BeEzrat HaShem

STINGY HERESY, Gift Ideas, NDE DEMONS, NonKosher Meds, Gnevat Daat, DOGS - Stump The Rabbi (154)

3 years ago
Transcript

0:00This year is packed with a lot of good stuff. First off, we go into the weekly parsha. Hashem says, "Build for Me a sanctuary." Does that mean that Hashem needs us in order to build Him a sanctuary? Is it relevant today? Are you supposed to build anything today? There are certain institutions that are saying that they're building the next Beit HaMikdash. Is it allowed? Is it frowned upon? Even more so, day-to-day, we deal with cheap people. Is that a disease that simply violates the Torah on a personal basis or a national basis? Aside from that, you have things that are happening in business every day. For example, if somebody is in the building business, but they have bids coming from different places, are they allowed to show favoritism for one company over another? If you have a young girl and she wants to start wearing makeup, is she allowed? At what age is she allowed to do so? Are dogs something good or bad for a Jewish household? And many, many more questions that are interesting, intriguing, and relevant to everybody's life, whether you're Chasidish, Litvish, Ashkenazi, Sephardi, Baal Teshuva, convert. Bottom line is, if you care about Hashem and you want to be holy, this lecture is for you. Enjoy, share, and if you'd like to support, please do so on our website, bhtorah.org or bezratHashem.org.

1:14we're back here on our Wednesday night "Stump the Rabbi" questions and answers. Sure, we're after some debate about the weekly parasha and some relevant things that can help our lives. We're going to go into some questions that I'm sure all of you have, but tonight is going to be for the um and all the wonderful things that the organization is doing. Just as a reminder for you guys, we mentioned last night the two campaigns that we have. We have the Purim campaign to help the poor people in Eretz Yisrael. We're actually trying to arrange about a thousand Torah scholars to study for a couple of hours during Purim itself, which is a very auspicious time to study because everything is closed and very few people study during that time.

2:27So specifically, we want people to study during this time. So we're arranging a special kollel for that time. So anyone that's going to be contributing to that campaign is not only going to be helping the poor, but it's also going to be helping a Torah scholar. So anyone that wants to donate for it and... Join us in this mitzvah. Go to bhtorah.org. Also, as a side note, what I mentioned last night, for anyone that is interested in helping us publish my new book, it's in Hebrew. And B'ezrat Hashem it will be in the market for free, as the rest of our materials are, probably in the next few months. So, anyone that wants to help us, wants to be part of this extraordinary mitzvah, you can simply contact us or you can just donate on the regular website bhtorah.org or bezratashem.org and simply let us know that that's what it's for. Baruch Hashem, I already have a couple of people that jumped on it, my dear brothers,

3:32uh, you know, found out about the, uh, the book and, uh, we're very excited to be part of it. So that's one of the, uh, great middot of, uh, Yisrael—being zealous for mitzvot. As soon as they hear about a mitzvah opportunity, they jump on it. But, of course, you know, one of the, uh, things that we have today is that we have a lot of opportunities to do mitzvot. Quite frankly, if you look at the history of Am Yisrael, with the exception of the time of Shlomo HaMelech, where even the streets—there were certain streets that were full of gold—the financial status of Am Yisrael at that time was unlike any other. Right now, the status of the world at large, but also the Jewish world, financially speaking, is very good. But yet, you're still seeing that there are many people struggling financially. You're still seeing that the world of Torah is struggling financially. There are many Avrechim, many Torah scholars, and

4:36that are barely making ends meet, struggling to pay their basic expenses. Many yeshivot are having a tough time remaining open or starting a new one. There are several people that want to start a Sephardic girls' seminary in Eretz Yisrael and are having a tough time simply because of money. There are certainly plenty of opportunities to open places here in the U.S., as well as elsewhere, but yet again, there's a shortage of money. So how could it be, on one hand, you have the financial status of the Jewish people being the best it ever was, with the exception of the time of Shlomo HaMelech, But at the same time, the world of Torah is still struggling. It doesn't really make much sense. This is one of the questions we're going to try to answer tonight, B'ezrat Hashem. The other question that we have is, is it connected or is it possible to connect?

5:36Uh, heresy with stinginess—meaning, is it somebody that's stingy, somebody that is cheap, doesn't want to give of what Hashem blessed him with, what Hashem blessed her with? Or even not give enough? Is that some form of heresy? Is it a problem? Is it just simply a personal choice—is your money your money, or is it something that you have to think about twice before you call it your money? These are some of the things that we're going to try to cover tonight briefly, because I know you guys have a lot of questions, but this is actually what Parashat Terumah starts off with. We have the Beit HaMikdash of the desert—the Tabernacle, as they call it in English. In Hebrew, it's the Mishkan, which is what Hashem commands us to build during this week's Parashat Terumah. and, interestingly enough, Hashem gives us, obviously, the specific choice of words to not only teach us about something that happened three thousand three hundred and thirty-four years ago in the desert, but rather something that is very much applicable today. Not that we are allowed to go out there and build a building and call it the Beit HaMikdash—that's forbidden until Mashiach comes. We have no permission to build anything called the Beit HaMikdash.

6:59but nonetheless, Hashem does expect us to read this parasha, learn it, and apply it to our lives each and every single year. How could I possibly apply this parasha to my life every single year when I don't have the opportunity to build the Beit HaMikdash? I don't have the permission to build the Beit HaMikdash. Well, that's one of the things we're going to find out tonight. So, Parashat Terumah in the book of Exodus, chapter 25... begins with Hashem commanding Moshe Rabbeinu to speak to Am Yisrael and tell them about building this Mishkan, this sanctuary. Vayedaber Adonai el Moshe lemor, daber el Bnei Yisrael veyikchu li terumah me'et kol ish asher yedvenu libo, tikchu et terumati, vezot haterumah asher tikchu me'itam: zahav, vakesef, unechoshet. So here we see an extraordinary statement by Hashem that we are going to spend most of the time on. Hashem speaks to Moshe Rabbeinu, saying, "Speak to the children of Israel, and they shall take for me a portion. From every man whose heart motivates him, you shall take my portion. This is the portion that you shall take from them: gold, silver, and copper."

8:16an extraordinary statement by Hashem that we are going to spend most of the time on. Hashem speaks to Moshe Rabbeinu, saying, "Speak to the children of Israel, and they shall take for me a portion. From every man whose heart motivates him, you shall take my portion. This is the portion that you shall take from them: gold, silver, and copper." turquoise, purple, and crimson wool; linen and goat's hair; red-dyed ram skins; tachash skins; acacia wood; oil for illumination; spices for anointment oil, and spices for the ketoret; shoham stones, and stones for the settings for the ephod and for the choshen. they shall make a sanctuary for Me so that I may dwell among them. Up to here, the first eight verses really, at first look, sound like something that happened in history. Most people that are looking at it say, "Oh yeah, this is something that happened three thousand years ago. I'm sure it was very exciting. But where do I find myself in here?" The average person will tell you, "I don't find myself in here. I simply...

9:37maybe it's a story, maybe it's a history, but as far as finding yourself here and your own obligations here, a person has to delve into it. As the Mishnah says, "Delve into it and delve into it, because everything is in it." So, Hashem tells Moshe Rabbeinu to get the people to bring gold and silver and all types of precious goods for it to be used. build this Mishkan to build this Tabernacle, but he uses unique language where he says, "Take for Me a portion." Now, usually, if you're going to ask somebody to give you something, you say, "Give me this portion," not "Take for Me." Why "Take for Me"? It should be "Give me." In fact This is one of the places where the Chachamim explained to us that everything is HaKadosh Baruch Hu. And in essence, when a person gives for the sake of Torah, what they're doing is they're actually giving to themselves.

