Is Calling Out Jewish Misdeeds Antisemitic? | Behalotecha | STUMP THE RABBI (271)
With a new Youtube journalist calling the misdeeds of some Jewish people, many are asking the same question--why is everything automatically antisemitic? In Parashat Behalotecha, we begin to see what HaShem expect of us, and what are some of the consequences of disregarding His expectations. What makes some Jews special and what can take that all away. The key lessons between the lines show us that there different types of Jews, and how bunching them all together is part of the Jewish and Nonjewish problem. BeEzrat HaShem, Today we will clarify the details the are blurring the picture for most. This will be followed by a questions and answers session with the live audience online. Enjoy, Learn, and Be Holy. BH Films Box – Sponsor A Kiruv Revolution! https://www.KIRUVBOX.org DONATE & SUPPORT @ https://www.BeEzratHaShem.org AI RABBI by BeEzrat HaShem Inc. https://www.AIRabbi.org Answers To Jewish Torah Life Questions In 30 Languages. Discover Jewish Wisdom at Your Fingertips, Rabbi Reuven's AI Rabbi offers wisdom and guidance in multiple languages, drawing from trusted, reliable sources. #AntisemitismToday #AIPAC #PrejudiceMeaning #AntisemitismDefinition #CancelCulture #ParshatBehaalotecha #Torah #Jewish #RabbiYaronReuven #Jews #God #inspiring #motivation #OrthodoxJudaism #Judaism
Transcript
0:05Reb Shmuel was asking a very good question about the nature of tefillah – what exactly are we asking for when we daven? And this brings us straight to the words of Dovid HaMelech, Alav HaShalom, in Tehillim, Perek Yud Zayin. He begins this beautiful tefillah by declaring: "Tefillah L'David. Shema Adonai Tzedek, Hakshivah Rinati, Haazinah Tefillati Belo Siftei Mirmah. Mi'lifanecha Mishpati Yetzei, Einecha Techazena Meisharim." And with these profound words, Dovid HaMelech sets the stage for a tefillah that is earnest, heartfelt, and entirely without pretense. It's a powerful lesson for all of us, reminding us that true prayer comes from the deepest sincerity of the heart, not from empty words. As we are about to embark on a deeper understanding of parashat ha'shavua, this week's Torah portion, specifically a challenging Rashi on the nature of kedusha, I sense a small technical difficulty here. Yes, it appears the audio is running off. Let us try again in a minute. Chas v'shalom, G-d forbid, that any interruption should deter us from our holy learning. We will resolve this b'ezrat Hashem, with G-d's help, and continue our shiur shortly.
1:06Can you hear me right now? "Yes, Baruch Hashem. It is truly good to see all of you, my dear talmidim and listeners, joining us again tonight. Please do write in the chat if anyone is experiencing any difficulty with the audio or video. Yes, Baruch Hashem, it seems we are clear. Excellent. We are grateful to the Ribbono shel Olam to be able to gather once more for this sacred learning. We've just had a brief technical adjustment, and now we are ready to continue." So, we've just concluded the first portion of our evening, the Divrei Torah, and I truly hope everyone gained some valuable insights and much-needed chizuk. Now, as we transition to the next exciting segment of our program, thank you very much. We're back here for our renowned 'Stump the Rabbi' session! We are now ready to take your questions, be'ezrat Hashem Yitbarach. Please, feel free to send them in or raise your hands; we're eager to engage with your she'eilot.
2:29Good evening, everyone, and welcome to our weekly shiur. We are delighted to have you join us. On our Wednesday night Stump the Rabbi, where after some Divrei Torah, you will ask some questions, and Be'ezrat Hashem, HaKadosh Baruch Hu will give us the answers. Tonight's program is dedicated for the refuah sheleimah of Rabbi Efraim ben Shulamit, Rabbi Nitzar, and Bat Anat. May HaKadosh Baruch Hu grant them a complete and speedy recovery, along with all those who are ill among Am Yisrael. Before we delve deeper into this week's parsha, I want to take a moment to acknowledge the incredible support we receive for all the sacred work we do. It truly is a collective effort, and we are profoundly grateful for the generosity of... and all of Am Yisrael and all the righteous Noachides that continue to support and help us do all the amazing things that the organization is doing, Baruch Hashem. For any of you who haven't watched the new video that we came out with, I cannot stress enough how important it is for you to see it. It offers a powerful testament to the dedication of our team and the impact of your contributions, prominently featuring our achievement of the Platinum Seal for three years in a row. It is truly very encouraging and motivating for anyone who has donated over the years to us. That is, obviously, a big high five – or much more than that. And for anyone who hasn't yet had the opportunity to contribute, don't miss out on what we are building moving forward. There are many big things on the horizon, as I have said several times over the last few months.
3:02...So any of you that want to support this holy work, I want to share a few words about our organization's standing. Then, regarding the organization, we have earned the Platinum Seal for three consecutive years. I encourage you to review the details of this achievement; it is very encouraging and very motivating for anyone who has donated to us over the years. That's obviously a tremendous hakarat hatov to all of you, and even more than that. And for anyone that hasn't yet had the opportunity to participate, please don't miss out on what is moving forward. There are many big things, as I've said several times over the last few months. Indeed, with Hashem's help, the biggest things that we've ever done are ahead of us... My dear talmidim and esteemed ba'alei batim, it is truly a privilege to gather here tonight to delve deeper into the sacred words of our Torah. Before we continue with our main topic, I wanted to share a brief update regarding some of the important projects that Hakadosh Baruch Hu has allowed us to initiate and pursue. B'ezras Hashem, we are always striving to expand our efforts in spreading Torah and yiras Shamayim. The biggest things that we've ever done are ahead of us. And some of them are coming out very, very, very soon. I don't want to give too many details, but a lot of the things that all of you have asked me for, and things you haven't even thought of, are coming very soon, B'ezras Hashem. And we're going to have some good news coming very soon. So any of you that want to support this vital work and become a partner in strengthening Klal Yisrael, please know that your contribution makes an enormous difference. Every act of tzedakah, every donation, enables us to continue these sacred endeavors, and may Hashem bless you with abundant success in all your undertakings, b'gashmiyus u'v'ruchniyus.
3:51Your generous contributions truly fuel our ability to expand these crucial initiatives. Please do go to B'ezrasHashem.org, and if you are donating from anywhere outside of the U.S., you may have an easier time donating on our second website, B'H-Torah.org. Our app also uses a different payment terminal, which some find more convenient. Our mission, lishma, is, of course, for everyone – whether you are a righteous Jew, a righteous Gentile, or simply striving to be righteous. And that spirit of seeking truth and righteousness will guide us as we embark on our main topic this evening. My dear talmidim, it is clear that many in our community, perhaps even yourselves, find themselves simply confused, regardless of where you stand. This year is for you. Why? Because there are a lot of questions out there about the Jewish world. And I don't have to tell you, but I'll simply remind you that it seems like every day there's a new YouTube journalist who's calling out the misdeeds of some Jewish people. As many of you know, there was that individual, Tyler, who released particularly distressing videos a few months back, and sadly, similar content continues to emerge. My dear talmidim, it is clear that many in our community, perhaps even yourselves, find themselves simply confused, regardless of where you stand. This year is for you. Why? Because there are a lot of questions out there about the Jewish world. And I don't have to tell you, but I'll simply remind you that it seems like every day there's a new YouTube journalist who's calling out the misdeeds of some Jewish people. As many of you know, there was that individual, Tyler, who released particularly distressing videos a few months back, and sadly, similar content continues to emerge. And quite frankly, it's surprising some people, but not me. And I'll tell you why throughout this show. But the big question that everyone is asking is, why is everything automatically anti-Semitic?
4:58My dear students, we find ourselves grappling with challenging questions in these turbulent times. It seems that any discussion, any critique, especially concerning our own people, can very quickly be labeled in a particular way. And frankly, it's surprising some people, but not me. And I'll tell you why throughout this shiur. But the profound question that many are asking is this: Why is it that everything automatically becomes labeled as anti-Semitic? This is a matter we must delve into with clarity and truth, guided by the principles of Torah. We must ask ourselves: We must ask ourselves: Is it simply anti-Semitic to talk about Jews in any way, shape, or form? Is it lashon hara to point out shortcomings when the intention is for teshuvah and growth? I mean, anyone who has watched my shiurim over the years knows that I call out our own people more than anyone else out there, precisely in order to inspire them to change. So, am I anti-Semitic now? Of course not! True love for our people means desiring their betterment, guided by Torah. And this very week, as we delve into our weekly parasha, we begin to see precisely what Hashem expects of us. My dear friends, as the Parashat Ba'alotcha opens with Hashem's direct command to Aharon through Moshe, we are prompted to reflect deeply on the nature of divine expectation and our response to it. This leads us to ponder some crucial questions central to our service of Hashem and our collective identity. Specifically, we must ask ourselves: And what are some of the consequences of disregarding His expectations? What makes some Jews special? And what can take all of that away? The key lesson we will uncover is that there are different types of Jews, and that lumping them all together contributes to the difficulties that both Jews and non-Jews are grappling with today. The wisdom of our Torah guides us to a nuanced understanding of Klal Yisrael and the diverse paths within it. By carefully examining the text before us, we will, B'ezrat Hashem, gain clarity on these very distinctions, and thereby come to a deeper appreciation of our individual and communal purpose.
6:17Good evening, dear talmidim and esteemed participants. It is a profound privilege, b'ezrat Hashem, to gather once again to immerse ourselves in the timeless wisdom of our holy Torah. As we approach Shabbat Kodesh, our attention turns to Parashat Behaalotecha. B'ezrat Hashem, tonight we will delve into certain details that frequently obscure the clear picture for many, leading some into difficult situations they never intended or desired, and others, perhaps less attentive, into circumstances they did not anticipate. Our parashah this week, Parashat Behaalotecha, opens with a foundational instruction. The Torah states, 'Hashem spoke to Moshe, saying: "Speak to Aharon and say to him,"' This divine directive, addressed specifically to Aharon, introduces a crucial mitzvah concerning the menorah, setting the stage for one of the most significant elements of the Mishkan service. Good evening, esteemed members of our holy community. We are gathered once again, Baruch Hashem, to delve into the depths of our sacred Torah. Tonight, we turn our attention to Parshat Beha'alotcha, and specifically, to the mitzvah of kindling the Menorah. The Torah states, "When you kindle the lamps, toward the face of the Menorah shall the seven lamps cast light." Now, in Hebrew, the phrase "toward the face of the Menorah" is el mul p'nei hamenorah. This profound directive also teaches us that the whole goal of this mitzvah is to elevate Am Yisrael higher. It's not just about physical illumination; it's about bringing forth the spiritual light within each of us. Just as the Menorah's light was directed forward, symbolizing the spread of Torah and kedusha (holiness), so too are we called to elevate ourselves and our people, to shine our light into the world by faithfully observing Hashem's commandments.
7:16The purpose of creation, the very essence of our existence as Bnei Yisrael, is to reach a state of complete bitul – self-nullification – before HaKadosh Baruch Hu. We strive to be higher in holiness, higher in servitude, higher in humility under their King of Kings, by fulfilling His mitzvot, whether they understand them or they don't. In today's world, there are many people that have issues with being commanded to do stuff. The ego today is bigger than ever. This inflated ego leads them to question everything, to demand understanding, and even to believe that chas v'shalom, God somehow needs them. This is a dangerous heresy that we see spreading like wildfire, unfortunately even from those who claim to teach Torah. We learn from the middos and the avodah of such a gadol hador as Rav Mordechai Eliyahu, zichrono livracha, what true emunah and bitachon really mean, and how one serves HaKadosh Baruch Hu with a full heart and mesirat nefesh. This foundational understanding is crucial, especially in our times, when we face so many nisyonos and encounter ideas that can shake the very foundations of our emunas Yisrael. especially when you have some people that call themselves rabbis that tell you things that are one hundred percent heretical, that have become the poison of the generation, much more than any other false religion, where they literally have convinced countless people that HaKadosh Baruch Hu actually needs you. Not a day goes by where somebody doesn't reach out to me and wants to debate the topic of whether Hashem needs you or not. This is a constant battle for the truth of Toras Hashem. We must remember, my dear friends, that HaKadosh Baruch Hu, Yisborach Shmo, is shaleim, perfect and complete in every way. He is absolutely independent of His creation, and our avodah is not to fill any perceived need of His, chas v'shalom, but rather to draw closer to Him and fulfill His ratzon, thereby elevating ourselves and the entire world.
8:13We speak of Gedolei Yisrael who embody mesiras nefesh, and none exemplified this more profoundly than Maran HaGaon Rav Mordechai Eliyahu, zekher tzaddik livrakha. He was an ish kodesh, a holy man, who truly served as the rebbe for all of Am Yisrael. There was truly nothing he would not do for his people. Indeed, his own Rebbetzin recounted that after he had fallen into a coma towards the end of his life, he miraculously awoke from it for a brief moment. He then explained to her that he had chosen this path, that he had chosen to depart from this world in this specific way. Such was his boundless love for Am Yisrael, a testament to the profound depths of his mesiras nefesh for the sake of Klal Yisrael. Because Hashem gave him a message that it was either that many Jews would perish in some tragic disaster due to the cumulative weight of aveirot (sins), or Hashem would choose one of the tzaddikim (righteous ones) of the generation. And Maran Rav Mordechai Eliyahu chose to be that person in order to avert the disaster from his fellow Jews.
9:13Rav Mordechai Eliyahu, zekhuto yagen aleinu, was known for his immense ahavat Yisrael and his willingness to help every Jew who sought his counsel. But despite that, there is a story about Rav Mordechai Eliyahu that many people don't know. Every time that he was at shul, people would come to him asking for advice, asking for guidance, asking for blessings. But there was one time that the Rav was different. Indeed, while he normally welcomed all, on one particular occasion, a visitor from out of town seeking a berakhah experienced a most unexpected reception. This unexpected reception perplexed many who were accustomed to his boundless ahavat Yisrael. While he did everything possible to meet everyone's needs, there was a time when things were different. A visitor from out of town arrived at the shul seeking a berakhah from the Rav. He pushed his way closer and closer, but every time he got close to Rav Mordechai Eliyahu, the Rav would turn around and give him his back as soon as the visitor would start speaking. Despite this repeated rejection, the man's determination remained, and he continued to press forward for his desired blessing. My dear friends, we learn from this story a profound lesson in hashgacha pratis, Divine Providence. The Rav, in his great wisdom, had turned his back to one particular individual who had come to seek a bracha, a blessing. But he did not entirely withdraw from his holy work. Instead, throughout this puzzling interaction, people would come and take time with the rabbi. He would turn back around and speak to them, bless them, and help them. And then the individual would push his way in front of the rabbi again, wanting a bracha. And the Rav again turned his back to him. This happened multiple times until the man lost his patience and could no longer contain his desperation. Finally, unable to bear the silence any longer, he pushed his way forward one last time.
10:34The talmidim watched in respectful silence, their hearts filled with emunah even as they couldn't grasp the meaning of the rebbe's actions. It was clear that the rebbe was acting with profound kavanah, and they trusted his wisdom implicitly. Thus, even as everyone saw this, they didn't understand why the rebbe was doing it, but nobody was asking questions. Everybody was simply understanding that the rebbe had his reasons. But the man did not, and he pushed his way in front of the rebbe and said, 'Rebbe, I have cancer. Give me a brachah.' The rebbe again turned around, but this time he spoke. His words, when they came, carried the weight of a profound lesson for all present, not just for the individual who had interrupted the moment. The atmosphere in the room shifted, as everyone braced themselves for the wisdom that was about to be imparted. ...imparted, and the rebbe, turning his gaze directly upon the man, said, "Why do some people not understand? Why do they not simply grasp it? No!" When the man heard these words, aside from being shocked and shamed, he realized it was time for him to go. And he left the place. After he left, HaRav Mordechai Eliyahu zichrono livrachah turned to the assembled crowd and said,... My dear talmidim, we often speak about the profound lessons Hakadosh Baruch Hu allows us to learn from the physical world, lessons that reflect spiritual truths and the nature of the yetzer hara. Sometimes, a difficult reality can serve as a powerful mashal for the spiritual challenges we face in our lives. Have any of you heard of cancer before? Of course, everyone knows what that is. It's the evil disease that kills so many and torments even more. So you know what cancer is? Cancer is when one of the cells that's in the body decides that it doesn't have enough. It wants more. It wants more space. This single cell, driven by an insatiable hunger, expands without limit, consuming all the resources around it, disregarding the delicate balance of the entire body. Its singular focus on "more" leads only to destruction and ruin for its host.
12:01This cancerous cell, driven by unchecked desire, expands relentlessly, growing beyond all proportion, and it continues to multiply itself, getting bigger and bigger, destroying everything in its path, until it ultimately kills the person. Sometimes, a person does the same thing to himself, where he's not happy with just his wife. He wants another one, and another one. This insatiable desire, this lack of contentment, mirrors the destructive path of the cancer cell. It's a desire for "more" that, if left unchecked, can lead to spiritual ruin, chas v'shalom. And this, my dear talmidim, is the profound lesson we can draw from the physical manifestation of illness. Just as the body suffers from a cell that seeks endless expansion, so too can the soul suffer when we give in to the yetzer hara's temptations for boundless "more." We speak of the constant need for growth, for aliyah, for ascending ever higher in our spiritual journey. The moment we think we have 'arrived,' the moment we become complacent, that is the moment we are in greatest danger. Sometimes, HaKadosh Baruch Hu sends us wake-up calls, not as punishment, chas v'shalom, but as a deep expression of His love, to shake us out of our stupor, to remind us of the great work we still have to do. And sometimes, HaKadosh Baruch Hu brings difficult challenges into a person's life, even severe illness, to serve as a wake-up call. Maran Rav Mordechai Eliyahu, zt"l, no doubt had Ruach HaKodesh, but it was simply clear to everyone present that Rav Mordechai Eliyahu knew a whole lot more about this man than the man knew about himself. This story illustrates how even a Gadol B'Yisrael like Rav Mordechai Eliyahu, zt"l, with his profound insight, understood the deeper spiritual state of an individual, often better than the individual themselves. It underscores the point: we may think we're doing enough, but Hashem sees the potential within us, the unfulfilled capacity, and sometimes, He orchestrates circumstances to help us reach it, to awaken us to the path of true tshuva and growth.
12:53Good evening, dear chevra. It's a privilege to learn together tonight. Our Sages teach us that the purpose of our existence here in Olam HaZeh is constant growth, constant striving for greater closeness to HaKadosh Baruch Hu. We are always on a journey, and the Torah guides us on that path. So often, we might fall into the trap of complacency, but the message of the Torah is clear. For example, in Parashat Nitzavim, Hashem tells us that we have to rise to the occasion. We have to do tshuva. We have to improve ourselves. That's the whole point of the Torah. You can't just think that because you went to yeshiva as a kid or learned a few years of Torah in kollel, you are enough. You are sufficient. You can't just think that because you are keeping some basic mitzvot, you are done. If you were done, you would no longer be here. This physical world, this Olam HaZeh, is a place of labor, of spiritual refinement. We are given this precious time to elevate ourselves, to rectify our souls, to complete our tikkun. My dear friends, we are taught by our holy Sages that the purpose of our existence in this world is to fulfill our unique spiritual rectification, our individual tikkun hanefesh. Anyone who has completed their tikkun no longer needs to be in this world. This means that every one of us who is still living in this world has a great deal more teshuva to do. But some people become engrossed in complicated questions in their minds, such as, "Why can't a convert marry a Kohen?" These kinds of inquiries, while seemingly profound, often distract us from the core task at hand: to serve Hakadosh Baruch Hu with simplicity and devotion, and to engage in diligent Torah study. Instead of dwelling on such matters, we should focus on the immense teshuva that awaits each of us and the countless mitzvot we can perform.
13:52Yet, some individuals become entangled in superficial intellectual pursuits, asking questions such as: What makes the Jewish people chosen? Who decided this? Things like this occupy people's small minds where, instead of simply serving the King and learning more and more about Him, and even learning the answers to those questions, they simply become obsessed with foolish things, which do have answers, but they don't actually look for them. They're just simply looking for excuses. This preoccupation with trivialities often masks a deeper, more troubling agenda, which is: We often encounter individuals who unfortunately delve into the profound teachings of our holy Torah and the words of our Chazal, not with a desire to understand and grow, but rather, chas v'shalom, to find things that don't match their ideology, and thereby to nullify the entire Torah in their mind. But the Torah, in Parashat Behaalotecha, tells us that HaKadosh Baruch Hu decided to make the Tribe of Levi, the Levi'im, special. As it is written in Sefer Bamidbar, chapter eight, pasuk fourteen: My dear talmidim, we've been discussing the profound declaration that the Levi'im are 'different,' 'special,' and 'Mine' in a unique way. What does this truly signify? The Torah elucidates this distinct status for the Levi'im in Bamidbar, chapter eight, pasuk fourteen: "So shall you separate the Levi'im from among the Children of Israel, and the Levi'im shall remain Mine." Even though all of Am Yisrael and the entire world belongs to Hashem, Hashem explicitly states this about the Levi'im, from whom come the Kohanim. This highlights their unique designation for divine service. Furthermore, Kaddosh Baruch Hu says that these Levi'im, these Levi'im...
15:14And so, my dear yidden, we find a profound distinction being made here by HaKadosh Barukh Hu. He is not merely selecting the Levi'im; He is emphasizing their unique and elevated status, declaring with absolute clarity: They're different. They're special. They're mine. What profound meaning can we glean from this declaration? Furthermore, HaKadosh Barukh Hu says that these Levi'im, these chosen ones, are set aside, singled out from the rest of Am Yisrael for a unique and holy purpose. It is HaKadosh Barukh Hu's will to make them His, to dedicate them entirely to His service, as He elaborates further in the pesukim that follow. My dear talmidim, as we delve into the profound depths of our sacred Torah, we must first recall the unique status of the bekhorim, the firstborn, and their initial consecration to Hashem. As we discussed, after the miracle of Yetzias Mitzrayim, the Ribbono shel Olam, blessed be His Name, declared: "the day I struck every firstborn in the land of Egypt, I sanctified them for Myself." However, in His infinite wisdom, Hashem later designated the Leviyim to replace the bekhorim for the sacred service. And so, my dear talmidim, it is about these Leviyim that the Torah states: "They shall remain to perform the service of Hashem. And He decided to make them His, as He says in Sefer Bamidbar, perek gimmel, pasuk yud-gimmel: 'For every firstborn of the children of Israel became Mine, both man and livestock...'" This transfer of sanctity, my dear talmidim, from the bekhorim to the Leviyim, represents a profound lesson in divine designation and the enduring requirement for avodat Hashem in our lives, whether through the sacred service entrusted to the Kohanim and Leviyim in the Beis Hamikdash, or through our diligent Torah study and performance of mitzvot in every generation. May we all merit to fulfill our unique roles in serving Hashem with complete devotion.
16:04Indeed, my dear talmidim, as we delve deeper, we understand that this was not merely a replacement, but a divine decree, a sanctification tied directly to a pivotal moment in our history. As it says, in a profound declaration from Hakadosh Baruch Hu Himself: "The day I struck every firstborn in the land of Egypt, I sanctified them for Myself. The firstborns were always special, but they were replaced by the Levi'im during this plague of the firstborn in Egypt." This momentous event, Makat Bechorot, the plague of the firstborn, fundamentally shifted the spiritual service within Klal Yisrael, establishing the everlasting dedication of the Levi'im. As the Torah Hakdosha explicitly details, fulfilling this divine mandate, it states: "Then I assigned the Levi'im to be presented to Aharon and his sons from among the children of Yisrael to perform the service of the children of Yisrael." So we see that this is not about prejudice; it is not arbitrary, nor is it meant to demean anyone. Rather, it is Chukas Hakadosh Baruch Hu, a clear decree from the King of Kings, Hakadosh Baruch Hu Himself, Who, in His infinite wisdom, established distinct roles and responsibilities within Klal Yisrael. So, is this demeaning? Is it meant to make one group feel inferior? Absolutely not! It's simply the rule of the King, HaKadosh Baruch Hu! He is the One Who decided that there are different levels, different roles, and therefore, they have different rules. Therefore, a Kohen cannot marry a convert, cannot marry a gerushah (divorcee), cannot marry a widow. Why? Because He decided it! It is His world, and He sets the parameters for each of us within Klal Yisrael.
17:20My dear talmidim, we often ponder the profound wisdom of HaKadosh Baruch Hu's actions in His world. Sometimes, we might observe what appears to be distinctions among people, whether in their roles, their strengths, or their challenges. We might ask, 'Why is one person given one path and another a different one?' It is crucial to understand that these distinctions are not born from a place of judgment in the way we might perceive it. not because he is better, nor because she is worse. It is simply to distinguish them from everyone else. He is the One Who created everything. He is the One Who runs the entire show. When a person questions his Creator, it means that not only does he not understand his Creator, he does not even understand his own position in the world. He doesn't even realize that he is the servant of HaKadosh Baruch Hu, the Master of the World. My dear friends, we are taught in our holy sefarim the importance of bitul hayesh and recognizing our true purpose. It is when we understand that we are but servants of HaKadosh Baruch Hu that true clarity begins to emerge in our lives. And a person who doesn't realize he is a servant can certainly run into a lot of confusion. But sometimes, when a person humbles himself and listens to Da'at Torah, he can fix his errors. For example, there was once a woman who was married for many years but could not bear children. This was a profound challenge, a test of emunah and reliance on the Ribono shel Olam. Such situations often lead us to seek guidance from those entrusted with the wisdom of Torah.
18:17My dear brothers, we learn so much from the stories of our righteous ones. Consider the pain of a couple who yearn for children, who pray daily, who do all that is humanly possible, yet their prayers seem to go unanswered. This profound yearning, this kisufim for a child, is a test of emunah. It is a deep, raw ache that many have unfortunately experienced throughout our history. And so it was with a certain woman, a tzadekes of our generation. And this was a righteous woman. She kept Shabbat. She kept taharat hamishpacha. She was modest. But year after year, her home remained childless. She decided to go to Rabbi Shlomo Zalman Auerbach and cry to the Rav. "Rabbi," she pleaded, "I want a baby. Rabbi, I want kids!" She poured out her heart, tears streaming down her face, her pleas echoing through the room where others awaited their turn. She continued to cry, her anguish palpable for all present to witness, expecting the great Gadol to offer a word of comfort, a blessing for a child. Indeed, she expected him to simply give a blessing on behalf of Hashem. But what happened next was truly astounding. and she continued to cry, her anguish palpable for all present. But when Rabbi Shlomo Zalman Auerbach finally acknowledged her, he shocked her. He did not give her the blessing she so desperately expected. She had been expecting the Rav to simply offer a blessing, certain that a promise of yeshuah on behalf of Hashem from such a Gadol would surely bring about the miracle she longed for.
19:16My dear friends, we find ourselves discussing a profound interaction, one that teaches us much about emunah and bitachon. A woman, distraught and yearning for a child, approached a Gadol B'Yisrael, seeking a brachah for offspring after many years of marriage. You would expect the Rabbi to offer a compassionate blessing and words of comfort. But that's not what Rabbi Auerbach did. The first words that came out of his mouth shocked her and everybody else in the room. Time and again, she pleaded, "Rabbi, I want to have kids. Rabbi, we've been married for many years. Rabbi, kayem zeh! Rabbi, I want children!" And the Rav says, "Hashem doesn't owe you anything." The room instantly grew quiet, a heavy silence descending upon all present. So, my dear friends, imagine the scene. Here was a woman, in tremendous distress, pouring out her heart, screaming and crying out before the Gadol HaDor, seeking his counsel, his bracha. And what happened next was truly astounding, something that deeply impacted everyone present. The Gadol HaDor listened, and then, after a long silence, he finally spoke, and then she fell silent. Many people were there; everyone heard it. And the words literally dug into the core of this woman. She could not even respond. What could she possibly say? Usually, when you approach a rav, you ask for a bracha, and he gives you a bracha, and with siyata d'Shmaya, we hope for the best. But this time, the response was so profoundly different, so unexpected, that it left her, and indeed everyone present, utterly bewildered. It was a moment that challenged every conventional expectation, forcing us to rethink our entire approach to emunah and our relationship with HaKadosh Baruch Hu. The Gadol's words were not a simple bracha; they were a challenge, a profound message, to counter the prevailing misconceptions of our generation that, Chas V'shalom, turn our Creator into a servant.
20:16But here, the Gadol Hador waited and waited and waited and waited as she was screaming and crying out, and eventually responded to her with the most confusing response in the world. Certainly, a response that negates the entire poisonous ideology that has permeated our generation, which tells people that God needs them and He owes them, and how people have literally turned God into some servant, chas v'shalom. So she came to one of our gedolim, the great posek Rav Shmuel Auerbach, zichrono livracha, with her complaints. She felt entitled, she felt Hashem owed her something because she was doing all that was expected of her, as if Hashem was some kind of vending machine, or Santa Claus. But Rav Auerbach tells her, 'God does not owe you anything.' As the silence became deafening, Rav Auerbach adds a few more words that change everything. And he tells this poor woman, 'But if you do something beyond what you have to do,' This, my friends, was the opening to a truly transformative teaching from Rav Auerbach, zt"l, on the nature of our service to Hashem.
