BeEzrat HaShem

GEZEL, EGO, LAZINESS, DELUSION, FORGIVENESS, DANGEROUS GUESTS, HaShem ECHAD - STUMPTHE RABBI (89)

5 years ago

Rabbi Reuven presents an insightful discourse on various sins, focusing on stealing. He emphasizes that people often steal due to ego, laziness, or delusion. Egotistical individuals believe they deserve more and justify stealing. Lazy people use the Torah as an excuse to avoid work, leading them to steal from employers or engage in dishonest business practices. Delusional individuals believe they will receive money miraculously and neglect their responsibilities, resulting in stealing. Reuven stresses the importance of clean hands and ethical business practices. He encourages listeners to rectify any past mistakes by returning stolen money promptly. To avoid stealing, individuals should find ways to make a living while incorporating learning into their daily routine. https://www.tikkunhabrit.live TIKKUN HaBRIT The Movie: THE MOST IMPORTANT FILM IN HISTORY!!! PRAYERS ARE NOT ENOUGH FOR THE TIKKUN HABRIT EPIDEMIC SO WE MADE A MOVIE YOU CAN BE PARTNER IN!! To Support our KIRUV and Torah Teachings work please DONATE at www.BeEzratHaShem.org If you'd like to invite Rabbi Yaron Reuven to give a lecture at your synagogue, home or office please email Info@BeEzratHaShem.org Rabbi Reuven is based out of Florida but travels to give lectures to different groups. Join one of our interactive "Interesting Torah" Whatsapp groups to get daily updates and short Torah clips that can uplift your day by texting 1.917.468.2324 or +91 93236 69880 Available on Apple iTunes Store, Amazon App Store and Android Play Store https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.beezrathashem GOOGLE App https://apps.apple.com/us/app/beezrat-hashem/id1279094981?uo=4 APPLE App https://www.amazon.com/Hosttec-Solutions-BeEzrat-HaShem/dp/B07QST1294/ AMAZON App Click here https://soundcloud.com/yaronreuven/sets/daily-chidush To Listen to our very popular "Daily Chidush" short audio series on SOUNDCLOUD or the Podcast Channel at https://beezrathashem.jewishpodcasts.org Born in Netanya, Israel, Rabbi Yaron Reuven began his American Dream as a little boy, when his family immigrated to the United States. He went from a newspaper boy at the age of 10, to a well-known self-made Wall Street multimillionaire by the age of 23. During his time in Wall Street, he owned his own private brokerage firm, a hedge fund, and an international insurance agency. He was featured on CNBC, Bloomberg and Chinese NDTV due to his success in the financial industry. At age 26 he faced a 7-year battle for his life when a simple surgery went wrong. From that moment his life would never be the same. This moment marked the start of a series of miraculous events and an exciting pursuit of truth, ultimately resulting in Rabbi Reuven renouncing his lofty position and success in Wall Street, after 16 years, to become a full-time KIRUV rabbi. His Teshuva story is sure to catch the heart of every listener.​ Rabbi Reuven’s shiurim are in English and Hebrew. His classes are focused on spreading the truth and divinity of the Torah through MUSSAR, scientific proofs, and many other methods to reach each individual listener. Rabbi Reuven is the leading educator on the topic of wasting seed in the English language with over 30 hrs of content published online. Rabbi Yaron Reuven is a proud member of the Igud HaRabbonim (The Rabbinical Alliance of America), a national rabbinic organization founded in 1942. Today, our 900+ members are congregational leaders, religious teachers, chaplains, heads of Jewish organizations and communal leaders united in their commitment to traditional Orthodox Judaism. For more information please visit: https://rabbinicalalliance.org/ #Gezel #Ego #Laziness #Delusion #Forgiveness #DangerousGuests #HaShemEchad #StumpTheRabbi #Judaism #Jewish #RabbiYaronReuven #OrthodoxJudaism #JewishWisdom #Chizuk #Shiur #Torah #Divine #Wisdom #Inspiration

Transcript

0:16We are back at our weekly "Stump the Rabbi" shiur, where after a little bit, you guys ask questions, and B'ezrat Hashem, we will give you the answers. Today... at our weekly "Stump the Rabbi" shiur, where after a little bit, you guys ask questions, and B'ezrat Hashem, we will give you the answers. Today... will be for a refuah shlema for Rabbanit Sarah Bat Anat, Rav Efraim Ben Shulamit, Rabbanit Levana Bat Sarah, Orit Bat Ilana, Michal Bat Yael, Talia Bat Sarah, Yitro Ben Avraham, Stefan Ben Katarina, Esther Bat Zipporah, and also for a hatzlacha rabah,

1:21to Marsha Bat Julie, Ayla Bat Marsha, Samuel Ben Marsha, Alexander Ben Marsha, Cephas Ben Marsha, Shaul Ben Farzaneh, Yitro Ben Avraham, Oshri Ben Doris, Gabi Ben Doris, Elad Ben Doris, David Ben Esria, and Reuven Chaim Ben Palaparel, And all of Am Yisrael and also Yehoshua Ben Noach. And all of Am Yisrael, especially the ones that are helping us do all the amazing things that we're doing, Baruch Hashem. We recently completed some of our financial filings for the organizations, and you have to go over a lot of different things and One of the interesting reports that the companies provided us is an insight into where all the donations are coming from. I mean, I know that when we look online, whether it's YouTube or Facebook, which, Baruch Hashem, are breaking all records as far as views,

2:38Right now, between the different channels that we have, we have a run rate of something around 10 million minutes per month. So, if you remember, last time we talked about this last year, we had about 5 million a month. And that was quite a growth from the year before. Right now, already just a couple of months into the year, we've already doubled what we've done in the last year. We're at 10 million minutes a month. The main channel, which is my channel, hit about 7 million or a little over 7 million last month. And then you have the other channels: Portuguese, Spanish, German, French, Indonesian, Russian, Turkish, and a lot of different channels. Then you have a lot of the Flemish channel. so we're well over 10 million minutes a month, and that's just on YouTube. If you calculate the Facebook and everything else, it's much, much more. So, more or less, it's more than doubled already from last year. Sometimes these different companies give you an insight into where the people are coming from because you see a lot of messages, you see a lot of...

4:03emails, but you don't necessarily always get a chance to know where everybody's from. Sometimes, you know, things are a little bit hard to know how many people are really watching because you'll see sometimes the video will only have, you know, a thousand, two thousand, three thousand views, and you're like, oh, okay, well, it's good, but it's not like... videos that have millions of views, but then you actually see that these few thousand views are actually a few thousand different people whose lives you've impacted. Now, how do you know somebody has been impacted drastically? One of the measures, not the only measure, uh, one of the measures is whether the person made a financial commitment, you know, because a lot of people can press, uh, on your video and say they like it and watch it, or just simply press play and then press stop and go somewhere else. You don't really know how many of the views that people have are actually people watching it, and even if you have people that are watching it, you don't necessarily know how many people are actually impacted by it.

5:06Now, of course, you're not going to necessarily have the full impact of a video on a person because sometimes, you know, you don't even know that the person was impacted by it until later on. Many times, people tell me, the first time they contact me by sending me a message of some kind, they tell me they've been watching my videos for two, three, four, five years already, and I've never heard of their name. So, you know, but apparently they were impacted some time ago. uh and uh this is a uh this is a very interesting thing. Now, how do you know that somebody was impacted if it's not them doing it? Because you don't even know that they exist. How do you know that they've been impacted? By financial commitment. As strange as that sounds, and as unfortunately superficial as it sounds, really that's what it is. Financial commitment when a person takes their hard-earned money and starts donating and even donating on a regular basis, making monthly contributions. You know, he doesn't get a product unless he's buying something from the website. But that's, you know, not the primary source of funds for the organization because 99% of the stuff we give is free. But...

6:25The thing is, though, that 99% of the money comes from donations. So you're not giving them anything. But yet the person has been inspired, wherever they are in the world, by a video or a set of videos to the point where they take a piece of their hard-earned money, and some people even a substantial amount of their hard-earned money, and start donating, even donating on a regular basis, making monthly contributions. You know, whatever they can. And that's really a great indicator that a person has been impacted, especially if somebody is doing something on a monthly basis and not just as a one-time thing. But even a one-time thing, you see people are inspired. Why? Because you see that this person could easily take this hard-earned money and go buy himself a phone, pay a bill, do something else with it, or eat with it. But instead, they choose to donate the money. Now, you could donate to millions of other organizations.

7:30Why choose to donate to our organization, b'ezrat Hashem? Obviously, you've seen a video that has inspired you to the point where you're going to change or are already changing your life. And you want other people to benefit from this change. Not just by seeing you as a better version of yourself, but also by other people learning it. So you want this teaching to continue. The reason why I'm mentioning this is because we got a map online. from one of the organizations that has the technology behind our payment processing, one of the merchant banks. It shows us a map of where all the contributions are coming from. And you would think, since I'm an English speaker and most of my lectures are in English, with the exception of once a week when I do something in Hebrew right after this lecture. But still, The vast majority of what we do is in English. And you would think, obviously, everything is in Hebrew. But the point is that you figure the vast majority of contributions would come from the United States. Incorrect. Why? First of all, there are a lot of English speakers all over the world. Second of all, the...

8:39Channels have grown massively, Baruch Hashem, where we're literally reaching the four corners of the world, especially when it comes to different languages and different places. And the map shows people not only watching, But becoming committed to supporting the Torah that we're teaching and making investments into it from literally all corners of the world. The only place I don't think we've been able to enter yet is China. Russia, we're just starting out, but there's a little bit, a few dots in Russia. Russia is massive, though. But... everywhere else on the map you'll see that there is a lot of red, which is an indication that there are people there, some more, some less, but nonetheless everywhere in Africa, in the Middle East, in the States, in Europe, in Canada. All of that said, he came from Canada, and a lot of people from Canada, which was really surprising how many people in Canada

9:43are not only watching our shiurim, but are supporting them. Of course, in the States, in Europe, in the UK, in Australia, in the Philippines, Dubai, Japan, which is unbelievable. India, there are a few. There are different people in Ghana, in Nigeria, all these amazing people that are watching the shiurim. But again, they're not just watching them. they're taking them to heart. They want other people to watch them. And they know that all of this costs money. They know that all of this, you know, there are employees, there are volunteers, and even the volunteers cost money. Why? Because even though they may not charge us an hourly wage, there are technology costs, computer costs, phones, and all types of things we have to support them with. Software, copyright, sometimes medical, sometimes legal, all types of different things that you know that the team has is probably around 60 people or so on our team, and it's amazing how hard everybody works to put subtitles on the different videos and how they make them into movies, and then

11:02making all types of designs for the flyers, the lectures, and the clips. A lot of work, a ton of work goes into what we're doing. I mean, from the amount of work that goes in, people always send me messages at odd hours, saying, "Oh, you're probably... But when it's tomorrow, can you please get back to me? And you know, they send me a message at 3:30 in the morning and they're surprised to get a response. They ask, why are you awake at three o'clock in the morning, four o'clock in the morning? I said, because I have people all over the world, not just you. You know, there's the team of Hashem that's all over the world, and sometimes they need guidance and help on a project at 3, 4 o'clock in the morning. Sometimes it's students from Australia, from different places around the world, that have a completely different schedule. and you have to become available. So yeah, we have no morning, we have no night, but nonetheless, it's really, really amazing to see that the people see the commitment and the hard work, and they themselves also contribute too. And I thank you for that. It was a beautiful map. I've seen maps throughout my whole life in school and things like that, but this was my favorite map ever. When you see a map,

12:21And especially when you compare it to last year and the year before and how much more it's grown and how it's continued to grow. Because it's not the money, it's the fact that you see you're impacting people's lives, and that gives you the strength, the chizuk, to continue. And that's actually one of the things that I wanted to discuss today because I got a lot of feedback, really, really amazing feedback, more than usual. on the lecture that we did recently about Gezel, about stealing. The Gemara itself says that not everybody has their hands in desecration of Shabbat or immorality or some of these bigger crimes, but almost everybody at some point or another has had their hands in stealing. And if you know what the details of stealing are, where it's not just the obvious stealing where you go and you rob a bank—that's Gezel, by the way—then there's a difference between Gneiva and Gezel. There's stealing and then there's robbing.

13:30stealing is when the person doesn't know that you're doing it. You're doing it in the dark, behind a person's back. And Gezel is like, you know, a Ponzi scheme or robbing a bank or, you know, a stick-up of some kind, where the person knows you're stealing from him but you're doing it in open daylight and there's nothing they can do about it. That's obviously much, much worse but but nonetheless, it's not really the only form of stealing. Sometimes people steal from their employees by not paying them the right salary. Suddenly, when payday comes, they never have the money, and they tell people, "I'll pay you tomorrow and tomorrow and tomorrow," and every paycheck is two, three, four, five days late for different reasons that are not valid. or sometimes they suddenly come up with different reasons why the paycheck is really supposed to be lower than what it is because, oh, I saw that you were late that day and you were picking up a personal phone call that day. I remember when I first started working on Wall Street, I worked for this really evil person who initially told me that I'd make a lot of money in commissions and things like that. But after we saw that’s not really true because I was just starting out, we agreed that he’d give me a minimal salary.

14:52and I was supposed to get $1,800 at the end of the month. I get a check from this guy, and he gives me 300 bucks, $320. I said, well, we're missing a little bit, a little bit like $1,500. you know right away he was ready. He comes up with a whole notebook, takes out his notebook from behind his desk, and he starts showing me different dates. "Oh, see this date? Your lunch was one extra minute, so I'm not paying you for the whole day. This day you picked up a personal phone call" at 7:30 p.m., and we weren't finished until eight. "I'm not paying you for the whole day," he said repeatedly. "That day you were late 20 minutes. I'm not paying you for the whole day," and so on and so forth. He literally ripped me apart, and that was my last day, obviously, in that place. I thought I would find another place, but the next guy was even worse. The next guy owed me a couple of thousand dollars and then told me he's gonna pay me the following month. When the following month came,

15:56And instead of giving me $4,400, he gave me $81. And I have a copy of the check to this day. $81. And his reason was that he never really told me that he was going to pay me. That was a figment of my imagination. So that's stealing. That's 100% stealing from people. And it happens a lot where people hire others and decide not to pay them. You hire a contractor to fix your roof, to fix your house. He does the job. And then you decide that, all right, by the way, senor, I don't have the money, so I'm just gonna pay you half. What do you mean? I did the work already. The guy doesn't really have much of a choice. like, listen, you could either take this, uh, you know, instead of ten thousand dollars, take this five thousand dollars or take nothing. If you want to take nothing, and the poor guy has to feed his family and kids, what's he gonna say? No? He takes the money and, uh, argue as he may, he doesn't have much to do. Or sometimes it's done in the opposite, where the contractor, you know, rips apart your house.

