OTD Rabbis, MIKVEH, Female Artist, Should I Convert or Remain A Noahide? - STUMPTHE RABBI (96)
Rabbi Yaron Reuven explains that when scholars neglect Torah study, they set a bad example for the community, leading to moral decay. Those without strong rabbinical guidance are vulnerable to sin and may even abandon their faith. Conversely, rabbis who prioritize Torah study and maintain ethical conduct inspire their followers and strengthen the community. It is essential to have a rabbi who guides and supports spiritual growth, rather than seeking out those who offer convenience or material benefits. https://www.tikkunhabrit.live TIKKUN HaBRIT The Movie: THE MOST IMPORTANT FILM IN HISTORY!!! PRAYERS ARE NOT ENOUGH FOR THE TIKKUN HABRIT EPIDEMIC SO WE MADE A MOVIE YOU CAN BE PARTNER IN!! To Support our KIRUV and Torah Teachings work please DONATE at www.BeEzratHaShem.org If you'd like to invite Rabbi Yaron Reuven to give a lecture at your synagogue, home or office please email Info@BeEzratHaShem.org Rabbi Reuven is based out of Florida but travels to give lectures to different groups. Join one of our interactive "Interesting Torah" Whatsapp groups to get daily updates and short Torah clips that can uplift your day by texting 1.917.468.2324 or +91 93236 69880 Available on Apple iTunes Store, Amazon App Store and Android Play Store https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.beezrathashem GOOGLE App https://apps.apple.com/us/app/beezrat-hashem/id1279094981?uo=4 APPLE App https://www.amazon.com/Hosttec-Solutions-BeEzrat-HaShem/dp/B07QST1294/ AMAZON App Click here https://soundcloud.com/yaronreuven/sets/daily-chidush To Listen to our very popular "Daily Chidush" short audio series on SOUNDCLOUD or the Podcast Channel at https://beezrathashem.jewishpodcasts.org Born in Netanya, Israel, Rabbi Yaron Reuven began his American Dream as a little boy, when his family immigrated to the United States. He went from a newspaper boy at the age of 10, to a well-known self-made Wall Street multimillionaire by the age of 23. During his time in Wall Street, he owned his own private brokerage firm, a hedge fund, and an international insurance agency. He was featured on CNBC, Bloomberg and Chinese NDTV due to his success in the financial industry. At age 26 he faced a 7-year battle for his life when a simple surgery went wrong. From that moment his life would never be the same. This moment marked the start of a series of miraculous events and an exciting pursuit of truth, ultimately resulting in Rabbi Reuven renouncing his lofty position and success in Wall Street, after 16 years, to become a full-time KIRUV rabbi. His Teshuva story is sure to catch the heart of every listener. Rabbi Reuven’s shiurim are in English and Hebrew. His classes are focused on spreading the truth and divinity of the Torah through MUSSAR, scientific proofs, and many other methods to reach each individual listener. Rabbi Reuven is the leading educator on the topic of wasting seed in the English language with over 30 hrs of content published online. Rabbi Yaron Reuven is a proud member of the Igud HaRabbonim (The Rabbinical Alliance of America), a national rabbinic organization founded in 1942. Today, our 900+ members are congregational leaders, religious teachers, chaplains, heads of Jewish organizations and communal leaders united in their commitment to traditional Orthodox Judaism. For more information please visit: https://rabbinicalalliance.org/ #OTDRabbis #Mikveh #FemaleArtist #ConvertOrRemainNoahide #StumpTheRabbi #Judaism #Jewish #RabbiYaronReuven #OrthodoxJudaism #JewishWisdom #Chizuk #Shiur #Torah #Divine #Wisdom #Inspiration
Transcript
0:14We are back here on our Wednesday night Stump the Rabbi, where after a little bit of Divrei Torah and Chizuk, you guys will ask some questions and HaKadosh Baruch Hu will give us some answers. Tonight you will go for a Refuah Shlema, for Rabbanit Levana bat Sarah, Rabbanit Sarah bat Anat, Moshiach ben Avigail v'Avraham, Orit bat Ilana, David ben Nesria, Doris bat Zhora, Talia bat Zara, Yitro ben Avraham, and also Rav Efraim ben Shulamit. And also for a Hatzlacha Rabah. Moshiach ben Avigail v'Avraham, Orit bat Ilana, David ben Nesria, Doris bat Zohra, Talia bat Sarah, Yitro ben Avraham, and also Rav Efraim ben Shulamit. And also for a Hatzlacha Rabah. and Zivug Hagun for Netanel Yosef ben Avraham and Reuven Chaim ben Palaparel. And also for Alex ben Noach, Joshua ben Noach, Oshri ben Doris, Gabi ben Doris, Elad ben Doris, David ben Nesria, Yitro ben Avraham, Shaul ben Farzaneh, Marsha bat Julie, Ayla bat Marsha, Samuel ben Marsha, Cephas ben Marsha, Alexander ben Marsha,
1:38and all of Am Yisrael and all of the righteous Noahides that are helping us do what we're trying to do to help the world see the light, see the Kedusha of the Torah, see that the only good way that exists in this world is the Torah way and to really tried to bring light to the nations, which obviously starts with Am Yisrael and spreads to the rest of the nations. Now, for anyone who watched last night's shiur, we began this year talking about the issue that's happening with Asher Meza and his rabbi, Kalkowski, and also his employee, Moshe Otero, how they're spreading a lot of rumors and nonsense, and we've offered them lots of money as a bounty to at least provide some type of evidence for all of these rumors they continue to spread.
2:42There's, there's, I believe, three families he converted here in South Florida that, at the end of the day, couldn't afford the conversion. And he refused to give them the certificates. Who is he? Who is he? The Beit Din or Yaron? Yaron. So this you know for a fact you told them? No, no, okay. Well, yes, people told me about the story, you know. Wait, so Yaron gives the certificate? I thought the Beit Din, the... I don't know the insides of the story. You know what I'm saying? I'm just telling you what I heard from reputable people. That's it. Now, on that basis, by the simple fact that I'm not saying it's a fact, I'm just telling you that this is what I heard. My issue with you is not so much the conversion amount of money you charge or make out of them, be it $1,000 or $2,000, even if you hold their certificate of conversion for extended periods of two to three years to make sure they don't leave your shul. I know that trick as well, but that's not the point. I'm glad you're involved in conversion and you're helping bring more Jews that are out there, even though at a very hefty amount. Now, I'm sure people out there who have gone through your program will probably speak up, and I welcome people to let the truth be known. Let the truth be known, not this gimmick of "I'll give you four hundred thousand dollars if you can bring up and show a check."
4:03Come on, Yaron. We know how the conversion business is all about and how it works. My gosh, I used to work with Rabbi Lerner. I know how it's done. I know how rabbis like yourself will come and speak to the Beit Din and get the kickbacks and get all of the goodies under the table, as it were, and then say, "Oh, I'm not making any money." Come on, I know the tricks. I know the trade. I know what you've gone through. This is why. I have gone and said, you know what? We've got a heter to gear them without making a penny. Now, good for you. You may have a big donor, someone that's underwriting these conversions. And if that's the case, that's your call. But I still get calls from people complaining of the $10,000 level, of the $2,000 level. You know, there's different levels. You're willing to negotiate. You're like a used car salesman. Can't get $10,000? I'll get $5,000. Can't get $5,000? I'll get $2,000. Can't get $2,000? Give me $1,000. I'll prolong your conversion and hold on to the papers. Now tell me you didn't do that. When I just stated information that I was told by many other people that his program charges at least $10,000 per person. Whether he keeps the money or the court does, I don't care. But for this, the sensitive little giant is going to get all his feathers ruffled, right? And that number is nothing new. $10,000 is a going rate for most of these online rabbis. And yes, local courts, when you live in a community, would charge you perhaps up to $2,000.
5:16But for this online program or these types of online programs, this is the standard—$10,000. And of course, they haven't provided any evidence. All they do is just add more rumors. Like today, I came out with another video saying that now he has some Chabad rabbi who told him the story about how I withheld the conversion papers from three different families that I converted here in Florida. I'm more than happy to see the evidence and write the check because no, it doesn't exist. And the two simple proofs are, number one, I don't do such things. I don't charge for conversion. As I said 50 times already, that the beit din charges, and apparently Asher doesn't know how to read. because we've already made two, three, four clips about this and we put on the screen that the beit dins that we've used throughout all of the years
6:18have never charged more than $2,000. So, I'm not really understanding why he just doesn't seem to get that point. He still insists on $10,000, and he insists it's either me getting the money or now he changed it to even if I don't get the money and I just get a kickback, but it's still $10,000. It's at least $10,000. $10,000. The $10,000 level. $10,000. The $10,000. $10,000. The $10,000. $10,000 to $20,000. $10,000. $10,000. Ah, so, you know, we've again provided this information over and over again. But the reason I mentioned it today again is because one of the things that we added to the video after last night's lecture, the live feed, we added, you know, the YouTube feed and the one that's on our app, B'ezrat Hashem, and in there we added different footage. Different footage, which the footage was of these people talking, you know, without anyone telling them what to say. These people talking about themselves. And anyone that watched that video, you know, may actually have gotten a heart attack when they saw that the rabbi of Asher Meza is a mechallel Shabbat.
7:37is a person that, you know, he openly and obnoxiously admits that he watches television on Shabbat, and if that's not enough, he takes his family to, you know, completely forbidden events on Shabbat to go watch movies at some event, at some... festival or something of movies, scary movies, and he does this on Shabbat. Good evening, everybody. I'm on my way home from Monster Bash Under the Stars, which was in Vandergrift, Pennsylvania. We, uh, we enjoyed ourselves, had a nice Shabbos, davened, I wore my shtreimel and my bekeshe. there at the campsite most of the day until it got too hot, changed back into a t-shirt but kept my Shabbos pants on, took a nap, and enjoyed. We walked around a little bit in the drive-in, talking to people who were also camped out there enjoying themselves at the Monster Bash program, including what we showed on the video. Chris Yeaworth and we talked about "The Blob," and we had some lawn chairs and a little table.
8:59And we sat and we had Kiddush and we brought some amazing meals. So we were able to have cholent and kugel. So not only are they going to watch television on Shabbat, or a big screen on Shabbat, which is obviously forbidden for Jews, but aside from that, if that's not bad enough, he even says, He knows it's wrong, but he does it anyway because he thinks it's okay, and it's wrong, but it's okay. And if that's not bad enough, he does it with his shtreimel. So, you know, yeah, maybe it's not the right thing to do. But I'm not, I'm not, and the truth is I didn't wear white socks. I got, I got the peiyos that are long and was wearing Crocs. But still, with a shtreimel in the back of the shirt, one of the light back of the shirt. With his shtreimel and the Hasidic garb, meaning that it's not only a Chilul Shabbat or the Oneg Shabbat, but aside from that, it's a Chilul Hashem. It's a desecration of Hashem's name. Now, and this is the Rabbi of Asher Meza. This is the Rabbi of Asher Meza. Of course, the apple doesn't fall far from the tree.
10:19uh, you know, although I don't remember ever hearing Asher Meza saying that he watches movies on Shabbat, I do know that he did say in the past that he watches movies and all types of other things that are forbidden for kosher Jews. But nonetheless, this is really interesting. Why is this really interesting? The question is, how does a rabbi go off the derech? I'll admit that I am a rasha and I have a lot of problems in my life, but... To say I'm not a rabbi, I don't know, I mean, rabbi is an English word, you know, you want to say I'm not a rabbi, I'm not a rav, I'm not a rabbi, Conservative or Reform, you can also spell reish aleph beit. I'm at least like them, you know, I work as a rabbi, that's what I do professionally. How does a rabbi go off the derech? Because, of course, Kolakowski admits that his Rosh Yeshiva many years ago told him it's forbidden to watch television on Shabbat. I mean, quite frankly, the Steipler Gaon said that television is avodah zara. So watching any of these movies, even during the week, is forbidden. That's a kal vachomer. But anyway, the question is, how does a rabbi...
