Should You Invite Non Observant Guests to Shabbat Dinner If They Drive?
Should you invite non-observant or secular guests to a Friday night Shabbat dinner if you know they are going to drive on Shabbat to get there? In this candid discussion on hosting guests on Shabbat and effective Jewish outreach (Kiruv), Rabbi Yaron Reuven examines why the answer depends entirely on the spiritual substance of the gathering itself. Drawing from his own past experience as a secular businessman attending Shabbat dinners on Friday night, Rabbi Reuven explains why simply offering free kosher food, challah, and socializing without Torah learning or a shiur fails to inspire Teshuva or motivate guests to keep mitzvot. Authentic KIRUV and meaningful Shabbat hospitality require more than treating Friday night like a social club or a weekly vacation—guests need to hear the Emet (truth) about Torah obligations, the Ten Commandments, and the real spiritual purpose behind keeping Shabbat. Even if someone drives to their first Shabbat dinner, hearing the unapologetic truth of Judaism plants a seed that can inspire them to stay locally or walk the next time. Watch to learn how pairing warm Jewish hospitality with real Torah education fulfills the true mission of outreach and helps secular Jews genuinely connect to Judaism. Full Shiur: Torah Foundation 41 https://youtu.be/_byNqJDEYxs Want to support our KIRUV work? Please partner with us to help Am Yisrael keep Shabbat and more! https://www.beezrathashem.org/donate Rabbi Yaron Reuven's short Torah Clips channel – Please Share The Video To Help Others Do TeShuva. AI RABBI by BeEzrat HaShem Inc. https://www.AIRabbi.org Answers To Jewish Torah Life Questions In 30 Languages. Discover Jewish Wisdom at Your Fingertips, Rabbi Reuven's AI Rabbi offers wisdom and guidance in multiple languages, drawing from trusted, reliable sources. #Torah #Jewish #RabbiYaronReuven #Shabbat 00:00 The answer is, it depends... 02:42 Rabbi Reuven's personal example of "Shabbat Dinner" 05:45 What is Judaism? 09:26 People have to be told the truth 00:00:00 Intoduction 00:00:03 Event's True Value 00:01:19 Inspire Jewish Connection 00:02:16 My Shabbat Story 00:04:08 More Than Free Food 00:04:52 Torah is Judaism 00:06:34 Unashamedly Teach Torah 00:07:59 Consequences for Change 00:08:59 Clearly State Mitzvot 00:11:28 Urgent Kiruv: Add Truth
Transcript
0:03Right, whether to bring secular people to a Shabbat event or not, it's not an easy question. And the reason why is because it all depends on the event itself more than it does on the people. If the event is like many events, which are simply a big feast, a bunch of people eating, drinking, socializing, but that's pretty much where it ends. No one is doing teshuvah from it. No one is encouraging people to do teshuvah. It's just simply a big free food gathering. Then to such a thing, I do not see any value in it whatsoever because the people that are coming to it, they may meet some new friends, but they're not gonna become more connected to Judaism as a result of it. They may end up finding a girlfriend, She may end up finding a boyfriend, but that's not going to make them more Jewish. That's just going to make them more sins. So if that's the event, no, I wouldn't invite people to it. Why? The event itself inherently has no value. It's just free food. Now, if the event is similar to what we have here, where there's food,
1:19there's a shiur, there's questions and answers, there's some socializing, there's some things that everyone could take home something, something everybody could get value out of it, then yes, there's a value to it, why? Because the person is going to get some food, he's going to get some music in a minute, he's going to get some socializing, he may meet somebody, maybe it's another business partner, maybe it's a future marriage partner, whatever it is, but there is hope that at some point during that night, that person will be inspired to become more Jewish. So if the event is similar to something like this, then yes, bring them. I can tell you from my own personal experience, When I was in the business world, I used to have rabbis come to my office at least three times a week. And this one particular rabbi, he was, apparently, very much connected to the French community, French Jewish community. He was a Chabadnik, and he came from France, but he had a whole community of French Jews.