17:02which is very, very common, rips your roof, your floor, your walls, or whatever it is, and then for an agreed-upon price that you have, and then he tells you, "Listen, sir, I'm sorry, but we're going to need more money." "What do you mean? I already paid you the $50,000. I paid you $25,000." "Yeah, no, no, I made a mistake. It's really $75,000, not $50,000." $50,000 is for the cost; that $25,000 is for me. I'm not working for free. He starts making you feel bad, but he ripped you off for another $25,000, and you really have nothing to do. Why? Because your whole house looks like Gehinnom. It looks like the structure went in there, and many times people fall into it. I remember my family had a remodeling that went from like $40,000 to, by the time they finished, it was like $170,000. one contractor after another, nightmares, nightmares, and this is stealing. this is stealing, and people steal from their jobs, from their employees, from insurance companies, and from the government. They are claiming welfare when, in reality, they have plenty of money. You know, the guy is making a hundred thousand dollars a year but tells the government that he still needs to get milk and cookies every month from the government, and he wants them to pay for this and that. And before you know it, the government is sending him

18:24know, 500, a thousand, two thousand dollars a month because they think that he really only makes 12,000. And that's stealing. That's 100% stealing. And a lot of people do it, including in the Jewish community and non-Jewish community. People lie to the government in all forms, and stealing is a very, very big problem. One of the things that we learned from the Chachamim is that money is considered blood. It's called damim. According to the Gemara, damim... It means blood, but also it's plural, so it's "bloods." Why "bloods"? Because there's more than one meaning and it's a plural aspect. The money is a... is a plural word. And when a person has mamon gezel (stolen money) on his hands, it means that he has stolen money in his hands. The Gemara says a person who has blood on his hands is not allowed to enter Gan Eden, even if he kept Shabbat, and he kept this, and he kept that. He comes to Shamayim...

19:26...and he has a resume of steel that's full of different ways that he stole from people, from companies, from customers, from the government, and so on and so forth. That person, with all of his beard and his peyot, and the tzedakah that he gave, and all the things that he has, if he did not do teshuvah and fix that stolen money problem, he cannot enter Gan Eden... cannot enter Gan Eden. And that's a very, very serious problem that a lot of people have, and they are going to get the surprise of their life. going to get the surprise of their life when they get up to Shamayim. Now the question is, as we discussed a lot of this in the previous lecture, what's the further question? Why do people steal? Why is there gezel? Why is there gezel? So, I heard this story that was told by Rav Chaim Zamir, who himself heard it from Rav Ovadia. One said the story where, in the old days, it was very common for a husband to work away from his home and be away from his home for weeks at a time, months at a time, in some cases, and even in some cases years at a time, to go make a living and then bring back the money and stay with the family for a period of time and then go back to work.

20:49And this one guy would go away for a month at a time, go away to work at some winery for another Jewish guy who unfortunately was a person that was addicted to money. And the Gemara in Masechet Sukkah says, if a person who loves money will never be satiated by money, meaning it doesn't matter how much he has, he'll always want more. And it's not always wanting more in an ambitious way, but rather in a fanatic way. This means that all bets are off; he'll kill his mother for money if he has to, he'll cheat insurance companies, he'll cheat the government, he'll cheat his customers, he'll cheat even his own employees that are making him the money. If that's what has to happen, this was one of the examples. where this man used to go away for a month at a time, then comes back to see his family, you know, after he gets paid for the whole month. He comes back on the train, goes to see his family, stays there for a week, and then goes back out again to work. As it would happen, the day he got paid his monthly income was on a Friday. So he got on the road to get to the train in time to arrive before Shabbat.

22:11But as you would have it, he missed the train. So he doesn't want to violate Shabbat, obviously. So he comes back to his employer, to the Ba'al HaBayit. And he says to him, "Listen, I missed the train. Would you mind if I stay with you for Shabbat? And then I'll go see my family after Shabbat." And the employer says, "Yeah, sure, no problem. You can stay here." And he stays in his usual spot. But now the guy has an issue. Why? he got the money, he got a full month's salary from hard work. He got the money, and in those days, I mean, he's not traveling with a safe. In those days, there were no bank accounts, so what is he gonna do? So, he has to find a place to hide the money, especially on Shabbat, where you're not allowed to deal with money and so on. So, what am I gonna do, he says. Ah, I have an idea! I'm going to hide it... between the wine barrels. No one's gonna go to the winery. No one's gonna go into the wine barrels over here, so I'm gonna hide it in between the wine barrels over there, and that's it. And that's what he did. He took his wallet, you know, full of money, put it in there between the wine barrels, and went and started celebrating Shabbat. On Motzei Shabbat, on Motzei Shabbat, he

23:29comes out to get his money and he sees, Hashem, may Hashem preserve us and help us, he sees his money and the wallet and any record of it is gone, nowhere to be found. Now he knows who could have possibly known that my money was here? No one broke into the wine. No one broke into this place. So the only one that could know is the employer, the host. Not only the host that he's staying at for Shabbat but also the employer. Not only the employer but the host. He's the thief. So without losing his cool, he simply goes to the employer and says to him, "Please, he knows he's known that this guy is not exactly straight. He works for him but so far, until now, he was good to them. But now he just stole the money from him. He says, "Please, do me a favor. I worked for a whole month. Please have some mercy on me. Give me my money back." "Employer, what? What money? I paid you already." "Yes, you paid me, but you took the money." "No, what are you talking about? I paid you." "You know, I pretend to play stupid. You know, the thieves always play stupid."

24:38And the reason why they play stupid is because they believe you're stupid. Thieves are notorious for thinking that the whole world is stupid. And I've met a few of them in my life, and it's a very interesting experience that I wouldn't wish on others. But anyway, thieves always think everybody else is stupid, so they play stupid themselves because they figure that the person is too stupid to realize that they're really not that stupid. so many words. This guy says, "What are you talking about? I didn't take from you. I'm the one that paid you. What, I'm going to steal from you? What kind of person do you think I am?" You know, they give you the guilt trip, but the guy knows it's not possible for anybody else to take the money because nobody else knew. Nobody else knew he was going to be there. Nobody else knew that he hid the money there. And better yet, no one broke into the place, so it's not like somebody broke into it and you could say, "Ah." Nobody, he was in there, nobody else knew. So he says, okay, so we have to go to Rav Kluger. Rav Shlomo Kluger, alav hashalom, was one of the tzaddikim of the dor, of the generation in the 1800s, a little over 200 years ago. And Rav Shlomo Kluger, he was the Dayan HaKadosh in the area. He said, let's go. So the guy says, yeah, of course, of course, we have to go to the Rav. We're Jews. Jews go to the rabbis. We don't go to secular court for sure.

26:01they both go to Rav Shlomo Kluger and tell him the story. Rav Kluger looks at the employer, looks at the employee, the poor employee whose money is gone, and then looks back at the employer. He says to the employer, "You're right, you're a tzaddik. You didn't steal the money." I'm sorry it happened to you. You know, he plays the whole thing: "Sorry it happened to you, but yeah, see the Rav." So the Rav says, "Yeah, you're right, but do me a favor. Give me the papers from the shelf behind you. I need to write the psak." The guy said, "Pesach? What Pesach, Rabbi? I need to write something. Give me the papers. I have to write." So the guy slowly gets the letter. He's not really sure he wants to... "What's Pesach? Why is there Pesach? What's happening here?" But he gets the paper. He listens to the Rabbi. He gets the paper. You know, in those days, paper was very expensive. So it's not like you have boxes of paper just sitting. You have to go get the paper, one paper at a time. Gets the...

27:14uh, writing equipment over there, the little feather, and he gives it a rub. He goes, "Okay, what's the name of your company?" He tells him the name. "Okay, so I'm writing over here. I'm just gonna let you know before I write, I'm letting you know, I'm writing that you have to put this on your company wall." What? What are you putting about the thing? Why does everybody have to know that he accused me of stealing? He's going to look for my business. No, chas v'shalom. You're not telling them that he accused you of stealing. You're telling them that somebody who is not Jewish broke into your winery and therefore all of your wine is considered yayin nesech, meaning the wine of idolatry, and Jews are forbidden from buying it from you. that the guy almost had three heart attacks and a seizure. What? Rabbi, what are you talking about? What do you mean? He says, what do you mean? Why is this confusing to you? You see, since you didn't steal the money, then surely the majority of the people that live here are idol worshipers, goyim, all types of Christians and so on. So surely it's not you. You're a tzaddik. You didn't steal the money.

28:35so one of them must have broken in since they're the majority. Once one of them broke into your winery and took the money, we have a halacha that when our wine is out of our sight and in the control of an idol worshiper, we automatically believe he touched it and used it for idolatry, and it turns into yayin nesech. forbidden wine that you cannot fix. So that means that all of the barrels that you have there are all yayin nesech, and unfortunately, you have to destroy them. You can't sell them to Jews. The guy's entire company would go bankrupt in a second, a lot more money than he paid. The guy thought he got over on the Rav. He thought he got over on himself because he says, "They can't prove that I'm a thief. They can't prove that I'm a thief, right?" So the Rabbi says, "Here you go, you have to put this." He goes, "No, no, Rabbi, Rabbi, I have to tell you something. Yes, I know who stole the money."

29:42"Okay, fine. Tell them to return the money." "No, no, no, Rabbi, I know who stole the money." "Fine, it's good. You want to bring him here?" "I don't know, but okay, fine. While you're thinking about it, go take this and put it on the wall so nobody goes and buys wine in the meantime. Put it on the wall for now." "No, Rabbi, I don't think we need to do that." "Why not?" He goes, "No, no, you see, Rabbi, the guy had to admit it. He says, 'Rabbi, I'm the thief.' 'Wait, but you just said you didn't steal.' 'No, yeah, Rabbi, I lied. Listen, how do I know that you're really the thief? Maybe because you don't like the conclusion that you're going to lose all this wine, you're making it up.' 'No, Rabbi, I'm going to go get it with the wallet, and you'll see that it's not just money I'm making up, it's his money, it's his wallet, I stole it.'" And that, rabotai yikarim, is when the chachamim say, talmidei chachamim marbim shalom ba'olam, the talmidei chachamim bring peace to the world, they mean this. It's not just, oh, the talmid chacham, you know, he wasn't nice to him, so therefore the talmid chacham made peace between them that way. No, sometimes it's to bring the righteous din to the world, that's bringing peace to the world. Why? Because now, rabotai, even though he got embarrassed,

31:07he got embarrassed. The reality is he saved his eternity. That embarrassment saved his eternity. It saved his eternity because if he would have died with that stolen money in his hands, he would have never gone to Gan Eden. Now, it's amazing how the chachamim know exactly how to deal with people, but many times People do different things without asking the chachamim. And they simply get to a point where they don't know how to function in the world. And that lack of knowledge, that ignorance, leads them to a place that no person, no Jew or Gentile, ever wants to be in, which is a place where you have blood on your hands. You have stolen money in your hands. Rav Avigdor Miller, alav hashalom, they publicized one of his divrei Torah today, very interesting and relevant. We're talking about the people working and so on. And the question is, does striving to become successful, you know, financially successful and comfortable, take away from Torah and yirat shamayim? That was the question they asked Rav Avigdor Miller. And he answers, this was an answer that he gave in 1980.

32:34uh, in April 1980 and Tape 308, Rav Avigdor Miller answers the following. He says that, uh, people that think such a thing are foolish people because they don't know how to fit this world with the spiritual world. And in order to succeed, Rabbi Avigdor Miller says, as a Jew, a person must have a decent gashmiut, meaning a way to sustain himself, materialism; he has to be able to survive. He has to have a profession. he must have some type of calling. Now, you don't necessarily need to be a doctor, you don't necessarily need to be some multi-millionaire or anything, but he says you have to make some form of living and not be a schlep, not be a failure. That's not a way to be a Jew, he says. If you

33:35are such a person that you can succeed in learning to become a scholar, you can become a talmid chacham, and so on. And you're learning a lot every single day, not just that you want to learn a lot. A lot of people tell me, "Listen, Rabbi, how do I get to a point where I can learn 12-14 hours a day?" And I said, "Well, how much are you learning now? Are you getting close to it?" "No, right now, you know, I watch a video a day, you know, like maybe I get like two hours when I'm in my car." Wait, so you want to go from watching a video, listening to a lecture, two hours a day, to go learn in a kollel, 14 hours a day? You think that that's a real... You could actually do that? You think it's that easy to learn? Even if you're listening to 12 hours of videos a day, to go from 12 hours of videos to 12 hours of learning, gemara, poskim, the Shulchan Aruch, and so on, It's a world apart. It's a lot more difficult. A lot more difficult. There's no question about it. Even if it's a good shiur, even if it's my shiur. It's a world apart, learning this and learning that. Of course, you should always listen to a shiur Torah. But again, there's a difficulty. On one hand, when you're learning a shiur, I'm giving you everything on a silver platter. I'm telling you the sources. I'm telling you what they all mean, and so on and so forth. That's what a good shiur is. But when you're learning in a book, you're learning from the Gemara, you're learning the poskim.

35:02you're trying to figure out what they're even saying, and you're hoping that you're even going to understand what they're saying after you see the conclusion because it's not necessarily so simple to understand all the time, especially if you're learning the Shas and so on. So it's a lot more toiling, a lot more difficult to understand, a lot more exciting at times, but nonetheless, it's not the same thing. But a person thinks that, oh, just because they like shiur Torah, they can go to a kollel, they can become the Gaon of Vilna, you know, learn 20 hours a day. It doesn't work that way. if a person is already learning many hours, continue learning more and more and more. If you see that you're already at a point where you're learning five, six, seven, eight, nine, ten hours while you're still working a real career and you still want more, you want to go to kollel, go for it, go for it, absolutely. But if you're only learning a clip here and there whenever you get a chance and you think that you're gonna become a gaon that way, and you're gonna

36:04it's not going to work, it's not going to work. But if a person wants to be a Talmid Chacham and he's able to do it, and not a lot of people could do it, he says you could learn all day. Some people can do it, and there are going to be some people that are willing to support these Avreichim. There are kollelim that give a small salary of maybe five, six hundred dollars a month And that's not enough to, obviously, feed the family, but at least it's something. And then you have to get some people to support you, whether it's family or friends and so on. And we, as part of our organization, we have several Avreichim that we send money to every single month. These are really serious Avreichim that are, each one of them, either already a Dayan or in the process of becoming a Dayan, which is the highest level that a person can get to. And we have some people that, you know, donate money each month to support these avreichim on our website. Some people want to donate to take on one week of their Torah. Some for two weeks, some for three weeks. And we give real amounts. We don't just say, listen, if you give $100, you're getting the merits of a whole month of Torah from this avrech. Bupkis. You're not getting a whole month. You're lucky if you get a day.