11:39And we're not talking about a person that used to be a rabbi. This is apparently a person that has a kehillah, has a community somewhere in one of the chambers of Gehenom. And he has a kehillah and he desecrates Shabbat regularly, like without really feeling... too upset about it, in fact, publicizing it. And if that's not bad enough, he says that he believes that I also violate Shabbat and watch television on Shabbat, and Rabbi Mizrachi somehow got into this conversation, and he also watches television on Shabbat, according to Kalkowski, because he figures that if he is surrounding himself and practically swimming in tumah and filth, everybody else must be doing it also. I admit, like my Rashi always says, it's not the right thing to do, to sit and watch a movie on Shabbos. But the self goes off, I wasn't manipulating the projector. I was there. So there's two ways to look at it. You think... you think
12:55To be honest, you think Yossi Mizrachi doesn't watch movies on Shabbos? You don't think he leaves the TV on? I can tell you worse things about Yossi Mizrachi, but it's none of your business. You think Yaron Reuven doesn't leave the TV on before Shabbos? I'm sure he does. He probably has a room somewhere. He leaves it on. The difference is I'm honest about it. And I'm not trying to hide who I am. So again, spreading more... you know, rumors and all types of nonsense. I mean, obviously, we don't watch TV at all. Needless to say, we don't watch TV on Shabbat. But the point being is, how does a rabbi, you have three in this case, technically, you have Kligowski, okay, watching television on Shabbat regularly, going and taking his, you know, so-called frum family, to movie events and the like on Shabbat and actually publicizing it, telling people that he's doing it even though he knows it's wrong. This was actually a clip that we had, along with several others, in last night's video. If you simply watch those, we'll add it to tonight's as well. On top of that, he is spreading false rumors
14:10And of course, his talmid, or two talmidim, Meza and the other garbage pail kid, Otero, also feel very confident about spreading false rumors and creating stories of that nature. The question is here, Rabotai, how does such a thing happen? Because surely when these people started becoming religious, Asher converted to Judaism, And if you look at his old videos, he has peyot and he looks quite a bit different, he talks quite a bit differently. Things have changed over the years for Asher. It's quite sad to see the steady decline that has happened over the years for Asher. Otero I don't know very much about other than the fact that it seems like he is a little bit senile and doesn't know how to read. But aside from that, I don't really know very much about him. But the point is that I'm sure that Otero used to be more religious, perhaps when he was younger. I'm not sure if he's a convert or a Baal Teshuva or if he was always frum. It doesn't really make much of a difference. But I'm almost certain that at some point he was more religious.
15:31And I'm absolutely certain that Kolkowski, you know, when he went to yeshiva, he was at least, you know, portraying a more religious person. I mean, he says he's the one that gave semicha to Asher Meza, even though his semicha, he says himself, his semicha is worthless. Let's say a very interesting thing. You know, you give somebody something that's worthless, and why did you give it to them? The semicha that I gave to my friend Rav Asher Meza, and I appreciate that Rabbi Mordechai here calls him Rabbi. On that account, I want to note one thing first: Rabbi Meza had semicha before he knew me. Why would I give semicha? My semicha really isn't worth anything. I'll be honest, I'm just a regular guy I happen to be a rabbi in a shul, head semicha, whatever. My semicha really isn't worth that much. You know, you're not going to be able to join the RCA with my semicha. You're probably not going to get a pitur from the Israeli army if you make aliyah. Anyway, my point is that how does the group here, you know, how does the group here that makes up rumors, at least one of them, really the leader among them as far as, let's say,
16:53the tolon pole here, or the guy that gave them the semicha, desecrates Shabbat, desecrates Hashem's name, walks around with Chassidic garb while he's pretty much doing all of this. How does that happen? How does somebody fall off so badly? I mean, it's really a sad story. To be honest with you, it's just a sad reality And then the question is, how does such a thing happen? And I have a theory. I have a theory that has, obviously, it's based on Da'at Torah, and that's what we'll talk about a little bit today, because quite frankly, I mean, we've seen certain things like this in the Torah. We've seen stories in the Gemara where people completely go off. You know, if you're looking at the Gemara, you have Elisha ben Avuya, who was one of the rabbis of Rabbi Meir Baal HaNes. uh you know he was so holy at some point that he was one of the four people that was privy to see something called the Pardes. This is, you know, part of the mystical teachings of the Gemara, where one of them, being Elisha, was able to see something called the Pardes, and he got confused, to say the least, after he saw it and became a heretic, desecrating
18:20uh, Shabbat desecrating, uh, Hashem's name, and committing a lot of different crimes, uh, while Rabbi Akiva, for example, also saw the Pardes and actually became better for it. So we see that holiness affects different people in different ways if it's not addressed or dealt with the right way. But we've seen Elisha went off the derech. Bottom line, we also have a Kohen... a Kohen Gadol that went off the derech after being a Kohen for decades. So he went off the derech and became a complete apikores. And the Mishnah in Pirkei Avot says, this is one of the examples we use that a person should never trust themselves until the day they die. Meaning you should always do teshuva, you should always work on yourself, you should always do what needs to be done as if you're a brand new Baal teshuva, as if you're literally meeting Hashem for the first time and you're excited. uh so we've seen someone that, uh, was not only religious, was the Kohen, the Kohen Gadol, uh, you know, and he goes off the derech. So we've seen that. We've also seen the entire nation, the entire nation of Israel. Obviously, it's quite a few times in the, uh, in it. We, uh, see, uh, disaster after disaster, uh, happen to Israel, and this is the very same...
19:45A nation that is called Dor HaDe'ah, the generation of knowledge, the generation that saw the words of Hashem and not just heard them. The generation that saw Hashem open up the seven heavens and show them that He is the only one, that there is no other God. You know that each one of them had prophecy that is even greater than the prophecy of Yechezkel. And some were obviously even greater, like Moshe Rabbeinu, the prophet of all prophets. But even the lowliest among them had prophecy higher than Yechezkel. So, you see, this very same generation, we can't even comprehend how holy they were. They reached the highest level of holiness in the history of Am Yisrael, the 49th level of holiness. It's literally near perfection. They received the Torah. They saw miracles that are beyond our comprehension. They were extraordinarily holy, but yet you see a week, while Moshe Rabbeinu is at Har Sinai, they have a part of them go and worship the egel.
21:00you know, the Golden Calf. Then you see, after this whole disaster is dealt with, Moshe Rabbeinu kills a few thousand people and gets the Torah all over again. You see, a week later, you have Tzelofchad, the first Mechalel Shabbat in history. That's a great Shabbat. Then you have, obviously, Korach and his Adat. And then you also have what we're going to be reading next week, which is Parashat Balak. and uh Parashat Balak, we see something extraordinary where the entire nation, this holy nation, this nation that just received the Torah, this nation that, as the pasuk says in Chapter 25 of Parashat Balak in the Book of Numbers, "Israel settled in Shittim." And the people began to commit harlotry with the daughters of Moab. It's like saying, you have a Chafetz Chaim, a Rabbi Ovadia, a Rabbi Elyashiv, a Rabbi Akiva, a Rabbi Meir Baal Hanes, and these Tzadikim, they went to some prostitution house. Is anybody really going to believe such a thing if you heard a story? No, obviously. These are holy people. They don't have such lives. But here we have...
22:26the generation, the generation of knowledge, fell to a horrible level. We're not talking about, okay, you know, one time the guy messed up, he, uh, you know, carried on Shabbat outside of the Eruv or something, or he, uh, touched or even if he watched TV on Shabbos. We're not talking about that. We're talking about, they went and they started worshipping idols in order to commit harlotry with the non-Jewish women of Moab. I mean, it simply doesn't get much worse than this. It simply doesn't get much worse than this. How does such a thing happen? How does such a thing happen? How do the three rabbis here making videos and apparently they're, you know, telling the world that they're teaching them something that's of value, teaching them to become Jews, teaching them to, I don't know, it seems more like they're teaching them to become Christians. But at least they portray themselves as if they're teaching Torah and they're teaching good things. And how does that happen that you just go off completely? Well, let's see. The Sefer Torat Moshe,
23:45which is a commentary on the Torah by the Chatam Sofer. He comments on this pasuk in Parashat Balak. He says, this verse is very interesting. Why do you have Am Yisrael go from their lofty, holy level to making just a disaster of disasters. Idol worship, then immorality, you know, being intimate with non-Jews. I mean, it's just a disaster. But after that, there's a very good thing that happened, which is that Hashem, you know, stops the plague of killing. Pretty much, He started, He simply decided to kill all of Am Yisrael. He gave a plague; He put a plague into the world. literally started killing Am Yisrael like flies. Then Pinchas, who becomes Eliyahu, goes and kills the biggest desecrator of Hashem's name, a person by the name of Zimri, the head of the Shimon tribe, and also the filthy woman that was with him, Kozbi. He kills them while they're in the act.
24:59And shows it to all of the people, and Hashem says because he was zealous for My sake, he took vengeance in My name, he saved all of Am Yisrael. If it wasn't for Pinchas, Hashem would have destroyed all of Am Yisrael. So here we have Hashem sees a disaster, simply, without any warning, decides to destroy Am Yisrael, and then, Baruch Hashem, we have a Pinchas, save the day, save practically eternity for all of Am Yisrael. And for that, he gets blessed, and the next parashah, Parashat Pinchas, he gets the blessing to live forever, he gets the blessing of becoming Kohen Gadol, which is something that he wasn't before, it was really something that you could only get if you were a... uh, direct uh, uh, uh, descendant or really a direct uh, son of Aharon HaKohen, uh, which he was a grandson, not a son. So anyway, he becomes a Kohen, he becomes a person that's gonna live forever, never dies. He gets these great blessings, he gets verses in the Torah mentioned after him, and he becomes the ultimate example of zealousness for eternity. So that's good, but what happened before is terrible.
26:15What happened before is terrible. How do we get from really, really good—we got the Torah, we're amazing, Hashem loves us, Hashem adores us, Hashem created the whole world for us, gives us His Torah... We go crazy, worship idols, and do the worst possible crime in the eyes of Hashem, which is immorality. A Jew with a non-Jew in the eyes of HaKadosh Baruch Hu is one of the worst possible things that can exist in the world. Whether it's a Jewish man with a non-Jewish woman or a Jewish woman with a non-Jewish man, either way, it's viewed as something that HaKadosh Baruch Hu hates, and it's a disaster. So now, how do we go from great... disaster great again or, you know, yeah, great again, I guess. So, in essence, we started doing good. We did teshuva, went off the derech like these three people—Meza, uh, uh, uh, uh, and whoever's like them—and then do teshuva, right? How do we get
27:28the problem here, Rabotai. So the Chatam Sofer says the following. If you noticed, the verse says, it says that Israel settled in the Shittim and the people began to commit harlotry. Question is, in the beginning of the verse, it says, Israel settled in the Shittim. And then it says, the people began to commit harlotry. Why is the same verse mentioning the people twice? I mean, shouldn't it say, Israel settled in the Shittim, and they began to commit harlotry? Why would it say, the people? It mentions, you know, Am Yisrael twice. So the Chatam Sofer says, that's because there are two people Am Yisrael has two statuses. When they are holy, when they're following the Torah, when they're doing what HaKadosh Baruch Hu said, they're Am Yisrael. They're the holy of holies. They're the chosen people. They're the greatest of the great. And simply, the world exists for their sake. When they're not, they're Am. They're just among the people. They're Am. They're not...
28:54doing so good. They're not doing so good. But they're not necessarily doing the worst yet. They're um, before they sinned, they're simply um, they're just not on the highest level. What is it like? We have, the Chatam Sofer says, we have Israel, which is the Talmidei Chachamim, the Torah scholars, the people that devote themselves to Torah, the people that devote themselves to Mitzvot, they toil in Torah, they teach Torah, they learn Torah non-stop, and they simply make Torah priority number one in their life. That's Israel. But then you have also the Am. The Am is the nation, which are people that are not necessarily desecrating Shabbat or going against the Torah, but they're not devoting their life to the Torah per se, and really they're more vulnerable to fall. Why? Because the less you toil for Torah, the more likely that you are going to fall to sins. Because if you invest a lot of time and effort into anything,
30:01you're going to be a lot more committed to it. If you built your own house with your own hands, it's less likely that you're going to sell that house. Why? Because you worked your, you know, you put your, not just you paid for it, you've worked to build it. It becomes like a part of you. So the more you work on something, the more you toil in something, the more you appreciate it, the more you protect it. If a person toils and toils in Torah, he's going to protect that Torah, even if there are certain things that are difficult in life and there are certain things that they don’t understand. Needless to say, they go and dedicate their life. But the Am, the people that are not necessarily dedicating their life to the Torah, are much more vulnerable. They’re much more vulnerable to different outside influences, if you will. So you see here that you have the highest level—Israel—and then you have the Am. So the Chatam Sofer says, how did the Am Yisrael then go to become, you know, you have the Am, but then right after that, immorality, intermarriage, nightmare. He says, notice what's between them. What war?