21:17We often find ourselves in a place where we assess our spiritual growth, our avodas Hashem, our service of the Almighty. And many times, when we speak about what we're doing for HaKadosh Baruch Hu, we list the fundamentals, the absolute bedrock of our Yiddishkeit. We say, 'Look, Rabbi, I'm doing this, I'm doing that.' But what are we truly doing? What is the essence of our devotion? All you're telling me is that you're doing the things that you have to do. You have to be modest. You have to keep taharat hamishpachah (family purity). You have to keep Shabbos. You have to keep the mitzvos. These are all things that you have to do. If you want Hashem to do something that He doesn't have to do, then you start doing things that you don't have to do in order to serve Hashem even more. This is the powerful message our Chazal teach us, the principle of middah keneged middah, measure for measure. When we go beyond the letter of the law, when we show HaKadosh Baruch Hu that our love and devotion inspire us to give of ourselves even when not strictly obligated, He responds in kind, with blessings that exceed our expectations, blessings that He doesn't have to give. This is how we draw down unparalleled shefa, unparalleled abundance, into our lives and into the world. It is a fundamental truth that has been understood by righteous individuals throughout our history, for generations. Sometimes, yeshuot come from unexpected places, from individuals who truly grasp the depth of a davening or a drasha. We learn from our Sages that one good deed can bring about tremendous blessings, not just for the individual, but for Klal Yisrael. We see a powerful example of this in the story of a righteous woman, who heard a profound message from one of the great rabbanim of her generation. And this righteous woman understood the message clearly, and she decided to open a chesed organization to help Jewish people who were struggling. When she went above and beyond to help Am Yisrael get closer to Hashem and to receive the brachot they needed, HaKadosh Baruch Hu blessed her in return, and she was granted multiple daughters. But her legacy, baruch Hashem, extended far beyond her immediate family. The sacred work, the chesed she established, became a foundation of support and strength for countless families, and it continues to this very day.
22:13And this strength, this clarity of purpose, is what sustains us. Baruch Hashem, what was built with true mesiras nefesh and vision, continues to stand firm. Until this day, over fifty years later, our organization is still alive and well, a beacon for all who seek guidance. Many times, however, when a person does not understand his proper role in life, he becomes confused and is susceptible to misleading messages. Consequently, anything that doesn't align with his ingrained predisposition or his fundamental hashkafah (worldview) can feel like a major tremor, a spiritual earthquake, shaking up his entire system and filling him with anxiety and fear. As we discussed, whether it's an attack on our people, an unexpected teaching from a rav, or even a personal mishap, these events can devastate someone who lacks a clear sense of self and purpose within Klal Yisrael. My dear talmidim, we've been discussing how all types of depressions, all the crying, all the tza'ar we experience, it often stems from one core issue: we simply don't realize our true, exalted role in the world. Sometimes, the Jewish people, Klal Yisrael, are truly the best of the best. So much so that Hashem Himself tells us, "These are mine," not just about the Leviim, but about every single Jew. And when one fails to grasp this profound truth, then every minor disturbance immediately shakes up the whole system as if there's a spiritual earthquake. Some famous person speaks against the Jewish people – earthquake! Some rabbi says something that's the opposite of what they've learned – earthquake! Somebody in the community said something bad about her – earthquake! She slipped and fell and broke a nail – earthquake! Everything that happens – anxiety, fear... This perpetual state of balagan, this constant feeling of being shaken, is a direct result of not recognizing the rock-solid foundation of our spiritual identity and our immense zechus as Hashem's chosen nation. When we truly internalize our shlichus, when we understand our tachlis in this world, then b'ezras Hashem, we can overcome these feelings and find genuine simcha and menuchas hanefesh.
23:11...When we're good and we connect to the mitzvot. But when we forget this connection, when we lose sight of our purpose, then what happens? All these feelings of depression and crying, all this spiritual disconnect, it's all because we don't realize our sacred role in the world. Sometimes Am Yisrael are the very best of the best, so much so that Hashem tells them, "These are Mine." This is not just about the Shevet Levi, who were uniquely chosen for service, but rather about Klal Yisrael – the entire Jewish people. My dear chaverim, we learn a profound lesson from the very essence of Am Yisrael. Even those amongst us who may struggle, or who may not yet observe the entirety of the Torah and mitzvot, still possess a neshama yehudit that yearns for connection. This yearning is an inherent part of our spiritual DNA, as Chazal teach us that even the rest of the Jewish people are called Goy Kadosh, a holy nation. But sometimes even we forget where our blessings come from, where our money comes from, where our success comes from. And therefore our HaKadosh Baruch Hu sends different messages to remind us. When we're good and we connect to the mitzvot, we experience immense bracha and clarity, our lives filled with simcha. However, when we unfortunately lose our way, even just a little, HaKadosh Baruch Hu, in His infinite mercy, gently reminds us through various means, sometimes even through challenging circumstances, to help us re-evaluate and return to Him. He yearns for our closeness, just as we, deep down, yearn for His, ultimately leading us to seek out even more opportunities for kedusha and mitzvot.
24:09My dear talmidim, we learn a profound lesson from the very essence of Jewish experience: that our connection to Hashem through His mitzvot is not merely about fulfilling obligations, but about a deep, heartfelt yearning for closeness. Sometimes, the initial decree or circumstance might seem limiting, yet the power of true desire for Kedushah can transcend boundaries. Indeed, we find that at times, we can even reach a level of actively seeking more opportunities to serve Him. A prime example of this occurred with Am Yisrael in this parasha, specifically concerning the very first Pesach that was celebrated in the desert. In accordance with all of Hashem's laws, they brought the korban Pesach, the Paschal sacrifice. However, some members of Am Yisrael were ritually impure (tamei) and therefore could not participate. They felt tremendous distress and keenly desired to celebrate this mitzvah. They felt this keenly because they understood the immense spiritual significance of the korban Pesach, and the missed opportunity weighed heavily on their souls. Their yearning was so great that they simply could not accept missing out on such a foundational mitzvah. As we learn from our Chazal, the mitzvah of Korban Pesach is of paramount importance. Even those who were tameh met, ritually impure from contact with a corpse, were not entirely excluded. Indeed, the very establishment of Pesach Sheni teaches us a profound lesson about the enduring desire of Klal Yisrael to perform mitzvos. And they went and begged and asked: "Can we celebrate something?" And Hashem changed the law for them. He made a second Pesach, Pesach Sheni, where they were able to bring sacrifices. The Gemara in Maseches Pesachim says, what happens if all of Am Yisrael were impure? Would nobody celebrate Pesach? The Gemara answers: "The opposite!" Even in a state of collective tumah, the entire Am Yisrael would bring the Korban Pesach. This highlights a fundamental principle: collective tumah does not prevent the Korban Pesach. It underscores the beloved nature of Klal Yisrael before HaKadosh Baruch Hu and their inherent connection to the mitzvos, even under challenging circumstances. It teaches us that the desire to connect to Hashem through His commandments is so strong, it can even overcome the strictures of ritual impurity, emphasizing the profound love and connection Hashem has for His children and their dedication to His will.
25:11When everyone is tameh, everyone brings the Korban Pesach. But if only some individuals are tameh, then those who are tameh can bring their Korban on Pesach Sheni. From this, we observe HaKadosh Baruch Hu's profound love and appreciation for His children, that they were so connected to the mitzvot that they sought to fulfill them even deeper, and He, in His infinite kindness, granted their fervent desire. My dear talmidim, we know that the essence of our Avodat Hashem is to continually deepen our connection with HaKadosh Baruch Hu. Through the profound wisdom of Torah and the guidance of our Gedolim, HaKadosh Baruch Hu constantly provides us with opportunities for spiritual growth. He gave Klal Yisrael an ability to connect to His Mitzvot and to Him, even deeper than what we had originally. But sometimes, a Jew finds himself in trouble. HaKadosh Baruch Hu says in Bamidbar, Perek Yud, Pasuk Tet: "When you go to wage war in your land against an enemy who oppresses you, you shall sound a short blast of the trumpet, and you shall be recalled before Hashem, your God, and you shall be saved from your foes." Meaning, HaKadosh Baruch Hu says: "The only reason why you're ever going to win any war is because I decide that you're going to win, not because you have good weapons." This powerful pasuk teaches us a fundamental lesson: our strength and salvation come solely from Shamayim. It is not our physical might or advanced weaponry that determines victory, but rather our unwavering reliance on HaKadosh Baruch Hu and the merit of our Mitzvot. This is a crucial foundation for all of our endeavors, especially in challenging times, and particularly in the context of Am Yisrael's survival.
26:10My dear talmidim, let us delve into a critical passuk from Parashat Behaalotcha, Bamidbar, chapter ten, verse nine. The Torah gives us explicit instructions, and a fundamental principle of emunah and bitachon, when it states: "when you go to wage war in your land against an enemy who oppresses you, you shall sound an alarm with the trumpets, and you shall be remembered before Hashem your G-d, and you shall be saved from your enemies. Meaning, Hakadosh Baruch Hu is telling us that the only reason we are ever going to win any war is because He decides that we are going to win, not because we have good weapons." It's not about military might or strategic alliances, but solely about divine providence and our connection to HaKadosh Baruch Hu. This is the absolute truth that guarantees victory. When we remember this fundamental principle, we are assured success; when we forget it, we court disaster. This is why we see, tragically, that when we rely on human power alone, true victory remains elusive. My dear talmidim, it is absolutely critical that we internalize this profound truth: victory belongs to Hashem. We must always remember that our strength is not derived from human endeavor or cunning. The navi Zechariah teaches us that it is not by might, nor by power, but by My spirit, says Hashem Tzeva'os. When we forget this fundamental ikkar emunah, we fall into the trap of relying on ourselves, on our weapons, on our intelligence, on our allies, on our politics, or on our money. We cry out, "Why?" They forgot who wins the wars. They thought it's the weapons. They thought it's the brain. They thought it's the allies, the politics, the money. Hashem says, no, no, no. When someone oppresses you, you cry out to Me, I'll save you. I'll make the weapons hit the target. I could even make the target disappear without the weapon. Simply know who's winning the war. Now, it is not because of good politics, nor because of strong allies. So long as you remember that, you will win every single war. If you forget it, you will lose every war. This is why the secular government of Israel hasn't truly won a war in thirty years. They might look good for public consumption, but in reality, they have not genuinely been victorious in any war. This is a fundamental lesson in bitachon: our true koach comes only from connecting ourselves to HaKadosh Baruch Hu through our tefilah and our mitzvos. When we are with Hashem, then truly, as Dovid HaMelech states in Tehillim, "Im Hashem lo yishmor ir, shav shakad shomer" – if Hashem does not guard the city, the watchman's efforts are in vain. May we all merit to always remember this profound truth, and thus bring about true yeshua for Am Yisrael.
27:12Today people think that their success, their security, their very existence, depends on their own strength, their own cleverness, or the power of their allies. But this is a fundamental error in thinking, a forgetting of who truly runs the world. Why? They forgot who wins the wars. They thought it's the weapons. They thought it's the sechel (intellect/strategy). They thought it's the allies, the politics, the money. Hakadosh Baruch Hu says, "No, no, no! When someone oppresses you, you cry out to Me, I'll save you! I'll make the weapons hit the target. I could even make the target disappear without the weapon. Simply know who's winning the war!" Now, this understanding is crucial for us, because when we lose sight of this fundamental truth, when we forget Who is truly in charge, then we begin to stray from our path. As we go further, we see what happens when Am Yisrael forgets their role in the world, forgets to be grateful and starts complaining. Now, this understanding is crucial for us, because when we lose sight of this fundamental truth, when we forget Who is truly in charge, then we begin to stray from our path. As we go further, we see what happens when Am Yisrael forgets their role in the world, forgets to be grateful, and starts complaining. The Mishnah in Masechet Avot says that Am Yisrael complained ten times in the desert, and Hashem nearly destroyed them every single time. Today, people think that if God doesn't follow their requests, they could be angry at Him, take revenge against Him, or disobey Him as if they are hurting Him. This is like drinking poison and thinking the other person is going to die. But here in the parashah, in Chapter 11, Verse 1 and on, it says, "And the people took seeking complaints."
28:11My dear talmidim, we see in our sacred texts a profound understanding of human nature, especially when faced with challenges. A person, in their spiritual journey, might sometimes fall prey to a dangerous mindset. Instead of true bitachon in Hashem, one might entertain thoughts like, "If Hashem doesn't follow their requests, they could be angry at Him. They might even attempt to take revenge against Him, or disobey Him as if to hurt Him. This is akin to drinking poison and foolishly imagining that the other person will die from it. But here in our parashah, in Bamidbar, chapter 11, pasuk 1 and on, it says, 'And the people were as complainers.'" This pasuk sets the stage for a tragic series of events. The Bnei Yisrael, having been miraculously fed and cared for by Hashem, were nonetheless filled with discontent. They had manna from Heaven, food that could taste like anything they wished, coming to them without any effort. Yet, instead of gratitude, they nurtured anger and sought out reasons to complain. This is the profound lesson for us: how a lack of emunah can lead to severe spiritual consequences, not for Hashem, but for ourselves. My dear talmidim, we continue our discussion on Parshat Beha'alotcha. We often ask ourselves, what exactly went wrong in the desert? Chazal teach us profound lessons from the Israelites' journeys. Let's look at the beginning of Bamidbar, chapter 11, verse 1. The Torah tells us: "And it was evil in the ears of Hashem, and Hashem heard, and His wrath flared, and a fire of Hashem burned against them, and it consumed at the edge of the camp. What were they complaining about? You have food coming to you without you working for it. The food can taste like anything you want. Reb Yidden, think about that for a moment! What greater comfort could one ask for? It's not just the manna, the miraculous food from heaven. We learn from the Midrash and Gemara that Hashem provided for them in every conceivable way."
29:07This included not only their food but also their physical well-being and daily necessities. You don't have to take a shower because you have the clouds of glory carrying you, washing you, and laundering your clothes. And the clothes grow with you. You don't even have to go shopping. They're new every day for 40 years. What are you complaining about? If you just read the verses like ignorant people where you read it literally and that's it and try to understand it yourself, it doesn't make any sense. As we discussed, the Torah itself tells us that the manna tasted like whatever the recipient desired. So, if one craved meat, one merely needed to imagine meat – a succulent steak, a tender filet mignon, or any delicacy one wished for. Even a taste like pig could be imagined, chas v'shalom. Therefore, on the surface, the complaint of Bnei Yisrael demanding meat seems utterly nonsensical. This is precisely why we must delve deeper into the Torah Sheb'al Peh, the Oral Torah, to truly understand the nature of their grievance. Because if one reads it like ignorant people, simply taking it literally and trying to understand it on one's own, the complaint truly doesn't make any sense. For they are saying, "Who will feed us meat? We remember the fish that we ate in Mitzrayim free of charge. But now our life is parched. There is nothing. We have nothing to anticipate but the manna!" Wait, how can this be? We have to understand what was truly bothering them. And indeed, the Gemara in Masechet Shabbat provides us with a profound insight into this very question, revealing the deeper spiritual dimension of their complaint...
30:03My dear students, we are delving into a profound passage concerning the man, the miraculous manna that sustained Am Yisrael in the desert. Our Chazal teach us extensively about the wonders of this heavenly bread. One of its most astonishing properties, as detailed in the Torah Sheb'al Peh, was its ability to taste exactly as the individual desired. In fact, as it is brought down, the manna tasted and was cooked based on the actions of the person. If the person was righteous, the manna would come from heaven and land right at his door, already ready to eat and taste like whatever you wanted. This brings us to a critical point: the Torah itself says that the manna tastes like whatever you want. So, if you desired the taste of meat, you just had to imagine meat. Imagine steak, imagine filet mignon, imagine whatever you wanted. You could even imagine pig, if you wanted. Therefore, the complaint, on the surface, doesn't make any sense. This is precisely why we must delve into the Torah Sheb'al Peh to truly understand what the underlying complaint was. The Gemara in Maseches Shabbos says, and further illuminates for us that "All sixty tastes of manna were on the table of the righteous." This clearly demonstrates that the manna possessed the miraculous capacity to transform its flavor according to the recipient's spiritual state and desire. So, when the Bnei Yisrael complained, "Our soul is dried away; there is nothing at all besides this manna before our eyes," it was not a simple matter of taste preferences. We must therefore explore the deeper, spiritual dimension of their grievance, and this is where the profound insights of our Chazal guide us to a true understanding.
30:32Good evening, dear talmidim and chaverim. We continue our discussion on Parashat Beshalach, specifically delving into the incredible miracle of the mann. You see, the Torah teaches us about the mann not merely as physical sustenance, but as a profound lesson in emunah and hashgacha pratit, Divine Providence. It wasn't just food; it was a direct reflection of one's inner spiritual state. The mann tasted and even appeared cooked according to the spiritual level of the individual. If one was righteous, the mann would descend directly from Shamayim and be found at their doorstep, already prepared and tasting precisely what they desired. It was truly a gift from Hakadosh Baruch Hu, manifesting in a way that spoke directly to the heart and soul of each Yid. This amazing property highlighted the direct connection between one's avodat Hashem and their physical reality. We learn from our holy Sages that the manna, this wondrous bread from Heaven, had different properties depending on the spiritual level of the one who received it. For the truly righteous, the tzaddikim, the experience was one of pure miracle and delight. They didn't need to exert themselves at all. One didn't have to do anything. One simply picked it up, and instantly, it took on any flavor one desired. Imagine ice cream, imagine cornflakes, imagine steak – you could imagine all of it together if you wanted! Nothing in the world was more delicious than this heavenly food, Baruch HaShem. And it was so perfectly nourishing, so utterly healthy, that one didn't even have to go to the bathroom, because every single particle of it would be completely absorbed into the body. There was no waste whatsoever. But if one wasn't quite so righteous, if one's spiritual standing was lacking, then the manna would not appear right at their doorstep. Perhaps they would have to search for it a bit, and when they picked it up, it wouldn't have that instant, perfect flavor. They would have to cook it a little bit, turn it into a cake, do something in order for it to be tastier. And for those who were truly wicked, like Dathan and Abiram, HaShem Yishmor...
31:21Chazal teach us that for the righteous, the manna would descend directly at the entrance of their tent, already prepared and tasting exactly as they desired. However, for those who were not on such a lofty spiritual plane, but still sought to connect with HaKadosh Baruch Hu, then the manna would land down the street. And when you would go to pick it up, you would have to cook it a bit, perhaps turn it into a cake, or do something else to make it tastier. But if you were truly wicked, like Datan and Aviram, their situation was even more challenging, requiring significant toil and effort to gather and prepare their portion from Shamayim. Yes, as the pasuk implies and our Chazal elaborate, the difference in receiving the mann was profound. While the righteous tzaddikim would find it right by their door, ready for consumption, enabling them to start their day of Torah learning by seven in the morning, for the Erev Rav and some of the other wicked people, it was a different story. Not only did the mann not land near their house or even down the street, but it actually landed far away from their dwelling. And for them to gather it, to process it, and then to cook it – it took a while, a considerable amount of time and a lot of effort. Although it still came down from Shamayim, this particular mann certainly required significant personal exertion. This, my dear ones, was a clear and public distinction, a sign from Shamayim revealing the inner state of each person, indicating who truly merited the Divine bounty with ease and who, perhaps due to their actions, had to exert themselves, perhaps even as a catalyst for teshuvah, for repentance.
32:14The Chachamim tell us that the manna was not just food; it was a daily spiritual barometer. It showed exactly where each person stood with Hashem. The Midrash explains that this manna would literally appear right at the door of the righteous, requiring no effort. For those who were less righteous, however, it would fall further away, necessitating a journey to retrieve it, reflecting their spiritual state. This phenomenon made everyone’s spiritual standing quite evident. So, not only did everyone know who was righteous and who was wicked based on what time they were eating. Oh, the guy just finished breakfast at 7 o'clock in the morning. Yeah, that's because it landed right by his door! He's full, he's happy, he's already learning, he's already having a good time. The other guy is still cooking; it's 9:30 in the morning. 'You've been cooking for two hours!' 'Yeah, well, first of all, it took me an hour and a half to get it...' ...And then, after you finally get it, you have to walk an hour and a half to come back! And after all that, you still have to cook it! So perhaps you'll eat by lunch, if you're lucky. Now, what was the message here? It wasn't just physical exertion. The message was clear: if a person found themselves struggling, if their manna was far away, it was an immediate spiritual accounting. It was Hashem showing them, 'Perhaps you cheated on your wife last night? Perhaps you stole from somebody? Perhaps you went against Hashem in some way? That's why this difficulty came upon you!' This was a daily, personal hashgacha pratit, Divine providence. This is the profound lesson of the manna. And it leads us to understand why they then started asking for meat...
32:40We've been discussing, my dear friends, the deeper meaning behind the complaints of Bnei Yisrael in the desert. On the surface, it appears they are merely grumbling about the manna, longing for meat and fish. But the Chachamim haKadoshim teach us that their complaints ran far deeper than a desire for culinary variety. They were not complaining because the manna didn't taste good, nor because they suddenly desired meat and fish. Rather, they were complaining because they did not want to change. They did not want to do teshuva. They wanted to continue being wicked, continue acting as if they run the world, continue stealing, continue lying, continue being immoral, continue being dishonest. And so, when we hear their complaints about the manna, the Chachamim teach us to look deeper. We might, in a sense, understand their spiritual state as if someone were complaining about a minor inconvenience—'I had to travel for an hour and a half just to gather my food, then another hour and a half to come back. Then I still have to cook it! Hopefully I'll eat by lunch!'—and we realize that this frustration isn't merely about the effort. It's a symptom, an outward manifestation of a deeper spiritual malaise, perhaps akin to acknowledging, 'Oh, so you cheated on your wife last night. Oh, so you stole from somebody. Oh, so you went against Hashem in some way last night. That's why it happened to you!' The external hardship, the perceived 'suffering,' was not the root cause, but a spiritual reflection of their inner corruption. So what really happened here? Why are they asking for meat? The Chachamim tell us that this wasn't about physical hunger. It was a rejection of the spiritual purity and simplicity of the manna, a longing for the licentiousness and physical desires they had in Mitzrayim, a desperate attempt to avoid the spiritual growth and demand for teshuva that the desert life imposed upon them. Their physical complaints were but a veil for their profound spiritual resistance to change and true service of Hashem.
33:11We see in the Torah portion how the generation of the desert began to complain, not truly out of a lack of physical sustenance, but from a deeper spiritual malaise. They cried out for meat, for the taste of the world they had left behind in Mitzrayim, but their true grievance was far more profound. These people who are complaining against Hashem, they're not complaining because the manna doesn't taste good. They're not complaining because suddenly they want meat and fish. They're complaining because they do not want to change. They do not want to do teshuvah. They want to continue being wicked, continue acting as if they run the world, continue stealing, continue lying, continue being immoral, continue being dishonest. They grew weary of the constant spiritual refinement, of the manna that forced them to live by divine providence, to confront their spiritual state daily. Their protests were a thinly veiled rejection of the opportunity for true teshuvah. And so, when HaKadosh Baruch Hu observed this deep-seated resistance, this complete lack of desire to transform and elevate themselves, He knew that mere words would not suffice. Only severe consequences could possibly awaken some of them, while for others, even that was not enough, leading to immediate divine retribution. It was at this critical juncture that the people explicitly voiced their profound discontent, crying out in defiance, saying, "Just give us meat! We know how meat tastes after you put it on a barbecue, and that's all we desire! Why must we constantly be reminded that we are spiritually lacking? Enough of this! Let us do as we please!" When HaKadosh Baruch Hu observed that these people had no desire to change, He knew that only severe punishment would work to awaken them. Indeed, for some, not even that was enough, and they were instantly struck down by Hashem. Hashem consumed them with a divine fire, especially the leaders of these rebellious individuals. These initial acts of severe judgment served as a stark warning to the remaining populace. Those who instigated the complaints and continued in their stubbornness faced immediate consequences. As for the rest of the community, who were also involved in the general murmuring and spiritual malaise,
34:15We recall the bitter episode in the desert when Am Yisrael complained about the mann and craved meat. It was the erev rav, the mixed multitude, who stirred up this great longing for physical gratification. It was these complainers who were stationed at the edge of the camp. Regarding the rest of them, Hashem declared, "You want meat? No problem. I will send you such an abundance of slav, of quail, that you will eat it until it becomes utterly repugnant to you, until it comes out of your nostrils!" Now, understand, my friends, this was not Hashem's revenge. Rather, it was another profound rebuke, another stern warning: "Do teshuvah before it is too late!" We see this powerful lesson unfold in the desert. Am Yisrael, complaining about meat, received a seemingly benevolent gift. because once Hashem sent all of the selav, all of these birds, and nobody even needed to hunt or anything; in essence, He was sending it just as the manna came right to the door. But He was also telling them, 'Look how much power I have! I can give you whatever you want. Do teshuvah and I'll continue giving you even more.' Hakadosh Baruch Hu was testing them, giving them an opportunity to rise above their physical desires and connect with Him on a deeper spiritual level. My dear talmidim, we see in Parshas Beha'alotcha the tragic narrative of Kivrei Hata'avah, a stark reminder of the perils of unbridled physical desire. The Jewish people, after all the miracles of the desert, began to complain about the manna and craved meat. Moshe Rabbeinu pleaded with HaKadosh Baruch Hu for them, and they were warned about the consequences. Some, perhaps, understood the gravity of their complaint and began to consider teshuvah, but others, unfortunately, were completely consumed by their cravings. They prioritized their base urges over any spiritual reckoning. And that’s the fundamental difference: there's always an opportunity to turn back to Hashem. Chazal teach us that even in the midst of temptation, a moment of introspection can save a person. But if you refuse to open your eyes, if you continue focusing on your desires, on your lusts, only bad things will come out of it. And those who didn't care about doing teshuvah and really only cared about fulfilling their lusts, ran after the birds, gathered as much as possible, and started eating right away. And that's why the Torah says that while they were chewing, while the meat was still between their teeth, HaKadosh Baruch Hu struck them with a terrible plague. This was a consequence not just of the craving, but of their stubborn refusal to acknowledge their spiritual misstep and repent, even after repeated warnings. May we all learn from this lesson to always strive for kedushah and to immediately engage in teshuvah when we stumble, rather than letting our desires consume us.
35:45...And so, my dear brothers, we learn a crucial lesson from the Torah. When we look at Parshat Beha'alotecha, at the tragic episode of Kivrei HaTa'avah, we see the immediate and severe consequences of failing to heed Hashem's warnings. The Bnei Yisrael had complained, they had lusted for meat, despite all the miracles and the manna from Heaven. Hashem, in His infinite mercy, still gave them what they desired, but with a clear message about the dangers of their actions. Yet, they persisted in their rebellious spirit, refusing to truly internalize the lesson. And what was the outcome? The Torah tells us plainly, that while the meat was still between their teeth, Hashem began to strike them down. Why did this happen? Because I had already given you a chance to do teshuva. I gave you multiple opportunities, various messages, chance after chance. But you had already debased yourselves to such a degree that you were too foolish even to desire to do teshuva. This is the message, my friends. Hashem is patient, but His patience is not infinite. He sends us warnings, He gives us signs, He provides us with opportunities for teshuva, for repentance and return. But if we harden our hearts, if we descend to a spiritual state where we are no longer even capable of wanting to do teshuva, then the measure of justice can be swift and severe. This is a profound lesson for us, especially in our times, when we see the challenges and accusations leveled against Klal Yisrael. We must constantly be vigilant, introspecting and striving to elevate ourselves, lest we find ourselves in a similar spiritual predicament, chas veshalom.
36:14Let us reflect for a moment on the unique position of Am Yisrael among the nations. Throughout our long galus, we have often been subjected to intense scrutiny and unfair judgment. It is not uncommon to hear accusations hurled against us, sentiments that sadly echo the painful cry, "You've lost your right to exist!" Indeed, in the world today, we see how people are quick to highlight various actions and deeds of Jewish individuals. And, unfortunately, every time a Jewish person is perceived to do something amiss, the world is all too ready to make a pronouncement, and often, these pronouncements are not merely about an individual's wrongdoing but are swiftly generalized to Klal Yisrael as a whole. They point fingers, crying "anti-Semitic, anti-Semitic," yet rarely do they delve into the deeper question: Why is this intense focus upon us, Bnei Yisrael? Why are so many non-Jews suddenly so keenly interested in our internal affairs, so much so that they are eager to highlight the Jewish individual who may have committed a transgression, the so-called "Jewish bad guy"? This constant spotlight, my dear talmidim, demands our careful consideration and introspection, for it reveals much about our role in the world and the challenges of sanctifying Shem Shamayim. My dear talmidim, we gather again to strengthen ourselves in Torah and yiras Shamayim. It is crucial for us to understand the world we live in, particularly the challenges faced by Klal Yisrael. We often observe how certain voices, certain elements of the public discourse, quickly rush to judgment regarding our people. For instance, there are the powerful media outlets, and other sources, that readily exclaim, "Oh, this individual is antisemitic, antisemitic!" Rarely does anyone actually pause to question, "Why is this truly happening? Why are all of these non-Jews suddenly so interested in us?" So much so that they're highlighting the Jewish criminal, the Jewish bad guy. This intense focus, my dear brothers, is not a new phenomenon for Am Yisrael. It is a challenge that demands our reflection, compelling us to strengthen our emunah and our commitment to Torah and Mitzvos. We must remember that our actions reflect not just upon ourselves, but upon the entirety of Klal Yisrael and ultimately, upon the Kiddush Hashem we are meant to bring to the world.
37:10My dear talmidim and chaverim, it is truly bewildering to witness the selective focus of the world today. It seems, chas ve'shalom, that when it comes to the Jewish people, a different standard is applied. All other pressing global issues are pushed aside. Suddenly, the entire conversation centers around us, as if the powerful Jewish people are the only people in the world of nine billion people. As if the criminal neighborhood they live in no longer has criminals. As if there are no school shootings every single week in America. As if there is no crime literally every second. It is as if, chas ve'shalom, all these other grave injustices simply vanish from the public eye when the yetzer hara stirs up sinas Yisrael. This disproportionate criticism, my friends, is a modern manifestation of age-old baseless hatred, and we must understand its true source. My dear friends, we see today a bewildering phenomenon unfolding before our very eyes. The world seems to have lost all sense of perspective and proportion when it comes to the Jewish people and the Land of Israel. It's as if the world has forgotten about all other evils; it's as if there is no rape, no pedophilia, no jails anymore in the world! All of a sudden, the only thing people can talk about is the Jewish people. Suddenly, in people's eyes, the Jewish people, the State of Israel, have become the most aggressive country in the world. They are labeled colonizers, they are labeled terrorists, they are called this, they are called that. They accuse us of every possible transgression, projecting their own biases and blindness onto us. This relentless vilification, this obsessive focus on our nation, is truly astounding. How can people so easily dismiss the fundamental truths, the historical realities, the very covenant that binds us to this land? They are simply forgetting a foundational truth...