37:20Why? It doesn't cost the guy a hundred dollars to live the whole day, the whole month. It's just not a reality. So we put real amounts, and we don't like to put these fictitious amounts that people use just to get donations. We tell people: you want to sponsor a person for a month? This is the cost. You want to sponsor for a week? This is the cost. And again, it also depends on the avreich. Some of them have a higher cost of living. We have one standard price, but nonetheless... there are people that donate their money, not just to us, of course, but to many other organizations and kollels to support these people that are willing and able to study Torah all month, all day, all night, and have no intention of doing anything else. So Rabbi Avigdor Miller says, if you can do that, good, but most people won't do that. And therefore, you have to make a living in a normal way, and you have to learn a trade. You have to find out what your calling is in life, whether it's to sell insurance, to work for some factory, to deliver products for Amazon, or whatever it is that you want to do, you have to find a trade.

38:29Not just the trade is not just to be a doctor or a lawyer. You could do a million and a half other things. Actually, being a doctor or a lawyer is not exactly like it used to be. People thought that, you know, in the old days, that was the main way to make money. There are plenty of other ways to make a lot more money than a doctor could ever make in doing all types of things. But nonetheless, the objective is not to necessarily make millions. It's just to do something that's going to help you make a living and so on. you have to have a home, you have to have a wife, you have to earn your own way and not live on welfare. Rav Avigdor Miller says, don't live on welfare. This means not to live on welfare when you have the ability to work. There are some people who have no choice; they are disabled and not able to work. For them, of course, they can live on welfare and take advantage of the opportunities available in the country they live in. But if a person is able to work... If a person is able to work, but they're simply lazy, or they don't want to push themselves to work harder to make more money, them living on welfare, Rabbi Avigdor Miller talks about them right here. He says, anybody who lives on welfare, and he's again referring not to the disabled person that's incapable of helping themselves, but the person that can help themselves and chooses not to.

39:49says anyone who lives on welfare is a flop, he's a failure, and his life is ruined. Even his spirituality is ruined. He thinks that just because he is going to learn a little extra as a result of him living on welfare, when he could really support himself if he just pushed himself a little harder to get a regular job, he thinks that it’s going to make him better spiritually. Forget this. No, he says, you're wrong, you're wrong. you're wrong. Even your ruchniyut is bad. Don't deceive yourselves. As the Gemara says, a man must teach his son umanut, a trade. And he says, uh, there's the Gemara that says the pasuk says, "See life with the woman whom you love," and the... says what does it mean "the woman whom you love"? It means the Torah. The Torah is the woman we love. The Jewish nation loves the Torah. But it says "See life with the Torah." What does it mean "See life with the Torah"? Learn a trade. It says you have to learn some kind of livelihood to go along with the Torah.

41:04to go along with the Torah. And that's the reality. Unfortunately, sometimes he brings a story. You sometimes have people fall into a trap—not their own trap, but somebody else's trap. And he shares a story. He says that he met a woman who converted to Judaism. Many times these converts are idealistic. They live in a different world. They're really high spiritually. And unfortunately, sometimes they don't know how to go back to reality. You know, and I've met some people where the first thing they want to do as soon as they convert is move to Israel. And I ask them, did you ever go to Israel to visit? No. Do you know anybody in Israel? No. Do you have a job in Israel waiting for you? No. Do you have a lot of savings that you're going to support yourself in Israel? No. So what are you going to do in Israel exactly when you get off the plane? Well, Hashem is going to help me. Great, yeah, Hashem is going to help you, but that's not exactly the right way to live.

42:11not exactly the right way to live, and sometimes they listen and sometimes they don't. When they don't, it's very unfortunate because I see them struggling a lot more than necessary. In one case, I remember the woman who did it ended up going to Israel, left her husband and kids here, and ended up ruining her entire life—divorce and all of that. But she lived in Israel, so it's not the right way to do things. Idealistic people do that. And Rav Avigdor Miller says that he met this young woman who was an idealistic woman, who was a convert, and he asked her, He asked her, who is she married to? And she said that she is married to another idealistic person. And he said, who is this person? She says, a Jew, he's a frum guy, frum from birth, and she loves him. And Rav Avigdor Miller says, what does he do? She says, he's a writer. He's a writer. Oh, he's a writer. What has he published? Oh, no, he hasn't published anything. Oh, what is he working on right now? No, he lies in bed all day long.

43:21he's in bed all day long. A man like that is not... What's wrong with him? Why doesn't he do something? She says, "No, no, he's a great idealistic person. He's thinking up plans and drawing up a plan for some great work. So, in the meantime, he is, uh, lying in bed thinking. That's the way he thinks while he's in bed." In reality, the guy's a bum, that's what he is. And some time passed, and Rav Avigdor Miller... heard that this woman ended up running away from the house with her three little kids because this idealistic writer that was lying in bed all day was beating her and the kids senseless. uh, that's the reality, and the reason why, he says, is because he never learned how to make parnassah. He was simply a lazy person, and when things dried up for him, he took out all of his negative energy on the tzaddeikes that married him. Now, the Mishnah in Avot

44:29says Rabban Gamliel, the son of Rabbi Yehuda HaNasi, who is Rabbi Yehuda HaNasi HaKadosh, who wrote the Mishnah. He says, Omer. What is Omer? What is Omer? Why does it say Omer? Omer is, in essence, "says." But why does it say "he said"? Why does it say "he says"? Omer. Why does it say amar? Like he said in the past. Why is it Omer? Omer means present. First and foremost, that's to teach you that this information is relevant to you today, 3,000 years later. 2,500 years later. Number one. Number two... in fact, "Omer" he says. Why? Because he's talking to himself first. He's talking to himself first, and he is doing all of what he says. He's not just saying it; he's saying it to himself and he's fulfilling what he says. So that, that, uh, I also heard, uh, from my Rav. So now, uh...

45:47says, Torah study is acceptable together with an occupation. Exertion of them both makes sin forgotten. So here, the Torah specifically says a person needs to learn Torah a few hours a day while you actually have a day job, unless the Torah is your day job. What does it mean the Torah is your day job? You're learning Torah all day. You wake up early in the morning... You wake up early in the morning and you pray, and then you start learning. You take a little bit of a break to eat, and then you go back to learning all day. You have a full schedule as if it's a full-time job and even more so. After dinner, you spend a little time with the kids and the wife, and then you go back to learning. You're going to learn 10, 12, 15 hours, as much as you possibly can. I mean, if you're learning a couple of hours a day, you're not really fulfilling your full potential.

46:48Now, if a person has a, I had this question where somebody told me, "Listen, my husband is starting to learn, but really he's not ready to learn the whole day. He's learning, you know, let's say from nine to one, and then he takes a break, and then he learns a little bit more at night." Should I tell him to go back to work? No, don't tell him to go back to work. Why? Because obviously what he's doing is coming from laziness, which we'll talk about in a moment. And if you're going to take him out of kollel, most likely he's not only going to stop learning, but he's probably going to continue being lazy, and even worse. So it's better to just leave him there and try to support him and be motivating to him and make his Torah a big deal so it entices him to learn even more. So Rabban Gamliel says that you have to have this Torah with a job, with some type of way to make a living. But all Torah that is not joined with work will cease in the end. It will cease in the end and lead to sin. Why? Because boredom leads to sin. If you're just going to work, you're only going to learn Torah a couple of hours a day, and then the rest of the day you're going to be a bum.

48:02to lead to sin. Why? Boredom leads to sin—that's just the reality of what Shlomo taught us. And if, on the other hand, you're just going to learn and not make the Torah really your full-time commitment, you're just going to treat it like a part-time endeavor. You're going to sin for sure, and one of those sins is more extensive than this. But if you want to learn the rest of it... would suggest listening to our Avot series. We have 179 lectures in the Pirkei Avot series online for free on the app—the Be'ezrat HaShem app—or on the channels that we have. Or you could just order yourself a USB, watch, and listen to all of the Avot series. But here this particular Mishnah is saying that if you're not going to learn Torah and work Which again, the Torah can be your work, but that means it's full-time, not part-time. You can't just do part-time Torah and nothing else. It's either full-time Torah or part-Torah, part actual work. If you don't do that, for sure your Torah is not going to survive because of the sins that you're going to have in your hand. And what kind of sins? What kind of sins? One of those sins, Rabotai, that's most popular, that's most often, is stealing.

49:22why is stealing? Why do people steal? Why did that employer steal from his employee? Why do people steal from the government? Why do people steal from their friends? Why do people steal even from their own family, from their own kids or their parents? Why do people steal? I'll give you a couple of reasons and a small insight and then get to your questions because I know you guys are probably eager to ask questions. But it's a very important subject and it's something that we need to learn. And now, b'ezrat Hashem, today we'll try to cover it. First reason why people steal is simply because they believe that the world owes them something. Simple. They have a huge ego. They believe that the company that they work for is not paying them enough. They're worth a lot more than what they're getting paid. And since the company doesn't agree, they just simply make themselves feel at home and take the extra cash that doesn't belong to them. Whether it's money that they're really supposed to be spending as a company expense, they turn it into a personal expense.

50:29or sometimes it's using company merchandise for their own personal use, or sometimes outright stealing all types of products, all types of things, and they simply steal from the company. Or the most common thing is, "Hey, Steve, do me a favor. Clock me in." "Oh, okay, you're here?" "No, no, no, I'm not coming in today." "So why should I clock you in?" "I want to get paid." "And that's, okay, you're going to do that for me also?" "Yeah," so Steve and Joe, that's what they do for each other. They work for a huge company, and... They don't want to work, though. They want to steal. So what do they do? They simply tell each other, "Listen, I'm going to work two times a week, but I'm going to get paid for five. You work two times a week, and I'm going to get paid for five. How? When we're not here, you're going to be here, and therefore you clock me in as if I'm coming in the whole day, and I..." management has too many employees to manage, and they don't know who's there and who's not. They look at a clock sheet, they look at some type of computer program, thinking that everybody's there and everybody has integrity. Unfortunately, these guys are stealing, and every single penny that they're stealing from that company will be a very serious punishment. They'll regret the day they were born. But nonetheless, people steal on a regular basis. As I mentioned before, they steal from the government, pretending like they don't have any money when they really do. They...

51:45They steal from insurance companies by making all types of false claims. One of the most common ways that people steal today is by pretending they are poor when they are not. and they have some type of damage in their house, and they bring Muhammad, the adjuster. They don't bring the insurance company's adjuster, they bring their own personal adjuster. There's always a Muhammad that is the adjuster. And it's not always a Muhammad; sometimes it's a Yaakov, unfortunately. And sometimes the Yaakov has a kippah. Don't think that I haven't seen religious guys actually do this crime. crime against the Torah. What would happen? You have a little damage, a little bit of water drips on the floor, and it, let's say, causes some damage in some place. So, you bring Muhammad, and Muhammad comes to the house, and they say that, you know, you're professional because you filed a claim with the insurance company. You have home insurance.

52:49So, call the insurance company. Listen, I have a claim. No problem. We need to get an adjuster out there. Do you want to use our adjuster? No, no, no. I'll get an adjuster. He calls Muhammad. Muhammad says, listen, you signed this deal. You signed this agreement. You're going to give me 10, 20, 30% of whatever money I'm going to get you. And, no problem. You signed the agreement. And there you go. Muhammad goes to work. And he sees, oh, you have... five thousand dollars in damage, and that actually really did happen. But let's see everywhere else, and he starts inventing damage that's completely unrelated. Instead of a five thousand dollar claim, he sent a $150,000 claim, and guess what? He gets the money. You think you're a big winner. You got $150,000 from the company. $50,000 goes to Muhammad. You got $100,000. Honey, you see, Hashem sends money. Hashem sends parnasa. Now we can really do that remodeling. You have no idea how many problems that money is going to give you. You think that you made money. You made money in an awful way. You made money in an awful way and you're going to pay for it.

53:59This is very common. I've seen it with my own eyes. And there are countless ways. Every day a new sucker is born. Every day there are two thieves that are born. Every day. Every day. Why? Ego. People believe that the world is stupid. People believe that the world owes them something. The company has a lot of money. I don't. They should give me something. Why? I'm great. That's what they believe. That's what they believe. And ego, rabotai yekarim, is one of the abominable things that exists in the world to the extent where it is written multiple times in the Torah. The most filthy, disgusting thing, the most abominable thing that one can think of is someone that has pride, someone that has ego. Why? Because that person not only has ego against other people but

55:01but even against Hashem Himself, where he thinks that he can fool Hashem. He thinks that if he says, oh, Hashem helped us do this, Why is it? Oh, I said, Be'ezrat Hashem, and that's why I won the poker hand and gambling. I said, Be'ezrat Hashem, and that's why we landed that deal where we're gonna, you know, take advantage of these customers and charge them 150% interest. He thinks that because he has a kippah and because he gave some tzedakah, he's fooling Hashem. That's why the pasuk in Tehillim, David HaMelech says in the name of HaKadosh Baruch Hu, HaKadosh Baruch Hu says to Am Yisrael, HaKadosh Baruch Hu says to the sinner, the sinner. He says, "You thought I was like you." What do you mean, "You thought I was like you?" You thought that just because I didn't punish you right away when I saw you stealing, you thought that just because I didn't destroy you and cause you to go bankrupt and homeless after all the corruption that you did, despite the money that you've donated—it was really stolen money that you donated—you thought that I agreed with you, that I was like you. Now, Hashem says, "I'm going to rip you apart," and it literally says that in the pasuk.