31:14Israel, before they committed harlotry, were at Shittim. What is Shittim? It is nonsense. The leaders of Am Yisrael, the ones that were the most lofty, the rabbis if you will, the ones that were supposed to be the Torah scholars, instead of toiling and toiling in Torah, they started watching movies. They started going to movie events. on Shabbat or during the week, they started playing sports, they started playing with guns, they started riding motorcycles, they started doing shtuyot, nonsense, things that the average person does, that the average non-scholar does. Now, when the non-scholar does it, a person that's an average person does it, it's obviously not good, but it's not as much of a disaster as when the scholar is doing it. Why? Rabbi Yisrael Salanter says, When a bachur yeshiva decides to simply not learn because he wants to go play basketball, he wants to go read some secular book, he wants to just go hang out, he doesn't want to learn.
32:27That loss of Kedusha in the world will cause some professor or some other weaker type of person in Am Yisrael to go and convert to Christianity or desecrate Hashem's name. What? There's a certain amount of Kedusha that's required in the world, and it's an even greater responsibility on the people that are already in it. The bachurim in the yeshiva, the avreichim, the rabbis, the people that are already in it. So when Yisrael stopped behaving like Yisrael and started going and doing shtuyot, they started watching movies, riding motorcycles, playing with guns, doing all types of nonsensical things. Surely it affected the Am that was already vulnerable to begin with. And now the Am falls, the Chatam Sofer says, to znut. They fall to the goyot, they fall to all the filth of the world, and simply destroy everything that they built until that point. Where you see, the fish stinks from the top. You see that any time you have weakness in the people, it starts with the leaders.
33:45It starts with the leaders. Weak leadership creates weak followers in every aspect, whether it's in business, and needless to say, whether it's in the Torah world. When you have weak leaders, they're going to breed weak followings, weak students. And obviously, we see here, it makes a lot of sense why Asher Meza is distorting the Torah on a regular basis when his rabbi is desecrating the Oneg Shabbat, desecrating Hashem's name, walking around with a Hasidic beard while going to non-Jewish events on Shabbat. And I would only imagine, probably other times as well, this is not a one-time event. When you have weak leaders, they're going to breed weak followings, weak students. And obviously, we see here, it makes a lot of sense why Asher Meza is distorting the Torah on a regular basis, when his rabbi is desecrating the Oneg Shabbat, desecrating Hashem's name, walking around with a Hasidic beard while going to non-Jewish events on Shabbat. And I would only imagine, probably other times as well, this is not a one-time event. since he himself says that he goes to this event and events like it every year, and obviously, the same applies for the other one, Otero. So, you see here that when the leader is weak, it creates, obviously, a disaster. And, of course, that's why it explains that the talmidim (students) of Meza
34:50feel perfectly comfortable putting pornography on his videos, on his live videos. Many people have complained. And in his comments, you'll see it, unless he deleted it already, you see people complaining, "Please stop these guys from masturbating on the video." Like you see a rabbi having students actually perform the most vile acts while it's, in essence, supposed to be a Torah shiur. And then, if that's not bad enough, the guys that are actually also there say, "Listen, why does it only have to be guys? What happened to you?" Do you have nothing, no whatsoever, no remorse for the Torah at all, no respect, no self-respect, nothing? You can say, no, I didn't do it, somebody else did it. Yeah, but this is the fruit of your labor. This is the fruit of your labor. If I had students like this, I think I'd commit suicide.
36:05happen to you people, but that's what's happening. When the teachers are weak, the students get weaker, and that's the degradation of the generations shown right in front of us without even having to wait another 30 or 40 years. So, you see that when the leaders are dealing with, that's what happens, that's what happens. And now We have to see what the Torah requires of us. Rabbi Yosef Karo, the Baal Shulchan Aruch, aside from writing the famous Shulchan Aruch that all of Klal Yisrael follows, also wrote the Beit Yosef, the Magid Mesharim, and other books. In the Magid Meisharim, these are the conversations that Rabbi Yosef Karo had with his private angel. He had an angel that was teaching him Torah. Now, this angel doesn't sugarcoat anything, I can tell you that. In Parashat Beshalach,
37:16The angel tells, this is the angel of the Mishnah. The angel of the Mishnah, every creation in essence has an angel. This Rabbi Yosef Karo was so holy, HaKadosh Baruch Hu showed him the angel, and the angel was teaching him Torah. In Parashat Beshalach, this is Rabbi Yosef Karo. This is not Yaron Reuven; this is not some mystical person that some people don't care for. Everyone accepts Rabbi Yosef Karo. And everyone accepts the Maggid Meisharim as a legitimate book from Rabbi Yosef Karo. This is like his personal journal. It's not like, oh yeah, maybe, no. This is not even Kabbalah. This is simply anyone that complies with Jewish rules, with the Shulchan Aruch; this is the author. It's not like some fairy tale somebody wrote and maybe, this is it. And you have here, a conversation, a little small tidbit of it. Rabbi Yosef Karo. It's a conversation with the angel, and the angel says the following to him: Always focus your heart. Meaning, the angel is telling Rabbi Yosef Karo, always focus your heart at all times, every hour, every moment, so that you do not think of anything except myself, my Torah, and serving me. In essence, he is speaking for Hashem.
38:27which is the secret of unity, not unity like everybody kumbaya likes each other. Unity of the, uh, that's why when you say Israel is supposed to extend the, the more you extend that, the more blessing you get. This is the special significance of it nonetheless. So, the angel says which is the secret of unity, of man actually uniting himself with his Creator. For the living soul attaches itself and unites with the Blessed One and his physical body and organs become the camp of the Shechinah. A person can sanctify themselves with their thoughts of how much they think about Torah and mitzvot and serving HaKadosh Baruch Hu to the point where HaKadosh Baruch Hu uses their organs as a place to put the Shechinah. You become literally like a living Beit HaMikdash. Then he continues, this is what is meant by the verse in Deuteronomy 10:20: "The Lord your God, you shall fear, you shall serve Him, and you shall attach yourself to Him."
39:45present you are uniting with Him by means of your mouth but not with your heart. Whenever you separate your thoughts from the fear of God, from His Torah, and from serving Him, you are, in effect, nullifying the unity of Hashem. So here we see that the expectation that he had of Rabbi Yosef Karo, obviously also us, but we're not at his level. Nonetheless, this is the expectation he had—to think about Hashem at all times. But what to think about Hashem? Oh, I love Hashem; hopefully, He's going to give me a new BMW. Oh, I love Hashem; hopefully, I'll get new customers. What? No, fear of the Almighty, he says. fear of the Almighty, first Torah, serving—that's what you're supposed to be thinking about at all times. And when a person doesn't, in essence, they are breaking up the unity of Hashem. They're, in essence, doing the opposite of what they're really supposed to be doing. So here we see the expectation of how much a person is supposed to fear and think about it at all times. And then, in Parashat Miketz...
40:54The angel says to Rabbi Yosef Karo, "The reason the miracles and wonders were performed in the past for the previous sages was that the thoughts of those involved were constantly attached to Me, My Torah, and fear of Me, without wandering away for even one moment. Hence, they rose and became attached to the upper traits. So, when they cast their eyes upon the guilty person, that person became a heap of bones." Here, the Maggid, the angel, tells Rabbi Yosef Karo, "You know the stories where you read in the Gemara, Masechet Shabbat, I believe it's page 32, where Rabbi Shimon Bar Yochai sees the person who caused all the trouble for the Romans by revealing that he said things against them. And this was actually a problematic convert." and he looks at this guy after he suffered so much, even though he got the Torah, but he suffered a lot from all that happened to him. So he looks at this guy and he says, "You're still alive?" And the guy turns into a heap of bones. Literally, he dies on the spot. So, not from Rabbi Shimon Bar Yochai killing him with his hands or with his sword, just simply, he looks at him and says, "You're still alive?" And in Shamayim, HaKadosh Baruch Hu reviews
42:20reviews the thoughts of the tzaddik and He sees that he's upset that this person is still alive. HaKadosh Baruch Hu says, "You're upset he's alive? Okay, that's it. He's not alive anymore. I'm sorry, you're My soldier. You're upset that he's alive? Fine, he's not alive anymore." Finished. He's not alive anymore. Things like this happen on a regular basis for some of these tzaddikim. Regular basis. Not like parables or fairy tales. It happened. It happened to them. You also see it in the Tanach. You see it in the Tanach itself. You see the prophet Elisha. Prophet Elisha, you have the story of the dry bones. There were people who were dead for hundreds of years that HaKadosh Baruch Hu resurrected all of them right there and then. Right there and then. Or one time, you have after Elisha HaNavi dies, and they put his body in the grave, and there was already somebody there. The second that his dead body, in essence, touched another dead body, the one that was dead came back to life. That's how holy Elisha HaNavi was.
43:31So these types of things are standard in the Torah, in the Gemara, and so on. And the Maggid says, why did this happen? Why do these people get such miracles, and the average person today can't even spell the word miracle? How come? He says, because they did what I told you. What did I tell you? To think of Me, to think of My Torah, to think of fear of Me without wavering, even a single moment. At all times, all of these giants thought about Hashem. At all times. When I first heard this years ago from my Rav, that the tzaddikim literally think about Hashem every single second of the day, I just couldn't comprehend it. How is that possible to think about Hashem all the time? I understand thinking about Hashem when you're praying, hopefully at least. I understand thinking about Hashem when you're studying. I understand thinking about Hashem when you're doing your mitzvah, you're active in the mitzvah. But to think about Him all the time, like you just woke up, you're thinking about Him. You're going to eat a little wafer or something, you're thinking about Him. You're drinking water, you're thinking about Him. You're doing your work in some business that you have, you're thinking about Him. You have a customer, you're thinking about Him. You're with your wife, you're thinking about Him. Yes.
44:51Yes, yes, yes, it's all 100% possible. When I first heard this, I thought this was imaginary. I thought this was imaginary, but it's 100% possible. And if a person can really, really do it to the extent that the Maggid says, that's how you can see a person literally become a walking miracle. So on one end, you have, obviously... that was thinking about Hashem and got to the highest possible level, resurrecting the dead, killing the living who were wicked and didn't have a right to exist. You see that. On the other hand, you sometimes see the very same people fall down to the lowliest level possible. Where you see Am Yisrael in Parashat Balak, Parashat Korach, and other places go and make a mockery of everything and has already told us that this has to do with the leadership. The leaders started doing obviously we're not talking about the leader being in his life, but the others. Obviously there were sub-leaders, the local rabbis.
46:14When they start acting like the regular commoners, the regular people, this affects people in a very, very negative way. Now, the question is, who is the rabbi? Of course, everybody can say, yeah, my rabbi is Rabbi Ovadia. Thank you very much, but who's your rabbi that is your Rav Muvhak, your rabbi that's going to direct you, that's going to teach you, and so on. Why do I need that? Everybody needs to have a rabbi. As the Mishnah in Avot says, "Make for yourself a rabbi." Now the Gemara in Masechet Bava Metzia, page 33a, has a Mishnah and Gemara on the subject. It says that all issues of rabbi and student have, there's a lot of halachot, there's a lot of laws that people really need to learn. you could find it in the Hilchot Talmud Torah of the Rambam in chapter 5, or also in the Shulchan Aruch in Yoreh De'ah, chapter 242, and in other places as well. But nonetheless, there are a lot of Halachot in regard to the relationship between a rabbi and his student. And here the Gemara says that one of the things that a person needs to know is if
47:35they lose something, and their father loses something, they if they you know they're they're gonna go look for something, they can make their own possession the priority over their father's. But if they could find both, good. But if there has to be priority, then they have to go; they can't choose themselves first. They don't have to choose their father's if... Let's say two people lost something or two people need help, both their father and their rabbi. They have to help their rabbi before they help their father. They have to help the rabbi before the father unless their father is a scholar, and then they can help their father first. Even if it comes to, they're both prisoners. They're both captive prisoners. You know, the Nochrim captured both their father and their rabbi. If their father is a regular person, he's not a scholar, they free their rabbi. And if there has to be a choice, they have to make a choice. They have to save their rabbi first. But if their father is a scholar, then they have to save their father first.