38:04We often hear many voices today questioning our historical and religious connection to the Land of Israel. Some propose various political solutions, while others cast doubt on our very right to be there. But, my dear friends, as Klal Yisrael, we must remember what our foundational texts teach us. It is imperative that we do not lose sight of the fundamental truth given to us by HaKadosh Baruch Hu, and that we are not forgetting that, first and foremost, if you are a religious person and you believe in the Torah, then you have an obligation from your own religion to believe that Eretz Yisrael belongs to Klal Yisrael. That's number one. But even if you're not religious—even if you're not religious—the very basis of your claims to any land you inhabit today often pales in comparison and is rooted in vastly different circumstances. We need only look around us to see this clearly. My dear talmidim, Baruch Hashem, we gather once more to delve into the profound lessons of our Torah HaKedosha. Today, I wish to speak about a critical aspect of emunah and hashkafa, particularly when we consider the narratives surrounding nations and their lands. It is easy to become caught up in modern political rhetoric, but the Torah teaches us a deeper truth about the transient nature of human claims versus the eternal truth of Hashem's dominion over the world. We must ask ourselves, what truly constitutes a claim to land? Are we being honest with ourselves when we look at history? Often, people forget the true origins, glossing over inconvenient truths. For example, when one speaks with such certainty about a particular land, one must truly ponder: You are forgetting that your country, regardless of whether it is America, or England, or somewhere else, how did you get it? What do you think? It just landed from Heaven and it was called England? It landed from Heaven and it became America? Did you forget what happened on Thanksgiving with the marches of the American Indians? The march of death? Did you forget the Civil War? Did you forget slavery? And so, my dear friends, before anyone stands up and claims 'this is my land because it has always been my land,' let them first open a history book. Let them truly reflect on the gezeirah of Hashem that brings nations up and casts them down. For history, when viewed through the lens of Torah, reveals a far more complex and often unsettling truth about the origins of national claims.
38:58My dear talmidim, we often find ourselves so eager to judge the world, to identify the source of all our troubles outside of ourselves. We look outwards, pointing fingers, eager to find fault. But our chachamim (sages) teach us a profound lesson, as it says in Pirkei Avot (Ethics of Our Fathers), "If I am not for myself, who will be for me?" This applies not only to individual responsibility but to national introspection as well. When we discuss history, when we discuss the origins of nations and peoples, we must do so with humility and a true understanding of how the world has evolved. Otherwise, we fall into the trap of hypocrisy. Consider, for a moment, the very ground beneath our feet, the lands we inhabit. Did you forget the fact that this land was built by people from other countries? There was no such thing as 'Americans' as a distinct people a few hundred years ago. Just like there was no such thing as 'Palestinians' as a distinct people a few hundred years ago. No, not even a few hundred years ago; perhaps only a hundred years ago. People all of a sudden are so obsessed with the perceived faults of others, with finding a current Yiddishe (Jewish) 'bad guy' – as if Am Yisrael (the Jewish people) is responsible for all ills – that they forget to look at their own backyard. They forget to look in the mirror, to consider their own deeds. Have they cheated on their wife? Have they cheated on their husband? Have they cheated on their government? Are they stealing from their customers? They forget that they themselves are not exactly so, uh, so kosher, let us just say. We must first cleanse our own homes, our own souls, our own communities, before we cast stones at others regarding the intricate tapestry of history and national identity.
39:29My dear talmidim, we often ask, "Why is this happening? Why is there so much tza'ar in the world, so much anti-Semitism against Am Yisrael?" It's because HaKadosh Baruch Hu uses anti-Semitism as a way to wake up His people to realize that they are doing things that are against Hashem. And when Hashem sends wake-up calls, He sends them in all different shapes and sizes. One of the most effective tools is to cause us to become so preoccupied with the current external adversary – that we forget to look at our own backyard. We forget to look in the mirror, to examine the fact that we may have cheated on our wives, on our husbands, defrauded our government, or are stealing from our customers. We have forgotten that we are not exactly so kosher, let's just say. We are quick to point fingers outwards, but the truest teshuva begins when we turn the mirror inwards, recognizing our own shortcomings and striving to do mitzvot with pure hearts and clean hands, in accordance with the Halakha. My dear friends, we often ask ourselves, especially when we look at the long and difficult history of our people, and even in our own times, about the challenges and the hardships that we face. We see animosity, we see baseless hatred, and the perennial question arises: Why is this happening? It's because HaKadosh Baruch Hu uses antisemitism as a way to wake up His people to realize that they are doing things that are against Hashem. And when Hashem sends wake-up calls, He sends them in all different shapes and sizes. One of the most effective tools is to remind us, through the actions of the surrounding nations, that we are a unique people, a chosen nation, distinct from all others. We have a special covenant, different rules, and higher expectations from our Creator. And when, Heaven forbid, we stray from the path of Torah and Mitzvot, when we do not heed His voice, then there are, regrettably, consequences that follow.
40:25My dear talmidim, we often wonder about the difficulties we face in this Galut. Why do we experience such animosity, such strange accusations? The Gemara teaches us that HaKadosh Baruch Hu has a plan, and sometimes He chooses to use the nations to remind the Jewish people: 'You are not like the rest of the nations. You have different rules. I have different expectations from you, and when you don't listen, there are consequences.' Now, despite the fact that if you look at the amount of times that Am Yisrael has faced such baseless hatred, such ridiculous accusations, one might despair. But we must remember that HaKadosh Baruch Hu's eye is always upon us, and even in these challenging times, we can find strength and a call to improve our ma'asim tovim. My dear talmidim, we've been discussing how to recognize the unfortunate manifestations of anti-Semitism in our times. One common and painful way we see this lashon hara – this evil speech directed at us – is in the constant negative portrayal of our people in various forms of media. Think about it: Jewish people are mentioned in the media in a negative way, whether in Israel, America, or other countries. The reality is that the Jewish people make up less than one-fifth of one percent of the total population of the world. The conspiracies of Jewish people controlling the media are so illogical that if they truly controlled the media, then you certainly wouldn't have all of this media against them. This shtus, this utter foolishness, reveals either an astounding ignorance or a malicious intent to perpetuate false narratives. It's a classic example of blaming a tiny minority for systemic issues, a tactic as old as time itself, and it continues to resurface. Let us understand, my friends, that such baseless accusations, which consistently paint us as manipulative and powerful beyond measure, are a very clear indicator of deep-seated prejudice.
41:23So, continuing from our discussion on the paramount mitzvah of distinguishing between good and bad, and the sacred responsibility we have to call out negative actions within our community, a crucial and contemporary challenge arises, particularly in today's interconnected world of social media and public discourse, but, needless to say, what truly makes a YouTuber or any political commentator anti-Semitic? What is the halakhic definition, or even the practical one, for us to understand? From a Torah perspective, if you have been following my words until now, you will appreciate that this is not merely a political or social question, but one that deeply affects our emunah and our commitment to Torah values. We are tasked with discerning truth from falsehood, and this demands a rigorous approach rooted in Yiddishkeit. My dear talmidim, we often find ourselves wrestling with the question of how to respond when we encounter those among our own who stray from the path of halakha and derekh eretz. While it might be uncomfortable, our Sages teach us the profound importance of tokhahah, of rebuke, when it is done with the right intention and method. Thus, whether in today's shiur or in any of my other shiurim, calling out errant Jewish people is an absolute mitzvah for us to do, in order to awaken them and help them realize the difference between good and bad. Not only for us to realize this ourselves, but also to remind the people who are doing wrong that they are indeed doing something wrong. They are going against the Torah. So what, then, is distinguishing our tokhahah from, say, a secular individual's criticism?
42:09My dear friends, we established earlier how we became a truly distinct people, a Goy Kadosh, a holy nation, at Har Sinai. This divine designation bestows upon us not only tremendous blessing but also a unique and weighty responsibility. We are obligated to uphold a standard of righteousness that reflects HaKadosh Baruch Hu's glory in the world. This includes our interactions, our business dealings, and our commitment to justice and truth within society. With this in mind, let us consider a crucial question regarding our role in challenging wrongdoing: Telling someone who is a thief and operates one of these unethical businesses—such as the cash advance industry or other industries designed to exploit people—what is the difference between us calling them out and some non-Jewish YouTuber calling them out? What is the halachic or spiritual difference? The difference is as follows... The ramifications of this distinction are vast, impacting how we fulfill our divine mission as a light unto the nations. We will explore these profound implications further in our next shiur, b'ezrat Hashem. Good evening everyone, and welcome to our weekly shiur. Tonight, we are going to explore the pivotal moment in our history when our identity as a nation truly solidified. Let's consider our origins. Before Mount Sinai, the Jewish people were not called the Jewish people. We were first called the Hebrews, the Ivrim, after Avraham Avinu, and then the Israelites after his grandson, Yaakov, who was also called Yisrael. When did we become Jewish? We became Jewish at Mount Sinai. That's when HaKadosh Baruch Hu called us His nation, a Goy Kadosh, a holy nation. This moment at Har Sinai was transformative, defining us forever as the unique nation of HaKadosh Baruch Hu. So, what exactly transpired at that sacred mountain?
43:12It was there, at Har Sinai, that our destiny truly began to unfold. We stood as a unified nation, prepared to accept our unique mission. And indeed, at that moment, we received the Torah. This pivotal event reveals several profound lessons. First, what officially made the Jewish people, Klal Yisrael, was not simply their collective presence or a large demographic number, because there were certainly many more of them in Egypt before Matan Torah. The raw numbers of people present were not the defining factor for our nationhood. Good evening, everyone. We often speak about Klal Yisrael standing at Har Sinai, ready to accept the Torah. But it's important to remember that not everyone who left Egypt merited that moment. The Midrash and Gemara teach us a very difficult, but crucial, lesson about what transpired before we arrived at Har Sinai. And Hashem killed at least 80% of the Israelites in Egypt. He left them there. He killed them during the plague of darkness. He didn't take them to Mount Sinai. Why? They didn't want to accept the Torah. They didn't want to become Jewish. They wanted to stay part of the nations. They wanted to stay Israelites with no obligations of the Torah. Hashem says, if you don't want to become the Jewish people, then I don't need you. This is a profound statement from the Ribbono shel Olam. It tells us that our very existence as a nation, as Am Yisrael, is contingent upon our acceptance of His holy Torah. We spoke earlier about the profound significance of Matan Torah, the giving of our holy Torah. HaKadosh Baruch Hu didn't bestow this ultimate gift upon Am Yisrael out of any personal need, chas v'shalom. No, He, the Master of the Universe, is complete and perfect in every way; He doesn't lack anything whatsoever. But if you, Am Yisrael, desire to truly elevate yourselves, to distinguish yourselves from the rest of the nations of the world, and accept My holy Torah, then your existence will be meaningful and enduring. As the Gemara teaches us in Masechet Shabbat, HaKadosh Baruch Hu performed an extraordinary act at Matan Torah. He lifted Har Sinai – Mount Sinai – over the heads of all of Am Yisrael, holding it like a barrel. And He declared to them, 'If you accept My Torah, then tov, good. But if not, if you refuse to accept My Torah, then I will simply drop Har Sinai upon you, and that will be the end of you, chas v'shalom.' This, my dear students, is precisely what the Baalei Tosfot on Masechet Shabbat astutely ask: What kind of a wedding is this? A wedding where the chatan and kallah are forced under the chuppah? A wedding with...
44:31So we're exploring a profound question raised by the holy Baalei Tosafot concerning Matan Torah, the giving of the Torah at Mount Sinai. As we know, HaKadosh Baruch Hu held the mountain over Klal Yisrael like a barrel. The Midrash describes this as a "sword to the neck," a coercive act. The Baalei Tosafot grapple with this: How can such a covenant, seemingly forced, be considered a loving one? They ask, how can we reconcile this with the notion of a free and joyous acceptance of Torah? This is like our wedding, the chuppah, where you have something covering the chatan and kallah. But if you don't accept My Torah, I'm simply going to drop the mountain and kill all of you. The Baalei Tosafot asked, what kind of wedding is this? A wedding with a threat hanging over its participants? This seems far from the joyous celebration one would expect from a union with HaKadosh Baruch Hu! And the Baalei Tosafot themselves respond to this challenging question, finding a powerful insight within the very fabric of creation, as we learn from the verses describing the first days of the world's existence... We're delving into a profound sugya today, exploring the nature of HaKadosh Baruch Hu's love for Klal Yisrael. We often ask ourselves, in moments of challenge and trial, how can we reconcile seemingly harsh decrees or difficult nisyonos with the boundless rachamim of our Creator? The Baalei Tosafot, in their deep wisdom, grapple with this very question, one that many of us may silently ponder: "A sword to the neck? A threat? What kind of love is this?" The Baalei Tosafot respond to this very question. They point out that we see from the Torah that when HaKadosh Baruch Hu created the world, regarding each day, it states, "it was evening, it was morning, the first day," and similarly for the second day, the third day, and so on. But then, when it comes to the sixth day, the Chazal highlight a subtle yet profound linguistic shift in the pasuk.
45:27Good evening, talmidim. We are delving into the profound depths of Parashat Bereishit, specifically the narrative of creation. As we learn, HaKadosh Baruch Hu created the world in six days. Regarding the first five days of creation, the Torah employs a consistent linguistic pattern. For instance, concerning the second day, the pasuk states: 'And there was evening, and there was morning, a second day,' detailing what was brought into existence during that specific period. But then, when it came to the sixth day, to Friday, which immediately precedes Shabbat Kodesh, the Torah's language subtly changes. Instead of 'a sixth day,' it says: 'And there was evening, and there was morning, HaYom HaShishi (the sixth day).' There is an extra letter hey at the beginning of 'sixth' – haShishi – which functions as the definite article 'the' in English. This small addition, the definite article 'the,' transforms a simple numerical count into 'the' designated sixth day, hinting at a profound significance unique to that specific day. Our holy Sages, zikronam livrachah, teach us that this extra hey, which has the numerical value of five in gematria, alludes to the Five Books of Moses, the Chumash. It represents that HaKadosh Baruch Hu on that very Friday made a cosmic vow, using heaven and earth as His witnesses. He declared that if Am Yisrael would accept these Five Books of Moses at Mount Sinai, then they would merit to experience the Shabbat that would follow, and thereby truly live. But if not, G-d forbid, the entire world would face destruction. This 'hey' thus links creation directly to Matan Torah and the eternal covenant between HaKadosh Baruch Hu and His chosen people.
45:55My dear talmidim, we often contemplate the profound purpose of creation. Why did HaKadosh Baruch Hu bring this world into being? Our Sages teach us that the entire existence of the universe was conditional, tied intrinsically to Klal Yisrael's acceptance of the Torah. The letter Heh has the numerical value of five, representing the five books of Moses, the Chumash. And this represents that HaKadosh Baruch Hu on the sixth day of Creation stipulated a condition, with Heaven and Earth as witnesses. He declared that if Am Yisrael accepts the Torah at Har Sinai, the world would continue to exist, reaching its culmination in Shabbat. Then the world would endure. But if not, the entire world would return to primeval chaos. This underscores the immense power and responsibility of Torah acceptance at Har Sinai. ...If you accept the Torah, then there is a tachlit, a purpose for existence. Without it, there would be no point for this world. And therefore, Har Sinai is not some 'lovey-dovey' imagination that people conjure up in their minds. He's God, He's the King of Kings, and He doesn't have rules that we could understand completely because we are not Him. If we were to know and understand everything, we would be Him. That is precisely why He gave us the Torah, so we can strive to connect with His infinite wisdom, even if we cannot fully grasp His essence. This is the profound depth we must appreciate.
46:56We often learn about Matan Torah as a beautiful, voluntary act, but Chazal reveal a deeper layer. The midrash describes Hashem holding Har Sinai over Klal Yisrael like a barrel, essentially saying, 'If you accept the Torah, fine; if not, there will be your burial place.' Now, some might wonder, why this apparent coercion? Was there truly no other way? The Ba'alei Tosafot say, nearly a thousand years ago, what did you think? Was Hashem an irresponsible God who would leave the existence of the entire world in the hands of a few million Bnei Yisrael? No. He had to let them know precisely what was on the line. If you accept the Torah... then Klal Yisrael secures its unique destiny and the very existence of the world. The stakes were incredibly high. Hashem wasn't just making a request; He was presenting an ultimatum, making it clear that the future of all creation hung in the balance. Hashem presented Bnei Yisrael with the ultimate covenant at Har Sinai, clearly outlining the consequences of their acceptance or refusal. He said to them that if they would embrace the Torah, then good, they would become special, they would become a holy people. But if not, G-d forbid, Hashem declared, "Not only will I destroy the entire world, but you will be the first to perish; you will be destroyed first!" Hashem gave them a vivid illustration of what was going to happen immediately after their decision. The very moment we made that momentous decision and accepted the Torah, we became Am Yisrael, the Jewish people. So, the first thing we understand from this is the profound significance of that covenant, the very essence of our identity.
47:53My dear chaverim, when we delve into the profound question of what defines us as Am Yisrael, what truly makes a Jew a Jew, we realize it's not merely a matter of birth. While yichus, our lineage, is undeniably important, the very soul of our nation, the foundational truth of Yiddishkeit, lies in our covenant with HaKadosh Baruch Hu. It is that the Torah made us Jewish, and adhering to that Torah is what keeps us Jewish. So, if somebody was born to Jewish parents, they are automatically Jewish according to the Torah. But if, chas v'shalom, that individual chooses to depart from this covenant, to abandon the path of their ancestors and disregard the divine instruction of the Torah... We have spoken about the path of adhering to the Torah. Now, let us consider the tragic situation when individuals, chas v'shalom, deviate from this sacred path. They decide to disregard what their parents and grandparents and ancestors have done for the last three thousand three hundred years, and they start following the rules of their imagination, the rules of their lusts and desires, and abandon the Torah. Then, although they were born Jewish, they are unfortunately not upholding the covenant. My dear talmidim, it is crucial to distinguish between those who merely identify as Jewish and those who truly live by our sacred tradition. When we speak of individuals or groups who reject our holy Torah and mitzvot, it must be understood that they are not practicing Yiddishkeit. They are not following the Torah, and therefore their ideology, their perception, and their actions have nothing to do with Yiddishkeit. On the other hand, if someone truly follows the Torah, whether they were born Jewish or converted to Yiddishkeit, and they are committed to its path, this demonstrates their profound connection to Hashem and His commandments. For such individuals,
49:10Good evening, chaverim, it's a pleasure to learn with you tonight. We're delving into a critically important concept, one that, sadly, often gets misunderstood, especially in the wider world. We're talking about the essence of what it means to be a Yid, a Jew, and the responsibility that comes with that sacred identity. Each and every one of us, from the greatest gaon of the generation to the simplest ba'al habayis, is a ben Yisrael, a child of Israel. And with that zechus, that privilege, comes a profound expectation. When someone proudly proclaims, "I am Jewish," when they stand as part of Klal Yisrael, as an inheritor of Toras Moshe, then certainly their actions are supposed to be motivated by what the Torah says. Whether it's how to conduct a marriage, how to raise children, how to conduct business, how to conduct your relationships, and so on. The Torah is our book of instructions. Instructions on how to live. So now, when a Jew, who perhaps doesn't observe Shabbos or kashrus, but nevertheless identifies as Jewish, acts in a way that is profoundly un-Torah-like, a lo aleinu situation where their conduct is the opposite of yashrus and mentchlichkeit, and then, chas v'shalom, some individual, whether it's a non-Jew or, Rachmana litzlan, a Jewish maskil who has lost his way, points to this person and says, "See? That's what a Jew is like," we are faced with a terrible chillul Hashem. Because the world, in its ignorance, often paints all of Klal Yisrael with the same broad brush. Our neshamos are all interconnected, like parts of one body. Therefore, the actions of each individual Yid have the potential to bring either great kiddush Hashem or, Rachmana litzlan, a great desecration. Our responsibility is to always strive for the former, to represent the beauty of Torah U'Mitzvos in everything we do, to show the world the light of HaKadosh Baruch Hu.
49:38We must always be vigilant, my dear talmidim, against the insidious poison of lashon hara and dangerous generalizations, especially when it comes to our holy nation. There are those, unfortunately, who seek to tarnish the entire Klal Yisrael by pointing to the actions of a few individuals who have strayed far from the path of Torah and mitzvos. When a talking head, whether it be on YouTube or otherwise, throws all of the people that happen to be Jewish into the same basket, you have a serious problem. Why? Because if you're saying that George Soros, Bernie Madoff are somehow representative of the Jewish people, you fundamentally misunderstand the concept of Klal Yisrael. These individuals, whose actions are a profound chillul Hashem and a source of immense pain, acted as individuals, driven by greed and a complete disregard for Torah values. Their deplorable deeds are a stark contradiction to everything Judaism stands for, and to label them as "Jewish criminals" is not only inaccurate but deeply anti-Semitic. Let us be clear: their personal transgressions do not define our people. We must always distinguish between the actions of individuals and the collective identity of Am Yisrael. So when we speak of individuals who have strayed far from the path of Torah, let us always remember that their personal failings are never to be attributed to our entire holy nation, Klal Yisrael. Therefore, when certain voices seek to generalize and throw the blame for the actions of someone like, the filth of a creature, Epstein, and all of the other criminals, and you call them a Jewish criminal, you are by default an anti-Semite. Why? Because their crimes had nothing to do with Judaism; it actually had to do with the fact that they are disregarding their Judaism. Their heinous deeds are a profound chillul Hashem, a desecration of G-d's Name, and they stand in direct contradiction to every sacred value the Torah HaKedosha teaches us. These individuals did not act because of their Judaism; on the contrary, they acted in direct opposition to it, abandoning its holy principles entirely.
50:36My dear students, it is crucial to understand that when a Jew, chas v'shalom, commits a crime, their actions are a betrayal of their heritage, not an expression of it. To call such a person a 'Jewish criminal' implies their Judaism is the source of their transgression, which is a grave error and indeed, an anti-Semitic trope. On the contrary, when a Jew acts in such a manner, they're disobeying their Judaism. They're ignoring their Judaism. They hate their Judaism. They didn't steal because the Torah says to steal. They stole because they don't care what the Torah says. They didn't rape. They didn't do all types of heinous, horrible things because of their Judaism. Quite the contrary. They did it because they abandoned their Judaism. This is a fundamental truth we must internalize, my friends. Such individuals have severed themselves from the essence of Yiddishkeit and the divine path of the Torah. They are acting as irreligious individuals, despite their birthright. However, I know what many of you are thinking in response to this, that... ...However, I know what many of you are thinking in response to this, that if their actions truly sever them from Yiddishkeit, then my initial point about the anti-Semitic nature of calling them a 'Jewish criminal' is strongly affirmed. So to call them a 'Jewish criminal' or the like is anti-Semitic because they would do the same thing even if they weren't Jewish. Now, of course, you're going to say, "Yes, Rabbi, but sometimes we see, unfortunately more often than we would like, religious Jews who commit these very transgressions!" Do the same thing.
51:32My dear students, we constantly emphasize the paramount importance of kiddush Hashem — sanctifying G-d's name — in all our actions. This includes demonstrating absolute yashrus (integrity) and emunah (trustworthiness) in our financial dealings. Sadly, we sometimes encounter the very opposite, a terrible chillul Hashem (desecration of G-d's name), where individuals who outwardly appear religious act in ways that deeply betray the values of our Torah. It brings to mind a troubling incident that occurred just a few days ago; someone showed me a video about an individual who pretends to be religious, yet has been involved in stealing what appears to be 40 or 50 million dollars from people over the last 10 years, through all types of elaborate scams. It's been one scheme after another. He has defrauded celebrities, businesspeople, and whoever else fell for his deceitful tricks; he even had his own father and other accomplices helping him in these illicit activities. All the while, he wears a kippah. Such behavior is a stark reminder that outward appearances mean nothing if the inner character and adherence to Halakha are corrupted. It is truly a tragedy, demonstrating a profound lack of yiras Shamayim (fear of Heaven), and precisely the kind of actions that bring shame upon our entire community, completely disconnected from the sacred teachings of our Torah. All the while, he pretends to be religious. And of course, he's not the only one; there are others. To call him a 'Jewish criminal' is anti-Semitic. Why? Because his Yiddishkeit has nothing to do with the crime. He is not committing a crime because he learned from the Torah that you need to go commit crimes, that you need to steal, to be a cheat, or to be a liar. It's quite the opposite. He is ignoring...
52:29My dear talmidim, we've been discussing the profound importance of guarding our mesorah, our sacred tradition, and the absolute primacy of Torah in our lives. It is truly disheartening, even painful, to witness how some movements, claiming to act in the name of the Jewish people, have strayed so far from our path. Indeed, when we speak of upholding the divine commandments, we find certain individuals and groups not only neglecting the Torah, but in fact, ignoring it even more profoundly than the secular and even the atheist Zionists. Because at least they don't pretend to be religious; at least they don't pretend to follow God. They actually protest against God, they fight against God, and they fight against the Torah. They want to destroy the Torah. They've been trying to do it for hundreds of years. So, consider this: the forefather of Zionism, Theodor Herzl, practiced Christianity, had a Christmas tree in his house, and even proposed in a letter to the Pope that his solution to antisemitism was to convert all the Jews to Catholicism! He harbored a deep hatred for Judaism. He didn't even give a brit milah to his own son, Hans. And tragically, we see this pattern repeated throughout history. Some of the other leading Zionists, when we examine what they wrote and what they said, their words literally sounded no better than those of Nazis. They had opportunities to save over a million Jews from concentration camps, and they chose not to. This is the tragic reality of a path divorced from Torah and true Yiddishkeit.
52:59even proposed in a letter to the Pope that his solution to antisemitism was to convert all the Jews to Catholicism. He harbored a deep hatred for Judaism. He didn't even give a brit milah to his own son, Hans. And tragically, we see this pattern repeated throughout history. Some of the other leading Zionists, when we examine what they wrote and what they said, their words literally sounded no better than those of Nazis. They had opportunities to save over a million Jews from concentration camps, and they chose not to. My dear students, talmidei chachamim, we have been discussing the weighty responsibility we bear when addressing the actions of those in positions of power, particularly within our own nation. It is a nuanced discussion, for while we are commanded to condemn injustice and immorality, we must always guard against implicating the entire Klal Yisrael for the sins of individuals. This brings us to a profound question that often troubles the heart: Why? Because it wasn't the Klal Yisrael – the entire Jewish people – whom such individuals truly sought to save. And in fact, one might argue that their policies sometimes seemed to prioritize specific political or material gains, even at a tragic human cost, rather than the true welfare and spiritual preservation of our brethren. Their conduct, at times, demonstrated a profound detachment from the core tenets of Yiddishkeit and the sanctity of Jewish life, reflecting values utterly antithetical to the Torah, even if they were born Jewish. Let us be clear: while a Yid always remains a Yid in the eyes of Heaven, regardless of their actions, we are commanded to distinguish between righteous conduct and deeds that bring chillul Hashem, a desecration of G-d's Name, to the world. Our responsibility is to uphold Torah u'Mitzvot and to pray for the betterment of all Klal Yisrael, even those who stray far from its path.
53:56It is imperative for us, as Bnei Yisrael, to always uphold the highest standards of derekh eretz and kavod ha-beriyot, even in our discourse regarding public figures. When we find ourselves compelled to voice criticism against individuals, even those in leadership roles, we must exercise extreme caution. So, when one is calling out people like Bibi Netanyahu or all of these other people who are doing things that are against humanity, against the law of the land, against morality, there is no problem with calling them out. The problem arises if one calls them a Jewish criminal, where one connects the fact that they are Jewish and implies that their actions are somehow a manifestation of their Judaism. Such an assertion demonstrates a profound misunderstanding of what it means to be a Yid, and it tragically gives ammunition to those who harbor genuine animosity towards our people. Their misdeeds, G-d forbid, stem not from their inherent Judaism, but rather from a failure to uphold the sacred covenant that defines us. And this brings us to a crucial point, talmidim. When we see individuals, even those who may appear outwardly observant, engaging in actions that are against the Torah, against halakha, actions that cause harm or are a khilul Hashem, we must be very careful with how we interpret and present this. To blame Yiddishkeit itself for such actions, to attribute their crime, because that is one hundred percent anti-Semitic. If you truly understood what it means to be a Yid, what it means to be Jewish according to the Torah, you would know that their crime is not because of their Judaism; rather, it is precisely because they are rejecting their Judaism. They are denying their Yiddishkeit! They are rebelling against their Yiddishkeit! It is not frumkeit that leads them to such actions; it is a total abandonment of frumkeit. We have a responsibility, therefore, to educate others and explain that true Jewish values are diametrically opposed to such behavior. This is a fundamental lesson we must all internalize and convey, always striving for kiddush Hashem.
