarah, you name them after Rivka, after Rachel, after Yehuda, after Gad, after, you know, Binyamin, Yosef, and so on, or after the Navi Ovadia, you name them after these holy people, then certainly this could impact your child in a positive way. So the first rule is to name your kids after tzaddikim. Do not name them after wicked people. Now, needless to say, don't name them after wicked people that died. In fact, Rabbi Yehuda Pataya writes in his Minchat Yehuda that he made the mistake of naming one of his children after a wicked family member that died and his child died. And he saw in a dream that his child died because that person's neshamah went into his child. Along with several other family members' kids who had a child, all of those kids died. And he says, "I'm teaching you, listen to me, never name your kid after a wicked person. Because that wicked person has multiple death penalties against them."
57:29And when you name him after this wicked person that didn't keep Shabbat, that didn't keep Taharat HaMishpacha, that didn't keep these things, that person's neshamah goes into that kid in order for him to receive the death penalty. Shem reshaim yirkav. Never name him after a wicked person. Three. As far as naming him after family members, if... the family member is righteous, you could lean towards it if it's going to make your parents happy and so on. But if the family member is wicked, doesn't observe Torah, you have no business naming them after wicked people. Why? It's not a good idea. It's not good for you, it's not good for the kid. And one of the ways you can get out of it is simply not naming the kid after anybody in the family, naming him after somebody in the Torah. Why? Because the name does have significance to the point where a kid could be the mission of that person. So we see that this argument, if you will, between the angel and Yaakov also has quite a bit to teach us. After that, we see that Yaakov tells his brother Esav that he cannot go along with them. He has to go his way, we're going to go our way. Why?
58:48Since we've already learned that the battle between Esav and Yaakov is a spiritual battle, it's an ongoing battle until this day. That means that every father, every mother, every brother, and every sister has to understand that even if you are strong enough to withstand the impurity that's coming from some family and friends that are going against God, that does not mean that you should go and do it. That doesn't mean that you should go hang out with them. Needless to say, it doesn't mean that your family can handle it also. So if you have wicked people in your circle, even if you want to do kiruv to help them do teshuva, don't do it next to your children. Because their impurity, their behavior can affect those little kids. And spiritually kill them, leading them to live a life that's the opposite. This is why Yaakov says, "You can't come with us. Not because of me, but because the kids are tender. The young ones are tender. They're fragile. They're not as strong as me. I can handle you. I've dealt with Lavan. I can handle you too. But my kids are not strong enough to handle your tumah, your impurity." So this, again, is a lesson for us all.
1:00:10now, after that, we learn about the rape of Dinah. Now, we've already talked about Dinah last week and in previous times where Dinah was punished for going outside and looking at the daughters of the land. A righteous woman will teach her daughters to also be righteous by staying home, by being a homebody. developing their character traits, not being involved or interested even in the non-religious world, needless to say, in the non-Jewish world. In previous generations, most of B'not Yisrael did not even go to school. This is only in the last hundred years or so that girls started getting an education in schools and seminaries. Why? There's really no need in the Jewish world for a woman to get a yeshiva education. And many sages
1:01:11We're against it because they thought, and rightly thought in many cases, that it's more trouble than it's worth. Yes, she'll get a lot of education, she'll know how to do a lot of different things, but she'll also become much more modern, which is actually what happened in many places. The girls of today are not the girls of the original Beit Yaakov that were willing to die for the sake of Torah and for Hashem and everything else. Today, girls get education, and all of a sudden, it's not enough for them to learn Mussar, to learn about the halachot of women. They also want to learn Gemara. She also wants to put on tefillin. She wants to be a rabbi like this zona that Manis Friedman interviewed or spoke to just the other day. She has tattoos all over her arms, Hashem yishmor ve'yatzil. She calls herself a rabbi and this moron speaks to her in a video for people to learn from. This type of warped mindset is the result of the educational system where people want more than what they need. Bat Yisrael needs to learn from her mom. That's the main teacher that she's supposed to have in her life.
1:02:20She needs to know how to read. She needs to learn the basics of how to run a house, how to be a righteous person, how to be a modest person. Know, obviously, the basics of the Torah, who our forefathers are, all the halachot that pertain to Shabbat, to kashrut, to running a house, to being a kosher Jew. But there's absolutely no need for her to go learn the skills that are taught in colleges and universities, chas v'shalom, and all of these other things. the basics of the Torah, who our forefathers are, all the halachot that pertain to Shabbat, to kashrut, to running a house, to being a kosher Jew. But there's absolutely no need for her to go learn the skills that are taught in colleges and universities, chas v'shalom, and all of these other things. And even if it's for the sake of getting a job, there are certainly ways to get jobs today and to learn specific skills without attending these impure places. Whether you want to call them Yeshiva University, or you want to call them Harvard, or you want to call them UCLA, it's all the same. They all have places full of homosexuals, liberals, and people that are anti-Torah. Why would you send your daughter, needless to say your son, to such a place? So Dinah is the example that we're all supposed to learn from. Once you get out of those four amot that you're supposed to be in, and start becoming interested in something else, HaKadosh Baruch Hu gave a very strong rebuke. And the reason why Dinah's beauty is not mentioned literally in the Torah, but only in the Midrashim, is because she was extraordinarily beautiful.
1:03:44that is worth mentioning in the Torah is if the beauty did not lead to trouble. The beauty of Sarah did not lead to trouble because she was reserved, she was modest, and Hashem did not let anybody touch her in the wrong way. The beauty of Rachel, the beauty of Rachel was something unbelievable and no one was able to hurt Rachel. The beauty of certain women in the Torah was mentioned. Why? Because it did not lead to bad things. The beauty of Dina did. Hence the reason why it's only mentioned in the Oral Torah. That beauty led her to get attention because she was looking where she wasn't supposed to look. And when the calculations in Shamayim were evaluated, she deserved it. But why did her father deserve it? Because her father... vowed to return to his parents to bring a sacrifice to Hashem as gratitude, which he delayed. He also hid Dina from his brother Esav, which the Midrash says she was supposed to be the woman that actually helps Esav do teshuva. So Hashem rebuked Yaakov, saying, "Oh, if you don't want to use her to get your brother to do teshuva,
1:05:11then we'll have somebody else take her. If you don't want to deliver the sacrifice that you promised on time and you're delaying it, then you're like Esav. This is what Hashem tells Yaakov: if you continue delaying it, you will be punished. And you got punished with the tragedy of your daughter because you didn't keep your word. Because the way that Yaakov was measured, which was with the precision of tzaddikim, That, in essence, brought this. Meaning that a person needs to be careful with the words that come out of their mouth. The divine judgment is very precise. So, it's not just what it all seems. Now, of course, what do we learn from the words themselves where it says that he lay with her, he raped her, but he also tortured her? The Gemara in Masechet Sanhedrin says we learn from Ya'anea that he did, meaning that he was with her both the traditional way and the opposite way. And from there we learn that the bi'ah, the intimate act between a man and a woman
1:06:30man and his wife, it's considered a consummation of the marriage, whether it's from that way or the other way. But needless to say, the one that's the other way is considered the unnatural way, which from there we learn that when a man lays with another man that is considered, when one man lays with another man, like a man lays with a woman, that's considered an unnatural way, an unnatural act, the same thing as an unnatural act between a man and an ox, a man and a cow. In the eyes of God, homosexuality and bestiality are exactly the same. So, Here we see that Dinah goes through hell. Then her brothers murder everybody—Shechem, Chamor, and everybody there. After they make the deal that they're all going to circumcise themselves, what right did Shimon and Levi have to do such a thing? What right did they have? The Chachamim teach us that
1:07:53In the Gemara Masechet Sanhedrin, there's a whole section about it, maybe about almost eight, ten dapim. In Hilchot Melachim, by the Rambam, there are two prakim, and maybe probably around 30, 40 halachot. There is an endless amount of information that B'ezrat Hashem we will do a shiur about one day, about the laws of Noach. The laws of Noach. And after the time of the flood, The laws of Noah became something that not only was an obligation, it was already an obligation before that. It was already an obligation; the first six laws were already obligated at the time of Adam HaRishon. But the people of the world, being born into a world that was already destroyed, accepted upon themselves the laws of Noah. including modesty, even during intimacy, including not worshipping idols, including not eating an animal while it's still alive, not committing adultery, not committing incest, not committing homosexuality, not cursing God, having a court of law. So, Shimon and Levi said, listen, these people from Shechem, they're Noahides.
1:09:18And one of the laws of Noach is to have a court. Now, certainly the whole country knows that he kidnapped our sister, which is a violation of the laws of Noach. Kidnapping is stealing. And yet nobody sent him to court, nobody judged him. And according to those very same laws of Noach, all of them become guilty, just like in Am Yisrael and in the Torah. If you see your brother sin, violating Shabbat, worshipping an idol, committing all types of sex crimes, and so on, and you don't say something, you become guilty of the very same sin. all of them become guilty, just like in Am Yisrael and in the Torah. If you see your brother sin, violating Shabbat, worshipping an idol, committing all types of sexual crimes, and so on, and you don't say something, you become guilty of the very same sin. The same goes for the Noahides. If they see that their brother is sinning, their sister is sinning, and they don't do anything about it, they all become guilty of it. So Shimon and Levi say they all saw this Shechem kidnap our sister and they didn't judge him, didn't bring him to court. They're all guilty. And the one main difference between the judgment of the Noahides
1:10:26by God versus the judgment of the Jews by God is that the judgment of the Jews is different from case to case. Some certain things they do, such as stealing, such as hating somebody, such as, I don't know, eating non-kosher, there are certain punishments, but it's not the death penalty. If they killed somebody, it could be the death penalty. If they worship an idol, it's the death penalty. Homosexuality is the death penalty. Violating Shabbat is the death penalty. Incest is the death penalty and so on. But other things are not necessarily the death penalty. For the Noahides, everything is the death penalty. Violation of any one of the seven mitzvot of Noah is the death penalty. So by them not having a court, they all deserve the death penalty. That was their reason. But the question still remains: if that's the reason, then why didn't Yaakov Avinu, the tzaddik, join them? Why didn't he join them? In fact, the Chachamim say that when they were making the deal with Shechem to go do the brit milah, Yaakov knew that they intended to kill them or to not keep this whole thing. So why is he upset at them later on?