10:50not giving to God, God is not short of money. In fact, this is actually one of the critical points that Onkelos and several other sages emphasized: the Nefesh HaGer, the Mizrachi, the Gur Aryeh, the Malbim, and Avraham. Needless to say, this would also include the Rambam and his father. Many sages harp on this particular point. to make sure that a person understands what is actually being said here. Because if a person doesn't understand what this sentence is, he can easily turn into a heretic. Therefore, Onkelos explains, this means, speak with the children of Israel and tell them that they shall separate before me a portion for the construction of the Mishkan. What does it mean separate before me? Why isn't he saying take from me? Onkelos specifically translates the words, which literally mean "take from me," as "separate before me" in order to avoid any type of misunderstanding that a person would have that would give him the convoluted thought that Hashem has any need whatsoever for his donations or that the objects of the Mishkan provided anything to Hashem.

12:14because the entire world belongs to Hashem and He needs nothing from it. So if somebody has read the basic commentary of the first couple of verses of Parashat Terumah at least once in their life, automatically they arrive at the conclusion that, number one, Hashem needs nothing. two: Everything we give for the sake of Torah, for the sake of helping, is really giving for our own sake because everything belongs to Hashem. So if He simply chooses to give it to somebody else, you can't get in His way. He's just simply going to give it to them, whether it's going to come from you or somebody else, always remains His choice. You can choose to be the vessel, but He could simply force you to be the vessel if He wants you to be. But either way, the second point is that everything belongs to Hashem. The third point that we actually see here and confirm is that some of the most popular rabbinical speakers in the world today, in the English-speaking world today, are 100 percent heretics according to the Onkelos, according to Nefesh HaChaim, according to the Rambam, according to Mizrachi, according to the Malbim, according to the Gra, according to the basic foundations of the Torah, because they say that God needs you. see here and confirm is that some of the most popular rabbinical speakers in the world today, in the English-speaking world today, are 100 percent heretics according to the Onkelos, according to Nefesh HaChaim, according to the Rambam, according to Rav Mizrachi, according to the Malbim, according to the Gra, according to the basic foundations of the Torah, because they say that God needs you

13:36And here, in this particular verse, we have the one time in the entire Torah that Hashem says, "Take from Me," as if we're giving Him something. He says, no, no, no. I said, "Take from Me," not "Give Me." Take something that I already gave you and put it towards the Torah, towards building a sanctuary. Don't misunderstand that I actually need this. Don't misunderstand that any mitzvah that you do, whether it be donations, or prayer, or learning Torah or anything else that you do is to God's benefit. Hence, the reason why Onkelos emphasizes that you need to understand this verse clearly, and that's why he translates it not in the same way as the literal translation, but rather in the actual interpretation of what it means. So there's no misunderstanding that, unfortunately, has become common today. for the same reason, Rashi also avoids the literal interpretation of "for Me," where he explains this term to mean that each person must dedicate his donation for Hashem, meaning for the name of Hashem, not due to any type of social pressure or personal gain. Meaning

15:01uh, the uh, take for me the uh, uh, this uh, terumah, this portion is meaning do it for My name, not for My benefit. Don't misunderstand these words or any other words in the Tanach to mean that God is benefiting from anything that you do. This is Rashi from 900 years ago; you simply cannot disagree with Rashi. You cannot disagree with the Rishonim. no such option doesn't make a difference if a later sage would ever say anything else or sound like anything else. So here we have Onkelos, we have Nefesh HaChaim, we have Rashi, we have the Malbim, we have the Gur Aryeh, we have Mizrachi, and now we go to the son of the Rambam, Avraham ben HaRambam, who says Earlier in the verse, Onkelos translates "תרומה" as "תפרישון," meaning "you shall separate." However, in the following verse, Onkelos translates "תרומה" literally as "תקבלון," meaning "you shall take." This is because the first statement in the verse was directed towards the donors, who were to separate items in their possession and designate them for the Mishkan, and the subsequent statement was directed to the people who collected the donations. They did not have to separate these items but merely took them from the donors to the Mishkan. This gives us a little bit of clarification of the process, the halachic process, of donating towards Torah, towards the Mishkan, and towards the Beit HaMikdash in the desert.

16:29was directed to the people who collected the donations. They did not have to separate these items but merely took them from the donors to the Mishkan. This gives us a little bit of clarification of the process, the halachic process, of donating towards Torah, towards the Mishkan, and towards the Beit HaMikdash in the desert. where he couldn't just go and give it to Moshe Rabbeinu and say, "Okay, go use this to build the next yeshiva, b'ezrat Hashem." No, you had to give it first and foremost; you had to separate it. As the statement says, as the Onkelos says, separate it from your assets. You have X amount of money; take a portion of it and separate it. make it so it's not yours anymore and give this to the public cause. Once you've given it to the public cause, then there are specific people that obviously work for this organization, work for Moshe Rabbeinu, and they're going to come and take it and utilize it for that purpose. But the first step is you have to separate it; you have to separate it from yourself. So here again, the Rambam and his son

17:41don't have the exact translation as what the Onkelos does, but in essence, they're learning something else from it. But again, they are clarifying that at no point should anyone ever arrive at the thought or the inclination that God needs anything. A needy god is a servant, not a God. when you have somebody that calls himself the most popular rabbi on YouTube, and then you have other rabbis from similar organizations or the same organizations start to piggyback off his heresy, and then as others that are trying to also piggyback off this heresy in different organizations, you're starting to see this cancer spread and people are starting to turn into a new religion. a religion that's more similar to some of the idolatrous religions in the world, whether it be Christianity, Catholicism, Buddhism, or all types of man-made religions that make a humanized God, more or less. Why? Because the second God needs anything, that means that you can be god over God. You can provide God something He doesn't have. And that is simply an impossibility. So,

19:01The one sentence, the one verse in the Torah that a person can say, "Oh, this is my source that shows that God needs something," it says, "Give me a portion." The sages attack it immediately and make sure that whether you're reading Rashi or Onkelos' commentary, which you're obligated to do every week according to the Shulchan Aruch, you're obligated to read either the Rashi or the Onkelos commentary each week for the weekly parasha. you will never arrive at such an understanding, which means that the only way you ever arrived at such an understanding is simply from your own convoluted mind, from your own heretical mind. Now, how could such a thing be the case? The parasha continues and says, Hashem says, I don't just want to command everybody to give. I want people to give

20:02their heart desires to donate. I don't want to force you to give. Why? Everything is Mine anyway, Hashem says. The whole world is Mine, and therefore, whether you give or not, if Hashem decreed for something to be built or for Torah to become greater, if Hashem decreed for someone to have or not to have... cannot get in the way. This is just like Mordechai said to Esther, who was the queen over there. But at the same time, she obviously doesn't want to be there. She knows that her nation is in danger, and Mordechai tells her, "You have to go and speak to Achashverosh and get him to cancel this decree." Esther says, "Yes, but I can't just go to Achashverosh. Even though I'm married to him, I can't just go to him. He has rules, and if he doesn't call you and you show up anyway, it's a death penalty. What am I to do?" Mordechai doesn't skip a beat; he doesn't sugarcoat it because he knows there's no time to waste. And the Megillat Esther says Mordechai says to Esther, "Whether you go or not..."

21:24should know the salvation is going to come, but if it doesn't come through you, just know that you and the rest of your family, your lineage, will disappear from existence. Why? You will lose your right to exist. Your name will become useless, meaning that Hashem puts you in a position where you could be the vessel that could help save Am Yisrael. you have dug your own grave, and no one's going to come visit. So here we see that when it comes to the Torah, you're never going to find political correctness, you're never going to find sugarcoating. You're going to find things that are pretty clear, and Hashem himself is telling us He only wants a man whose heart motivates him. you dug your own grave, and no one's going to come visit. So here we see that when it comes to the Torah, you're never going to find political correctness, you're never going to find sugarcoating. You're going to find things that are pretty clear, and Hashem Himself is telling us He only wants a man whose heart motivates him.