54:47Indeed, my dear talmidim, it is crucial to understand that genuine Yiddishkeit demands adherence to Halakha, both in our devotion to HaKadosh Baruch Hu and in our interactions with one another. When individuals abandon the principles of our sacred Torah, particularly the Mitzvot that govern our conduct, it is a profound tragedy. Chas v'shalom, some people who commit heinous acts may still claim to be Jewish, but their deeds speak louder than their words. By their actions, they are denying their Judaism. They are rebelling against their Judaism. Even if they appear to be a shomer Mitzvot, if you see someone who looks like a religious Jew doing things that are against the law, doing things that are hurting other people, it is imperative that we recognize that such actions are a profound chillul Hashem, and they do not represent the Torah or the Jewish people. Their actions stem not from their Jewish identity, but from their personal flaws and base desires. Such a person, regardless of their outward appearance, acts solely out of their own obsession with lust, with power, with money, with materialism. It is a fundamental distortion of what it means to be a Yid. Good evening, everyone. We are learning tonight a very fundamental principle from our mussar and hashkafa. When we discuss individual responsibility, it is crucial to understand where the true source of action lies. It is a terrible mistake, one that unfortunately we see rampant in the broader society, to generalize about groups of people based on the actions of individuals. The Gemara teaches us that 'every person is judged according to their deeds.' We must remember this when we evaluate the character of others, and indeed, ourselves. He's not doing it because he's Jewish. He's doing it because he's a criminal. And he would do it whether he was Jewish, or Chinese, or Ethiopian, or whether he came from planet Mars. He's doing it because of his obsession with lust, with power, with money, with materialism. The same principle applies to any individual; to attribute one's actions to their race, even to a lesser extent, is a fundamental misunderstanding of human nature and bechirah – free will. This understanding is vital, for it empowers us to hold ourselves and others accountable for personal choices, rather than seeking facile explanations in superficial characteristics. Each soul is unique before HaKadosh Baruch Hu, and our judgment of others must reflect this profound truth. We pray for a world where individuals are truly seen for who they are, and for the choices they make.
55:34My dear talmidim, we must be exceedingly careful about how we speak and perceive others. It is a grave error, an aveirah in its own way, when we characterize an individual primarily by their background and then link them directly with a crime. For example, when they will say, "This black fellow just robbed somebody," or "This Arab just killed somebody." Or even, "This Chinese criminal!" What does it have to do with the fact that he is Chinese? What does it have to do with the fact that he is Arab? He committed a crime. The reason for that act, rebbeim, is crucial to understand and properly categorize. My dear talmidim, when we speak about the underlying reasons for human failings and transgressions, it is crucial to understand that Bechirah Chofshis, free will, is paramount. We cannot attribute sin to external factors such as one's background or appearance. Rather, the decision to stray from the path of Yiras Shamayim and Mitzvos is a personal one. For instance, consider a situation where an individual commits a crime. The reason is simple: because he committed a crime. He did not commit a crime because he is Black. He did not commit a crime because he is an Arab. He committed a crime because he succumbed to a lust for materialism, a lust for power, a lust for things that simply have nothing to do with his color, and nothing to do with his race. These are internal failings, not external ones. Now, the reason why I say it is 'to a lesser extent'... ...is because, at least within the Jewish world, we have the Torah, which provides a clear framework from which one can learn morality. You can learn what is righteous and what is wicked from it. So, when an individual who is Jewish decides to be a criminal, we already know that they have veered away from the truth of their very foundation. The principles are clearly laid out for us by Hakadosh Baruch Hu Himself, providing an unwavering guide for ethical conduct. In contrast,...
56:53The Torah, baruch Hashem, provides us with an eternal, unchanging ethical framework, a clear sense of right and wrong that transcends time and shifting social norms. It is a divine blueprint for a meaningful life. In stark contrast to this profound truth, their teachings. On the other hand, when somebody lives a secular life and, therefore, is simply trying to comply with the rules of man – rules that change from second to second, from person to person – they don't have any real foundation of morality. They are simply operating on a philosophy of 'survival of the fittest.' But even 'survival of the fittest' doesn't tell you that it's okay to steal from somebody, because you would not be okay if somebody stole from you. We see, then, that even the most rudimentary understanding of human interaction, the basic instinct for self-preservation, doesn't actually justify harming or stealing from others. There's a fundamental recognition, ingrained in every soul, that certain actions are simply beyond the pale. Every person, deep down, knows that killing, robbing, or stealing is wrong, regardless of their philosophy. This is the shared humanity that Hashem instilled in all of us, a universal sense of yashrus (uprightness). My dear talmidim, we must always remember the foundational principles of Torah and Mitzvos, which guide our conduct and our perceptions. We are taught that human beings are created b'Tzelem Elokim, in the image of G-d, and this confers upon every individual a fundamental dignity and sanctity. It is with this understanding that we must approach discussions of justice and morality. even Derech Eretz does not endorse this kind of mentality, nor does it condone killing or robbing people. Everyone knows it is wrong. Such actions fundamentally contradict human morality and Derech Eretz. So when someone labels a criminal, saying, 'This person is a black, green, yellow, Chinese, Christian, Muslim, or Buddhist criminal,' it is... a profound misunderstanding of justice and an affront to human dignity. This misguided approach not only fails to address the root causes of crime but also fosters division and prejudice within society. Such an outlook is deeply flawed, as we shall now discuss.
57:51My dear brothers, we must always internalize the ikar emunah (fundamental principle of faith) that our holy Torah guides us in all matters, including how we perceive and judge others. We observe in the broader world, rachmana litzlan (God forbid), how sinat chinam (baseless hatred) and prejudice can unfortunately take root. We must assert that it is something that is systematically wrong, racist, and stupid to judge individuals because of their color, race, or religion, as these characteristics have nothing to do with any crime they may have committed, nor with the underlying reasons for their actions. The very same applies to us, Am Yisrael (the Jewish people). We have the holy Torah, and HaKadosh Baruch Hu (the Holy One, Blessed Be He) tells us Himself that He will fight our wars and bring us victory, provided we remain steadfast in His Mitzvot (commandments). This divine assurance provides the ultimate perspective on how we should approach challenges, both personal and communal, knowing that our strength comes from adhering to His will. ...knowing that our strength comes from adhering to His will. And what is the reward for adhering to His will? HaKadosh Baruch Hu promises us that if you do what I said, if you do what I commanded, I will win every war for you. We see this explicitly stated in Sefer Shemot, in Parashat Beshalach, chapter 14, verse 14, where Hashem tells us through Moshe Rabbeinu, 'Hashem will fight your wars, and you shall remain silent.' This means that we can even reach a point where we achieve victory in all our wars, against any enemies, whether personal or national, without even lifting a weapon. This is the profound truth of bitachon (trust in God) and emunah (faith). However, if you don't...
58:48My dear students, we learn a profound lesson from this very incident. Hashem's patience is immense, but His message is clear. When we stray, when we forget the source of our bounty and the purpose of our existence, Hashem Himself declares the consequences. He says to us, as it were: if you don't, you treat Me as if I am meaningless, as if I am just like nature, like gravity, that it just happens to be that way. You forget I gave you rules, you forget what made you Jewish, you forget the laws of My Torah; then I will treat you even worse. This, my dear students, is a stern warning from the Master of the Universe. It reminds us that our relationship with Hashem is not passive; it is active, built on our commitment to His Mitzvot and His holy Torah. We must never forget the One who brought us out of Mitzrayim, who gave us the Torah at Har Sinai, and who sustains us every single moment. For if we do, G-d forbid, we risk the severest of consequences. May we always strive to remember our Maker and fulfill our sacred purpose. My dear talmidim, we often think that the challenges of emunah and yiras Shamayim are products of our generation, filled with materialism and distractions. We imagine that if we were only in a purer environment, all would be simple. But the truth, as we learn from our holy Torah, is quite different. The struggle against the yetzer hara is an eternal one, present even in the most pristine conditions. And we see even in this parashah. We were at Mount Sinai. We were getting food from heaven. We didn't need to work. We didn't need to bathe. We didn't need to launder. We were literally living in heaven on earth. But yet, even then, there was the yetzer hara that made some of us forget Who our Maker is and what our purpose in the world was. And Hashem punished them. Killed some. Made others suffer. These severe consequences served as a stark reminder of the gravity of our covenant with Hashem, teaching an unforgettable lesson about the sanctity of our mission and the unwavering authority of the Ribbono Shel Olam.
59:47It is easy to be swayed by outward appearances or by a display of raw power, Rabotai Yekarim, and we might be tempted to think that because someone has asserted their will strongly, their actions are automatically justified or aligned with Torah, when in reality their influence stems not from holiness, but from sheer determination and force of personality, but made everybody realize who's the boss. So, Rabotai Yekarim, when you bunch together the Torah-observant Jews with the rebels of Judaism, who most of the time are secular, leftist, liberal, and anti-Torah, you are creating a spiritual confusion that is truly catastrophic. These are not just different approaches; these are fundamentally opposing worldviews. To equate loyalty to Hakadosh Baruch Hu and His sacred mitzvot with active rebellion against them is an act of profound spiritual blindness. It is an insult to every ba'al Teshuvah, to every Jew who strives daily to fulfill the will of Hashem. It diminishes the immense value of Torah and mitzvot themselves. We must understand that our identity as Jews is intrinsically linked to our acceptance of Torah miSinai. Those who actively fight against Torah values, who promote agendas that are anathema to everything we stand for, cannot, and should not, be placed in the same category as those who dedicate their lives to Hashem and His Torah. Doing so, my friends, is not just a semantic error; it has grave spiritual consequences, leading to a fundamental misunderstanding of who we are as a people.
1:00:17My dear chaveirim, it is incumbent upon us always to exercise sharp discernment. We must distinguish clearly between those who sincerely strive to fulfill Hashem's will and those who, G-d forbid, merely wear a veneer of piety. Indeed, sometimes they pretend to be religious, but in truth, they are rebels. When one indiscriminately lumps together those who are loyal to Hashem and His holy Torah with those who rebel against the Torah into the same category, and declares, "they are all Jews, they are all the same," this not only demonstrates shtus (folly) and a profound ignorance of what the emet (truth) truly is, Such a fundamental misrepresentation, my brothers, completely obfuscates our understanding and prevents us from ever truly comprehending the profound motivations behind a life dedicated to Hashem and the purpose of existence itself. My dear talmidim, in a world often shrouded in confusion and conflicting ideologies, it is paramount that we firmly grasp the eternal truths that guide our lives. We often speak of discerning right from wrong, of acting with integrity and purpose, but from where does this ultimate standard emanate? What is the bedrock upon which genuine righteousness is built? Without this foundation, how can we truly understand the world and our place in it, especially when faced with the gravest of challenges? It also shows that you can never even arrive at what the truth is, because someone who is motivated by the Torah – that means they are motivated by God's Law, motivated by righteousness, motivated by good, motivated by fear of God, motivated by the purpose of life. Only a person truly dedicated to Torah u'Mitzvos, whose every fiber is aligned with the divine will, can perceive reality with clarity and act with emunah and yashrus. This is the ultimate standard, brothers, the unwavering compass by which we must navigate all aspects of existence, whether in times of peace or, chas v'shalom, in the midst of conflict.
1:01:12My dear talmidim, as we continue our shiur today, we must confront some of the harsh realities of the world HaKadosh Baruch Hu has placed us in. It is not always a simple or straightforward existence. Indeed, sometimes, the very purpose of life will involve wars, and the Torah gives us ways to understand how to act in such conflicts. This whole notion of people thinking, 'Oh, there shouldn't be any collateral damage!' That, my friends, is not understanding the true nature of war. Don't forget how your country—whatever country you're in—fought its wars. They didn't take water guns to Vietnam. They didn't throw... ...They didn't throw pillows. They engaged in battle, and regrettably, in war, there is hefsed and pain. While we constantly pray for a world of shalom, we must also be realistic about the world as it currently is, and understand that sometimes, even in terrible circumstances, there are rules of engagement. Our responsibility is to always rely on HaKadosh Baruch Hu, and pray for the speedy arrival of Mashiach, when all wars will cease and everlasting peace will reign for Am Yisrael and all humanity. If somebody comes to kill you, kill them first. This, Rabotai, is the reality of the world, and we see it reflected in history. When facing an existential threat, nations do not hesitate. Think, for instance, of the atomic bombs dropped on Nagasaki and Hiroshima. The Allied powers did not go and ask Hitler if he wanted to have coffee. They went to war. And in war, there is collateral damage. In war, some people who are not soldiers die. This is a harsh truth, but one that our Torah acknowledges when it speaks of milchamah (war). While we always pray for shalom (peace), we must understand that decisive action is sometimes required to protect Am Yisrael (the Jewish people) and ensure our future, as our Chachamim (Sages) teach us about pikuach nefesh (saving a life).
1:02:07...So when somebody is inspired, motivated, and adheres to the laws of the Torah, they understand that its wisdom extends to every conceivable facet of human existence, from the minutiae of daily life to the gravest matters of national security and self-preservation. Indeed, Rabotai, the Torah even contains specific laws pertaining to warfare. We are not permitted to simply initiate a war without just cause. Nor are we allowed to harbor an active enemy within our midst. We are commanded to know how to defend ourselves. As the Sages teach, Im ba l'horgekha, hashkem l'horgo – if someone comes to kill you, rise early and kill him first. This profound principle, Im ba l'horgekha, hashkem l'horgo, underscores the Torah's practical guidance in protecting life and ensuring the survival of the Jewish people, demonstrating that no aspect of our lives is left without Divine instruction. We learn from our holy Rabbeim throughout the generations that the Torah is not merely a collection of stories or ethical guidelines. Rather, it is the divine blueprint for existence itself, a detailed instruction manual given by HaKadosh Baruch Hu for living a life of true purpose and meaning. This is why we understand, ...meaning that the Torah has halakhot and instructions for everything, from the moment you wake up in the morning until the moment you go to sleep, throughout your entire life, from the moment you are born until the moment you pass away, and even after you pass on, regarding what your family needs to do. Everything is codified within our holy sefarim. So, when someone is inspired, motivated, and adheres to the halakhot, the laws of the Torah, then there is no doubt that such a person is on the right path. This is the path that brings true blessing and chesed to the individual, to their family, to Klal Yisrael, and indeed, to the entire world, fulfilling their true purpose in Creation, bringing nachas to HaKadosh Baruch Hu Himself.
1:02:58My dear talmidim, we must always remember the profound truth that HaKadosh Baruch Hu has given us the Torah as a guide, a clear path for life. When an individual sincerely clings to the ways of Torah, when they truly make mitzvos their life's pursuit, then there is no doubt that such a person will walk on a good path, one that is beneficial for themselves, for society, and for the entire world, bringing forth bracha and rachamim to all of creation. On the other hand, when someone is a rebel against the Torah, whether they are a rebel wearing a kippah and a beard, or they are a rebel immersed in their Zionist atheism, that person is a rebel, pure and simple. There is a fundamental difference between someone who strives to live by Torah and someone who actively rejects it. And it's crucial for us to understand this distinction, because... My dear talmidim, it is absolutely vital that we understand the deep confusion that exists today, particularly when people attempt to paint actions that are antithetical to our mesorah as somehow being rooted in our sacred Torah. There are those who, unfortunately, choose a path that is entirely divorced from Yiddishkeit, yet they may speak in the name of the Jewish people or even claim a connection to our heritage. We must be clear: That person is not acting the way they are acting because of the Torah. Quite the opposite. They are acting the way they are acting because they are going against the Torah. They do not care what Hashem says. Needless to say, they do not care what other people say. They just want to fulfill their own base lusts, their own desires, their own will—just like the majority of the world. So, to conflate those two—true Yiddishkeit with such behaviors—is a terrible error that causes immense chillul Hashem and obscures the truth of our sacred tradition. We must always delineate clearly between those who uphold the banner of Torah U'Mitzvos and those who, sadly, abandon it for their own purposes.
1:03:58...and we certainly wish that all people would learn from us in the proper spirit. But ultimately, we have to recognize that this whole issue of antisemitism is ignorance, and it is part of the problem that is causing so much confusion among Jews and Gentiles. When we came out with various lectures about the truth about Tzionut and how it is inherently the enemy of the Jewish people, the enemy of the Torah, and of the true essence of what it means to be a Jew, loyal to Hash-m and His mitzvot. Indeed, to illustrate the danger of such ideologies, even when seemingly opposed to each other, we even brought forth quotes from the evil Nazis, including passages from Mein Kampf, to show precisely what they articulated concerning the Jewish people. Many anti-Semites took clips from these very lectures and publicized them, garnering millions of views. I must confess, I sometimes wish I knew who they were, so I could perhaps have them manage our YouTube channels and help us achieve millions of views for the rest of our content, l'shem Shamayim, for a holy purpose! But the point is that initially, there were Jews that saw this being highlighted by Nazis, by anti-Semites, and came to me complaining.
1:04:59And so we see, my dear talmidim, that the Ribbono shel Olam often tests us through difficult situations, through nisyonos. Sometimes, when we act with mesirus nefesh – with self-sacrifice for Klal Yisrael – we might face criticism even from within our own community. For instance, when we decided to publicize certain matters, or put up those prominent displays of Yiddishkeit for all the world to see, some had concerns. But the point is that initially, there were Jews that saw this being highlighted by Nazis, by anti-Semites, and came to me complaining; they came to me complaining, 'Look,' they said, 'you're promoting anti-Semitism! You're promoting things that are going to cause Jewish people harm!' They truly believed they were acting for the good of Klal Yisrael, concerned for our safety. But I understood, with the guidance of my Rav, that this was not the case, and that sometimes, we must stand firm. And of course, I knew what I was doing because obviously I have a Rav that tells me what's allowed, what's not allowed, what I should, what I shouldn't do. So there was no question in my mind. And I addressed every one of the people that came up with these and I explained to them that not only is this good, but you'll see that there's going to be good things coming out of it. Because at least here, the anti-Semites are hearing... We often find ourselves in situations where difficult decisions must be made, and it's natural for people to question the path chosen. However, as Yidden, we have a clear path to follow when it comes to halakha and hashkafah. And of course, I knew what I was doing because, obviously, I have a Rav that tells me what's allowed, what's not allowed, what I should do, and what I shouldn't do. So there was no question in my mind. And I addressed every one of the people who came up with these concerns, and I explained to them that not only is this good, but you'll see that there are going to be good things coming out of it. Because at least here, the anti-Semites are hearing a truer representation of what Yiddishkeit really stands for. This is crucial for Kiddush Hashem in our generation.
1:05:51So, my dear friends, when we speak about the Jewish people and our responsibilities, a crucial question often arises: what is our perspective, our hashkafa, on those who claim Jewish identity but do not live according to our sacred traditions? The Torah perspective is concerning those individuals who happen to be Jewish. They are not acting in the name of Judaism; they are not representing the Jewish people. Rather, they are representing themselves, they are representing their own desires. Even if they call themselves Jewish, if they desecrate Shabbat on a regular basis, they are as much following Judaism as a monk. The fact that they are Jewish by birth is certainly a truth, a Halachic reality we acknowledge, as the Torah tells us 'a Jew remains a Jew' no matter what. However, this status does not automatically grant them the spiritual merit or the right to represent Klal Yisrael when their actions contradict everything the Torah stands for. My dear talmidim, we often grapple with a fundamental question concerning our brethren who, regrettably, find themselves distant from the path of Torah and mitzvot. Are they still considered fully part of Klal Yisrael simply because their parents are Jewish? Indeed, that is precisely what our holy Torah teaches us, yet we see them, at times, disregarding its profound wisdom. Of course, we ceaselessly strive to encourage every single Jew to do teshuvah – to return to their spiritual roots, to embrace the beauty and truth of Judaism. However, until that blessed moment arrives for every individual, we must realistically understand the spiritual landscape we are navigating. There is a crucial difference, a fundamental distinction. When someone is truly inspired by the eternal light of the Torah, their actions will invariably lead them down a righteous path, one that brings immense benefit not only to themselves but to all of humanity. This is the profound contrast, my friends, between a life guided by Divine wisdom and one driven by ephemeral, earthly impulses. The Torah-inspired individual strives for kedushah and truth, creating a world filled with goodness and spiritual elevation, a stark departure from the self-serving struggle that, unfortunately, characterizes so much of the secular world.
1:06:51Reb Yidden, we are commanded by Hashem to live lives of kedusha and Torah, to follow the path of mitzvos. But let us consider for a moment what happens when a person, chas v'shalom, departs from this divine guidance, when his actions are no longer rooted in Yiddishkeit. When someone is inspired by politics, by self-interest, by lust, or by materialism, then what does it become? It becomes a world of survival of the fittest, just as it is among the rest of the nations. You see this survival of the fittest in China, the survival of the fittest in Saudi Arabia, the survival of the fittest in America, the survival of the fittest in England. And what is the consequence of such a mindset, of such a system? People commit crimes. This is the sad reality of a life lived without the light of Torah. When one's sole motivation is personal gain, to achieve their benefit and their desires, then the very notion of "good" is twisted. They might tell themselves it's for a greater good, or that they simply hope not to get caught, disregarding completely the pain and harm they inflict on others in the process. This, my friends, is the antithesis of a Torah life. My dear students, we are often tasked with understanding the complexities of human nature, particularly when it comes to actions that defy reason and morality. Our holy Torah provides us with profound insights into the human condition, guiding us to comprehend the yetzer hara, the evil inclination, and its subtle workings. It is not always a blatant desire for evil, but often a warped perspective. We must ask ourselves: what truly motivates an individual to transgress, to commit an act that is clearly harmful or forbidden? It is a fundamental misunderstanding to believe that when people engage in wrongful conduct, they do so out of a conviction that their actions are inherently righteous or l'shem Shamayim. On the contrary, people do whatever they want, not because they think it's good, but rather because they want the benefit that comes out of it, and they hope they won't get caught. This is a crucial distinction. No criminal thinks that what they're doing is inherently good, but they figure that they will do this, and more good will come out of it than bad, completely disregarding the fact that they're hurting people in the process. This applies across the board, to all individuals, irrespective of their background or identity. This understanding teaches us that the root of such actions is often a deep-seated obsession with personal gain, a distorted kavanah focused entirely on self-interest and the avoidance of immediate consequence, rather than any intrinsic belief in the goodness of the act itself. Therefore, when we analyze human behavior, especially concerning those who stray, we must recognize this universal struggle against the allure of immediate gratification and the delusion of escaping accountability. It is a challenge for every single person to overcome their yetzer hara and to always strive for actions that are truly tov v'yashar in the eyes of HaKadosh Baruch Hu.
1:07:51My dear talmidim, we live in a world where discernment is crucial. We must learn to differentiate between the individual and the klal. Often, when negative actions occur, people are quick to cast blame widely, even on our entire nation. But we must understand the truth behind such incidents. Consider those who commit certain wrongs: they are not committing the crime because of their color, their race, or their religion. They are committing it because of their obsession with their own self-interest. So for all of those people that continue to lump together all Jews into the same basket, you are anti-Semitic and ignorant. This lesson is paramount. We must never fall into the trap of collective guilt, nor allow others to do so to Am Yisrael. It is a profound mitzvah to judge fairly and to seek the truth, distinguishing between the actions of an individual driven by personal desires and the holy aspirations of our entire nation. We often hear these discussions about right and wrong, about tzaddikim and resha'im, and sometimes it feels distant, doesn't it? Perhaps we think, 'What does that have to do with me?' And the truth is, I don't think you care. On the other hand, for those that have now woken up and realized, 'Wow, there is a difference!' If you look at the actions of the righteous rabbis, Rav Ovadia Yosef, the Chafetz Chaim, Rav Akiva Eiger, the Rambam, the Ramban, and the Arizal, all of these great sages, all of these righteous people, famous and not famous. Their very lives serve as living examples, shining brightly throughout history, showing us the path we should emulate. Their impact is undeniable.
1:08:50Good evening, everyone. It's truly inspiring, isn't it, when we reflect upon the great individuals throughout our history, and even in our own times, who have brought so much light into the world. You see how these people helped improve the world in different ways, certainly spiritually and certainly materially. They built institutions, fostered understanding, and uplifted countless souls, all rooted in their commitment to Torah and mitzvos. On the other hand, if you look at all of the 'bad guys' – those who brought destruction and suffering – you'll see one common denominator among all of them. Not a single one of them followed the path of Torah and mitzvos. Their actions, no matter how they tried to rationalize them, were not aligned with Hashem's will or Halakha. It was never just a matter of breaking human laws or hurting their fellow man; their ultimate transgression was always against the divine word, against HaKadosh Baruch Hu Himself. Their evil deeds were done completely outside the framework of true Yiddishkeit, even if they happened to be Jewish by birth. My dear talmidim, it is crucial to always distinguish between the actions of an individual and the immutable truth of the Torah itself. When discussing instances where individuals who happen to be Jewish commit wrongdoing, we must understand the full ramifications. When they committed these transgressions, their actions also went against the Torah. It didn't just go against the law of the land, nor did it merely go against the interest of another fellow human being. Rather, such acts went against the Torah, and indeed, against HaKadosh Baruch Hu Himself. Meaning, these actions were certainly not done in the name of Judaism. The perpetrators merely happened to be Jewish individuals. Such actions are a personal failing, a betrayal of the very principles we hold dear, and not, chas v'shalom, an outgrowth of our holy tradition. This distinction is paramount for anyone seeking to understand the truth, and for anyone who truly wishes to call out wrongdoing with clarity and emes.
1:09:44My dear talmidim, we often discuss the critical importance of hashkafa and discerning emet – truth – in all aspects of life, especially when evaluating actions or individuals. It is a fundamental middah to approach every situation with objectivity, devoid of external biases. We must always remember that the essence of a deed stands independent of the person's identity. For example, consider a situation where: just like a bank robber might happen to be Chinese, or from Pakistan, or an African American from America, or from any other background. These details are entirely incidental; the person's ethnicity or origin has nothing to do with the act of theft itself. Therefore, when one truly seeks to discern the truth, one must first ensure a clear understanding of what that truth entails, devoid of superficial factors. Anytime you are considering calling someone out, it is imperative that your critique stems from a place of emet and not from personal prejudice. The Chachamim teach us the grave error of judging based on preconceived notions or generalizations. We must always strive to address the action, not to unfairly characterize the individual based on their group identity. Remember, our objective is tikkun olam, to fix and refine, not to create further division or misunderstanding. ...And for all of those people that are saying, 'wait, but what about the welfare, and what about the many kids...' - my friends, if there is a legitimate concern, if there is a problem that needs to be addressed, chas v'shalom (Heaven forbid), in a specific instance, then certainly, there's no problem with it. But make sure you call them out for the right reasons and don't add your own personal bias into the picture. Because if you just simply decide that you hate all black people, but you decide that you hate thieves and you assume that all black people are thieves, no one will agree with you. This applies universally, in all situations. We are taught to judge lema'an HaShem (for the sake of G-d) with ayin tovah (a good eye) and dan lekaf zechut (judge favorably), distinguishing between the individual and the generalization. It is pashut (simple) common sense, b'derech eretz (with proper conduct), that we do not stereotype any group.
1:10:44My dear talmidim, in every civilized society, there are systems in place for those who qualify to receive support. This is the law of the land. We must not, number one, assume that we know more than we do about who is qualified, and number two, fall into the trap of broad generalizations. The reality is simple: certainly there are some that are thieves, and certainly there are some that are not thieves. To say that they are thieves because of their color has nothing to do with it. And just like it makes sense clearly to anybody, it should make sense when it comes to Judaism as well. This principle of individual responsibility, not collective guilt, applies to all areas. And so, for all of those people that are saying, 'Wait, but what about the welfare, and what about the many kids...?' we must be prepared to articulate the truth, grounded in the halakha and the reality of our lives, which reflects the brachah of large families, not a burden. Good evening, talmidim. We are discussing the principle of dina d'malchuta dina – the law of the land is the law. This is a fundamental concept in halakha, guiding our interaction with the medinah we live in. Sometimes, we hear discussions, even among our own, that seem to question the validity or morality of certain actions, particularly concerning parnassah and government assistance. Let's clarify this, based on the Shulchan Aruch and the understanding of our Gedolim. The reality is that every government in a civilized country has benefits available to whoever fits. If a person fits the criteria, they fill out the applications and get qualified. This is the law of the land. You cannot, number one, assume that you know more than you do, and number two, cast aspersions or judge others based on your own limited understanding. We must remember that the Ribono shel Olam provides parnassah to everyone in His own wondrous ways. To question how a family with many children manages, or to imply impropriety, is not only unproductive but often stems from an underlying agenda, rather than a genuine pursuit of emes. So, you cannot, number one, assume that you know more than you do, and number two...
1:11:42My dear talmidim, it is imperative that we understand the true nature of the challenges we face. We live in a society governed by Dinah d'Malchusa Dinah, the law of the land. Yet, we sometimes encounter those who act as if they are above these laws. One might disagree with the law of the land, acting as if they are the ones running the country. If such individuals truly dislike the law of the land, then they are free to leave. But the reality is that when people go and say, "Well, how do they afford seven, ten kids?", they reveal their true motivations. To this, we answer simply: Hashem gives the money! Just like He gives money to an Elon Musk, He gives money to a regular person, and He gives money to a Jew; He gives money to every human being. When people ask those types of questions, you realize that they have an agenda. Their questions are not born of genuine concern or curiosity, but from a preconceived notion. It is a deeply ingrained prejudice that uses baseless accusations as a flimsy excuse to foster hatred against Klal Yisrael. My dear talmidim, we often observe that when individuals harbor deep-seated animosity, particularly towards Klal Yisrael, they possess a predisposition that has nothing to do with the argument at hand. They are simply employing all of these various pretexts as a proxy and an excuse to hate Jews. This is precisely what Hitler, may his name and memory be blotted out, accomplished, and it is precisely what every other notorious anti-Semite has done throughout history. Their hatred is fundamentally pre-determined, and they merely seek any available justification for it. Therefore, we must recognize that such hostility stems from a predefined prejudice, not from rational discourse or any actual grievance.
