Missing Information, OTD CONVERT, Saying Amen, YISHMAEL, Angels, INTERMARRIAGE-STUMP THE RABBI (140)
Transcript
0:15We are back here on our Stump the Rabbi, our longest-standing series, to go over some interesting things in the Torah. We will delve into it and delve into it because everything is in it. Tonight's shiur will be for the Refuah Shelema for Rabbanit Levana bat Sara, Rabbanit Sara bat Anat, Rav Ephraim ben Shulamit, Avi Mori David ben Nesriah, Imi Morati Doris bat Zohra, and Hatzlacha Rabbah to all of Am Yisrael, and all of the Righteous Noachides that continue to support us, that continue... To contribute, anyone that wants to contribute to our organization should go to bezratHashem.org. Or something easier, if you'd like, you can go to bhtorah.org. Or you could donate on our app. Surely it's the best place to watch our lectures. There are going to be some major updates coming soon in the app. On the website, there's actually an extraordinary link.
1:24... project coming soon regarding questions and answers on the website. So that's coming soon, b'ezrat Hashem. So anyone that wants to help us, wants to be a partner in these big projects that the organization is doing, miraculously, by all means, contribute and be generous, b'ezrat Hashem. Also, for all of you that haven't already signed up... uh, to uh monthly contributions, I think that one of the best things that a person can do is to contribute, you know, already schedule their donations ahead of time. Of course, sometimes the income changes, opportunities change, projects change, but everybody should have at least a certain amount of money that they know they can handle each and every month, and they can already program it ahead of time, just like you do with your phone bill and your electric bill and everything else. And this actually helps the organization have some kind of an idea of what it could do as far as projects because this is what we call a "run rate" that the organization has.
2:34they know what they're going to generate more or less. This gives us and any organization an understanding of how much they can spend on movies, videos, and all types of other things that we do. So, anybody that hasn't signed up for the automatic monthly donation and wants to be a part of it, you can do that on the website, and you'll succeed um So, we have, Baruch Hashem, a lot of things going on in the world today, a lot of things going on in the media. Of course, you have the elections, the market correction, the Hollywood craziness. anti-Semitism is at an all-time high. Crime in general is at an all-time high. There's obviously a war at large and an even bigger war in the process. Twenty-six countries are on the verge of bankruptcy, which, if one of them declares bankruptcy, could certainly become a domino effect that could collapse the entire economy. You have a lot of interesting things that are happening out there, a lot of dangerous things. Of course, you have
3:44New storms and different types of ecological dangers in the world. Of course, the COVID virus decree has not passed. And the world is, of course, a mess. I mean, if you look at just simply the crime that's happening in the world today, and you compare it to what your grandparents, what our grandparents had to deal with, there's literally no comparison. Despite the world seeming to be more civilized and more sophisticated, the crime rates have really hit all-time highs across the board. Every day you hear of more murders, more pedophilia, more horrible things. but yet, despite all of that, one of the main things that has hit the news more times than others, and in fact has captured the attention of the Jewish world more than many other things, are the comments of the mentally ill Kanye West. And the question is, is Kanye West correct?
4:51Is this something that is truly correct, what he said? Of course, he said anti-Semitic remarks. But is he correct? I actually made a short little video on TikTok discussing this in just a couple of minutes. But of course, we'll discuss it further with much more important details in this shiur. Because one of the main things that people don't realize is that there is a continuous mistake that anti-Semites make. especially the modern-day anti-Semites, like Kanye West and others who, you know, are celebrities that hate us. And that mistake is their misunderstanding of what a Jew is. You see, Kanye West, when he made the comments that he made about how he has all this bad history with the Jewish people and how they control Hollywood and they control the media and they control the stories... And he can't find a movie that he wants to hear about one of the historically significant people from African American descent. But yet, you can find many stories about the Jewish people, which, you know, immediately in my mind, I thought to myself, I mean, he claims to have so much money. Why doesn’t he just make the movie, you idiot, instead of complaining about not having the movie? But apparently that didn’t go into his little mind.
6:15Yet he got so much attention for his anti-Semitic remarks that the Jewish world at large is literally losing their mind. And yet I've yet to hear anybody actually address what he said as far as whether it actually has validity or not, because the truth is it does have validity, meaning that he's obviously not right for being anti-Semitic, but he is right about the things that he's saying. which, to elaborate on that, is that the mistake that Kanye West and many other idiots like him make is that they assume that all Jews are alike. So he thinks that the Jews that he met in Hollywood, the lefty liberal, anti-Torah, anti-God, atheist, communist mentality, pedophiles, immoral people, adulterers, thieves, and all types of horrible people, who are more like the people of Sodom than they are like the people of Mount Sinai. But he believes that those people he met in his life, because surely
7:23he's not close to anyone that's really a Jew that learns Torah, so he thinks that they are the Jews, they are the Jews, and therefore, since they are the Jews, this is his opinion on them. Now, quite frankly, anyone that has been listening to my shiurim for at least the last few years, knows that we speak against those very same Jewish people on a regular basis as an obligation that the Torah has on us. We have to do that because a Jew is not supposed to be unethical, a Jew is not supposed to be immoral, a Jew is not supposed to be an adulterer, and certainly, a Jew is not supposed to take advantage of the weak. uh, and in fact, if you actually get to know real Jews by going to a kollel, going to a yeshiva, seeing someone delve into the Torah and sacrifice their life, their time, their energy, their everything into learning the words of God, into serving God, then you realize there is literally a world of difference between the real Jews and the Jews that he simply has a problem with.
8:27And what he doesn't realize, and the many others like him don't realize, is that they're not describing the Jews. They're simply describing their own environment because everyone around them is like that. Not just the Jews, whether the guy is of Italian background, Greek background, Arab background, or whatever other background. if he's in the Hollywood crowd, if he's in a celebrity world, if he's in a materialistic world, if he's a gangster rapper, if he's all of these different things, that's his attitude, that's his morale, that's his ideology: simply kill or be killed, survival of the fittest. and the behavior that is around him is simply by everyone, but he wants to pick on the Jews because, of course, his little mind says that's the target. Because, of course, it's a way for HaKadosh Baruch Hu to remind us to ask ourselves: Are we really Jews, or are we part of the fakers? Are we really closer to being the people of Sodom and Gomorrah?
9:30or the people that were chosen at Mount Sinai. The reality is that anyone who has actually met real Jews who are Torah observant, keep Shabbat, learn Torah on a regular basis, and live their lives in accordance with the Torah, would have no idea what this guy is talking about if he's describing all of our people. Because if you go to a kollel, you go to a yeshiva, they don't even know what you're talking about. Stealing from people? Chas v'shalom. Adultery? Chas v'shalom. Taking advantage of people? Chas v'shalom. Being unethical? Chas v'shalom. We're not going to go to Gehenom for any amount of money. We're not going to go to Gehenom for anything that God says not to do. So if you look at the real Jewish people, which are the very same ones that began with Avraham Avinu, that received the Torah at Mount Sinai 3,300 years ago from Moshe Rabbeinu. all of these things. If you compare those people to the people that he's comparing them to, there is no comparison. We're nothing alike. In fact, the only reason why there are Jews in the world today, both secular and religious, is because of those very same Jews that sacrificed their lives learning Torah throughout all of the generations. Because all of the ones that were secular and remained secular and had secular children certainly lost their connection to Judaism within one or two generations.
10:55once they assimilated and started marrying the goyim. But of course, Kanye West never did any of that history. He's too bombarded with all types of clever ideas in order for him to actually think for more than a second. And of course, he has some mental illnesses too. But nonetheless, it's not Kanye West that we have a problem with, but rather we have a problem with not realizing what is a Jew. Most people, including religious Jews, don't... don't realize that there is a world of difference between the secular Jew that the world knows and the religious Jew that the world doesn't necessarily know. And, of course, there are always those fake religious ones that dress the part, look the part, but are even worse than the secular ones. So, of course, these are always the different messengers that the Yetzer Hara will send. to cause even more confusion. But one of the things that I learned when I was on Wall Street for nearly two decades, making all types of investments, literally making nearly a billion dollars in business. Not income, but business transactions.
11:59And we had an enormous amount of opportunities come at us every single day. All types of things flying right, flying left, going up, going down. And one of the things that I learned throughout all of those years is that the most valuable asset, the most valuable commodity, you can call it, that a person can have in that career and, in fact, in life, aside from time, is information. Information. Why? Because when you have the correct information, you can make the right decisions. When you don't have the correct information, certainly you're more likely to make the wrong decision. aside from time, is information. Information. Why? Because when you have the correct information, you can make the right decisions. When you don't have the correct information, certainly you're more likely to make the wrong decision. The problem is not regarding whether you have the correct information or not having the correct information, because that's usually easy to tell. The problem is controlling yourself while you don't have all of the information, because that is certainly going to lead you to the wrong decision. So one of the things that Kanye West made as a mistake is that he simply doesn't have all of the information.
13:05The question is, are we doing the same exact thing with our lives? And we're going to go through a few things in our Holy Torah to see what kind of, you know, predispositions we have. What kind of, you know, conscience do we have? What kind of mindset do we have? What kind of inner voice do we have that's going to tell us what is the story, you know, what is the conclusion without necessarily having all of the information? The Gemara... says in a story, an example, an event that took place. In fact, a couple of real-life events took place that will shock you. They said that during the times of the Greeks, when the Greeks were causing many people to become Greeks, like the Americans are doing, like the Germans did, and unfortunately, like Israel is doing, which is to become secular, to become atheistic, to become anti-Torah. During this time period, a couple of thousand years ago in the religious community, it once happened that a person, a Jew, was riding on a horse on Shabbat
14:18the Beit Din saw him, brought him to the court, and stoned him. Now, of course, they didn't kill him on Shabbat; they killed him the next day after proving that he was guilty, and they stoned him to death. Now, one might ask, is riding on a horse forbidden on Shabbat? Needless to say... Is it forbidden to such an extent that it's a desecration of Shabbat to require stoning? And the answer is no, it's not forbidden. So how did the Beit Din do such a thing? How did the Beit Din, and these are holy people, these are righteous people, how did the Beit Din take the life of another Jew from this world with what seems to be a wrong decision? Another example the Gemara gives is that there was one time an incident where a man cohabited with his own wife outside in the open under a fig tree. And they brought him to the Beit Din and they punished him by flogging him and his wife. Now, does this, of course, this type of act of immorality
15:45it's not allowed, but if somebody does that on any other day, are they going to get flogged? And we're talking about the time of the Sanhedrin. Surely today, there's no stoning, there's no flogging—we don't have a Sanhedrin. But if we talk about then, if somebody else did that six years before, ten years before, twenty years before, twenty years after, they wouldn't flog him, they wouldn't stone him. But yet, these, they did. And again, we see what seems to be a mistake, but not just a mistake where a few people ate non-kosher food, not just a mistake where people started observing the holiday too late or too early, but a mistake that actually cost lives. Could it be that our holy wise sages take life so lightly when the Gemara itself says specifically that any Beit Din that delivers a death penalty more than once every seven years is a vicious Beit Din? So could it be that this is such a case? We're gonna leave that answer till later on. But in the meantime, think for yourself, is the Beit Din right?