56:06people steal money eventually lose everything eventually get completely destroyed just like you saw with Bernard Madoff. The guy was living on cloud nine, donating millions and millions of dollars everywhere. Everyone liked him and honored him and so on because he was not only a savvy businessman, apparently, but did a few good things actually in a business world where he built the infrastructure of trading that people use till this day. But he built off of that good platform, just like Christianity. He built off of the good, legitimate platform into a world of corruption. And he built a Ponzi scheme of tens of billions of dollars and ended up destroying the lives of all of the so-called friends, family, and his own two kids. One of them committed suicide. The other one ended up dying of cancer after a lot of embarrassment two years later. His wife still lives in embarrassment to this day. One of the friends that he had committed suicide. All types of people killed themselves as a result of Bernard Madoff's scam. He, baruch Hashem, died recently, and I wouldn't want to be in his trial, needless to say, where he's going to end up being because of how much chilul Hashem he caused. He stole money, and he donated the money to Jewish charities, to non-Jewish charities, to all types of things, and people thought he's a good guy because he's donating so much money.

57:35HaKadosh Baruch Hu says, you thought I was like you? And what ended up happening? The Mishnah in Avot says, anyone who desecrates Hashem's name in hiding where nobody knows, eventually HaKadosh Baruch Hu will expose them to the whole world. And Bernard Madoff is one of the perfect examples that we see where all of his crime was behind the scenes. No one knew for decades, but when HaKadosh Baruch Hu exposed it, everybody knew. Nobody doesn't know. Everybody knows. And the embarrassment came out everywhere and is still there and will never go away. And the same thing happened with other reshaim, whether it's Epstein, the pedophiles, the rapists, and all these ugly people who commit crimes and think that HaKadosh Baruch Hu, because He doesn't punish them right away, agrees with them. Those books which say that it's only because of ego—that's reason number one why people steal and, quite frankly, why they commit all sins: a huge ego. Reason number two: laziness. People are lazy and many times they use the Torah as an excuse.

58:40excuse to justify their laziness. Instead of going to work, they warm up their couches and their chairs all day. They don't want to move; they don't want to work because they think they’re in the cave. "Oh, how come you're not going to work?" "No, no, who needs work? The rabbi says to focus on Torah." "Yeah, but the rabbi also said that you know you have to live, you have to eat." "No, don't worry. I'll ask my parents for money." Well, your parents have a lot of money like that? They're planning on supporting you when you're 35 years old already? Oh, listen, they're okay, they're okay. And you find out that the parents are really, they themselves are struggling, but that's only because they have a degenerate son or daughter who doesn’t want to work, and she or he wants to be Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai, sit on the couch all day, listen to shiurei Torah, and she thinks she's doing a mitzvah. Not a mitzvah. Not a mitzvah. It's not a mitzvah to put yourself in such a situation, and you are causing people to struggle because you're lazy. It's not because you're righteous. It's not because you're righteous. People are lazy, and that's why they think that they're allowed to steal from people. But they won't call it stealing. They'll call it what? They're helping me. I'm elevating myself. Elevate yourself both in gashmiut and ruchniut. If you want to be an avrech, go to a kollel. Go to a kollel and study full-time. But you want to be somebody that's just listening to shiurei Torah, reading a book whenever you get a chance, and you think that you are doing righteous things? You're not doing righteous things.

1:00:09living an illusion, an illusion you're living, and unfortunately, that laziness caused a lot of people to steal. Sometimes you'll have people simply steal from their companies. Why? Instead of working, he takes off. "Oh, where'd you go yesterday? I didn't see you." "Oh, yeah, no, I had a shiur." "Yeah, but I'm not paying you to go to a shiur." I'm not paying you to go to a shiur Torah. Yeah, but come on, you're a Jew, I'm a Jew. I need to learn. Okay, you need to learn on your own time. I'm paying you to work. I'm not paying you to learn. You want to go learn? Go to the kollel, they'll pay you. And people justify that. Or sometimes, like I told you in the past, people will listen to a shiur Torah or read a book while they're at work. if you have the kind of job where your boss truly doesn't mind as long as you fulfill your obligation at a specific time, no problem. You're allowed to listen to a shiur or read a book or scratch your head. But if you don't have such a boss, and your boss does mind, and he does want you to work and not do other things, then if you are violating that, you're stealing—100% stealing.

1:01:15And why are you doing it? Because you don't really feel like working. You're like, ah, you know what, should I work, lift boxes on my head, or should I just sit there and learn Torah? So that's the thing. It's the laziness that people have that causes them laziness. to steal on a regular basis. Laziness, laziness, laziness. And it's a disaster. That's why people end up living on borrowed money. And they borrow from Peter to pay Paul. And they borrow from the credit cards. And they borrow from that one. And they pay that one. And they maneuver themselves. And they think that makes them savvy. And that's how they're getting by. Bupkis. Bupkis, Rabotai. That's not the way to live. That's not the way to live—to live constantly fooling people or beating the system just because you are lazy and you don't want to work. That's not the way of a Jew. It's not the way of a good human being. A person needs to work. You want the Torah to be your job? Go work full time in the Torah world. But if it's not, you have to get a regular job. You have to get a regular job. But people live a fantasy life, a fantasy life. What do they do? No, no, Rabbi, listen.

1:02:24I'm doing kiruv all day. Oh, okay, Baruch Hashem. So how are you making a living? You're working for a kiruv organization? No, Rabbi, I'm publicizing your stuff. Oh, thank you very much for publicizing my stuff, but I'm not paying you because you're not an employee. So how are you living? Oh, no, don't worry, Rabbi. I got a few things going on. And then you find out later on, you know, six months, eight months, a year later, where the guy's crying to you or the girl's crying to you. "Hey, listen, Rabbi, can you do me a favor? Maybe you can make me a campaign?" Campaign for you? Why? Are you dying? What happened to you? "No, listen, I haven't paid my rent in eight months. And also, I borrowed some money from some people. I need to come up with some money." How much is some money? "Oh, you know, only $25,000." What do you think? We're going to make a campaign because you're lazy? You don't want to pay people their rent? You don't want to pay your mortgage? You don't want to pay. And on top of that, you're borrowing from people knowing that you can't pay back, which actually the Torah says, the minute you borrow money when you know you have no way of paying it back, the Torah calls you a Rasha. So all of that Torah that you learned, it's not going to a good place. Not going to a good place. You're a thief.

1:03:35You're a thief. Why? Because you're lazy. Lazy people are lazy people. They are very, very lazy, and many times they use the Torah as an excuse to be lazy. That's, Rabotai, not a good thing. Not a good thing. The third reason is delusion. That's the third reason. People are delusional. What do they do? They simply think that they became... they just did a year, two, three, four years ago... And they think that they became Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai. How? I'm just simply going to be here, I'm going to read some books, and I'm going to watch some videos whenever I get a chance, in between breakfast, lunch, and dinner, and, you know, a few desserts. And also... a little bit of TV, and also a little bit of sports, and also a little bit of CNBC, and Hashem is going to send me my parnassah. I don't need to go to work. Work is for people who have no emunah. I have emunah that the money is going to arrive at my house. You don't have emunah. You are lazy. Lazy. Go work. Go work. You are lazy. You don't have emunah. Why? Because the reality is that if you got...

1:04:48...government letter from somebody investigating you, that second all of your emunah goes in the garbage. You're gonna start crying like a little baby. You start crying like a little baby. The reality is, people are lazy, but they're delusional. They're delusional, and they think that they could just sit there and Hashem's gonna send the money. Doesn't work that way... Doesn't work that way. Even the people that do get miraculous parnassah. I can't tell you that I don't live on a miracle. We see miracles on a day-to-day basis. Day-to-day basis. But what do you think? It comes for free? You think that it's something that doesn't come with a lot of tests. You think that the bank account doesn't go to zero and you have no money to eat. You think it doesn't get to a point where you have no idea how you're going to pay the bills. You think it doesn't get to a point where you have major crises. You think it comes for free. People are delusional. But even during that time, you go work. You go do. You keep operating. And that's the reality. Emunah is not something that you acquire for free.

1:05:54requires an enormous amount of Torah, mesirat nefesh, and a lot of other things. And I can tell you myself, it's not easy. It's not for everybody. But people think it's just because they're lazy that they don't have emunah. It doesn't work that way. It doesn't work that way. One day before the shiur, I wish I could share all of the different miracles that we've gone through, but at the same token, all of the different tests that we have to go through in order to get there. And even there, B'ezrat Hashem, we're only 1% of 1%, B'ezrat Hashem, of having actual real emunah. To have real emunah, Rabotai, is a lifelong mission that's full of hurdles and difficulties and tests, and so on and so forth. It doesn't come for free. It doesn't come for free; it doesn't come easy. And people that are lazy, many times, will use the Torah as an excuse to do nothing. What are you doing? No, I'm starting a business. What business are you starting? I'm still thinking about it. Well, last time I asked you six months ago, eight months ago, you were still thinking about it. Yeah, no, back then I wanted to maybe do an Amazon store, but now I'm thinking eBay. Oh, so eight months it took you to think that instead of opening an Amazon store to sell a product you don't even have, you are now thinking to open an eBay store, but you still don't have a product. You are lazy.

1:07:11You are lazy, and the only reason why you're still alive is because you're torturing the people around you. Borrowing money you can't repay, cheating people, telling them that you're going to pay them back, lying to people, making all types of fake campaigns. And I even have some people, they send me messages literally on a weekly basis and tell me, "Rabbi, can you do me a favor? Can you maybe get some of your people to donate to this campaign? I'm running the campaign." It's always the same guy. He thinks that I'm a fool. three or four years already, he sends me these fake campaigns that he makes. It's all him, but he says, "Oh, it's an anonymous family that, you know, they don't want to disclose their name, but they're really struggling. They don't have any money to pay the mortgage." And you would think, "Oh, wow, you know, Rabbi, you should feel remorseful about it." What don't feel remorse for that person. Why? He chooses to be that way. He sits at home and does nothing all day, other than gamble any dollar that he gets. He gambles, he steals, he does all types of horrible things. That's why he doesn't have any money. He has no integrity, but he keeps stealing from people even more with fake campaigns. And there's other people like that. They send me messages, "Rabbi, you know, 36, 36." They pretty much have 500 people on their contacts, and they send everybody a request for 18, 20, 30 dollars.

1:08:29They don't have to work. Why? They figured that I'll send 500 requests, 10 people are going to answer me. I made my money for the week. Lazy people that are delusional, that are lazy, and that have a huge ego because they think everyone is stupid. Rabotai HaKelim, do not put yourself in that position. And if you identify yourself in any aspect of what I just said for the last hour, correct it immediately. correct it immediately. Do not have any stolen money on your hands. Not because you're lazy, not because you're delusional, and not because you're egotistical and think the world owes you something. That does not give you the right to steal from them. It's very important to have a clean business, a clean way to make a living, and most importantly, clean hands. Clean hands. And if you don't have clean hands because you've made some mistakes...

1:09:30No problem. Fix it. Immediately. Fix it immediately. Fix it immediately. Sometimes I talk about this subject, tell people, listen, you have stolen money, give it back right away. Give back right away. And some people don't have the money. But some people do have the money. Ah, listen, Rabbi, you know, I did this, this, this, and this. And I stole, you know, I have, you know, I have like $20,000 in the bank. But if I pay this $10,000 right away, I mean, it's half my money. Can I just make payments? That's a foolish person. That's a foolish person. Why? You have the money that you stole. And not only that, you have even more than the money that you stole. And you're thinking, let me just make some payments. Who guarantees you that you're going to live long enough to make all those payments? And the best part is usually it's small, tiny payments where it's going to take them a thousand years to pay it back. That's an egotistical person who thinks God is stupid. Not only the people, God is stupid. That's what he thinks. I'm telling you, and I'm telling you again, do not be such a person.

1:10:41Do not be such a person. You have to know it is critical for a person to combine this Torah with a way to make a living. If you don't have a way to make a living, then you need to find one. You have to find one. You have to find one. And if you're saying, no, no, but I want to be a Torah scholar, then that means the second you wake up, you go to the kollel. And you're there until you can't see straight anymore. Because you're studying all day, then you go, spend some time with your family, and then you go back to learning a little bit more, and then you go to sleep. But if you're only learning one, two, three hours a day, you should get a job. You should get a job. Why? Because you should be able to learn a few hours a day and work. You should be able to do both. But if you're only learning at kollel and you don't really want to go to work, talk to me. Maybe I'll smack some sense into you and hopefully either get you to study more or get you to work. But you can't continue wasting your life. Don't waste your life, Rabotai. You have 24 hours in a day. You're not supposed to waste a single minute of it. Even your sleep is supposed to be part of your avodat Hashem.

1:11:52So make sure that every minute of your day is part of your avodat Hashem, whether it's working by learning Torah, working by doing chesed, by doing mitzvot, by doing kiruv, or working for some company, working for your own company to make a living so you can eat, so you don't have to live on some fantasy, and definitely not on stolen money. B'ezrat Hashem, we'll continue answering your questions now after I get a little bit of a drink, and then B'ezrat Hashem we'll continue. I made a beracha before. Okay, let's see the questions. Wait a minute. Where are the questions today? Okay. They changed the section for the questions. Interesting. Okay.

1:12:52Let's see. One is asking, what exactly were the ma'amadot in ancient times? I'm sorry, I don't understand the question. I understand the question, I'm sorry. uh, Ethan, uh, is using a light bulb permissible to substitute for a candle on Shabbat if needed? And, uh, two, how does one believe in... Okay, two very good and very different questions. So, in regards to using a light bulb If a person does not have candles because he cannot afford to buy candles, or he completely forgot, it's a one-off, not on a regular basis, he forgot to buy them and he doesn't have enough time to buy them because Shabbat is coming,

1:14:00...or the candles that he has are simply not working for whatever reason, then a person can turn on the light and turn off the light, and then turn on the light as a light bulb. However, that's not something that a person should do, but rather only as a last resort. If you find yourself doing that twice in one year, it already shows that there's a problem... Two, how does one believe in Lashon Hara? Okay, so the issues of Lashon Hara are very extensive. The Chafetz Chaim wrote extensively about Lashon Hara. It's translated into English and many other languages, but in general, there are three people that are punished for the issues of Lashon Hara. the person that says Lashon Hara, the person that listens to the Lashon Hara and believes it, and also even the person that Lashon Hara is being told about. Why? Because the Gemara says that no one is spoken against, no one is someone that is embarrassed because they're innocent. There really is a reason for it.