22:47should want to give it? Why should he want to give it? Why should he want to give it? Or perhaps if he reads the following verse later on, what he sees in verse number eight, "They shall make a sanctuary for Me, so that I may dwell among them." now, although the third Beit HaMikdash has not been rebuilt, we're still waiting for the Mashiach to come. Had he come, like some religions say or some people say, the Beit HaMikdash would have been built. So one of the clear signs that Mashiach has arrived is if the Beit HaMikdash is built. If it hasn't been built, that means Mashiach hasn't arrived.

23:52Because that is one of his first obligations. Now, Hashem says, although the Beit HaMikdash was not built, Jewish people are obligated to read this Torah portion and apply it to their lives every single year. To apply the verse that says, "You shall make a sanctuary for Me, that I may dwell among them." How can I make a sanctuary? When a person takes money that they worked for, takes money that they have, and takes a portion of it that's significant—not money that they could simply lose without caring. know, like somebody has change and he forgets to take the change out of his pocket and he throws the pants in the laundry, and then when he realizes that he still had the money in the pocket, he doesn't really lose any sleep over it because it's so insignificant—not that kind of money. When a person puts a significant amount of his money and invests it into publicizing more Torah in the world, helping other people do teshuva and get closer to Hashem, making sure that talmidei...

25:21have everything they need in order to study Torah at full force. And he contributes, she contributes to the best of their ability, but no less than at least 10% of what they make each month, as well as any other opportunity to give charity that's above it. If they really want to test their emunah, they would give 20%, but no more. doesn't ask you to give a hundred percent. But why should one even work a full-time job, invest X amount of time learning for this job, building his career, doing everything possible—blood, sweat, and tears—to finally make a living, and then, after working all that time, getting that paycheck, without even thinking twice Take 10% of that money, invest it into an organization like Be'ezrat Hashem, invest it into Kiruv, invest it into Torah scholars, without thinking twice. Without saying, you know what, maybe I'll do this next month, maybe I'll save up and make it a bigger amount. No, no. Simply, until I don't give that 10%, it's not my money. Just like at the time of the Beit HaMikdash. Until the farmers...

26:45didn't give that 10 percent until they didn't give the portion to the Levi, until they didn't give the portion to the Kohen. Until they didn't give that portion, they weren't allowed to use all of that crop, all of that food. Why? It's not mine until I give. And therefore, it's explained to us through these words that when a person takes their hard work and invest that money on a regular basis into Torah, but the real Torah, not some false version of Torah, and not a sugar-coated version of Torah or some idolatrous version of Torah, but the real version of Torah that empowers people, real versions of Torah that are honest to what it says. That person that's donating the money is really taking what Hashem gave them and investing it into themselves because that's the only money that they will be able to take with them when they leave this world. Regardless of whether a person has a net worth like Elon Musk of hundreds of billions of dollars

28:09a Bezos or Warren Buffett or all types of other billionaires out there, or a person like one of the sages who had literally a couple of vegetables left before he died. Regardless of what net worth they have while they're alive, once a person dies, none of that money can go with them. Only money that is valuable to them is the money that they invested into the Torah, money they invested into doing acts of kindness that are permissible according to the Torah. Because if you're kind to wicked people, if you're kind to murderers, rapists, and anti-Torah people, that's not kindness. So not all kindness is the same. But needless to say, when a person invests that money into Torah, that means that that money becomes part of their eternity. That money is really a blessing that Hashem gave you that you are now taking and investing into yourself. Yeah, but I'm investing it into the Torah. No, what you're doing is that you're taking what Hashem gave you and you're building a sanctuary for Hashem.

29:20your heart because your donations are investments that build a Shema sanctuary in your heart. And perhaps if you think about it deeply enough, you'll realize that if this is really the sanctuary that Hashem is talking about, that we're supposed to read about every year, then I'm supposed to build a sanctuary for Hashem. Even though it's not the third Beit HaMikdash, He's saying, build a sanctuary for Me. I can't build the Beit HaMikdash, but the verse is still relevant. So how could it be relevant? You have to build a sanctuary for Hashem to be among you. How can you build a sanctuary for Hashem to be among you? Now, if you build a church that publicizes some guy that died 2,000 years ago, how is that building Hashem a sanctuary? If you're building a mosque that publicizes some guy that says that an angel spoke to him in the middle of a desert... says to kill the Chosen People, how is that publicizing Hashem? If you're building some zoo and you're getting the elephant a new cage, how is that building a sanctuary for Hashem? But if you're investing into the Torah, the Torah that is the instructions, the love letter from God

30:39you're investing into the world of Torah to help more people learn Torah, to help more people who are already learned to learn even better, and learn even more without having the financial hardships that they do. Then what you're doing is you're actually fulfilling this verse and building yourself not only in eternity where that money is actually valuable. even more so in this world, you're building a sanctuary for Hashem in your heart because what ends up happening is that now that you've made a commitment—not as a one-time "I'm excited, let me just donate a bunch of money," and then you don't hear from the guy for six years. No, you made a commitment, no matter how big or how small, to take 10% of your money and donate it as soon as you get it. not waiting for months, you're not waiting for days. As soon as you get it, it's like automatic. Why? Because I want to make sure that, number one, Hashem knows I want Him. Hashem knows I want Him in my life, and I'm recognizing the fact that He really gives me a hundred percent. The least I can do

32:05is to take 10% of it and invest it into publicizing His name. Two, you're reminding yourself that despite the fact that you're the one who woke up at 5:30 in the morning to go to work, and despite the fact that when you worked, you lifted, you called, you climbed, and you did whatever you did for whichever business you worked at, the reality is that all of that was Hashem doing. You did not do all that work. Why? Because the strength to do the work, who gave it to you? The ability to do that work, who gave it to you? The job itself, who gave it to you? The customers, who gave it to you? The air in your lungs and the vision that your eyes see, who gave it to you? The sound you hear, who gave it to you? The money in your pocket, who gave it to you? Hashem. ...when a person thinks about how much Hashem gives him, only a heretic would think that they have permission to be stingy when it comes to Torah. But many times, stingy people will rationalize not giving. What are they going to say? "No, listen, I only give once a year. I give during the holidays, so you know, I don't give during the...

33:31You know what the truth is? You don't give even during the High Holidays. And even if you give, you don't give 10%. Anyone that actually does the calculations on how much they give, more times than not, they'll find out that they're not even giving anywhere close to 10% of what they have. And needless to say, they're not giving it for the sake of Torah. They're giving it for the sake of friends, for the sake of family, for the sake of camaraderie, for the sake of popularity, for the sake of social interests. But net-net, to give something for the sake of building the Torah, very, very few people do it. But it's not necessarily always their fault. Sometimes a person simply does not have the merit, and Hashem doesn't want them to give. They may give, but for the wrong causes. They have hundreds of millions of dollars. You ask them for a donation, build the shul, build the yeshiva, help the poor, they'll give you a thousand dollars, maybe five hundred dollars. Somebody comes to them and says, "Listen, we want to build a new aquarium for Billy the killer whale, and we're going to put a plaque of the donor on the aquarium so that every time people come to the aquarium

34:57while they're looking at the giant whale jump and eat and do all that stuff, you know, they could also see the name on a plaque of the guy that donated it. Okay, how much does that cost? Oh, it's nothing; it's not a big deal. We're only talking about a million and a half dollars. That's it. You got it. For a plaque? You promised a plaque? Yeah, yeah. There you go. Wait, wait. So, to publicize Torah, to publicize the only reason why the Jewish people exist to this day, despite all of their enemies throughout all of the generations, the Assyrians, the Babylonians, the Spaniards, the Romans, the Greeks, the Turks, the Nazis... Endless amount of enemies we've had, and the only reason why we survived is because of this very same Torah, not because of any other reason. And instead of investing that million and a half dollars there, where does he invest? He invested in building an aquarium. Now, if you ask him, "Well, how come you don't invest in the Torah?" He'll tell you, "What are you talking about? I do. The rabbi just came, I just gave him a big check. I just gave him a big check." What?

