BeEzrat HaShem

Israel Horowitz What's The Difference Between The Torah And The Talmud

9 months ago

What's the Difference Between The Torah And The Talmud? Rabbi Yaron Reuven answers a question from a viewer about the Torah and the Talmud and clearly explains that the Written Torah cannot be observed without the instructions in the Oral Torah, aka the Talmud. This video refutes many of the foolish claims by Israel Horowitz and other heretics that deny the Oral Torah just like the christians do. Full Shiur: Stump The Rabbi 258 - https://youtu.be/Rcy47gW6-s0?si=NW2DeWOCtSI4dhWE SHOVAVIM is the best time to reflect, do TeShuva, and repair moral missteps. Commit to this Tikkun and BeEzrat HaShem see life-changing Bracha: https://TikkunHaBrit.Live Want to support our KIRUV work? Please partner with us to help Am Yisrael keep Shabbat and more! https://www.beezrathashem.org/donate Rabbi Yaron Reuven's short Torah Clips channel – Please Share The Video To Help Others Do TeShuva. AI RABBI by BeEzrat HaShem Inc. https://www.AIRabbi.org Answers To Jewish Torah Life Questions In 30 Languages. Discover Jewish Wisdom at Your Fingertips, Rabbi Reuven's AI Rabbi offers wisdom and guidance in multiple languages, drawing from trusted, reliable sources. #Torah #Jewish #RabbiYaronReuven 00:00 Introduction 02:02 Israel Horowitz's wife fake conversion 05:08 Punishment for violating Shabbat 08:12 What are Tefillin? 12:55 Israel Horowitz's kartoon kosher 15:17 How To Read Scriptural Hebrew? 19:31 Israel Horowitz did it his way 00:00:00 Intoduction 00:00:03 Torah vs. Talmud: Written and Oral 00:00:22 Components of Written and Oral Torah 00:00:51 The Inseparability of the Two Torahs 00:01:29 Criticism of Heretics: Israel Horowitz 00:02:35 Horowitz's Views and Torah Observance 00:03:16 Defining Heresy and the Oral Torah 00:03:59 Historical Context of Heretics and the Rejection of Oral Torah 00:04:36 Understanding Torah Requires Both Written and Oral Components 00:05:03 Oral Torah and Observance of Commandments 00:05:56 Shabbat Observance: Examples and the Oral Tradition 00:07:39 The Necessity of Oral Torah for Understanding God's Laws 00:08:01 Examples of Oral Torah: Tefillin 00:08:52 Tefillin Debate and Horowitz's Ignorance 00:09:58 Addressing Heretics and the Importance of Oral Torah 00:10:49 Choosing Judaism: Following the Torah 00:11:19 Religious Purity and The Influence of Sin 00:12:41 Consequences of Sin 00:13:08 Halal Meat & Torah 00:14:16 Sins and Spiritual Figures 00:14:41 Oral Torah 00:15:22 Reading Torah without Oral Torah 00:17:52 Following the Torah: Book, People, Destiny 00:18:40 The Tzaddikim and Reshaim 00:19:15 The righteous, the wicked, and Teshuva 00:20:16 Torah and Jewish Identity

Transcript

0:03What's the difference between the Torah and the Talmud? Well, the Torah has two parts: There's the Written Torah, which is the Five Books of Moses, and then there's the Oral Torah. The written Torah is the five books of Moses and the rest of the Tanakh, which includes 19 other books: the Prophets and the Writings. The Oral Torah consists of the Mishnah and the Gemara, which combined are called the Talmud. Additionally, the Zohar and all the writings of the major sages up to this day are also part of the Oral Torah. And the two go together. There's no such thing as just following the written Torah or just following the Oral Torah. The two come together, and it's even mentioned in the Torah itself many times that Hashem gave us torot, which is plural, not just one Torah, singular, but torot. Moshe Rabbeinu tells us that at Mount Sinai, we received the Ten Commandments and we got the torot, which is a plural word for Torah. or just following the Oral Torah, the two come together, and it's even mentioned in the Torah itself many times that Hashem gave us Torot, which is plural—not just one Torah, singular, but Torot. Where Moshe Rabbeinu tells us that at Mount Sinai, we got the Ten Commandments and we got the Torot, the, the multiple, which is a plural word for Torah.