2:43and he would have these big feasts every Friday night, and he invited me to it. And I went there one time, and I didn't live anywhere close to this place. I had to drive to go there, which obviously was where I erred, because he would come to my office 15 times a day sometimes. So he knew where I was, he knew where the event was, there was simply no way of me walking there. So I went there, I saw a bunch of Jews, some were young kids, some were older people, some were this, some were that. I saw a bunch of food. It was free. It was wonderful. But guess what? There was nothing Jewish about it from my perspective as a secular person. Why? Okay, so I'm eating. Okay, so the guy next to me is Jewish. How does that obligate me to keep Shabbat? The guy told me, "Drive." I asked him, "Is it okay if I drive?" He said, "Yeah, just come. So, meaning that there was nothing about it that for me, I'm telling you from a secular perspective mindset, there was zero about it that made me desire to do any mitzvah or to keep Shabbat at all. All I know is that it was an opportunity to maybe meet some people. It was an opportunity to eat. It was an opportunity to go to a new place that I haven't been to, but that's it. The next Shabbat,
4:08nothing happened. My life did not change. So I agree that there are a lot of good things that Chabad has done. There is certainly good that they have something in these places that are in the middle of nowhere, and people that are visiting Thailand and all types of places in the world, they have a place to go celebrate Shabbat. I agree, it's good. There's a place that has kosher food, that has Shabbat dinners and so on. No problem. I don't have a problem with it. But if that's your only way, just give him free food on Friday night. That's the end-all, be-all mission of Kiruv. I'm sorry. It's not enough. not enough. A secular person is not going to be inspired to become more Jewish as a result of eating challah and gefilte fish. It will never happen. And if he's Sephardic like me, he'll probably become Christian before he becomes, uh, you know, because Sephardim don't get along with gefilte fish.
5:14But guess what? My Ashkenazi students and friends and so on, they love it. I say, "Enjoy. Take all of it. Take my piece also. No problem." But with all jokes aside, food is not enough to make you want to be Jewish. There are plenty of people that, you know, attach themselves to the customs as if they are mitzvot. And unfortunately, the customs are not the mitzvot. It gets to a joke level where it says that if Shabbat was a custom, everyone would keep it. But the truth is that if we want Jews to return to Judaism, we have to explain to them what Judaism is. Judaism is following the Torah. Without the Torah, there is no Judaism. Without Torah, there is no Judaism. There's no such thing as "I'm Jewish, but I don't believe in the Torah." It's not such a thing. Even if a person puts on tefillin every day, and he says Shema Yisrael, and he gives tzedakah, and he does all 613 mitzvot somehow – he's a Kohen, he's a Levi, he's a Yisrael, he's everything; he's a man, he's a woman, he's everything – but he doesn't believe that Torah is from Shamayim? Guess what? He is not considered a kosher Jew. He's considered a heretic. He has no share in the world to come.
6:34Because Judaism without Torah is not Judaism. It's nothing. So if we're going to show them the beautiful parts of Shabbat without explaining to them why we have Shabbat, why it's not just another day of the week that's a vacation. It's not an off day from work. It's not a day to have dinner. Guess what? When I was in business, I didn't have to wait till Friday night to have dinner. I ate dinner every night at different restaurants. and some of them had a lot better food than I had that Friday night over there. So a person has to understand that it's not enough, especially today, when there's a wealth of information out there that's coming at everybody from everywhere. We can't be shy about what we represent. The Christians are not shy about what they represent. The Muslims are not shy about what they represent. They tell people right to their face, listen, if you don't believe in what we believe, you're going to hell. That's what they say. That's if you're a Muslim, they tell you, listen, if you're not Muslim, you're part of the kuffar, you're part of the heretics, you're going to Jahannam, you're going to hell, to Gehenna. And the Christians say the same thing. If you don't believe in Yeshu, you're going to hell. They're not shy about what they believe. Whether the guy's religious, not religious, Jewish, not Jewish, black, white, they're not shy. And guess what? Their system works a whole lot better than ours.