49:01Here we see that the rabbi is in an extraordinary position to the extent that we see here we have the Ten Commandments, which say you have to honor your father and your mother, right? But that is the basic understanding. Chachamim tell us, yes, you have to honor your father and your mother. We're not saying to dishonor them. But if you are going to look at all of the little details that come with this commandment, you'll see that Hashem's honor comes first, and part of the honor of Hashem is to honor your rabbi. The question is, who is your rabbi? So the Chachamim say, there's a debate between the Chachamim, and this is what they say. The rabbis were talking, and Rabbi Meir Baal HaNes says, your rabbi, is the person that taught you wisdom. What's wisdom? That's your rabbi. That's the first opinion. Another opinion says, no, it's not just someone that taught you; rather, it is the person that taught you most of your wisdom. So let's say, for example, you have several rabbis that you learned from. You watch videos of Rabbi A
50:23You watch videos of Rabbi B and you go to a shiur of Rabbi C. You learn from three different rabbis. Now, out of the total of wisdom that you have, that you've acquired from learning from these rabbis, surely one of them has given you the majority. So let's say if you... have three rabbis. One rabbi that you learned the most from gave you, let's say, 50% of your wisdom, and the other two are, let's say, split evenly 25% and 25%. And therefore, that rabbi that you learned the most from is your primary rabbi; that's your rabbi. And the Bach says that anyone who teaches you anything that you didn't know, even a single Mishnah, you should already give him honor as if he's your rabbi. What's the actual halacha? chapter 12, verse number two, and also chapter five, as well as siman 242, halacha number 30, all say the halacha is like Rabbi Yehuda.
51:40Rabbi Yehuda says, the person, the rabbi that taught you most of your wisdom, that's your rabbi, that's your Rav Muvhak. I said, no, maybe there isn't really any more Rav Muvhak because you could really learn a lot from books. But really today, I think the Rav Muvhak is more applicable than ever because most people in our nation today learn most of what they know from videos and audio and things of that nature rather than learning from books. That's just the reality of things. The point being is that the person you are learning the most from is your rabbi. That is your rabbi, which means that if your father and your rabbi were both prisoners, you have to save your rabbi before your father, unless your father is also a rabbi. So now, this already shows what our Torah, what our sages, are teaching about the significance of a rabbi.
52:44Significance of a rabbi is obviously up there. What about the significance of a talmid? The student himself is the student. He's a student. Does he deserve respect? Where the rabbi has to say, please, come to the shul. Please, if you don't want me to teach this, I won't say it anymore. If you get offended by what I say, I won't do it. What happens? The same Gemara, Bava Metzia, gives a story. Story of a rabbi and a talmid. Not just any rabbi and talmid. Two of the greatest people in their generation. Rav Huna and Rav Chisda. Rav Huna was Rav Chisda's rabbi. Rav Huna was the rabbi. And the Gemara says, Rav Chisda inquired of his rabbi, Rav Huna, that if a student has a special type of student, He's not just your average student who just takes everything on a silver platter. Rather, he's like one of those students who is really clever, really smart, a serious scholar, where the rabbi can give him a shiur for 30 minutes, and the student extrapolates it into a four-hour shiur. He's not just any type of student. He's a student that is what you call a student that's needed, where the rabbi benefits from that student also.
54:08So if Rav Chisda asked his rabbi, Rav Huna, if a student whom his teacher needs, what is the law if the student comes across his father's object and his teacher's object? Should he still retrieve the father's object or the teacher's object? Meaning that we all know the halakha is that if the rabbi lost something or the rabbi is captivated and also the father's captivated, that the student has to free or help the rabbi first before the father. Unless the father is a scholar, which is that exception. In every other circumstance, they have to help the rabbi first. The rabbi takes priority over the parents. So now, Rav Chisda, a Talmid Chacham, is asked a clever question. He says, what if the rabbi needs the student too? should he still be considered his Rav Muvhak, really his rabbi? Because, you know, technically, this is a special student. He's a really smart guy. He contributes a lot, and so on and so forth. Rav Chisda...
55:25misunderstood what his student was saying, thinking that Rav Huna, his talmid, is in essence talking about himself because he himself was a really big tzadik and a chacham and contributed a lot and was clever and so he was really what he's talking about. So Rav Huna thought he's talking about himself. And Rav Chisda said, "Chisda, Chisda," He says, "I don't need you. You need me. For 14 years, you need me." Here we see the Rav reply in such a way that causes tension between them until they both calm down and realize they both made a mistake.
56:25They both made a mistake. Rav Huna realized that the student didn’t mean that he should be treated differently. Essentially, what he was trying to say was not, "You're not really my rabbi; I'm already at your same level." He wasn't saying that. He was just asking a question to toil in Torah. And he fasted for 40 days. Rav Huna fasted for 40 days for misunderstanding the student. The student Rav Chisda also fasted for 40 days because he asked the question inappropriately to his rabbi and offended his rabbi. But then it says Rav Chisda fasted 40 days because he caused Rav Huna to feel dejected, and likewise Rav Huna fasted 40 days because he had unjustly suspected Rav Chisda of acting insolently. And then they came back to learning together. What do you see here though? My dear Rav says, look at the lesson here. What's the lesson here about this whole fight? What's the lesson here? The rabbi is a giant. The talmid is a giant. They misunderstood each other. But there's a lesson here. Why is the Gemara putting it here? What do we need to know? They disagree. Today, somebody doesn't like what you say in a shiur. Oh no, he's not only not my rabbi anymore. He's Erev Rav. He's the worst. He's the worst. So here we see, they misunderstood each other. They suffered for it.
57:52They did teshuva for it. But what happened in the end? Rav Chisda, Rav Huna, the teacher, the rabbi, didn't change his mind. Meaning that, yeah, I misunderstood you. I thought that you were thinking that you were talking about yourself. But that doesn't change the answer. Meaning, Chisda, Chisda, you need me. Chisda, you need me. For 40 years you need me. that's not a, uh, that didn't, I didn't answer that that way because of what you were asking. That's still the answer. You're the student, and you will always need me for 40 years. You're going to need me. Where does 40 years come from? It says that a person who has a Rav has to understand that he's going to need that Rav, he's going to need that Rav more than he needs air. Why? It's going to take you 40 years to truly understand what your rabbi is teaching you. Just like Am Yisrael only understood the value of Moshe Rabbeinu after he died. Meaning, he was already their rabbi for 40 years, but they only began to understand how amazing he was after 40 years. After 40 years. So here it says, you need me and you're going to need me for 40 years.
59:09So now we see that the attitude of the rabbis has to be such where they have to let the student know who's boss. Now, is this the way? Is this the way that works today? Obviously, in most places, it's not necessarily the way. Why? In most places, the rabbi could be a person that has a title, "rabbi," but the person that calls the shots is usually the one that has the most amount of money. As they say in Hebrew, the person that has ownership of the hundred, meaning the hundred-dollar bills, is also the one that has the owner of the opinion of what to do. So unfortunately, in many places, you see that the people that run the show are the board of directors, or some big donor, or a combination thereof. And this is unfortunately one of the disasters, one of the disasters that's happening. And the Chida said a few hundred years ago that the Torah lost its honor when rabbis started taking money from rich people and, in essence, gave them control of the shul as a result. And this happens, but it didn't always happen, and it doesn't happen everywhere.
1:00:29In fact, if you look at all the successful communities, you will see quite the opposite of this. One of the great examples that I just learned today from my Rav, Rav Ephraim, is the story of Rav Chaim Kreiswirth. Rav Chaim Kreiswirth was one of the Gedolei HaDor of the previous generation. He left this world about 20 years ago. ...And he was an extraordinary one of the giants of the generation. Literally, the entire Torah was inside his brain. He knew the whole thing by heart. There was one time he had one son... So during his wedding, he invited all the giant sages of the generation. Rav Kreisworth invited all the giant rabbis to celebrate his only son's wedding. Because of so many big rabbis and important people, there was some delay to the wedding.
1:01:30So Rav Kreisworth goes to Rav Ovadia, which gave a lot of respect, you know, they had a lot of mutual respect for each other, so much so that Rav Ovadia says he doesn't think, he doesn't think there's anybody else in the generation like Rav Kreisworth, something unique. And he says, you know, while we're waiting, since we're at the wedding of the Abba Shaul family, Let's, among us, between the two of us, count how many times the name Abba Shaul appears in the Gemara. Because there's one of the sages in the Gemara, his name is Abba Shaul. So let's go back and forth. You give me one source, I go to the other until we go through the entire Gemara. And Rav Ovadia starts, Rav Kreiswirth next, oh, in this Gemara, page this, Rav Abba Shaul appears. Oh, yeah, you're right, on page that one, he appears again, on page that one, he appears again, and he goes back and forth, back and forth, back and forth, until Rav Kreiswirth says to Rav Ovadia, hold on a second, Rav, I'm sorry, but you skipped one. You skipped one. He says, where did I skip one? He says, oh, on that Gemara over there, on such and such page. He says, Rav Abba Shaul,
1:02:42Rav Ovadia says to him, "No, no, no, kvodo, mechila. No, it's a mistake. Why? We're talking about Abba Shaul. The Abba Shaul that you're mentioning, if you look at the commentary by the Maharsha over there, one of the sages that practically comments on every page of the Gemara, you see what the Maharsha comments. He says, this is not the same Abba Shaul that's all over the Gemara. This is an Abba Shaul, Abba Shaul ben Botnit. We're not at the wedding of ben Botnit." We're at the wedding of Abba Shaul. So there are two Abba Shauls in the Gemara. One time, this other one appears. I didn't count him because we're talking about the other Abba Shaul. And this, Rabotai, they go through the entire Shas by heart. One, one, one. We're not talking about, they remember some halacha that was mentioned somewhere. Literally going from their, mamash, their neshama. I can't even say a brain. From their neshama, they go back and forth and tell you each and every single page. Each and every single page in the Gemara that mentions the sage Abba Shaul. And this is, Rabotai, not long ago.
1:03:51This is not long ago. We're not talking about the generation of Moshe Rabbeinu. We're talking about 30 years ago, 40 years ago. Now, how did they run their kehillah? How did they run their kehillah? Rav Chaim Kreiswirth was asked to come to Antwerp, to Antwerpen in Belgium, to lead the community over there. And at the time, he came from Israel to America. And when he asked the Chazon Ish, one of the Gedolei HaDor, a sheilat rav, he asked his rabbi, should I go to lead the community in Belgium? The Chazon Ish initially said no. And the Lubavitcher Rebbe also said no. He wanted to stay in America. But the people in Belgium were saying, listen, really, we really need you. We need a giant to help us. We need a giant to help us because there's more Reform, there's more heresy in Belgium. They're looking to hire a weak Orthodox rabbi in order to turn Orthodoxy into Reform. We need somebody strong like you, so...
1:05:02But he asked the Rabbi, he asked the Chazon Ish. The Chazon Ish said no. He was a little bit surprised the Chazon Ish said no. But he asked the Rabbi and that's what he did. One day he gets a message. The Chazon Ish says, I changed my mind. Go to Belgium. Go to Belgium. Now, he didn't ask him a second time. It's mamash, the Chazon Ish got some type of Ruach HaKodesh a few weeks before he died, and he gave out a lot of different instructions to different people all over the world of things that need to be done. And here, there was a question that came up years before, and he changed his mind. He said, go to Belgium. And he ended up, after that, going to Belgium, and he built a world of Torah in Belgium. A world of Torah. An entire community changed, something out of this world. And Baruch Hashem, to this day, there's a lot of Torah over there. And they asked him, what's the secret to building such a strong community, full of Torah, buildings, yeshivot, chesed, what's the secret? He says, the secret, the secret is in the Gemara Masechet Bava Metzia, page 33a. What is it? Chizda, chizda, I don't need you.
1:06:17I don't need you. A Rav has to come to a community and tell the community, "I'm here to help you. Now you come help me. You're benefiting out of this. I don't need you to provide me my sustenance. You're allowed to pay the Rav if you want. You can donate to the Rav. You can do all types of things, but the second you buy the Rav, he's not a Rav anymore. He's not a Rav anymore." He's not a rabbi anymore. This is the same exact thing, Rabotai, we see with Rav Tzion Levi. Rav Tzion Levi, alav haShalom, was also from the same generation, one of the Gedolei Olam, one of the giants. And the 24-year-old avrech was sent to Panama to be the head rabbi. When he arrived over there, he said, "There's no mikveh. I told you, part of the deal, you have to have a mikveh." "Ah, mikveh, mishmikveh. Come on, rabbi, forget about it." He tells the kehillah, a 24-year-old avrech. We're talking about the people of Panama. I went to Panama five, six times in my life, when I was still in the business world. And it's a very interesting place, some beautiful stuff over there, and extraordinarily wealthy people. Some people over there, Baruch Hashem, were blessed with literally billions of dollars, an enormous amount of power, and so on. So anyway, here we have...