1:15:11excuse me, so but the point being is that both the main punishment obviously is for the guy that says and the guy that believes him. So, let's say, for example... Somebody says to you, "Oh, you see, Steve? Yeah, Steve, you know, he makes five million dollars a year, and he just donated a million dollars to tzedakah (charity)." Who says Steve wants you to tell people about how much money he donated? you believe this, you say, "Oh wow, Steve donated a million dollars! Wow, if I had five million dollars, I also would donate a million dollars!" You just believed. You believe, so it's very important that as soon as somebody says something in the name of somebody else, you say, "Oh, hold on a second. Do me a favor. I don't want to hear it. I don't want to hear it. Why? I don't want to be a partner. I'm just not interested."

1:16:17The best rule of thumb is to do your best to avoid talking about specific people. You could talk about things, but don't talk about specific people. Don't talk about specific people. You could even give examples. Listen, there's a person I heard about. He was in some business, and he made $5 million, and he took 20% of his money and donated it. That has the same value as saying that Steve made $5 million and donated $1 million. now, of course, saying Steve did it and you both know Steve, and Steve happens to live down the street, is a much juicier statement, but it's forbidden. It's forbidden to say, it's forbidden to believe. So, it's important for a person to avoid talking about people. Also, if somebody says, "Listen, I heard this guy did such and such a bad thing," you're not allowed to say, "Okay, I heard this guy called you a..."

1:17:22That's the most common. The most common Lashon Hara is when your so-called friend tells you that somebody else, who is also your friend, said some nice things about you sarcastically. He said he called you A, B, C, D, E, F, G, and came up with enough curses to fit every letter of the alphabet and everything. And he is your true friend. He's coming to you and telling you about it. You are forbidden from believing this person. You're forbidden from believing this person. And in fact, you're foolish if you believe this person. Why? Because the reality is, believing him is believing Lashon Hara. That's number one. Number two, why would you believe a sinner about somebody else that he is accusing of sinning? Usually, the sinner always accuses everybody else of being sinners. That's the reality. He always wants to cancel everybody else. But the Gemara says, a person who cancels other people, he himself is canceled.

1:18:33uh so if he comes to you and pretends to be your friend and says that, listen, this guy called you all these different names, it's something personal, you're not allowed to believe him, not to believe him. Now, you can't verify it, you can ask Steve if he said such and such. You can pick up the phone and go meet him. Listen, Steve, I heard that you said A, B, C, D, E, F, G about me, is this true? And if Steve obviously says it's true, then you could say, okay, so I know what he said is true and... no longer the guy admitted to yourself, but until then you're not allowed to believe it. And by believing it, it means that you can't go and dislike or go against Steve who supposedly said something about you until you verify it. So, let's say for example, somebody says to you, "Steve said ABC about you." And that, if he really did say those things, that would cause you to fire him if he works for you. That would cause you to not want to be his friend. That would cause you to disassociate with him. You're not allowed to do any of those things until you verify. Until you verify. Now if you say, "No, I don't want to be in an altercation. Let me just disconnect." Not allowed. Why? That's taking revenge. That's taking revenge, and that's wrong. You have to go verify. Go and verify. So you either completely...

1:19:57Don't believe and disregard everything that was told to you as if it wasn't told, as if it was deleted from your mind. Or go and verify, see if he said it. If he said it, then you can do whatever it is that you want to do that's appropriate. But to simply believe what this sinner told you about somebody else is a crime and it's foolish because he is the sinner telling you about somebody else's sin. He's not a reliable witness. Not a reliable witness. So it's important to know. Next question, Bill. Is a thief allowed to come to the victim and ask for forgiveness without paying back the stolen money? If the thief goes to pay back the stolen money but the victim tells the thief that they don't need to pay the money back, does the thief have to insist? If the victim continues to refuse the money, does the thief have an obligation to give the money to charity? Sorry for asking so many questions at once. Thank you, Rabbi. Okay, so a person that stole money is not forgiven until he returns the money. He cannot say, "I'm sorry," and that would be enough. He has to return the money. He has to return the money. Now, if he comes to the victim and says, "Listen, I stole fifty dollars from you, fifty thousand from you, and I'm going to pay you back. I either have the money right now or I have part of the money and I'll pay you the rest," and the victim says, "No, no, no, you don't need to pay me back. I forgive you, I forgive you, I forgive you," then you're forgiven. No problem. You can move on with your life.

1:21:09Now, if he comes to the person and says, "Listen, I stole fifty dollars from you, fifty thousand from you, and I'm going to pay you back. I either have the money right now or I have part of the money and I'll pay you the rest," and the person says to you, "No, no, no, you don't need to pay me back. I forgive you, I forgive you, I forgive you," then you're forgiven. No problem. You can move on with your life. can move on with your life, but you have to have him do it. Don't say, "Hey, listen, I can't pay you back, but maybe you could just..." No, no. Tell him, "I'm going to pay you back. I owe you fifty thousand, a thousand, two thousand, five thousand, and I'll pay you every so often. I'll pay you the money." Fine. But if he says, "No, you don't have to pay me back," fine. It's like he just gave you a gift. But if, let's say, for example, you stole the money and the guy that you stole it from died or disappeared off the face of the earth, and after a lot of effort, you can't find him, what do you do? You have to give that money that you stole from him to charity, to a public cause that could potentially affect him. Whether it's publicizing the Torah that could potentially affect him, or it's something that is connected to him. So, let's say, for example, if he lives in the city of New York.

1:22:30Maybe you could, you know, invest in something like a public cause, such as a homeless shelter or some type of public water treatment. Whatever it is, it should be a public cause. Obviously, the best is Torah, but nonetheless, you have to give the money that you stole to something that he could potentially benefit from. But that's only... If you cannot reach him because he either died or because you can't find him, he simply moved away. Nobody knows where he is. But I've had situations where people, you know, identify that they had stolen money in their hands, know who the people are that they stole from, know exactly where those people live, and still tell me, "Listen, Rabbi, can I just give it to you as charity?" as you know, why don't you give it to them? No, if I give it to them, that means I need to admit that really they were right and I did steal from them, and that's going to bring my family a lot of embarrassment, so I have to avoid it and so on. So technically, the embarrassment is actually good for you, and that's really the ideal way to do teshuva for it. But even if you can't deal with that, then I told her, listen, just give it to her anonymously.

1:23:47Make sure you go or send somebody to put money in a place where you know for sure they are the only ones who are going to get it right away without putting your name on it, and they get the money. "No, but maybe I could just give it to you as charity." I tell them, "Do me a favor, do not donate this money to me. Do not donate this money to an organization." "Oh, why are you like that, Rabbi?" "I'm not like that. I don't want stolen money. I don't want stolen money." And I've done that several times with people where they told me of some different, you know, fugazi act that they're doing, that they're stealing in one way or another or whatever. And they think that I am going to solve their problem. No, it doesn't work that way. yes, if you cannot pay this other person back because they don't exist anymore or giving them back the money could put you in harm's way, like for example if you stole from, I don't know, you stole from the government. You know that if you tell the government that you stole money from them, they'll put you in jail for a nice 20-30 years, so you can't really tell them. So yeah, you can take such money and you can donate it to our organization or to other organizations that are doing good things, sure.

1:25:03but as part of your teshuva, because you cannot technically put yourself in harm's way for the sake of returning the money, you can do that. We've had people who have done that with us, where they couldn't return the money to certain entities, so they would donate the money and so on. Fine, but if you know that you can't do it and you just don't want to deal with it don't send me stolen money, don't send me stolen money. This is not Christianity, this is not Christianity where I'm going to tell you, "Listen, go throw a few Hail Marys and make sure not to fumble," and that's going to solve your problems. It's not going to be, not going to be... You know we want to have both siyata d'Shmaya in all of our Torah. We want things to be as kosher as possible, and sometimes we have to make hard decisions that have to do with money and even return money to certain people because of certain things. And baruch Hashem, every time we've done it, we've had amazing results, amazing results. Moshe, nobody ever loses as a result of following what Hashem says. And

1:26:10Next, Robert, as an Uber driver, how much should I be talking to my customers? Many people like to have conversations, but we have a limited amount of words to speak in our lifetime. Also, a man must not increase words with a woman. Should I try to avoid talking? generally speaking, you're 100% right. Talking to women, for sure, you should not do. And even for men, wasting your words about nonsense is not exactly conducive to your life or even to your job. It doesn't matter that they prefer to talk. The key is what's good for you, but also what's good for your business. So I've used Uber and other types of services throughout my whole life. I'm not exactly... I don't need somebody to talk to me. It's nice to have a conversation with some people sometimes, but generally speaking, people are too busy, and they don't necessarily mind a little bit of quiet. But even if a person wants to talk, you don't necessarily need to do the talking. You could just sound like you're interested. "Oh, really?" And then let them talk for five hours.

1:27:20yeah, okay, let them talk for another three hours. That way you're not, you know, pushing them off. You're not being nasty to them; you're letting them talk. They want to talk? Let them talk. They can talk themselves, but you don't necessarily need to join the conversation and start telling them about your wife and your kids and your husband and your dog and your cat and and your uncle and how you found your friend from childhood. You don't need to do all that stuff. Let them do the talking. If that's what they want to do, they need to talk. Sometimes people need to talk to get rid of certain anxieties. It's a problem that some people have where they need to talk and it's actually considered chesed. It's considered chesed to listen to them. It's considered chesed. There's a very famous story with Rav Moshe Feinstein where one time he was obviously a very, very busy person. Aside from learning an enormous amount of Torah each and every day, he built Judaism in America. American Judaism does not understand how much

1:28:25It owes three major rabbis, which are the Klausenberger Rebbe, Rabbi Moshe Feinstein, and Rabbi Aharon Kotler. These are the three giants that built American Judaism. Surely, there are others that have contributed immensely, but they were the ones that were really the pillars from the beginning. Now, he was very busy. He had a lot of learning, a lot of teaching, a lot of beit din, and so on and so forth. So, Chachamim, in general, are very precise about their schedule. One time, Rabbi Moshe Feinstein told the people that were at the kollel, "Oh, come on, here's a little cake. We're going to do a siyum haShas." I mean, the Rav completed the Shas countless times, but they saw that the Rav was much more excited about this Shas. Much more excited about this Shas. They asked, "Rav, what's so special about this Shas that the Rav is so celebrating? The Rav must have completed the Shas many times. Why is this one so special?" He said, "No, this one took me 20 years to complete."

1:29:38many years to complete the Shas. What, did you learn all of the mefarshim and the poskim and everything? No, no, no. I learned the Shas like every other time, but it took me 20 years. Why did it take me 20 years? He says because this is a Shas I only learned when there was a little bit of time between changing the tefillin, putting on the tefillin, taking off the tefillin, and also anytime I was in the elevator. Anytime I was in the elevator, there's a little bit of time. You know, there's two minutes here, one minute there, three minutes there. That's when I would learn it. That's when I would learn it. Finish the Shas in 20 years. Rabotai, if we finish the Shas in 20 years by reading it regularly, not on an elevator, regularly studying all day, that's already a ma'ala. Rabbi Moshe Feinstein was so precise with his time, he calculated every minute, every minute, that he would finish an additional Shas on top of the countless other times that he finished it. And some people say he finished it over 400 times.

1:30:39Point is, how did he finish it 400 times? Was he a speed reader? No, he took advantage of every single minute, every single minute. While we're all chatting, "Hey, how you doing? How you doing? How's the wife? How's the kid? Where you going for vacation?" All that nonsense. Don't do it. They don't do it. But that doesn't mean that they're nasty to people. Doesn't mean they're nasty to people. Rav Moshe Feinstein, zt"l, one time had to go to an important meeting. He was about to get into a car, but a very poor man came to the Rav. "Call the Rav, call the Rav, please, please." Now, usually, the Rav would have to go. And the guy that was taking him, the Rav's helper, said, "I'm sorry, the Rav is busy." Rav Moshe Feinstein said, "No, no, yes." He stopped. He said, "Yes." Now, the driver knew that they had a schedule to meet. The Rav was very busy, but the Rav said, "No, okay, quiet." then the poor man gets a dollar from the Rav or whatever amount of money that he got, whatever he had in his pocket—a few dollars, whatever it was.

1:31:46as he gives him the money, the guy starts pouring his heart out to Rav Moshe Feinstein. "And you know, I used to do this and that, and it is, and it is..." And the Rav, and the helper is looking at this like, "Listen, you got the money, you got the Rav’s attention. Yeah, let's go already." That's what he's thinking. He's thinking there's a mitzvah here to do, to help the Rav. The Rav says, "No, let him talk." He talks to him for 10 minutes. People that would come to see him sometimes wouldn't get that much time. This poor man got 10 minutes of his time, and he kept talking and talking and talking about all of his life's problems and how he had all this misfortune and Hashem, all of these problems. And Rav Moshe Feinstein is there, listening attentively to every word that he says. Every word that he says. 10 minutes. He says, "Thank you. I'm sorry. I'm in a hurry. I have to go, but I really appreciate it. We can talk in the future and so on." And the guy was so happy. He took the tzedakah that he got from the Rav, and he had a smile on his face like, "That's it. That's all I need in life." Rav went inside the car. They started going and, of course, the people that are there with them, the helpers that are there, it's like, "For the Rav, lamdeni, teach us. Teach us."

1:33:02Why did you spend so much time with this, you know? Not exactly. He says, my tzedakah wasn't the money; my tzedakah was the chesed, the chesed of giving him my time. That's what he needed. He didn't need the money; he didn't come to me for the money. He came to me for those 10 minutes. That's what my thought was. Sometimes listening to somebody talk, that's the chesed you need to give. But don't go out and take this advice to the extreme and just talk to everybody that wants to talk to you and waste your entire life. No, you have to obviously be very careful, very precise. But the point being is... my tzedakah wasn't the money; my tzedakah was the chesed, the chesed of giving him my time. That's what he needed. He didn't need the money; he didn't come to me for the money. He came to me for those 10 minutes. That was my thought. Sometimes listening to somebody talk, that's the chesed you need to give. But don't go out and take this advice to the extreme and just talk to everybody that wants to talk to you and waste your entire life. No, you have to obviously be very careful, very precise. But the point being is in your particular profession, let them do the talking. You could just hum, nod, say "yes," "wow," "thank you," "wow," "go on." That's what you should do. They don't necessarily need you to get involved. Next. Rabbi, can you go a little bit into the halacha of gezel? We just talked about it for an hour. Let me see.