7:59why does it work? Because they tell people what they believe in, even though what they believe in is a lie. They preach it like it's the truth. We preach the truth like it's a lie, like we're shy, we're not sure. Listen, come for Shabbat. What is it? Oh, it's just a nice opportunity to have dinner with the family, be around, you know, other fellow Jews. Okay, yeah, free dinner Friday. Okay, I'll see you there. What else does it come with? Listen, we'll talk nice stories. Okay, I'll hear stories. Okay, I ate, I drank, I heard the story about some rabbi from 3,000 years ago, great. I'll see you next Friday, and I'll see you every Friday for the next 20 years. But I will not observe a single Shabbat in the process. Why? You did not tell me any consequences, any obligations, anything that would make me believe I have to do this. It's not a recommendation. So,
8:59I love the fact that Chabad does great things to feed the poor when they do, to help the people that don't put out to fill in, to whatever good they do, I agree. But as a word to the wise from someone that's been doing this day and night, sacrificing every moment of my existence for more than a decade now, if you do not tell people that there is A consequence: they simply do not get it on their own. They don't arrive. They're not Avraham Avinu that they arrive at the conclusion on their own. They say, "Listen, if I don't do this," they're not going to arrive. You have to tell people this is not a recommendation. And again, I'm not saying give them a shiur, but gain them on day one, like Avraham Avinu gave to all of his guests. But people need to know it's not a vacation. Shabbat is a day that you're not allowed to drive. Now, even if the guy still chooses to drive, he at least was taught that he's not allowed to drive. So you tell the guy you have to eat kosher all the time. And even if the guy eats a cheeseburger 20 minutes after he leaves, at least he heard it's not allowed. So guess what?
10:10That cheeseburger will not taste as good now. Why? Because in the back of his mind, he heard it's not allowed. So in the back of his mind, his consciousness is punching him a little bit. It's like, listen, the Rabbi just told you it's not allowed. Okay, maybe next time. The sin doesn't taste as sweet once you know it's a sin. But as long as nobody told me that I'm doing anything wrong, why should I change? Why would I change? Why would I leave my non-Jewish girlfriend? Why? She's pretty. She's nice to me. She's this. She's that. Why should I leave her? If you don't tell me it's not allowed, if you don't tell me I'm going to get punished for it, if you don't tell me my life's going to go to— it's going to be a hell on this Earth and the next if I don't leave her, why should I leave her? She's nicer to me than all the Jewish people that I know. Why should I leave her? If you don't tell me that stealing is not okay, why should I stop stealing? Okay, so it was his stuff. Now it became my stuff. So what? Yeah, but he worked hard for it. I also worked hard to steal it. You know how hard it is to steal money without getting caught? So unless you tell me that what I'm doing is wrong and it will have a consequence, I will not figure it out on my own, because the yetzer is working overtime to convince me that I'm already going in the right direction. So to simply give people free food,
11:28and hope that they're going to arrive at the right conclusion on their own, it's simply not going to work. And even in the cases where there's an anomaly where it works, it takes too long. We don't have that kind of time anymore. Moshiach is around the corner. Whoever got to the stop is there. Whoever's not there is not there. There's no more, I'll wait 20 years for this guy. I got to give him the information. Whatever he decides, he decides. That's why I always tell people, "Listen, can you call my cousin, my friend, my so-on, and convince him?" I'm sorry, I don't have that kind of time. Why? Because his blood is not redder than everybody else's. I can give a shiur that will impact thousands of people. He can watch one of those. To spend the same amount of time talking to him one-on-one, it's not worth it. Because I can use that same amount of time to talk to 5,000 people. not that kind of time where I could dedicate 40 minutes to every single phone call, I'm sorry. Why? I could use that 40 minutes to impact 5,000 people. I'm not going to impact one guy. It's not worth it. So we have to do the best we can with with the mindset that we're running out of time. So dinner? Yes, free dinner? Even better. Invite them? Yes, but just add
12:46a little bit of emes into that. What? Tom. Listen, by the way, Shabbat was one of the ten commandments. So, at the very least, the guy, even if he doesn't plan on keeping it, at least he heard something. Unless he heard something that obligates him to that. Maybe next week I'm gonna come but I'm gonna get a hotel instead of driving. I'm gonna get a hotel and I'll walk here. Or next week I'll stay at the Rabbi's house. Or next week I'll do something. And I think that's the goal. So if they can add that recipe to it, it becomes a fantastic kiruv, chesed, and everything else. And I think that was the original intention of the Lubavitcher Rebbe when he started this whole thing, was to do kiruv. It wasn't just simply, you know, to get a bunch of free dinners to people.