Millionaire NY Developer's Warning on Cash Advance
Real estate mogul Eli Gindi issues a stark warning: the Merchant Cash Advance (MCA) industry is compromising the moral and financial compass of the next generation. Drawing on decades of traditional business experience, Gindi breaks down how predatory lending practices not only violate fundamental Jewish laws against charging interest but actively train young entrepreneurs to prioritize exploitation over honest value creation. Then Rabbi Yaron Reuven reveals the gritty truth about how the Merchant Cash Advance business operates, and what happens to a small business that takes a Cash Advance loan. The business owner thinks they’re getting a loan to save their business, but little do they know they just killed their business. Any hope for the business to survive likely died when they signed the MCA deal. Full Podcast: The Dark Side of Cash Advances https://youtu.be/X8aBTtuVjNE?is=lf5NbB-rggoc2FIB Want to support our KIRUV work? Please partner with us to help Am Yisrael keep Shabbat and more! https://www.beezrathashem.org/donate Rabbi Yaron Reuven's short Torah Clips channel – Please Share The Video To Help Others Do TeShuva. AI RABBI by BeEzrat HaShem Inc. https://www.AIRabbi.org Answers To Jewish Torah Life Questions In 30 Languages. Discover Jewish Wisdom at Your Fingertips, Rabbi Reuven's AI Rabbi offers wisdom and guidance in multiple languages, drawing from trusted, reliable sources. #Torah #Jewish #RabbiYaronReuven 00:00 Millionaire Eli Gindi on Cash Advance business 01:43 A line of credit for a struggling business? 03:49 Deceptive Cash Advance Business Tactics 06:55 False Promises turn into a Nightmare 00:00:00 Intoduction 00:00:01 The Problem of Cash Advances 00:00:30 Religious Prohibition & Aligning Interests 00:01:33 Predatory Lender's Mindset 00:02:19 Borrower's Desperation & Hastened Demise 00:03:49 Deceptive Sales Tactics & Misrepresentation 00:04:41 Misleading Financial Terms: Fake 9% Rate 00:05:25 Misleading Financial Terms: Daily vs. Annual Rates 00:06:18 The Vicious Cycle of Financial Ruin 00:08:58 Broader Economic & Societal Destruction 00:09:41 Call for Leadership & A Stark Warning
Transcript
0:01And I believe that one of the biggest problems that we have in the community today, which bothers me like nothing else, is cash advance. I mean, for, you know, today it's like a drug, and kids wanna make money fast, and I understand that 'cause there's a lot of money out there. But you're losing the, those... You are teaching a generation how to be criminals, how to be conniving. When you're tricking someone to get money, Jew, not Jew, nah, no way. You know, it's very simple. You know, Torah tells you, don't charge interest. Says, don't charge interest to a Jew. And you could have a hetter iska, you could have things, but why does it tell you don't charge interest? Because it wants your interest aligned. Usually, if you're more successful than the other person, the guy who's going to loan him the money, if their interests align, they'll be partners in his business, take 50%, 60%. Your interest, you'll both succeed. He'll succeed. If your interest is only the, your interest, and that's all you're interested in, you know, after 120, you're lucky enough to meet God, you didn't let that guy out that you loaned the money to; he's not letting you out of the grave. And this is not me; this is the Gemara talking.
1:09Jeff Sonn told me that story years ago. He showed it to me from Rabbi Miller's. You know, interest doesn't work. You know, you, you, you want your interest aligned. Take 90% of his business, you'll make sure he's successful. And I've seen the movie in life. Any time people loan money for interest, the end of the day they always get beat. They always lose the money. It always happens. There's... I saw the movie. People that were the kings in our community, the next generation came out lost. So long as he has three months worth of lifetime in the business, they'll lend the money. They don't care about his business, they don't care about his payroll. They care about... they analyze, how much blood can I suck out of him until he dies anyway? So it has nothing to do with helping him. It's a predatory business for a reason. It's called predatory lending for a reason. It's a predator. Predator looks for prey, so doesn't care about helping him with payroll. So the guy that can't make his payroll, that's his problem.
2:15Their lending him money is not helping him; it's magnifying the problem. And it's not a solution, is what you're saying? It's not—it's, it's, it's, it's actually a more difficult death. Right. Because if he doesn't borrow from them, he still has other options. He could still borrow from friends and family. He could still fire some people. He still has other solutions where he could buy himself more time to give himself a better opportunity to turn things around. But this fast-forwards his demise. Yes. This doesn't, this doesn't delay his demise; this expedites it. Yeah. It just looks like help. Yeah, but do they know what they're signing? Do you feel that that's misleading completely? Is it... Or they're so desperate that they don't care, they just are attached to the business emotionally, or, you know, they feel like their whole life is falling apart? I've been building businesses since I was 10 years old. I've been... Almost 40 years. And I could tell you that as much as a person can love their business, there's, there's always going to be a red line. There's always going to be a red line.
3:22Of how much he wants to nullify himself there. Of desperation. You know, yes, put everything into it, but there's always a red line. Right. By the same token, a person who could start a business is also a person who can understand how, you know, what really is risk/reward in things. So when they're signing these documents, there's no way that they ever really understand what they're signing, because no one would dare sign this if they knew what's going to be the end. So- Right. So walk us through, let's say someone wants a half a million dollars. Right. What is he signing over there? How does the interest work, and how does he look six months down the road? He was struggling to begin with. So he's al- he's already being- It's no secret. Yeah. He's already being misled from day one, because nine out of 10 times, the person that he's talking to is not giving him his real name. Mm. So Shalom is now uh you know uh Steve. Okay? So already we're starting with you know different... You know, he's not talking to the right people. And then sometimes Shalom pretends to be two or three people. He pretends to be Steve, but then he pretends to be Steve's supervisor, Joe.