1:11:49So there's different opinions that go back and forth about this with the Ramban, Rashi, the Midrashim, and so on. Ultimately, it was that they did more than was the original plan. The original plan was to kill Shechem and Chamor, the two criminals, the father and the son. Why they did it? he's the one that raped her. He's the one that's keeping her in his house. They're the criminals. The rest of the people, they didn't do anything. That was what Yaakov thought was the plan of Shimon and Levi. And that was the original plan. But when they came back with a bunch of slaves, a bunch of gold, a bunch of everything, and there are bodies everywhere, dead. Everyone knows a huge disaster, an atomic bomb just went off. Yaakov rebukes them, "Why did you do more? Why did you do more once we got there and we saw that they're all idol worshipers?"
1:13:05We saw that they're all criminals anyway. We couldn't control ourselves. It wasn't just about our sister anymore. We just said they're all criminals anyway. That's what the Ramban says. They're all criminals anyway. It wasn't just our sister being their only crime and them not having a court being the only crime. They're all idol worshipers. We murdered all of them. They all went against God. so now Yaakov says to them, "You put me in an uncomfortable position," and then later on it says that the whole world became afraid. The whole world became afraid of Yaakov. Why? There is a sefer, there is a sefer, that's a Midrash. That is called Sefer HaMilchamot, or Milchamot Bnei Yaakov, The Wars of the Sons of Yaakov. The Yalkut Me'am Lo'ez has details of it, and it's in volume 3A. Highly, highly recommended for you to read it for yourself, needless to say, to read it to your kids. There is a whole section at the end of this parasha, Parashat Vayeshev, that talks about...
1:14:18the wars of Yaakov and his children after what happened with Shechem. Why? After what happened with Shechem, all of the other Canaanite nations, which some of them were giants, went to war with the 12 tribes, went to war with Yaakov. And it goes into details of how the 12 tribes Massacre one nation after another. One giant after another. One building after another. Killing 30,000 people a day each. In some cases 5,000, 10,000, 20,000. Literally unbelievable things. Also, it talks about the powers that they had. Supernatural powers from which you can see where all the superhero movies of today got their ideas. These are all concepts that are found in our Torah. So after they massacred everybody, everybody became scared. That's why there was the terror. So now the last question that we have is why did Esav become such a filthy person, an enemy of God? Where the prophet Michah says in the name of Hashem, "I hate Esav, but I love Yaakov. Esav, I hate him." So this is not just our feelings towards Esav; this is what Hashem feels. He hates Esav. That Esav, the only thing that he inherited is literally, he's going to be the powerful one in this world where he has the highest level of impurity.
1:15:31of God, where the prophet Michah says in the name of Hashem, "I hate Esav, but I love Yaakov. Esav, I hate him." So this is not just our feelings towards Esav; this is what Hashem feels. He hates Esav. That Esav, the only thing that he inherited is literally, he's going to be the powerful one in this world where he has the highest level of impurity. which Chachamim said was transferred into Yeshu, into those people, all the missionaries, all the idolaters that are trying to recruit Jews into their idolatry, all of that Tumah, the Pope, and the followers, this is all, Rabotai, part of the battle between Esav and Yaakov, good versus evil. Good being Yaakov, evil being Esav. Why? I mean, if he had such an elevated neshama, So much potential, and then you tell me that he went astray. At the very least, I would need to know: what did he do? What did he do? Is there a place in the Torah that shows what he did? Yes. Where? In this week's parasha. In this week's parasha, in chapter 36, it talks about the offspring of Esav and...
1:16:55His wives, Ada, Oholivama, Basmat. But then if you follow the names, you'll see some unusual things. What will you see? You'll see that the names of two of his wives... Ada and Oholivama used to be called Basmat and Yehudit because they had fake names when they married Esav in order to fool his father into thinking that he was righteous and that they were righteous. Then you see the names of the kids, and you start noticing that there is a problem here. Why? Ada had a kid named Eliphaz. Eliphaz ended up committing adultery with his father-in-law's wife and had a daughter. Then Eliphaz turned his daughter, Timna, into his concubine. In so many words, another wife, his girlfriend. From there, from this incestuous act,
1:18:25Now, if this was the only incest, adultery in the family, it would be one bad thing. But it's not. You see that Korach, Korach who was one of the descendants of Eliphaz, also came. also came from an adulterous act. An incestuous act, actually. Anah, Tzivon, Lotan—quite a few different names are involved in all types of things, where you'll see, for example, in chapter 36, verse 20. You see that it says the sons of Seir, the Horite, were Lotan, Shoval, Tzivon, and Anah. Those were his sons. But then later on, it says the sons of Tzivon, not Seir, were Ayah and Anah. And Chachamim say this is the same Anah. Same Anah. How could it be?
1:19:53that Tzivon, who was the son of Seir, ended up having an incestuous relationship with his mother. Therefore, Anah was his son and his brother. So, when a person sees that the choices of women, choices of relationships, choices of business that came from Esav and his children and his wives, they will find that they were the first to crossbreed animals, which is forbidden for both Jews and Gentiles until this day. It's called kilayim. His son, the one that came up with it was the first one. Anah was the first one to combine the male donkey with the female horse, which brought the mule. Since Anah himself came from incest, this was normal to him, just things that are unnatural, things that are kilayim.
1:21:16So you see that incest and adultery were common practices in the house of Esav. Whether it was his wives being with multiple men or his children or he himself. You see that their business practices, what they did for a living, were certainly crooked. see that when you go into the details of who the names are, you see that there are literally footsteps of disaster, one after another, connected to every single one of them. So now you would say, "Wait a minute. If there's such a disaster, I understand why Hashem turned them into the enemy of Yaakov. But by the same token, why let them exist?" So the last answer is the following: one, because there is a battle between good and evil that has to exist until Mashiach comes. But two, one of the ways that Hashem brings the salvation, brings the special treasures into the world, is by hiding them inside filth. Hence the reason why, like we said last week
1:22:33soul of the Mashiach has been brought into the world and transferred from generation to generation through different strange acts, whether it was the incest between Lot and his daughters, or what seemed like an inappropriate relationship at first—until they got married—between Yehuda and Tamar Or it was what seemed inappropriate at first until later on. Well, obviously the picture is much clearer between David and Batsheva or his grandmother Ruth converting after, you know, everything is strange. When you want to transfer a very precious treasure, the Chachamim say, "cover it with garbage." And one of the Chachamim asked, why did Hashem create Esav? And Hashem says, because I saw... that in the future, there's gonna be Rabbi Meir Baal Hanes. And just for his fame, it was worth it to bring all of Esav and all of the tragedies. And it's not only just Rabbi Meir Baal Hanes, but all of the people that learn his Torah, all of the people that follow in his footsteps. When a person understands that there are going to be different special treasures that are gonna come into the world from that Esav,
1:23:54The only way to rationalize it in our human mind is by understanding that the judgment of G-d, the Divine judgment, is not like ours. This family could be like the family of Lavan, but still have Rivka, Leah, and Rachel. All come from there, in one form or another. We have the children, or the parent, and so on. The sister. If you mean Lavan, Lavan who ends up becoming a Bilaam, Bilaam HaRasha, the enemy of Am Yisrael, the enemy, the nemesis of Moshe Rabbeinu. Chachamim say Bilaam is Lavan, Lavan is Bilaam. But yet, those special sparks of Kedusha came from there. And that is happening until this day where special converts... that are observant of the Torah, abandoning all false beliefs, abandoning all connection to idolatry, abandoning any connection to the actions and behaviors of the nations, and gluing themselves to the Jewish people of today and throughout all the generations. You see that these people, when they truly connect
1:25:08They connect in such a fashion, you forget that they're even converts. You forget that they were ever not connected. Because the truth is, they were always part of us. Many of the neshamot that are coming into the world today through conversion are people that strayed in previous generations, in their previous incarnations, and their punishment was to be reincarnated as non-Jews in order for them to convert to Judaism. The neshamot of the converts were at Mount Sinai. But the path of the convert is never easy. Needless to say, it's not for a normal, you know, natural-born Jew, I should say. So, the Divine judgment is something that's beyond our comprehension. But after we see all of this, and we understand that there is, details, behind the details, behind the details that explain everything, we can then understand the following. When it says that the wicked, when they die, it's good for them. And it's good for society. We understand that because life is not just this world. Life is beyond this world. When a person understands that there is a heaven and a Gehinnom,
1:26:34They understand that the sooner a sinner, a wicked person, is out of this world, certainly it's better for society that doesn't have to suffer from his stealing, his lying, his cheating, and his murder. But it's also good for him because the sooner he stops sinning, the sooner his punishment will end. And perhaps maybe he'll even get another chance to do teshuva by being reincarnated. And even if he's not reincarnated, certainly it's better for him to have his punishment end sooner rather than later. Because the more he sins, the more he'll have to be punished. Even if that means that it's going to be a million years of Gehinnom before the Neshamah is officially destroyed altogether. So it's in his interest, because he chose to be Esav's follower, it's in his interest that he die. It's in his interest that...
1:27:34that the drunk wicked person is not around anymore. But at the same time, it says that wine and sleep are good for him. Why are wine and sleep good for him? Because when he's drunk and sleepy, he's making fewer sins. He's making fewer sins. Certainly, it's better for him Because he doesn't pursue the evil deeds that he typically does when he's clear-minded. The same goes for them being all over the place, dispersal of the wicked people. It's good for them. Why? Because when the wicked people are united, they cause much greater damage. So for them to be separate from each other is certainly better for them. Why? Because if they unite, they'll make more sins and they'll get punished even worse. So it's good for them to be dispersed. Assembly for the wicked is terrible. Like we said, when they combine, they create bigger damage. This unity among certain wicked people out there is not a good thing for them, needless to say for the rest of the world.