1:07:3424-year-old avrech comes to a kehillah where you have members in the kehillah literally worth hundreds of millions or billions of dollars and have political powers to the point where they practically control the country. And he's telling them, if you don't get me a mikveh by this day, within a few days, I'm leaving. They thought he was joking. "You're going to leave the penthouse we gave you, the fancy house we gave you? You lived in a hole in the wall. You're going to leave this place?" They didn't take him seriously. He left his house with the suitcases and went to the airport. They realized that he was serious. They begged him to come back. "Please, please, please. We're sorry. Until we got you over here. Please." He said, "You have a short amount of time. You have to get the mikveh open right away." They had to literally build a mikveh in extraordinary times. extraordinary timing. Right away they had to do it. Why? That's the Torah. A 24-year-old. Not that long later, some of the community's wealthy people decided they wanted to do something for the sake of kiruv. But their own version of kiruv. Why do people do this today? They open a nightclub for Jewish people. A nightclub for Jewish people. People do this stuff in
1:08:57Oh, we're going to have a singles event at the synagogue. So instead of them sinning with the non-Jews, they'll sin with the Jews. Like instead of intermarriage, we'll have issurim. This is karet, this is karet. And they actually think this is kiruv, but this is a mitzvah. 100% forbidden, these singles events and all of this nonsense. That's not the way of Am Yisrael. But nonetheless, these people in Panama didn't realize they have the gadol hador, that's 24 years old, among them. And these guys bought a building. They bought a building to have a Jewish nightclub. Rav Tzion Levy heard about this. He went to the place. He saw it. On Shabbat, everybody came to shul. You know, everybody respected going to shul and so on. Even some people that wouldn't keep Shabbat. Everybody came to shul. Rav Tzion Levy says to them, I decree. I decree. that you're going to sell this place. What? Anytime a Jewish community buys something, you have to ask the rabbi who gave you permission to buy this building, to open such a place. And therefore, I decree that you're going to sell this building, and all of the money is going to go to the synagogue to build a new kupah for the building.
1:10:27seen everywhere in the country. Something that's going to make Kiddush Hashem. The community, talking about millionaires and billionaires among them, looks at a 24-year-old and says, we're sorry, Kavod HaRav, you're right. We'll sell the building, give all the money to the synagogue, and make a fence here for the sake of HaKadosh Baruch Hu. How did Rav Tzion Levy do such a thing? How did Rabbi Ovadia do the same thing? How did Rabbi Kreisberg do the same thing? How did these G'dolei Olam do this? And yet today you have people afraid to tell their community not to desecrate Shabbat. How? Chisda, Chisda, I don't need you. When a rabbi lets his community know that you need me, not I need you. You need me. Not that I need you. Then he will be able to successfully teach his students and get them to do something. But if they think the opposite, you've already failed, you might as well go become some janitor somewhere else. But then unfortunately, Abotai, there are sometimes people that go off the derech, like the three that we talked about, Krakowski, Otero, and Meza, and people that are similar to them.
1:11:58How does such a thing happen? The same exact thing. It's not that Krakowski didn't tell them, "I don't need you." It's that Krakowski knew from day one he needs Meza, because Meza gave him a job at some point years ago. And if that's not bad enough, none of them have a rabbi. Not Meza, not Otero, not Krakowski. They're all, they're all rabbis. They all are their own Moshe Rabbeinu. They all listen to themselves. And when a person does not have a rabbi, there's nothing worse than that. Why? There's nobody out there to tell them, "Habibi, I don't need you. You need me. And therefore, you have to listen to me." what you're doing is wrong. No one is telling them what they're doing is wrong. All they have is friends, all they have is colleagues, all they have is people that are falling down with them further and further and further away from the truth. This is one of the critical things that each and every one of us has to always know: if you do not have a rabbi,
1:13:18no security whatsoever that you will remain Jewish. You have no security whatsoever that your children will remain Jewish. Why? You have nobody telling you you're wrong, you need to do teshuva. If you don't have a rabbi that's going to tell you you're wrong, you need to do teshuva. You are extremely vulnerable. And if you're even worse, like these three, where you don't want to listen to anybody even if they did tell you, The reason I say almost is because anyone that's alive, still physically alive, technically can do teshuva. Technically. And even that has an exception. B'ezrat Hashem, we always realize who our rabbis are, what we need to do, where we stand, what our responsibility is. And clarify in our own mind over and over and over again.
1:14:23...how much we need this, how much we need our rabbis, how much we need to learn from them at every opportunity, appreciate them as much as possible, help them in any way possible, support them in every way possible, and try to do whatever we can to build the Torah. Why? It's for ourselves; we benefit from it. It's not for the rabbi, because who wants the rabbi to have money? Hashem will provide for him in a million different ways... A lot of people thought, oh yeah, look, how is he going to eat? What is he going to eat? His books? How is he going to eat? When he first married the Rebbetzin, everybody made fun of the Rebbetzin. Why are you marrying this guy? He's not going to work. He's going to learn Torah non-stop. What is he going to eat? His books? But the Rebbetzin knew what she had in her hands. She knew she had a Gadol HaDor in her hands. She knew she had a Tzaddik in her hands. She stuck with him, and Baruch Hashem, money was never a problem. Money was never a problem after things settled down, and Baruch Hashem, Rabbi Ovadia started becoming well-known around the world, eventually becoming extraordinarily wealthy. In the beginning, of course, they dealt with a lot of difficulties. They lived in a one-room apartment with no bathroom, no kitchen, and no bedroom.
1:15:35So, of course, there was difficulty. Because they stuck to the Torah, HaKadosh Baruch Hu rewards those that learn Torah and toil over Torah through poverty to make sure that they arrive at richness. What do you think? Rabbi Ovadia did it by himself? Absolutely not. He had a rabbi, and he understood the value of the rabbi. And everyone that ever made it in Judaism to anything of value, anyone that has children that have made it to anything of value, No, I can only cross the street if the rabbi says it's okay. But as soon as you start hearing people disregarding the rabbis as if, "Nah, they're just like us, no big deal," you already know these people are on a downward spiral with possible disasters being very, very near, very soon, and unfortunately, very often. We love Hashem, we always know what the truth is, we always follow it, we always do it. And follow what our rabbis say through thick and thin. And make sure that we have our children follow what the rabbis say through thick and thin. Because when we do that, we have the protection of the Torah. With that being said, we can now have as many questions as you want over perhaps the next hour or so.
1:17:07David, can you elaborate on the men's mikveh laws of being undressed in front of other men? What's your source and so on? I mean, there's a lot in regards to mikveh. As far as a few things I can tell you off the top of my head, a man should not go to the mikveh with his son. The son should never see the father naked and so on. That's one thing that's very well known. Second, a man should never look at another man's private area. Even if they're both naked in the mikveh and they are both comfortable with themselves and so on, you're not allowed to look at another person's private parts—not men, not women, and actually not even animals. If you see animals mating, you're not allowed to observe such things because it creates all types of tumah (impurity) and inappropriate thoughts in a person's mind and so on. That's another thing. As far as being naked in front of another person, you're allowed to, in essence, do that, but technically a person should be modest in the way they cover themselves until they get to the actual water itself. So you should always have a towel.
1:18:18As soon as you get to the mikveh itself, you take off the towel, which means that your back is facing everybody else. No one's really seeing the front of you. You dip into the water, so that way, everybody that would see your face is only seeing your face. The rest of your body is covered. Now, as soon as you finish dipping, however many times you dip, whether it's one time or three times or seven times, everybody has their own customs. customs, you get out of the mikveh, obviously, you should, you know, try to cover yourself as much as you can. Get yourself a towel and cover yourself immediately. Cover yourself immediately. Don't be like one of these people who are like the Greeks and the Romans, walking around like a free willy. like you're some whale or something. Don't do that. Cover yourself, have some respect, have some honor for yourself, and cover yourself. Now, obviously, if you see somebody else's private part or somebody else sees you, and it's, let's say, more of a direct area of vision, not that you're specifically looking at it or they're specifically looking at it, that's not a problem. It's not a problem.
1:19:37But the point is to have some modesty, to have some modesty. Now if you see that the mikveh that you're going to has people that simply have no tact whatsoever, have no modesty whatsoever, and are simply like one of these horses that like to dip into a pool. That's all they are. They're proud that they're into the water. They think that's going to fix all of their sins while they're sitting like this. Krakowski, in one of his videos, is proud of the fact that he just finished dipping into a mikveh, and a few moments later, he tells you about how he desecrated Shabbat. So, you know, people like that obviously have to be more conscious of that. But if you see that there are people walking around the mikveh all the time with no class, no ethics, no... censorship, no nothing. They simply think that it's okay to be a whale, even if you're a human. Therefore, you should try to avoid these people. You should try to avoid these people, come to the mikveh. At times that they're not coming, either much earlier or a little later or on different days, or change mikveh, change mikveh. Simply speaking, you should not go to a mikveh where there's a bunch of "whales" walking around. The best thing to do, really, if you're going to go to a mikveh on a regular basis, is to do as much as you can to be the first one there.
1:20:58...the first one there. There's a lot of reason for it. One of them is this: the whole modesty issue. Another reason is the fact that if you have a very active mikveh, then, you know, kind of, if it's a really active mikveh like some out there, then by the time you get there, you know, it's like the mikveh, and then there is a layer of stuff that's floating... kind of gross. So it's best to be first. Best to be first if you can. If you can, you can. There is no obligation for a man to go to a mikveh. There used to be a... that men had to go to the mikveh every time they were together with their wives but saw that the men were not able to uphold this particular rabbinical enactment, and therefore they canceled it. So there's no obligation for a man to go to a mikveh. The obligation to go to a mikveh is... Oh, I just realized the microphone is not even close to me.
1:22:03uh, I, um, the, uh, the man is, uh, not obligated to go to the mikveh. The women are obligated to the mikveh; uh, that's an obligation. It's a Torah obligation. If a woman, uh, does not go to a mikveh, her husband is not allowed to touch her, not allowed to touch her. Uh, and, uh, that's why I love Levy, for example, in our story that we told earlier. Uh, that's why Levy picked up and, uh, practically left. new community they just moved into because they weren't going to, you know, open a mikveh like they promised. So, a man is not obligated to go to a mikveh. He could go to a mikveh, and in some cases, he should go to a mikveh, but there's no obligation to do it. if going to the mikveh is going to lead you to sin as a man, then it is much better that you never go to the mikveh. Never go to the mikveh at all. But if you have a kosher mikveh, you have a mikveh that has reasonable people, people that have their marbles together and have some decency, then you should go to a mikveh. It's a very holy thing to do.
1:23:09uh, okay. Reuben is asking: I have a friend who Klukowski was one of the three on their Beit Din for gerut. The others were kosher talmidim. I highly doubt, no, Klukowski really is... such a good kosher should he make a geirut um i mean you would have to go to a Beit Din for such a thing but i don't think you'd have you uh uh you um would have to get a second conversion um if the others were kosher talmidim and so on uh plus who knows when Klakowski became like he is right now. I don't know if that's it's always been this way, but generally speaking, it's not too often that they would cancel a conversion and say it's not valid, especially if the other people were kosher Jews and so on. Generally, the times that you have a lot more
1:24:18stringency as far as conversions is if the person that converted themselves didn't keep any mitzvot from day one. They never kept Shabbat and so on. And that person, obviously, they could have fooled the Beit Din, but they didn't fool Hashem. That person is still a goy, according to most opinions. Or if the Beit Din is Reform or Conservative Rabbis or Apikorsim, uh, that uh, at the time of the conversion, and it's well known already by then that they are, that's usually when you have a conversion that's, you know, not valid to begin with. But once a conversion is valid, generally speaking, they don't undo it. If a person has a conversion by somebody that's a kosher person, and later on that person goes off the derech. That doesn't change their conversion; they're still kosher. There's no problem with it. But again, it's important to
1:25:24pick your rabbi well and not just go to anybody that's going to convert you, the first one to convert you, or for the best price. A lot of people make decisions like that because they don't really know better. But if you can get guidance for things like that, you should go to someone who is a well-known, well-respected rabbi that you know if somebody else in a different community heard his name, would help you rather than hurt you. This is also why I tell people that, uh, with conversions by people like, uh, well, not people like Asher Meza's conversion or Hotez's conversion, I believe only destroys people's lives. They don't help them. They And for a couple of reasons. Number one, the overwhelming majority of the people that Asher Meza converts should never be Jewish to begin with because they have no concept of what being Jewish is, and they're not willing to make the sacrifices to become a Jew. They want to still live non-Jewish lives but call themselves Jews, for better or for worse.