17:04Is the Beit Din wrong? If they are wrong, under what precedent are they wrong? Is it just because the Halacha says no, therefore we have to follow it because technically the Torah says don't veer right or left? On the other hand, if they're right, why are they right? Why? Because they're the Beit Din? Because they're the Chachamim? Because they're the wise ones? They can just do whatever they want and just kill people whenever they feel like it? Have you ever heard such a thing? Have you ever seen Moshe Rabbeinu do such a thing? No. So think of it initially on your own and try to figure out where does your conscience stand? Where do you stand with this type of equation without having all of the information? Now, the Shaarei Teshuvah, written about 800 years ago, somewhere around 700 or 800 years after the Gemara, the Talmud Bavli was put together, by
18:05Rabbeinu Yonah of Gerona, he was the nephew of the Ramban, Nachmanides. And in his Shaarei Teshuvah, in the third gate, section 36, Lamed Vav and Lamed Zayin, it says, you must not harden your heart nor close your hand to your destitute brother. This is a verse that's in the Torah, in the book of Deuteronomy, chapter 15, verse 7. And he says that we have been admonished to remove from our soul the quality of cruelty and to implant within it pleasant saplings, the faithful virtues of mercy and kindness, as the verse says also in Deuteronomy 28:9, "Walk in His ways," meaning walk like God, be like God, be merciful. Since it's possible for one not to be tight-fisted and show grace to the poor, but without being merciful, the verse says in Proverbs 12:10, "The mercy of the wicked is cruelty." And therefore, the verse says, "You must not harden your heart." The punishment for acting cruelly is harsh and bitter, as will be explained in the Gate of Cruelty, a different section of the book. Now,
19:27Here we see that Rabbeinu Yonah seems to be paskening differently than what our Beit Din did. Again, we don't have all the information yet. Is he really paskening differently? In the very next section, he starts with a verse that says, you must not have pity on him, nor be compassionate to cover up for him. wait, you just told us that we have to be compassionate, and you brought a verse. But then again, you brought another verse in Devarim 13:9 that says the exact opposite—not to have pity on him, not to be compassionate. So tell me, which one do you want me to do? Be compassionate or not compassionate? Naturally, most people would say, yeah, of course you have to be compassionate. God is a loving God. You must love everyone, accept everyone. Of course, that's only a figment of our imagination because nobody loves everyone and nobody accepts everyone. It's just that the ones who usually pretend like they do accept everyone until somebody disagrees with them, and then they become the real monster that they've been hiding this whole time. But yet, here we see that there are two things being discussed: real Torah, real words of God, but without having all of the information.
20:49it seems like most of us will naturally lean towards the direction of saying there's something wrong here. It seems that the sages are wrong. Either they're contradicting themselves by saying be compassionate and then don't be compassionate, be merciful and then don't be merciful. On the other hand, they're saying, listen, it's not really a Torah violation to ride on a horse on Shabbat, but yet they killed the guy. so it seems like something is not just missing, but something is outright wrong. If you look at the weekly parasha, as many are supposed to each and every week, you're supposed to go over the parasha. A word to the wise is that if you've read the weekly parasha already with the commentary of Rashi Many times you have a good understanding of what Rashi says on each verse. Perhaps you should graduate and start learning some Onkelos. If you've done Onkelos as well already,
21:56have a good understanding of what Onkelos says along with Rashi. You still have to do one of them, but add to your weekly regimen perhaps one of the other midrashim. Eventually, graduate to even get to a point of maybe reading some Nonetheless, there's an endless amount of commentary, and the reason why there's an endless amount of commentary is because every bit of commentary has a new layer of information that, when one studies it and sees it, makes all the difference in the world. It's literally the missing piece of the puzzle that we sometimes didn't know existed. Quite frankly, most of the time we didn't know existed. But we thought this is the way it's supposed to look until that missing piece came, and then it made so much sense. We couldn't believe that we lived without that piece. In the beginning of the parasha, Parashat Vayera, we already learned that Avraham Avinu had the brit milah last week, and
23:00then he's obviously getting tested more and more. During this parasha, it begins by sending him the guests, the three angels, which we discussed already earlier this week. When people ask if the sages tell us that Avraham was observing the Torah laws at the time, uh, that he was alive, even though it was before the Matan Torah, how come he gave the angels milk and meat? And we already learned that if you look at the verses, it says that the bakar that he gave them, the calf that he gave them, was one that he made, which our sages teach us he literally made by using Kabbalah. Similar to how, you know, this is from the Sefer Yetzirah, similar to how the Maharal Miprag took a couple of other Chachamim and, in order to protect the Jewish community, they made a golem. And in fact, there were other Chachamim that made golems at different times throughout Jewish history. These are beings, in essence, that are made from the ground. And they, for all intents and purposes, look like human beings. But they don't speak. They operate and do what their master tells them. And the way that they get life, in essence, is that they have the Name of God on them.
24:26so this is obviously there's a specific pattern to it. The instructions of how to do it are still available for anyone that wants to make themselves a few golems. But of course, this is something that preceded the Maharal, and Avraham Avinu himself made not a golem but rather made a calf So when you feed a calf that you made with milk, it's not considered a violation of the Torah because it's not considered meat, according to Halacha, because the meat that Halacha is referring to is meat that came from another animal. So that little bit of information, when I first found out about it years ago, made a whole lot of difference to me. Why? Because it was a much better answer than the other answers that I got, which is, you know, well, listen, you know, this was before the Torah. Or listen, they, you know, he gave them the milk and they drank it and the cheese and they ate it and then they washed their mouth and then they ate the meat. All these other ones are good. They're right. They're perfect. They're fantastic. But it wasn't for me.
25:40The one that I got from the Zohar HaKadosh, that made a whole lot more sense to me. Now again, for each neshamah, they're tuned differently, and different things will connect with them. But when you have another piece of the puzzle, you realize how much you are missing. How valuable that missing piece is, is only something you realize after you find it. Because you only realize that you were missing something significant once you found something significant. also one of the things that we see that shows us in this parasha is that Avraham is speaking to Hashem, trying to convince Him not to destroy Sodom. But yet we have to ask ourselves: why did Hashem want to destroy Sodom in the first place? Of course, we see that it's an immoral place; it's a horrible place. But it has been a horrible place; it has been an immoral place for a long time. Why now? So, the pasuk says that Hashem says, "I hear the screams from Sodom." What screams, ask the sages?
27:02The screams were the screams of the daughter of Lot. One of the daughters of Lot, the Midrash says, in Gemara, actually also in Masechet Sanhedrin, on page Kuf Vav, or 106, I believe, in Masechet Sanhedrin, says that the daughter of Lot did a good thing that was illegal in Sodom. What was it? She fed the homeless. It was illegal to feed the homeless. It was illegal to help the poor. It was illegal to have guests in Sodom. But the daughter of Lot saw that there was a person who didn't have food, didn't have the ability to take care of himself. But she also knew that it was illegal. so, as clever as she was and good-hearted, she decided that since everyone goes to the well, no one's gonna expect anything, no one's gonna look after anything. What is she gonna do? After she goes to the well, instead of getting water, she'll put some bread in the bucket and walk away, lower it into the well a little lower so no one can see it.
28:12and walk away, and the homeless man will come grab the bucket. Everyone will think he's getting water, but really he's getting a piece of bread and some food to eat. So this good-hearted daughter of Lot did that, and of course, the evil people saw it and got her arrested. What was the outcome? Since she violated the law of Sodom, The court decreed that they had to punish her. Since you want to be a giver, we'll make sure to punish you by giving. How? They put honey all over her body and placed her in a location full of bees, allowing the bees to continue taking from her until she died. The screams of this poor girl were heard by Hashem. And this was the last straw that, after He saw the homosexuality, the pedophilia, the murder, the rape, the stealing, everything that He saw, this was the straw that broke the camel's back. Now, it wasn't really the only reason that Hashem destroyed them. It was simply the last thing that happened. Why didn't Hashem do it before?
29:33Well, one thing we learned from last week's parasha, if we add the pieces, is that last week, the Sodomites had an opportunity to do teshuvah. You see, after the war of the kings, where Avraham Avinu went to defend the honor of Hashem, not just to find his nephew Lot, because the Midrash Rabbah says that Avraham Avinu told his people, "I'm going against these kings. Anyone that's coming with me is coming. If no one comes with me, I'm going alone, and I'll die al kiddush Hashem," meaning, "I know I'm going to war, and it's suicide because these kings, they killed a bigger army." not just to find his nephew Lot, because the Midrash Rabbah says that Avraham Avinu told his people, "I'm going against these kings. Anyone that's coming with me is coming. If no one comes with me, I'm going alone, and I'll die al kiddush Hashem," meaning, "I know I'm going to war, and it's suicide because these kings, they killed a bigger army." Needless to say, we have a tiny army. So I know I'm going for suicide, but I'm willing to go die for the sake of kiddush Hashem. So the Midrash asks, what kiddush Hashem are you dying for? This is not jumping into the fire of Ur Kasdim and not worshipping an idol. What kiddush Hashem is there? Avraham Avinu knew that the whole war of the kings was a war against Hashem.
30:36And the whole plan that these kings had was to kidnap Lot, the nephew of the most famous man in the world, Avraham Avinu, who was getting many people to do teshuva, many people to pray to Hashem. And since they knew that Lot looked exactly like him, since they knew that people were following Avraham, they wanted to take control of everything. And this war was actually against Avraham. was against Avraham. And Avraham Avinu says, "They're looking to eliminate the name of Hashem from this world. I'm going to go fight for the name of Hashem, knowing I might die. Whoever is coming with me is coming; whoever is not, I'm still going." So now, Avraham Avinu, after he had this war and miraculously destroyed all of these people, the king of Sodom comes out of his hiding hole. and tells Avraham, "You can take all of the money, just give me all the people." Now, the king of Sodom and his people obviously realized that Avraham Avinu was a holy man. Otherwise, he wouldn't have been able to win such a big war. This was full of miracles. They knew of Avraham since they obviously knew his nephew. Everyone knew who Avraham Avinu was. Everyone knew how righteous he was. And also, when Malki-Tzedek comes and honors him,
32:03He publicizes it even more. And for those of you that don't know who Malki-Tzedek is, Malki-Tzedek is Shem, the son of Noach. So this, Rabotai, was apparent to everyone. And everyone had an opportunity to learn the word of God from Avraham Avinu. But yet the Sodomites instead of doing teshuva and realizing that their mistaken ways led them to near annihilation, they went back to their bad ways and got even worse. Instead of listening to what the Rabbi said when he told you to do teshuva, when he told you not to go there, when he told you not to do this, when he told you not to give that, what did you do? You did it anyway. You figured, no, no, it's going to work out anyway, and everything got much worse. And that's exactly what happened with Shlomo. They went back to their ways and they got much worse. Why did they get much worse? Because now they didn't have that same angel protecting them, saying, "Listen, they don't know. They don't know. They don't have a teacher. They don't have this. They don't have an excuse anymore." Why? You had an opportunity. You had Avraham Avinu right in front of you. Instead of going with him, listening to him, what did you do? You went back to your ways.
33:23you went back to your addiction to money, addiction to immorality, addiction to prostitution, addiction to pornography, addiction to all the filth in the world. That's what you went back to. You went back to not having a Rabbi. Why? Because you're too smart to have a Rabbi according to you. You're too good to have a Rabbi according to you. No one understands you according to you. You don't need anybody to tell you because you know yourself better than anyone and everybody else doesn't know you. And what ended up happening is you got much worse. Sodom and Gomorrah happened. HaKadosh Baruch Hu tells Avraham Avinu, "I'm going to destroy it. I'm going to destroy it because after they saw you and they didn't do teshuva, I wanted to give them a little bit more time, but with this last act of murdering a young woman for being generous, they lost their right to live." So here, this little bit of missing information adds a few more pieces of the puzzle for us. A few more pieces of the puzzle of why Hashem did it when He did it. Why He did it overall, we knew all along. But why He did it at that particular time certainly makes a very big difference. Now, later on in the parashah, we learn more things about the tests of Avraham Avinu.