1:29:01But even tranquility is not good for them. Why is tranquility not good for the wicked people? Because when a person has peace of mind, he has the ability to think and plan. And when the wicked people plan, they plan bad things. It's better for them to keep busy. work at some factory, go run Google, go run whatever it is that you do. Be busy with work, be busy doing other things. Just don't relax. Why? When you relax, you have master plans that create damage. And the exact opposite is for the righteous. When a person sees these statements initially without understanding the Divine judgment, it looks bad. But when a person sees things from the eyes of the Divine, God, the eyes of the Torah, he sees, ah, if it says so, there has to be a reason. And certainly, those reasons are available to us, at least some of them. Hopefully, this gave us a little bit more clarity on that question and answered the question of the people that
1:30:21have family members that are wicked, you should first try to help them do teshuva, send them videos. But if they're set on being atheists, homosexuals, enemies of God, idolaters, and so on, your best bet is to simply stay away from them. Why? It's better for them, and it's better for you. Because if you stay close to them, eventually they'll affect you. And if they affect you, their punishment will get bigger, and certainly will yours. And that's not something anybody should want. So, Baruch Hashem, I hope that this gave you guys some chizuk. I know this was longer than usual. But, Baruch Hashem, this will cover a very important subject that I know is on the mind of a lot of people. Certainly was something that we learned this week. Baruch Hashem. So now we're going to take a short drink and you guys can start asking questions. Okay. Reminder to everybody, whoever wants to donate for the new movie will enter the raffle to win a tallit, one of the fancy tallits that I just showed you earlier. The amount of money, obviously, certainly is up to you. That's what it is. Okay. First question I see.
1:31:44which are the brachot rishonot and achronot on cereal that has the majority of rice or minority of wheat? Then it's mezonot. Then it's mezonot. There are some kashrut organizations that certify the cereals have on their websites the different blessings for different cereals. I also know that I love—what's his name? One of the Rabbanim, I forget his name, he actually has a write-up about the different blessings for all the different cereals and granola bars and so on. You can find this online. If you can't find it online, you can send me a message on WhatsApp, and if I have it handy, I'll send it to you. Next question, Jack. Let's see, why do Chazal call... he actually has a write-up about the different blessings for all the different cereals and granola bars and so on. You can find this online. If you can't find it online, you can send me a message on WhatsApp, and if I have it handy, I'll send it to you. Next question, Jack. Let's see, why do Chazal call
1:32:55what Rachel did by giving Leah the simanim was a noble act so as not to embarrass her sister, but it's okay to have Yaakov embarrassed and Lavan and all of his buddies in the morning laughing at him? You just can't justify it. You can't justify doing good deeds at someone else's expense. This has everything to do with our shiur. In fact, the very same Midrash... uh if you uh we talked about earlier this very same Midrash but early on in uh it talks about this whole thing oh your question in essence where it's uh first off in a um Midrash Rabbah in Parashat Vayetzei, section 70:18 It says, uh, Yaakov says, there's a pasuk in the Torah, 29:21, where it says that Yaakov says to Lavan, "Deliver my wife, for my term is fulfilled, and I will consort with her." So the Midrash says, what kind of language is this? Who says this to his father-in-law? "Come, bring me your daughter so I can consort with her," meaning I could be intimate with her. What is this? Even criminals don't say such a thing!
1:34:12So certainly this is not what the clear language was, but rather Yaakov was saying, "I am now 84 years old. How do we know? Because when he got the blessing from his father, he was 63." then he stayed 14 years at the yeshiva of Shem and Ever. So that's 77, and he had to wait seven years to marry the daughter of Lavan. So he says, "I'm 84 years old, and I know through prophecy that the 12 tribes have to come from me. So if I don't start now, it's not going to happen. I need to get married right away. We can't delay this." So now, this is when Lavan understood that he had Yaakov in his hands, in so many words. But he needed partners, so what did Lavan do? The Midrash says that Lavan went to the people of the town and said to them, "You know that we used to have a drought; nobody had water until Yaakov..."
1:35:15Yaakov came here and Hashem blessed the water. If you want Yaakov to stay here so the water can stay blessed, you have to help me keep him here. He said, okay, fine. He says, first of all, he wants to marry my daughter. So I have a plan that he's going to marry the other daughter because that way he'll be forced to work for me for another seven years. But I need to make sure that none of you are going to tell him. So all of you have to give me a bunch of money as collateral, as a promise that if you tell, then you lose the money. So everybody that was essentially looking out for their own interest, for Yaakov's blessing to stay, they all joined forces. And then... The Midrash says that during that night, Yaakov was a little bit baffled by how much partying was happening, how many praises he was receiving from all of these people. And they say, well, he asked them, why are you giving me all these blessings? Why are you with me? What is all this? Oh, no, because you're the reason we got blessed with the water and everything else. And they started singing a song to him.
1:36:20uh, started singing a song to him. The Midrash says, in essence, that some of them were trying to hint to Yaakov, "It's Leah, it's Leah, it's not Rachel." They felt bad. uh, or they were, in essence, trying to cover their bases by the fact that they knew that he's gonna, you know, switch the girl. But when he wakes up tomorrow and finds out, he can't blame them. Why? Because we tried to tell you. We can't do it next to Lavan because he would kill us. He's a wizard, he's a sorcerer. But we tried singing to you; you didn't get the hint. That's probably more like it. Either way, this whole plan was a very, very big plan. Then they went with him. they were going to him and his new wife. She was completely covered; he didn't see anything. They shut off his candles. Yaakov says to them, "What are you doing shutting off the candles now? You guys are a bunch of men; there's one girl here." He says, "No, what are you talking about? We're not immodest like your people."
1:37:27are shutting it because that's the way we accepted it upon ourselves already at the time of Noach that anytime a man is with his wife, there has to be darkness. You, on the other hand, and your people, you're not modest. Why? We saw proof. You, uh, you already kissed Rachel when you came here. You're not even married to her. How did you do that? So they switched the flip, or they flipped the script on him. Why? Because they needed it to be dark. So as soon as they cancel the marriage, they can't, they can't see, he can't see her. Then the Midrash says, Yaakov calls Rachel, and Leah signals like she's Rachel. But then in the morning, he sees it's not Rachel, it's Leah. And initially, he's upset. Naturally, he says, "Liar, the daughter of a liar; cheater, the daughter of a cheater; you know, the deceitful one, daughter of a deceitful woman, the daughter of a deceitful man. Didn't I call you Rachel, and you said that it's you?" And Leah says something that, at first, will take you by surprise. What did she say? Leah says to Yaakov...
1:38:54Is there such a thing as a Torah scholar, a talmid chacham, who doesn't have students? I learned from you. I'm your student. I learned from you. You've been here for the last seven years giving divrei Torah to not everybody. I listen. I learned from you. What did you learn from me? You said the story where, in order not to lie to your father and get the blessing because your mom told you to go get the blessing, you wanted to honor her. Right? So, what did you do when your father said Esav? You said Esav is your firstborn. It's not you. I did the same thing. Why? For the same reason you did it. You said... Esav is your firstborn in order not to lie. I said what I said in order not to lie. You did it because you wanted to follow what your mom said, for honoring your parents. I also had to honor my parents. My father told me I have to do this. And this also answers why Rachel did it. She was honoring her father, but even more so, she was also saving her sister from trouble.
1:40:06Meaning that this is not something that she did in order to embarrass Yaakov. And in fact, it didn't embarrass Yaakov because Yaakov was looking to get married for the sake of bringing the 12 tribes. In order to bring the 12 tribes, he had to marry both of them one way or another. He had to marry both of them. he only realized that after the fact. Hence the reason why in a few weeks, when we read the blessings that Yaakov gave to his son Yosef right before he dies, he prays towards the head of the bed and he thanks Hashem The Torah asks, or the Midrash asks, why did he pray to the head of the bed? To thank Hashem for giving him the head of the family, which is Leah. Leah gave him the most children. She gave him six children, which is the combined number of all the other three wives that he had. So, Yaakov initially didn't realize, wait a minute, how could this be? Liar, deceit, this, that. But then when he saw that she brought him a child...
1:41:20He realized this is a blessed marriage. He realized this is what Hashem wanted. Initially, people were making fun of her, saying she's a cheater, she's a liar. But then they all realized when everyone saw the children that were coming, everyone realized, including Yaakov, this is what Hashem wanted the whole time. Now, as far as Rachel is concerned, again, Rachel is also a prophetess. She also knew that the 12 tribes had to come from Yaakov. She also knew that our father commanded her and she had to fulfill the Torah and honor her father. But she also knew that at some point she also had to be one of the wives, and especially since there was mercy from Heaven that she only had to wait an extra week. Because after the marriage of Leah... look at the verses; it says that Lavan says to Yaakov, "You want to stay? You could after the marriage ceremonies are done in seven days, you can marry Rachel," meaning that Yaakov didn't have to wait another seven years; he had to wait seven days. Which, by the way, that's like the Sheva Berachot, the seven blessings you have after marriage. From there, we also learn not only Sheva Berachot but also that you don't combine two celebrations.
1:42:34says that you don't combine a Chol HaMoed with a wedding. Chol HaMoed is you have your wedding at a different time; you don't combine multiple blessings, multiple celebrations. So from there, also, he had to wait one week and then he married Rachel. So it's not like they had to wait another seven years; he just had to work another seven years. But either way, once they saw how it all worked out, they saw that this was literally the hand of God. so there wasn't anything about embarrassing him or hurting him or doing a mitzvah in a way of a sin. She was trying to follow the laws of God by honoring our father, by being forgiving, by being patient, and in essence, by giving the benefit of the doubt and also saving our sister from the embarrassment that she was experiencing because her sister was crying. Her sister was crying because the prophecy they received originally was that Yaakov was going to marry the firstborn, the older of Yitzhak's sons. The firstborn of Yitzhak's sons, Esav, was going to marry her.
1:43:54the youngest of the daughters of Lavan. So when she was crying, she was crying because at that time Esav was the firstborn. So the Maggid of Dubno says that what Leah did is that the prayers she prayed literally overcame the original judgment, overcame the blessings and the prayers of even her sister Rachel, And where Hashem actually allowed Yaakov to become the firstborn when he bought the firstborn rights from Esav. Hence the reason why Leah says that this is a thing. As a rabbi that doesn't have students, I did exactly like you did. You followed your rabbi. You followed your parents. You did everything you did. I did exactly what you did. followed everything. I followed everything that you did, and I also followed the prophecy that we had. The prophecy was that you have to marry the firstborn. You're the firstborn, so I had to marry you. That was my judgment. I was supposed to marry the firstborn; you are the firstborn, that's why I had to marry you. And that's also the reason why Rachel couldn't be the first one to marry him, because she was no longer the firstborn.