1:26:29And you see these so-called rabbis, Meza and Otero, converting people en masse by going to a mixed beach. And then you have Otero over there taking pictures of the half-naked women and putting them on his Facebook page and on his YouTube page and so on. So obviously you see these people have no concept What's, you know, what conversion to Judaism is because their rabbis themselves have no concept of what Judaism is, what Torah is, what modesty is, what tact is, or what anything is. That's reason number one. Reason number two is because, at this point, Meza is well known in many communities as an apikores. as a person that creates a lot of problems in the Jewish community. I already had several people contact me from Colorado, from different places in Florida, and other places that have a lot of dirt, let's say, or about the problems that he has. And he even himself says that more than half of the people that he converted
1:27:39are not accepted by any community. So why would anybody want such a conversion that's not accepted by any community? I just don't understand that. I mean, you're pretty much signing yourself up to have a very high likelihood that you're gonna be rejected wherever you go. And your kids will be rejected wherever you go. And you may not care about yourself because you have a chip on your shoulder and you think that you know enough. that it doesn't really matter where you convert because you know what you need to do and so on. Yeah, but what about your kids? You know, you may not care about where you are because you are in your own planet in your mind, and your wife doesn't care where she is because she's in her own planet, or vice versa. Fine, but what about your kids that perhaps one day want to go to yeshiva? Perhaps they want to have a normal shidduch from some frum family. You think anyone's going to marry them? You think anyone's even going to want to go on a date with them? Absolutely not. ...and your kids are not going to understand the chip you had on your shoulder and the excuse you had to use somebody that's not even a person that follows halacha. It’s a person that's well-known as someone who goes and breaks the fence of Judaism. So, that's the thing—you’re going into it with a reality that you will have a lot of problems.
1:28:57Why? Why? Is there some type of a mission in your life to create suffering for yourself? I mean, usually, suffering comes by itself into people's lives. Why create suffering for yourself? You could say, no, listen, he's the only one that would convert me because I live in the middle of nowhere, Montana. I live in the middle of nowhere, Oklahoma. Well, let me break it to you. If you live in the middle of nowhere and you're not part of a Jewish community, you should not convert to Judaism. Because you do not know enough and will not know enough on your own to live a righteous Jewish life. You simply will not. You won't know what to do on Rosh Hashanah. You won't know what to do on Rosh Chodesh. You won't know what to do on Yom Kippur. But now, unlike when you were not Jewish, where it wasn't a sin for you to do anything that's the opposite of what halacha is, now it's a sin. now it's a sin. Now you're going to get punished for it. So again, it's really misleading the public in such a fashion that it causes a lot of harm for people, and hence the reason why it's something we have to talk about.
1:30:15I think it's important for people to know that you don't necessarily need to go to a Beit Din that is recognized by the Rabbanut of Israel because there are plenty of good Batei Din of kosher rabbis that are not part of the Rabbanut. The Rabbanut is not accepting anybody new anyway. And aside from that, it's a whole political situation that's beyond anybody's control. You know, one day we would like to have a Beit Din of our own. Whether it will be accepted by the Rabbanut or not remains to be seen, but we don't have a Beit Din right now. All of our students, we take them to a Beit Din that is recognized by the Rabbanut. The couple of people we did in Florida, we took them to the Beit Din of Miami or South Florida over there, and then most of our students, we took them to Rabbi Eliyahu Ben-Chaim in New York. is one of the most well-recognized rabbis in America, uh, needless to say in the world of conversions. And then we had a couple of conversions in, uh, in Israel and so on also. But the point being is that all are recognized by the Rabbanut in Israel, just in case somebody wants to make Aliyah or so on. Now, does that mean that all Batei Din that are not part of the Rabbanut are not kosher or not good? No, it doesn't mean that. There are very good Batei Din that are not part of the Rabbanut.
1:31:42but not mezuzahs, not oteos. Why? It's not because they're not part of the Rabbanut that they're not good. It's because they are not good. They don't follow halacha. When their rabbi openly says, Kolkowski says that he desecrates Shabbat practically, Okay, he is desecrating Hashem's name, walking around with Hasidic garb on Shabbat in movie theaters. You have people like that, and when these guys are taking pictures of models of women that are half-naked, going into a beach and putting it on the internet, when you have them desecrating on a regular basis, and that's the person that converted you, that conversion paperwork is worth no more than toilet paper. No one will ever accept such a thing. But if you have a serious talmid chacham that knows what he's doing, is a kosher person, and they convert you, there's no problem. There's no problem. But again, you also have to be careful who you go to. You have to also not be a sucker and just pay any price. You have to be patient and you have to also know what you're doing. But nonetheless...
1:32:56A person needs to know that if Hashem wants you to convert, He'll open all the doors that need to be opened. If none of the doors are opening, then you should be a little bit more patient. I'm not saying give up, but you should be a little bit more patient and don't make abrupt decisions—decisions that are going to cost you a lot, a lot, a lot more than money. One is asking, in a commentary, why has it been said that the sin of the Golden Calf has never been completely forgiven? Until when or where or ever will it be forgiven? The sin of the Golden Calf was something that was beyond the ability of Am Yisrael to have it forgiven because there's no such thing as a sin that is just eliminated. judged by a person saying, "I'm sorry." Everything has a consequence. Once a person shoots a bullet, even if he regrets the fact that he shot a bullet or he regrets the fact that he jumped off of a building, it's already done. There's going to be an effect. That bullet will hit something.
1:34:14that person is falling. There's just no way around it. So once a sin happens, that's it. The sin is there. There is a taint, a stain, a damage in the universe, and a damage in the spiritual world from that sin. Now, the damage created by the Golden Calf was too much for Am Yisrael to bear, meaning that they could not fix that stain in a single, uh, uh, way because, uh, let's say, for example, if you have you know, if you have kids, sometimes they go outside, and they come home. You give them new clothes, and they come home with mud and colors and all types of stuff on their clothes. When they come home, you throw it into the wash, and most of the stuff comes off. Sometimes it stains, and you have to wash it a little bit more, perhaps put some bleach on it and all types of things. Nonetheless, you keep washing and washing, and sometimes replacing, and so on.
1:35:17But if the kid goes outside and he comes home with tar. With tar, not only on the clothes, but on himself. Now, you could put that kid in the shower for three hours. It's not coming out. It's not coming out just because you put some water on it. You could put some soap on it too. It's not coming out so easily. There are certain things that require a little more effort. You have to scratch it off. You have to wait. It may even take a few days for certain things. It may take a few days. It may take a lot of effort. You may have to peel some skin even with certain chemicals and so on, meaning that you'd have to wait for the skin to regenerate and therefore have the chemicals taken out of the body. But the point is that with each stain, there's a certain amount of cleaning that has to be done. With the stain that was created by the Golden Calf, Cleaning it in one shot would have destroyed Am Yisrael, and therefore Hashem split up the cleaning process—the rectification of the sin of the Golden Calf—for all generations until Mashiach comes. Because if He would have done any more than that, it would destroy the nation, so because it was that big of a sin...
1:36:47Next question: Katya is asking if a woman is blessed with gifts such as the ability to sing, artistic abilities, and so on, would it be considered immodest to act upon those gifts? It all depends on how she acts on those gifts. Singing in general is not recommended for women because Jewish men are not allowed to hear women sing. Jewish men are not allowed to hear a woman sing, period, unless it's their wife and it's just one-on-one and it's wife and kids and stuff like that. But if there's neighbors and family members and so on, the woman is not allowed to sing next to people. So what career are you going to have? You're going to sing to your husband? Now, there are some women that say, "No, I'm going to be a kosher Jewish singer and I'll only sing to women." period, unless it's their wife and it's just one-on-one, and it's wife and kids and stuff like that. But if there's neighbors and family members and so on, the woman is not allowed to sing next to people. So, what career are you going to have? You're going to sing to your husband? Now, there are some women that say, "No, I'm going to be a kosher Jewish singer and I'll only sing to women." uh, now although that is possible and it is done, I don't recommend it, uh, simply because if you, uh, fail, the yetzer hara is going to tell you that's because you only have, you know, uh, a partial audience
1:37:53start putting stuff into your head that if you started singing to men with all types of clever ideas of how to do it, you'll succeed more. So already you're putting yourself in danger by singing that way. The second thing is that if you succeed, then it's a world full of traps of the Satan. And quite frankly, for all singers, all singers have to be careful of the Satan of success. Singing is not exactly an easy field to go into, especially in today's world. You see, actually, that there are some people who started off as good, religious singers and then turned out to be people who completely left Judaism after they achieved success. And they fell for the trap of the Satan. They started doing drugs. They started going with, you know, non-Jewish, non-religious people. And in some cases, they became complete apikorsim. So singing in general, I don't recommend it. Can you do it? Only if it's for women. But that's, again, problematic. But it's not 100% forbidden. But it's still not recommended. But as far as art...
1:39:06you're an artistic person, that's a perfectly good skill that you can develop, and you should develop and use it in order to do kosher things with it. You could do a lot of good things with it. There are many Torah books and children's books for teaching Torah that are using the art of well-known religious women who are doing the art. Join the characters and the different things, and they really make the books a lot more fun and a lot more attractive for the kids to learn. To do such a thing would be the greatest thing you could possibly do for yourself. You know, I would love to have my daughter uh, do that one day as long as she grows, she has an artistic ability and that would be a fantastic thing for her to do. But again, you have to be careful. You have to ask your rabbi, "Is this good? Is that good?" Just because you're an artist doesn't mean that you can paint anything. Just because you're an artist doesn't mean you can do anything with art. You have to have a rav who is going to direct you and tell you what to do, and you won't go right or left without him saying so.
1:40:19So it's not just about utilizing the ability, which you should utilize that ability, but it's also knowing how to and having someone with Daas Torah tell you how to utilize it. But nonetheless, that's a much more valuable talent that you can use for the sake of Kedusha. Also, to make a living and also to make a very good living, there are some artists that make an extraordinary living in the Jewish world. So there's definitely a way for a person to succeed in it, to enjoy what they're doing, and to utilize the talent that they have. There's actually a well-known artist named Gadi Pollack. Gadi Pollack is a baal teshuvah who became a very serious Torah learner, but what the world knows him for is that right now, he's perhaps the most sought-after artist in the Jewish world. well-known, uh, artist named Gadi Pollack. Gadi Pollack is a baal teshuvah who became a very serious Torah learner, but what the world knows him for is that right now, he's perhaps the most sought-after artist in the Jewish world. Uh, pretty much he's such a well-known artist in the Jewish world that if his name is on a book, people will buy it just because of that. They don't even care what the book is about. It could be about Mount Sinai, it could be the Haggadah, it could be about middot, it could be anything. If you have Gadi Pollack on it, you pretty much know it's good and it's right. This is stuff...
1:41:40is amazing. Aside from the Torah itself that's in it, it is very, very well put together and extraordinary. It's something that should be in every house, Sephardi or Ashkenazi. It's a beautiful, beautiful Haggadah. You can learn a lot from it too. But aside from that, the art that he has is something out of this world. It's something out of this world. It's beautiful stuff that's relevant to what's being discussed. A lot of artists, you know, do things that are just general. They just, you know, make a picture and the picture, you know, is nice or not nice depending on a person's taste. But some artists are just exceptionally talented. Gadi Pollack is one of them. Now, Gadi Pollack is a Baal Teshuvah. And when he, what I heard from my Rav is that when he did Teshuvah, he didn't know what he was going to do because he was an artist his whole life. And he used to make art for things that are not right according to the Torah. And so he thought maybe he's going to utilize his art in different ways or do something else.
1:42:48But one of the things that I heard is that the Rav told him, no, davka, use your art ability to sanctify Hashem's name. Sanctify HaKadosh Baruch Hu's name. And that's what he did. Same thing happened with another baal teshuvah that is in Israel who, I forget the name, but he was a well-known artist and he put art to every mishnah. every Mishnah in the Shas Mishnayot in Hebrew, and there's a drawing for each one of them that he did. It's a very, very well-known set of books in Hebrew that children and even adults learn from because the art he made makes it much easier for people to learn. Unfortunately, they only translated one of the tractates. ...uh, of this particular set to English, it's only for, uh, uh, one tractate. But nonetheless, this is an artist who was a ba'al teshuvah that used his talents for the sake of Torah. So there is definitely a lot of need for art...