1:12:36But sadly, Rabotai, there are those who seek to undermine this truth, to sow discord and doubt. They try to twist perceptions and find fault where none truly exists against the essence of our people and our Torah. And then they started inventing reasons why. They would highlight the few 'bad apples' within a community, as if those isolated cases represented the entire group. They would point to a few Jews who erred, chas v'shalom, as if all of Klal Yisrael were thereby indicted. They would similarly point to a few individuals from other specific groups, as if all members of those groups were inherently flawed. They generalized, taking the actions of a minute few and applying it to everyone, as if the entire world was corrupted. This is a common tactic, my dear friends, to try and discredit a whole through the isolated failings of a few. But we know better. We know that such generalizations are false and malicious, designed only to divide and conquer. Rabbosai, in our contemporary society, there's a prevalent notion that good and evil are fluid concepts, entirely dependent on individual perception or the prevailing trends of the time. Many argue that human reason alone is sufficient to define morality, and they dismiss the eternal wisdom of our holy Torah as antiquated or irrelevant, chas v'shalom! But anyone with common sense, and even a little bit of truth in their heart, knows that's all a lie. One has nothing to do with the other. So our Torah, Rabbosai ha-Yekarim, is beautiful. It's perfect. It's the law of G-d. It doesn't change. The more you learn what our Torah says, the more you'll understand what good is. It is precisely through deep engagement with its teachings that we gain clarity. Because, dear brothers, the only one who truly knows good is the One who invented good, the Creator of the world.
1:13:29My dear chaverim, we are living in a generation fraught with confusion, where the very definitions of right and wrong, good and evil, are constantly being challenged and distorted. People search for meaning, for purpose, for a path to true fulfillment, but often look in the wrong places. We must remember that only the ultimate source of all existence can define what is truly beneficial for us, for Klal Yisrael, and indeed, for all of humanity, because the only One that truly knows good is the One that invented good, the Creator of the world. So long as we're following what the Torah says, we have a path that's going towards good. The moment we veer away from that path, the moment we disregard the Torah, we are no longer on the path of good; we're on a path of disaster and evil. This foundational principle, my friends, is what truly defines our journey. Our Chazal throughout the generations have stressed this truth without compromise. It is not our subjective opinions, nor the fleeting trends of society, but the unchanging wisdom of HaKadosh Baruch Hu, as revealed in His holy Torah, that provides the unwavering compass. When we deviate from this derech HaTorah, we inevitably find ourselves lost in a wilderness of our own making, experiencing the bitter fruits of disobedience. It is a harsh reality, but an undeniable one that plays out in our lives, in our communities, and indeed, in the entire world around us. My dear brothers, we often ponder the state of the world in which we live. Chazal teach us much about human nature and the ways of the nations. So when we witness the challenges and the prevailing spirit of discord, we seek deeper understanding. And that is why we see the things that we observe in society and even in everyone's backyard. There are many good Jews out there that the world does not even know about, because they are too busy hating us to recognize the good within our midst and to appreciate those whom they should truly cherish. And that is why the Gemara in Maseches Sukkah says that if the nations knew how valuable the Beis HaMikdash was for their benefit, for their very welfare... they would have acted very differently. They would have rushed to protect it, understanding that the blessings it brought forth were for all of humanity. It truly served as the spiritual heart of the world, channeling bracha to every corner, to every nation, ensuring their prosperity and peace.
1:14:28So we understand that HaKadosh Baruch Hu is the Creator of all, and though there are distinctions, His divine providence extends to everyone. This is why our Sages teach us about the profound role Am Yisrael played in the Beit HaMikdash for the benefit of all humanity. Imagine, if the nations of the world truly grasped the significance of what transpired within those sacred walls, how differently they would have acted! They would have sent their armies to protect the Holy Temple, to protect the Beit HaMikdash. Because every year during Sukkot, when Am Yisrael would pray, they would bring sacrifices in the name of the nations to protect the nations and bring them blessings. If the nations knew this, they'd literally send their armies to protect the Jewish people and the Beit HaMikdash. This wasn't just about Jewish survival; it was about bringing blessing and protection to the entire world, as ordained by HaKadosh Baruch Hu Himself. Indeed, the very purpose of these offerings highlights the interconnectedness of all humanity under G-d's benevolent rule, demonstrating that Klal Yisrael's prayers for the nations are a fundamental aspect of the divine order. So, having understood the divine mandate for Klal Yisrael to pray for all humanity, one might naturally ask: Why should the Jewish people pray for the nations, and desire the nations to benefit? Because it is all HaKadosh Baruch Hu's laws. He created all of it. Yes, there is a difference between the Jew and the Gentile. Absolutely. But even among the Jews, there is a difference between one Jew and another. And these distinctions are indeed significant, affecting our understanding of responsibility and spiritual standing.
1:15:19My dear talmidim, we often speak in general terms about 'a Jew,' but it is vital to delve deeper into the nuances of our holy nation. Chazal teach us that there are many different levels and categories within Am Yisrael, each with its unique responsibilities and spiritual significance. We must recognize that there's a fundamental difference between a Jew who, though born Jewish, unfortunately does not observe halakha, and a Jew who, whether born into the covenant or having embraced it through geirus, faithfully adheres to halakha. And even among those who faithfully adhere to halakha, there's a profound difference between someone who possesses a specific lineage or status within Klal Yisrael. Is he an Yisrael? A Levi? A Kohen? A Ger tzedek? Or, chas v'shalom, a Mamzer? This clearly illustrates that even among those committed to Torah and mitzvot, there are many distinct categories, different places, different roles in the world, and unique purposes. So, instead of focusing solely on... My dear talmidim, we often speak about the profound unity of Am Yisrael, and indeed we are all one soul, connected by our shared destiny and our sacred covenant with Hashem. Yet, within this profound unity, the Torah itself reveals a magnificent, intricate tapestry of diversity. We see this even in the very fabric of our people, the different distinctions and responsibilities bestowed upon us by Divine wisdom. When we consider the various classifications and roles within the Jewish nation, we are compelled to ask: is it a Yisrael? Someone that's a Levi? Someone that's a Kohen? Someone that's a convert? Someone that's a mamzer? Meaning, even among the Jews, there are differences: different categories, different places, different roles in the world, different purposes. So, instead of focusing so much on these outward distinctions or on aspects that may seem challenging at first glance, let us pivot our gaze. Let us always strive to understand the profound wisdom and intrinsic beauty within every part of our holy Torah, seeking to grasp the deeper truth that unifies all.
1:16:02My dear friends, when we delve into the depths of Torah, it is often tempting to focus on areas that we find perplexing or that challenge our current understanding. However, I want to offer you a different perspective: instead of focusing on the things you don't like because you don't understand, start looking at all the beautiful things that you can understand in the Torah. And perhaps become more motivated to learn more of the truth about the things you don't understand and realize that not only you didn't understand, but you didn't understand that you didn't understand. And now that you do understand, you love it because of the truth. This approach to limud haTorah cultivates a deeper appreciation for Hashem's infinite wisdom and truly transforms our spiritual journey. Good evening, dear talmidim and esteemed members of our shiur. Tonight, we will delve into a fascinating shailah in Choshen Mishpat, a scenario that raises intriguing questions about commercial law and trust. As you know, we often present cases that challenge our understanding of halacha. This particular case, which we've been discussing for a few weeks, has generated much thought. These are some of the things that I wanted to say. Now I know that some of you have been waiting for me to give you the answer to the question that we asked a few weeks ago. And then I'm going to ask you another question. The question a couple of weeks ago was: one man sells something to another man, we'll call it a bicycle. Reuven sold a bicycle to Shimon. And Shimon said, "Listen, I'm going to give you one thousand dollars in a check, but you have to cash it today." So, the condition was explicitly stated by Shimon. Now, the next part of the story unfolds, which will lead us to the crux of the shailah.
1:17:01Reuven said, 'No problem.' Shimon then gave him the check. However, Reuven received a call on his way to the bank that his wife needed him, so he didn't go to the bank that day. He figured he would go the next day. When he went to the bank the next day, he took the check out of his pocket and realized that it was blank, because Shimon had used ink that disappears. So, Reuven came to Shimon and said, 'You have to pay me!' So, my dear talmidim, we've been discussing this intriguing shaylah concerning the check. Shimon, you recall, wrote a check to Reuven but with a clear tnai – a condition – that it must be deposited immediately. Reuven, however, delayed, and as a result, the ink disappeared, rendering the check useless. When Reuven came demanding payment, what was Shimon's claim? He stood his ground, and Shimon said, "No, no, I don't have to pay you because I told you. I had a condition. I told you that you had to deposit it yesterday. And had you deposited it yesterday, it wouldn't have erased. But you didn't follow the instructions, and therefore, it's your loss. I gave you the money." Now, some of you, my diligent bnei Torah, weighed in with your initial thoughts. Some of you said, "Shimon is right. He gave him rules. He has to deposit the check. And Reuven didn't listen. He has lost." And others, perhaps seeking a compromise based on pesharah, suggested, "Maybe they should split it." But what is the din here? What does halakha dictate in such a scenario? Is it truly Reuven's loss, or does Shimon bear responsibility? We must delve into the principles of kinyanim and tnayim, as laid out by our Rishonim like the Rambam and Rashi, and as elaborated upon by the Acharonim in the Shulchan Aruch and its commentaries. We need to examine whether the condition set by Shimon was a valid and enforceable tnai in halakha, or if there's a different aspect to this shaylah that we haven't yet considered. We will see that the poskim have much to teach us regarding the true legal standing of this unique case.
1:17:56Chaveirim (friends), we've been delving deep into the sugya (topic) of kinyanim (acquisitions) and the halakhic requirements for a valid transfer of ma'os (money) in a transaction. We spoke at length about how a payment isn't truly finalized if the instrument itself isn't valid mi'd'Oraisa or mi'd'Rabbanan. This brings us to a practical shailah that came up in our beis medrash this week regarding Reuven and Shimon. Some might have thought, regarding the pesak (ruling) we're about to discuss, that we should perhaps just give Reuven part of the money, be nice about it. But then, some of you correctly pointed out, "No, no, Reuven needs the money! He didn't get paid!" What's the halakhic answer? The answer is that Shimon has to write a new check with normal ink and give it to Reuven. Why? Because from the moment that he wrote the original check, he already had a problem. The original check, for whatever reason – whether it was written with erasable ink, or it was a post-dated check that wasn't valid at the time of the kinyan, or it bounced – wasn't a proper, valid transfer of ma'os according to halakha. Just as we established earlier, if the payment isn't valid by the time one attempts to use it, it's as if the money was never truly given for the transaction in the first place. Therefore, Reuven has not actually received payment according to halakha, and Shimon still owes him the full amount. because the transaction was not based on a condition. The transaction was: "I'm going to give you my bicycle, you're going to give me one thousand dollars." And if you're choosing a payment method of credit card, check, cash, coins, or apples, it doesn't make a difference to me. If I agree to take the payment from you, that's the payment. But if your payment that you chose is not a valid payment by the time I use it, then you never actually gave me money.
1:18:54Chavreim, we've been discussing various aspects of halakha related to commerce and transactions, and now, I'm going to ask you something a little more complicated. In the old days, people used to use the barter system. What, precisely, is the barter system? You'd exchange goods for goods. So if, let's say, you had apples but you wanted bananas, you would tell the other merchant, "Listen, I want 100 kilos of bananas. In exchange, I'll give you 100 kilos of apples or 50 kilos of apples, depending on what the value of each one is. It could be that apples are more valuable, less valuable." So they exchanged goods for goods, mamash, without money. This system, chavreim, was the standard for centuries, l'havdil, before currency became widespread. Now, let us consider a practical she'eilah based on this. There was once a ba'al habayis named Reuven, and he had some apples. And Shimon was also a merchant of apples, but his shipment didn't come, chas ve'shalom. Chavreim, we've been discussing various aspects of halakha related to commerce and transactions, and now, I'm going to ask you something a little more complicated. In the old days, people used to use the barter system. What, precisely, is the barter system? You'd exchange goods for goods. So if, let's say, you had apples but you wanted bananas, you would tell the other merchant, "Listen, I want 100 kilos of bananas. In exchange, I'll give you 100 kilos of apples or 50 kilos of apples, depending on what the value of each one is. It could be that apples are more valuable, less valuable." So they exchanged goods for goods, mamash, without money. This system, chavreim, was the standard for centuries, l'havdil, before currency became widespread. Now, let us consider a practical she'eilah based on this. There was once a ba'al habayis named Reuven, and he had some apples. And Shimon was also a merchant of apples, but his shipment didn't come, chas ve'shalom. And he had customers. He had customers for apples. And the price of apples was sky high. Every apple was selling for $10. And he wanted to sell apples. So he came to Reuven. He saw that Reuven has a lot of them. He said, Reuven, listen. Give me some apples. Give me a, you know, a supply of apples to sell.
1:19:53My dear friends, we delve today into a fascinating halakha concerning mamon – monetary dealings – and the nuanced interactions between bein adam l'chaveiro, one person and another. Our Chazal, of blessed memory, provide us with many practical scenarios to illuminate these complex laws. Let us consider the case of a certain merchant, let's call him Shimon. He had customers for apples, and the market price for apples was extraordinarily high; each apple was selling for ten dollars! Shimon was eager to sell apples, so he approached Reuven, seeing that Reuven had a plentiful supply. He said, "Reuven, listen, please give me some apples. Give me a, you know..." He was about to specify the quantity he needed from Reuven, and explain his plan for repayment, which we will discuss further. ...10 crates of apples, and as soon as I get my shipment later today, I'll give you the 10 crates of apples back. But at least in the meantime, I can do some business.' Reuven said, 'No problem. I'll give you apples.' The explicit understanding was, 'You give me apples back today.' Indeed. Well, as you would have it, Reuven gave him the apples, and So, the initial agreement was clear: Shimon was to deliver ten crates of apples to Ruben. However, as often happens in business, things didn't go according to plan. And Shimon never came back that day. He was busy; he had things to attend to. He didn't come back with the apples. He had received a shipment, but he never delivered them to Ruben. A week passed. The price of apples dropped by ninety percent; instead of being ten dollars an apple, it went down to one dollar an apple. But Shimon eventually came back, saying, "Listen, here are your ten crates of apples." Naturally, Ruben was quite taken aback by this. He immediately confronted Shimon, expressing his astonishment at the offer, given the drastic change in market value. Ruben then passionately argued, as we will see, that he was now entitled to a hundred crates of apples, not just ten. This, as we will discuss, led them to seek the guidance of Abedin, a respected dayan.
1:21:24We have a classic halachic dilemma, brothers, a scenario between two parties, Reuven and Shimon, that often comes up in our batei din. Imagine Reuven, a shrewd businessman, had an agreement with Shimon. The deal was for apples, a certain quantity, but the market took an unexpected turn. So, when the time came for the exchange, here's what transpired: Reuven said, "No, no, no, no, no, no, no, no!" He insisted, "You have to give me a hundred crates of apples!" When Shimon looked puzzled, Reuven explained, "Why a hundred crates? Because last week, the price of an apple was ten dollars! Now it's only a dollar!" Shimon, however, retorted, "Okay, a dollar, ten dollars, what do I care? The deal was, I'm going to give you apples, and you're going to take apples. What's the problem here?" Unable to resolve their dispute, they brought their case to the Av Beis Din. Now, this brings us to a fundamental question in Choshen Mishpat that we must delve into. So, chaverim, we've been delving into the complex sugya of dinei mamonot, particularly concerning commercial agreements and the concept of ona'ah – fair pricing. Now, let's consider a scenario that often arises in business dealings and presents a compelling she'eilah for us to dissect based on halakha. The she'eilah before us is: who's right? Is it permissible for him to give 100 cases of apples instead of the 10 that were originally agreed upon, simply because the market price of apples has dropped significantly? Or is this not his responsibility, because, as the saying goes, 'apples for apples'? What do you chaverim think? As you talmidim ponder this over the next few days, please come prepared to discuss with a mekor – a source from Gemara, Rishonim, or Acharonim – that supports your view. We're looking for a profound limud, not just a simple answer, as we seek to understand the da'as Torah on this matter. May Hashem grant us much siyata diShmaya in our learning.
1:22:23My dear talmidim, we are delving into a complex she'eilah today. The Gemara in Bava Kama presents a fascinating case. We have many interesting points to consider regarding this matter. However, remember, one must not merely state an opinion, but rather provide a reasoned basis for it. Thus, your conclusion should stem from genuine lomdus, not merely a guess with a fifty-fifty chance of being correct. We seek a genuine reason why: why one might argue he must give him apples and that suffices, or why he must provide ten portions, or why some intermediate solution, or whatever else you might conclude. That is indeed a substantive answer. Consider these possibilities, research the Mefarshim, and come prepared next week to discuss your insights, be'ezrat Hashem. My dear Yidden, when we speak of harbatzas Torah and chesed, it's not just abstract concepts. Baruch Hashem, with your partnership, your mesiras nefesh, we've seen incredible fruits. She'koach to each and every one of you who has joined us in this holy work. Your generosity, your sacrifice, your vision, it has yielded, Baruch Hashem, the most incredible results this past year: here's what your support did, and it was all verified by Candid. A staggering 238,000 Jewish individuals were fed or financially assisted. Over 15,000 Torah shiurim and 500 Torah films were produced and distributed across twenty-three channels and fifteen languages. We also distributed 280,000 free sefarim by Rav Ephraim Kahlon and myself worldwide. And Baruch Hashem, the impact continues to grow, touching even more souls, reaching further than we could have ever imagined, truly a testament to the power of Klal Yisrael working together, a testament to what we can accomplish when we unite for Klal Yisrael's benefit. We've seen, Baruch Hashem...
1:23:19My dear friends, Chazal teach us the immense power of harbatzat Torah – spreading Torah – and baruch Hashem, with your support, we've seen incredible siyata diShmaya in this sacred endeavor. The reach of our shiurim and educational initiatives has grown exponentially. For instance, the number of individuals engaging with our online content and programs was up from 150,000 the year before. Beyond that, a remarkable 2.3 million outreach materials were given out free of charge, such as Asher Yatzar cards, USBs, and CDs. All of this, baruch Hashem, was funded almost entirely by individual donors, just like yourselves. There were no large foundation grants; rather, it was simply dedicated people like you, who watched our videos, got inspired, and decided to partner with us. Your commitment and generosity are the very lifeblood of our harbatzat Torah, enabling us to continue this vital work and illuminate the world with the eternal wisdom of our mesorah. May HaKadosh Baruch Hu bless each of you abundantly for your unwavering support and partnership. We have covered some profound insights this evening regarding parashat ha'shavua. Now, as is our custom, we open the floor for questions. Therefore, everyone may now ask your questions, and B'ezrat Hashem, HaKadosh Baruch Hu will guide us to the answers. Very well, let us see. Yes, please, what is your question?
1:24:25My dear friends, Baruch Hashem, we've had a truly inspiring shiur today. Before we conclude with a hearty amen, I just want to address a few administrative matters and questions that have come in. I see some kind messages, and let me see. Thank you for all the blessings. I appreciate it. What's the website to donate? You can go to beezratashem.org. I'll spell this for you: B-E-E-Z-R-A-T-H-A-S-H-E-M dot O-R-G. And if you didn't get all that, you could just send me a message. If you're having trouble finding the site, or if you prefer, you can send me a message on any platform, and B'ezrat Hashem, I will send you the direct link. Usually, you can also find the website link clearly posted on my profile. Thank you all for your support of Torah learning and for joining us. May Hashem bless you with much bracha and hatzlacha. Chazak, chazak, v'nitchazek! You can also find me on Tik Tok, or wherever else you could send me a message, and I'll send you the direct link. And as I said, you could just look at my profile; usually, my websites are always there. Now, for a profound question that's come in: 'Who killed Yonah's tree?' Hashem did. This brings us to a very significant point about bechirah chofshit (free choice) and divine will, as someone has asked: '
1:25:41In our journey through Torah, we often grapple with the profound concept of bechirah chofshis, free will. A critical question that arises is, can a person go against the will of Hashem? Yes, we have free choice! We see it clearly in this week's parashah. Hashem says that they were part of Am Yisrael; they were complaining and going against His will, so He killed them. This demonstrates that even with divine intervention and destiny, our choices carry immense weight and consequences. Indeed, we are not mere automatons, but beings endowed with true agency. We have free choice; we are not robots. As the Gemara states, "everything is from Heaven except for yiras Shamayim," meaning the fear of Heaven. This signifies that the outcome of many aspects of our lives – whether you are born or you die, rich or poor, married or single, have children or don't have children – all of these different things Hashem decides. But whether you will follow Hashem and His holy Torah – that, my friends, is entirely in your hands, completely your choice. My dear talmidim, we delve into a fundamental concept in our Avodas Hashem: the idea of bechirah chofshis, free will. It's the cornerstone of our accountability and the basis for reward and punishment in the eyes of HaKadosh Baruch Hu. The Rambam explains this beautifully. He doesn't just tell us what to do; He gives us the capacity to choose. And listen: What He says, that is in your hands. You decide whether you do that or not. Because if He were to decide for you what to do, then it wouldn't be right for Him to either reward you or punish you. Because if He decided for you that you're going to do only right, why should He reward you? You're a robot. It's like rewarding the dishwasher for washing dishes. That's what it was created to do. That's all it does. It has no will of its own, no ability to deviate from its pre-programmed function. Its actions are purely mechanical, and therefore, there's no inherent praise or blame attached to its performance. It simply fulfills its purpose. This is precisely why our own human actions hold such immense weight. Unlike a machine...
1:27:05So you see, talmidim, without genuine choice, there is no basis for schar va'onesh, for reward and punishment. We don't credit a machine for simply fulfilling its design, do we? After all, if your dishwasher started, you know, building cars, then maybe you should give it a reward, but I wouldn't wait too long for that, because it's not going to happen. It's the same concept here: if Hashem My dear friends, we are discussing the profound concept of bechirah chofshit, free will, a cornerstone of Jewish thought. The question arises: why doesn't Hashem simply force us to do good? Why doesn't He make us all tzaddikim? The answer is fundamental to the entire system of reward and punishment. If Hashem would decide for you to do the righteous things, then there would be no reason to reward you because you didn't decide this, you didn't choose that. On the other hand, if you did bad things and it was really Hashem forcing you to do bad things, then it wouldn't be right for Him to punish you. This is precisely why Hashem, in His infinite wisdom and justice, granted us the immense gift of free will. It is our ability to choose between good and evil, between following His mitzvot or straying from them, that gives meaning to our actions and makes us deserving of reward or punishment. And indeed, throughout the Torah, we see countless examples of individuals exercising this free will, for better or for worse. As we've established, the very foundation of reward and punishment hinges on our genuine freedom to choose. If our actions were merely compelled by divine decree, there would be no basis for either. Because it wasn't up to you; He decided for you. But we see clearly in the Torah, in practically every single parashah, that there were some people who went against Hashem's will, and therefore Hashem punished them. As soon as we open up the Torah, the Book of Genesis, Sefer Bereishit, we see that Adam HaRishon and Chavah went against the will of Hashem and were punished. We see in the second parashah, Parashat Noach, where we find that the world went against the will of Hashem, and He destroyed all of them. This pattern continues, for example, at the time of Avraham Avinu, with Sodom and Gomorrah. Those entire cities went against Hashem, and Hashem destroyed all of them, and so on and so forth. So if...
1:28:05My dear friends, we have been discussing the profound concept of bechirah chofshis, free will, and its critical role in our spiritual lives. This divine gift implies accountability, and with accountability comes schar v'onesh, reward and punishment. One might ask, what happens when humanity, or a significant portion of it, chooses a path diametrically opposed to the will of Hakadosh Baruch Hu? We have numerous examples throughout our sacred history. For instance, the world went against the will of Hashem, and He destroyed its wicked inhabitants. We see this clearly at the time of Avraham Avinu, with the infamous cities of Sodom and Gomorrah. Those entire cities went against Hashem, and Hashem destroyed all of them. And so on and so forth throughout history, demonstrating that there are profound consequences for our choices. So, if we were to say that Hashem does not involve Himself in the world, that there is no reward or punishment, we would fundamentally undermine the entire purpose of creation and the very basis of our faith. Indeed, if Hakadosh Baruch Hu's will were simply to the point where He would dictate your free choice for you, there would be no free choice at all. There would be no point to schar v'onesh, to reward or punishment. And one of the thirteen principles of Jewish faith is our belief in schar v'onesh. Hashem rewards the righteous and punishes the wicked. Any Jew who does not believe in schar v'onesh is considered a heretic. Such a denial undermines the entire framework of our spiritual lives and our accountability before Hashem.
1:29:00Good evening, everyone. We often discuss the weighty themes of the Yamim Noraim, and one question that frequently arises in this season of introspection is about divine decree and human free will. Many ask: 'Does Hashem write down exactly what we will do for the coming year on Rosh Hashanah or Yom Kippur?' No, Hashem does not write what a person will do on Yom Kippur. Rather, Hashem decides whether that person will live or die, will be profitable or at a loss, will be sick or healthy. It is not the actions themselves that are predetermined; rather, a person decides their own actions. And certainly, a person can do teshuvah and change that fortune. This understanding empowers us, demonstrating that our spiritual work and sincere teshuvah can truly alter the decree. Kol Tuv. Good evening, talmidim. Tonight, we'll address a common misconception related to the origins of the Koran, a topic that occasionally arises in discussions of early Islamic history and its relationship to our tradition. Let's consider the following assertion: The Jews wrote the Koran for the Arabs. True or false? False. The Koran was partially plagiarized by Muhammad, who learned many stories from a Jewish wise man. He learned a lot of stories from him because this Jewish man was friends with Muhammad's father; they even did business together. Moreover, after a significant argument with his own Jewish community, this talmid chacham decided to embark on a long journey. During this period, he resided with Muhammad's father for some time, and as a token of his appreciation, he would spend his time teaching various narratives and teachings.
1:30:01My dear talmidim, it is with a sense of wonder that we continue our shiur tonight, exploring the intricate threads of Divine Providence, or Hashgacha Pratit, throughout history. As we delve into the early narratives surrounding the nascent stages of Islam, we encounter a fascinating account from historical sources. We learn of a particular Jewish individual, a scholar of Torah, whose life intersected in a most unexpected manner with the family of Muhammad. This righteous man had been friends with Muhammad's father; they did business together. However, this Jewish man had a significant argument with his own Jewish community. Consequently, he decided to embark on an extensive journey. He eventually came and stayed with Muhammad's father, residing with him for a considerable period. As a demonstration of his gratitude and respect, he would dedicate his time to teaching young Muhammad. It was during this period, my dear friends, that this Jewish sage imparted a wealth of knowledge to the future founder of Islam, specifically sharing with him numerous stories and profound narratives derived directly from our holy Torah. This unique interaction, taking place at a time when Muhammad’s family were avodah zarah worshipers and had no prior exposure to monotheistic teachings, profoundly influenced the young man, laying an extraordinary foundation that would shape subsequent historical developments in ways only HaKadosh Baruch Hu could orchestrate. ...Muhammad learned these Jewish stories, because before this, his family were idolaters; there were no Muslims before that time. So, this Jewish man—I believe he was a Yemenite—taught him many stories from the Torah. Muhammad was a clever young man,
1:30:54Our Sages teach us about a particular individual who, despite being exposed to the sacred traditions and stories of Am Yisrael, succumbed to the temptations of ego and innovation. He heard the ancient narratives, the aggadot and the ma'asiyot, which were transmitted through generations, and he liked these stories, and he eventually claimed them as his own, and he added various elements of shtus to them. He mixed falsehoods with the truth in order to present them as his original inventions. Subsequently, he endeavored to recruit others to follow his path, and when he approached the Chachmei Yisrael of his generation, seeking their endorsement for his novel doctrines. With arrogance, he began to expound upon what he believed were his original insights and teachings. ...As the Gemara in Avodah Zarah discusses the nature of false prophets, we see how dangerous it can be when someone claims to bring a new religion that contradicts our sacred Torah. The historical account, my dear talmidim, of Muhammad's encounter with the Jewish communities in Medina is a stark and tragic example of this. When he presented his so-called 'revelations,' attempting to validate his claims through the existing monotheistic faith, he sought the recognition of the Jewish scholars there. They, of course, understood that his claims were a distortion and an invention, not a divine message. and he started telling them all that he knew. They told him, "Listen, everything that you know comes from us! It comes from the Torah. You are not inventing anything new here. And the ideas that originated from you are pure nonsense. What is true is from our Torah and our Chazal. What is false is your own invention, what you are adding to it." Consequently, he did not exactly appreciate the fact that they were not accommodating his new religion. So, he had them all killed; he murdered them all in cold blood. This horrific act of genocide against the Jewish communities of Medina, particularly the Banu Qurayza, tragically sealed their fate and underscores the profound chasm that emerged. It clearly demonstrated his utter intolerance for anything that challenged his newly fabricated theology, especially the unwavering truth of our sacred Torah and the traditions passed down through generations. This historical event is crucial for us to understand, as it illustrates why, even in the Quran itself, it says that if the Muslims do not know what the truth is, they should go to the people of the book—meaning the Jewish people—for they possess the true, original revelation that Muhammad attempted to distort and plagiarize.
1:31:49My dear talmidim, as we delve deeper into understanding the surrounding cultures and their interaction with our holy Mesora, it is crucial to analyze the historical perspective. Many inquire about the origins and content of the Koran and its relationship to our sacred texts. And indeed, from our perspective, the reality is clear: the point is that the Koran is comprised of various sections of the Torah, which Muhammad plagiarized, alongside his own original additions. And that is also why in the Koran it states that if the Muslims are unsure of the truth, they should consult the People of the Book. And these "People of the Book" are none other than the Jewish people themselves. So while they may have, at times, harbored animosity towards us – even Muhammad himself, despite his own personal enmity, knew and understood that we possessed the ultimate truth. This recognition, even from an opposing viewpoint, underscores the profound significance of our holy Torah and our unbroken chain of Mesora. Therefore, for us, Talmud Torah must always take precedence, and a Rabbi teaches us that learning may take precedence until the last chance for Avodah, meaning until one has completed all other necessary Mitzvot and only Avodah remains as a final act of devotion to Hakadosh Baruch Hu. hate us. While Muhammad hated us, he still knew that we possessed the truth. Limud Torah may take precedence until the last possible time for avodah, meaning prayer.