34:54We see that his nephew Lot also goes back to his bad ways. Avraham has to suffer this, knowing that this happened, but also having problems at home. What problems at home? Avraham journeyed from after this war... Instead of having some peace and quiet, he journeys to another new region where his wife, Sarah Imeinu, is kidnapped again. She was kidnapped in last week's parasha by Pharaoh. This week, she's kidnapped by Avimelech. Her beauty is noticed right away. When he says that she's my sister, Avimelech doesn't wait for even a moment before he takes her to be his wife. Hashem makes a miracle and closes all of the orifices in the body of Avimelech and everyone in his palace. Meaning they not only cannot procreate, they also cannot go to the bathroom. They also cannot give birth.
36:21And certainly, this type of horrific nightmare is not just a cold or a coronavirus. Avimelech apparently has enough merit for Hashem to speak to him in a dream and tell him why this is happening. And then Avimelech gives her back. But it's told by Hashem to ask Avraham to pray for you. Ask Avraham to pray for you. Why ask Avraham to pray for you? Because as long as he doesn't forgive you in his heart, this will not go away. Now, prayer—if a person understood the value of it—it would change their life. I heard a Dvar Torah from Rav Biderman, a real chassid, who says beautiful divrei Torah, an extraordinary talmid chacham, and he said in the name of the Chazon Ish, our dear Chazon Ish, that we've been learning his sefer for the last couple of years together. He says in the name of the Chazon Ish, from the Kovetz Igrot,
37:49In section 132, the Chazon Ish says, "Know that at all times, no matter what happens, everything is planned by Hashem. Through every difficulty, I hold strong to my emunah because nothing happens by accident; everything is determined by Hashem. I invest my efforts in tefillah (prayer) to merit salvation." Therefore, I put little emphasis on hishtadlut, meaning the extra effort above and beyond prayer. Why? Because most of the hishtadlut is misunderstood by people. Meaning people do not apply the right amount of hishtadlut. In fact, they do not know how much hishtadlut they're supposed to have. Many times, people ask me questions about how much bitachon they should have, this and that, and usually, they are either working too hard or simply too lazy to work and thinking they have bitachon. Now, the Chazon Ish continues, and he says, "Therefore, the primary hishtadlut that a person needs to have..."
39:12...is tefillah (prayer). That's the primary hishtadlut, and only sometimes a person is required to put in additional effort. But to do only hishtadlut and forget about tefillah is certainly not considered fulfilling the obligation of hishtadlut. End quote. The Chazon Ish... throws us a life-changing chiddush here. You have issues in your life. Whatever they may be, we all have our bag of tricks that we have to deal with. The Chazon Ish says that you have to understand your hishtadlut, your effort, whether it's your effort to make money, your effort to get married, your effort to do this, your effort to do that. Most of the time, the amount of effort you're exerting
40:13is either too little or too much because you misunderstand what hishtadlut really is. In fact, the biggest part of hishtadlut is at all times supposed to be prayer. The biggest part. Surely, there are certain things that require some extra effort. You need to go to the bank, you need to get a job, you need to go on a shidduch date, you need to do certain things. Certain things require a little extra. and therefore do both. But what ends up happening many times is that we get carried away in whatever task we're in. We're in the middle of a lawsuit. We're in the middle of a negotiation to buy something. We're in the middle of a negotiation to sell something. We're in the middle of producing something. We're in the middle of destroying something. We're in the middle of hiring someone and firing someone. We're in the middle of doing whatever it is that we're doing. And even things as simple and natural as bringing a child into the world. We're in the middle and focused on—we want another boy, we want another girl, we want another child, or two, or 87.
41:21And you're so focused on the goal that you just keep trying and trying and trying this way and that way. "I'll get a job there, and I'll get a second job over there. I'll sleep six hours instead of eight hours, and maybe four hours instead of six hours, or perhaps two hours. Maybe I'll read this, I'll do that, and I'll go meet this one." We're so involved with the hishtadlut that we forget about prayer altogether when the Chazon Ish says the exact opposite. your main part of your hishtadlut is supposed to be the prayer and only sometimes add the extra stuff, like going to the bank, the things that need to happen naturally. But if your hishtadlut became the priority to the point where your prayer is virtually non-existent in comparison or literally non-existent, then certainly you are not fulfilling your obligation of hishtadlut. Why? Because if you think that it's in your hands, in your power to get what you need and not through your mouth and your heart, as Moshe Rabbeinu tells us, it's in your mouth, it's in your heart to fulfill it. You pray to Hashem and Hashem makes it happen. But if you think that if you keep banging on the wall, eventually it's going to turn into a castle, you're sadly mistaken. So this is actually a lesson that Hashem teaches us here. That even the Goy, Avi Melech, yes, you made a mistake. Yes, I didn't kill you yet. But to fix it, not only do you need to give Sarah back to our dear husband, but you have to plead with him to pray for you. Why? You need prayer. You need prayer.
42:48you're sadly mistaken. So this is actually a lesson that Hashem teaches us here. That even the goy, Avimelech, yes, you made a mistake. Yes, I didn't kill you yet. But to fix it, not only do you need to give Sarah back to her dear husband, but you have to plead with him to pray for you. Why? You need tefillah. You need tefillah. And that's exactly what happened. Avraham prays for him and he gets healed. Later on, we see a little bit more, a little bit more in the story. That story here, of Avraham being told by his dear wife Sarah after Sarah sees that Ishmael is an animal, Ishmael is a murderer, Ishmael is a psychopath, and Ishmael is a chutzpan that made fun of Yitzchak.
43:57of Avraham being told by his dear wife Sarah after Sarah sees that Ishmael is an animal, Ishmael is a murderer, Ishmael is a psychopath, and Ishmael is a chutzpan that made fun of Yitzchak saying, "You know that your real father is not Avraham; he's only my father. Your father is Avimelech because if Avraham was your father, you would have been born at the same time as me. But you weren't; you were born only after." After Sarah hears this, she knew he had to get out of the house now. Ishmael was also strong. But we hear that after Avraham woke up early, obeying Hashem's instructions to listen to his wife and send out Hagar and her son, Yishmael, it says that he gave bread and a skin of water and gave them to Hagar. He placed them on her shoulder along with the child. What does it mean he placed them on her shoulder along with the child?
45:22Shortly later, we hear that Yishmael is sick and on the verge of dying before Hashem makes the miracle of showing the well. In fact, the well was always there; He just didn't allow her to see it until He decided that it was time. But the question is, what happened to Yishmael? Why is Yishmael dying? Why isn't his mom dying if he was already dying? the time that he left the house. Why? Chazal teach us that Sarah Imeinu looked at this boy and saw how evil he was. She put an ayin hara on him, and that made him sick. That made him sick. Now you would think, "Oh wow, Sarah Imeinu, that's a dangerous ayin over there." is not something that just happened here in this parasha. It happened a couple of times. In fact, after the Akedah, after the Akedah, you hear that Avraham Avinu went to the test that Hashem gave him, almost sacrificing his son.
46:45And after passing that test, it says that Avraham went back. Avraham returned to his lads. So Chachamim asked, wait, Avraham and Yitzchak went to the mountain. The whole thing happened, and then Avraham, it says in the pasuk, returned. Where is Yitzchak? Chachamim say in the Midrash Rabbah that Yitzchak went to one of two places. The Zohar HaKadosh says he went to Gan Eden. Hashem gave Yitzchak a nice tour in Gan Eden—the Gan Eden that's in this world. Other Chachamim say, no, he went to the yeshiva of Shem and Ever to go learn Torah. Fine. They don't contradict. He could have gone to both. The question is, why? Why did he go there? Why didn’t he just come back with Avraham Avinu? So the Midrash Rabbah says, in Parashat Vayera, Rabbi Chanina says, Avraham sent Yitzchak. the yeshiva of Shem and Ever to go learn Torah. Fine. They don't contradict. He could have gone to both. The question is, why? Why did he go there? Why didn't he just come back with Avraham Avinu? So the Midrash Rabbah says, in Parashat Vayera, Rabbi Chanina says, Avraham sent Yitzchak
48:12Separately. Why? He was afraid of Ayin Hara. He was afraid of Ayin Hara, that after such a big miracle happened, where Hashem did not allow him to kill his own son, did not allow him to sacrifice his own son, and they both got elevated exponentially, spiritually, reached a whole new level in reality, Avraham was afraid that there's going to be an evil eye on them. And therefore he says, son, it's better you go alone. We go separate ways. Because if they see us together, it could be ayin hara. Let them ask, where is he? Let them be occupied with, where is he? What happened? Who? What? When? Instead of already knowing everything's okay. It's better people wonder if everything is okay than knowing everything is okay. Why? Because people naturally are not happy for your okayness. They're not happy for your happiness. People like if you have problems. Why? That's an evil eye. There's ayin hara and ayin tov. Two different things. When people see that you have good
49:29Even if they have good or even better themselves, they see you have good and they don't like that you have good. You got a new job? They don't like it. You got married? They don't like it. You have a new kid? They don't like it. You have a big house? They don't like it. You know how to speak? They don't like it. You don't know how to speak? They don't like it. Everything they don't like. Why? Because they're evil, jealous people. And of course, we've had to deal with these people our whole lives. There are plenty of those. But then there are people that have the evil eye. And people that have the evil eye, that put an evil eye on someone, are not necessarily doing that out of hatred. Sometimes it comes from that. But sometimes it can even be someone that loves you. It can be your mother, your father, your brother, your sister, your wife. In fact, you can even do it to yourself. Why? When someone... Puts too much value into a certain thing. Oh, you see how successful he is? Yeah, well, why do you care how successful? No, no, no, it's just, you know, I'm happy for him. I'm happy he looks successful. He just bought a $2 million house. You know, last year he was collecting, you know, he was collecting change in the streets. Oh, you see what he did to this? Why do you care? Evil eye. Very dangerous.
50:46Avraham Avinu saw this in real life. Why? His own wife looked at Yishmael. Yishmael almost died. Only because of the miracle of Hashem did Yishmael come back to life. And Avraham Avinu knew that even though Yitzchak is a tzaddik, as soon as Yishmael and Eliezer see that they're back, they can see everything's okay, that in itself can be an evil eye. Why? A miracle happened. a miracle happened. It's a very big deal. People could put an evil eye. Where else did this happen? If you notice, the Midrash says—this is again Midrash Rabbah in Parashat Noach, 56—and the Midrash says, you know, this evil eye thing...
51:46It's well-founded across the Torah. Gemara Masechet Berachot has a whole section about the evil eye. That's why it's always good not to necessarily say so much about yourself to people. What do I mean by not saying so much about yourself to other people? Stay as quiet and as secretive as possible. One of the things that I always tell all my students is, don't tell people your problems. Don't tell people your successes. Talk about general things. Don't talk about your life. Don't talk about things that are happening in your house. Why? It's not going to add any value. In fact, it can create a lot of jealousy, animosity, an evil eye, and so on and so forth. Sometimes, once in a blue moon, people listen to me, but usually, people like to ask me for advice but not listen, which is by far the most annoying pet peeve in the world. But nonetheless, one of the things that we know we have a tradition of is that you don't tell people that you're pregnant for as long as possible. Meaning, if you can hold off telling anyone that you're pregnant until the baby's already here, that's ideal. What do people in the world do today? The second that she gets a little thing that says she's pregnant, oh, she puts it on Facebook. She tells everybody, a mass text message to the whole family: "We're having a baby." And what a disaster it is if that doesn't end up happening because of all types of complications.