1:29Furthermore, Hashem says that He loves Avraham Avinu because he preserved My Torah, which is, again, plural. So now, of course, there are heretics and mental midgets, like this guy named, um, what's his name? People keep asking me to talk about him, Israel Horowitz. the last thing this guy is, uh, is Israel. He is a kofer apikores that insults the Torah on a regular basis. He's married to a goyah, but he did his own homemade, you know, uh, conversion. You are Armenian Christian, for anyone who doesn't know, and that's how you were raised: very God-fearing, very traditional. What you've done now is transitioned to Torah observance. Sure, yeah, I wouldn't call it a conversion, necessarily.

2:35...more than the sages, and believes that you don't need to eat kosher food or observe family purity. In so many words, he thinks that his own understanding of the written Torah is sufficient to... observe the laws of God but literally completely dismiss anything that the Oral Torah states. Now, this guy is somebody that is actually a joke. Unfortunately, many people know so little Torah. they don't understand the difference between a heretic and someone who actually knows what they're talking about. They base their judgment on whoever they are attracted to more, who has charisma, and so on. But like I told you, There are many heretics every other day, and many of them try to reinvent the wheel, but there's nothing new under the sun. Heretics like them existed in the past. We used to call them Sadducees or Baitusim. There is, of course, Christianity, started from a heretical Jew. There are all types of heretics throughout history. This is nothing new. And the one common denominator that all heretics have is that they hate the Oral Torah.

3:59hate the Oral Torah. In fact, the original heretics, the Sadducees and the Boethusians, who existed a couple of thousand years ago, originally planned on dismissing the Written Torah as well. However, no one wanted to follow them because people wanted to follow God. They knew that Hashem gave us the Torah at Mount Sinai, so the heretics changed their strategy from advocating for no Torah at all to claiming they were following just the Written Torah. From them stemmed the Karaites and all the types of heretics. But anyone that actually studies the Torah Properly and also swallows their ego to realize that they certainly do not know more than the scholars of today. Needless to say, they don't know more than the scholars of past generations. Anyone that actually studies the Torah understands that it's not possible to have a Written Torah without an Oral Torah because you would not be able to understand anything.

5:03Without the oral Torah, not only will you not know how to observe the commandments, but for example, Hashem tells us in the Torah 12 times that a Jew who violates Shabbat receives the death penalty. This means it's a very serious crime according to Hashem; it's the equivalent of idolatry. Now, this refers to intentional desecration of Shabbat, not accidental. If it is accidental, they'll have to bring a sacrifice; in today's world, they would have to do teshuva (repentance). but nonetheless, at the time of Moshe Rabbeinu and during the time of the Sanhedrin, which means for thousands of years, anyone who desecrated the Shabbat, the Torah commanded us to actually kill him. In fact, Moshe Rabbeinu killed someone who violated Shabbat only two weeks after we received the Torah. It's in the Torah—Tzelophchad was his name. If this is such a big deal that the violator, the desecrator, gets the death penalty, then certainly we need to know how to observe it and how to not violate it.

6:08The Torah is extremely clear. And for any of these nonsense preachers who want to talk about the fact that the Torah is not understandable, what's not understandable? We know what these things are. Shabbat says don't work. Don't leave your place. Cook your food on the sixth day. Don't burn a fire. Clear instructions. Just don't work. Stay at home. Don't cook. Just be. Be. Oh my G-d, it's so hard. What should you do? Can you rip toilet paper? Can you separate almonds and pistachios? Because the guy that got a death penalty, he didn't light fire on Shabbat. Because the only thing that the Written Torah says about not violating Shabbat is don't light fire on Shabbat. But yet, Hashem commanded Moshe Rabbeinu, literally told him, "Kill the guy and make sure that everybody sees it, so they will be afraid also." And everybody that saw him violate Shabbat, they're also part of killing him. They have to throw the rocks at him.