1:43:57And for artists and for people that are talented, you can use your talents, but again, you have to discuss these things with your rabbi and make sure that you follow whatever the rabbi says and do it. You can definitely use those gifts Hashem gave you. uh, Charlie is asking if you did full teshuva a few years ago for sexual sins with a non-Jewish woman and do feel sorry for the sins but still think of the sin once in a while, does new teshuva need to be done? Teshuva has several different steps as we discussed. First of all is stopping the sin. Second of all is putting a fence around it in order to not come back to it. And third is regret. Now, regret has stages. There's regret that I just messed up, and then there's regret that's even deeper, that comes from disgust, where I regret I was even present in such a place, where you're reviled by such a thing. I have one person that I know that, when they first started doing teshuva specifically for the same issue, for being with non-Jewish women, and so on.
1:45:14know a, uh, initially he said, "Okay, you know, I'm not gonna do it again," and so on. But as they, uh, got more and more religious and more and more into learning, they started saying to me, "I can't believe it. I can't believe I did it." Okay, fine. Don't kill yourself over it. Okay, good, you didn't do it, but you know, move on, move on. And they would just harp on it constantly. And I told them, "Okay, you know what? If you really feel that bad, go pray to HaKadosh Baruch Hu with 100 tears." Like, cry your heart out. Cry your heart out. Beg Hashem for forgiveness. That you can't believe that you did it. That you messed up. That you didn't know. Like, really, really cry your heart out. And after that, you know, you're finished. Why? Once you cry your heart out for something, that's it. You feel already. It's not a matter of, "I'm sorry for it." It's that you've cried so much over something that you're disgusted with it already. It's disgusting. It's like, ugh. And that's really where you need to get to. So it's not a whole new teshuva. It's just about elevating your teshuva a little bit more to get to a point of disgust with the sin.
1:46:23get to a point of disgust. I think the shiur we did last week talked about disgust in life. I highly recommend that shiur to people on a regular basis. I think it's a very important hashkafic teaching to know that, in essence, our goal, our aspiration should be to become disgusted by the sins, not just stay away from them, but become disgusted by them. Ariel is asking a question. In the Talmud, Masechet Gittin, page 57a, it says that Yeshu told Onkelos to convert, which you have mentioned in the past. My question is, doesn't it say elsewhere that a liar in this world is also a liar in the next world? Yes, it does say a liar in this world is a liar in the next world. But Yeshu wasn't necessarily known to be a liar. He was known to be an arrogant womanizer.
1:47:27It was an arrogant womanizer, and he chased women, and he was an adulterer like his mother, and he had a big ego. So even when his rabbi told him to do teshuvah, he didn't do it. So obviously, when a person gets burned in Gehinnom on a regular basis by a fecal manner and so on, there's really no room for ego over there. uh so uh that's the case but uh um you know it's not necessarily the the liar part the more of the lies were done after him rather than by him uh neshama is asking does Torah talk about burning sage in one's home to do a cleansing And is this practice forbidden? Ah, okay. No, I mean, there are different Kabbalistic things that some Mekubalim do for spiritual cleansing and so on. But generally speaking, this stuff is not really practiced by real Kabbalists anymore because a lot of the stuff that used to be problematic in the past,
1:48:44almost is almost unheard of, and also most of the stuff that anyone would ever need is very easy to get. First of all, make sure that in your house, there is someone learning Torah on a regular basis. Not all the time—it doesn't necessarily need to be 24 hours in the Beit Midrash But make sure that the people of the house, the man of the house, are learning Torah every day. An hour, two hours, three hours a day they're learning Torah. They're doing mitzvot, they're following things, and so on. That's number one. The second thing is to make sure you have very good quality mezuzot. Very good quality mezuzot, that's critical. The third is to eliminate any form of idolatry. ...any form of idolatry from your house. You have to be very careful with idolatry; eliminate it. Fourth is any type of immorality or immodesty. You have to eliminate it from the house. So when a person does these few things... have somebody learning it a lot, they have good quality mezuzot, they don't have idolatry or immorality in the house, they don't need any more spiritual cleansing than that. And if they do, it's probably better for them to move, because then they probably have some type of dybbuk or something in the house, or some type of demon in the house that only a few people in the world know how to remove.
1:50:08Uh, if a Jew doubles the speed of a 10-minute shiur, meaning 2x speed, what will his reward be based on? Either 10 minutes or five minutes? Five minutes. You didn't learn 10 minutes of Torah; you learned five minutes of Torah. Uh, so therefore, you get a reward for five minutes. If one removed the light bulb from inside the fridge, but the switch that closes or opens the circuit inside the fridge is still opening and closing the circuit, does that count as being completed? No. If the light is not being turned on, then it's fine. You're perfectly fine as long as the light is not being turned on and off. Yesterday, he spoke about Oneg Shabbat. How is a Noahide supposed to keep Oneg Shabbat? A Noahide is not supposed to keep Shabbat, period. There is no Shabbat for Noahides. For a Noahide to keep Shabbat is a violation of the Torah. They're not allowed to keep Shabbat because it's considered stealing, which is a violation of one of the seven commandments for the Noahides. They're not allowed to steal. Shabbat is a covenant between Me and you, Me and the Jewish people, not Me and the world. Shabbat is a Jewish mitzvah. A Noahide that keeps Shabbat, Rambam says, it's a death penalty.
1:51:28uh, so a Noahide is not allowed to keep Shabbat. Now, the exception to the rule is if that Noahide is in a legitimate conversion process, and even then, they only keep 99% of Shabbat. 99% meaning they have to intentionally desecrate Shabbat with something small, like turning on or off a light or something like that on Shabbat one time. but in that particular case, a person that's in the process of conversion would keep Shabbat and oneg Shabbat just like a Jew. But if they're not intending to convert in the near future, they are not allowed to keep Shabbat, and therefore oneg Shabbat is not relevant. Saul is asking, is there a way to say a bracha before drinking from a water fountain? It feels like no, due to not having all the water in one cup. You don't need to have all the water in one cup to make a bracha. If you're thirsty, you have to make a bracha. It's not a matter of it being in a cup. If you're thirsty, if you're drinking because you're thirsty, then you have to make a bracha before you drink.
1:52:41Jack is asking a question to people who are converting: What incentive do they have to convert? Why convert? If you could achieve the same results as a righteous Gentile, like Job, Noah, Chanoch, or Adam, if you want to attain higher spirituality, who's to stop you? Why the need to go through the whole process of conversion? Because you're going to be held responsible for your sins. Isn't it better to stay a righteous Gentile than to be a Jew? You're almost guaranteed great rewards. It's hard being a righteous Jew. Think of it as being a righteous Gentile and a heretic. Okay, I get the point. all right, so why would anybody convert? Now, of course, everybody has their own reasons for why they want to convert, and I'll tell you some things as far as the reasons that I've heard through the many, many converts that I've dealt with over the years. I'll also tell you some of the reasons they should convert even if they don't know. As far as the reasons why people convert to Judaism, one of them is because they want more than just an unorganized way of serving Hashem. As a Noahide, generally speaking, Noahides do not have an organized format of serving Hashem. So, when they pray, they pray from their own words. They don't pray from a siddur. When they
1:53:59are doing something like eating, there's no blessing, no holidays, no gatherings of the community. Even though there are a few places where there are Noahide communities, generally speaking, there's no real legitimate... Noahide communities everywhere. So really, when you are a Noahide, you're on your own. You're on your own, and it's very difficult to remain on your own as far as growing that over time. Why? Because you may be okay being on your own since you've already lived life, seen the world, and decided that this is the right way. But your kids may want to go somewhere else. Your kids may want to go in a different direction. So your kids that are on the path with you in the beginning as a Noahide, one day they're going to grow up. They're going to want to go and date and get married to somebody. And they may meet somebody. that they could believe they could build a family with that's not only not a Noahide, but is actually an idol worshiper. So what are you going to tell them? No, you're not allowed to marry a Christian because you're a Noahide? Good luck with that one. So the longevity of a Noahide is very, very difficult to maintain. That's another reason. The third reason is that people want to be part of the Chosen People.
1:55:17They want to be part of Klal Yisrael because they know Am Yisrael is special. Am Yisrael is the oldest nation in the world. It's the nation that outlived all of its enemies. And B'ezrat Hashem will continue to outlive all of its enemies. All of the people that tried to destroy us, Hashem destroyed them. All of the enemies of Am Yisrael, HaKadosh Baruch Hu, removed from the world and protected us. Despite the whole process being very painful, we are here and they are not. Now, the Noachides don't have such protection because there is no Noachide nation. There is no Noachide nation. So if, let's say, you're an Asian Noachide and people decide that we're going to go to war with Asia, we're going to go to war with China or India or something like that, there's no unity among the Noachides in that country. know or even around the world. But a Jew, a Jew doesn't matter if he lives in India or he lives in Pakistan. It doesn't matter if he lives in Australia or America. It doesn't matter if he lives in a hole or a mansion. Once there's issues in the world, we unite. We simply unite. Why? Because we all know, at the end of the day, they're uniting us even if we don't want to unite with each other.
1:56:33uh with each other, so there is a unity, and people want to be part of that unity. That unity is the oldest unity in the world. Uh, so that's another reason. Now, there are some other things that perhaps a person, uh, doesn't understand, uh, whether they're a Noahide, an oppressor of conversion, or they're a convert already, or they're a Jew, and these are the things that they should know. being a righteous Noahide is a lot more difficult than people think. That's why I always tell people, if you have the ability to convert and you don't, you are an idiot. Why? Because converting to become a Jew gives you not only a bigger burden of mitzvot, if you will, and so on, but in reality it's a bigger opportunity to serve Hashem on a higher level. uh, but aside from that, it gives you a "get out of jail free card" that you don't have as a Noahide. What's that "get out of jail free card"? Teshuva. Teshuva is a special gift Hashem gave to Am Yisrael, meaning that although all people can technically repent and say "I'm sorry" to Hashem.
1:57:46If the person is a Jew and they repent at the highest level, they do teshuva at the highest level, meaning not just from fear of punishment and Gehinnom, but also from fear of the Almighty and His Majesty, and even out of loving Him and so on, kadosh, who turns all of the sins into mitzvot. They get rewarded for some of their mistakes in the past due to this teshuva. But even if they don't reach the highest level of teshuva, they still reduce the punishment because the intentional sins become accidental, and the accidental sins become pretty much non-existent. The Noahide doesn't have such a thing. Noahide says, "I'm sorry." Hashem says, "Okay, no problem. I accept it and I forgive you, but I still have to punish you. Not permanently like it was before, but you will still have to be punished. Why? Because the teshuva, the full teshuva, the irrational teshuva, is only a special gift for the Jewish people." So that's also when it comes to Gehinnom.
1:58:53The options are much better for the Jew, to say the least. as far as avoiding punishment, the same thing goes with heaven. The heaven of a righteous Noahide is nothing in comparison to the heaven of a righteous Jew. Meaning, if you're already going to serve Hashem to the best of your ability and so on, you want to get the best, you know, the best price for what you're doing, right? the highest level of heaven for a Noahide is nowhere near, nowhere near, the standard heaven for a Jew. They have a lower level, a lower heaven. It's a completely different heaven, and it's much lower than a Jew's heaven, both because the Jew has to do a lot more in order to earn heaven and also because there's a lot more on the line for the Jew to lose if they don't follow suit.
1:59:54so the heaven, the reward for a Jew, is worlds apart from the Noahide. There's nothing in comparison. There isn't a special protection over the Noahide like there is for the Jew. know both spiritual and physical. Hashem did not promise the righteous Noahides that He'll feed them and bathe them and never eliminate them and so on and so forth. All those promises are only for Jews. All those promises are only for Jews. There are special blessings for Jews. Now, of course, there are blessings for righteous Noahides, but let's not think for a moment it's the same thing. Even if they are righteous, it's not the same thing. It's not the same thing. That's another thing. uh also in regards to the gentiles that you're mentioning—Noah, Iyov, and so on—they are not normal Noahides. Why are they not normal Noahides? Because there was no other option beforehand.
2:01:06uh, so even though technically Avraham is considered a Noahide, if you will, he's not considered a Noahide like a Noahide would be today. Why? Because the Torah wasn't given yet. They're only considered Noahides because the Torah wasn't officially given to the entire people yet. They... they had it and they followed it, but it wasn't a nation yet. So, they were only in that class because there wasn't a Jew officially yet until Mount Sinai. So, a Noahide of today is not related to Jacob. not related to Isaac. It's not necessarily related to Abraham, you know. So, so that's that's a completely different category. Everyone is related to Noah because the world restarted all over again from Noah, or the same thing with Adam. Same thing, also with Job. Job lived at a time before Matan Torah, before the acceptance of the Torah.