53:08she thinks, "Oh yeah, because of the hormones. Oh yeah, because maybe I pushed myself too much. Oh yeah, maybe because of this or maybe because of that." No, no, 99% of the time it's the evil eye. What do you mean, but everybody was happy for me? No one says that it's because they're not happy for you. The evil eye doesn't necessarily come because people are unhappy for you. it could come from loved ones. Therefore, it's best to keep things private, as private as possible. But of course, most people are going to say, yes, yes, yes, tomorrow they're going to forget everything. And they're going to publicize their whole lives to the world. Do you think it's a coincidence that most people that flash their cash and their cars and their success end up declaring bankruptcy within a matter of a few years and becoming big disasters? No, it's not a coincidence. Even in our holy Torah, We have an event that happens in the book of Daniel. Nebuchadnezzar HaRasha wants everyone to bow to his idol. He had an extraordinary idol, of huge size, built, and he made this idol appear as if it's God. Because the idol was floating in the air. Imagine this massive structure floating freely in the air.
54:32Chachamim say it was done through magnets. Now, this idol also had the ability to say things, which made people believe that it really was God. Until Daniel the prophet climbed the idol and took away the name of God that was in its mouth that allowed it to speak. But before all that happened, Nebuchadnezzar made a decree that everyone has to bow to his god, or else he throws them into the fire. Hananiah, Mishael, and Azariah, the three friends of Daniel, go to the prophet and say, "We're not going to bow to this idol. Now we can run." "Tomorrow, what is it going to say in the paper? All of the nations bow to the god. So, people are going to think, 'Oh, all of the nations—that includes the Jews too.' So, we can't run away. It'll be a desecration of Hashem's name. So, we are going to tell him, 'We're not bowing. He's not a god. He's a nothing, and you're nothing.'"
55:49And then he's going to throw us in a fire. He has a fire that he's been preparing for weeks to make sure that it's really hot and incinerates anyone that goes even close to it. All we want to ask is, is God going to save us like He did with Avraham Avinu? The prophet says, one second, let me talk to God. That's how easy it was for him to go speak to God. speaks to God. God says to the prophet, "No. Tell them, 'No. If they want to jump in the fire, jump. They don't want to jump, don't jump. I'm not saving them. Not saving them.'" The prophet hears. The prophet says. He's not allowed to change the words. A prophet that doesn't say the words of Hashem that he's given faces the death penalty. So he tells Chananiah, Mishael, and Azariah, Hashem said, he's not going to save you. If you want to jump and die in Kiddush Hashem, by all means, go ahead. Up to you. So Chananiah, Mishael, and Azariah leave, and then Hashem says to the prophet, you know I'm going to save them, right? He said, but God, why did you tell them then? Because if I would have told them, what's the big deal of them jumping in the fire?
57:03want them to earn all of the merits from this point on until they jump into the fire. I want them to earn every one of those merits. So needless to say, the next day they tell the boker netzach, "He's a zero. He's nothing. The idols are nothing." Quickly they get thrown into the fire, and Hashem saves all of them. A big kiddush Hashem. The Midrash asks, what happened to them? How come we never hear about them again in the Torah? I mean, if anything, we should have heard of them at least as much as Daniel the prophet. hear about Daniel. Daniel talks to the, uh, he becomes best friends with the, uh, uh, Angel Gabriel. Uh, although he has a whole book in the Tanakh, that's the Book of Daniel, at the very least we should hear, uh, the Book of Hananiah. We should hear something more about what happened to them. Did they get married and have kids? They'd likely do something. What happened? The Midrash says...
58:22the reason you don't hear about them is because shortly after, they died. How they died—everyone made such a big deal out of this whole thing that happened because it was a big deal—that it put an evil eye (ayin hara) on them, and they died from the ayin hara, not from the fire. Some Chachamim say no, because they knew this, they had to run away and learn in secret, learn in secret far away. We hear about them later on in the Tanach, but under a different name, where it says in the book of Zechariah, chapter 3, verse 8. Listen now, O Yehoshua, the Kohen Gadol, you and your companions who are sitting before you, for they are men of wonder. Chachamim say, what is this "men of wonder"? Oh no, these are the three men that a miracle happened to them. So they didn't die, but they knew there's an evil eye on them. There's trouble, there's problems. Run away, change place, become anonymous.
59:39here we see that this little bit of missing information about the Akedah, about Avraham, is a big deal. I'll give you one more example because I see that we're already running out of time, or maybe two. It says at the end of the parasha that after Avraham returned to his lads. He left the Akedah. It says that it happened after these things that Avraham was told, "Behold, Milka too has borne children to Nachor, your brother. Utz, his firstborn, Buz, his brother, Kemuel, the father of Aram." So the question is, Why does it say the wife of Avraham, of Nachor, Milka? Usually, it doesn't mention the wives. And not only does it mention, it highlights. Milka bore children. Why? If you reverse back to chapter 11, verse 29, the Ramban says, look, what does it say over there?
1:01:07It says Milka was Nachor's wife, right? She was the daughter of Haran, who was the father of Milka and Yiska. Who is Yiska? Yiska was another name for Sarah Imenu, meaning that Milka was the sister of Sarah, the wife of Avraham Avinu. So two brothers are married to two sisters. So why does it say, Milka too had children? It says, Milka had children with your brother Nachor. The next word, too. Why too? It says, just like Sarah Imenu, your wife, had children. At 90 years old, she had Yitzchak. Her sister, Milka, also had a miracle, and she had these children when she was very old. The miracles run in the family. Baruch Hashem. the Midrash also says that Avraham Avinu was very scared. Why was he scared? Look at how many tests he had: thrown into a fire, going to war with four kings, the Akeidah with Yitzchak. You know, it’s a nightmare of nightmares. Why was he scared that all these things happened? Hashem says, no, no. Behold, Milka too bore children.
1:02:33your brother and then names the sons. Why do we care about these sons? Firstborn, Buz. So many people say, yeah, no, we know these names because eventually we get to Rivka, who ends up marrying his son. Then you should have just said Rivka was born. Why are you mentioning all these other names? I mean, say Utz, Utz, firstborn. What's firstborn? No. Avraham Avinu was scared to have many more troubles. Hashem says your troubles are over from now on. No more tests. You passed all the tests. Avraham says, yeah, but there's a certain judgment that comes to the world. There's a certain amount of tests that have to come to the world. What's going to be? No worry, somebody else was born into the world to take over the tests. His name is Utz. He's your nephew, your brother's son. Chachamim say, who is this Utz? Reish Lakish comes and says, Utz, that's Iyov. Iyov, you have a sefer in the Torah, in the Tanach, the book of Iyov.
1:03:49Job is Iyov. Iyov took over the tests. Another piece of information you ask is, "When did Iyov live?" When this, when that, surely there's all types of debates. But now you have another piece of the puzzle. Oh, oh, it's now I know what's Iyov and why this, why that. Ah, having more information, more information. Another really important key question that I'm sure all of you have heard is this question. An angel told him that this time next year, Sarah is gonna have a son, and it says that Sarah laughed, so Avraham laughed. Now, Hashem already told Avraham in Parshat Lech Lecha not to worry—your descendants, your blessing, it's not going to come through Eliezer, it's not going to come through Yishmael; it's going to come through someone else, a son that Sarah is going to give you. When Avraham heard this initially, he also laughed.
1:04:50...going to have a son, and it says that Sarah laughed, so Avraham laughed. Now, Hashem already told Avraham in Parshat Lech Lecha not to worry—your descendants, your blessing, it's not going to come through Eliezer, it's not going to come through Yishmael; it's going to come through someone else, a son that Sarah is going to give you. When Avraham heard this initially, he also laughed. But now he's hearing it the second time, and Sarah is in the background, and he hears it from the angels, and Sarah laughs. It seems to be the same thing as when Avraham Avinu laughed. But yet, HaKadosh Baruch Hu says to Avraham, why is it that Sarah laughed? Why is it that Sarah laughed? Why? Hashem was critical of her. Why? In fact, it also says that Hashem says to Avraham, you know, she said that how could I have children when I'm so old? But in reality, Sarah also said that, you know, my husband is so old.
1:06:17i'm old both but Hashem, it appears, changed the truth. And of course, we've all heard different people say different things. The basics that everybody teaches is that, yes, Hashem changed the truth or didn't say the whole thing. She really said that her husband is old and she's old. He just said that she referred to herself only, so there's no problem, you know, of shalom bayit between Avraham and Sarah. Meaning that Hashem is willing to change the truth for the sake of shalom bayit. Now, this we've all heard. But most of us are not really sure how to use this in our lives. In fact, it created a question. And this question created a problem in the mind of the Ohr HaChaim HaKadosh. The Ohr HaChaim HaKadosh says... first and foremost, why is Hashem treating the laughter of Sarah differently than the laughter of Avraham? And furthermore, when Hashem said to Avraham what Sarah said, can it really make sense in your mind?
1:07:41the God of truth, whose signature is truth, would really lie? Surely, there's something else. And there is. It says the following: Who sent the angels to tell Avraham and Sarah that there’s going to be a baby? In reality, the biggest part of the message was supposed to go to Sarah. Why to Sarah? Because Avraham already heard it. In fact, the angel got punished for not saying it directly to Sarah. She was in the background. The angel got punished for that. But nonetheless, when Sarah heard this, she didn't 100% accept it. But then she said, how could it be? How could it be? When did she say, how could it be? After HaKadosh Baruch Hu miraculously changed her body to be young again at that moment. Meaning that when she said, how could it be that I'm old and really now I'm young back again? All this happened. Ha! And HaKadosh Baruch Hu says, Hashem got upset at that.
1:09:05How come you didn't believe 100% that I would bring you a child until I changed your body? You had a doubt, a little bit of a doubt in your level, Sarah, holy Sarah, a little bit of doubt in your level, that when I sent you the promise that I would give you a child. You didn't 100% believe it until I changed your body. How come? Why didn't you believe 100% before I changed your body? Is something above Me? Is there something that I can't do? And therefore, when Hashem says to Avraham about Sarah, He is talking about She's old, and she doesn't mention that she said Avraham is old because it has nothing to do with Avraham being old or Sarah being old. What He's telling Avraham is, "I'm upset with Sarah right now because she didn't believe Me until I changed her body. How come? How come? She didn't laugh with joy until I changed her body. How come?"
1:10:26So it's not that Hashem changed the truth for the sake of Shalom Bayit. The Ohr HaChaim HaKadosh says, no, no, it's even more than that. It's actually that Hashem told them the full truth. What was inside Sarah that was missing a little bit at that moment, at her level, that we can only wish to reach her toenail in holiness. At her level, she didn't believe 100% until she got a whole new body. How come, Avraham? How come? had nothing to do with Avraham being old. Hashem didn't mention it because it had nothing to do with the argument altogether. See, see, Rabotai, the little bit of information that was missing until now, whoever didn't know any of this, turns the whole story into something completely different. And the same thing goes with all of our Holy Torah, where you delve into it and delve into it because everything is in it. The Holy Torah says in the name of Rabbeinu Yonah, you must not harden your heart, you must be merciful. But,
1:11:46Whoever is merciful to his fellow creatures will be treated mercifully by Hashem. Whoever is not merciful to his fellow creatures will not be treated mercifully by Hashem. But then it says, don't have pity on him. Don't be compassionate. Don't be merciful. Why not? What's the contradiction? There is no contradiction. It's a completely different lesson. it says here the Torah is teaching us not to be compassionate, that we can't be nice to everyone, we can't be merciful to anyone. We've been admonished herein neither to be compassionate nor to have mercy for those who cause other people to sin and falter. Our sages said in Yalkut section 121 states that whoever acts mercifully to the cruel will ultimately act with cruelty to those who are merciful. This means that if you have somebody who is a missionary, or somebody who is teaching falsehood—even if it's Torah but it's false, and he is adding his own two cents—that is not acceptable.