7:09they have to push him off the building and so forth. The whole death penalty was executed by the people who caught him committing the crime. What was the crime? He gathered wood. Where does the written Torah tell you that if you gather wood on Shabbat, you'll receive a death penalty? Guess what? It's not written anywhere. It's not written anywhere. So, how would the guy know that he's going to get a death penalty for gathering wood? I mean, obviously, God didn't put us in this world because He wants to kill us. If He wanted to kill us, He would just do so without a reason. We, therefore, understand that the details of the rules are provided elsewhere. other words, there is an Oral Torah, there's an oral tradition detailing all the laws. The same concept was an example of one of the things I mentioned in the shiur today, where God tells us that you will have a reminder of this Exodus on your arm and between your eyes. What do you have?

8:25Your eyes are not Hindu. Nobody has a red dot between their eyes. We are not Christians who put some dirt on their forehead once or twice a year on some Wednesday. So, what is the Jewish thing that's between the eyes? Nothing. Look at any Jew's forehead—there's nothing between their eyes. Look at people's arms—nothing. So, what is it? Obviously, this is the tefillin. tefillin, which in English is called phylacteries, is something that every Jewish male aged 13 and above has to wrap around his arm and put on his head every single morning. Do you put on tefillin? If you can, tell me about it. Sure. Yes, I put on tefillin. And look, there is a debate about whether it's even a literal commandment. I can see it both ways. However, it doesn't necessarily need to be exactly a square black box with writings the way the rabbis say. It needs to be on special parchment with special writing and all of these specifics. That's not true. It's just not true. So, yeah, to the extent that the...

9:29tradition is reliable in the fact that it takes the four paragraphs discussing the sign on the hand and the ornament between the eyes, and you go ahead and you put those on some scrolls and wrap them upon yourself, sure. But the details and even the word "tefillin" do not exist in the written Torah. This is found in the Oral Torah. So, imbeciles and mental midgets like Horowitz, Yisrael Horowitz, are so stupid that it's a mockery for anyone that knows Torah to even consider them. are so foolish that it's a mockery for anyone knowledgeable in Torah to even consider them. The only reason I'm mentioning this individual is that a rabbi sent me a message at 8:10 this evening, less than an hour before the shiur. Send me a clip of this guy telling me, can you mention him? I've heard of this guy already for a couple of years. I just never really wanted to mention him because he's, it's a mockery. But when rabbis ask me for a favor to mention and expose a heretic, I do so if I think it will be beneficial for the public to be warned. But nonetheless, people that understand Torah,

10:49Understand that there must be a written and an oral Torah. There are people who don't want to understand it or don't want to accept it. They will make endless excuses, endless explanations, and rationalizations, performing mental gymnastics to justify their lives. If you want to make a new rule, call it something else. There are plenty of religions in India. I think someone told me one time that there are 80,000 different cults and religions in India. Go there. There are all types of religions all over the world. Why do you have to harp on Judaism if you don't actually like it as is and you want to change it? You want to reform it? So that's one of the things that makes you realize that when the sages explain to us that there is... Call it something else. There are plenty of religions in India. I think someone told me one time there are 80,000 different cults and religions in India. Go there. There are all types of religions all over the world. Why do you have to harp on Judaism if you don't actually like it as it is and you want to change it? You want to reform it? So that's one of the things that makes you realize that when the sages explain to us that there is... Purity and impurity, you realize that this is much more than logic, rationale, or IQ. As the Gaon of Vilna explains, which I saw in the Sefer Yashar by Rav Kanievsky, when a person makes a sin, automatically the...

12:11Prosecutor, that he creates this angel, that he creates, that it says every time you do a mitzvah, you create an angel that helps you do mitzvot. Every time you do a sin, you create an angel, if you will, or shed, that will make you want to do sins. And the Gaon of Vilna explains that it's not that the angel is now going to make you do other sins. No, if you fell for lust, made the sin of lust like this guy did where he married a non-Jew and he just decided that she's just going to become Jewish because he thinks she is. Then, guess what? You will now have the desire to make more of that same sin. Don't be surprised that he will defend intermarriage, which he does. Don't be surprised if he defends eating non-kosher because he eats non-kosher. Israel Horowitz, do you see any issue with purchasing and eating halal meat? No, not at all. What's wrong with purchasing halal meat? You don't even need to purchase kosher meat or halal meat. You don't need any of that. All you need is the animal. The Torah just specifies two things about animals: what kind of animal, and not to eat the blood. When you go to your local grocery shop and buy beef steak or chicken cutlets, they have drained the blood out of those animals.

