BeEzrat HaShem

Healthy Regret vs Depression: True TeShuva

3 weeks ago

Does regret over past mistakes have to lead to depression? In this powerful lesson, discover the true meaning of TeShuva and why proper repentance brings genuine happiness and closeness to HaShem rather than lingering despair. Authentic TeShuva begins with cutting off the wrong action and completely removing yourself from the environments and influences that lead back to it, allowing your life to improve by aligning with the will of HaShem. Rabbi Yaron Reuven says, falling is part of being human, but accepting failure and staying down on the floor is the real mistake. Healthy regret simply recognizes the missed opportunity to draw close to HaShem sooner, whereas perpetual sorrow and self-blame actually deny the validity of TeShuva and question God's limitless mercy. Learn how to leave your past behind, trust fully in HaShem's forgiveness, and rise up stronger on the right path. Full Shiur: ARMILUS Vs. MASHIACH - 10TH ANNUAL HOSHANAH RABBAH All NIGHTER SHIUR https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YT6JIqFhE-o Want to support our KIRUV work? Please partner with us to help Am Yisrael keep Shabbat and more! https://www.beezrathashem.org/donate Rabbi Yaron Reuven's short Torah Clips channel – Please Share The Video To Help Others Do TeShuva. AI RABBI by BeEzrat HaShem Inc. https://www.AIRabbi.org Answers To Jewish Torah Life Questions In 30 Languages. Discover Jewish Wisdom at Your Fingertips, Rabbi Reuven's AI Rabbi offers wisdom and guidance in multiple languages, drawing from trusted, reliable sources. #Torah #Jewish #RabbiYaronReuven 00:00 First step of TeShuva 01:16 Good Regret vs Depression 04:50 Doing TeShuva the right way 00:00:00 Intoduction 00:00:04 Real Teshuvah vs. Depression 00:01:01 Benefits of True Repentance 00:02:21 Healthy Regret, Not Depression 00:03:32 Failure is Inevitable, Acceptance is Not 00:05:01 Trusting Divine Forgiveness

Transcript

0:04Well, as far as getting into a depression, that means that they're not really doing tshuva. They're doing something that maybe sounds like tshuva, similar to tshuva. They want it to be tshuva, but it's not quite tshuva. And the reason why is because the first step is to stop the sin. That's the first step. The second step is to do whatever they need to do to not go back to the sin. So, let's just say, for example, if they were doing drugs, they're not only going to stop doing drugs, they're now not going to go to the same places where they used to do drugs, or the same people they used to do drugs with, and so on and so forth. That's the first two steps. So, they stop the crime, and they are stopping themselves from going to places that they're going to commit the crime again. Now, That in itself should create a certain amount of benefit and happiness in that person's life over a period of time, because as a result of doing the will of Hashem, their life will improve. Now, the further they are from that sin, the more they're going to realize how bad that sin was for them. Not just how bad it was,

1:30and against the will of Hashem, but how bad it was for them to do it, how it wasn't good for them, it wasn't beneficial for them. And that is going to make them regret that they didn't start keeping Shabbat sooner, that they used to do drugs, or that they used to be immoral. The fact that they realize the magnitude of how bad this sin was for them, that is usually the first stage of understanding, of having regret. And furthermore, the more they do the will of Hashem, the more they're going to care about the relationship they have with Hashem, that they're going to regret the fact that they damaged their relationship with Hashem in the past, and they didn't develop the stronger relationship that they have right now with Him sooner. So, none of this should create a depression. Rather, this should create a closeness to Hashem and also a, you know, the only regret that they should have is that they missed out on an opportunity to do it sooner. But that's not something that would cause any normal person depression. That's just like, oh, I can't believe I could have been, you know, I could have been a bigger, you know, bigger tzaddik yesterday instead of today. I could have been a millionaire yesterday instead of today. I could have been married yesterday instead of today. So it's like the missing out of, ah,

2:51I could have done this sooner. I wish I would have done this sooner. That should never make a person depressed. Usually when people are depressed about something, it's because they're going in the wrong direction in some way. where they're just harping on the fact that they've made a mistake without really truly fixing it. Like they're upset that they did something, but they're not necessarily one with the decision. They're just upset that things didn't go right. So it's important for a person to always understand that Hashem created humans. Humans are expected to fail. Even if you're doing tshuva, you will fail again in different things. Failure is not inherently evil. Accepting failure is evil. You understand? So there's a difference. If I fall, I am expected to get up.

3:53Even if I fall twice, I'm expected to get up twice. Even if I fall seven times, I'm expected to get up seven times. No one is going to fall and just say, you know what, I fell already five times, that's it, I'm just going to stand on the floor forever. I'm just going to lay down on the floor in the middle of the shul forever. No, no, it's not a normal thing. Even if you fell five or ten or fifty times, you get up. So, to fall is going to happen in life. Sometimes a person falls in anger, Sometimes a person falls with issues of morality. Sometimes a person falls for doing something dishonest. Falling is part of your journey that is going to happen. And we need to learn from all of it. accepting the failure of falling, whereas you know what, I feel now with it, from now on, I'm just, I'm just gonna live this way. I'm just gonna stay on the floor, I'm just gonna fail all the time. That's accepting the failure as if it's okay, and that's not okay. So I think that if a person is doing teshuvah the proper way, they're gonna realize that their mistakes are mistakes that HaKadosh Baruch Hu is well aware of, and He's giving you the chance to

5:01of fixing it, even if it's a horrible mistake, even if it's a terrible mistake, and you being upset about it, you being depressed about it, is misunderstanding the whole mitzvah of tshuva. The whole mitzvah of tshuva is that Hashem is giving us a chance to fix the past. So if a person looks at all of the righteous people that are mentioned in the Torah, you'll see that some of them made very, very big mistakes. For example, Rachav. Rachav was the wife of Yeshua ben Nun. But before she was the wife of Yeshua ben Nun, she was the most immoral person on planet Earth. Okay, that was her job. So if she can not only do teshuvah, but also become the wife of the Gadol Hador, then surely you can do teshuvah for whatever you did and also go on the right path. There's no reason to be upset about it forever. You can be upset about it for a certain period of time to say I'm sorry, but once a person says I'm sorry to Hashem, they cannot allow themselves to continue harping on that sorrow because harping on that sorrow is, the Rambam says, a person does not believe teshuvah. He does not believe that Hashem will forgive them. And that's heresy.

6:22so it's a bigger sin than the sin that they've even made. So a person has to believe that Hashem is going to forgive them. If they say 'I'm sorry' and follow these footsteps, they have to believe, they're obligated to believe that Hashem will forgive them. And if they don't believe it, then they're making a bigger sin than the sin that they're worried about. So they're questioning God's mercy. So that's not healthy.

BH Headquarters