1:12:57is like these groups of heroes that decided to write a whole new commentary that contradicts Rashi. These groups of idiots think they're chachamim, wiser than Rashi, wiser than the rest of the chachamim. You think that you are going to get away with this spiritual murder? No, no, no. You are causing people to sin. And anyone that's merciful on such people that teach falsehood, that teach heresy, that teach you all types of things that are against the Torah — needless to say, teach you idolatry or teach you all types of things that are going to lower your yirat shamayim — those people are causing others to sin. You're not allowed to have mercy on them. You're not allowed to give them the benefit of the doubt in any way, shape, or form. And in fact, when disaster strikes and Hashem destroys them like He did with Sodom and Gomorrah, we are obligated, according to the Shulchan Aruch, to wear white and celebrate like it's Yom Tov. Now, this sounds vicious only to people who don't know Torah. Now, what about our first little bit of information?
1:14:10that was missing something where somebody went on a horse on Shabbat and got a death penalty of stoning, even though the Chachamim say it's not really Chilul Shabbat, or the person that was acting immorally with his own wife, but outside in the open, also got flogged. What about that? Says the Gemara, the Sanhedrin has permission The Beit Din has the permission to inflict lashes and even capital punishments in situations that are not mandated by the Torah. it's not with the intent to transgress the statutes of the Torah that the courts may impose these measures. Rather, it's with the intent to build a fence around the Torah and the safeguarded statutes. When we see that the world at large is becoming enemies of the Torah, disrespecting the Torah, and disregarding the Torah, we have to become even more stringent for their sake. When we see that people are so careless about Shabbat
1:15:21that they start riding horses on Shabbat. Even though it's not forbidden to ride a horse on Shabbat, it's certainly disrespectful to the Shabbat. We're going to treat that person as a full mechallel Shabbat, like he's driving on Shabbat, and give him a death penalty. Why? Let them all see and be afraid lest they fall like him. Why don't we flog that other person? Because everyone knows you're not supposed to be immoral, even with your own wife outside. But they became like Greeks. We have to put a stop to it. Give them a heavy punishment. Why? Let other people see and fear Hashem as a result. So there are times that the Sanhedrin was actually obligated to magnify the law in order to protect the law. And that little bit of information, if you didn't have it until now, it didn't make sense that they killed a guy riding a horse. It didn't make sense that they flogged the guy and his wife just because they were doing what every idiotic teenager is doing today.
1:16:37It didn't make sense that Hashem was upset with Sarah for laughing. It didn't make sense that Yishmael was a hero, but then he became sick, you know, that his mom had to carry him the second he left the house. It didn't make sense until it made sense. You see, if a person only knew the little bits of information that are missing in every aspect of the Torah, they would never have a question that they didn't have an answer for. They would never have a doubt They would never have any issues because they would have the truth. The problem is that most people don't have the time, ability, or even know-how to gain all this information. So Hashem sends us different messengers to give us this information. The only question that's left to answer is: Are we going to be like Sodom and Gomorrah, that when they saw Avraham Avinu destroy miraculously these four kings that beat them, are we going to follow Avraham, follow the holy man and his truth, even though it's sometimes harsh, even though it's sometimes difficult, even though it's very different than what we think is right and what we want to do?
1:17:56or we're just going to go back and figure, oh, we got another chance. Unfortunately, Rabotai, most people pick the latter, just like Sodom did. Hence the reason why Hashem continues to bring wrath upon people's heads, just like He'll bring wrath upon anyone that is against the Jewish people, against the holy nation, against the Torah, and needless to say, against HaKadosh Baruch Hu. May it be His will that all of us continue to learn Torah, continue collecting the sparks of holiness that are the missing pieces to the puzzle, to get us closer to Hashem, to get us closer to the sages, to get us closer to our holy Rabbanim that are alive today, that are trying to be the messengers, that are trying to be the ones that help us. Let us have the ability to do it, and at the very least, the mental fortitude to know that it's the right choice to listen to Da'at Torah more than it is to listen to our own opinion at all times, at all costs, and B'ezrat Hashem, at all opportunities. With that being said, we're going to take a short break to drink something and then you guys can ask some questions.
1:19:40okay, let's see. Uh, okay, Jack is asking if it is relevant for a man to be on the bottom with his wife if he is overweight and has no stamina. Uh, yeah, the Rambam says that a man is allowed to be with his wife in any way that he wants, so long as the seed goes where it's supposed to go. Uh, Daniel is asking, does a wicked father still get rewarded for his righteous son's good deeds? Uh, yes, actually. In fact, there is a Gemara that says that not only does a wicked father get merit for his sons, but even Haman... who tried to destroy Am Yisrael, because his heavy decree led to Am Yisrael doing teshuva, fasting for three days and doing teshuva and changing their ways, he actually merited to have grandkids that ended up converting to Judaism and becoming big rabbis, big Torah scholars that were teaching Torah in Bnei Brak.
1:21:03So, certainly, there is a merit to having righteous kids, even if a person is wicked. Next, he's under the Beit Din... Okay, I don't know what that means. There's something on my screen. Okay, yeah. All right. If a convert stops being religious, is there any hope to bring him back? Or is there no hope? So long as a person is alive, that means that they can still do teshuva. uh, whether they will do teshuva or not, that obviously remains to be seen. It all depends on how glued he is to the impurity that he's gotten himself into. Just like any average Jew out there, there are unfortunately many young people that grew up in religious homes and left everything. They became not only secular, but they usually become the worst...
1:22:07type of secular person. They become enemies of the Torah. In fact, um There are many stories like that of people literally taking it to places that even regular secular people don't. Because whatever experience they had with Judaism was so bad in their eyes, they made Judaism into their enemy. They would dafka eat pig and dafka eat chametz on Pesach, and food on Yom Kippur, and so on. but certainly, some of them do come back. It's unfortunately not a big enough percentage, but certainly, there are some of them that do come back. I've seen it happen. In fact, there were a couple of guys that we had that grew up religious and then had bad experiences in yeshiva. left everything, became completely secular. One of them went to, like, Thailand or something, and made all types of mistakes over there. The other one, I think, went to Australia. Both of them lived lives full of sins, lives full of horrible things. And we had the opportunity to help them, to connect with them, specifically with Rabbi Osher. And these couple of guys right now are fully religious. They're back, they're learning every day.
1:23:28So certainly it could happen. If it could happen to them, it could happen to anybody. But again, it all depends on the willpower of a person. It all depends on how much a person is willing to admit the truth. I heard... where he said that one time he had a place where he was speaking, and there was one guy, a clever guy, who was questioning and debating him, if you will. they started going back and forth, debating this, that, and the other thing. He said this guy was a smart person, and surely everybody was very interested in this debate. Everyone was very interested in this debate; they were going back and forth. At the end of the debate,
1:24:29Rav Ades remained on his side. The other guy remained on his side. And then Rav Ades says, okay, after we had a debate, can I ask you something personal? And the guy said, yes, but only if nobody else is in the room. It's okay. So everybody left. And Rav Ades said to him, everything that I said to you, you heard it? You heard everything? Meg, if I told you that all you have to do is keep Shabbat for 10 minutes every week, and all you have to do is eat kosher during that time and recognize that there's a God... would all of the proofs that I gave you make sense for you to follow Torah? And immediately the guy says, "Yeah, of course! You're 100% right, I'll go with you." And he says, "That's when I knew that all of the proofs and the debate that was going back and forth had nothing to do with him disagreeing or misunderstanding. No, no, it has to do with his desires."
1:25:56Because while he's having a debate, and this is not understandable to him, and that doesn't make sense to him, and he doesn't want to believe this, and science says that, and the professor says this, all of that, that's only because he realizes that if Judaism is right, that means I have to keep Shabbat, that means I have to keep kosher, that means I have to put on tefillin every day, that means I have to change my life and I don't want to change my life. So he's fighting tooth and nail to calm his conscience. But if you told him, no, no, the whole religion, everything, the only obligation you have is just 10 minutes a week, oh yeah, sure, I'll do it all. Everything is true all of a sudden. All the prophets, all the righteous people, everything, everything is true. means I have to keep Shabbat, that means I have to keep kosher, that means I have to put on tefillin every day, that means I have to change my life and I don't want to change my life. So he's fighting tooth and nail to calm his conscience. But if you told him, no, no, the whole religion, everything, the only obligation you have is just 10 minutes a week, oh yeah, sure, I'll do it all. Everything is true all of a sudden. All the prophets, all the righteous people, everything, everything is true. Why? Because if I don't have to change my life, then I agree with everything. But if I do have to change my life, he doesn't want to agree with anything. All of a sudden, there are all these contradictions. So that's the reality. The reality is that whether it's a convert or a natural-born Jew that has gone in the wrong direction, to get them back to the right direction requires a certain amount of desire from them to want to be in the right direction.
1:27:11a certain element of truth has to still remain with them. And if the person has that in them, then certainly they can come back to being fully religious and even more this time than the first time. But so long as they are so addicted to their falsehood and their desires, then unfortunately they're not going to see the truth even if it's punching them in the face. Not because it's not there, not because they don't understand, but simply because they don't want it. And that's why the Gemara and the Sefer Sanhedrin say, "How could it be that Am Yisrael worshiped idols at the time of the Beit Hamikdash when we all know there were so many open miracles?" At the time of the Beit HaMikdash, the Gemara says everybody knows that Am Yisrael did not want to worship these idols. What they really wanted was to be immoral with the non-Jewish women. But they knew that so long as they were connected to the Jewish communities and the rabbi kept coming to them and visiting them and asking them to come to shul and asking them to bring korbanot, they couldn't really do what they really wanted to do.
1:28:14So how do I get the rabbi to stop coming to visit me? And how do I get the rabbi to simply give up on me? I'll tell him I'm an idol worshiper. The second he sees that I'm an idol worshiper and I cause other people to be idol worshipers, the rabbi doesn't come anymore. The second he doesn't come anymore, I don't feel any shame anymore. I can go. He can go back and be with all types of non-Jewish women and commit all types of immoral crimes. And obviously, the same thing with the women who wanted to be with non-Jewish men. She wanted to be with the Romans. She wanted to be with the Greeks. She wanted to be with Amalek. How did she get that done? She told the rabbi that she is an idol worshiper. The second that she said she's an idol worshiper, that's it. deal with them anymore. Can't deal with them anymore. So it wasn't about idol worship. So that's the thing. It's all about how addicted the person is to their desires and how much they're willing to change. If they're willing to change, then certainly they can, but if they're not willing to change because they like their desires more than they like their life, then unfortunately, we'll have to wait a little longer until Hashem destroys their desire in one way or another.
1:29:18and has enough mercy on them to destroy their desire in such a fashion that they know that they have to do teshuva sooner rather than later. Next question by Charlie: In the Amidah prayer on Shabbat, it says Hashem gave Moshe a beautiful crown for his head as he stood with Him at Mount Sinai as he brought down two tablets of stone. What happened to that crown? uh, well, actually, everybody got a crown. All of them. Obviously, Moshe got two crowns at Mount Sinai, before they sinned with the Golden Calf. But after the Golden Calf, the angels took back this gift. Also, Rashi said Avraham didn't do a Brit Milah. He did tipat dam at the end of Lech Lecha where it says, yeah, this is one of the other commentaries. If a person reads it further, they know that a Brit Milah was done. Hashem helped him with it. A lot of miracles.