1:45:17So that's, again, one of the different Chachamim, whether it's the Midrash from a couple of thousand years ago, or it's the Maggid of Dubno from a few hundred years ago, or others, all combined into one to give us a more complete answer of the righteousness of Hashem and His servants. Next question. My neighbor is marrying off her daughter. Baruch Hashem, she will be having separate dancing at her wedding, Baruch Hashem, but not separate seating. It will be a buffet-style wedding. Is this allowed? Listen, if it's a very frum family, then certainly it's better for it to be separate seating. But if it's not, if it's a baal teshuva wedding, if they're already doing separate dancing, that's already a miracle of miracles. Thank God that this is the case. The only thing I would recommend is to try to make sure that a husband sits next to his wife and his wife sits next to somebody else's wife, not next to somebody else's husband.
1:46:23So the seating should be arranged by the bride and groom or whoever is arranging the wedding, where wives sit next to wives and husbands sit next to husbands. Meaning that even though they're all sitting together at the same table, let's say you have eight seats, each man is sitting right next to his wife on one side and somebody else's husband on the other. he's permitted to sit next to both of them. That certainly is much more ideal. Next question: Rabbi, how is it possible to read in Bereishit 5, "walked with God and that God took him," and not pay more attention to those words? Those words were my first light in Torah. Since then, I've wanted to learn more about Chanoch. What did he do to please Hashem so much? Okay, so there is not much that we can learn from Chanoch. We can learn about Chanoch. And the reason why is because Chanoch was extraordinarily righteous. He got to the highest level of kedusha by secluding himself in a cave.
1:47:41and eliminating any contact with society in order to elevate his neshama by learning Torah, by learning the word of Hashem, and eliminating any possibility of any sin whatsoever. So much so that Hashem decided that if you're so righteous, but you're not delivering this righteousness and teaching anybody this righteousness, there's no purpose for you to stay in the world. So Hashem took Chanoch and turned him into Malach Memtet. Malach Memtet is the highest level angel that is also sometimes called God in the Torah. He's not God, but he's, in essence, one of the angels that speaks on behalf of God. Malach Memtet—we're not allowed to even say his real name. Some people write his name sometimes for some reason. I'm not really sure if they're aware that they're not allowed. He's a very, very holy Malach. That's Chanoch. That's Chanoch. We have no problem saying any word that's mentioned in the written Torah. There's no problem with saying it at any time, obviously aside from the name of Hashem, which you can only say when you're reading the Torah or teaching it. But as far as other things, you can say them. However, there are certain names of angels and also certain names of God that you're not allowed to say under normal conditions and sometimes ever.
1:48:58Either way, Chanoch became so righteous, so holy that he sanctified himself to the point that there was no longer a purpose for him to stay in this world because he wasn't teaching anybody else. And the Gemara says that Avraham Avinu had the ability to be much higher than Chanoch, but he chose to serve Hashem by going to do kiruv. And that actually limited his spiritual growth because he couldn't seclude himself from everybody. In fact, he did the exact opposite. He would invite people. He would teach them Torah. He would convert people to become Noahides. That's what the Gemara says in multiple places, that Avraham Avinu... was converting the men and Sarah was converting the women. What does it mean, converting? There was no Judaism yet. There were Noahide laws. So there were either idol worshippers or Noahides. So Avraham Avinu was getting people to observe the Noahide laws.
1:50:01But because of that, because he was busy with helping people do teshuva, to abandon idolatry, to learn about Gehinnom, that's what the Zohar HaKadosh, Parashat Vayera, says that that's what Avraham Avinu was teaching them. Teaching them about Gehinnom, teaching them about suffering, and what's going to happen to them if they stay idol worshippers. That was the first year he would give people about Gehinnom. First time that he's just met them, they just ate, okay, let me tell you about Gehinnom. That's what the Zohar HaKadosh says. And because of that, because he was spending so much time teaching, he couldn't elevate himself more spiritually to the same extent that would even supersede. But that ended up becoming favorable in the eyes of Hashem because that was actually the ultimate purpose. Hashem doesn't want you to come to this world and just serve yourself and sanctify yourself. He wants you to use the Torah in order to share it with other people. Learn a lot of Torah but also share it too. That's where the Gemara in Masechet Avoda Zara, I believe it's page 17, says that a person that learns Torah and doesn't teach Torah is like a person that doesn't have a God.
1:51:11Meaning that you have to learn from the Torah how to emulate Hashem, be giving. How could you learn His word and not give and not share? So Chanoch wasn't obligated to give because this was before the official giving of the Torah at Mount Sinai, but he was not able to fulfill a purpose beyond what he did because there was no purpose for him in the world. He didn't want to be involved with people. So certainly we can learn about him, what he became, but we can't really learn from him in the sense that a person is not supposed to seclude himself from society to such a point where they know the entire Torah but don't want to share it. A person needs to help people do teshuva, get people to come back to Hashem, like Avraham Avinu did. But as far as one other thing I could say is that there is a book that the Christians love to quote, which they call the Book of Enoch. This is not a book that a Jew is allowed to read for multiple reasons. One of them is because it's not divinely inspired; it was not added to the Tanakh, and there are certain things that are problematic.
1:52:30uh, that a person is not supposed to read it. Of course, the Christian idol worshipers love this book because it makes them feel like they have something extra. But for us, this is nothing extra; these are mistakes that are leading to more mistakes. But needless to say, you know, the Gemara in Masechet Avodah Zarah says, "stolen waters are sweeter." People always want what is unreachable, what is beyond. So now that I said you're not allowed, five people are going to go right away and start reading it. Why? Because people are foolish. They want what they're not allowed to have. Same thing with, sometimes you have, I have to argue with different people that are not ready to convert but they want to observe all the mitzvot. They want to observe Shabbat, they want to live like Jews, but they don't want to convert to being Jews. Or, you know, other things. People always want what they're not allowed to have. there is plenty of Torah, there are plenty of people that davka want to go after what they're not supposed to do, like a ba'al teshuva who wants to go learn Zohar and Kabbalah, or women who want to learn Gemara or Zohar—all types of things. These are things that a person is not supposed to do. The same thing goes with the Book of Chanokh, the Book of Enoch.
1:53:47Certainly, it's not a book for anybody that's watching this show to read, and certainly, it's not a book for anybody else to read. But of course, people can do whatever they want. I'm just simply the messenger. Next question. Are you allowed to eat fruits and vegetables from Israel this year? Can you please explain the rules of Shemitah? The rules of Shemitah are way too detailed for me to give you a show about it right now, especially since it was last year. If the fruits are from now, yeah, it's not a problem. It's not a problem. It was a problem last year. Anything that you're getting right now is typically not a problem. But generally speaking, the exporting of fruit is not such a big business in Israel. They have to keep it for themselves. Whereas most people that are buying fruit today, even if you're buying it in a kosher market, they’re not getting it from Israel. They’re getting it from Texas. They’re getting it from Florida. They’re getting it from California and wherever there’s still water. They’re not getting it from Israel. If a rabbi's answer leaves a talmid with more questions, should the talmid approach their rabbi for further clarification? Will it benefit the talmid to change the way they interpret the world around them to match the rabbi's perspective?
1:55:05Okay, I think I understand what your question is. As far as if a person asks the rabbi a question, and the rabbi gives them an answer, and the answer creates more questions, yes, if the student wants more answers, then he certainly should ask more questions, sure. But again, one thing I always recommend for people that are asking questions is to ask questions that are relevant to your rabbi and not relevant to what somebody else said. Like, don't ask me questions about what some other rabbi said. "Oh, Rabbi, look, he said such and such in this video. Can you tell me why?" I don't know why he said what he said, and I don't have the time to go watch his video. And this is also not really appropriate. So it's like asking your boss about why some other boss gave his employees a raise. It's inappropriate. It's bad manners. So the first thing is, if a person is asking his rabbi a question and his rabbi gave him an answer, and the answer created more questions, certainly you should go back to the same rabbi and ask him more questions. That's not a problem.
1:56:11But he should, number one, make sure that's the case. Number two, do some homework. Meaning, don't be one of these people that expects to be spoon-fed like a baby. Meaning that if you got an answer from the rabbi, and the answer created more questions, do a little work to try to find the answers on your own from different things that the rabbi quoted. If he quoted a Midrash or he quoted a commentary, go open the book or the page that he said, or the other sages, or something to try to find some of the answers on your own because that's going to make you more, you know, more complete. and the answer created more questions, do a little work to try to find the answers on your own from different things that the rabbi quoted. If he quoted a Midrash or he quoted a commentary, go open the book or the page that he said, or the other sages, or something to try to find some of the answers on your own because that's going to make you more, you know, more complete and it's going to force you to learn much more. Many times, people want to be spoon-fed every little bit of information, and what ends up happening is that they end up losing their appreciation for the Torah, and they end up forgetting the Torah because they didn't toil for it. So, what I would recommend is if you got something from the Rabbi already, that's some type of answer. That is certainly a starting stage for you to try to investigate a little bit more on your own. See if you have the divine assistance where Hashem sees now. You asked the question—that's the first base of effort. You've tried looking at, you know, reviewing the answer that you got to investigate more on your own by toiling over the Torah and opening some books.
1:57:33So that in essence gives you the merit for Hashem to show you the answer in different places. Now, after you've searched and you still have some more questions, certainly you should go back to the same Rabbi. "Rabbi, listen, I asked you this question. You gave me this answer. I looked for more information about this answer because I had some other questions. This is what I found." in such and such places, but I still have this other question and I couldn't find the answer. Can you help me with that? That is a fantastic talmid. That is a fantastic student that actually wants to grow to be a talmid chacham and not somebody that wants to be spoon-fed like a baby at 50 years old. So, that's the thing that I would recommend to people. Most people are going to completely forget everything I just said to you and literally delete it from their minds and continue being little spiritual babies, being spoon-fed everything for 50 years. Rabbi, can I eat this? Yes. Rabbi, can I go there? Yes. Rabbi, this? Rabbi, that.
1:58:37Fine, I don't have a problem answering the questions. I know Rabbi has a problem answering questions, but a person has to help themselves in order to grow. That's the thing that a lot of people don't do enough. Why? Because they want fast information, and the outcome of fast information is that it loses its value in the eyes of people. So always ask, but always do homework too. Ask, get answers. You have more questions, which is a natural thing you're supposed to have, meaning your natural inclination should be... that the more you learn, the more questions you have. It literally will never end. It will never end. No subject has an ending in the Torah. No subject. Like whether it's what we learned today, no ending. We can have a shiur from here until a million and a half years more. It will never end. If you go into more sources, more things, more steps, more, more, more. The Torah is wider than the ocean. So in essence, the more developed a talmid is... the more they'll have questions. But again, you also have to ask questions that actually matter to you, questions that are significant. But if a person wants to delve into a subject, literally, they could focus on one particular subject for a million and a half years and they wouldn't finish.