36:09What? $100 is respectable. Yeah, but to the whale, you gave a million and a half dollars. If you only treated your own people as well as you treat whales, we'd be in business. This is one of the things that Rabbi Ephraim taught me years ago. I don't know how the conversation got to it, but he said if people treated Torah scholars as well as they treat wild animals, we'd be in good shape. Look at what they feed these wild animals in the zoos, in the safaris. They give them steaks. They give them big pieces of meat. They give them everything they possibly need. But the moment that a Torah scholar gets $100 in financial benefits from the government, everyone calls him, "Ah, you're living off of our taxes. You're living off of us. You're a waste of time." But to the tiger, to the elephant, to... Anyone else that's in a zoo, whether human or animal, no problem to give them. For the sake of the Torah, no. Why is that? One of the reasons is because Hashem specifically says here, He doesn't want everyone's donations. He'll allow anybody to donate whatever they want to donate. But for them to donate for the right cause, they have to have the merit to do so.

37:34they have to have the merit to do so. And if I didn't see this with my own eyes, it would be hard to believe. And I know that many of you are not going to believe me. And quite frankly, I don't blame you. Why? It's hard to understand. The first time I heard it, maybe 10 years ago, I simply lost my mind. I couldn't believe it. This whole concept of merit, having a merit to donate for the sake of real Torah, And one of the things that I saw with my own eyes were people that would even show interest in investing in Torah, having the ability to donate—meaning money was never the issue. But when push came to shove, something always happened at the last minute, and somehow it just didn't happen. Somehow it just didn't happen.

38:37whether it be lawsuits or business failures, a lost phone number, a lost phone, sickness, all types of strange things. Now, if somebody would have invested $1,000 into a tiny little business called Amazon, a tiny little business called Google, before it became what it is today, that person would be one of the richest people in the world. If the people that told us, I'm telling you from firsthand experience, that they wanted to invest in our organization when we first started out, this is eight years ago, one guy supposedly had $150 million, and he wanted to invest a substantial amount of money

39:38of several other people along the way. If they would have invested, that means that they would have been partners in at least 22 books of Torah that we've published and at least 120,000 people that we have fed. Literally millions of hours of Torah that have been taught, countless people doing teshuvah, countless babies being saved from abortion, countless marriages being saved from breaking, and many other wonderful things. But unfortunately, some of these people were so poor in merits and... that Hashem did not even allow them to donate one dollar. And if that wasn't sad enough, the sadder ones are when people lose their merit. Where they initially have a merit, they donate, they start contributing, sometimes even substantial amounts of money—$5,000, $10,000, more, and so on. And they watch the shiurim, and they get invigorated and inspired.

41:06Sometimes they're coming from different religions. They end up converting. Sometimes they're Jews and they just become even more frum than what they were. Sometimes they're new to Judaism altogether. They're Jews. They were born Jewish but knew nothing about Judaism. So literally from all walks of life, they start to get familiar with our lectures, with myself, with Rav Ephraim, now with Rabbi Leib, with Rav Shavit, all of the different rabbis of B'ezrat Hashem, but especially Rav Ephraim and myself because we've been, obviously, the founders of the organization and... these people would contribute and start becoming part of the organization's partners, if you will, because, you know, each month you get a certain amount of money from them. Then, out of nowhere, you see they disappear without any warning, without any announcement, without anything. In the beginning, when these things would happen, it would be surprising.

42:06Now, I don't have the time nor the interest to go chase people for money. And to this day, Baruch Hashem, I have yet to have any conversation with anybody about their donations. I always tell people who tell me they want to talk about donations that there's really not much to talk about. We have a website. We have a mailing address. If you want to donate, you can choose one of those options. You don't need me to help you to donate. Unless you want a secretary to call you and help you process the donation, I'm not going to be the one who convinces you to donate. And the whole point of this talk is not to convince you to donate. The whole point of this talk is to make sure that everybody understands that whatever they do with the money that Hashem gives them is only for themselves. And I know that this sometimes, and more times than not, it hurts people's egos. But these are clear verses in the Torah. To think otherwise is problematic, to say the least. And I've seen this with my own eyes, where somebody would literally be a donor, even a key donor, where they would contribute $100,000 a year or more, and then, one day, disappear. And you don't even know why. In the beginning, it was a surprise. In the beginning, it was a very big surprise that this person or two or three or five who were donating a substantial amount of money suddenly stopped because you know it wasn't financial problems because...

43:30Their financials improved drastically from the time that they started donating over the next couple of years. The more they donated, the more they did well in their businesses. So it wasn't a financial problem. It wasn't a marriage problem. It wasn't a religious problem, but something happened. In the beginning, it would drive me crazy. trying to figure out why. I mean, we helped this person, we did whatever we could, and eventually, referring to our Torah learning and experience, seeing this time and time again, clarified the picture. And the picture became much sadder than I could imagine. We simply realized Oh, they lost the merit. It's not that they don't like you or they don't have the money. They lost the merit. God no longer wants the money that they make, that He gives them, to be used for something that is going to give them exponential reward for whatever they did.

45:00God decided, I don't want it. Go donate to some elephant. Go donate to some heretic. Go donate to some guy that pretends that he's homeless. Go donate to, I don't know, your sister's dog to save him from cancer. Go donate to a lot of other things. Don't donate to the Beit HaShem. Why? I don't want it. And that is very sad because... You have no idea what just happened here. What did this person do to lose the merit? Did they kill somebody? What did they do? The only thing I can tell you is it's a common denominator. I don't know what anybody did. I don't ask. Generally speaking, usually we lose contact altogether when people stop donating because usually they're either embarrassed of it, or they're uncomfortable, or whatever it is. can tell you this: the one common denominator among all of the people that were contributors, especially the larger contributors, and simply stopped or deteriorated to such a point where it's almost non-existent in comparison, there's one common denominator. As strange as it sounds

46:24the only common denominator I could possibly find among all of them is they stopped watching the lectures. That's the common denominator, meaning that apparently, there was some type of spiritual growth that they were getting as a result of watching the shiurim, as a result of watching the lectures. at some point, the evil inclination tells a person, "You've grown enough. Try something else," and unfortunately, a person falls for the trap and stops watching the lectures. In the beginning, they go down from three lectures a week to one lecture a week. Then, they go down to one lecture every few weeks, and eventually, it gets to zero. And almost never do they realize that there is a loss of merit there. They lost an interest in being part of the organization. They lost an interest in using their money to build the very same place that helped build them.

47:42And what ends up happening is they go on in their life without even realizing what just happened. It's literally like somebody walking around with a terminal disease and not even realizing it. Now, one of the saddest things in the world is that even if you try to tell this to people, it's almost impossible for them to accept it. To be honest with you, if it wasn't in the parasha and what Hashem gave me to say, I wouldn't even say it. because it's not something that people could usually accept. But I've seen this so many times, and it's a very common thing when you see somebody lose their merit. Now, one of the things that causes a person to lose their merit, aside from what I just said, of not elevating themselves in Torah, not continuing to be committed to it,

48:43is a lack of gratitude. When a person is ungrateful, the Gemara says that person becomes one of the people that Hashem hates. So, whoever told you that Hashem loves everybody is simply not telling you the truth. Why? Because the Gemara lists multiple people that Hashem hates, and one of them is a person who is ungrateful. he's ungrateful to man, it's only a matter of time before he's going to be ungrateful to Hashem. And if he's ungrateful to Hashem, certainly he's going to be ungrateful to men. Many times, people don't realize how gratitude is a necessity in life, a necessity in relationships, a necessity in business, a necessity in every aspect of life. And many times, what ends up happening is that lack of gratitude leads to stinginess because now they don't necessarily think that anybody else helped them get that job, helped them find marriage, helped them do whatever it is that they're doing now. But in the beginning stages, helped them have a blessing in their life. What ends up happening is that this lack of gratitude turns into stinginess.