1:30:28uh, in regards to the Brit Milah of, uh, of, uh, Avraham Avinu, uh, can you explain what is the means of Tikkun Soferim, uh, also Masechet Soferim, and what does it, uh, mean in the, uh, text of, uh, scripture when it says that, uh, Nun Aleph or Kuf and, uh, when this, this goes into the, uh, different Dikduk? of the Torah, different things, so there's a lot of different interesting things in regards to the language. Um, also, there's, you know, with certain letters that are used with certain words, if a certain sentence starts with the letter vav, it has a certain amount of significance, whereas if a sentence in the Torah starts with a he, it has certain significance. So, there's a lot of intricate details. uh, when it comes to the world of dikduk, further in regards to tikkun soferim, is that there were printing mistakes. Sofrim were the printers, and the printers at times made mistakes. And since we are the nation that reviews our texts, our scripture, more than any other nation, in fact, more than all the nations combined
1:31:46so we see these mistakes. At some point or another, there was actually, in the times of the Torah, a tradition to go over the Torah once every three years. But to make sure that the scrolls for everybody are the same uh, but once they saw that this was too long of a period of time, we started going through the Torah portions once a week, like we do today, and completing the entire Torah each year. In the old days, they would actually have an event where the Everybody would bring their Torah scrolls, and the king of the nation would have his Torah scroll. They would literally go word for word to make sure that everybody had the very same text with no mistakes. Now, this is one part of our written Torah. This is our written Torah. But then we have the written part of our Oral Torah. And the Oral Torah had a lot more issues where you have different printing mistakes, especially with the printing presses, where there are times that the people at the press would make a mistake for different reasons. I mean, people make mistakes to this day. I actually have a friend that was about to come out with a responsa, a serious Torah scholar's book.
1:33:09and after he put everything together, then he sent it to get edited and to make sure everything was good—the spacing and everything else. He got the work back, and it was ready to go to the printer. He decided, for whatever reason, even though he's gone through this book I don't know how many times, that he wants to go through the whole book again. His own book. And he starts going through the whole book, one page after another, after another, after another, after another, after another. And then, all of a sudden, he sees there are like two or three sentences that describe the most immoral things that happen between a man and an immodest woman. Literally, he wants to cry. He has no idea. He wants to vomit. Where does this come from? This has nothing to do with the book. What is this? He starts looking. Maybe there's a mistake here. What's going on? How? He starts looking at his file on the computer. It's not there. How could this be? He calls the editor. What's going on? And the editor is a Tzadik also. It's not like some guy that you could accuse him of such things. So what ends up happening is
1:34:30One of the things that the editor did also was adding certain graphics to the book, like certain symbols, fonts, and things like that into the book. And one of the symbols that he got for the book, the creator of that symbol apparently is morally sick, to say it politely. He called the symbol that he created that is available for people to use in their books and whatever they want to print. He called the symbol these two or three sentences that talk about what happens between a man and his wife. And when the guy put it in the book to use it for aesthetic reasons, he copied and pasted both the symbol and apparently the name of the symbol, which he didn't realize. So this is obviously a printer error that's more recent. It happened maybe, I don't know, 10 years ago or so. But the point is that these types of things happen. In the times of the Gemara, there were different printers that printed the Vilna Shas that we have right now, the structure.
1:35:50of the Shas that we have today did not always look like this. There were other types of Gemarot where it was the same text, but it was structured and looked different. The image of the page was different, the number of commentaries on it was different, and so on. so when they made these different changes at different times or different printing houses printed them, there were times when there would be mistakes. Because again, it wasn't like today where you have, you know, you put everything in a computer, you press print, and these, you know, two-ton machines pretty much follow your commands. There was obviously a lot more to it. The way that they used to print things just even a hundred years ago was a world of difference between how it's printed today. So each time it's printed by a different group of people, and usually these people that would print. the Talmud and other Torah books were also printed by scholars who were also religious Jews. It was something that the Jewish people were always very careful about, to use other Jews who knew what they were doing. But at times, there would be mistakes. So, since some of these mistakes made either significant differences where...
1:37:12certain amounts of books were sold to a group of people, and that's the way it was for them, and that's the way they learned, you know, for five, ten, twenty, thirty years until they discovered that there is a different word over there in the commentary by Rashi or by somebody else, or even a few letters in the Gemara or words in the Gemara. So, this is why today, sometimes, if you open up certain books, they'll say, "This is the version that we're keeping. Let's say, for example, we're maintaining what Rashi had, but there are others that have a different wording here," and they'll tell you sometimes what it is, or sometimes they'll tell you that they... the commentary by the sage, it seems to me that he did not have the correct Rashi or the correct Rambam because he's quoting the Rambam or he's quoting Rashi, but neither one of them said what he's saying. So either there's some text that we don't know or he got something from somewhere else. Sometimes these things were done intentionally by heretics.
1:38:20the different reformers, like the ones today, that have a whole book—the Five Books of Moses—where they came out with, in essence, a commentary on the whole Chumash that is, in essence, their own commentary as well as distortions of the commentaries of different sages, both where they pick whatever they want to minimize the miracles, to minimize the significance of God, to minimize the significance of the Mesorah, and many times they will actually only use part of what the sage says, eliminating the part that makes all the difference. Other times they would literally just make up stuff. They'll say that the Abarbanel said this, but in reality, he never said it. So these types of things are happening to this day. And of course, they happened in the past. Today it's much easier to find out.
1:39:26uh, when these things happen, uh, because, you know, the technology and how it advances and so on, there's a lot more access to information and communications today. But in the old days, these types of heretical, uh, books, or mistakes that were simply mistakes, not intentional mistakes, these types of things, uh, you know, they, uh, they could have, you know, been around for a while. they could have been around for a while until people found out there's an issue. But nonetheless, it's something that we're aware of, and there are many, many writings of the sages that deal with it. And for any of you who are interested in that subject, I'm talking about these groups of heretics that... are, you know, came up with this new commentary of the Chumash which even many of the Chachamim throughout all of history spoke against. Anybody that would dare come up with commentary on the Chumash coming out of their own mind that contradicts Rashi. You know, so these groups of idiots wrote something called
1:40:43that you know, literally contradict Rashi in every way possible and destroy the Torah. Now, Rav Malachia Kotler recently spoke out publicly against them, and some other Gedolei HaDor have signed letters against these people. But... if you open up this, uh, this Chumash, you'll see that there are haskamot by different big rabbis. So it's, so it's confusing until you pay attention to the, to the, uh, uh, to the details when you realize that they have haskamot from big rabbis that are not for this book. They're not for this book, they're for a different book that was actually good, that was, uh, you know, they just followed the basic tradition. So unfortunately, there are snakes everywhere, and a person needs to know enough Torah to know how to protect themselves. But even more so, they need to have a good rabbi that will give them a certain direction to go, and they should follow it. The problem today that I see is that many people either don't want to listen to the rabbi at all, even if they ask him questions, they don't listen, or they pick a way that they want to go.
1:41:53they look for a rabbi to kosher it, like they go in a sea full of sharks, and after they realize it's full of sharks, they tell the rabbi, "Rabbi, it's okay, right? I'm swimming here." know it's okay that I watch this heretic rabbi, it's okay that - can you check this one? Can you check that one? Because if the rabbi has enough time to check and be the security guard for you... Unfortunately, many people do that. Many people don't want to listen, don't want to do what the rabbis say. They just want to be their own rabbi. They usually call you when it's too late. ...uh, after they've made the decisions to send their kids to certain schools, after they've made the decisions to take certain jobs, after they've made the decisions to give money to certain organizations, after they've made the decisions to marry certain people, then they ask you, "What do you think?" Why are you asking me if you've already made a decision? "No, I just want to know what you think." It doesn't matter what I think... Because literally, it doesn't matter what I think. Why? Because you already made a decision. What difference does it make? The problem is, no, no, no, really, because, oh, the problems came. That's why you're asking me what I think.
1:42:57you're trying to figure out how to get out of this mess, ah, the problem is that it's a problem. So the tikkun of klal Yisrael is an issue that we've dealt with throughout all of the generations, but I think in this generation the more significant thing is to fix our Middot. Because tikkun of klal Yisrael is the least of our problems, the bigger part... uh, next, my cousin is invited to a distant relative's intermarriage between a Jewish woman and a non-Jewish man. I told her she should not attend. She stated that the girl is already living with him and she's due to give birth to his child in about one month. She said since the baby is Jewish and she plans on raising him as a Jew therefore it does not matter. How can I convince her that this is completely against Hashem and the Torah? Well, you should tell her that since she is with a non-Jewish man, the baby may be Jewish according to the Torah, but that baby is not his son. First of all, he's not considered spiritually his son.
1:44:10...and number two, she's gonna suffer a lot from this baby and from this husband. Just give it a matter of time. Now, she's probably not gonna listen to any of that, so what I would suggest for you to do is to simply tell her to watch my movie "Hashem Took Back His Millions." Hopefully... She will get inspired. I would highly recommend that you watch it with her if it's possible. If not, then pray a lot before you send her the movie. Hopefully, she gets inspired enough to not go to this wedding. But there's not that much that you can do. People... are not willing to listen to anybody and simply conclude what is true and what is not without having all the information. You know, we just learned about that today. It's typically the wrong decision, so here it's obviously the wrong decision. Why do we say "amen" to our own bracha in the Amidah after the blessing of peace at the end of the Amidah? There are certain blessings that add that it's also in Birkat Hamazon.
1:45:16uh, there are certain blessings that we have done to add an extra, uh, extra, uh, signature, if you will, because "amen" is really an acronym that means 'El Melech Ne'eman,' which means 'God, the King, who is reliable,' meaning that all of these blessings that I just made, I really believe He's going to fulfill them. So, in essence, that's what it means, and that's also what it means when other people say "amen" to your blessing. They're saying that they believe that the words you just read are true, that God is the King of the world, that God created everything, that God brought the food from the ground, that God allowed this man to marry this woman, and whatever the blessings that you're saying. When they say "amen," they're saying that yes, this is the God, this is the God of Israel, this is the God that created the world. he's the King, he's the King of Kings, he's the only God, and whatever He says is true. Now, also be careful not to say "amen" for no reason. That's called an "amen yetomah" (an orphaned amen), and the Zohar HaKadosh and other sefarim say that there's a severe punishment for people that say "amen" for no reason or say "amen" to the wrong people. For example, if somebody is a mechaleil Shabbat...
1:46:35if he says a blessing like Kaddish or the like, you're not allowed to say amen. If you say amen, you'll get punished for it. Now, I know that there are some people that are so lenient they change the Torah and they tell people that it's okay to have a chazan, even a baal koreh, a person that's reading from the Torah or being the chazan for the kehillah, even though he drives on Shabbat. As long as he doesn't drive in front of the rabbi, this is obviously not true. This is complete nonsense, idiocy. If a person does not observe Shabbat, he's not allowed to be chazan, he's not allowed to be part of a minyan, he's considered an idol worshiper, and you're not allowed to say amen to his blessings. If you say amen to his blessings, you are committing a sin, for which you'll get punished. So, "Amen" is a big deal. It's not just an acronym like they use in the English language and other languages just to save some ink and time. We use specific acronyms for specific reasons, but it's important for us to know what they mean. And "Amen" has a very significant value.
1:47:39So when the sages instituted in the prayer for us to say "amen," that's in essence a chizuk to everything that we say. When other people say "amen," it's a chizuk to what we say. It's even more meritorious for the one that says "amen" than the one that says the blessing. But when somebody says an orphaned "amen," meaning "amen" for no reason or "amen" out of time, let's say for example somebody said a blessing or somebody said Kaddish, and the person uh, wasn't even there, or he was just not even paying attention, and he said "amen," you know, a minute later, 30 seconds later. He has a very serious problem for doing such a thing. So, I mean, there's a lot of interesting details. Also, if there is a ba'al koreh that is observant of Torah and mitzvot but happens to read too fast reads too fast when he does the Shemoneh Esrei, again so fast that by the time he completes the blessing, before anybody says amen, he already started into the next blessing. That's a very serious problem. Somebody has to tell him to slow down. Why? Because the obligation is to not go on to the next blessing until the majority of the kehillah has said amen.