1:34:20Charlie, can you explain the second half of the prayer of Nasi regarding sacred birds and holy sparks? I'm sorry, I don't understand the question. It's too early today. I don't understand. Okay, Bill, is a person allowed to make a declaration that they forgive everyone who has wronged them in any way, stealing, just as a sort of catch-all, in case someone once wronged me, but I forgot about it? If you want to do that, you have to do that privately, not publicly. Do it privately, and you could write a list of all the different people that have hurt you, stole from you, hurt you, whatever it is, write a list. Excuse me, and then look at the name. ...and think about what happened and say, "I forgive this person." Pray for them and then move on to the next name and the next name. But actually think about what happened and forgive them wholeheartedly, not just say it blindly like some superheroes do, who want to pretend like they are tzaddikim, and they make a Facebook post, "I forgive everyone. I don't have any hard feelings against anyone." Three seconds later, somebody cuts them off, and all the curses in the world come out, you know...

1:35:44Why? This is ego. Ego. People make public statements about how they forgive everyone, they love everyone; they just want everyone to think that they're tzaddikim. Don't do stuff like that. You want to forgive everyone for stealing from you, for saying bad things about you? No problem. That's a very good thing to do, very praiseworthy, only if it's legit and you do it privately. Nobody knows. Nobody knows about it except you. You write the names down, you pray for each and every single one of them, and you say, "I forgive you," after you think about what they've done to you and you forgive them wholeheartedly. Then you have yourself a very, very serious act that's praiseworthy. But if you do anything else, like publicizing it to the whole world that you don't feel bad and everyone is great no matter what they did to you, that's nonsense. That's all ego, and that's not going to get you anywhere. so make sure you do it right. I'm not saying that you're doing the wrong thing; I've just seen the wrong thing done so many times. It's usually a couple of times a year during the yamim right before Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur where there's a massive text message forwarding campaign.

1:36:53sends everybody some blanket statement that they most likely didn't even write themselves, of how they are sorry for all the things they did to you, and they hope you forgive them. They just send you a text and think that qualifies as an apology. Not only is it not an apology, it's chutzpah. It's chutzpah! You want somebody to forgive you? You did something wrong to them? Go call them or meet them and say, "I'm sorry." Don't send me a text message saying, "I'm sorry." The best thing is sometimes people tell me, "They send me this message, Rabbi, I'm really sorry." What do they think, I'm a prophet? What do they think, I'm a prophet? They send me a text message. The only information that I have is I already have their name stored in my phone, so I know who they are, and that they say, "I'm sorry." They think that this means something to me. Most of the time, I don't even respond. So I wait for them to give me some more information. The best is when people are just saying, "Hi," like they expect me to respond to them and start having a social conversation with them. I hate that. Don't send me a "Hi" message. Do me a favor. Don't ask me how I am. You have a question? Ask the question. Don't ask me how I am. That's not a question.

1:38:03That's an opening for conversation. Just tell me what you want. But the worst thing is, somebody says, "I'm sorry, Rabbi." They're waiting for me to ask them, or say, "Don't worry about it," or "What did you do?" I don't do that. Usually, I wait for them to tell me what they did. And the best thing is, "Oh, I'm sorry, Rabbi. I said really bad things about you to all my friends. You know, I disagreed with you, but really, now I know that you're right and you're saying the truth. But I said a lot of bad things to all my friends about you. But I hope you forgive me." Habibi, that's not an apology. That apology you can take and delete it. ...could take that apology and throw it in the garbage. Why? It doesn't matter if I forgive you. I could forgive you until I'm blue in the face; it doesn't make a difference. Hashem has to forgive you. Why? You went against someone that teaches Torah to help people do teshuvah. Now those people, therefore, are not going to want to learn their Torah, and that could lead them to not do teshuvah. You have HaKadosh Baruch Hu to deal with now. So how do you fix it with HaKadosh Baruch Hu? What do you think, if you say I'm sorry to Him that's going to be enough? No, habibi...

1:39:13you have to go and meet every single person you said bad things about because you're saying bad things about Torah, not about me. Who cares about me? I'm a zero, less than zero. You said something about what I'm saying. I'm not saying things in my opinion. I'm saying what the Torah says. I'm saying Mishnayot. What am I saying? What am I saying? You're saying you don't like it, and you're saying it. You have to go, talk to every single person, say, "Listen, I said this is nonsense, he's crazy, he's fanatic, he's this, this. I'm wrong. I'm wrong. Everything he says is a myth, whatever, whether it's about me or somebody else." That's an apology. You want to do that? You don't do that. Yeah, no problem. As far as me forgiving you, I forgive you automatically. You don't even have to tell me you're sorry. You don't even have to say I'm sorry for all the bad things you said about me. You don't have to say I'm sorry at all. Don't waste your time telling me I'm sorry about the bad things you said about me. Don't waste your time. Number one, I already forgive you. I already forgive you. I care less. You could write a whole blog about me. I forgive you. Forgive you. Why? I feel bad for you. Why? Because the amount of damage that you brought on yourself by doing what you did, the last thing you want is for me to be upset about it.

1:40:29You already caused yourself so much trouble. Because of that, I feel bad for you. How much damage you brought to your life. So, I forgive you. I forgive you automatically. Don't worry about it. Don't waste your time saying "I'm sorry" to me. Go fix it really with the other people. Go fix it really by writing different articles. Go fix it really by publicizing the real truth of what should be done. Don't waste your time telling me "I'm sorry." Go say "I'm sorry" to HaKadosh Baruch Hu for desecrating His Torah and desecrating His name. That's what you should focus on. As far as me, I forgive you. I'm sorry that you even got to that point. what people don't understand is that so many times people think that if they send a blanket text message to random people, or their parents, or their brothers, saying, "Listen, I'm sorry if I did anything bad to you. I hope you forgive me and I forgive you," they think that's an apology. That's not an apology. An apology requires effort. "Yeah, but it's embarrassing." Okay, it's embarrassing. Good, good, it's embarrassing. That's a real apology. If an apology is not embarrassing, it's not an apology.

1:41:35If you're not embarrassed while you're apologizing, you're not really apologizing. You're not really apologizing. Look at a little kid. Look at a little kid where you say, you know, he did something wrong. He did something wrong to his sister. He did something wrong to his brother. You tell him, listen, say, I'm sorry. Is that kid happy to do it? If it's a real apology, he's not happy to do it. Why? He's embarrassed. So what happens many times when a little kid says, I'm sorry? He starts crying. starts crying, "Oh, I'm sorry I did it to you." Why? He's embarrassed. It's a natural thing. If you're not embarrassed, it's not really an apology. It's not really an apology. So, text message—nobody's crying over text messages. Nobody's crying over text messages. Don't make apologies over text message; it's a waste of time, a waste of time. It's just a false sense of righteousness, and it also stems from ego. Welles says, "Should I still give tzedakah to random homeless people I see if there's a slight chance they might spend the money on drugs? Should one go out of their way to give money to homeless people they see if there's a chance they might be dangerous?"

1:42:42uh, no and no. Uh, listen, it all depends on what you mean by money. If a homeless person comes to you and asks for it, you know, for charity, you can give them one dollar. Uh, it's not a problem. Uh, give them one dollar and walk away and don't spend much, uh, much time there because they could be dangerous. You know, to put yourself in danger and definitely do not go out of your way to give any homeless person or any person that could be dangerous, even if they're not homeless, charity. Do not put your life in harm's way. That is not a suggestion. That's not advice from the Torah. It's not the right way to think. And, in fact, you shouldn't even give them that much money. You should give them a dollar, two dollars, that's it. I mean, it all depends on your financial situation, but not much. Why? Because you don't know where the money is going to go, and it's best to focus on giving the real money that you have for the sake of the Torah. That's what you want to do. You want to publicize the Torah because it's not just about what you give, it's what fruits, what you give, ends up with. Because, you know, you could have an apple,

1:43:50could have an apple, and that apple could be worth a dollar, or that apple could be worth $100,000. How could an apple turn from $1 to $100,000? Simple. If you take that apple, and right after you finish eating it, you take the seeds of that apple, and you plant them, and you plant them, and you water them, and you plant them, and you water them, and you water them, and you water them, and you let the tree grow, and now you have an apple tree. Simple. If you take that apple, and right after you finish eating it, you take the seeds of that apple, and you plant them, and you water them, and you plant them, and you water them, and you water them, and you water them, and you let the tree grow, and now you have an apple tree. have an apple tree. That apple tree will give you apples for as long as it's alive, and that is going to generate you a countless amount of money and food and so on and so forth. So now, when you give money to some homeless person, the best case scenario is you have yourself an apple. That's the best case scenario. But when you give to the Torah, automatically it's a field of apple trees. If it's the right Torah, if it's the right place, if you're giving it to one of these fake organizations that only care about money and spend it on themselves, their houses, cars, and all types of garbage, then unfortunately it's better to give it even to the homeless person than to those people.

1:45:00but if you give it to a legitimate Torah organization where they use that money to actually publicize Torah, to help people, and so on and so forth, then you have yourself not only an apple tree, you have a field of apple trees. You have a lot of good, and that's what you should do. Now, unfortunately, because people have changed over the years, it's very important to know that people have become much more dangerous today than they were in the past. In the past, it was customary that people who are not from town would come to different communities, and each week, different people within the community would host them in their houses. Strangers, you know, this rabbi came from a different town, this Jewish guy came from a different town, they're in town, and the community would, everybody would take turns to host these guests that are from out of town. It's not that they were invited by anybody. They were just simply stopping over and had to stop traveling for Shabbat. So they stopped at that community and would go to shul. After shul, they would need to go somewhere to eat something for Shabbat. It wasn't like today, where there are hotels everywhere and so on. So they had to eat somewhere for Shabbat. What would the community do? Each week, a different family or a different group of families would host the guests from out of town.

1:46:22Why? Because that was the traditional way of doing things, and that was the way that things were done for, you know, since the beginning of time. Today, Rabotai, Rabbi Ovadia Yosef zt"l says, you don't really do that anymore. Why? Because today, people have become much more dangerous, and it was after a story that happened that this changed, where there was a person that came into town, that no one knew, but clearly looked like a very righteous person, a Torah scholar. And one couple that did not have any kids thought that if they host this person and help him, that maybe this would be a segula for having children, for doing good things. Maybe Hashem would help them have a kid. And they hosted this person, and the person said, listen, I'm here from out of town. I need to be hosted for some time if you... uh could let me study here and they said sure you have a room and you could study as much as you want. You'll have breakfast and lunch at the same time, or dinner every day, and you could study as much as you want. And that's that. That's how it was. This person literally would enter the room in the morning, start learning, and would not leave. He would not get out of the room other than to take the bowl of food.

1:47:45to eat and that's it. For months, months like this. A few months like this. It got to the point where everybody's like, "You guys won the lotto. You have one of the 36 hidden tzaddikim in your house. The guy doesn't leave the room. He's studying Torah all day, all night. Unbelievable! This guy must be, maybe he's the Mashiach, maybe he's this, maybe he's that." And people were amazed by it. And the couple themselves were very happy to do it. You know, they were a very simple couple. Very, very modest and very humble and so on. One day, this is one of the stories that when I heard it, and even right now I'm telling it, I know this happened. And it's a disaster. A disaster, Rabotai. One day, the husband comes back from his work and he sees that the room of the guy is open and he's not there and his bags are not there. Then he sees his wife crying and he says, "Honey, what happened? What happened?" She says, "I'm sorry, I'm sorry." He says, "What? I'm sorry? What happened? What happened?"

1:49:03says, "I'm sorry. What happened? Why are you crying? What happened?" She says, "He's been here for several months, and he's learning in this and that. Today, when you went to work, this rosh yeshiva looked out and he came to me, and he said to me..." I've been here for several months, and I've noticed that you pray and you're a good woman and so on, but you don't have any children in this house. And she said, "Yeah." He said, "You know how I'm able to sit here? You know how I'm able to sit here and study for all these hours, for all these months?" And she says, "No, I don't know." And she's scared; it's the first time he's talking to her in a few months. He says, "Because really, I'm Eliyahu HaNavi." I'm Eliyahu HaNavi, and in order for me to bring the Mashiach, it has to come from you. It has to come from you. He says, "Okay, so give me a bracha." She says, "No, it has to come from you and me."

1:50:14says, "I was so desperate, and I believed everything that he said. That Hashem, she committed the act with him. Hashem, and only after this pig, this filthy, disgusting excuse for a person, completed the act..." did she realize she made the mistake of her life? He is not only not Eliyahu HaNavi; he's not even the dust that Eliyahu HaNavi ever walked on. And all he will ever see from Eliyahu HaNavi is the command to destroy him for eternity in Gehinom. That's all he's gonna see from Eliyahu. But this rasha was a sick person. that, uh, made this crime. It was obviously a planned crime; it was not in the heat of the moment. It wasn't a one-time thing—it was a planned crime. He had such a sick mentality that he would pretend to be learning Torah for months at a time, with this being the ultimate goal. And because of sick people like this and, unfortunately, how easy it is sometimes to fool certain people, it says

1:51:26you cannot host strangers in your house. You can't host strangers in your house; you have to know who they are. You have to have something to reference regarding their history. Don't just pick up some stranger off the street and say, "I'll come to my house, and I'll host you," and think that you're doing a mitzvah. It's not good; it's too dangerous. You're putting your life or your family's life at risk. There have been some stories where it's not just a destroyed marriage but also other things. uh, worst murder and so on. So you have to be very careful in today's world. But nonetheless, as far as being kind to people, it's good to be kind, but that doesn't mean that you have to put yourself at risk. Don't put yourself at risk. uh, did Hashem create all of His own traits? Uh, that's a non-starter question, and the reason why is because that is a misunderstanding of Hashem as a result of comparing Hashem to us. What does that mean? See, we as human beings...

1:52:27however smart or foolish, however good-looking or ugly, tall, short, male, female, and so on, we are comprised of parts. We are comprised of parts not just physically, where we have different organs and bones and things of that nature, but rather, we are parts where our thoughts are separate from us. Our thoughts are separate from us; they're not one with us. And our memories are also separate from us. and the reality is that we don't necessarily need this body to have these thoughts and memories and so on. Whereas HaKadosh Baruch Hu, when we say, our God is one. What does it mean, "our God is one"? It means that Hashem is one. He does not have parts, and by not having parts, that means that His past, present, future, His thoughts—all of that are one.