1:59:49But so the key is to try to help yourself and try. Ask the rabbi, get an answer. If you have some more questions, then do some homework. Also, don't be one of these talmidim who do what, unfortunately, they do in many yeshivot, even most yeshivot today, which is what's called pilpulim. Pilpulim, Rav Ovadia and many chachamim, Rav Shach spoke heavily against it, which unfortunately became the way of yeshivot. I'm not really sure But pilpulim is, in essence, creating questions for the sake of creating questions. It's purposeless questions just for the sake of mental stimulation. You already know the answer, but you start asking hypothetical questions or things that are just for the sake of mental stimulation. Don't be one of those. Ask questions with a purpose, ask questions that matter to you, that are going to get to some type of point. So that's the third thing I would say. With the combination of those few steps, certainly a person who would do them and follow those steps will become somebody much more than he or she is now. Next question: If a person is cooking pareve soup and uses a dairy serving spoon, does the pareve pot become pareve or remain pareve, or does it become dairy?
2:01:14Uh, no, it remains pareve. It remains pareve. For it to turn into dairy, it would require a lot of different steps. It would have to boil, in so many words. It remains pareve. Michael, on Monday and Thursday, when the Torah is read as part of the three times per week... that was reinstituted by Ezra, is there an extra holiness or help from heaven available on those days for giving shiurim or studying, for example? I mean, as far as the institution of reading the Torah during those three times, so there's never three days in a row where there's somebody that doesn't learn Torah. So if somebody goes to shul, then they're certainly going to hear the Torah at least every few days. So, that's the reason. As far as their extra holiness, certainly when a person makes more mitzvot, there's more holiness around them, and there are more angels protecting him. So, when a person goes to shul on Monday and Thursday or on Shabbat, they're able to make more mitzvot than they are able to make during the rest of the week because there are extra blessings that are made for the reading of the Torah.
2:02:29uh, so that already gives them additional strength. Further, it also talks about how there are special angels that a person creates every time he does a mitzvah, but even more so when he reads the weekly parasha. So, when a person reads the weekly parasha, whether it's on Monday or on Sunday, he creates angels that will give him a lot more strength. for the entire week. This is the reason why it's better for a person to read the parasha in the earlier part of the week rather than the latter part, as most people do. Those angels give him extra strength to learn more, understand more, and receive more blessings for parnassah and so on. More blessings, more learning, and more Torah are always going to yield more good. Jeremy, if they didn't have the future Torah portions, how can their feeling be kosher? Since we know that Avraham Avinu kept everything, so the Oral Torah is something that was already available since creation and...
2:03:46Hashem created the world by writing the Torah with black fire on white fire. Chazal say it was created 974 generations before He created the world. Now, what does it mean that He wrote the Torah? If He wrote the Torah, that means that He had also the five books of Moses. So how could that be if He already knows the story? Then how did Moshe and the rest of the people have free choice? So the way that Chachamim explained it is that initially, Hashem created the world, He created the Torah by writing the entire written Torah from beginning to end, the same five books of Moses that you have right now, but it was all a single word, meaning there was no separation between the letters. And every single thing that ever existed the past, present, or future was inside those letters, inside that text. But again, it was only a single word, if you will, because there was no separation between the paragraphs, no separation between the words. There was no "Bereishit," there was, you know, there was one word from the beginning all the way to the end of "Zot HaBeracha." Now, after this, this also included all of the rules
2:05:10the rules which include, you know, eating kosher, the rules that include taharat mishpacha. So those rules, that part of the Oral Torah that's within the Written Torah, it's hidden within it, everything is connected to the Written Torah. That part, he gave, that Oral Torah, he gave already to Adam HaRishon. And from there, the Torah was transmitted, the Oral Torah was transmitted from Adam HaRishon to Shet, eventually to Metushelach, Metushelach to Noach, Noach to Shem, and eventually to Avraham, and Avraham to Yitzchak, Yaakov, and so on. The 12 tribes, and then eventually the rest of Am Yisrael. So now, the Oral Torah was available throughout all of that time, and in fact, it was much more extensive. then what we are familiar with today, the Gemara in Masechet Avodah Zarah, says that the tractate of Avodah Zarah that we have today is five chapters, I believe. Five chapters. The tractate of Avodah Zarah that Avraham Avinu had was 400 chapters, and some say it was 600 chapters. Meaning his Oral Torah was much more extensive than ours. Much more extensive. Rabbi Yehuda HaNasi, when he took the Mishnah, he didn't take the entire Mishnah.
2:06:34and all of the Baraitot that existed, he only took some of them. That's why you'll have the Gemara that mentions Baraitot. There are all types of additions in addition to the Mishnah. There are other things that weren't included in the six parts of the Mishnah. The Oral Torah has those six as the core foundation, but there's a whole lot more that was not included. And even before that, there was a lot more at the time of Moshe Rabbeinu, and there's a lot at the time of... Of Rabbi Akiva, there was a lot more. The point being, what we have today is the essence of Torah. The essence of Torah. And it's not even the same level of essence as the previous generations of Rabbi Akiva and his 24,000 students. We don't have the Torah of the 24,000 students. We have the Torah of the five students that he had to restart everything with: Rabbi Shimon Bar Yochai, Rabbi Meir, Rabbi Yehuda, Rabbi Yose, and Rabbi Elazar ben Shamua. Rabbi Meir Baal HaNes, Rabbi Yose, Rabbi Yehuda. So we have a handful of students. The 24,000 students that died, we don't have their Torah.
2:07:40So we only have parts of the teachings of Rabbi Akiva, but we have almost nothing of the Zugot, Shemaya and Avtalyon, the Antigonos Ish Socho, all of the great sages that are mentioned in Pirkei Avot. Most of them, we don't have their teachings. Needless to say, we don't have all the detailed teachings of David HaMelech, of the... The other prophets that preceded them, the Torah of Moshe Rabbeinu, you know, we have, or his generation, we have. Again, we have the five books of Moses, but the oral aspect of development that happened in previous generations is much, much more than what we have today. So now, that Oral Torah already was from the beginning; therefore, Avraham Avinu was able to use the Book of Creation... in order to create things, create cows, create every, you know, on demand, create all types of things. The Gemara in Masechet Sanhedrin also mentions certain Chachamim who used to create a calf every Friday in order to eat on Shabbat. There was a certain Chacham, a certain Tanna, who created a person to help him do things, like a servant. But then another Chacham killed him.
2:08:56There's also one of the Chachamim from just a few hundred years ago, the Maharal of Prague, who made a golem, creating a person. But they can't speak, though. To speak is only possible for someone who has a neshama. Either way, there are certain teachings that are part of the Oral Torah that have always been and still are here. uh, you need to know how to use them. But the point being is that part Avraham Avinu had, and this is the reason the Zohar says so. Since Avraham Avinu had all of this, he also had the fact that a Noachide is forbidden from keeping Shabbat. So what did he do? How could he keep Shabbat and not keep Shabbat? So the Zohar says Avraham would create a cow every Shabbat in order to break Shabbat. That was the way he would, that's the way he would break Shabbat. By creating something. You don't have to create on Shabbat. He would create a cow every Shabbat. So when you tell people today who are not Jewish that they're not allowed to keep Shabbat, they're like, "No, no, Avraham is my forefather." No, Shabbat was not given to everybody. It's very frustrating because they have no idea. They have no idea that even if they want to say all the things that they want to say, they're still not following the law. Avraham Avinu didn't keep Shabbat to the same extent as a Jew keeps Shabbat now because he wasn't allowed.
2:10:17But as far as the other things that he was allowed to keep, having a mezuzah, having tefillin, all those other things, there was knowledge of those things. Again, the mitzvah of tefillin doesn't say things that are part of the narration of a story that didn't exist. It's not like, for example, something that happened, a conversation that happened between Moshe and Paro. So you know when you read this mitzvah, it's in essence Hashem commanding us to love Him with all of your heart, with all of your soul, with all of your resources. And then, if you don't do it and you worship idols, then Hashem will bring suffering, damage, disaster, famine, death, horrible Gehinnom in this world. I honestly don't understand how people are not scared to death just by reading mitzvah and uh, people say, "Oh no, I don't believe in punishment." Do you realize that Gehinnom is scarier than death? I don't know what people are reading these days, but anyway, so that's not a problem to have it, uh, and in the feeling at the time of Avraham Avinu. But again, there is the bigger part to understand that the written part of the Torah, that written part of the Torah, already existed from the beginning, but it was a single word.
2:11:41did it get separated over time when Hashem gave, uh, uh, uh, uh, when at Mount Sinai when, uh, it's spoken about in the parsha, and, uh, Hashem gives the Torah to Moshe, and He tells him where to separate the words, so you know, the Torah starts with the Bet because Aleph is only Hashem. Then you have Bet, Resh, Aleph, Shin, Yud, Tav. So you have a Tav, stop, put a space. Bereshit. Okay, then you have Aleph, Bet, Resh, Aleph. Okay, stop over there, separate. Okay, Elohim, then Yud, Kei, Vav, Kei. Stop, separate, and He tells him, okay, after seven words, after seven words, stop the sentence. That's the end of the sentence. That's the end of the sentence. Bereishit is wisdom. The reason why that sentence has stops after seven words is to remind you that Hashem created the world in six days and stopped on the seventh. Seven represents many different things. The point being is every single detail
2:13:00not only where to separate the sentences, but the vowels that are used, the sounds that are made, the reason why there is a certain amount of letters in every word, why every sentence is. Hashem decided for it to start with a specific letter versus a different letter, where it seems superfluous for it to be there, it seems extra to be there. All of those details were taught to Moshe Rabbeinu because he received the entire Torah. what we received at Mount Sinai as a people is the essence of the Torah, and the essence of the Torah included both the written Torah and the Oral Torah. However, the Oral Torah had to be developed further through study in order to make us partners in the Torah. Hashem left certain things for us to develop. simply things that are not finished. Certain things are finished; they're called, in the language of the Gemara, a halacha l'Moshe mi'Sinai, which is a law that doesn't even require a verse in the Torah. This is the law, for example, the laws of tefillin. There are nearly a thousand relating to tefillin, and there is the fact that tefillin will always be black.