1:32:50So, yes, it's true: once it comes time to pray mincha, you are certainly obligated to pray. The primary exception to skip prayer that I'm familiar with, aside from the obvious pikuach nefesh — saving a life — is if someone is involved in zikui harabim, meaning, if someone is actively engaged in kiruv. When an individual is dedicated to kiruv, bringing fellow Jews closer to Hashem and Torah, they are indeed granted certain special halachic dispensations given the profound significance of their mission. My dear friends, while these dispensations for kiruv are significant, we must always remember that they do not entirely absolve one from their personal obligations. This is not to mean that they shouldn't pray. Rather, it means that there are certain exceptions, such as those for pikuach nefesh, the saving of a life, that are considered on the same level as the profound mission of kiruv. And this brings us, my dear brothers, to a broader, essential point about the unique truth and unparalleled antiquity of our sacred Torah. Is that why the Quran arrived several centuries later? No, my dear friends, it wasn't just several centuries later. It was, in fact, approximately 2,000 years later. We, Klal Yisrael, received the Torah at Har Sinai over 3,338 years ago. This ancient and unbroken chain of tradition, brothers, is what makes our Torah eternal and incomparable amongst all spiritual paths. ...reverberating through history. The Quran, for example, came into existence about 1,400 years ago, but we are talking about a 2,000 year difference from Yeshu's time. Where is Yeshu now? He is in Gehinnom, because he led people, or misled people, to go against the Torah, to abandon the Torah. And this is precisely why his spiritual state remains one of ongoing judgment and correction for his grave misdeeds.
1:34:15Indeed, his transgressions were so severe that his spiritual state remains one of ongoing judgment and correction for his grave misdeeds. Let's understand why his punishment is ongoing and so severe. He hated the Chachamim, the Jewish sages of his time. He would often refer to them derisively as 'Pharisees'. Furthermore, he brazenly proclaimed, as is even recorded in their New Testament, that he was 'greater than Shabbat', along with many other foolish and misguided ideas attributed to him. He deliberately misled Yidden, Jewish people, to abandon the Torah. Therefore, HaKadosh Baruch Hu punished him, and he continues to be punished to this very day, because the devastation caused by his actions is still causing people damage to this very day, as he turned himself into an idol. Now, regarding Hilchot Shabbat, can a person heat up food on Shabbat day by using a hot plate? "Today, Chaverim, we gather to delve into a very practical and important halacha that touches every Jewish home on Shabbat Kodesh. The question often arises: is one permitted to heat up food on Shabbat using a hot plate? This is a fundamental inquiry into the melachot of cooking and reheating, and how we ensure a warm seudat Shabbat within the bounds of halacha. The Shulchan Aruch and later poskim address this directly. So, let us examine: can a person heat up food on Shabbat by using a hot plate? As we learn from our Sages, the halacha is clear that as long as the food is already fully cooked and the hot plate is set up before Shabbat, this is indeed permissible and how we observe the mitzvah of enjoying hot food on Shabbat."
1:35:05My dear talmidim, we continue our discussion concerning the beautiful mitzvah of oneg Shabbat, specifically focusing today on the preparation of food. As we know, there are many halakhos that guide us in ensuring our Shabbat meals are both enjoyable and entirely permissible. One common question that arises, especially for those new to observance or even for seasoned individuals, relates to the use of a hot plate or blech on Shabbat. To clarify some common practices regarding this, let us consider the following scenario regarding Shabbat food preparation: the hot plate is programmed before Shabbat, either to remain on continuously or to come on and off for the lunch meal, according to one's custom and halakhic understanding. If the food is already fully cooked – meaning, for example, if it is already ready-made chicken or kugel and all you are doing is heating it up – then, of course, every frum Jewish home does that on Shabbat. That is how we partake of hot food on Shabbat. You already cook all the food before Shabbat, and you turn on the hot plate before Shabbat, and you leave it on for the entire Shabbat, thereby allowing the food to remain warm and ready to be served when you desire, without violating any prohibitions of cooking or reheating. It is crucial to remember that the food must be fully cooked and entirely ready to eat before the commencement of Shabbat, as heating raw or partially cooked food on Shabbat is strictly forbidden. We must always ensure our practices align with the halakha and the spirit of Shabbat.
1:35:36Good evening, my dear brothers and sisters. In our ongoing study of Hilchot Shabbat – the laws of Shabbat – we arrive at a practical and very important discussion concerning the use of a plat, or hot plate, to keep food warm. It is essential to remember that on Shabbat, any act of bishul, or cooking, is strictly forbidden. The purpose of a plat is solely for shehiya, to maintain the warmth of food that was fully cooked and prepared before Shabbat. Regarding the use of a timer to regulate when your plat goes on and off, that is a matter of personal preference and often depends on various halachic opinions concerning timers on Shabbat. However, l'ma'aseh (in practice), many people simply leave their hot plate on for the entire duration of Shabbat. Now, concerning the food itself, it does not spoil on the plat because it is being continuously kept warm. If you have food that you do not intend to consume immediately from the plat, it should be stored in the refrigerator. However, and pay close attention to this, Chaverim (friends), you may not take cold food from the refrigerator on Shabbat and place it on the plat with the intention of heating it up. Such an action would constitute bishul, cooking, which is forbidden on Shabbat. The plat is designated for food that has been on it from erev Shabbat (the eve of Shabbat), a concept known as shehiya, or for food being returned to it under specific halachic conditions, which is called hachazara. The goal is to maintain the food's warmth, not to cook it. Therefore, when food is on the plat, it is not for "however much time it needs to get hot" in the sense of bringing it from cold to hot, which would be bishul. Rather, it is there to remain warm. Typically, the food will be served hot because it has been kept warm since erev Shabbat. But again, let me emphasize this critical point: the food must be entirely cooked and ready before Shabbat. This fundamental distinction, between merely maintaining warmth and actually cooking, is the cornerstone of all Shabbat halachot related to food. It underscores the principle that all you are permitted to do on Shabbat with a plat is to keep already-cooked food warm, not to cook it. These principles hold true across different communities, though there can be specific minhagim and rulings that vary, for example, concerning the practices of Sephardic Jews.
1:36:06Good morning, talmidim. We continue our shiur on the halakhot of Shabbat, delving deeper into the intricate laws of bishul, the forbidden melachah of cooking. A core principle is that for it to be permissible to keep warm or reheat food on Shabbat itself, it is imperative that the food be fully prepared before Shabbat; therefore, all one is doing is merely heating the food and not cooking it. Now, this brings us to an important distinction, particularly concerning the custom of Sephardim. Among Sephardic communities, there is a stricter approach regarding items that might still undergo a 'cooking' process even if they were previously cooked. This is especially relevant for liquid-based dishes, as there are different opinions concerning whether liquids can be mitztamek ve'ra lo, meaning they are worsened by further cooking, or if they can still improve, thus constituting a new act of bishul. We are discussing the halakhot of bishul on Shabbat, specifically the complex issue of bishul acharei bishul – cooking something that has already been cooked. While solid foods, according to most poskim, do not become "cooked again" once they are fully cooked, liquids present a different challenge. That means that you cannot reheat soup on Shabbat, because that's mostly water, and there's an opinion that water can cook again, even though it's already cooked. So therefore, if a Sephardi Jew wants to eat hot soup on Shabbat, they have a few choices. One choice is to already put the soup on the hot plate before Shabbat. This ensures the soup remains hot throughout Shabbat without violating the melakha of bishul. However, this leads us to another set of halakhot concerning how one serves and handles the pot once Shabbat begins.
1:36:47My dear students, we have been discussing the halakhot of shehiyah for Shabbat food, particularly how to keep warm dishes, such as soup, permissible to eat. Now, let us consider the din of chazarah, returning food to a heat source on Shabbat itself. For many of our Sephardi brethren, a warm soup on Friday night is a beloved oneg Shabbat. When they serve it on Shabbat, there are generally two scenarios regarding the pot of soup on the hot plate. Either they do not remove the pot from the hot plate at all; they simply serve from it and leave it on the plata if they intend to have more later on, or for the next day. Alternatively, if they do take it off and place it down elsewhere, then they may not put it back onto the hot plate. This is a significant din to remember, as any act of returning food to a heat source when it has cooled or been removed creates a serious concern of bishul on Shabbat, which is a melakha de'oraita. There are, of course, exceptions and particular scenarios, such as when one employs a sha'on Shabbat (Shabbat timer) to ensure the plata is off when the pot is returned, and then it switches back on. However, for most Sephardim who enjoy their soup primarily on leil Shabbat, the initial concern of leaving it on or not returning it is most pertinent. My dear brothers, let us continue our discussion on the intricate halakhot of Shabbat, specifically concerning shehiyah and chazarah. As we've learned, great care must be taken to ensure no transgression occurs when keeping food warm. Returning a pot to a heat source on Shabbat, known as chazarah, is generally prohibited unless specific conditions are met. So, one might ask, how can one ensure food remains warm for the Shabbat day meal? ...unless they have a timer which allows them to place the soup onto the blech when it is not active; that is, during the interval after the timer has turned it off and before it powers back on. The ikkar is that one can indeed strategize to fulfill this halakhah. However, many Sephardic communities, observing their particular minhagim, often consume their Shabbat soup primarily on Friday night. This preference stems from various factors, including the differing psakim and stringencies adopted regarding the halakhah of chazarah.
1:37:36So, my dear friends, we've been delving into the beautiful mitzvah of oneg Shabbat, the delight of Shabbat, and how enjoying warm, nourishing food is such an integral part of that experience. This naturally leads us to the practical halakhot surrounding keeping food warm and reheating on Shabbat itself. We discussed earlier some of the Sefardi customs and the conditions they apply. Now, while there are some who eat it even later on Shabbat, you must always know the precise halakha and how to perform it correctly. Ashkenazi Jews, on the other hand, poskin that one could take food off a hot plate – let me clarify the nuance here – they permit taking it off a hot plate and then later on Shabbat, putting it back on the hot plate, without all the specific conditions that I mentioned previously. So there's a slight difference in how these halakhot are applied. Understanding these distinctions helps us appreciate the depth and beauty of Torah Sheba'al Peh and the careful consideration given to every detail of Shabbat observance. Now, this brings us to another related point... You know, my dear students, while there may be some differences in customs, and even specific halakhot depending on whether one follows the traditions of the Ashkenazim or the Sefaradim, the underlying principles often remain consistent. For instance, regarding the halakha between the Ashkenazim and Sefaradim when it comes to soup, but the fundamental point is that eating hot food is part of the pleasure of Shabbat. This is actually the reason why chamin, or what is also called cholent, became such a central part of our Jewish cuisine throughout the centuries, precisely because we were not able to cook on Shabbat and we desired to eat hot food not just on Friday night, but also on Saturday afternoon and Saturday morning.
1:38:22We've been discussing the profound spiritual significance of Shabbat, and how it impacts every aspect of our lives, even our meals. As you know, the Torah forbids cooking on Shabbat. Yet, we are commanded to make Shabbat a day of oneg, of delight, and for many, that includes warm food. The ingenious solution our sages and communities developed over generations to ensure we could enjoy a warm meal on our holy day, known as hamin, my dear children, refers to the same dish; it just depends whether you're Sephardi or Ashkenazi what you call it, but it's essentially the same food. This is actually the reason why hamin has been a staple Jewish food throughout the centuries. Because since we weren't able to cook on Shabbat and we wanted to eat hot food not just on Friday night, but also on Saturday afternoon, Saturday morning, and even for seudah shlishit. To achieve this oneg Shabbat despite the prohibition on cooking, our ancestors developed a culinary masterpiece. What kind of food could possibly accomplish this great feat, my friends? …and how we fulfill the mitzvah of oneg Shabbat, particularly concerning hot food. This brings us to a crucial point about preparing food on Erev Shabbat for the next day. Sometimes, we want to ensure we have warm food readily available for Shabbat lunch or Seudah Shlishit. For that, then you need something that can stay on the fire without getting ruined. Usually, if you leave food on the fire, keeping it heated for a long period of time, it gets ruined. So, for example, if you take a chicken cutlet and you put it on a hot plate, if you leave it on for overnight, by the time you want to eat it the next day, it will become not even chicken or a cutlet; it will become like rubber, quite gross. This presents a real challenge for Shabbat food. Most foods, as we understand, suffer from prolonged cooking; they dry out and become unpleasant. However, there are specific types of food that are different—foods that the longer they cook, the better they become. And that, my dear friends, brings us to the beloved chulent."
1:39:20Now, generally speaking, when we consider how to prepare food, the standard understanding is that there's an optimal cooking time, because for the majority of foods, the more they cook beyond an optimal point, the worse they actually get. When food is raw, it certainly improves through the cooking process until it reaches its peak readiness. However, once it's ready, further cooking generally ruins it; it might dry it out, or break down its texture too much. This is true for most dishes we prepare. Yet, there are some unique foods where the opposite holds true: the more you cook them, the better they become. Cholent is precisely one of these. This is exactly why we can prepare our cholent or chamin and let it simmer for extended periods, even placing it on the plata or in the oven on Friday afternoon, hours before Shabbat begins, and not touch it until Seudah Shlishit late Shabbat afternoon. It will taste absolutely amazing, because the nature of these foods is that their flavors deepen and meld beautifully with prolonged cooking. We've been discussing the halachot (laws) surrounding the preparation of food for Shabbat, particularly concerning keeping food warm. One of the beautiful things about cholent is how it perfectly aligns with these halachot, even benefiting from the extended cooking time. ...so even if you start putting your cholent or chamin on Friday afternoon or Friday morning, before Shabbat even begins, and you don't even want to eat it until, let's say, Seudah Shlishit, which is late Shabbat afternoon. Therefore, it's cooking for twenty-four hours. It will taste amazing. Why? Because it's a type of food that actually improves with time. This characteristic makes cholent a perfect Shabbat food, fitting perfectly with the halachic requirements of slow cooking and keeping food warm for the duration of the holy day. Indeed, this is precisely why cholent has become such a standard dish in Jewish homes.
1:40:13We're discussing the practical applications of halakha in our daily lives, particularly concerning Shabbat observance. Many of our traditional foods, dear brothers, have deep roots in these very halakhot. For instance, when we prepare for Shabbat, we know there are certain limitations on cooking and reheating. This brings us to the beloved dish of cholent. There are some types of soup that also actually improve over time. But the point is, the reason why cholent is such a standard food in Jewish homes is precisely because of this halakha of heating food on Shabbat. It allows for a warm, hearty meal without violating the prohibitions of cooking. And the reason, as a side note, why gefilte fish is a popular food for Ashkenazi Jews is, it's not because it's necessarily delicious for everyone, but rather it's directly connected to the halakha of borer, of separating. Our poskim have ruled that when one eats fish with bones on Shabbat, if one removes the bones from the fish, it violates the melakha of borer, of separating. To avoid this chillul Shabbat, our ancestors developed the custom of taking the fish, grinding it all together, and making it into a patty or a loaf. This way, the bones are ground into the fish, and one can enjoy the meal on Shabbat without any concern of violating borer. We often wonder why gefilte fish became such a staple in Ashkenazi households, especially for Shabbos. Many think it's simply a matter of taste, but the truth is rooted deeply in halakhah. It's not because it's delicious for them. It's because of the halakhah of borer. They pasken that when you eat fish and you have bones in it, if you remove the bones from the fish, it violates Shabbat. It violates the law of borer, of separating. So because of that, they take the fish, they grind it all, make it into like a patty. By doing so, they ensure that the melakhah of borer is avoided entirely.
1:41:07By grinding the fish completely, as is characteristic of gefilte fish, they completely eliminate the issue of separating bones from food on Shabbos. And so, there are no bones to remove. And that's why this has been a part of the customs of Ashkenazi Jews for hundreds and hundreds of years. Sephardi Jews, on the other hand, do not usually eat gefilte fish. Some do, some do not. I actually have a friend who is a Sephardi Jew, but he is married to an Ashkenazi woman, and he combined... He actually created a fascinating culinary fusion, bringing together two distinct traditions. Oftentimes, when Bnei Yisrael from different communities marry, they find beautiful ways to combine their unique minhagim. I remember an instance where a husband from Tripoli, whose family had rich Sephardic traditions, married a wife from Poland, who brought with her the customs of Ashkenaz. And what a magnificent blend they created, especially in their kitchen! They prepared the famous gefilte fish with the famous Sephardi dish that's called chreime, which is a hot, spicy red sauce with fish. Usually, you make the chreime with salmon or some type of fish, but he actually combined fish from both traditions, creating a truly memorable and unique dish. Such beautiful syntheses of customs are not uncommon within our diverse klal Yisrael. My dear talmidim, we often discuss the beauty and importance of maintaining our family minhagim, our customs, which have been passed down through generations. But sometimes, especially when two traditions meet, we find fascinating blends. I recall one instance when a family combined his customs from Tripoli with his wife's customs from, I think she was from Poland. And they made this dish. And, actually, that was the only time in my life that I ever ate gefilte fish. I didn't know it was gefilte fish at the time; I probably wouldn't have eaten it if I had known. But I actually liked it! I was quite surprised that it was gefilte fish. So you see, there are some people who do such things, combining different minhagim in creative ways. But usually, when it comes to matters of halakha, we are careful to adhere to the established traditions of our ancestors. However, in areas of taste and culinary preference, sometimes these fusions can be quite delightful and even broaden our palates, baruch Hashem.
1:42:33My dear friends, we often speak about the beautiful tapestry of Klal Yisrael, and how Hashem, Baruch Hu, has blessed us with diverse communities, each with its unique customs and traditions, even down to our culinary expressions. A common observation, perhaps an oversimplification, is that Sephardic food tends to be "red," while Ashkenazic food is "not red." This isn't a strict rule, of course, but it points to a very real difference in culinary heritage. Sephardic cuisine, originating from the Jews of Spain, Portugal, North Africa, and the Middle East, naturally adopted the vibrant spices, tomatoes, and peppers prevalent in those regions. Think of the rich stews, the sauces, the use of paprika and saffron – these indeed often impart a beautiful, reddish hue to the dishes. On the other hand, Ashkenazic cuisine, developed in the colder climates of Eastern and Central Europe, relied on different staple ingredients. Potatoes, carrots, onions, root vegetables, poultry, and fish prepared with simpler seasonings were more common. So, while delicious and hearty, their dishes typically present a different palette of colors, less dominated by those intense reds. It's a wonderful illustration of how Am Yisrael, while spread across the globe, remained faithful to Torah and Mitzvot, while absorbing the local flavors and textures into their everyday lives. Yet, through all these variations, one constant remained: the unwavering adherence to the laws of kashrut, which united all these diverse culinary traditions under one sacred banner. It shows us that diversity within unity is not only possible but beautiful, as long as the foundation of Torah and Mitzvot remains paramount.
1:43:08And it is precisely this unwavering adherence to the fundamental laws of Torah and Mitzvot that brings us to a profound and critically important area of halakha, particularly regarding the sanctity of Shabbat. Often, in our modern world, we face temptations and challenges to these sacred observances, prompting questions like: Is it bad that I use my phone on Shabbat because I'm just sort of addicted? My friends, if you are Jewish, then absolutely it is not just 'bad'; it is a severe violation of Shabbat. It is, in fact, a desecration of Shabbat. You will end up going to Gehinnom for it. Understand, my friends, that this is not merely an abstract concept or a light matter. The gravity of such an action is immense, and its spiritual repercussions are far-reaching. My dear talmidim, we live in a generation fraught with challenges, and none perhaps more insidious than the siren call of modern technology. We speak often of Shabbat Kodesh, the holy Shabbat, a day given to us by HaKadosh Baruch Hu as a sign between Him and us, a day of rest and spiritual elevation. Yet, how many of us, or our children, succumb to the temptation of these devices, these 'phones,' even on the holy day? It is a nisayon, a test, of the highest order. When I observe the constant distraction, the inability to put down that device, even for a moment, even when one should be connecting with family, with one's own neshamah... This is deeply concerning. You might think, 'What's the big deal? It's just a quick glance.' But Chazal teach us the gravity of even a small chillul Shabbat. You'll realize that it is the most foolish act you could ever commit. I implore each and every one of you to deeply immerse yourselves in the halakhot of Shabbat. Consult your Rav, study the Shulchan Aruch, the Mishnah Berurah, and other sefarim dedicated to the sacred laws of Shabbat. Understand the profound consequences of what it truly means to commit Chillul Shabbat. The spiritual ramifications, my friends, are severe; it is not going to look pretty, all for the sake of a mere, silly phone. Is it truly worth sacrificing the Kedushat Shabbat, the sanctity of this holy day, for such a fleeting and ultimately empty distraction? Think about the eternal damage you inflict upon your neshamah, upon your connection with HaKadosh Baruch Hu. Chas v'shalom, God forbid, that we should treat Shabbat Kodesh so lightly. Let us strive, each and every one of us, to elevate Shabbat, to make it truly a day of rest and spiritual growth, a day free from the clamor of the mundane, and certainly free from these devices that pull us away from our true purpose. May we all be zocheh, merit, to properly observe Shabbat and bring bracha and light into our homes and into the world.
1:44:00We are discussing here the profound mysteries of Gehinnom, matters of Olam Haba that demand our utmost concentration and yiras Shamayim. And yet, some of us, chas v'shalom, are distracted by trinkets. What exactly is so urgent? Get a book. Go sleep. Go play a board game with your siblings or something. Why do you have to look at your phone? What's going to happen if you don't look at your phone? Is it going to explode? Let's see. This is the yetzer hara trying to pull us away from limud Torah, from connecting to Hashem! We must fight it with all our might. We need to be fully present, with a geshmak for Torah. Now, let us return to the nature of the various chambers of Gehinnom and the souls that traverse them. A very pertinent question, my dear talmidim, one that touches upon fundamental aspects of hashgacha pratit and tzelem Elokim. Indeed, a talmid has just asked: "Do some people get out of Gehinnom after several years while some remain there forever? I'm confused." Yes, my dear student, you raise an excellent point that requires clarification. Indeed, there are seven chambers in Gehinnom. I actually have a whole shiur that goes into detail about each chamber, exploring the specific types of aveirot that lead one to each level. I also have a detailed video presentation about Gehinnom that delves into these different facets as well, which I encourage you all to review. As we learned in last week's shiur, the first six chambers are indeed temporary, designed for spiritual purification, and one eventually emerges, having atoned for their misdeeds. However, as our Sages teach us, the seventh chamber of Gehinnom is reserved for those whose sins are so grave that their spiritual defilement is permanent, and from there, one does not depart. It all depends on the severity and type of transgression a person commits. Therefore, we must constantly strive for teshuva and fear Hashem, may His Name be blessed.
1:44:56So we learn that while many souls go through a period of purification in Gehinom, this process is not indefinite for everyone; the first six chambers end at some point. It could be a day, an hour, a year, a thousand years, however much time, but at some point it ends. Except for the seventh level of Gehinom, the seventh chamber of Gehinom. Whoever comes in there does not come out. So, it all depends on the type of sin that a person makes. This is why the gravity of certain transgressions, especially the desecration of Shabbat, is so profound and warrants such serious consideration from each of us. My dear students, we are constantly reminded of the profound significance of our actions in this world and their eternal repercussions. The Gemara, our holy texts, and the words of our Sages repeatedly emphasize that while mitzvot bring immense reward, aveiros, G-d forbid, carry serious consequences. There are indeed some sins that automatically place a person in the seventh level of Gehinnom, unless they perform complete teshuva before their passing from this world. And one of these most severe transgressions, as our Torah explicitly warns, is violating Shabbat. So, the person who is playing on their phone, watching television, driving their car, eating at some non-kosher restaurant, or working on Shabbat – yes, anyone who is actively desecrating Shabbat – such an individual faces a most serious spiritual reckoning, one that Klal Yisrael must always strive to avoid. We must be ever vigilant in upholding the sanctity of this holy day, for the Chachamim teach us the profound significance of every single moment on Shabbat.
1:45:50...they must also understand that prayer alone is not a substitute for adherence to mitzvot and teshuva. Indeed, rachmana litzlan, it is taught that those who completely abandon the path, those who, chas v'shalom, do not fulfill the fundamental mitzvot, are in a most precarious spiritual state. Therefore, it is understood that they are automatically going to Gehinnom forever, unless they observe Shabbat or do teshuva. This is a crucial foundation of our faith. Now, I see a hand, and someone is asking, "Is there a soup kitchen near me?" My dear friend, that is a practical question not directly related to our shiur on spiritual matters, and I do not have that information readily available. However, after the class, we can perhaps address such needs. Let us now return to our discussion of spiritual rectification. Good evening, dear talmidim and esteemed listeners. Tonight, we will address a frequently asked question pertaining to tefillah and our connection to tzaddikim. The question is often posed: Is it permissible to ask deceased tzaddikim to pray on your behalf? Yes, it is permissible. However, it is paramount that you pray for yourself as well. Furthermore, one should not solely rely on someone else's prayer. In fact, there is a well-known segulah that HaRav Mordechai Eliyahu, alav hashalom, taught concerning this very matter. He said that whenever someone has an issue for which they wish to pray, they could go to a tzaddik and pray, making a commitment that whichever tzaddik will pray for them and help them attain the mercy of Hashem, they will dedicate their next mitzvah, whether it is giving tzedakah or any other good deed they perform, on that tzaddik's behalf.
1:47:00So, my dear friends, understanding that the neshamos of our holy tzaddikim continue to desire spiritual elevation even after their physical departure, how can we facilitate this and, in turn, benefit ourselves? A powerful custom exists whereby one could go to a tzaddik's grave, for example, and pray, saying that if this tzaddik will pray for me and, in essence, help me obtain the mercy of Hashem, I will do the next mitzvah I perform, whether it's giving tzedakah or any other mitzvah, on his behalf. And this reciprocal act, dedicating a mitzvah to the zechut of a tzaddik, creates an incredible spiritual bond and brings immense nachat ruach both to the living and to the neshama of the departed, truly a profound merit for all involved. We must always remember, chaverim, that all our prayers and supplications are directed solely to HaKadosh Baruch Hu, the Holy One, blessed be He. Yet, there is a profound understanding in our tradition that allows us to connect with the spiritual merits of the righteous. As we discussed, one may express in their prayer a request for a tzaddik to intercede on their behalf to Hashem, for Hashem to answer their prayer. And regarding this sacred practice, the venerable Rabbi Mordechai Eliyahu, zichrono livracha, taught us a vital insight. The reason why Rabbi Mordechai Eliyahu, zichrono livracha, said this is good is that the ultimate desire that the tzaddikim have after they leave Olam Ha'zeh is another way to gain more zechuyot, another way to gain more mitzvot. Because they can no longer perform mitzvot in Olam Ha'ba; there are only mitzvot to be performed in Olam Ha'zeh. So when a person performs a mitzvah on behalf of a tzaddik, or on behalf of anyone who has already passed away, it is a tremendous zechut for them, and for the living. This perspective not only illuminates the spiritual rewards for the departed tzaddikim, but also underscores the immense spiritual power we possess through our actions in this world, even when they are performed in memory or merit of others. Indeed, every mitzvah we perform elevates not only ourselves but reverberates throughout all the worlds, bringing us closer to HaShem and to the ultimate redemption.
1:47:59When you undertake to dedicate the merit of a mitzvah for another, it is vital to articulate your intent appropriately in prayer. So, if you're going to do that, for example, you could say, obviously, always pray to Hashem. You never pray to a person, whether they're righteous or not; you pray to Hashem. And also, you could say during that prayer, that a righteous person, a tzaddik, pleads on your behalf before Hashem to answer your prayer. This powerful and focused prayer, coupled with the mitzvah itself, creates a profound spiritual connection. Indeed, a profound concept in our tradition is dedicating our spiritual endeavors. When we perform a mitzvah with the intention that its spiritual merit, its zechut, should ascend for the aliyat neshamah (elevation of the soul) of a departed tzaddik, it creates an incredible connection. So, in this way, the next mitzvah you perform, or any mitzvah you are planning — you obviously must know which specific mitzvah you intend to do — its merit will be credited directly to their spiritual account. And the greater the mitzvah you plan to undertake, the more spiritual benefit is generated, making their heavenly intercession for you that much stronger. We're discussing the profound power of prayer, tefillah, and how we can best ensure our supplications are heard in Shamayim. While the sincerity of our heart is paramount, it is also well known that our own zechuyot, our merits, and the merits of the tzaddikim can significantly enhance our pleas. This is why, when we visit kivrei tzaddikim, the resting places of the righteous, we pray there. We understand that by connecting to their tremendous zechut, we're enabling the more likely you are to get tzaddikim who have passed away to plead in your case. So, for example, if, let's say, you have a lot of money, but you say that, you know, if anyone prays for me, I'll go donate ten dollars or one hundred dollars, then most likely no one's going to help you. No one's going to pray on your behalf. But if you're going to plan to donate a lot of money, then that merit is something that's worth something. Or if you're going to do some other mitzvah, you're going to start keeping Shabbat, you're going to start learning Torah for several hours, or committing to deeper spiritual growth. All these actions accumulate significant zechuyot for you, bolstering your spiritual standing and making your tefillot much more potent in the Heavenly courts.