50:07where even when Hashem sends them different opportunities to earn their merit back, all of a sudden they think, "Why? Why should I give my hard work to these people? If they want it, let them go work for it. Why do I have to give what I have to them?" Now, if it stopped there, it would be bad enough. But the reality is that that lack of gratitude doesn't only lead to stinginess. Stinginess leads to heresy. Because if that person ever has a moment of truth where he's questioning, why am I stingy? Or somebody questions him, why don't you want to give? immediate response that a person has is, "Why should I give what I made? Why should I give what I have? Why should I give what is mine?" Forgetting that you owe nothing because everything in the world is Mine. "Mine is the money, Mine is the gold," says

51:31God, the Lord of Allegiance. So, when a person says, my money, my houses, my property, that's why I don't want to give my stuff, I worked for it, that's a form of heresy. A heresy that unfortunately leads to very, very bad things—not just in this world. Now, the... things that a person does in order to win different things in this world literally have no limits. People are willing to do anything to get the job they want, to get the woman they want, to get the man they want, to get the house they want. Literally, people want to do everything, and they invest all of their energy into building a temporary world. When you tell them that you have an opportunity to take this temporary possession and make it permanent fixture in your life in this world and the next. Where in this world you will have an opportunity to have Hashem in your heart at all times. Why? Because every time you invest into the Torah, it automatically makes you more connected to Torah, more inclined to learn Torah, and more invested in Torah.

52:55have more divine assistance when it comes to learning it, following it, and doing anything that's necessary because you're investing into this place and you're making Hashem and His Torah a permanent fixture in your heart and a permanent fixture in your life. But even more so, all of that money, instead of going to buying more properties, more insurance policies, more Bitcoin, more stocks, and more everything else... eventually, it is going to be given to somebody else, and many times, it's not somebody else that you thought it was going to be given to. Usually, that somebody else is someone that you would not give it to. Many times, people die with the most possessions that they ever had, meaning that they spent their entire lives working for somebody else working for somebody else to benefit from all their hard work, and many times that somebody else doesn't even care for them. So, instead of leaving their money towards Torah, they have plans to give it to this son and that daughter, and this campaign and that campaign. Instead of making...

54:11What the sages say is the proper step, which is to give during their life, not to wait until they're dead and hope that their kids will give on their behalf. What ends up happening is that people get to a point where they lose all merits and all rights to give for the sake of Torah. Because if they would ever have the merit to give for the Torah, that means that that money becomes part of eternity. was an extraordinary tzaddik, one of the giants of the generation just a few hundred years ago was the name. There was a time when they needed to raise some money to free a Jewish prisoner. It's a very big mitzvah to free Jewish prisoners when they're in the prison of the gentiles. Of course, the decree was heavy. The amount of money was extraordinary, and they needed to raise 30,000 rubles, a huge sum of money. So they came to Rabbi Levi Yitzchak and they said, "Listen, you're the biggest rabbi of the generation. We need your help to raise this money." He says to them, "I'll come with you under the condition that you're not going to tell me..."

55:41what to do if I want to go somewhere and ask someone or say something? You're going to let me do what I want to do and not control my speech and where I go? He said, "No problem. You come with us wherever you want to go." And they started going different places, collecting here, collecting there, but not much luck. As they're walking, there's a huge collection of a field full of beautiful trees. And there's an entrance, a road, but they walk past it. He says, "Why are you skipping it? Why don't we go here? There's a big house, a mansion down the road." So the people say to him, "No, this is not a place that anybody goes to anymore." He says, "Why not? It's not Jewish people?" They respond, "No, no, it's actually a Jew." But it's a Jew that's extraordinarily wealthy. Wealthier than Korach. But he is the stingiest man alive. But he's not just stingy. Some people are stingy but they still give a little bit. No. This one is so stingy that his pleasure is to not give more than a penny and to make fun of the people asking from him.

57:10says, "I want to go here." "But I'm wasting our time. We had a deal. I'll go anywhere I want." "Okay, you want to go there, Rabbi? Fine, you go. You guys don't have to come with me if you don't want, but I'm going." "We're coming, we're coming." So they walk down this huge road, beautiful trees, beautiful flowers. I mean, this is a little heaven, you know, one of these huge... plots of land, you know, all types of beautiful things on it. Eventually, they get to the mansion, and they knock on the door. The butler answers with a smile on his face, immediately saying, "Are you sure you're in the right house?" "Yes, yes, we want to see the owner of the house." "That's right. Suit yourself. I'll call him." As soon as the owner of the house sees them, he smiles, "Oh, welcome! Come, come, sit down. Come over here, please come in." He says to him, "Yes, we, uh, have a, uh, situation. There's a Jewish prisoner under the, uh, prison of the, of the gentiles, and we need to do everything possible to free him. And, uh, we need to raise 30,000 rubles, and we're hoping that, uh, kvodcha would help us."

58:37And the guy says to him, "You're new here. Have you ever heard about me, who I am?" He says, "No, I'm just here to help. I figured that you may want to help. Do a mitzvah." And this guy sees that the Rav is so pure and naive. He says, "Okay, fine." He goes, he comes back a moment later. He says, "I got something for you." oh yeah, sure, what do you have? And he takes out, you know, the equivalent of a penny, a tiny little coin, something that even a paper towel you can't get with it. "Here, a shiny penny for you." He opens his hand, he puts it in his hand, and all of a sudden the rabbi starts blessing this guy. Yisham, he says the name of Hashem and blesses this person, "Mi Sheberach Avoteinu Avraham, Yitzchak, v'Yaakov, may He bless this person with good health, with success in his business, a happy marriage, successful kids, ta ta ta ta," and he goes on and on and on. He's ecstatic about it, and the guy...

1:00:03He's confused. Usually, when he gives the penny to people, they throw it in his face, curse him out, he has a laugh, and then, you know, the entertainment's over. He's never seen anything like this. Needless to say, a rabbi is dancing around while he's giving him blessings. not just a simple blessing. He's going on and on and on, and even the Hasidim that came with the Rabbi, they're confused. Maybe the Rabbi doesn't know what he just got. Maybe the Rabbi is confused. Maybe he thought he gave him a gold coin instead of a penny, and they're not even sure, but they don't dare say a single word. All they're doing is watching the Rabbi give this guy blessings as if he just found Mount Sinai. And after some time, he completes the blessing and the guy says to the Rabbi, he goes, "Wow." You sure like that coin, huh Rabbi? Oh yeah, we really appreciate it, Baruch Hashem. You want another one? You would do that? Sure, I'll do it. And the guy goes back to the room. He comes back with a coin in his hand. He goes, here you go. Rabbi Levi Yitzchak of Berditchev opens his hand.

1:01:20accepts the coin, and all of a sudden the blessings begin again. But now it's completely new blessings. It's not the same blessings. New blessings altogether. And he blesses the guy that you have success in your marriage, in your health, in your this, in your that, do, do, do, do. Every blessing under the sun that the guy has ever heard has been nothing in comparison to the blessing that he's getting from the Rav MiBerditchev. And each simply cannot believe what's going on over here. The Chassidim are watching. They have no idea what's going on over here. And the rabbi is blessing this stingy rich man. And after he finishes, he says, "Rabbi, I love your blessings. I mean, if I give you a ruble, would you give me more blessings? A ruble is a lot more than just what I gave you." The rabbi says, "Let's try."