2:14:15Square, uh, you know, from a kosher animal, and so on and so forth. Many of these dinim, many of these laws, are not related to specific verses. They're called "halacha l'Moshe mi'Sinai," meaning we have verses that tell us that we have to have tefillin, to put them on our head, put them on our arm next to our heart, but certain details... have always been known because this is what we got from Moshe Rabbeinu. It does not require a verse. There are certain laws that do require a verse. Then there are certain laws that have to be developed over time through toil because they cannot be answered before the question actually exists. So this is the part that Hashem, in essence, gave the Chachamim the opportunity to be partners, just like He gave Am Yisrael the opportunity to be partners in the physical creation by giving us the mitzvah of brit milah. A baby is born with the foreskin, and in order to become a partner with Hashem in the physical creation, we perform a circumcision, a brit milah. Why didn't Hashem just create us all like Moshe Rabbeinu or like Adam, without a foreskin? Because He wanted us to be partners in the physical creation.
2:15:36part is in the physical creation by, in essence, creating us imperfect. And by having the Brit Milah, we become perfect. Same concept as the Torah, where Hashem gave us a Torah that has to be developed through further study. It has to be developed by the Chachamim, and there was a certain power, in essence, given to the Chachamim. There are verses in the Torah that represent that. The point being is that there are certain things that Avraham Avinu and the previous generations had, that is beyond the scope of anything that's available today. It's only going to be available once Mashiach comes. There is even a Torah that nobody ever had. which is the Torah of Shamayim, which is what people will learn when they go up to Shamayim, if they have the merit. There's a certain Torah that doesn't exist right now, meaning nobody can see it in this world. Nobody has seen it. It's only Torah that's in Shamayim. And again, they ask, what does Hashem do? What does Hashem do? He toils in Torah. There's a certain time of the day that He runs the world, judges the world, and there's a certain time of the day that Hashem toils in Torah.
2:16:43What is He toiling? Beyond our comprehension. Beyond our comprehension. So that's that. Now you guys are asking some big questions today. How do you... save the Orthodox Jew from homosexuality. If he's an Orthodox Jew, then he's certainly not going to be homosexual. But if he has, you know, a person who is attracted to the same gender, then certainly that person needs to learn more Mussar to understand the will of Hashem and the punishment for when a person does not go according to the will of Hashem. I would also recommend for them to read different parts of the Gemara in Masechet Sanhedrin that talk about homosexuality and what Hashem thinks of it and what kind of punishments they are going to get. There is a... Let me see where it is. One second. In Masechet Sanhedrin, daf 54a, it continues for a while, talking about homosexuality and bestiality, how it is unnatural, and so on. So certainly, that can help in learning about how it is not only forbidden, but at the time of the Sanhedrin, a person would get a death penalty.
2:17:59page 54a, and it continues for a while, talks about homosexuality and bestiality, how it's unnatural, and so on. So certainly, that can help in learning about how it is not only forbidden, but at the time of the Sanhedrin, a person would get a death penalty. uh from it the worst type of death penalty. Nonetheless, today, when a person acts on homosexuality, they are, in essence, giving themselves karet and also a divine death penalty, meaning that they are guaranteeing themselves that they will die young. meaning earlier than they're supposed to. If originally they were allotted, let's say, 120 years, they're going to die before the age of 50 or 60. They're also guaranteeing themselves that if they have kids, those kids are likely to die. They are guaranteeing themselves that they will lose money and have a troubled life, to say the least. Also, after this life is over, they'll go to Gehinnom, and they won't come out. So they'll, in essence, be guaranteeing themselves hell on earth and after.
2:19:05So the more a person learns about how much Hashem detests homosexuality by learning the parts of the Gemara that talk about it, by learning the shiurim that we talked about, that have multiple shiurim that talk about homosexuality, the more a person learns these things, alongside learning about the issues of Kedushah, of Tikun HaBrit, the more a person is going to sanctify themselves. Typically, the person today that has this issue, it's because they were already an immoral person. Before they so-called discovered they're homosexual, they were already a promiscuous person, even if that promiscuity came from themselves. uh and we'll learn actually in next week's parasha about the issue of onanism, the issue of wasting seed, that the first two sons of Yehuda sinned with. Yehuda's first son sinned with what's called onanism, named after his first son, Onan.
2:20:13and they wasted seed despite the fact that they were married. Hashem killed both of them, showing us that this obligation of protecting your brit and not wasting seed and not being promiscuous is an obligation both on Jews and Gentiles, even if that promiscuity is with yourself. Now, what ends up happening is when people are promiscuous with themselves or with others it creates an impure spirit that falls upon them and leads them to become more inclined to commit more sins. The more they sin, the stronger the yetzer hara has control over them, inclining them to do something even more taboo. So much so that Ramban (Nachmanides) and also other rabbis bring different sources from the Torah and the Gemara that say that this is where homosexuality and bestiality begin with. Eventually, he is with himself, then he is with the opposite gender in a promiscuous way, without marriage, without purity. Then he is promiscuous with multiple women, and when that's no longer enough, he wants to be with men, the same gender. When that's no longer enough, eventually he's going to go with animals. And this is something that we've seen in society; we've seen
2:21:33in the world. It is not a big secret that there are literally millions and millions of people that have become so promiscuous that they literally are with animals, they're with the same gender, they're pedophiles. There are so many immoral things that are happening in the world today that it's literally become a standard, a standard that you know the topic of conversation, and what they're trying to do today is they're actually trying to normalize the most immoral, horrible things in the world. Like, there's one, you know, wicked, wicked person who used to be a professor at a university who wrote a book about how we should change the description of pedophilia to "attraction to minors." And how it's not really such a big deal; it's just that you're attracted to kids. Sick people.
2:22:33Now again, if you look at the Gemara, you look at the Midrashim, you'll see that some of the previous generation, the most righteous people in the world, married at very young ages. You know, David HaMelech married Bat Sheva. Bat Sheva was six years old. You know, Rivka was three years old. The different tzaddikim and tzaddikot were very, very young. But again, the body was different physically back then. The world was different, very different back then. Everything was different. You cannot compare us today to those times of three, four thousand years ago. ...that's already discussed by the sages, that, you know, it's an enigma. You know, a person who goes with a child is a criminal. Pedophilia is forbidden. You know, it's not something that could be compared to King David... and so on. But the point being is that today people want to pretend as if we are in the same physiological shape as we were back then, as if it's perfectly normal. Pedophilia is not normal,
2:23:45rape is normal, homosexuality is normal, all the filthiest things are normal, and now also bestiality, which is people with animals, is also normalizing. This is something that we had to do research on at some point as part of the research on this whole Tikkun HaBrit stuff, and the issues of bestiality have grown exponentially over the years. There are literally countries countries that have bestiality as a normal part of their society to the point that it has changed the physical makeup of the people to a certain extent. For example, Brazil. Brazil is known as a very promiscuous state. What a lot of people don't know is that there is an enormous amount of bestiality in Brazil. Enormous amount, so much so that the highest rate of erectile cancer is there, also dysfunctioning and so on. There is an enormous amount of bestiality in the Arab countries with donkeys and sheep. There's a lot of bestiality in America. There's at least three, four million people that admit to being with animals on a regular basis. is there, also dysfunctioning and so on. There is an enormous amount of bestiality in the Arab countries with donkeys and sheep. There's a lot of bestiality in America. There are at least three to four million people who admit to being with animals on a regular basis.
2:25:00There are even hotels that cater to these sick people in Las Vegas and other places in the United States. There are places in different European countries that literally have hotels and all types of gatherings, highlighting this filth of people with animals. And, of course, there's always an article or two that you'll find on the internet here and there about some sick person that married his puppy, or her horse, or some other crazy person that ended up getting killed as a result of that. When they found the dead body, they found a dead body, you know, in the middle of shem yishmor, an act. highlighting this filth of people with animals. And, of course, there's always an article or two that you'll find on the internet here and there about some sick person that married his puppy, or her horse, or some other crazy person that ended up getting killed as a result of that. When they found the dead body, they found a dead body, you know, in the middle of shem yishmor, an act with their animal, and this is something that you know is a horrible thing for society, not only because of the immorality aspect of it and the disgustingness of it, but also it shows us how far we are from where we need to be. Needless to say, it also harms the animals. The animals many times become infertile at that point; they're no longer able to breed.
2:26:08Point being is that this is part of what's happening in the world today, and it all starts with the individual. The individual that is not rebuked when he tells people that are important to him, people that are familiar with him, people that are in a position of knowledge that he has or she has unusual feelings to something that's forbidden, something that's not the normal way. They're not attracted to the opposite gender; they're attracted to the same gender. Those people accept that person as is, and even give them support, thus enabling it. enablement that this person now says, "Oh, since everybody accepted me coming out of my tomb or closet or whatever it is, you know, then it's a, um, I'll continue expressing myself." And these people end up ruining their lives. Some of them, you know, transform themselves and
2:27:14into different things, and of course, you know, the spiritual impurity that's on those people is going to tell them, "This is the way you always were; you already knew this when you were five; you already felt this when you were this" There's fairy tales. But the point being is that, yes, is there a person that's attracted to the same gender? It's not an attraction, it's simply being more connected to somebody because of having more in common with them, where a male is more feminine or a woman is more masculine. But as far as this, you know, even if a person wants to say there is an attraction there, even if there's an attraction, it still doesn't permit it. Why? You're attracted to somebody else's wife. Does that permit you to go sleep with her? No. You're attracted to some dog. You're attracted to fire. You like to burn things up. You're a pyromaniac. Does that mean you're allowed to do it? No. You're attracted to murder. You like to see blood. King David liked to see blood. King David was a red-haired genius and he also was born at a certain time that he was attracted to blood.