13:47This idea that you need a special certification from a rabbi, or imam, as in kosher or halal—such as a hechsher or halal certification—is not in the Torah. That's simply not the law as conveyed in the Torah itself. You can look through the Torah, the five books of Moshe Rabbeinu, and you will see that nowhere does it specify any specific form of ritual slaughter that you need to perform. In fact, those specific certifications are entirely man-made and rabbinic in origin. All of the sins that a person commits create a desire within him because each time, he creates a spiritual figure that now entices him to commit further. It's like feeding the monster; you created a monster, and the monster wants more and more and it's never satiated. That's, in essence, the common denominator among all heretics. they focus on the oral Torah is because, as I've mentioned, the depth and clarity found within it makes it impossible for them to twist its words.

15:08The Oral Torah is an absolute must. As I've said many times, and I will continue saying this a million more times, the Written Torah is literally unreadable without the Oral Torah. literally unreadable without the Oral Torah. Why? Because in the Hebrew language, the holy language, we do not have vowels like you have in other languages, such as in the English language. In the English language, you have five letters: a, e, i, o, u, and sometimes y. They're used as vowels, meaning that these are foundational letters. that are in every single word in English, Spanish, German, and so on. You must have one of those letters or more for a person to be able to read and understand the word. In Hebrew, we don't have such a thing. So, what is the vowel system in Hebrew? It's called nikud.

16:11Nekudot are like those dots you see in the middle of the letter or under the letter when you read Hebrew. But the written Torah in the Torah scroll, the original way it was written, and you still have in every shul, even the Reform shuls, will have the same written Torah in their Aron HaKodesh. Spent $200,000 to make sure it's the right one. They don't follow it, but everybody has the same Sefer Torah. And every Sefer Torah you will see does not have nekudot, does not have the vowels. So, how do you know how to read it? How do you know that it's Moshe and not Massei? That's a big difference. How do you know it's Bereishit? not, how do you know how to say it, why is that a difference? Because the difference between one vowel and another could make a different word, could change the meaning of the entire language, and can make the difference in the entire sentence.

17:25If it weren't for the Oral Torah, from which the vowel system originates, we would not be able to decipher a single word in the Torah. We would not know what anything means. To claim that the Written Torah stands alone, and there is no need to follow the Oral Torah, is clearly a statement that only a fool would make. Most people don't know this, so they think that the missionaries from Christianity and the heretics who were born Jewish, like this Israel — how it's, uh, they, uh, they sound good, so therefore they must be telling the truth. But, like I said, the more you learn about the topic, the more you realize that the truth is far, far away from them. Truth is with the people of the book, with Am Yisrael, and Am Yisrael has the Torah, the written Torah, the Oral Torah, and anyone that wants to follow is welcome. Anyone who wants to go against can join all the heretics that came before them and were eventually destroyed. Who was the biggest heretic 200 years ago, 400 years ago, 800 years ago, a thousand years ago? Who were they?

18:40rarely ever hear of those people. Why? Because, as the Torah says, "The name of the wicked will rot," meaning it is forgotten. Who are the tzaddikim? They are the righteous people, the Torah sages in every single generation, in every single town, and throughout all of time. Who were those Torah sages? Why? Because the righteous people grow like a palm tree, producing endless fruit. No wind in the world could ever blow them away. Even after they leave this world physically, their neshama, the spark of their neshama, their writings, their Torah, continues to flourish, continues to be here. So, a person that wants to join the reshaim, enjoy whatever it is that you are seeking, because it's short-lived.

19:45Eventually, you'll be wiped out like all the wicked people before. But it's not the same. People do teshuva before it gets too late. The record shows I took the blows and did it my way. We are meant to be a light unto the nations, not to follow their misguided practices. Remember, every Jew must remember that he's a Jew and she's a Jew. We don't celebrate non-Jewish holidays, even if they seem harmless. It's a zilzul, a disrespect to the Torah and can lead to chillul Hashem, a desecration of God's name. Stick to our holy Torah and our own holidays. That's the path of a true Jew.

BH Headquarters