❌ Wrong name. Who is right? (Answer) #Torah #shorts

❌ Wrong name. Who is right? (Answer) https://youtube.com/shorts/nyDINffixsw #shorts #halachicQuestion #torah Link to the Question: Wrong name. Who is right? - Question: https://youtube.com/shorts/LUlcsaqHMXU One of the most important aspects of Jewish life is integrity. Far more than the secular world, the holy Torah has endless sections and teachings discussing how to conduct oneself honestly and properly according to the Will of HaShem. Should the grandfather pay for the engravings? Was he obligated to pay, given he indeed got what he needed in the end? What's the Torah opinion? Join BeEzrat HaShem. Learn with Rabbi Lev Leib Lerner. Study kosher Jewish ideologies and halachos. Toil in the Torah, follow the right path, and be Holy. #JewishHashkafa #JewishIdeology #JewishThoughts #JewishMentality #JewishValue #OrthodoxJudaism #Teshuvah #Teshuva #Repent #Repentance #Mussar #MussarTeachings #JewishEducation #JewishWisdom #KosherTorah #KosherEducation #TorahEducation #Emet #Emes #Truth #JewishNation #KlalYisrael #AmYisrael #JewishPeople #TorahStories #WeeklyTorahStories #HalachicStories #TorahStories #JewishHonesty #JewishIntegrity #JewishBusinessLaw #JewishMonetaryLaw #Torah, #Tanakh, #God, #faith, #laws, #rabbi, #morals, #ethics, #morality, #jews, #torahLecture, #lawsOfPurity, #LawsofJudaism, #BeezratHashem, #RabbiLevLeibLerner, #LearnwithLerner, #RabbiMizrachi, #HalachosofJudaism, #biblestudy, #selfdevelopment, #selfimprovement, #musarmovement, #lawsforwomen, #lawsofbrachot, #rabbiefraimkachlon, #rabbiyaronreuven, #jewishstories, #shabbatcandles, #torahstudy, #ConvertingtoJudaism, #TorahLaws, #ToviaSinger, #TorahTruth, #Hashem, #shorts, Discover the complex halachic dilemmas that arise in daily life, proving that Jewish law often runs deeper than simple emotions. In this intriguing shiur, Rabbi Lev Leib Lerner addresses a fascinating question that has been previously explored in our video Wrong Name, Who is Right? Though the initial inquiry is too detailed to repeat, the ultimate answer, provided by the esteemed Rabbi Yitzchak Zilberstein shlita, offers profound insight into the principles of nezakin, or damages. The foundation of the psak rests upon a remarkable story involving two men, Reuven and Shimon. Driven by anger, Reuven stormed into Shimon's wine shop and deliberately smashed an expensive barrel of wine before making his escape. Moments later, police detectives arrived, searching the premises for untaxed wine barrels. They found nothing to support their suspicions and departed. The reason for their failure? Reuven's destructive act had, inadvertently, cleared away the very evidence the authorities were seeking. Shimon was saved from a hefty fine and potential imprisonment. The question for the poskim became: Since Reuven’s damage ultimately benefited Shimon, does Reuven still have an obligation to pay for the broken barrel? According to the Teshuvos Mekor Chaim and Piskei Hoshen Nezikei, the answer is unequivocally yes. The halachah dictates that the situation is judged based on the precise moment the damage occurred. The future benefit, however great, does not negate the initial obligation to compensate. This crucial principle of Choshen Mishpat must be understood by every Torah observant Jew. Rabbi Lerner then applies this powerful teaching to the original case involving an engraver who etched the wrong name onto a cup, resulting in a ruined object at the time of pickup. Even though circumstances later changed, making the inscribed name correct, the damage remains. Learn why the grandfather, Yaakov, is not obligated to pay the engraver for the flawed work. This video emphasizes the critical need to consult with the greatest Chachamim of our generation, like Rabbi Zilberstein SHLIT"A, for proper guidance, ensuring that our decisions are based on Torah wisdom and not personal feelings.