2:28:24like a salve. A salve picked murder. King David picked doing brit milah, being a mohel, and also being the rabbi that was an expert in taharat hamishpacha. So the women would bring him any time they had questions of taharah. So there are certain people that are attracted to certain things. No problem. There is a way to do things in a kosher way. Just because you're attracted to something doesn't mean that whatever you're attracted to is allowed. So a person needs to know what's allowed, what's not allowed. And if the Torah says it's not allowed, it doesn't make a difference that you're attracted to it or not. You have to find a way to do something that will give you the same fulfillment in a permissible way. In a permissible way. And b'ezrat Hashem, if this person... at the very least, listens to what I just said over the last 10-15 minutes and watches some of the shiurim that I made about the topic, they could very well end up being like the same person who wrote a letter on our website a few years ago. When I met him, he was homosexual and believed that homosexuality was normal as a teenager.
2:29:33And Baruch Hashem, today he is a Talmid Chacham, learns Torah every single day, a Frum Jew, a Tzadik Kadosh, Kodesh Kodashim. It's somebody that I wish for any one of us, myself included, for our daughters to marry such a person. But this person used to think, ten years ago or less, that homosexuality was perfectly normal. today you meet this person, you're not even going to have a thought that this is the case. Why? The person sanctified himself. And he wrote a letter. He wrote a letter on the website. Certainly, it's something that gave chizuk to some of my other students that had this issue. And I sent it to them, and they read it, and they all said that they got chizuk from the letter, that they know now it's possible. Through learning Torah, that has an emphasis on Mussar. And obviously Mussar includes Tikkun HaBrit and all the other things that we teach. But this certainly is a curable spiritual ailment. But if you tell them, "I love you anyway, I accept you no matter what you do," you have murdered him with your own hands. You've murdered him or her with your own hands. Why? Because you simply gave them permission to do whatever they want.
2:30:50And I know that this is the fashion in the world today, but that's also why those very same parents regret the day they were born later on in life, when those kids don't bring them grandchildren, when those kids continue acting weirder and weirder all the time, when those kids end up becoming an embarrassment to the family, even for those parents that pretend like they're proud of their kid who has a boyfriend and he's a boy. i promise you that if he didn't have a boyfriend and he had a wife instead, those parents would be much happier. Nobody's happy with a homosexual child or anything like that; they just want to pretend. Uh, next, can you say over water and have in mind they've washed them off all of the loved ones that are needed? Sure, yes, this is segulah. school out to change the decree, uh, uh, that's a bad decree by saying the blessing of shehakol. Yes, good question. All right, let's see, uh
2:32:10I was just told Christians divorced Judaism. The original Christians were Jews. But then they went further and further into complete idolatry. Anyone that follows the words of the New Testament is an idol worshiper. There’s no... because the New Testament itself... is forbidden. Number one, it's forbidden because it says that God is three and not one. Number two, it contradicts the Written Torah. Number four, it is anti-Semitic and against the Jews, especially when it talks about how Jews are the sons of Satan and all types of other nonsense. or that at the end of days only 144,000 Jews will survive, only people that worship Yeshu. But last but not least, it's also prohibited for anyone to start a new religion. So Christianity and Islam are prohibited according to the Torah. The only thing that's allowed in the world is for someone to either be Jewish or a righteous Noahide. No one has permission to start a new religion.
2:33:21This is also the reason why, as far as observing Shabbat, if you look at the Rambam on it for Noahides, not only are Noahides forbidden from observing Shabbat like Jews on Shabbat, but they're also forbidden from observing Shabbat on any other day. Meaning they can't turn a Tuesday into Shabbat and observe that Tuesday like a Shabbat of a Jew. That's prohibited because that's creating a new religion. question: What are your current views on art school, especially for yeshiva boys who have learned for a solid few years in yeshiva and want to be able to learn without English? There are also other perushim (commentaries) other than Tosafot and Rashi, so could you explain this? I've discussed art school in the past. I think art school is one of the greatest gifts that was brought to this generation. I think that most yeshiva bachurim today that learn in yeshiva are not really toiling in Torah to the point where
2:34:28They're going to double-check. They're going to protect their berakha. They're going to work on their middot. They're going to have yirat Shamayim. They're going to have kavod for the rabbanim, and they're not going to really, really toil like some of these bachurim we might know in Israel. But not all of them, just some. The average bachur that I've met in America cannot read Gemara without English because more times than not, they arrive at the wrong conclusion, and I've met guys that are even in America who still don't know how to read and arrive at the right conclusion like they would when they read in English. So, the point of the Gemara and the entire Oral Torah in general is for you to understand what it says. It's not like the Written Torah, the Five Books of Moses, where there's a special significance in actually reading the words in Hebrew. the main purpose is for you to understand what it says. So, if English, French, Spanish, Arabic, or whatever other language there is out there is going to help you understand what it says, then certainly it behooves you to read it in that language. Now, if a person
2:35:38wants to read it in the Hebrew-Aramaic language of the Gemara, by all means, they can. But I would still recommend that when they do arrive at their conclusion, they double-check. Unless they have a rabbi in front of them who is a Talmid Chacham, who has completed Shas, and who knows what he's talking about. ...but if they're just studying on their own, I highly, highly recommend for people to learn from ArtScroll and not from the other types that are out there, simply because the G'dolei Hador backed ArtScroll. Rabbi Moshe Feinstein, Rabbi David Feinstein, many of the Gedolim backed ArtScroll... Some of the other things that are out there, they may have some good things in them, but they were not backed by G'dolei HaDor. As Rabbi Akiva says, Am Yisrael is like a dove, and the wings are our Chachamim. If we don't follow our sages, we don't follow our Chachamim, we're a dove without wings, we're going to die. So when you have G'dolei HaDor, like Rabbi Moshe Feinstein, Rabbi David Feinstein, and other giants such as Rabbi Elyashiv, all the giants that backed ArtScroll...
2:36:40and you have tzaddikim that have been behind it since day one, why go anywhere else? Now, certainly, ArtScroll has also other things they're developing, such as the Tosafot they now have in English, and they have a Chumash with Gemara in it. They have a lot of different things. If a person simply delved into Torah day and night, they wouldn't finish all the books that ArtScroll has already translated into English anytime in the near future. Needless to say, all the books they haven't translated. So instead of making the language such a priority, I would highly recommend that people make the Torah a priority. And I think that many people lose themselves in the language part of it, and they force themselves to learn in a language they don't understand. And quite frankly, I've met some bachurim that have gone to yeshiva, 17, 18, 19 years old, 20 years old, 25 years old, I ask them, "What are you learning?" And this is not one time, two times, five times, or ten times. A bunch of times. I ask them, "What are you learning?" "Oh, I'm learning Gemara such and such." "Okay, great. Tell me something about what you're learning." Nothing. Silence. You can hear the silence. Or if they tell you something, it's wrong. More times than not. Of course, once in a while, there's a diamond in the rough. But many people simply are not understanding it. They're not understanding it. And also, quite frankly...
2:38:05The style of learning today is frowned upon by many of Gedolei Yisrael, Rav Ovadia, Rav Elyashiv, many of the Chachamim of the previous generation. We're against the way that people learn Gemara today, which is they learn it in such a fashion where it's with such an investigation into every word and pilpulim, and going into it that literally it takes them days or months to complete a single page. To complete a single page, which ends up happening is that the average person takes two, three years or more to complete a single masechet. They'll study three, four, five hours just to complete three lines in the Gemara. And they think, "Oh yeah, I learned Torah today." Bitul Torah, not learning Torah. Bitul Torah. be surprised if anybody's even going to get a mitzvah for what they're doing. Why? Four hours, two lines, intentionally three years, one masechet. After you've already been learning Torah for 10, 15 years, when are you going to finish the Shas? When are you going to live, like, 1200 years? When are you going to finish Shas?
2:39:21go learn, learn the ArtScroll, unless you're a baki in the language itself, and you understand it like you understand English, go learn it, understand it, see the commentary, finish the Shas a few times, then learn it with Tosafot, you know, initially you learn it with Rashi, then, after you finish it a couple of times, you can learn it also with Tosafot. You can learn it with some Rishonim and so on, but initially, learn and understand what it says. Learn, no, no, no, we're really going and investigating deeply into it, and I know it took me two years to finish Masechet... but I did it with my rabbi, and I really understand everything. Okay, buddy. By the way, what's the next Masechet? Let's say it's Masechet Shabbat. By the time you get to the halfway point of Masechet Shabbat, which is probably in five years from now, according to that pace, you'll figure out that what you understood in Masechet Berachot was wrong until you got to Masechet Shabbat. And guess what? By the time you get to that same half of Masechet Shabbat, you'll realize that you need to learn Masechet Avodah Zarah in order to understand Masechet Shabbat. But you're not going to get to Masechet Avodah Zarah even for another 15 years. Why? Because the Torah is a nervous system. You need everything. And if you take too much time...
2:40:42you're never gonna finish, never gonna do anything, never gonna know anything. And guess what? Even by the time you get to that answer or anything else that's out there, guess what? That content that you spent two, three, four, five, six, seven thousand years learning, you forgot it already. You forgot already. This is the reason why there are so many people that, even though they've been learning Torah for 20 years of their life, they don't know anything. don't know anything. ArtScroll is a gift to the generation, giving people an ability to learn the pshat in a correct manner and then be able to build upon it as much as you want. But first, learn the correct foundation. People are so arrogant they refuse to change. Even when spoke against it, they don't say anything. I have a friend who wrote about it in one of his responsa, and after the Israel—I think it's Perek Aleph, yeah, Aleph—I think he spoke about it, bringing many sources of how many of the Gedolim were against this form of learning that's standard in the world. So, what I tell kids that are going to yeshiva today in their yeshiva...
2:42:01Rosh Yeshiva forces him to study in this fashion where it's like, you know, like a turtle that's reading upside down while he's in the shell, then listen to the rabbi, do what he says, but as soon as you have a break for lunch, as soon as you have a break for whatever, as soon as you go home, on the way home, open an Artscroll, read as much as possible. Learn as much as possible outside of the seder. Why? That's what's going to become you. The stuff you're learning over there is not going to help you in life. Maybe you're going to learn a few things about how to do certain things, but the content—you're never going to get to real significant content. You're never going to finish the Shas. is what's going to end up happening is that you're going to have what's happening in the world today. You have a bunch of kids, a bunch of guys 20, 25, 30 years old in America, never completed the Shas one time. But there's baalabatim that work nine to five, work eight to eight, but they would study a daf yomi, daf yomi. They're not obviously going into every detail, but they learn daf yomi an hour a day.