1:53:35There is no Hashem being separate from His thoughts or traits or so on. There are different aspects of Hashem where, in a Kabbalistic world, there are different stages that you have, ten different Kavanot, and so on. that you have in a Kabbalistic world, but those things are not different parts of Hashem. That would make it idolatry. The traits of Hashem are not separate from each other; they're, in essence, all different facets of the same Hashem. He's not separate; His thoughts are one with Him. What does that mean? that actually is one of the most extraordinary things that I've learned, and maybe, maybe I will fully understand it one day and maybe you will as well, is the difference between us and Hashem. When Hashem said, "Let us create man in our image," He meant that in a deeper sense.

1:54:39So it's obviously not "man in our image" where we look like Hashem because Hashem doesn't have a body. He has no body, has no likeness of a body, and so on. But rather, He created us like Him, where we have the ability to know the difference between right and wrong. But more so, we have the ability to create. We have the ability to create. how do we create? Uh, now most people think when they think creating, they think maybe they're a YouTuber. They're called creators today. If you're a YouTuber, you're a creator. That's not a creator. Uh, that's an innovator perhaps, but that's not a creator. A creator is someone that makes something out of nothing. And Hashem is the One that makes something out of nothing. But He says He created us in His image, so how could we create something out of nothing? In fact, we do that on a regular basis. We do that on a regular basis with our thoughts. Most people do not value their thoughts. They don't think that their thoughts are, uh, have, uh, such a, uh, such a value or and so on. But the reality is that every single time that you think something, every time there’s something that happens, something is created in the world every single time. That’s where the Gemara, page 26a and also 86, I believe...

1:55:40are, uh, have, uh, such a, uh, such a value, or and so on. But the reality is that every single time that you think something, every time there's something that happens, something is created in the world every single time. That's where the Gemara, page 26a and also 86, I believe but mainly 26 or 83, says the thoughts of sin are worse than a sin. The thoughts of sin are worse than a sin, meaning that the sin itself is limited to physicality. The thought is not limited. But even further, the thoughts of sin is a crime only against Hashem. Whereas the act of sin is a complete disregard for Hashem and for everybody else. How is that so? When somebody, let's say for example, commits gezel, when they rob somebody in broad daylight, it means that the person cares less about Hashem and cares less about man.

1:56:52but when somebody steals at night and behind everybody's back, that means that he only cares less about Hashem. Hence the reason why the punishment is more severe for such a person in some cases, because that's a person that completely disregards Hashem. Now, the Maharhu, Rabbi Chaim Vital, uh, brings that when a person, when a person actually truly understands his thoughts, he would be scared, scared to think about certain things because he would understand that when a person thinks, he is creating certain things in the upper worlds. Those thoughts are going to the highest level of the world. It could be even, and that place, that thought is going into the Kodesh HaKodashim.

1:57:55now, if a person is thinking something holy, sticking to Torah thoughts and so on, he is building. But if he is thinking immorality, if he is angry, he is destroying. In essence, he is bringing a prostitute to the Kodesh HaKodashim of heaven. So much so, so much so, that he writes that Titus, Titus who brought a prostitute into the second Beit HaMikdash and committed the filthy act on top of a Sefer Torah, inside the Kodesh HaKodashim of the Beit HaMikdash. Now, we, as human beings, think that's the worst possible thing you can ever do. The worst desecration of Hashem's name that a person can ever do.

1:58:56right, technically wrong. Technically wrong. Why? The Sefer Nefesh HaChaim says a wise person will understand to have his heart in constant fright and trembling. he pays attention to the actions that are not good and therefore can damage the upper worlds. The words and thoughts that he has can lead to even more destruction than what Nebuchadnezzar and Titus caused when destroying the Beit HaMikdash, and he gives the details of what Titus did, as I just mentioned. and the moment a person desires to think a forbidden thought of immorality, may the Merciful One save us, he thinks of immorality in his head. He is then bringing a prostitute to the place of Kodesh HaKodashim of the awesome upper world, because the mind is the altar of the thoughts, and there is the place of the neshamah.

2:00:19with the whole and in the holy upper worlds when he lets in that thought of immorality, he is letting in the powers of impurity into the holy places in the upper worlds and increases the powers of impurity of the Sitra Achra inside the upper Kodesh HaKodashim, causing much more damage than the impurity brought by the acts of Titus bringing a prostitute into the Kodesh HaKodashim of the lower worlds. And such is each sin that a person allows into their heart—it is like a foreign fire, such as anger or other inappropriate desires. May the Merciful One save us. Meaning that one who is angry, one who is angry, that's a sin that is in his head. He is angry in his head.

2:01:22Because it's in his head, it's in his mind, he causes more damage than Titus caused with his filthy act because the anger in his mind is in his mind and therefore it's damaging the Holy of Holies of the upper worlds. So on this, it is written in the book of Isaiah, chapter 64, verse 10, "The Temple of our holiness and our splendor." where our fathers praised You has become a fiery conflagration, and all that we have desired has become ruined. That, Rabotai, is what happens to the mind. a person allows inappropriate thoughts, and people don't really understand the magnitude of their thoughts. When you think that something is actually being created as a result of your thoughts, that's why if a person really truly understood

2:02:44would learn how to control their thoughts, they could literally turn into something that's as holy as the Holy of Holies, like an angel among men. And that's where the story that I told yesterday about the Maggid Meisharim with Rabbi Yosef Karo comes in. So the point of why I'm saying this whole introduction to this particular issue is that when we think, something is created, and we think, something is created, which means that thought is the highest part of spirituality. However, the difference between us and Hashem—one of the endless differences—is that He created us in His image, but when we think of something, something is created, yet we don't see it. Hashem, on the other hand... when He creates, when He thinks of something, since that thought is not separate from Him, that means that as soon as Hashem thinks of it, it happens instantly. It's not like Hashem thought, planned it out, wrote it in a little book, and then it happened. The second that Hashem has the thought, it is, in essence, at the same time as the act.

2:04:00the creation of the thought is no different than the creation of the actual outcome of the thought. While to us it's a step process that we don't actually get to see most of the time, to Hashem it's a constant reality. So therefore His traits are not separate from Him and nothing else is separate from Him. In fact, that is the reason why the Pasuk says that there's nothing else but Him, and the Zohar HaKadosh comments on it, meaning that there literally is nothing else but Him. Everything in the world, including you and I, and everything else that's in the universe, is all Hashem. The pasuk says that there's nothing else but Him, and the Zohar HaKadosh comments on it, meaning that there literally is nothing else but Him. Everything in the world, including you and I, and everything else that's in the universe, is all Hashem. is all Hashem. There is nothing else other than Him. So He's not separate from His thoughts or from anything else for that matter. Since it was a long question with a short answer, we'll take on maybe another one or two questions.

2:05:08Are dress standards for Noahide women the same as for Jewish women, or do they have more leniency to show elbows, for example? Well, women in general should be modest whether they are Jews or Gentiles. It doesn't necessarily make a difference; they should be modest for several reasons. Number one, it's more respectful, being somebody that was created... uh, by Hashem. But also recognize that they were created by Hashem and recognize that Hashem is watching. So if you were walking around next to the King, you would not be walking around in a bathing suit. Let's just say that. Whether you're Jew or Gentile is irrelevant. The second thing is that you also have to understand that you don't live... alone in the world. And women that dress immodestly end up, they're doing it because they're looking to attract attention. That's why they're doing it. Less clothes do not make a person less hot.

2:06:08doesn't it the material is the, uh, what makes a person less or more hot, but whether you wear long sleeves or short sleeves doesn't necessarily change, uh, whether a person's hot or not. In fact, throughout all of time, uh The world where the Jew or Gentile used to wear long sleeves everything and, in fact, Am Yisrael was in the desert for 40 years not only with long sleeves but with turbans and scarves and everything else. Until this day, people that live in the desert wear complete outfits. complete outfits with turbans, scarves, and you know, their whole body covered. Why? Because it's not the clothing itself—whether short sleeve or long sleeve—that makes you hot or not, it's the material. It's the material. So a person should know that Hashem is the one who created them, and they should know that when they are

2:07:09When they are exposing themselves, they're only doing it for one reason, which is to attract the attention of others. And it's not positive attention, but rather a lustful attention. And that lustful attention is causing other people to sin. And Hashem does not necessarily take revenge on those people because He likes to take revenge, but every cause has an effect. Meaning that Hashem runs the world with a measure for measure. When you cause other men who are married to someone else or are supposed to be married to someone else to not necessarily want to stay married to that someone else because they're thinking about you or somebody like you as a result of seeing your immodesty, or they're thinking about the deficiencies of the person that they're with after they see your beauty, then Hashem has to act in measure for measure. Just like you caused marriage problems, He will give you marriage problems.

2:08:15if you don't have a husband to have marriage problems with, it is very likely you also won't have a husband to have marriage problems with because of that reason. And if you do happen to find a husband who wants to marry you, then Hashem will give you the marriage problems. Why? because you cause marriage problems because of your immodesty and immorality, and therefore, HaKadosh Baruch Hu has to give it to you in return, especially if He likes you, because He wants to give you the suffering in this world. If He doesn't like you, He won't punish you at all in this world, and He'll leave it all for Olam HaBa, where you'll go for eternity if all of it is reserved for that place. But the point being is, is that a woman should be modest at all times and not dress in any way that is attracting people's attention in a lustful way. And if she wants to play stupid and say, no, I'm just wearing short sleeves because I'm hot and all that stuff. Okay, you can play stupid all you want. In Shamayim, they know the secret and they know it's all...

2:09:24bogus. You're only walking around like that because you're looking to get attention, and the fact that you no longer care about that attention because whatever happened doesn't mean that it's okay. You started off that way, where you started off wearing no sleeves. because you were looking for attention, you started off wearing shorter skirts and tighter skirts. You were looking for attention, or better yet, you were lying to yourself by wearing longer skirts that were as tight as the, uh, as tight as the Nazis were on us. you know, these people, these women that wear these tight skirts or these pencil skirts, they think that that's modesty or they think that that's allowed. Anyone that's wearing these tight skirts has to understand it's called a pencil skirt because you're writing yourself your own sentence in Gehinnom. That's why it's called a pencil skirt. There's nothing modest about it. It's actually better to wear loose pants that are like a sack.

2:10:27than to wear those tight pencil skirts. But if you think that that's gonna get you to Heaven, you're sadly mistaken. Sadly mistaken. A woman has to be modest. That's a reality. Why? Number one, it's an acknowledgment that God runs the world and He's the one that created you. Number two, It's because you're not in a vacuum. You're not alone. You are affecting other people. And the only reason to walk around in such a way is because you're looking to attract attention, illicit attention. And I'm specifically talking about Western society places and not if you, let's say, live in a jungle, and there are people there walking around in underwear. I'll be surprised if you're watching my lecture, but nonetheless, if you live in Western society, the reason why you're exposing your body is for bad reasons. It's not for good reasons, and it's definitely not for the weather. And even if it is for the weather today, it wasn't for the weather when it originally started. So, the point being is, people need to be modest, whether Jews or Gentiles.

2:11:28Next question, Jimmy. How important is it for women to understand that a husband must learn Torah? Why? Well, if we learn Torah, then we will learn not only how to be righteous Jews, not only to learn about our G-d, but we will learn what is different between us and animals. That's the difference, that's the one. Why? Because animals, animals operate based on their instinct. If they want something, they go after it. That's how animals work. Animals function based on instinct. They act based on their desires. They're hungry, they go hunt. It doesn't matter that they're tired. If they're hungrier than they're tired, they get the energy and they go kill somebody. Why? they're hungry. Now, what about the fact that that zebra they're about to kill has a family, has kids, was planning on going on vacation next month? It doesn't make a difference. The lion's hungry; he goes and he kills the zebra. He does not care about the fact that this zebra was a really nice guy. It's kind of funny too. It doesn't make a difference why. He has instinct; that's how he operates. But...

2:12:36Most people in the world operate very similarly to animals. They simply are there to fulfill their desires; that's all they're there for. They wake up, go to work in order to make money, in order to get the pride that they want, the intimacy that they want. the food that they want to fulfill their desires. If they didn't have to work and they could just skip all of that work and effort and get straight to the desire, that's what they would do, which would, in essence, eliminate any difference between them and the lions and the zebras. which means the only thing that can restrain a person from acting purely based on their desires is the teachings of the Torah. Why? Because the Torah's number one objective is to teach you how to control and why to control your desires. Because, quite frankly, without the Torah, there is no reason for you to control your desires.

2:13:37If it weren't illegal, people would kill each other left and right just to get their stuff. People would kill each other. If you knew that your next-door neighbor has $500 million and you have a blue-collar job, you're barely making 500 bucks a week, and your next-door neighbor has $500 million, and you know that if you kill him, you're gonna get all that money without any question, and you're not gonna go to jail, and no one's gonna care. What are you gonna do? You're gonna go kill that guy in two seconds. Why? I want the money, I want the results. That's why—why should I continue working for $500? I'll just do this one quick little job, and I'll send this guy to Heaven a little quicker. What stops you? What stops you? You can't say the law, because I said it's legal, right? It's legal. We're playing a hypothetical example. What's going to stop a person? The Torah. Why? The Torah tells you that even if the law of the land allows you to kill, you're still forbidden. Even if the law of the land allows you to commit adultery, you're still forbidden. Even if the law of the land allows you to steal, you're still forbidden. So, in essence, the Torah is the only thing that teaches us how to control our desires and why to control our desires. And the reason why is because God said so.

2:14:54God is the only one that can determine what is good and what is bad. Man cannot determine it. So if a woman wants to marry an animal, she could go to a nightclub, she can go to a zoo, or she could marry a person that doesn't learn Torah. All will be the same. If she wants to marry a human, a person that knows how to control themselves, then she has to make sure she marries a person that's learning Torah, not just before marriage, but every single day. Why? Because if you don't learn Torah every single day, you will not know how to apply it to your life every single day, which means that eventually you'll go back to becoming the animal that you began as. So if a woman wants a happy marriage where she actually has a husband that's a human being and not an animal, then she should send him to learn Torah as much as possible and don't think for a second she's absolved from it, she herself needs to also learn Torah every day—not as much as the husband, but she also needs to learn Torah because she needs to know what to do, how to do, why to do, and so on and so forth. She has to learn Mussar every day, she has to learn the laws of modesty, she has to learn the laws of Shabbat, of holidays, and so on and so forth. She has to learn a lot of Torah every single day. Why? Because she has to know why should I control my desires. needs to also learn Torah every day—not as much as the husband, but she also needs to learn Torah because she needs to know what to do, how to do, why to do, and so on and so forth. She has to learn Mussar every day. She has to learn the laws of modesty, she has to learn the laws of Shabbat, of holidays, and so on and so forth. She has to learn a lot of Torah every single day. Why? Because she has to know why should I control my desires. I have a...

