BeEzrat HaShem

Minyan Halachah: Mechallelei Shabbat

1 months ago

Minyan Halachah: Mechallelei Shabbat 00:00:00 Intoduction 00:00:00 Minyan Zählung bei Shabbat-Verletzung

Transcript

0:00Rabbi, I was wondering if a Jew breaks Shabbat in private, can he still be counted in minyan? That depends. The Gemara in Masechet Avodah Zarah explains that if there are ten people who know that the person is breaking Shabbat, even though he does it in private, it's considered in public. meaning, the fact that there's public knowledge about this person's desecration of Shabbat on a regular basis makes it a public sin. He doesn't have to drive in front of everyone for everyone to know that he drives on Shabbat. See, if everyone knows that he does not keep Shabbat, even though he does it in private, he still cannot be counted in minyan.

BH Headquarters