4:26You know? Why? Because the whole thing is a lie from the beginning. I have training vi-, I have training, uh, uh, uh, recordings that people gave me, uh, that, uh, they got working in this business. Literally, they teach the people to lie from the first second. Mm-hmm. Secondly, on the paperwork, many times you'll find something where they say something like 9% recovery rate. Now, this 9% recovery rate is to mislead the customer to think that, number one, they are a, uh, they're a company that's trying to collect receivables, like they present themselves, which is not. And number two, to present as if it's 9% rate. It's not 9% rate. You know what that 9% is worth? Mm. Zero. It's the same thing as putting a picture of Pikachu on the paperwork. That 9% has no value whatsoever. That number, that recovery rate, is not even advertising. It's literally worthless. It's just purely to mislead, and it's very common on that paperwork. Secondly, when they do present the rate, at some point or another, they show it as a daily rate, which the average person does not understand, even if he's a businessman, does not understand, because no bank tells you, "We're gonna charge you .2% per day.
5:42Mm. No. They tell you, "We'll charge you 14% a year, or charge you 28% a year if it's a credit card." That's what, you know, they give you annual percentage rate. Right. That's the normal thing that you have- Right. ... by law. But the merchant cash advance business misleads by saying, "No, we're gonna charge you 1.6%." So even the guy looks, 1.6, "Okay, so 1.6%, that's a pretty good rate. Wow, it's even better than my bank." Or in the best-case scenario, the guy says, "You know what? Oh, so 1.6, so if I times that by 12, so yeah, it's more or less like a credit card." He doesn't realize that 1.6 rate is almost 50% a month. So he doesn't, he has no concept of what he's paying. When does he realize it? After he signs the paperwork, after he signs his business away pretty much. It's a death sentence to the business. Then he wakes up and he realizes, "Wait, they just drafted money—they took money out of my account for the rate. I just borrowed the money yesterday. Two days later, they're already taking money out. And guess what? The next day they're taking money out.
6:43They're, in many cases, taking money out of the account every day, which is poison to any normal business. Because your main thing in any business that creates value for a business is cash flow. When you're sucking out all the cash flow out of the business – you're out. You're killing the business. You're out. So now they're taking money every day and he can't stop it. He complains on it all he wants. Listen, mister, this is what you signed. Oh, he didn't know? Okay, sorry. Next time read the paperwork. So now they're starting to take money out of his account every month. He realizes he put himself into a bind, but he's still optimistic because the guy promises him, "Listen, don't worry, this is just our first deal to get, you know, to get our feet wet, to get to know you." You know, he's still pretending to be his friend now. "We just lent you $50,000, you have to give us 75,000 in a couple of months. That's just to get to know you, but don't worry. After you do this right, we're gonna give you a, uh, we're gonna refinance the loan to give you a small business loan." You know, like the, you know, small business loans like the ones that the government helps with and then the ones that you only pay 8% on.
7:45This is all fairy tale. This will never happen. And three months from now when he doesn't have enough, or he even does have enough, they say, "Listen, we can't do the small bit, but if I give you another 300,000 of merchant cash and you pay back $450,000 in a couple of months, then we'll get you that $3 million that you told me you wanted. The 3 mil- then we'll give you that." So the whole thing is smoke and mirrors, and all they're doing is trying to refinance him to give him a bigger loan by selling him a bigger dream that one day he's going to get that multimillion-dollar investment that will never happen. Hmm. Because they're just simply sucking more and more that they can out of his business, and Hashem help him if his business is not growing at least 50% a year. Because at that point, the demise is even faster. So the average business cannot survive a merchant cash advance. This is the reason why more times than not they go bankrupt. More times than not, they end up in lawsuits. More times than not, this ends up destroying jobs, destroying the, uh, the, the guy's life.
8:58Some people have committed suicide as a result of this. Many people have lost their jobs, and one of the big things that's going to make this whole thing blow up is when the government wakes up – the government of America and other countries where this is happening, but mainly America is hurting – and realizes that the economy is being destroyed silently as a result of this business. Because the number one thing that moves an economy, any economy, is not the Coca-Colas and the Pepsis and the Apples of the world. It's the small business. So when you are systematically destroying small businesses in every opportunity that you can, you're destroying the economy. And this is exactly what they're doing. This is what they did in, in the previous generations, and this is what's happening. And it's unfortunate that there's not enough rabbinical leaders, uh, you know, leaders of any kind, in the Jewish community speaking against this business. And I think I'm giving everyone the Kaf Zechut that they're not aware- Right ...
10:02of how evil this is, but it's becoming harder and harder for me to believe that because of what I see. Actually, you're not alone. It's called merchant cash advances. It's called MCA. This is one of the biggest reasons why you hated Jews. Whoa, whoa, whoa. It's not a loan. It's not a loan. It's a loan. Something that can lead to the next Holocaust. Now, you're gonna call me extreme, you're gonna call me crazy, but if you pay attention, you'll see exactly why. and those are the ones that are crushing you, crushing your business, taking money out of your account-