2:43:04finish the Shas every seven years. So what ends up happening is this Baal HaBayit goes to the Beit Knesset and he doesn't have any respect for the rabbi. Why? The rabbi is still on Masechet, uh, I don't know, he's unknown. He's still halfway through the Shas, even though he's already 50, 60 years old. But this Baal HaBayit, he finishes the Shas. In his mind, he thinks he's bigger than the rabbi. He doesn't realize the rabbi obviously usually learned a lot more than just that. But that's the point. People have to understand. It's necessary for you to learn the entire Talmud multiple times throughout your whole life. And the traditional way it's being done today, it is simply not possible. Simply not possible. ArtScroll has enabled people to complete it. If it wasn't for them, I can promise you many, many tens of thousands of Jews would not even be learning Torah today. Needless to say, finishing the Talmud and becoming Talmidei Chachamim and so on. And again, anyone that knows anything about Torah, anything about Torah, knows that there are Chachamim from the previous generations that wrote their books in different languages.
2:44:17the Talmud itself, the Talmud itself, you'll see, the Talmud itself, part of it is in Aramaic. Why did they write in Aramaic? Why isn't all of it in Hebrew? Because the language of the day was Aramaic. Meaning that if the language was so important for you to read it in the holy language, then why is half of it in Aramaic? Let all of it be in Hebrew, or none of it in Aramaic. If the language was so significant, then why did some Chachamim write their books in French? Arabic and many other languages. Why? Because when it comes to the Oral Torah, the key is to understand. Very, very few things outside of the Written Torah have to be read in the holy language only. You know, things from the Kabbalah, the Zohar, the Rambam—few things, but generally speaking... it's a known thing that a person needs to read the Oral Torah in his first language when it's possible. It's not possible. It's not possible. I wish that, you know, ArtScroll would replicate itself and, you know, translate every book that was ever written in any language that's in the Torah.
2:45:38uh, but, uh, you know, because certainly there are other people who are trying to do something similar, but many times you find that the translations are not reliable or the commentaries they use are not reliable or a combination thereof. For example, I've spoken out against Sefaria a few times, even though they provide a service that I think has benefits to it. They provide a lot of translations that nobody else has translated. But unfortunately, unless you are somewhat Torah knowledgeable and have Yirat Shamayim, there are certain traps within their translations and commentaries that if a person is not aware, they could literally be learning things that are heretical, things that are a part of idolatry. Like in Pirkei de-Rabbi Eliezer, they have commentary from Christianity. uh, in other places, they have all types of strange things that are forbidden. Now, of course, the majority of what I've seen is good, but many times there are problems there. So that's the key. Whereas ArtScroll, they're from ultra frum Jews. One time, I remember I heard a story from them
2:46:49that, uh, from one of their founders, uh, that, uh, there was a person that they hired to, uh, to, uh, uh, translate, um, I don't know what, it was one of the, uh, one of the, uh, great, uh, books of Judaism, and maybe it was the Prophets or something, something significant And when this person translated, they paid him; it was a big job. And then, when they got the translation, they saw that he added a few tidbits of his own as far as the commentary. And in one place, he wrote, "Rashi is wrong." Meaning, he decided Rashi is wrong. They are frum Jews, they are tzaddikim. What did they do? They paid the guy the money, they took his job, and they threw it in the garbage. Why? Anyone that says Rashi is wrong clearly does not have Yirat Shamayim, clearly is not someone that you can rely on for anything. You can't learn his Torah, you can't read his Torah, you can't do anything. Why? We have a tradition. Rashi is part of that tradition that is staying there, and without Rashi, we cannot take one step right or one step left either in the Written Torah or the Oral Torah.
2:48:04Rashi is across the entire Talmud. He gave the commentary on the Talmud before even the Tanakh. You cannot even understand a single word without Rashi, needless to say, show me one person that could actually interpret a verse the correct way without Rashi. It's impossible. Why? Because there are traditions. There are traditions. There's something that people are not aware of. So, the point is that when someone is willing to lose that much money because they paid the guy, And not even tried to edit the work. They just simply threw it out and started all over with somebody else. A whole new payment. Meaning that they had to pay double, practically or more, to get someone with yirat shamayim to do the job. When someone is willing to do that and not during the times when they made zillions. We're talking about during the early stages. where we're still struggling to make ends meet, still struggling to pay checks, and so on. When you have that kind of yirat shamayim, I am happy to learn your Torah, to promote your Torah, to even sit next to you. It's amazing.
2:49:19Now again, I don't know anybody there on a personal basis. All I know is that it's a gift to the world I've benefited from. Many of my students have benefited from it. And any opportunity that I have, I tell people this is the most reliable translation that I've seen, commentaries that I've seen. And Baruch Hashem, I was born in Israel. I speak Hebrew. So I can understand certain things when I see there are certain issues, there are certain mistakes, there are certain... I see. And, Baruch Hashem, it's a person that studies. Artscroll has something to rely on. Is it something that a person should give up on just for the sake of building the language? I don't see the benefit in it. Because either way, even if you learn Artscroll, you're going to end up learning the other languages over time anyway, so I don't see the benefit outweighing the other benefits of actually learning more Torah. Because quite frankly, I see a lot of bachurim today—I have students that are with me two, three years—they already know more than them. Guys that are learning Torah for two or three years know a lot more than some of these bachurim that are in kollelim.
2:50:38And it's not like, oh, these guys are geniuses. I don't know. Regular people. Regular people learn every day, commit a few hours a day to learning Torah. They already know more than some of these bachurim in yeshivot, more than some of these people that have been learning for 10, 20, 30 years. Why? Again, I think it's a mistake. There's a mistake that's being made. And, you know, this creates more people to follow the right footsteps rather than create more, you know, Oh, you're against this, you're against that. What do I benefit out of it? You think I want to get commissioned out of an art school? I'm telling you guys to learn as I'm telling you. Okay, wow, we're almost at three hours, guys. I still have another shiur to do in Hebrew. Okay, how can we answer that question? Ready?
2:51:39I just found out my genetic roots of the Jewish family tree is DNA. A Jew is not determined by DNA; it's determined by halacha, the laws. Question: Is it simply a lack of fear of Hashem if one falls to their desire even though they know it's a sin? Or is there something else lacking in that person who sins knowingly and cannot control themselves? Well, it's certainly a lack of fear of Hashem. And it is also a certain lust that they have for something. It's both. Of course, if they had the right amount of fear of Hashem, they wouldn't even move the wrong way. But we're not on that level. So they also have to overcome some of these other things. Okay, guys, I need to contain myself a little bit, even though I would love to stay with you guys and learn some more. I think that I need to rest a little bit before my next shiur. If I don't have another shiur, I'll probably go on for a little longer. Baruch Hashem. You guys are asking good questions. Okay, another question. To my understanding, Rabbi Mizrachi, from someone I heard, says it's allowed. It's confusing. I have no idea what you're talking about. I'm sorry. Uh...
2:52:57Let's see. Oh, okay, okay. All right. So I think I did answer all the questions. Where to donate? Donate on bezratHashem.org or bhyeshiva.org or bh... donate at bezratHashem.org, or bhyeshiva.org, or donate on the Facebook page. You could also donate on YouTube now. You could donate on YouTube. You could also even set up a monthly donation, but it's not really a subscription. It's just a donation that's monthly for $20 or $50, whatever you choose. You get little gifts for it, like different stickers. You could even donate on our app. There's plenty of ways to donate if you really want to donate, if you want to donate by sending a check. I always tell people it's best to donate online instead of sending checks because if you have the desire to do a mitzvah, the sooner the better. Rather than sending a check and waiting for the mail and changing your mind and all types of things, the sooner the better. It's worth the extra few percentage points. It's worth it.
2:54:07Okay. All right. I think I did answer, actually, Baruch Hashem, all the questions because I see some of these other questions I haven't answered. They were answered in the shiur itself. Okay. Thank you again for learning with me. Again, a reminder for anybody that donates in the Gehenom campaign, we'll enter this campaign where somebody's going to win a fancy, schmancy, beautiful tallit like I have. ...and uh, or if anybody wants to buy it, they can go on the website and buy one for themselves. Okay, thank you for learning with me. In life, there are no shortcuts, no tricks, no magic. The valley cave you fear possesses the cure you seek. Go within just now... Once you cross that threshold, there is only one way out. There was a rich family that lived here called the Hetheringtons, and unfortunately, their daughter passed away from a heart attack inside the house. Basically, they were so devastated that they reached out to people claiming to be psychic mediums. They actually weren't psychic mediums. They opened up a total of 11 portals inside this house and invited spirits and entities from all different kinds of dimensions.
2:55:35Well, I think there are certain pieces of evidence that there is an afterlife. The resurrection of the dead is affirmed pretty clearly in the Talmud and the Midrash. To be honest with you, giving this lecture is a nightmare. If it were up to me, I wouldn't do it. There are going to be some graphic details. This place is amazing. The person after death went to a place called Sheol. This is by far the largest near-death experience study that has ever been conducted. People go to a place, and they experience strange phenomena. Sometimes, they will even see a character of some type. Where did that come from? I don't know why that one chain is swinging back there. They may describe feeling profoundly peaceful, seeing a bright, warm, welcoming light. Some people describe watching doctors and nurses working on them with incredible accuracy. Next thing I knew, I was above my body watching the operation. How long did you feel like you were gone? I went to a place of timelessness. And so what that means, it could have been a second, could have been five minutes. I don't know.
2:57:03Can you imagine waking up from your sleep and not being able to move? As I'm lying there, I realize that there's an evil presence next to me. Do you believe that angels and demons exist? Holy moly, dude, get out of here! Oh my gosh, dude! Strange things keep happening. Bizarre nightmares. As if I'm on fire. Satan’s Hollow is what it's called, the portal to Hell. Some people call it an eye of fire, while others said it looked like the portal to Hell opening up. And the next thing I knew, I was outside of my body, looking at my body. What I'm going to do is called clairomancy, the art of throwing lots or throwing bones. 2,000 years of experience passed down, recorded, of how demons work. God has them all on a leash, and He lets the leash go enough to let them tempt us because that's what makes us spiritually stronger.
2:58:14i'm trying to be as graphic as possible so you understand what we're talking about. It's your ticket to reality. It's your ticket to freedom. It's your ticket to immortality. Is there an afterlife? Is there a God? What happens to us after we die?