1:02:22The guy goes, gets a ruble, gives it to the rabbi, and the rabbi begins a set of blessings. And he gives him blessings—blessings the world has never heard before, things unlike anything else. The guy smiles. He is getting the pleasure of all pleasures here. He's like, "This is what you get for a ruble? Rabbi, what if I give you a hundred rubles?" Do I get another blessing? The rabbi says, we can try. The guy goes, gets 100 rubles. And the rabbi now starts bringing blessings from the Kabbalah, from the Zohar. And he's blessing him. And the guy just simply couldn't believe it. He's so happy. He's in a different world. He's heard curses of all kinds, in every language possible. Blessings like this, no one's ever heard. After the rabbi completes this, he says, "Hold on a second. What are you guys actually looking for? What are you doing here?" They said, "We're here to collect money to free a prisoner." He asked, "What do you need to free the prisoner?" They replied, "30,000 rubles." "Okay," he said, "I'll do that." He goes back into the room and comes back with 30,000 rubles. "Here you go," he said. The rabbi, of course, gives him blessings.

1:03:51many, many more blessings, and then they all leave. Now, of course, there was no time to waste. They immediately went and used the money to free this prisoner. Shortly afterward, they found out that this cheap, stingy rich man became the most generous person in the community. Suddenly, he wanted to donate to the yeshiva. He wanted to donate to the synagogue. He wanted to donate to the homeless shelter. He wanted to donate to free the prisoner. He wanted to donate to everything. And he became the biggest gevir in the community. That's when the chassidim came to Rabbi Berditchev and said, "Kvodo, what did you do to him? Was it Kabbalah? What did you do to him?" how did you do it? When we were there, we didn't see anything. So can you please explain to us how you did that? We've been going to him for 20 years, and he never donated even a penny. How did you get him to do all this? He says, "I knew who he was. Many of the poor people that came collecting came to me complaining about him and how

1:05:08insults them, embarrasses them, and gives them nothing, not even a cup of water. As soon as I saw that penny, the evil inclination told me, "Throw this penny at his face. Is he joking?" But then I looked at the penny and I saw that the Satan is inside that penny, meaning this guy The entire evil inclination is inside his money. He's so stingy that even the penny didn't have the merit to go to the right place. That's why people kept throwing it at him. So I figured, let me take this penny from him, and all of a sudden, he wanted to give me another penny. And I saw the next penny... and I saw that there's still some evil inclination in that penny. Obviously, these are things that normal people don't see. But Rabbi Levi Yitzchak of Berditchev saw. I saw that there's still some evil inclination in there. So I said, "Yeah, give me that one too." And then he gave me a ruble. And after that, I saw there's very little left of this evil inclination, of this Satan. I took that one too. And then he gave us a hundred. And that was the first time I saw nothing on it.

1:06:38we succeeded in eliminating his evil inclination of stinginess. From now on, he will be a big donor for the sake of Torah. Now, of course, the greatness of the Rabbi Levi Yitzchak of Berditchev doesn't need to be clarified any further. But the truth be told, there's also greatness to that stingy donor. greatness that may not be appreciated at first look. At first glance, you want to punch the guy in the face. At first glance, you think, "Why doesn't this guy donate? People are struggling. You have so much. How many beds can you sleep in? How many houses can you live in? How much food can you eat? You have extra, give!" But the reality is that some people have lost their merits, where they don't have the ability to give.

1:07:39And that person, although he didn't have the right intentions, at the very least, he tried. He gave a penny. And when he heard a blessing, he didn't discount it; he appreciated it for what it was and gave more. Not realizing the value of that penny, that first penny opened up a merit that he hadn't had in years. A merit to give another penny. The second penny gives a merit to give even more. And the reality is that when a person does one mitzvah, the Mishnah in Masechet Avot says, the reward for one mitzvah is another mitzvah. Why is the reward for a mitzvah another mitzvah? Why don't you just give me a penthouse? Why don't you just give me a plane? Why don't you just give me a bunch of cash? Why is the reward for a mitzvah another mitzvah? Because the truth is, explains the Rambam, There is nothing in this entire world, even if you calculate from the beginning of the world and all the way until the end, that is as precious as a single mitzvah. Nothing in this world, meaning all of the wealth that ever existed in this world, all of the pleasure, all of the good that ever existed in this world.

1:09:03not enough to reward a person for a single mitzvah that they did, and because of that, the real reward that a person gets for a mitzvah is an opportunity to do another mitzvah. Now sometimes that opportunity will come with more tools, more money, a car, a job, a wife, kids, whatever it is it's not the kid or the wife or the car or the job that is the reward; it's the mitzvah opportunity that comes with them because the real reward is much greater than this world. The only thing that's greater than the reward that a person will get from a mitzvah is the reward that he will get for causing somebody else to do a mitzvah. Rabbi Shimon Bar Yochai says, greater is the reward of a person that causes another to do a mitzvah than even the reward that he will get for the mitzvah that he does for himself. Meaning that you will get an endless reward for your donation, for your good deeds. But guess what?

1:10:27There's an endless reward times infinity that you will get for causing somebody else to do a mitzvah. Now, for those people that say, "Oh, you know what, so let me just focus on causing other people to do and I don't have to do anything myself." No, no, no. In order to have success in causing other people to do a mitzvah, you have to have the merit. And you can't have the merit if you don't do the mitzvah yourself. From there we see that HaKadosh Baruch Hu says, "Take from Me a portion. Take from what I've given you a portion and invest it into building a sanctuary for Me in your heart." Something you can very well do today. Now, if you find yourself having a tough time building that sanctuary that's full of Torah in your heart, and you find yourself more inclined to donate towards dogs, heresy, lies, Reform, liberalism, and all types of LGBT-type interests, then you should cry for mercy from Above to at least give you the merit like that guy who gave a penny.

1:11:44With that being said, I'm going to take a quick drink and you guys can start asking some questions. Hi Rabbi, is it okay to give to the Temple Institute? Two things. One, I don't recommend other organizations when I don't know what they do behind the scenes, not just what they show on their website. So I don't recommend anybody unless I know the institution from the inside out. If I know that the people are not stealing, I know that the people have integrity, they follow the Torah, they follow Gedolei Yisrael, they follow everything, and not just have a nice website and good videos. So I cannot ever recommend any institution that I don't know that about. That's why the only organization that I recommend is the one that I run, which is BeEzrat Hashem. Now, the second thing I can tell you about, you know, anyone that is out there telling people we're going to start a new Sanhedrin, we're going to build the Beit HaMikdash, we're going to start doing things without getting permission from Gedolei Yisrael to do so, is not someone that I would invest in, simply because that is a problematic mentality.

1:12:56they may not be desecrating Shabbat, but they're also not following what the Mesorah is. So again, I don't know what everybody does and how they do it. What I do know is that several Chachamim have asked us about this issue and have considered some strong steps against different institutions out there that are, in essence, portraying as if they are, uh, rebuilding the Beit HaMikdash now without the Mashiach being here, so I don't see that as a, uh, as a good idea. Last but not least, there is nothing greater—there's nothing greater in the world—than investing in helping people do teshuva. It's greater than investing in anything else; it's greater than investing in the Beit HaMikdash itself. Because the only thing that a person can do for their Creator is to bring one of Hashem's other children closer to Him. That's the only thing that a person can do. Now, Hashem doesn't need you to do it, but in essence, the money that a person has, the children, the buildings, all of these other things, all of it belongs to Hashem.

1:14:06Now, when you bring one of Hashem's children that Hashem has been waiting for for the last 3,000 years to come back to Him, you help them do teshuva, there's simply nothing greater than that. And there's literally endless sources that support that. There's no one that's going to contradict it. So if you're going to compare helping people do teshuva, investing into kiruv, uh, against anything else out there, you'll see that it does not compare. So much so that the Rambam writes nearly a thousand years ago that even if somebody has good deeds and great Torah knowledge, they are nothing in comparison to the merit that a person who helps other people do teshuva has. Meaning, this is not just an opinion of some kiruv rabbi from 2023. This is part of our mesorah. And it all stems from what I just said before, which is the teachings of Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai, who says, greater is the person that causes other people to do a mitzvah than even the mitzvah that he does himself. So even though...