1:49:01the majority of the kehillah said amen, at least 10 people. But even more so, if it's a big kehillah, the majority of the kehillah should say amen. Which means that if he's reading too fast and nobody has enough time to say amen or nobody's paying attention, so only a few people are saying amen, then the ones that are saying amen are getting punished for doing it. because it's an "amen yetoma" and he obviously is not doing the right job. So, this turns a mitzvah into a sin. It's important to know these little details of the law because they make a lot of difference. They make a lot of difference on Judgment Day—in this world and the next world. So, your cousin or friend, whoever it is that just decided that it's okay for her to go to an intermarriage wedding because they're having a son... because it makes sense because she likes it, because of this, because of that. Unfortunately, this is a person who is so ignorant. I don't believe that you can help her directly by teaching her or by talking to her. Yet, something else needs to spark her neshama. That's why I would suggest showing her the movie, showing her the truth, and perhaps that will spark her enough to, at the very least,
1:50:08you know, learn more, be willing to learn more, be willing to accept more. It may or may not change her mind about this particular event, but it could change her life from this point on once she realizes that she's living her entire life in a wrong fashion. And, you know, maybe even eventually get to the other one that's marrying a non-Jew. Can we open the shells of pistachio nuts on Shabbat and Yom Tov? Is there a difference in laws? There's always a difference in certain customs between Sephardim and Ashkenazim when it comes to kosher laws and things of that nature. There are things that the Ashkenazim are more stringent about, especially during the holidays like Pesach. But there are also certain things that are not custom; they're just basic halacha. So, as far as eating food, peanuts, pistachios, you're allowed to have them on Shabbat and Yom Tov without a problem. No problem.
1:51:16...also, very healthy to have pistachios. Peanuts are not so healthy, more fattening. So, if you want to have a big belly like me, eat a lot of peanuts. If you want to have a small belly like I had 30 years ago, eat pistachios. Shomer Mitzvot says, after Hagar fled from Avraham Avinu's tent, why did the angel tell Hagar that she would have a son who is a wild beast and everyone will be against him? This sounds like a curse instead of a blessing. Hagar had humbled herself to return to Sarai Imeinu. Shouldn't she be rewarded? She was rewarded. She was rewarded with a son. She was rewarded with being the wife of Avraham or the maidservant of Avraham. but we can't help the fact that she comes from the Sitra Achra. She comes from the place of Tumah. She comes from Egypt. You know, she's not a pure Neshama like Sarah Imeinu or like Avraham Avinu. She came from the place of Tumah. So Tumah produces Tumah. So even though Avraham Avinu was Kodesh Kodeshim, still his Zera
1:52:30went into this, and it produced a problem. It produced Yishmael, which even though Chachamim say that Yishmael himself eventually did teshuva, still the fact that it's coming from that part of the spiritual world, from the place of the Sitra Achra, it produced all of the Yishmaelim, all of the enemies of the Jewish people to this day. And the Chachamim say that Yishmael's descendants are Worse, they cause more suffering than even Eisav, which until now doesn't seem like it because Eisav obviously killed millions—Holocaust, Inquisition, and so on. But apparently, at the end of days, Yishmael is going to cause even more harm. But that's the reality. So it's not necessarily a curse; it's a reality. For example, if there's a fire... And you tell a person, "Don't put your hand in the fire." And they put their hand in the fire. And they get burnt. When you told them, "Don't put your hand in the fire," was that cursing him? No. Simply telling, this is a reality. You put your hand in the fire, you're going to get burnt. Now, he did it anyway, and he got burnt. Did he get cursed? Did the fire punish him? Did God punish him? No. It's just simply, it's a cause and effect. It's a reality. It's an outcome. Hagar came from the Sitra Achra, came from the Tumah.
1:53:55from the impurity of the world. In fact, Yishmael, it says that she found him a wife. She found him a wife that was the daughter of the biggest sorcerer, the biggest witchcraft person in Egypt. That was who the wife of Yishmael was. Uh, the Gemara says that ten servings of witchcraft were given to the world; nine of them were given to the Egyptians. Next question... Can an angel be punished if they don't have free will, or do some of them have free will? Angels don't have free will like us, but they do have free will. It's just that they get punished right away when they don't follow their job, whereas Hashem gives us more time. So, they're not robots. Angels are not robots like people think.
1:55:09Angels speak, angels have opinions, angels have roles, angels get destroyed. In fact, the Gemara in Masechet Sanhedrin says that about the way that Gavriel, the Malach, the holy Malach of Am Yisrael, speaks to Hashem on behalf of Am Yisrael. It's scary once you read it. Scary once you read it. Even the Chachamim say, can an angel really speak to Hashem this way? And they say, yes, he can. He does speak to Him that way. Why? It's on behalf of His children. So He allows it. So Hashem allows him to speak in a harsh manner. The angel speaks in a harsh manner to G-d. How? Because he's speaking about His kids. Speaking about His kids. It's like, for example, Somebody is a very respected, you know, king or president or whatever successful person, obviously doesn't take, you know, anybody else's craziness. He likes certain things done the way he likes them done, and nobody tells him what to do.
1:56:10And all of a sudden, somebody comes and starts yelling at him. And everybody's like, whoa, whoa, whoa, she's going to kill this person. She's going to rip this guy's head off. And all they see, he's yelling at him. And everybody's like, wow, how is he not punching him in the face? How is he not killing this guy? How is he not getting one of his snipers to shoot him down? He's just taking this guy's yelling and screaming. And they get closer and closer and closer and closer and closer. And what do they hear? They start hearing the conversation. the guy's saying: "You're irresponsible! I can't believe you did it! I can't believe it! Terrible! You should be ashamed of yourself!" And they're even more in doubt: "I can't believe it! How is he allowing this guy to call him irresponsible? Terrible! You should be ashamed of yourself!" He never lets anybody talk to him that way. And they get closer and closer and closer, and they say: "Irresponsible to leave your son in the car! He almost died! I had to save him!" Ah, he's yelling at him because... The father didn't take care of his son. The father was not merciful to his son. The father... That's why he's listening to him. Because he cares about his son. So he cares about him. You love my son. I love you. So the angel, Gavriel, says, speaks...
1:57:26tough at times, not obviously not all the time. It's not a gangster, but the point is that the angels have much more of an opinion than we would think. They just get punished differently. of the sources that you have, that is, when Hashem in creation says, "Let us create man in our image," what does it mean "let us create man in our image"? The Gemara says that a king, and it's the way of a king to show, you know, to have consultants, not because he needs their opinion but rather it's the way of a king. So, He consulted with the angels. If the angel was just a robot saying "yes, no, yes, no, yes, no," then... ...then what is He consulting with? There's nothing to consult. But no, each one had an opinion, and there were actually a couple that said that He shouldn't bring man to the world because they would sin. In fact, there was a whole slew of them that said no. He destroyed all of them. Then He created another group of angels. They also said no. He destroyed all of them. He created another group of angels. They said, listen, weren't the first group right? What did they say that was really wrong? Humans really are going to sin. So it's a whole thing. The point being is, He created man. And then after He created man, the same third group of angels said, oh, you know what? Maybe the first group was right because look, they're sinning. Hashem says, you would sin also if you were in the world that they were in.
1:58:56so this angel said, "No, no, we think we would be okay." So He sent them. He sent those angels to the world. That's the, uh, the two angels that turned into the Nephilim. So, the point being is, we see from there that angels do have opinions. They also get punished. Those few angels that became the Nephilim are in a special place called Azazel, getting punished. But you know, there are whole teachings in regards to that too. All right, I'll never fall for the... I'll never fall from the Noahide path. I've been following you for a couple of years. I feel guilty for not learning as much as I should. I am that single father with full custody who messaged you before, looking for a Noahide community. Well, Baruch Hashem, many, many messages have come in. I don't remember everybody's messages, but I think the last count... was like over half a million messages in the last 12 months. So you could just do the math of what that averages out per day. So I don't remember all the messages, but I can tell you that there are plenty of people that are trying to cater to the non-Jewish world, to the Noahide world. But with all due respect to everybody that's trying to cater to them, I don't think it's really possible to do that in a...
2:00:24for a lot of different reasons. Many times the Noahides want Judaism but "light," so they want a prayer book, they want a certain study regimen, they want a yeshiva, they want holidays. In essence, they want Judaism, just "light," and that's not allowed. That's not Noahide. But what the people that are trying to create is typically that; it's like a lighter version of Judaism. so there is no Noahide community that I'm familiar with, and the ones that do exist, or whatever versions of ours, are usually just small groups of people here and there. Typically, they are led by individuals who are really after people's money more than they are after people's neshamot, because if those rabbis really were looking to do the will of Hashem, they wouldn't even start a Noahide community because they have a responsibility for Jews before they have a responsibility for Noahides. And that's a halacha. So Hashem does not want the Noahides to have communities. He wants each person to do what they need to do to be a righteous Noahide, to learn what they need to learn. If you happen to be fortunate enough to have
2:01:44Friends and family that are on the same boat as you, living next to you, by all means. But for the Noahides to start having structure definitely will lead to problems. Why? Because they're getting their learning from the Jews and they're trying to emulate and follow the Jews, and it's only a matter of time before they start acting like Jews to the point where they're actually no longer Noahides that are righteous because they're creating things that are forbidden. you know, there are a lot of things that are forbidden for Noachides to learn, but many Noachides specifically want to learn those things. There are many things that are forbidden for Noachides, but Noachides specifically want to do those things, like observing Shabbat and all types of things like that. So that's the thing. I always tell people, listen, if you like the mitzvot, if you like the Torah, do whatever you can to be a Jew. That's it. Stop lying to yourself and thinking that you can remain a righteous Noachide. In fact, It's a conversation that I had with one of my long-time students just a couple of weeks ago where he came back. He's been with me for a while. A few years ago, I told him that he needs to convert to Judaism. And he said, "Yeah, but listen, I could help so many Noachides. I could do so much good in the Noachide world. Jews already have leaders. Jews already have this. Jews already have that." And I tried to explain to him that this is a mistake.
2:03:07uh, his logic is mistaken. He should, uh, uh, become a Jew. But again, I'm not here to convince anybody. If you just ask me for advice, I'll give it to you. Um, but, uh, anyway, he didn't listen to me. Maybe three years have passed, and I guess he just came back to his senses. Even though we've been in touch this whole time, apparently something happened, and he came back to his senses. He realized that he made a mistake that cost him a few years of his life and almost cost him his life. which is that he realized that, wait, being a Noahide, it's not just about me; it's about my wife, kids, descendants, everything. So now, the truth is that there is no Noahide community, and there will not be a Noahide community anytime soon that's kosher because, like I told you, it's always going to have issues. You're going to be forced to do a lot of things that are going to put you and your Noahide status of righteousness in jeopardy, such as you're going to have kids, and those kids will have to go to school at some point. wife, kids, descendants, everything. So now, the truth is that there is no Noahide community, and there will not be a Noahide community anytime soon that's kosher because, like I told you, it's always going to have issues. You're going to be forced to do a lot of things that are going to put you and your Noahide status of righteousness in jeopardy, such as you're going to have kids, and those kids will have to go to school at some point.
2:04:13Okay, now, yeah, of course, homeschooling is fantastic for those that can actually do it, but most people can't do it. So they have to send their kids to school. And what are those kids gonna learn in school, in kindergarten, in junior high school? And what are they gonna learn? They're gonna learn Halloween, Christmas, Kwanzaa, I don't know, homosexuality, pedophilia, you know, Batman and Robin. They're gonna learn that stuff. So even though you may be teaching them about God and all that other stuff, still, they're gonna have friends that celebrate all types of idolatrous holidays. gonna learn Christmas, Kwanzaa, I don't know, homosexuality, pedophilia, you know, Batman and Robin. They're gonna learn that stuff. So even though you may be teaching them about God and all that other stuff, still, they're gonna have friends that celebrate all types of idolatrous holidays. they're gonna want a tree on Christmas, they're gonna want a pumpkin on Halloween, they're gonna want bunnies with chocolate eggs on Easter. They're gonna want all that stuff, not because they believe in your kind of idolatry, but because they want to be like their friends. So, what are you going to keep telling them? No, every year? Good luck with that. good luck with that and staying married because even the best spouse in the world is gonna break when their kid starts crying that they can't have this toy because it's not kosher according to the rabbi. So, the reality is that people need to understand that being a Noahide is not just a decision for yourself.