2:02:08So, so that's another thing. So it's not the same type of thing. The other thing is also, again, you can't really put the average person of today in the same caliber as the most righteous people that ever lived. You know, Iyov is one of the most righteous people that ever lived. Iyov is one of the most righteous people that ever lived. Chanoch turned into an angel. He became Malach Metatron. He's not even a human being anymore. Adam HaRishon, for all intents and purposes, also is not really a typical human being. So it's not really the same apple-to-apple relationship. Type of thing and also the expectation that Hashem had from those people that you're mentioning is much higher than He does for a regular Noahide of today. Therefore, their reward was much higher, but also His tolerance for mistakes of your typical Noahide today is very different. So that's another thing—the reward and the punishment and the teshuva...
2:03:15pretty much the whole spiritual aspect, the whole spiritual world of the Jew, is completely different than the Noahide—completely different. And so, that's another thing. Longevity, like I said before, is almost non-existent in a Noahide world. And if a person can convert, they should convert. ...but really the biggest thing would be that if a person truly loves Hashem, then they should want to serve Him in the best possible way. You know, if a person truly loves their wife, they should express their love to their wife in the best possible way and not just say, "Hey, listen... What's, what's, you know, say it, speak, speak. Oh, he writes her a text message, you know, "143." Speak, say something. Why? You really love me? Say something. Say something. "I love you." What are you, a mute? Say something. You're shy? You're not shy when, you know, come on. So it's the same thing. A person serving HaKadosh Baruch Hu: "I love you, Hashem," but they only want to serve Him with a few mitzvot? It's a joke.
2:04:30So the more a person loves Hashem, the more they want to serve Hashem. They have to look at the mitzvot as opportunities to connect to Hashem, as opportunities to serve Hashem, as opportunities to love, to show the expression of love to Hashem. That's what a person who loves Hashem does. And just because they're serving Him less, doesn't mean that their punishment is less. That's a mistake. Because the punishment for a Noahide is much more severe much more severe in many cases than a Jew. Why? Because, for example, we have different punishments for different sins as Jews. If a person steals and he returns it on his own, then he's okay. If he steals and he gets caught, he has to pay double. A non-Jew steals, it's a death penalty. whether he steals one dollar or he steals a hundred billion dollars, it's the death penalty. Death penalty by the Torah. Okay, everything for the non-Jew is a death penalty. There is no, like, "Oh, slap him on the wrist, whip him a little bit, say I'm sorry." No, everything is the death penalty for the Noahide. So it's not exactly the ideal situation for someone who can do more.
2:05:52for someone that can serve Hashem better. Because, again, although there are more mitzvot, there is less punishment if you mess up. There are more ways to rectify, there's more leniency to fix certain things, and there's more mercy. In so many words, it's a bigger deal, but it's a better deal. whereas the Noahide thinks that he's saving himself with some time and some obligations, but it's not necessarily the case. If he messes up in anything, which he will, he is earning himself a punishment that is severe. That's it. It's just the reality of things. So that's why I tell people: don't think that just because you have fewer mitzvot, you have a better deal. It's not a better deal. It's a lesser reward. It's, in many cases, a bigger punishment. And there are many more ways to mess up than people imagine. Many more ways to mess up than people imagine. And I think personally, for a person that has, Baruch Hashem, a family, and as being one of my...
2:06:59most important things in my life, but also one of the things that I talk to people about more than most things. I think that anybody that's in this world, that's not a teenager, someone that's already married and thinking about the future and so on, wants longevity, wants their kids to continue doing what they're doing. It's almost impossible to do that as a Noahide. It's almost impossible to do that as a Noahide. Pretty much, it's very likely that the Noahides' children will either go to and become a different religion of idolatry. Sometimes they'll become Jews. But many times they'll become atheists or agnostic, as they call it. But really, it's just another form of atheism because they just live in the world like an animal and listen to nothing and no one. So it's not such a great bargain like people think. And as soon as a person has the ability to convert, they should convert immediately because the Gemara says that anyone who delays their own conversion
2:08:13not because the beit din converts delays it or financial difficulties delay it or things like that, but they themselves delayed because they, you know, want to have a good time. They want to make some more sins for longer. That's not really sin for them anymore. They'll actually get punished for that once they become a Jew. Hashem will actually rebuke them for not converting sooner because they already knew the truth and they delayed serving Him to full potential. The Gemara says that Hashem will punish them for it. The ideal situation for a person is to serve Hashem at the highest possible capacity. In so many words, you wake up in the morning only because Hashem allowed you to wake up, and your whole job of the day is to serve Hashem and connect Hashem to everything you do in your life. even if you're working and you're cleaning bathrooms or you're selling cars or you're building houses or whatever, you have to connect Hashem to everything that you do. That's how a person is supposed to live, from morning until sleep. Hashem is part of their life and part of their thoughts.
2:09:19day and, you know, every day and really try to emulate our forefathers who literally thought about Hashem 24 hours a day, seven days a week, to the point where they were able to manipulate nature because they really didn't belong among the commoners of the world, as they were so holy. So, when a person is annoyed and It's not necessarily as easy to do that because you're also surrounded by people that are most likely not in the same direction as you. Whereas in the Jewish world, there are Jewish communities where you'll have some really good people that you can have support back and forth with, build something together, and be part of a community. uh, you don't really have that in the Noahide world, so that community can mean a lot to somebody. Now, again, a person can become holy as a righteous Noahide, there's no question about it. It says that whether Jew or gentile, whether man or woman, whether a rich person or a maidservant
2:10:32uh, you know, everyone can get to a point of having ruach hakodesh, you know, as far as, uh, you know, having an extraordinary spiritual power that's beyond our comprehension, if they're holy enough. Not because they woke up on the right side of the bed, but if they, you know, sanctify themselves, they can get to a point of ruach hakodesh. But that's going to be a lot more difficult to do if you're surrounded by, uh, you know, a bunch of idol worshipers. which is very common in the vast majority of the world. And you're going to say, no, no, I'll go to, I'll live in a religious Jewish community. So if you're going to live in a religious Jewish community with the kollel next door and a synagogue next door, why don't you just become a Jew? What, you think you're saving yourself any punishment, any responsibility because of it? You're not. actually, uh, you're actually taking a very, very big risk, a much bigger risk than you can imagine. Because if you do mess up, your way back home is much more difficult, much more difficult. So, if a person can convert, they should, and they should do it as soon as they possibly can.
2:11:40We're almost done. I guess, dear Rabbi, that you are my rabbi. There is no one within 30 miles of where I am. Okay, no problem. It's just that you have to do whatever you possibly can to move closer to a Jewish community. You have to move closer to a Jewish community. For now, you know, obviously... We do the best that we possibly can, but to communicate and to talk to anyone that asks us questions and so on, that's important. But a person should do their best to move closer to whoever their rabbi is. You don't necessarily need to live next door to your rabbi. My rabbi lives in Eretz Yisrael. But I make sure that I do whatever I can to, you know, and exert myself as much as I can to make sure that I'm always on the same page as my rabbi. Now, of course, I have a little bit of a unique blessing in my life that my rabbi is also my chavruta and he's also my partner in the organization of B'ezrat Hashem.
2:12:41And he's also pretty much the most important person in my life. That's a very unique situation. So I talk to him every day in one form or another and so on. But nonetheless, if a person is not as fortunate to have such a thing, that doesn't mean that they can't have a very successful relationship with their rabbi. They could have a successful relationship with their rabbi, but it's all based on how much you invest in it. If you invest a lot into that relationship, you'll get a lot. If you invest little into that relationship, you'll get little. Simple. Can you show proof that it's the same results of being a Noahide or a Jew? I would like to see that. No, it's not the same results. It's not the same results. I guess you're asking somebody else. Okay, uh, is there a t'shuva for non-Jews? I already answered that. Uh, Yosef is saying, "Please don't answer for the rabbi." Thank you, Yosef. It would be nice if people didn't answer for me, but you know, I guess maybe I take too long to answer the questions. Alright, last question. I'm kind of tired. I have another shiur coming up in a couple of hours.
2:13:48I'll be watching the baby dog over the week for somebody. The dog needs attention, or else it cries. I know you said you shouldn't sleep in the same room as dogs, but would this be an exception? No, you should not sleep in the same room as a dog. Let him cry. You could put him outside. You could put him in a kennel. You should not sleep in the same room as a dog. Needless to say, you should never sleep in the same bed as a dog. That's a terrible idea. But don't feel so bad if you did. I used to also. I had a dog for 16 years. His name was Bully. At the time, he was like my son. And that's before I had kids. But once I had kids, I understood that there's no comparison between dogs and kids. even though they both drive you crazy. But the point being is that, you know, when I learned some of the things about issues of dogs and so on, I realized it's a mistake. It's a mistake to own a dog. If you don't own one, you shouldn't get one. It's my opinion, though. But, you know, some people love dogs. They want to have it. You're allowed to have it.
2:14:54But if you're going to have it, you still should not make any exceptions as far as allowing the dogs to sleep in your bed and things like that. That's just inappropriate. It's inappropriate for a lot of reasons. It's bad for marriage. It's bad for a relationship. It's bad for the issues of taharah and tumah (purity and impurity). It's just not good. Just listen to what I'm saying to you. It's just not good. You want to do it? Do it. But, you know, don't. That's my suggestion. Uh, can Satan falsely fulfill one's prayer when he hears one making a supplication to Hashem? I'm aware he can't read one's mind, but can't he hear when one prays out loud? i mean, as far as reading the mind, it's not necessarily the case that he can't read the mind. because, i mean, you have a yetzer hara, and your yetzer hara is based on your mind; it's not based on what you say. so you're thinking, "oh, i want to go and watch a shiur Torah, i want to go to kollel," but then your yetzer hara says, "yeah, but maybe you could watch sports." where's that? yet you didn't say it out loud.
2:16:04you're saying it in your mind and you're still fighting, you know, fighting against yourself, and one part of you says to go to the Beit Midrash and learn Torah or watch a shiur Torah, and the other one is saying to go watch basketball. Where is that? That's in your mind. So I don't know who told you that he can't read your mind, but that's not true. and as far as whether he could fulfill somebody's prayer, yeah, I mean, there's a lot of traps of the Satan, and sometimes the Satan will give you an indication that your wrong direction is the right direction, but I believe that if a person is, the closer a person is to the Torah, and he has an understanding of what he needs to do, he has a Rabbi that's going to guide him in one way or another, then Satan will have fewer tools to trap him in such places. If you are going to buy a home that you know Avoda Zara was practiced in, how do you cleanse it?
2:17:10depends what level of avoda zara was practiced in it. Meaning that if it was a church, there is a halacha that says that if there is no other choice, you are allowed to turn a church into a synagogue, but you have to remove everything from it. Meaning you have to, you know, remove any furniture; you can't reuse the furniture. Paint the walls, and pretty much replace as much as you possibly can—anything that would accept tumah. And the same concept with a home. Obviously, don't keep any of their furniture or any of the things that they used. uh, based on how much avodah was practiced, if they're, let's say, you know, idol worshipers, like Christians, Catholics, you know, whatever they are, but they didn't necessarily serve an idol inside the house, they didn't pray to the idol or bow to the idol or do any type of sacrifices to an idol inside the house that they left you
2:18:13you know, for their temple or for their church, then, you know, there's not much work that needs to be done to fix the house. I would recommend painting the house, but the biggest thing is just don't use their furniture and stuff like that, but that's it. But if there was actually legitimate, you know, like church, you know, where people were actually bowing to an idol or serving an idol in one way or another, then there's a little more work that needs to be done. More work that needs to be done to kind of eliminate as much as you possibly can. But again, you know, there are exceptions. It's case by case, and you'd have to review what the situation is. Okay, guys, I have to get some rest. And we have another shiur coming up in Hebrew in the next couple of hours. We will see each other next week. Baruch Adonai le'olam. Amen ve'amen.
2:19:47Seven years of lectures. Seven months of film editing. Countless hours of study by two Rabbis. Information we received over 3,000 years ago. All for this moment. Tekuma had agreed. Remove it. If you sate it, you're never going to have enough. The Yetzer Hara, when it gets a hold of something, does not let go. It's time for us to rectify what we have done. Normal numbers should be somewhere around 20 million or higher.
2:21:17You're never going to have control over it if you start it. You only feed it when it's permissible according to the law. Pornography is as addictive as crack cocaine. Baruch HaDayan HaEmet
2:22:28Baruch HaDayan HaEmet.