1:15:12by donating to different Jewish organizations, you're certainly causing other people to do mitzvot, but then you have to calculate what is the greatest mitzvah that someone can do. Now, even if you say the greatest mitzvah is to, let's say, keep this or keep that, or buy this or buy that, every mitzvah is great. But to help somebody do teshuva, that means that you are a part of every single mitzvah that they, their children, and all of their descendants will ever do in history. So there's simply nothing greater than that. So if you compare that to anything else, you're simply going to realize there's really nothing greater to invest in. Everything pales in comparison. And it's not an individual opinion; it's a reality. Go to any sefer, any real book that discusses this, you'll see that there's simply nothing that compares to it. Now, of course, we still have a need for homeless shelters and places that help children and orphans and so on. There's still a need for it, and certainly there are people that donate for those things. But if a person looks at things from a spiritual investment perspective, there's simply nothing in comparison to it. But I know that

1:16:27sometimes, most times, people don't look at their donations as investments. They look at their donations as, uh, some type of, uh, something close to their heart, whatever is either socially acceptable, socially, uh, uh, uh, welcomed, uh, you know, something that they are connected to in some form or another, benefit from in some form or another. And if they were an orphan, they'll want to donate to orphanages. If they were a divorcee, they'll want to donate to divorce organizations. You know, people donate to things that they can relate to, things that they can connect to. And that's nice, but it's not necessarily the right way to do things. Why? Because just like if you're going to be investing in properties or you're going to be investing in stocks or any other form of investment, If you're a good investor, and I spent nearly two decades being an investor on Wall Street, I can tell you, if you're a good investor, the first thing that you're going to look at is what can make me the most. What can make me the most? What is the best risk-reward?

1:17:34Meaning everything has some form of risk, but everything also has, if it's an investment, some form of reward, if it's a real investment. So what has the best risk versus reward odds? If a person looks, one thing can give you, you invest 100, you can make 10. So at the end of the year, you'll have 110. Okay, 10%, thank you. Another one can make you potentially 15%. Another one can make you 17%. Another one can make you 20%. Okay, great. And then they come to you and say, oh, listen, this one can make you 40 million percent. Excuse me? What do you mean 40 million percent? Yeah, you can make 40 million percent because this is a company that's called Amazon. You can buy it for a penny, and it may end up being the greatest thing that the world has seen in the last 20 years. And go from books to selling everything. The only thing they don't sell is people. And I think that's coming soon. So, you can do that. Now, if the person is normal, they say, okay, hold on a second. What's the risk? But even if there is a risk, how much could I... There's such a huge potential. So, in comparison to the others, if you're a good investor, usually you're going to pick the latter. Either way, I know that I could talk until I'm blue in the face like the screen behind me.

1:18:52And people are still going to follow their emotions more than they're going to follow their brain. That's just the reality. But we still give the information because there are some people that want the right information and they'll decide accordingly. But either way, it's because it has to do with the parasha. My secular cousin moved into a new home and had a baby girl. I'm trying to mekarev her. Therefore, what gift do you suggest that I give her? uh, the gift that you give her is something relevant to Torah. If she is a reader, then I would recommend that you get her a good book. Rav Nissim Yagen's book, a Rabbi Mizrachi book; if she reads Hebrew, she could also get my book. And, you know, that's certainly a book, or she can get some other books that we've recommended in the past. About different sages. If she doesn't read books yet or doesn't read Torah-related books and things like that, then I would recommend you get her some type of video. So, you know, either get the Kiruv package that we have that has all types of CDs and USBs with different things she can watch and listen to, or you could order the USB set for her, or you could give her some type of...

1:20:08Torah-related product that is going to teach Torah, not just like Shabbat candles or Shabbat towels. That type of stuff is not going to really help her life; it's just more furniture. You want to give her something that could potentially save her eternity, so something that's going to teach Torah. And like I said, Torah books, CDs, USBs—that's the type of stuff that I would give her because that's something that could potentially save her. Now, it may not work right away, but I can tell you that when you invest in the Torah, it's always like planting seeds. I actually had a guy that I sent him a Q-Package for free as a gift. I was speaking to him, seeing that he has some interest and so on, maybe three years ago. Something like that, three years ago. And I sent him a Q-Package, you know, of books, CDs, and interesting stuff. Now, each Q-Package costs almost $300, so it's not something you can do every day with everybody. But, you know, once in a while, if I see a serious opportunity to help somebody do teshuva, and I know that there's no chance in the world they're going to buy it on their own, but there is a chance that they may actually look into it if they get it as a gift, sometimes I take a chance. And well, anyway, I sent this guy the information.

1:21:33He accepted it; he was very, you know, happy about it, and that's it. I lost touch with him. I hadn't, you know, I didn't hear from him for a while. About, uh, maybe three or four months ago, I hear from him again. "Hey Rabbi, I just want to let you know I really appreciate everything you do. I've been watching your lectures." I look at my phone and think, "Oh wow, this guy, I haven't heard from him in three years, two and a half years." he starts asking some questions and so on and then I ask him, "Okay, so, uh, how long have you been doing teshuva?" and he says, "When I started looking into the package six months ago," meaning the package that I sent him three years ago sat there collecting dust for two years plus, did nothing. i spent money, efforts, I even made the package myself. Those packages are not easy to make; they take a lot of time. Just the shipping alone is like $30-$40, you know? So, you put a lot of effort into this thing, each one of these packages.

1:22:38Me, I look at them all. This is another seed; this is another seed. It's another investment; it's another opportunity. You never believe it. I told people listening early on, I wish I had a whole team of people making these Kiruv packages to send to different people. I think there's a lot of potential, but you need a huge amount of money for it. Either way, the number of people that have done teshuva from those packages is unbelievable. sometimes it doesn't work right away, but this guy, he kept it on the back burner for two years. Eventually, he had enough merit to open it. He looked at some of the books and, little by little, became more religious. Now, in the last six months or so, he started keeping Shabbat, started learning Torah every day, and moved to a religious neighborhood. so, so wonderful things happening, and sometimes it takes a while for them to grow. But that's the way you gotta look at it—as long as you give a person you care about some form of real Torah that they can learn from, not just enjoy the beauty of it or the way it looks.

1:23:53But something they can learn from, a book, a CD, a USB, something like that, you can be sure that that seed has a lot more value than anything else you can buy them. Because that seed could literally be something that saves them for eternity. And I'll tell you a story. There was once, Rabbi Yagen, alav ha-shalom, Rabbi Nissim Yagen. He... This was his people. He gets a letter, one of those letters that's, you know, a really, really long letter. And, you know, I don't know why people think that, for whatever reason, they think that, you know, the rabbis never have anything to do and we can just read these really, really long letters. God bless people. I mean, I appreciate the letters and everything, but many times you have these 5-, 10-, 20-page letters and emails and you simply don't have the ability to read all of it. At best, maybe you'll skim through part of it, even if you look at it. Sometimes it's so long, it's so scary, you don't look at it at all. Not because you don't care. It just takes too much time. It's 40 minutes just to read something. It's a book.

1:25:00But anyway, one time the Rabbi again gets a letter, a long letter. He says, usually I don't read these letters, but I delved into the first few words and it got me to read more and more and more. Before I knew it, I read the whole thing. And he says it was one of the most extraordinary stories I was ever a part of. And it comes from a woman that says, I saved her life. I saved her marriage. But I'm never going to believe how. said her and her husband have been fighting for a very long time. What's the fight about? Her husband became more religious, and she has no interest in becoming religious. No interest. And as he's becoming more and more religious, she is becoming more and more upset that he is becoming religious. And it gets to a point where he says, "Listen, if you're gonna peak..."