2:05:26it's a decision for everything that happens in your life from this point forward, with your kids, with their kids, with their kids' kids, and so on. And that's why I say to people that to be a righteous Noachide is a lot more difficult, a lot more difficult than people can think. And I personally think that it's much easier to deal with the difficulties of being a Jew and it is much more worth it to deal with the difficulties of being a Jew than to deal with the difficulties of being a Noachide. Because at least with the difficulties of being a Jew, there's a certain sense of community, even if you don't necessarily live in the biggest community. There's a certain, you know, structure to a certain extent. There is an order. There's a lot more to it. and quite frankly, it's definitely something that has more stability, even though we get in trouble too. Everybody gets in trouble, but being a Noachide is not as easy as people think. So when this guy realized that his kid is going to want all of these things, and he's either going to have to learn how to say no every second word for the rest of his life,
2:06:40or, you know, he's gonna have to abandon ship or he's gonna have to convert. You know, he realized he made a mistake and You know, he thought that he was going to be the Superman of the Noahide world, only to realize that you have to first save yourself, then worry about the world. So, Noahide communities, with all due respect to all those that are trying to do it, quite frankly, from the ones that I've seen, the organizations that I've seen try it, they're not doing the right thing by the community; they're simply creating a new religion. uh, they're giving people sedarim, they're giving people uh, all types of things that are not supposed to be part of it. They're in essence giving you a Judaism light version, uh, and it's not supposed to be that. It's not supposed to be that. I'm not saying you can't be a Noahide. Certainly, there are Noahides that are good Noahides and should remain Noahides, and there's no problem. But you cannot expect the, uh, the, uh, this the structure that you want because there is no unity among the Noahides like there is among the Jews. I'm not talking about unity as far as opinion. Certainly, you can find like-minded people, but Jews in general, even if we have a, uh, uh, uh, we disagree
2:07:53even if we disagree bitterly about something, the second there is a test in the world, a decree in the world, some type of holocaust of some kind, some type of government decree, all of a sudden, we forget about everything and we unite. Why? Because spiritually we're connected whether we like it or not. None of that exists in the world of Noachides. There is no spiritual connection between one Noachide and another. Even if they like each other and they're friends with each other for a thousand years. There is no connection between the nations, even amongst each other. Even if it's an Arab with an Arab or a Christian with a Christian. One Christian is from Japan, another one is from China, another one is from France. There's no connection among them. There's no unity among the Goyim. So that's the thing. People are trying to create a non-Jewish version of Judaism. And if it was possible, and if it was something that was desirable by Hashem, then certainly this is something that the Sages would have taught.
2:08:59But if they didn't teach that, certainly this is not something that is desired by Hashem. The Noahide has an obligation to serve Hashem to the best of his ability and follow the Noahide laws. One of the big objectives of the Noahide is also to help the Jews serve Hashem because the better the Jews serve Hashem, the better those Jews can teach the Noahides. But most Noahides today that you see online and being very vocal are really lying to themselves. They're lying to themselves by simply pretending that they're a Jewish version of a Noahide or all types of other things. the better those Jews can teach the Noahides. But most Noahides today that you see online and being very vocal are really lying to themselves. They're lying to themselves by simply pretending that they're a Jewish version of a Noahide or all types of other things. And my The reason why I mention this is because I'm seeing that this problem is growing not because of what the people want but rather because of how they're being misled by false leaders that are after their pockets. These groups, you know, are writing all these books and having all of these forums for Noahides because they figure, listen, there is
2:10:12let's say, at best, there are 20 million Jews in the world that we know of, whereas non-Jews number almost 8 billion. So they figure, according to their logic and math, even if I get 20 million Noahides, 200 million Noahides, it's an entirely new nation. So there's a lot of money involved. Never, ever learn. Torah from someone whose priority number one is money is problematic. Although money is necessary for people to do what they do, to do outreach, to provide certain services, the second it becomes the number one priority, that means that God is not, and that cannot be. That cannot be. God is always one. Of course, they can tell you that God is one. But I can tell you that's not possible for God to be one in their mind. Why? Because according to halacha, they're not allowed to do what they're doing if they're Jews. A Jew is not allowed to teach a Noahide if there's another Jew that needs to learn. Meaning, before you take time to address the problem of a Noahide, you have to make sure that there's no Jew that has an issue that you need to deal with.
2:11:29Even more so when it comes to Torah. So you're not allowed to teach a group of Noahides, even if there are 20,000 Noahides, and there's one Jew that wants to learn. The 20,000 Noahides are willing to pay you $1,000 a ticket. That means they can make a few million dollars for that event. The Jew doesn't want to pay you a dollar. have to go and teach that Jew. That's what the Torah says; that's what HaKadosh Baruch Hu says. This means that all of these people that have these Noahide organizations and they focus on Noahides as their gig—that's a problem, that's a very serious problem. Now, if you help Noahides... like what we do, what Rabbi Mizrahi does and other rabbis do, which is, you know, as something that is also done, meaning you're helping the Jews and fulfilling your obligation, and when possible, you also help the Noahides without jeopardizing your responsibility of helping the Jew, then you can do that, no problem. And I have plenty of Noahide students that have been with me for years and that we try to do our best to help them, some to help them convert,
2:12:36some to help them just have decent lives, whatever the case is. That's not a problem. That's not a problem. And I always try to encourage people to convert because I think it's simply a better life for those that are able to do it. But don't let anybody fool you into thinking that there is permission for me or for any rabbi on planet Earth to make Noahides a priority over Jews. There's no permission whatsoever. Which means that by default, according to the Torah, anyone who does it is making a mistake. It's making a mistake. So I know the Noahide communities want this, but again, you have to decide what's more important to you: the word of God or the word of your preference. Do whatever you prefer. So I know it's hard to be alone. People want communities. People want to be part of something. It's definitely not an easy thing to be in the position of a new Jew, a new convert, a new Noahide. It's not easy at all. But if a person wants it badly enough, is going to learn enough, do enough, eventually Hashem is going to open up the doors.
2:13:46We have no permission to force the door and break it down. We have no permission to do it. We do our best. We learn as much as possible. We do as much as possible. We're charitable. We do chesed. We make changes in our life. And eventually, when Hashem sees we've done enough and it's time, He opens the door for us, whatever that door is. But the problem is that people feel like they should just break down the door to the House of God and simply make decisions for Him, telling Him how to run His house. And unfortunately, sometimes they have rabbis helping them. How do you know how much cruelty you should exercise until you are no longer being kind? Cruelty, cruelty is not something that you're allowed to exercise unless it's an enemy of Hashem, and it's only under certain circumstances. Generally speaking, I would say most people, if you don't know how much to do something like that, don't do it at all. Just simply ignore the situation altogether. Leave it. Don't bother.
2:14:51with such people. It's better for people to let professionals do it rather than doing it themselves. But again, every case has to be evaluated on its own. There's no one-size-fits-all. especially when it comes to dealing with people. Because each person has a different face, different ideas, and different perspectives. So you have to deal with each person according to where he stands. That's a Christian concept, that Satan is a rebelling fallen angel. Christians have all types of concepts. I don't care about them. They're idol worshipers, so they create all types of things that are offshoots of Judaism. Their whole religion is an offshoot of Judaism that they distorted. Are we obligated to give tzedakah to a person that has all kinds of good and expensive stuff?
2:16:02He says that he needs money for tuition and computers for his kids. He and his kids were expensive. No, you don't have to give tzedakah to people like that at all. And in fact, you should not. You should not give people tzedakah when they are so lavish with their money. You give tzedakah to needy people. You give tzedakah to publicize Torah. You give tzedakah to where it's needed, not to where it's wanted. Unfortunately, today there are a bunch of people that are just leeches that like to live off of the public. And it's very easy to do so today because you could just join a bunch of different groups on the internet and just send requests to people to help and pretend like you're some miserable person. And when there's literally millions of people that a person can reach each day. Surely, there are going to be some people who are naive and kind enough to say, "Okay, you know what, I'll send you $10, I'll send you $5, I'll send you $20, I'll send you $50." The guy can make a big living out of it, probably make more money than a regular job. But, of course, this is not the way to live. This is not a productive way of living. This is hustling that is against the way of Hashem.
2:17:09Next, Rabbi, is someone allowed to use an electric breast pump to feed their newborn on Shabbat? No. What a person needs to do is one of two things. One, they could simply pump before Shabbat and fill up some bottles, put them in the fridge or freezer, and that way she's not going to need to do anything on Shabbat. on Shabbat, that's the ideal way to do things. Or there's a manual pump, but not electric. Electric is problematic unless the baby's life is at risk. You know, at that point, everything is allowed if the baby's life is at risk. But under normal circumstances, if the baby is healthy and everything is okay, no, it's not allowed.
2:18:11How do you avoid being cruel to yourself, especially when doing teshuva? There's no mitzvah of looking down at yourself and thinking that you're a loser or being too hard on yourself, especially since many times it could lead a person to destroy his confidence. If a person doesn't have confidence, then he's not going to have the inspiration to continue building and growing. there's no mitzvah of looking down at yourself and thinking that you're a loser or being too hard on yourself, especially since many times it could lead a person to destroy his confidence. If a person doesn't have confidence, then he's not going to have the inspiration to continue building and growing because he could easily get to a point of losing hope. So it's very important for a person to focus more on the present in order to have a better future than to focus on the past that he can't change. Now, of course, there are certain things in the past that are still present, meaning the person's flawed character traits. Although they caused him more problems in the past, if he hasn't overcome them, they're still present. So he has to overcome those things. But as far as the things that he can't do anything about,
2:19:11whatever crimes against men or God that he did in the past that he can't do anything about, he shouldn't spend so much time feeling sorry for himself. He has to simply make sure that it doesn't happen again, and the only way that he can do that is by learning Torah, doing the mitzvot that he's responsible for, she's responsible for, and literally perfecting themselves to the best of their ability, so that when the tests come again, the same ones that he had in the past, he has enough tools and strength to overcome it. Why did Hashem ask Avraham about Sarah laughing and not ask Sarah directly? I explained it to the Rav Reuven Schur, because he was in essence telling Avraham that... uh, about why he's upset with, uh, um, okay, I think that, uh, I think that there are enough questions the rest of them, I see that I've already answered. Um, yeah, okay, uh, reminder for everybody, we have, um, you know, the, uh, event in New York is supposed to happen a month from now, approximately a month from now. Anyone who wants to arrange
2:20:27a group of people to come to a shul, to an office, a house, whatever, wants to arrange a shiur, you can send us a message to events@bhtorah.org, events@bhtorah.org. If you can't remember the email, just send me a message on WhatsApp and I'll give you the email. and we could arrange something. A lot of people have been asking me about coming to New York for a long time, so finally, Baruch Hashem, we're coming, but we obviously want to make sure that we're booked as much as possible to have as much chizuk as possible. So anyone that can do something, do it. Other than that, thank you very much for learning with me at the shul. If you want to support all the things that we do, Baruch Hashem, you can go to bhtorah.org. If you want to sponsor an avrech, an avreich kollel, that's on bezatashem.org. If you want to get yourself some USBs, either for yourself or to distribute, that's also on one of the websites, bhq.org. So there are a lot of different opportunities to help, to contribute, to learn. And b'ezrat Hashem, na'aseh v'natzliach. Thank you very much for learning with me. Shabbat Shalom, Shabbat Mevorach to everybody. Kol Tuv.