2:16:14I have a person who is in constant conflict with a group of anti-Semites. and in a legal issue and asked me my advice about something. But because there are these anti-Semites, they unfortunately sometimes have a lot of control, a lot of money, and a lot of power in the secular world. One of the arguments that they're using against this person is saying that this person loves God, loves her God, more than she loves her children, and loves our God more than she loves her children. And therefore, that makes her bad because she's different. Now, first and foremost, she's not different. There are literally billions of people in the world who worship a god. Many of them worship the God of Israel. But unfortunately, many of them are worshipping false gods. Nonetheless, those people are willing to die for that god and are willing to kill their kids and so on. So this is really not so different, not now and not in the past.

2:17:18but nonetheless, the God of Israel is unique. Why? Because the God of Israel is not only someone that is expecting you and obligating you to love Him, but in fact, is also obligating you to love your children whom you brought into the world. And when a person understands what this means, that means that unlike what people think, that I love God more than I love my children and that makes me bad, what you don't understand is that my Torah, my Torah actually obligates me, obligates me, not that it's just good, not that it's suggested, but obligates me to act acts of love towards my children by feeding them, clothing them, bathing them, and taking care of them because they're my responsibility. My Torah obligates me to do those acts of love towards my kids, whether I like them or not. towards my children by feeding them, clothing them, bathing them, and taking care of them because they're my responsibility. My Torah obligates me to do those acts of love towards my kids, whether I like them or not. And because of my love for Hashem, I have to do it. So the reality is, it's not that I love Hashem more than I love my children, but rather the only legitimate reason I have to love my children

2:18:33that's beyond anything emotional. My love for God, because that's what obligates me to love my kids, that's what obligates me. Surely, the fact that they're cute and smart and this and that, that's all cute. But if you don't have that, if you don't have that, they're not cute. If each one is like one here, one there, and uh, and then they're not exactly smart. You ask them one plus one, they say, you know uh uh see you know they're not exactly geniuses and you ask them to uh come give me a kiss they go kiss the wall you know you don't have one of those kids are you obligated to love them? you obligated to feed them? Are you obligated to bathe them? Are you able to teach them Torah, spend time with them to make sure that they know what to do? Yes, yes, why not? Because you love them, because you love, because that's what a person has to understand. The Torah is what makes us Adam. Adam. What's Adam? Adam is higher than human. Adam is higher than human. Adam is someone that is a person that is able to speak and is serving HaKadosh Baruch Hu. That's what Adam is. And when a person does that,

2:19:42person is a big success and one person who doesn't, unfortunately, is no different than an animal. So, like I said, if a woman understood what she will have if she does not have a husband learning Torah, then she would not only want her husband to go learn Torah, she would beg him, beg him to learn Torah. And if she doesn't understand still, simply look at the statistics of divorce rates. Over 80% of marriages end up in divorce in Western society. But if you look at the average kollel that has Talmidei Chachamim in Yerushalayim, in Bnei Brak, in Monsey, in Lakewood, all these different places that have kollels, have Avreichim, have Tzaddikim learning Torah, Divorce is only something they learn about because it's part of the halachah; it's not part of the day-to-day. Why? Well, that has nothing to do with us. Sure, it happens from time to time, but the more somebody is glued to the Torah, the more they honor their wife.

2:20:54Like she's a princess, like a queen. The more somebody learns Torah, the more the wife honors the husband. There is no reason to divorce. Why? Torah makes you love each other more than ever. It makes you celebrate each and every single month on mikveh night. Celebrate like it's a celebration of all celebrations. Like you just won the, I don't know, the lotto 500 times. Mikveh night. Mikveh night, the greatest day in the world. Every month? Yes, every month. Every month. What? That's what the Torah teaches. A woman who understands what the Torah teaches would beg her husband, beg her husband to go learn Torah. Beg. Beg. When a person understands what the Torah does, that's all they want. But that's the problem. Many people don't know and therefore they think, no, he's learning Torah so he's spending less time with me. all you got to do is look at Western society and you see that they spend all day with each other. In fact, they spend so much time with each other they forget that they're not husband and wife, even though they act like husband and wife.

2:22:06in together, and they move out together. They have a few this and a few that, and they do this and they do that. They spend all day and night together until they leave each other and say, "I hate you," and say, "I loathe you," and they want to kill each other. They talk bad about each other and curse each other. Why? Just two days ago, you loved each other. You acted like you were husband and wife. What happened? What happened? Nah, she's up to all the curses in the world. But how could it be? How could it be? You spent so much time together. went on vacations together. You bought each other presents. You know how it was—all lust, that's it. Nothing to do with Hashem, nothing to do with Hashem. It was all lust, it was all meeting a physical need. No different than a horse, no different than a lion. Why? That's the world. That's the world—a world without Torah is a world of animals. a world has no right to exist. Why? Hashem is not looking for a world full of animals. The animals were created in order to serve Hashem's people. That's what the animals were created for: to serve Hashem's people. Now, if Hashem's people want to turn into animals, there's no point for the other animals. Why? There's no reason to have both. You have to pick one.

2:23:32world has no right to exist. Why? Hashem is not looking for a world full of animals. The animals were created in order to serve Hashem's people. That's what the animals were created for: to serve Hashem's people. Now, if Hashem's people want to turn into animals, there's no point for the other animals. Why? There's no reason to have both. You have to pick one You have to pick one. And if Hashem has to pick one, He'd pick the actual real animals, the lions and the zebras. Why? Because they're actually better at being animals than human beings are. Go, try racing a zebra. See who's going to win. Go, try out hunting a lion. See who's going to win. try to, you know, outmaneuver any one of the animals. No one. You're not going to maneuver anybody. Go try to fly. You can't. Why? Because you're not as good at being an animal. Unfortunately, people act like animals. Why? Because they're not. So when a person knows what Torah is, they would literally beg, beg their spouse to learn it and even invite them to learn together.

2:24:33but nonetheless, there is a need for a couple to learn a little bit together. However, the husband also needs to learn alone for the majority of his learning because he has a bigger obligation. Okay, one more question: how does a person also get punished when, at the same time, if they are embarrassed, all of his sins can be wiped out? Am I misunderstanding? No, punished in the sense that... First off, you're right. When a person says Lashon Hara about somebody, then actually, the person that's being spoken about gets all of their mitzvot. But the Gemara says in Masechet Moed Katan that they're not saying these bad things about you or these things about you for no reason. This really has more to do not with Lashon Hara, but with Rechilut. Rechilut is with Motzi Shem Ra, when you... say gossip, gossip about somebody. And people are not going to invent gossip about you for no reason. There's usually a little bit of truth in it. So that's, in essence, the problem. It's a little bit different than Lashon Hara. It's like a brainchild of the same thing. That's what I was referring to. Thanks for the correction. Leah Levitan, the Shulchan Aruch says, one

2:25:49should first sleep on his left side for the first half of the night and then switch to his right side for the second half of the night. However, what if one finds that almost every night when sleeping on his left, they experience strange or even perhaps scary dreams, but when sleeping on the right, he experiences nothing of this nature? In this case, is he allowed to sleep on his right side only, or is this a violation? It's an interesting question. Surely, if something is causing you harm, then that opens up certain room for leniency, especially in a case like this. Because even if somebody starts off their night sleeping on their left... Once they're asleep, most people lose control of their body. Most people lose control of their body and they're going to end up moving anyway. So if, let's say for example, you have some type of, you know, sleeping on your left causes you major pain, you have a certain condition, or if, like you said, it's causing you a certain type of trauma,

2:26:56then yeah, you can make the change, especially since the Shulchan Aruch itself says that you would make a change anyway if you would go to sleep later. Meaning if you're sleeping before the middle of the night, which at this point in Florida is somewhere around one o'clock in the morning. So if you go to sleep before the middle of the night, you'd start off on the left side. But if you go to sleep after the middle of the night, you start on the right side. So the Shulchan Aruch is already telling you that there is room here for changes. Needless to say, if it's causing you harm. Yaakov, I'm studying the sefer Sha'ar HaChofetz Chaim, and chapter one says that one of the reasons Am Yisrael was in Egypt so long was due to lashon hara. Do you have more examples? In Rav Alav HaShalom, gave one example. Moshe was ratted out. Yeah, that's the primary example, that when Moshe Rabbeinu

2:28:05Moshe Rabbeinu saw that the Jew was being beaten up by the Egyptian. He saw that the Jew was being beaten up by the Egyptian. And the next day, he saw that two Jews were fighting. And he stopped them. He said, "Don't hit him, you rasha." According to the Torah, as soon as you have your hand up in the air, ready to hit another Jew, without hitting him, you are already considered wicked. So Moshe Rabbeinu told him, "You're wicked." And the person responded, "What are you going to do? Are you going to kill us like you killed the Egyptian?" It says that Moshe Rabbeinu knew that the thing was known. How did he know the thing was known? How did this guy know? How did he know? Because the guy that told them, "What are you going to do? Kill us like the Egyptian?" was the only witness. Why? Because he was the guy that he was protecting, meaning Datan and Aviram were the two that were fighting there. And the day before, one of them was being actually beaten up by the Egyptian.

2:29:12He was being beaten up by the Egyptian. Moshe Rabbeinu came and defended him, saved his life. And instead of being grateful to him, he went and went against him. Not right away, but initially, he appreciated it. Moshe saved his life, right? But the next day, he was fighting with his brother-in-law. They were brothers-in-law. and uh they uh as soon as uh was rebuking him, automatically he became uh the enemy. This unfortunately happens to this day. This happens to this day where you could help somebody do teshuva, you could help somebody convert, you could help somebody even get married And the second you tell them something that they don't like, that's it, you turn into Amalek. And I've seen all of those things happen. I don't deal with this on a regular basis, or even at all, really. I try not to do it, but sometimes I try to help.

2:30:13I don't know, maybe, I don't know if it's yet, but sometimes I try to help people for free. If I have two students that perhaps could be a good match, I try to help them, and I don't like it. I think I've said that before in the past, but nonetheless, I try to do it. With Hashem's help, we've succeeded a couple of times. But one time, I actually had a couple... that they, we made the shidduch. In so many words, we made the shidduch. So you figure, these people, one of them was looking for a shidduch for, like, I don't know, five years or something like that. And the other one was also looking for a shidduch for, you know, a while. And baruch Hashem, we had the merit to find the shidduch, make the shidduch. They got married. So it's the best possible result, right? Guess what? A little while after, They completely disassociated with us. Why? They didn't like a little bit of rebuke that I said was necessary. Turn into the enemy. Turn into the enemy. And that's just the way it happens in life. That's just the way it happens in life. The same thing happened in other aspects, as I've told you in the past. Why? Because that's the way people are. If you don't have...

2:31:27the midat ha'emet, which is the trait of emet, means you have to apply it to yourself on a regular basis, not just to other people. The second you get the emet on yourself, you're going to turn into an enemy. And I see this a lot with people that like to rebuke other people. People that like to rebuke other people usually do not accept it themselves. themselves do not accept it, and I've seen it many times. People rebuke the wrong way. They see somebody putting a picture on the internet or saying something on the internet. Instead of approaching that person privately and then saying, they go off on this person in comments and telling them to change. There's that like couldn't you just go to the guy privately? Like, you had to tear him up? You couldn't be like, "He's not doing this on purpose; he's not a learned person." But that's it, to tear him up. But as soon as you tell that person why, they say that it's all for the sake of Hashem, right? They're defending Hashem or whatever they're doing. The truth is as soon as you do the same thing to them, we're not even... the awful way you tell them privately, "Hey, by the way, I think you're doing the wrong thing here."

2:32:39that's it. They turn you into... and this all stems from ego. It all stems from ego. And as far as Am Yisrael, unfortunately, for a while... and one of the other examples that you can see in the Torah itself during that time is with Yosef HaTzaddik. was guilty of against his brothers where he told his father Yaakov that his brothers were acting inappropriately because he saw them talking to women. He saw them eating an animal that he believed was not kosher, and he didn't investigate exactly what they were doing. In fact, they were doing the right thing. they were doing the right thing. The animal was an animal that was inside the belly of an already slaughtered animal, which you don't have to slaughter because it's considered part of the body of the already slaughtered animal. The point being is Yosef HaTzadik, even though he meant well, made a mistake and said Lashon Hara about his brothers, and that's why he had to go into Egypt as a prisoner.

2:33:52for all those years until the salvation came. So there are other examples, Baruch Hashem. There's another example with the serpent. The serpent was the first one to make a sin by saying Lashon Hara about Hashem. So that's another example of Lashon Hara. Okay guys, I think it's enough questions for the night. I really do appreciate you learning with me. There were fantastic questions today. Give yourselves a round of applause for all the wonderful questions. I'm sure they're going to make very valuable learning for others. I enjoyed it for sure, and hopefully you did as well. Be'ezrat Hashem, you all succeed for the rest of the week to continue learning, to continue doing mitzvot, to continue succeeding in all the good things that you do, especially succeed in doing teshuva day after day, night after night, b'ezrat Hashem, and to help others do the same. Thank you again for learning with me, have an exciting week, and we'll talk soon.

2:35:10Seven years of lectures. Seven months of film editing. Countless hours of study by two rabbis. Information we received over 3,000 years ago. Seven years of lectures. Seven months of film editing. Countless hours of study by two rabbis. Information we received over 3,000 years ago. If you satiate it, you're never going to have enough. The sulfur plant, when it gets a hold of something, it does not let go. Time for us to rectify what we have done. Normal numbers should be somewhere around 20 million or higher. If you satiate it, you're never going to have enough. The sulfur plant, when it gets a hold of something, does not let go. It's time for us to rectify what we have done. Normal numbers should be somewhere around 20 million or higher.

2:36:40You're never going to have control over it if you start it. You only feed it when it's permissible according to the law. Pornography is as addictive as crack cocaine. Pornography is as addictive as crack cocaine.

2:37:51Pornography is as addictive as crack cocaine.

BH Headquarters