1:49:08...all of the sins are addressed, the path of teshuvah and spiritual growth is a continuous journey. It requires a sustained commitment, and this commitment can manifest in many ways. So, whether it is that you're going to learn for several hours, or whatever else you plan to offer of your time and dedication, the consistency is what truly matters. On a somewhat different note, someone asked, 'Do we have any kivrei tzaddikim in Florida?' I confess, I don't know the answer to that particular query. While the resting places of tzaddikim are indeed holy, our primary focus should always be on building our spiritual connection through Torah, tefillah, and mitzvos in our everyday lives, wherever we reside. The Shechinah is present wherever Yidden learn and grow in Avodas Hashem." Indeed, my dear student, that's an excellent question often pondered regarding converts. The query is: does teshuva take place before, during, or after conversion? And the answer is that teshuva should start taking place as soon as possible, and you continue even after conversion, because even though all of the sins that a person committed as a non-Jew are indeed erased once they convert, as it is part of the tremendous gift that Hashem bestows upon the convert, there are some specific transgressions that still require rectification. For example, if one stole as a non-Jew, then they still have a fundamental obligation to return the money even after conversion. This is because gezel, theft, impacts another person directly, and such a sin against another human being requires direct restitution to the wronged party. We learn this from the Gemara in Bava Kamma, which emphasizes that sins between a person and their fellow human beings are not forgiven until the wronged party is appeased.
1:50:02...that a person committed as a non-Jew are indeed erased once they convert, as it is part of the tremendous gift that Hashem bestows upon the convert, there are some specific transgressions that still require rectification. For example, if one stole as a non-Jew, then they still have a fundamental obligation to return the money even after conversion. This is because gezel, theft, impacts another person directly, and such a sin against another human being requires direct restitution to the wronged party. We learn this from the Gemara in Bava Kamma, which emphasizes that sins between a person and their fellow human beings are not forgiven until the wronged party is appeased. So, when we speak about teshuvah, especially teshuvah for sins between a person and his fellow, it's not enough just to regret the action or to ask HaShem for forgiveness. There's a fundamental principle that we must restore what was taken or fix the damage that was caused. This applies particularly in cases of monetary wrongdoing, and it's not just because you owe the money, but rather more significantly because if you don't pay the money, then it could create a Chillul HaShem; it could create other sins. People will say, 'Look, this guy is Jewish and he doesn't return the money that he stole.' This brings us back to the core concept of teshuvah shleimah, complete repentance. It's not merely an internal feeling, but an active process of rectifying wrongs, both in the eyes of HaShem and in the eyes of man. Only when the Chillul HaShem is rectified and the financial obligation is fulfilled, can one truly say they have done teshuvah on that particular sin, allowing for proper atonement.
1:50:35But teshuvah is something that a person needs to do every day, regardless of whether they're in the process of conversion or they already converted, or they were born Jewish, or they're a rabbi, or they're the rabbi's son or daughter or wife. Teshuvah is something that we have to do every day. It's one of the 613 laws. It's something that's required to do every day. It's not just something that takes one second. Do I speak French? No. My dear talmidim, it is truly remarkable what HaKadosh Baruch Hu allows us to accomplish in spreading Torah. We are living in a time of unprecedented technological advancement, which we can harness for kiddush Hashem. You see, despite the common perception that my teachings are primarily in English, baruch Hashem, but I have a French channel with thousands of subscribers who hear me speak French because we use artificial intelligence as part of our system where I have my shiurim dubbed into, I believe, fifteen or sixteen different languages. So you can hear me speaking French on my French channel, Arabic on my Arabic channel, Spanish on my Spanish channel, and also in Chinese, and many more lashonot. Indeed, the reach of Torah today is truly global, thanks to these wondrous tools. May we continue to use them l'shem Shamayim, always to bring more light and understanding to the world, amen. My dear talmidim, it is truly astounding to see the hand of HaKadosh Baruch Hu throughout the entire world. His divine providence, His Hashgacha Pratit, extends to every single individual, no matter their background or origin. We see this manifested in the incredible diversity of people who connect to Him, from all corners of the globe. Whether they are from Korea, Germany, Russia, or any of the many nations speaking diverse languages, the yearning for truth and connection to HaKadosh Baruch Hu is universal. This is a fundamental concept for us to grasp: that Hashem's presence and His ability to hear is not limited by geography or tongue. He is everywhere, and He understands every prayer, every heartfelt plea. We must remember this as we contemplate the universal nature of prayer and our relationship with our Creator, Ribbono shel Olam.
1:52:12We've been discussing the power of Tehillim, the Psalms, and how they express our yearning for HaKadosh Baruch Hu, the Holy One, Blessed Be He. This brings up a related question that I often hear, particularly regarding prayer from non-Jews: "Does Hashem listen to the prayers of a Noahide, or does a Noahide need to convert?" Hashem listens to anybody that prays to Him. Hashem knows everything. It's not that His listening implies automatic fulfillment; just because Hashem listens to everything doesn't mean He's going to answer 'yes' to everything. This applies to everyone, whether Jew or Gentile. This is a profound lesson for all of us, reminding us that Hashem's ears are always open to those who turn to Him with a sincere heart, regardless of their background. Friends, before we dive into our text today, I wanted to share something. Baruch Hashem, I'm so happy with the ArtScroll I got. It's a beautiful sefer containing Tehillim and Kohelet (Psalms and Ecclesiastes). Yes, yes, they have great stuff. Also, actually, for those of you that follow our Teshuvah Music channel, there's going to be a new song coming out that starts a new series. We currently have a series of the entire Tehillim. We've already completed about thirty percent of the Tehillim. We're already starting a new series called, 'Songs of Kohelet,' turning Kohelet into songs. It's a wonderful initiative, and I encourage you all to explore it.
1:53:24...but all of them are focused on bringing kedushah into the world, whether through psukim or divrei Torah. In that vein, we have a new series of songs of Kohelet, turning Kohelet into songs. So, there's a new one that's coming out, I believe, in the next 24 hours. That's going to be the first nine verses. It's absolutely beautiful, absolutely beautiful! A lot of cool stuff is coming out for the Shuvah Music channel that you guys should follow. This is a wonderful initiative to spread Torah through music. May you all be zocheh to listen and be inspired! My dear friends, in our pursuit of spiritual growth and teshuvah, it is crucial to immerse ourselves in an environment that elevates the soul. This includes the music we listen to. It must be music that inspires us, music that draws us closer to HaKadosh Baruch Hu. Indeed, we have hundreds of such songs already available on the channel. You can access the 'Teshuvah Music' channel, B'ezrat Hashem, or if you prefer, go to my main YouTube channel and simply look through the other channels we feature. You will find one specifically named 'Teshuvah Music'. There, you will discover a vast collection, hundreds of songs spanning various genres – whether Middle Eastern, rap, or pop – we have many styles. But all of them are imbued with sanctity, featuring clean language and elevated topics, truly what we call Teshuvah music, designed to inspire and uplift us in our service of Hashem. May we all merit to be drawn closer through such holy melodies.
1:54:24My dear friends, when we speak about drawing close to Hashem and living a life imbued with kedushah, we must consider all the influences we allow into our spiritual space. This includes the very sounds we listen to. Songs that talk about doing teshuvah, that talk about serving Hashem, with clean language, clean topics. Beautiful. Holy music. That's what we call it, teshuvah music. Such music helps us cultivate an atmosphere of Yiras Shamayim and love for Hashem, truly aiding us in our path to spiritual perfection. We've had some excellent questions come in this evening, Baruch Hashem. Let's address a few more before we conclude our shiur. One question that often comes up, especially in our outreach efforts, is about conversion. Someone asks, "I'm 30 years old. Can I become Jewish?" Sure, why not? You have to convert through an Orthodox Beis Din. Then there's another point raised here: "Are the Noahide Laws all a non-Jew needs to go to Heaven?" Yes, indeed. If you follow the Noahide Laws and make yourself a righteous Noahide, you certainly have a share in the World to Come. So, whether one chooses to embrace the full yoke of mitzvot as a Jew or uphold the Sheva Mitzvot Bnei Noach as a righteous gentile, the path to a meaningful life and a share in the World to Come is open, Baruch Hashem.
1:55:34Baruch Hashem, my dear students, and welcome to our shiur Torah. We discussed last week the profound responsibility we have to uphold the sanctity of our traditions and to exercise discernment in all aspects of our lives. Today, I want to address a few pertinent questions that arose recently, which touch upon these very themes. A question was posed to me by a student, articulating a situation that many in our generation grapple with. He began, and I quote: "Well, Rabbi, my mother's family insists that we are Jewish, but there is no evidence, yet my mother was Jewish." To this, the halakha is unequivocally clear: if your mother is Jewish, then you are Jewish. This is the fundamental principle of Yisrael al pi ha'Em, that Jewish status is passed through the mother. While formal documentation, or shtaros, can be important for practical halakhic matters, a strong and consistent family mesorah, a tradition affirming Jewish lineage, is taken very seriously by a Beis Din. In cases requiring formal clarification, a Beis Din will carefully investigate the sheketz, the facts, and guide the family according to Torah law. This individual then continued with another query, asking: "What about music by the Beatles that gives righteous messages?" My dear friends, when we speak of tzidkus, true righteousness, we are referring to something that emanates from Torah and mitzvos, from kedusha and yiras Shamayim. Frankly, from my perspective, I don't remember ever hearing righteous messages by the Beatles. Moreover, one cannot separate their music from the surrounding culture, including all the drugs they did and promoted. Such influences, far from promoting genuine tzidkus, often lead to confusion and spiritual decline. Our niggunim, our sacred melodies, and the music we choose to listen to should uplift our neshamah, our soul, and draw us closer to Hashem, not lead us astray with fleeting or questionable trends. We must constantly strive for that which truly elevates us in our avodas Hashem. May Hashem grant us the wisdom and discernment to always choose that which strengthens our connection to His Torah and mitzvos. Chazak u'baruch.
1:56:02My dear friends, as we delve into the nature of kedushah, holiness, in our lives, it's crucial to understand where genuine spiritual elevation comes from. Many people today conflate personal preference or aesthetic pleasure with true spiritual value. For instance, when we discuss music – specifically, what truly uplifts the soul and brings us closer to HaKadosh Baruch Hu – we must make a clear distinction. Some might argue about the music of the nations, and I've heard it said that even certain popular songs can be 'righteous.' But let me be clear: There is no righteous music by the Beatles. It is a delusion, perhaps, to think so. There is no intrinsic righteousness in it. You may certainly enjoy it, but that enjoyment does not impart spiritual righteousness to you. The kedushah of music, a niggun, comes from its source, its intent, and its ability to connect us to the Divine, not from our individual taste. One must be discerning, as the Gedolim have always taught us, separating the sacred from the mundane, the kodesh from the chol. This principle of discernment, separating the sacred from the mundane, the kodesh from the chol, applies to every aspect of our spiritual lives. And it brings up interesting questions that people often grapple with, questions like: 'How exactly do we achieve true spiritual elevation?' Perhaps you've even wondered, do you get rid of hate by getting rid of ego? And often, people also observe, 'I find it strange that in the Torah they never talk about who did the pyramids or more precise details about them.' This is a very good point, a common observation that many make when they delve into Chumash. Well, if you look at some of the Midrashim, it does talk about that, giving us some of those details. But again, my dear friends, the Torah is not a book of stories. This is a crucial distinction, because it defines how we approach the entire body of our sacred texts.
1:57:03Good evening, everyone. It's truly a great zechus to be here learning together. We often think of the Torah as a collection of ancient tales, but we must remember that the core essence of the torah is a book of instructions that happens to have stories in it. So if Hashem would put every story that happened during the life of Avraham Avinu, for example, then the Torah would be a million and a half pages just to discuss the first few years of his life. So the Torah specifically puts things that are applicable and relevant to every single generation, whether it be story or law. This profound selectivity teaches us that every word, every narrative, and every commandment within its sacred pages holds eternal significance and direct guidance for our lives today. May we all be zoiche to internalize these holy words and live by them. May we all be zoiche to internalize these holy words and live by them. On a related note, we often get asked about opportunities for involvement with our organization. Do we accept volunteers to help with anything? Absolutely. We have a whole volunteer team. We have dozens and dozens of volunteers, Baruch Hashem. And each one of them helps with different things. Some help us with their technology talents. Some help with marketing. Some have time to distribute our books in their communities. We have many different volunteers. If you want to volunteer for our organization, you can send us a message. We encourage anyone interested to reach out.
1:58:10My dear talmidim, as we conclude our discussion on the profound importance of achdus and chessed in our daily lives, and how these actions elevate our avodas Hashem and bring glory to the Ribbono shel Olam, I want to bring to your attention a practical way we can all contribute to building a stronger kehillah and spreading Torah. For those of you interested in taking a more active role in our beis medrash or in the various chessed projects we support, please either email or WhatsApp, and let us know what you want to help with. We would be happy to see if we could add you to the team. We love our volunteers; volunteers are a big part of the heart of the organization. I actually think that every employee we have started as a volunteer at some point. It is a beautiful thing to see how dedicating oneself to Klal Yisrael can lead to so much growth, both personal and communal. So, please, if your hearts are moved to join us in this holy work, do not hesitate. May Hashem bless all of our efforts, and may we continue to see bracha in all that we do. May Hashem bless all of our efforts, and may we continue to see bracha in all that we do. This spirit of achdus and practical chessed is truly beautiful to behold, and we see it in so many aspects of our daily lives. Sefardim eat soup served by Ashkenazim in the morning of Shabbat. Yes, I think it's the ultimate goal in this world: to become a righteous and just person. After all, Hashem owns and deserves all the glory, indeed. Our purpose in this world is to live in a manner that constantly brings honor to His exalted Name, upholding His Torah and mitzvos in every fiber of our being.
1:59:13My dear students, we are living in challenging times, times where the very fabric of society seems to be unraveling before our eyes. One of the most alarming trends we witness today, one that deeply concerns every observant Jew, is the dramatic decline in birth rates across the globe. We must address this profound question: what is the root cause of this demographic collapse, this phenomenon where fewer and fewer children are being born into the world? This, my friends, is no accident. It is, unequivocally, the outcome of a world that has increasingly embraced atheism and forsaken the path of Torah. When people become consumed by self-centered desires, when they are driven solely by materialism, and when their minds are narrowed because they deny the presence of Hashem in their lives, then they inevitably begin to behave like animals, acting purely on instinct and a philosophy of survival of the fittest, devoid of higher purpose. This stands in stark contrast to the eternal wisdom of our Torah, which teaches us that life's greatest blessings and its true purpose are found in building Klal Yisrael, in raising families steeped in kedushah and Torah, and in fulfilling the very first mitzvah of pru u'revu. In generations past, before the insidious creep of secularism, having children was indeed the ultimate pride and joy, a central pillar of every righteous home and community. It is only in recent centuries, as people have strayed from the path of emunah, that this sacred understanding has been tragically lost, replaced by a hollow pursuit of transient pleasures.
1:59:43Indeed, my friends, when you truly observe the world and contrast it with past generations, generations that were steeped in Yiddishkeit and Torah, you will find a profound shift. In those times, having children was not merely an option or a burden; it was the crown jewel, the ultimate nachas, the very pride and joy of every home, of every community, reflecting the divine purpose of creation. This held true not just for Klal Yisrael, but generally for societies that maintained a connection to a higher power. Only in recent centuries has this understanding tragically changed. That's because people have become much more materialistic; they have embraced an atheistic worldview; they have become utterly meaningless, utterly purposeless. They have lost sight of the Tzelem Elokim within themselves, choosing instead to live solely for transient gratifications, forgetting the eternal obligation of pru u'revu and the immense brachah that comes with building a family dedicated to Hashem. It is truly a zechus for us to hear such encouraging feedback, baruch Hashem! It brings us great joy when the niggunim on the channel resonate with you. I love the True Music channel! What's the name of your app? Uh, we have two apps, baruch Hashem. Let me share with you a little about them, so you know where to find all our shiurim and content.
2:00:46My dear friends, in our pursuit of spreading Torah and its wisdom, we also harness modern technology to make our teachings accessible to everyone. To that end, baruch Hashem, we have developed some digital resources to assist you in your spiritual growth. We have two apps. One of them is called the Be'ezrat Hashem App, or you can find it under the name BH Torah App. You can find it on the Apple App Store for iOS devices or on the Google Play Store for Android. Alternatively, should you be unable to locate it there, you may visit our website to download the app directly. Through this app, you can access our lectures in various languages, including, of course, English, and also find a selection of inspiring Jewish music and a comprehensive collection of other Torah resources. And so, with siyata d'Shmaya, this app provides a wealth of Torah knowledge at your fingertips. That's our Be'ezrat Hashem App, truly a treasure trove for your spiritual growth, baruch Hashem. and then we have a second app, which is called AI Rabbi. You can access it at airabbi.org. This app is one where you can ask it any question regarding life, marriage, business, hadrachah (guidance), Torah stories, and questions on various parts of the Torah. And it will give you an answer that is in accordance with the Torah, that... This innovative tool ensures that all responses are rooted firmly in halachah and our sacred tradition. Good evening, talmidim. We are living in a time of tremendous technological advancement, and baruch Hashem, we are striving to utilize these tools for the dissemination of Torah. We've been working on a new digital resource, an advanced Torah platform, if you will, that baruch Hashem, is now coming to fruition. This system uses reliable, vetted sources that we have carefully curated and put into the system. It's not just unverified internet chatter, chalilah. Among these sources are over fifteen thousand shiurim that we have delivered over the last decade or so. So, if you pose a question, and I have already addressed it in one of my many shiurim over the years, the system will provide you with the answer, either in text or voice, whichever you prefer. Furthermore, it will also provide you with the sources, enabling you to explore the original material in its entirety, ensuring that every answer is grounded in authentic Torah knowledge and easily verifiable. This way, you'll be able to trace the information directly back to its origin.
2:02:10let's say, for example, if one of these sources is one of my shiurim (lectures), when you click that link to that source, it'll take you to that shiur, to the exact spot where I spoke about your question. So, for example, if you ask a question like, 'Who is Rabbi Akiva?' My dear students, we constantly strive to make our Torah learning as accessible and efficient as possible. Many of you are already familiar with the dedicated application we have developed to house all these shiurim. One of its most remarkable features, which truly enhances our ability to delve into the depths of Torah, is its precision search function. Let me elaborate on how this works, as it directly addresses a common challenge in lengthy shiurim. This application will give you several lectures where I have spoken about specific topics. And when you click on it, it will go to, let us say, a two-hour lecture, but it will not go to the beginning of the lecture. It will go precisely to the exact spot within the lecture where I actually spoke about the particular subject. So you will not have to waste time searching for it. It is, Baruch Hashem, a fantastic application. It is actually getting a major upgrade, B'ezras Hashem, in the very, very near future, perhaps even within the coming days, which will bring even more capabilities and chinuch opportunities. We pray that this tool will continue to be a powerful conduit for spreading Torah and yiras Shamayim in our generation. We are eagerly anticipating its completion, for, b'ezrat Hashem, where it will have both the features we have been waiting for and some exciting new functionalities. It will offer many more capabilities than ever before, and will also include a dedicated desktop version, along with various other enhancements. This is all expected to be released any day now. We look forward to seeing it in action very soon, im Yirtzeh Hashem. Now, let us turn our attention to another crucial she'eilah that has been raised...
2:03:19Good evening, dear talmidim. We have a few announcements before we begin our shiur tonight. Firstly, regarding the new siddurim and sefarim that many of you have asked about for the upcoming chagim, I have an update. Hopefully, within a week or less, maybe even in the next few days, we'll see. We're waiting for our development team to complete all the different parts of it. Now, a very important she'eilah (question) has come up that touches on a serious matter of halakha: What is the halakha on money made from immoral practices, like cash advances? Are they required to give back the money made from them? This is a profound question, and it touches on the very foundations of dinei mammonos, monetary laws. When a business or individual engages in practices that transgress halakha, particularly those involving ribbis (interest) or other forms of gezel (theft), the obligation of teshuvah (repentance) includes hashavas aveidah (returning what was illicitly taken). Often, the practicalities are extremely complex. For those who have been involved in such enterprises and now wish to do teshuvah and exit the field, the challenge of tracking every single transaction and identifying each individual from whom money was taken can indeed be nearly impossible. However, the fundamental principle remains: they must cease these immoral practices immediately. So, my dear friends, what are the practical steps for teshuvah in such a challenging situation? As we've been learning, the first and most critical component is to absolutely desist from the forbidden act. Therefore, the very first step for these individuals is wholly and completely exiting the field. Yea, they stole from people. They have a very serious problem, a chilul Hashem even. And, listen, as far as giving the money back, it's going to be virtually impossible for them. Because to track every single deal, and how much, and who, and what — it's going to be very, very difficult. But the most important thing they can do is stop it immediately and unequivocally. That immediate cessation is paramount. Once they have stopped, the next step, of course, is the firm resolve never to return to that business again, to make a true commitment for the future, a kabbalah.
2:04:19My dear chaverim, when we speak about the grave sin of engaging in such a business, a business which, chas v'shalom, causes so much spiritual damage and Chillul Hashem, the path to tshuvah is demanding but absolutely essential. The first and most crucial steps are clear: first, stop and get out of that business as soon as possible. Secondly, make sure you never go back. Thirdly, be remorseful and apologize to Hashem and to anybody else that you can, that you've hurt. Certainly, you must apologize. And if you want to, ah, do even more, you should try to encourage other people to leave that business. This final point, encouraging others to abandon such aveirot, is indeed the highest level of tshuvah for such a grave matter. It's a tremendous Kiddush Hashem when one not only rectifies their own path but also helps others do the same, thereby undoing some of the damage that has been done. We've been discussing the serious halakhic implications of the cash advance business, and the imperative for teshuvah for those involved. It's a challenging path, certainly, but an essential one for spiritual healing. Indeed, we must recognize that the more people you help to leave that business, the better, because you are going to undo some of the damage that you've done. But the point is that it's not an easy thing, because there's a great lust for money, and the sums involved are substantial, making it very hard for people to leave. But if a person could overcome their desires—if one has the siyata d'Shmaya to truly master their yetzer hara in this regard—then they are on a path to immense spiritual reward. Getting out of that business is, without doubt, the greatest thing they could ever do for themselves. Baruch Hashem, I have seen this borne out in the lives of many, including quite a few students who were once involved in cash advances and, Baruch Hashem, heeded my words and left it.
2:05:09and get out of it. It is the greatest thing they could ever do for themselves. Baruch Hashem, I have several, quite a few students who were in the cash advance business in the past, and Baruch Hashem, they have listened to me and left it. But there are many more who did not leave it, who chose to leave me instead. Indeed. We understand that each individual faces difficult decisions regarding their parnasah, their livelihood, and it is a challenging nisayon. Still, each person makes their own choices; it is ultimately up to them. However, for those involved in the cash advance business, who perhaps are contemplating leaving but are apprehensive about having to return all the money and so on, as I have emphasized, the paramount thing is to leave and extract oneself from it. This is the primary obligation. And one must have bitachon that if you take this step, Hakadosh Baruch Hu will certainly guide you. My dear talmidim, we've been delving deep into the prophecies of the Acharit HaYamim and the signs of Mashiach's imminent arrival. As we discuss these grand, overarching themes, it's natural that practical questions arise regarding our personal avodat Hashem and how we rectify our past to prepare for the Geulah Sheleimah. A profound question was recently posed to me by a concerned soul regarding the burden of past debts and errors: "As far as paying back all of that money and so on, Hashem will certainly find a way for you to fix that throughout the remainder of your life. But the ikar, the paramount thing, is to extricate oneself from such situations entirely and to commit to a path of teshuvah. "Moving to a different, yet equally vital, aspect of our daily spiritual lives, another talmid inquired about communal prayer. He asked, 'How does one go about joining a minyan?' To clarify, a minyan is simply a quorum of ten Jewish men who are shomrei Torah u'mitzvot, observant of Torah and its commandments. It is not something one 'joins' in the sense of a club, but rather a gathering one participates in for prayer."
2:06:37Good morning, my dear friends, and welcome back to our shiur on the profound topics of Geulah and Acharit haYamim. We've been delving deep into the prophecies and the understanding of the final redemption. A question often comes up, especially in our modern times, regarding the identity of some of the key players mentioned by our Sages: is it possible that Gog, at the end of days, will be artificial intelligence and his army will be mostly robots or something similar? No, it's not that. Gog is an actual person. If you watch my film called Gog u'Magog, it talks about a person. But there is another entity. It's not a person. Indeed, this is a crucial distinction we must always remember. Gog himself is not some abstract force or machine; he is a man. But this brings us to a deeper point, as we know there are other entities, not human, which will play a role in the end of days wars, elements of ultimate impurity, like the Amilus we briefly touched upon earlier, which comes from an ancient rock and holds a very specific power in the final cosmic struggle. Now, my dear talmidim, we've been discussing the Geulah Sheleimah and the coming of Mashiach. Of course, there are many profound secrets and mystical elements connected to the Yemot HaMashiach that our Sages reveal to us. Sometimes, we get a glimpse into these deeper layers, aspects that aren't always discussed openly. Perhaps one day we'll do a full shiur about it. All I can tell you is that it's a... it's called Amalek. And this entity comes from an ancient source. It embodies the ultimate tumah, and that's also going to be part of the end-of-days wars. Let's just leave it at that. It's a very complex and profound spiritual struggle. It's not going to be like the Transformers or like the Terminator movies or anything like that. But there are going to be a lot of supernatural things. Things that the movies didn't think about. These are spiritual battles, battles for the soul, far beyond what any Hollywood production could conceive. Moving on, on a different, yet related, note, a question often arises regarding the inclusion of Bnei Noach in these final times.
2:07:37Many people have ideas about what the Messianic era will be like, some perhaps influenced by popular culture, but we need to understand it through the lens of Torah and our holy sefarim. While it's true there will be a transformative era, it's a very... Let's just leave it at that. It's not going to be like the Transformers or like the Terminator movies or anything like that. But there are going to be a lot of supernatural things. Things that the movies didn't think about. No, there's no problem of a Noahide praying next to Jews. They are also children of Hashem, and their sincere prayers are certainly welcome. They are obligated in the seven mitzvot Bnei Noach, and prayer is a fundamental expression of belief in the Ribbono shel Olam. There are, of course, distinctions regarding communal prayer and the specific mitzvot that require a minyan of ten Jewish men, but a Noahide's personal prayer is always precious. So, my dear friends, we understand the immense power of mitzvot and teshuvah in fortifying our neshamah against all spiritual challenges. This spiritual strength is not only for the individual but also amplified when we gather as a community. When we come together for tefillah in a minyan, we create a powerful conduit for divine blessing. But there's an important halakha we must remember regarding who can actually be counted in that minyan: it's just that they cannot be counted among the minyan. In fact, even a Jew who is not Torah observant—for example, a Jew who drives on Shabbat. While he is a born Jew, if he does not observe the halakhot, he too cannot be counted in the minyan. It requires ten fully Torah-observant Jews. This is crucial for ensuring the sanctity and efficacy of our communal prayers and other mitzvot that require a minyan. Every Jew is precious and has an eternal neshamah, of course, but for these specific halakhot, the standard of complete Torah observance is paramount.
2:08:37My dear talmidim, we've spoken about the practicalities of halakha, about Shabbat observance and the sanctity of a proper minyan. But sometimes, the challenges we face are not merely external; they are spiritual battles within. Many people ask, "Rabbi, how do we protect ourselves from spiritual negativity? How do you get rid of an evil spirit?" How do you get rid of an evil spirit? You do as much good as the Torah says is possible, especially by helping other Jews do teshuvah – whether by sharing these lectures, by supporting financially, or by doing everything you possibly can to publicize Torah. The more you add merits to your account, the stronger your neshamah becomes to fight off anything that is evil, that is hurting you, or trying to hurt you. This, my dear friends, is the timeless counsel: by strengthening your neshamah through every good deed and every word of Torah, you build an unshakeable fortress against all spiritual harm. May Hashem grant us the strength to always choose the path of kedushah and bring Mashiach closer, speedily in our days. My dear students, we have an important question for today's shiur, concerning the proper conduct regarding our tefillot and congregational worship, particularly in situations where not everyone in the community adheres to all aspects of halakha. A student asks: "Most of the people at my Chabad shul drive on Shabbat. Should I not attend?" My immediate answer is this: If you are relying on these individuals to form a minyan, meaning that if there are not at least ten Shomer Shabbat men present in your Chabad shul or whichever shul you attend, then there is indeed no point in praying there as a congregation. Because if you proceed without a proper minyan, you face severe halachic issues. If there isn't a minyan of ten Shomer Shabbat men, but you still bring out a Sefer Torah and recite the birkhot HaTorah during Kriyat HaTorah, those blessings are considered birkhot levatalah — blessings recited in vain. Such an action, chas v'shalom, would constitute a sin, as you are not fulfilling a mitzvah but rather uttering Hashem's Name in vain. Similarly, if someone recites Kaddish without a minyan, the congregation cannot respond amen. The entire framework of communal tefillah, with its kedushah and kaddishim, is predicated upon the presence of a legitimate minyan of ten observant Jewish men. Therefore, it is imperative to ensure that the minyan is properly constituted by individuals who are Shomer Shabbat, so that all aspects of our communal avodat Hashem can be performed with proper intention and according to halakha. This is a fundamental principle in our practice, and it safeguards the sanctity of our tefillot and berachot.
2:09:51Indeed, a minyan is not merely a suggestion; it is a fundamental requirement for numerous aspects of our communal avodat Hashem. If you proceed without one, you run into serious issues, because there's no minyan. And in fact, it could lead you to sins. For example, if you don't have a minyan, but you still bring out the Torah scroll and recite Birkot HaTorah, those blessings are berakhot le'vatala. These are serious transgressions. You are not fulfilling mitzvot. Similarly, if someone recites Kaddish, you cannot respond with amen. Therefore, it is absolutely essential to ensure that you have a proper minyan present for these communal prayers and readings. ...communal prayers and readings. So, it means you have to have at least ten people that are Torah observant, meaning they keep Shabbat and so on. It's not merely a headcount; it's about having individuals who are committed to mitzvos and Halakha. All right, we'll take maybe another couple of questions now. One moment, yes, brother, go ahead. What should I do if I see a fellow Yid going to his car after going to the shul on Shabbat? This is a very sensitive issue, and it requires a thoughtful and compassionate approach. Often, one's first instinct is to confront, but we must be careful. We've just delved into the profound life of Rebbe Akiva, a true beacon for all generations, who started as a simple shepherd and ascended to the 50th level of Kedusha. It teaches us that every Yid, no matter their background, has an incredible potential within them. Now, on a related note, a question often arises about how we can help others discover that potential, especially those who might be further away from Torah observance. Often, there's a concern expressed, something like: "I'm afraid I might push him away." To that, I say: Well, if you know the person, you could try to reach out to him at some point during the week. Send him one of our lectures; try to get him to watch them with you, or maybe you could watch it together. Send him my movie; try to educate him by sending him information that we have, and hopefully he'll listen and he'll observe Shabbat. I have many lectures and films about Shabbat, so you could send him some of that. Remember, our goal is always to inspire, not to compel. It's about planting the seeds of truth and Yiddishkeit, connecting with their neshama, and showing them the immense light and joy of living a life connected to Hashem. With Siyata D'Shmaya, may we all merit to see many more Yidden come closer to the path of Torah.
2:11:23Now, before we delve further into our parshah this evening, I understand there was a question from one of our diligent talmidim regarding the life of Rabbi Akiva. A very important inquiry indeed! Which Gemara or Midrash discusses the life of Rabbi Akiva? There are different parts in different places. You will find some at the end of Masechet Berachot, and some in Masechet Gittin. Indeed, his story is found scattered throughout the Gemara and Midrashim. Rabbi Akiva was one of the greatest sages that ever lived. He is uniquely credited with having reached the Fiftieth Gate of Kedushah. Thus, different parts of his life are recorded in various holy texts. But there is a significant section about him in Masechet Berachot. I hope that gives you a clearer picture of where to seek out the fascinating narratives of this Gadol hador. Are there any other questions, perhaps related to our topic, or anything else on your minds, b'ezrat Hashem? We've covered some foundational principles today, talmidim. Now, I want to address a few common misunderstandings that regrettably persist, as questions have arisen from some of you. A few others have brought up similar points. I recently heard of a rabbi who reportedly says that people can go to Har HaBayit now if they immerse in a mikvah first that day. Is this true? Absolutely not. It is unequivocally against the Torah itself, based on fundamental halakhot regarding ritual purity and the sanctity of the Beis HaMikdash area. Let me be clear: the prohibition against ascending Har HaBayit today, even after tevilah in a mikvah, is a strict halakhic mandate. We are not pure enough to enter that holy ground, and any such attempt constitutes a severe transgression. This is the unanimous ruling of all the great poskim, and we must adhere to it without question. Our responsibility is to safeguard the sanctity of that place, not to transgress its boundaries out of ignorance or misguided enthusiasm.
2:12:24My dear talmidim, we often ponder the prolonged galus and sometimes, understandably, questions arise concerning the ultimate Geulah and the coming of Mashiach. We might hear people say, "With all these thousands of years, all of these delays, it implies that Mashiach isn't coming, or that we ourselves must initiate everything." Is that truly the case? Does all of the delays say so? No, it's not true at all! The question often comes up: "Can we start building the Beis Hamikdash now?" No, what we might build today is not the Beis Hamikdash that is destined to come down from Shamayim. It's not a construction job that is solely dependent on our physical hands in the conventional way, but rather a miraculous, Divinely orchestrated event. We must remember that our role is in teshuvah, in Mitzvos, in Avodas Hashem, thereby preparing ourselves and the world for its spiritual reception. Hashem's plans for Olam Haba and the eternal world transcend our limited understanding of flesh and blood existence. So, building upon our discussion that it's the neshama that truly defines us, and that our tikkun is a process transcending one physical lifetime, let's address a common query that sometimes arises. We've spoken about the world changing significantly around the year six thousand, and even further after seven thousand, with the Ramchal teaching us about its continuation up until ten thousand years. Despite this clarity, there are those who question whether by the year seven thousand the world will no longer exist. This naturally leads to the questions: why would Hashem create a world that people will not live in forever? And why would people need to live forever if you talk about people being the flesh and blood? But as we discussed, the very premise of 'people' living forever must be understood through the lens of the eternal neshama, rather than the temporary physical form, and that the world's purpose extends far beyond just this physical existence.
2:13:16We must internalize this fundamental truth: that what truly defines our existence is not our physical body, but rather our spiritual essence. It is this core understanding that allows us to grasp the profound journey of our souls. Flesh and blood is not you. The neshama is you. You've been here already since the time of Adam HaRishon, and you just get reincarnated each time until you complete your tikkun. Now, the world is going to change throughout the next — you know, around the year six thousand, and change even further after seven thousand. And the Ramchal says all the way up until ten thousand. But the point is that the ways of the world change. This understanding is crucial because the very fabric of existence, the 'ways of the world' as we know them, Indeed, we learn that many aspects of our physical existence and even the world as we know it, gashmiyus, are going to change drastically once Mashiach comes, and even from millennia to millennia, there are different phases of the world. But the real 'you' is not the flesh and blood, nor the hats, the skirts, the sneakers, or even the mustaches. The real 'you' is the neshamah that's inside. That is the eternal spark of G-d within each of us, the essence that remains constant despite all external transformations, a truth we must always remember and live by. It is this inner core that truly defines us and connects us to the Divine. Good evening, Chaverim, let us delve into a critical point of Halakha that guides our interactions in the world. A recurring question often arises: is it permissible, or even beneficial, to engage in debate with Jewish heretics? The answer, my dear students, is unambiguous: not only is it not worth it, it is absolutely forbidden. I mean, we learn from our holy sefarim the stringent directives regarding distancing ourselves from a min. The Halakha is very clear: you are not even allowed to be within six feet of such an individual due to the profound spiritual danger they pose. If such a proximity is forbidden, how much more so is active engagement and debate, which might lend a false sense of legitimacy to their views? This is a fundamental principle of protecting our spiritual purity.
2:14:44Our Chazal teach us a profound halakha regarding those who stray from the path of Torah. Indeed, the Gemara states that if it is an apikorus, a Jewish heretic, one is not even permitted to be within six feet of him, for the spiritual protection of Klal Yisrael. Now, with such a stringent halakha, you might be contemplating, 'Rebbe, how do I then ask you a personal question about this or any other matter?' My dear talmid, you just did. The door to she'eilos is always open, even when we discuss challenging topics, so please, do not hesitate to clarify any uncertainties. Before we delve further, I open the floor for any questions you might have regarding our discussion on divine providence. Ask whatever you want to ask. But when I answer, I will respond to it fully. My boyfriend said he's watching the stream, so I'm saying hi to him. Ah, that is quite nice. It is commendable that your boyfriend is following the shiur as well. Good evening, everyone. We strive in our avodat Hashem to understand His ways, to grasp the profound intricacies of His creation, and to comprehend the reasons behind the mitzvot. It is a noble pursuit, a lifelong endeavor. However, we learn from our holy sefarim that sometimes, in His infinite wisdom, Hashem, baruch Hu, sometimes does not grant us immediate clarity and answers. Why would that be? It is simply because either we do not yet have the tools to understand, or the time has not yet come to understand, or Hashem wants us to overcome some type of test or obstacle in order to reach that deeper understanding. So, for example, when Moshe...
2:16:01So, for example, when Moshe Rabbeinu asked Hashem at Mount Sinai to let me see Your glory. And Hashem responded, 'No one can see My face and live.' But we know that Hashem says that He doesn't have a body or the likeness of a body. So what does it mean, 'No one can see My face and live'? Meaning that Moshe Rabbeinu wasn't asking to see a physicality of God, but rather he was trying to understand how Hashem works. So Hashem says, 'You cannot see My face,' meaning the things that I'm doing now that haven't been completed yet because you don't have the ability to understand them and still stay in this world, still stay alive. 'But I can show you My back.' What's My back? The back is the things that have already been completed in the past. For example, creation of the world, I can't show you My face, meaning the things that I'm doing now that haven't been completed yet because you don't have the ability to understand them and still stay in this world, still stay alive. But I can show you My back. What is My back? My back refers to the things that have already been completed in the past. For example, the creation of the world, You know, the Gemara in Menachot, in a very powerful aggadah, tells us that Moshe Rabbeinu davka wanted to see all the future generations, to understand the souls, the missions, and the struggles of all the different people that have lived, and so on. So Moshe Rabbeinu wanted to see some of those things, but then Hashem started showing him some things in the future. And He showed him the life of Rabbi Akiva, and he saw how Rabbi Akiva rose to greatness and became one of the greatest chachamim that ever lived, but he also died a very horrific death, where they tortured him and killed him, and so on. A truly devastating end for such a tzaddik. It was at this point, witnessing such a profound and bewildering paradox, that the passuk states,
2:17:16...it was at this point, witnessing such a profound and bewildering paradox, that the Gemara relates Moshe Rabbeinu's astonished reaction and question: "And Moshe Rabbeinu had a question: 'How is it that he learned so much Torah yet he received this? Is this a reward? What is this? This is a horrific punishment!' And Hashem responded, 'Silence! This was My initial thought.' Moshe Rabbeinu then asked, 'What does it mean, "This was My initial thought"?'" Moshe Rabbeinu was struggling to comprehend this answer, which leads us to the deeper explanation that the sages provide. They explain that if you look at the first verse of Bereshit, of the book of Genesis, the first verse of the Torah, it says, 'In the beginning Elokim created...' So Hashem created the world with the midah of Elokim, which is the trait of judgment. And then later on, it says that Hashem's four-letter name, the Tetragrammaton, which is the measure of the trait of mercy. As we discussed, this crucial element of divine governance, the blend of justice and mercy, is hinted at from the very beginning of creation. Indeed, the Sages explain that if you look at the first pasuk of Bereshit, in the book of Genesis, the first verse of the Torah, it states that Hashem created the world with the Middah of Elokim, which is the trait of judgment. And then, later on in the narrative, it says that Hashem's four-letter Name, the Tetragrammaton, represents the attribute of mercy. This profound teaching regarding the interwoven midot, the attributes of din and rachamim, sets the stage for our understanding of how these divine qualities manifest within the neshamot of the greatest Tzaddikim, such as Rabbi Akiva.
2:18:04My dear friends, we often speak about Hashem's attributes, His midot, and how they manifest in our world. Let us consider the creation itself, the very bedrock upon which all existence rests. The Midrash teaches us a profound concept regarding this: that initially, the world was created with a primary attribute, the midah of Din, of strict judgment. So initially, Hashem created the world with judgment, meaning that anyone who would do anything wrong would immediately be judged. But He also knew that this is not possible for people to exist in such a world, because we would literally all die within a few moments of being created. So He added the trait of mercy. And it is this interplay between Din and Rachamim that truly defines our spiritual reality and our purpose in this world. Now, the neshamah of Rabbi Akiva, zichrono livracha, had a profound and unique connection to these very midot, particularly the attribute of Din, the attribute of judgment, which underpinned his entire spiritual journey and his service to HaKadosh Baruch Hu. We often find ourselves grappling with profound questions, especially concerning the suffering of tzaddikim, of righteous individuals. The Gemara in Menachot (29b) relates how even Moshe Rabbeinu, our greatest prophet, asked Hashem, "Is this Torah, and this is its reward?" upon witnessing the brutal martyrdom of Rabbi Akiva. He saw Rabbi Akiva's flesh being raked with iron combs, Shema Yisrael on his lips, and struggled to comprehend such a decree. The answer, as we know, alluded to the deep spiritual roots of middat ha-din. Rabbi Akiva, being a soul of immense spiritual stature, was therefore intrinsically connected to the attribute of judgment, the middat ha-din. And therefore, when Hashem judged him and gave him that horrible death, which he received as a kapparah, as a tikkun, and so on. It was a profound spiritual rectification, a tikkun olam that we, with our limited mortal understanding, cannot fully grasp. This teaches us a fundamental principle: Hashem's ways are beyond our comprehension. What appears as a tragedy to us is, from a Divine perspective, a meticulous and precise act of justice and mercy, a process of purification for the highest souls, culminating in an ultimate spiritual elevation. We strive to accept the Divine decree with faith, even when we don't understand the "why."
2:18:51We learn from the Gemara in Menachot, my dear talmidim, about a most perplexing moment. Moshe Rabbeinu, our greatest prophet, was shown a vision of Rabbi Akiva's future martyrdom, his flesh being flayed with iron combs. Moshe Rabbeinu cried out, "Such Torah, and such a reward?!" And Moshe Rabbeinu asked about it. Hashem didn't say, "This is right, this is wrong." He says, "Silence! This was My initial thought." Meaning, this death that Rabbi Akiva experienced is in accordance with My initial thought of creating the world with judgment. So, of course, Moshe Rabbeinu was not able to comprehend the full story until he left this world, where there are no limitations of the physical body to obstruct true understanding. It is then that the neshama, free from the confines of gashmiut, can truly grasp the depths of Hashem's middas ha'din, revealing how even in apparent tragedy, His justice is perfect. My dear talmidim, we often grapple with the profound challenges and suffering we witness and experience in this world. Sometimes it feels overwhelming, especially when we consider the deep wounds, the petza'im, that people carry from a young age, from their very age of innocence. We ask ourselves, how can one truly recover? How can one find wholeness again after such experiences? The Torah gives us a deeper perspective. It teaches us about the true nature of a human being, that we are not merely physical beings. The very essence of a human being, the neshama, is not hindered by the limitations of flesh and blood. No matter what trials the body and emotions endure, the neshama, that divine spark within us, remains pure, complete, and untouched by any physical or worldly defilement. It is this eternal part of ourselves that holds the key to healing and provides us with unwavering strength, even in the darkest moments. We must always remember this fundamental truth when we seek to understand ourselves and help others navigate their struggles, for the neshama is always whole, always connected to its Divine source, HaKadosh Baruch Hu.
2:19:46My dear talmidim, this is a profoundly difficult question, and one we must approach with the utmost rachamim and understanding: what answers do we give those who are abused and hurt from the age of innocence? It is a case-by-case basis. It is not something that has a general answer. Of course, there are many emotions involved. There is a great deal of trauma. Each individual situation requires careful hashgacha pratit and guidance from rabbonim who understand the complexities involved, always with immense sensitivity and da'at Torah. Brothers, sisters, when we speak about guiding individuals through life's complex challenges, particularly those involving spiritual growth or hardship, it requires immense wisdom and discernment. We cannot simply offer blanket advice, for it is deeply personal and multifaceted. It also depends on their level of understanding of Torah and their commitment to it. There is no 'one-size-fits-all' approach; everything must be handled on a case-by-case basis. A person has to not only be sensitive to their unique situation and emotional state, but also deeply knowledgeable in Torah and spiritual psychology to truly help them navigate their struggles and find meaning within them. As we've discussed in previous shiurim, particularly concerning yissurim and challenges, a true spiritual guide, a rav or a mashgiach, not only needs to listen and empathize, but also has to be knowledgeable in how to actually help those people and not just simply pacify them or try to make them feel better. It's not about making them feel better. Rather, it's about making them aware of what transpired, understanding its value from a positive perspective, even amidst suffering. This is a profound teaching, and certainly not a 'one-size-fits-all' approach. If you want to learn more about such matters, there is much to explore in the teachings of our Gedolim, especially regarding emunah and bitachon through adversity, and certainly in the sefarim of the Musar movement which delve deeply into these very topics.
2:20:45My dear talmidim, we continue our profound exploration into the channels through which sheffa, Divine abundance, flows into our lives and into the world. In past shiurim, as many of you know, I've often discussed how we confront life's challenges. So, for instance, in those lectures that I've spoken about suffering, I've spoken about traumas, and things of that nature. Perhaps some of you are wondering, "Rabbi, do you speak German?" I don't speak German, but I do have a channel in German where thousands of people watch my shiurim. They watch with my voice, and simultaneously in German, because we utilize various technologies to have my lectures translated into fifteen or sixteen different languages. German is certainly one of them. And it is truly a testament to the Ribbono Shel Olam's hashgachah pratis, His divine providence, that we can disseminate the light of Torah to so many corners of the globe, bringing comfort and wisdom to countless souls. This global reach, indeed, is a powerful conduit for drawing down even more sheffa for all of Klal Yisrael. My dear friends, Chazal teach us profound principles about how divine blessing, shefa, flows into this world. Often, people seek shortcuts or remedies, looking for various segulos to enhance their spiritual and material well-being. A common question that arises in this context, particularly regarding items that gain popularity, is whether certain objects possess inherent power. For example, some may ask, "Do beads draw down more Sheffa?" The simple answer, my beloved talmidim, is that these physical items, while they may hold personal significance for some, do not intrinsically draw down shefa as our holy mitzvos do. The seller might profit from such beliefs, perhaps from people who believe nonsense, but the buyer truly gains nothing in terms of divine blessing. We must always remember, it is our adherence to Hashem's will that truly opens the channels of rachamim and shefa. Consider the profound wisdom of our Sages regarding the zeken, the beard, and the peyos, the sidelocks, on a Jewish man's face and head. These sacred hairs, by virtue of being a direct mitzvah from the Torah, are indeed profound conduits for bringing down divine mercy and blessing into the world.
2:21:42We must always remember, chaverim, to discern truth from falsehood in all our dealings. Whether in matters of ruchniyut or gashmiyut, we see that sometimes, perhaps to the seller, the seller gets more money because he sells it to people who believe nonsense, but the buyer doesn't get anything. Ah, beards. So, let us discuss beards. It's not shefa (divine emanation) from the hair on a Jewish person's face that solely brings down rachamim (mercy); this is a distinct spiritual channel compared to the hair on a Jewish man's head. Indeed, the spiritual significance of the beard is multifaceted. As the Kabbalah teaches us, beyond bringing forth divine kindness, it can also... My dear talmidim, we often discuss the various minhagim and halachos that shape our lives and define our outward appearance as yidden. Regarding the matter of the beard, we see that it is common for many Jews to maintain longer beards. While this is certainly a beautiful custom, steeped in ancient tradition and carrying deep mystical significance according to the Kabbalah, it is not an obligation by any stretch of the imagination. The only chiyuv when it comes to the beard is not to shave it with a razor. You are certainly permitted to trim your beard with an electric shaver or scissors. This is because the Torah explicitly prohibits lo takifu pe'at zekanchem, which means one may not destroy the five distinct corners of the beard with a razor; doing so would be a serious aveirah. Good evening, Rebbetzin, dear talmidim and respected members of the kehillah. Let us continue our shiur tonight by addressing a few practical halakhic questions that have come up. First, regarding the mitzvah of growing a beard, a common point of discussion is about its length. Some people wonder if there's a specific requirement. If a person wants to grow a longer beard, they can, and many frum Yidden cherish this minhag, but they don't have to; there is no halakhic obligation to grow a long beard. The ikkar din is to avoid hashchatat zakan, the destruction of the beard with a razor, as explained by the Shulchan Arukh. Now, moving to a very different and far more weighty matter that has been on many people's minds, one that touches upon the dinim of milchama (war) and pikuach nefesh (saving a life), a difficult question has been raised: are Gazan civilians innocent halakhically? Not necessarily. According to halakha, the determination of innocence or culpability in a wartime scenario is complex. It depends heavily on their active or passive participation, support, or direct threat to Jewish lives. The halakha distinguishes between those who are truly uninvolved and those who, even passively, enable or support aggression against Am Yisrael. The din of rodef (pursuer) and milchemet mitzvah (obligatory war) provides a framework for these difficult decisions, emphasizing the paramount importance of protecting Jewish lives and property from those who seek to harm them. However, it requires careful psak halakha (halakhic ruling) by competent poskim in each specific situation, taking into account all factors. These are not simple matters, my friends. They require deep understanding of Torah, halakha, and current events, guided by our great Gedolim who provide us with the proper hadracha. May HaKadosh Baruch Hu bring peace and clarity to Am Yisrael and grant us all siyata d'Shmaya.
2:23:17"Now, someone has raised a very fundamental question, one that touches upon the very essence of halakha and the structure of Klal Yisrael. The question was, and I quote: 'How can a gentile like myself become a Kohen, a priest of Aaron?' My dear friend, you simply cannot. The status of a Kohen, the priest of Aaron, is an inherited one. It must come directly from the lineage of Aharon HaKohen, zichrono livracha, through an unbroken patrilineal line, as clearly delineated in the Torah. This is not a role that one can convert into, nor can it be attained through any other means. It is a sacred inheritance, passed down from father to son, generation after generation. This unique kedusha, this holiness, is fundamental to the very fabric of our people and the roles assigned within our service to Hashem." Good evening, dear talmidim and bnei Torah. We have a couple of important questions submitted for tonight's shiur. Let's address the first one that just came in: "Rebbe, how can we reconcile seeking intercession with the verses where Hashem forbids consulting with the dead?" Who said to seek intercession in that manner? Why would you want to seek intercession directly from the dead? What are you, idol worshipers? What intercession are you even talking about? What are you talking about?! This is avodah zarah! We pray to HaKadosh Baruch Hu directly! Yes, we go to the graves of tzaddikim to ask them to pray on our behalf to HaKadosh Baruch Hu, but to consult with the dead, chas v'shalom, is forbidden! That is a grave transgression, davka, against the Torah itself. Now, moving on to the next question: "What is your opinion of full self-driving cars used on Shabbat?" Forbidden! Absolutely forbidden! This is a clear desecration of Shabbat; it's a disgrace of Shabbat, and it's certainly not allowed. And with that, we conclude tonight's shiur. May we all merit to learn and live by the glorious Torah. Shkoyach.
2:24:09My dear talmidim, we must always strive to internalize the profound significance of our mitzvot, particularly those that are fundamental to our covenant with Hashem. We are speaking here of something truly grave; to cause a chillul Shabbat, a desecration of the holy Shabbat, is not merely something discouraged or a minor infraction; it is absolutely forbidden according to the Halakha. It is a transgression of the most serious nature, carrying severe spiritual ramifications, and we must guard against it with all our might. The sanctity of Shabbat is a cornerstone of Jewish life, a testimony to creation, and we are commanded to preserve it diligently. So, my dear friends, we've been speaking about where we ought to direct our energies and our search for wisdom, chaveirim. We learn from our holy Torah that our focus must always be on serving HaKadosh Baruch Hu and building our world with mitzvot. And this brings us to a question some might raise, perhaps out of curiosity, or sometimes, chas ve'shalom, out of desperation. And I've heard this asked sometimes, maybe even facetiously: "Last question, do you think you could call upon the dead? Like, call somebody on the phone?" Now, this is an important point, because the Torah is very clear about this. Chazal teach us explicitly about the prohibition of doresh el ha'meitim, consulting the dead. We do not engage in such practices. Our emunah teaches us that our connection is with HaKadosh Baruch Hu, and our guidance comes from His holy Torah and from our living Gedolim and talmidei chachamim. Our attention must be on the living, on our families, on our communities, on the mitzvot we can fulfill in this world, not on trying to find answers from those who have already passed on to the next world. Their time for tikkun is complete; ours is still ongoing. Let us focus on what we can do, on the mitzvos we can perform, and on seeking HaShem's wisdom in the proper channels.
2:25:10When we delve into the profound teachings of our Chazal, like the Aggadah on Adam and Eve, sometimes people wonder how we can access the insights of Rabbanim who lived centuries ago. There's a proper way to engage with their wisdom, through their sefarim and through the interpretations passed down by our mesorah. But some individuals, perhaps innocently, might ask, 'What if I have a question for Reish Lakish, or for the Rambam himself?' Well, if they're alive, maybe they'll answer me, but I usually don't call people who are too busy. So, as far as the dead, I don't know what their phone number is. If you have their phone number and you know for sure they're going to answer, maybe we could set up a conference call or something like that. There are nine billion people alive today; why do people want to talk to the dead? I don't understand. Our Torah teaches us very clearly how to seek guidance. We turn to the living Poskei Hador, to the Gedolei Yisrael of our generation, and we diligently study the words of our Chazal as they are transmitted through their sefarim. To attempt to communicate directly with the deceased is not our way; it contravenes halakha and distracts from the true path of Torah scholarship and spiritual growth. The answers we seek are found within the living tradition and its appointed guides. That's a very good question you've raised, and one that often comes up in our discussions of Sefer Bereishit. You're asking if Rabbi Reuven, zichrono livrachah, had a specific interpretation regarding Adam HaRishon and Chavah. Regarding Rabbi Reuven's interpretation of Adam and Chavah, of course, there are many things that were written by Chazal about Adam HaRishon and Chavah. However, I'm not entirely sure what you mean by 'the interpretation.' But if you'd like, I have several lectures that go into a lot of detail. Just go to my YouTube channel and type in either 'Bereishit' or 'Adam and Chavah,' and you'll find a wealth of information there. These lectures delve deeply into the p'shat and drash, exploring the profound lessons we can learn from their story. I encourage everyone to explore these topics further, as they offer foundational insights into human nature and our relationship with HaKadosh Baruch Hu.
2:26:07So, my dear friends, I encourage you to delve deeper into these subjects. You can find more discussions on these profound topics. If you just type in different words like that on the search box in my YouTube page or my app, and you'll see there are different shiurim that I've made about the topic. Many of them, I would say, at the very least half a dozen or more, have many different things to talk about. Okay, we learned, we enjoyed. Hopefully, we can take some of these things and apply them to our lives. Anyone who wishes to support, whether the yeshiva, the kollel, or kiruv outreach, and contribute to all the wonderful things that our organization is doing, I want to emphasize that your contributions are vital and greatly appreciated. Your support enables us to continue our sacred work. My dear friends, kol Yisrael areivim zeh bazeh – all of Israel are guarantors for one another, and it is a tremendous zechut to be able to help one another, especially in matters of Torah and chesed. Baruch Hashem, our organization has been privileged to engage in truly profound avodat kodesh, and b'siyata d'Shmaya, the impact is growing daily. We are constantly seeking ways to enhance our efforts and to make it easier for klal Yisrael to partner with us in this holy endeavor. So, all the wonderful things that the organization is doing can now be supported on our B'Tzel HaShem page. You can contribute by regular credit card, by sending a check (whether via email or WhatsApp), by donating with cryptocurrency or with stock. You could even follow the example of a few individuals who are now sending different gold bars and even jewelry. Indeed, there are many, many ways you can contribute, and we are profoundly grateful for every act of support. Of course, anyone who wishes to volunteer – if you are a serious person and possess an ability to help us – we would be more than happy to speak with you. You can send a message, and we will try to get one of our team members to connect with you promptly. May HaKadosh Baruch Hu bless you all for your continued dedication to Am Yisrael and Torah.
2:27:00Rabotai, in our collective avodas Hashem (service of G-d) and especially in the holy work of kiruv (outreach), there are countless opportunities for everyone to participate, each according to their unique strengths and talents. Whether it is helping with technical aspects, administrative tasks, spreading the word, or even contributing financial support, and jewelry. There are many, many ways you can contribute, of course. Anyone who wants to volunteer, if you are a serious person and you have some type of ability to help us, we would be more than happy to speak to you. You can send a message, and we will try to get one of our team members to communicate with you, to see which part of the team you could best contribute to. May Hashem grant us all siyata diShmaya (heavenly assistance) in this vital work of spreading Torah and inspiring teshuva (repentance). So, my dear brothers, my dear yidden, I encourage each and every one of you to take this message to heart. If you feel inspired to join our efforts, please do not hesitate to communicate with me, or perhaps with our team leaders, to discuss how you might contribute to this sacred work. Either way, Rabotai, I implore you: do as much as you can to serve Hashem; do as much as you can to help other people hear these shiurim so they can change and transform their lives, directing them towards the path of Torah and mitzvot. U'vezot Hashem, all of us will not only merit to do teshuvah, but we will also use kiruv as a powerful means to rectify what we may have blemished in our own past. Indeed, this is a profound concept that our rabbanim teach us. Many might question the efficacy of their own teshuvah...
2:27:46So, my dear friends, as we draw close to the conclusion of our shiur today, focusing on the profound concept of teshuvah, let us internalize this vital point: because as good as the teshuvah is, one never truly knows if they have achieved full and complete teshuvah for themselves. But once you help many others to do teshuvah, then certainly their merit will be enough to fix whatever shortcomings you may not have rectified on your own. Thank you very much for learning with us. May Hashem grant everyone much success in all their endeavors. Shabbat Shalom to all of you, and b'ezras Hashem, we will learn again next week. On a separate note, before we depart for Shabbat, I'd like to introduce you to your new best friend, a remarkable new resource for continued Torah learning. Imagine having an AI Rabbi directly on your WhatsApp, providing you with answers to your questions based on kosher Torah sources, available in over 30 different languages, whether you want to ask in Spanish, Chinese, or Portuguese. You'll have the ability to ask questions at will, receive accurate and reliable sources for everything you ask, and most importantly, gain a deeper understanding of the truth, empowering you to rely confidently on the information provided. My dear talmidim, we live in an age where technology can sometimes be harnessed for the sake of Torah. I want to share with you a new initiative that is based on kosher Torah sources. This program operates in over thirty different languages that are available to you, so if you want to ask a she'eilah in Spanish, in Chinese, in Portuguese, or whatever language you prefer, it's available for you. For instance, you could ask, "Can you tell me about Rabbi Akiva?" Each answer is time-stamped to the relevant shiur or sefer. Simply press this green button to access "AI Rabbi" on your WhatsApp. You will have the ability to ask she'eilot at will, you will be provided with authoritative sources, and most importantly, you will be able to know the emet and be able to rely on these Torah sources. This is a tool, baruch Hashem, that helps spread the light of Torah.