1:26:00Your religion or me? And the guy says, listen, I love you. I don't want you to leave, but I'm not going to become non-religious. I'm not going to go to the beach with you anymore. I'm not going to violate Shabbat. I'm not doing it. Why don't you listen? Why don't you this? She was never willing to listen to anything. Now, around that time, a Rebbe again had a trip to Europe. I believe it was Europe. And, you know, in those days, they had tapes, cassette tapes. Instead of CDs and USBs, they had cassette tapes. And you would have people usually buy a whole collection of tapes to put them in, you know, in the local shul. And you could just take the tapes. You would have, let's say, 300 tapes. And they wanted to borrow one. They would borrow it, listen to it, and then put it back, like a library. So he brought this collection and gave it to the place. The place, for whatever reason or another, didn't want it or the guy couldn't accept it, so they didn't know what to do with it. One day, a couple of the guys that had it said, "Listen, we're leaving town. We're gonna be gone for a while. What are we gonna do with these tapes?"

1:27:18They go, I don't know. Well, Rav again told us we have to make sure we can go somewhere. What are we going to do with them? All of a sudden, they see somebody else that they know. They go, hey, listen. Can you do us a favor? Can you take care of these tapes and listen to them, maybe share them with some people? And the guy said, sure, why not? Looked like a newly religious guy. Interested. He takes the tapes. And he starts listening to these tapes and he becomes more and more religious. But he doesn't dare bring these tapes to the house. Why? Why? his wife can't stand him. It's the same wife that we're talking about. His wife can't stand him becoming religious, and if he brings 300 tapes of Torah to the house, she'll probably hang him at night. So every day, he, you know, sneaks in another tape, listens to it, finishes, gets another one. And one day, this wife tells him, "Listen, I'm leaving you. I already talked to the lawyer. We're done." just has to show up to the court on, uh, this, uh, day at this time. Poor guy has nothing to do, so what are you gonna do? He says, or she says, the night before the court appearance that finalizes everything and officially ends this marriage.

1:28:50The husband is out working or something. He was gone. And she was really upset that he chose God over her. And she, you know, starts reminiscing with herself. She put on her wedding dress, and she's crying herself to sleep. And she looks up to the sky and says, "How come I don't feel it?" How come I don't feel this thing that he does? I don't feel God. I don't feel it. And she says, "God, if you're real, please show me." And she fell asleep. The next morning, she goes into the car, and before the appointment, which is later on that day at four o'clock or something like that, she goes into the car, and the car automatically plays the tape that's already in there. She starts listening to what's on the tape, which is a shiur by Rav Nissim Yagen.

1:29:51Goes into the car, and before the appointment, which is later on that day at four o'clock or something like that, she goes into the car, and the car automatically plays the tape that's already in there. She starts listening to what's on the tape, which is a shiur by Rav Nissim Yagen. Telling people about reward and punishment. What happens? Don't steal. This, that. She forgets where she's even going. She continues to listen to the whole tape. She finishes it. She gets home. The husband is there. She says, okay, we have to go to the appointment. She goes, no, no, I'm going to cancel it. The husband’s like, okay. When do you want to do it? I don't know. But do you have another tape? He says, "Tape for what? The tape, the tape that you have in the car. Do you have another one?" The guy almost had a heart attack from happiness, but he didn't want to show it to her. He's like, "Yeah, I kind of have some. Yeah, yeah, I can get you another one. Sure." "Can you get one quickly? I need one. I need one." The guy runs to the car, shows up with a tape. "Oh, thanks." Okay. She goes back in the car. She's listening to another tape. She's driving aimlessly. No reason to drive. She wants to hear the tape. She hears another tape.

1:31:14She finishes it. She comes back home. It's only an hour. She comes back home. "Do you have another tape?" She's like, "Yeah, I can get you another tape." She gives him another tape. Another tape. Another tape. And she's crying herself, but this time from happiness. She tells her husband, "Finally, I want to be religious. I want to cover my hair. I want to do everything." And he says to her, "How? How?" And she tells him what she said. She said, "I didn't feel what you feel. I didn't know what you know. I didn't want to hear it. You told me you believe in this thing in the air that's God, this Creator. I didn't feel it. I didn't grow up that way. And last night, I looked at the sky and I said, 'If you're real, God, please show me.'" And today, He showed me. Today, He showed me. I went into the car, and for the first time in my life, I heard Torah. And I heard God was speaking to me through that Torah. Because I don't know where you got those tapes. What I do know is that had it been any other day, it wouldn't have worked. Today, I knew God was talking to me. And Rav again says the story—I heard this from him several times—he says, "I'm reading this letter and I'm crying, crying. Why?"

1:32:39wouldn't have worked. Today, I knew God was talking to me. And Rav again says the story—I heard this from him several times—he says, "I'm reading this letter and I'm crying, crying. Why?" Who would have known? This set of tapes that looked like it was supposed to go to one place, they backed out on it for some unknown reason. Then it's like roaming around. The guys that were responsible for it forgot about the fact that they have the tapes. They end up giving it to some random Jew that just started doing teshuva, who was in the process of a divorce, and that guy saves an entire generation of Jews with that set of tapes. When you invest in Torah that can help people, whether it's a tape, a CD, a USB, or a book that can help people get closer to Hashem, you're not just helping that person become entertained. You're not just helping that person get closer to God. You're literally giving that person the means to save an entire generation of Jewish people. And that's why there's nothing greater than that.

1:34:02My neighbor has a special needs child. Is he supposed to put on tefillin? That depends. It depends on the extent of his special needs. if he's all there mentally, he just has some difficulty operating his body and so on, but he still has all of his limbs and he's aware of who God is, then somebody should put the tefillin on his arm. Even if he's missing one arm, he still puts it on the other arm. In fact, the halachah is that the Yalkut Yosef talks about how if, let's say, somebody is missing their hand up to the elbow, then they still put tefillin on that arm. But if they're missing beyond that, then they put it on the other arm. Some say you should still put it on that nub but don't make a blessing. Instead, put it on the other arm and make a blessing when you put tefillin on the head. The point is that there are different forms of disabilities.

1:35:09if the person, you know, has a level of autism or other types of mental disorders, that is, the person is not with us. He's just completely unaware of reality, has no concept of right and wrong, and things of that nature. Then no, he's absolved from the mitzvot. He's not judged for them. That neshama came to the world to suffer in that body for a certain period of time and until it goes to heaven. Usually, those neshamot are the neshamot of righteous people that need to suffer for a certain amount of time in a physical body. And Hashem puts them in those bodies specifically to protect them from sin. to protect them from sinning because if they have a normal body, they can potentially sin and lose the heaven that they were supposed to get. But anyway, He puts them in those bodies. So, usually, people that are completely, you know, disconnected from the world, unable to communicate, unable to function altogether, many times those can be the very righteous people.

1:36:16Either way, if the person is in that fashion, then they're absolved from the mitzvot. There's nothing that they can do. They have no concept of what anything is. On the other hand, if they are still communicating, aware, but they have some problems or inabilities regarding their body, then they can still fulfill mitzvot and somebody obviously needs to help them. So it all depends on the person. What is Pidyon Nefesh? Pidyon Nefesh is one of the things that the Kabbalists, you know, people do it, people that are involved in Kabbalah do it. If there is a person who has, you know, just... Really tough time, let's just say. Somebody's having a lot of bad things happen to them. Either there's sickness, they have financial issues, they have legal issues, they have problems with health issues, things like that. They can't have children.

1:37:28then sometimes they will go to somebody that can do a Pidyon Nefesh for them, and what that is, is that they take 180 coins and they do this specific type of prayer for the sake of that person takes a long time to do it, and that's why not everybody does it. Usually, the people that do it, you know, charge for it because it costs a lot of time. Even if a person is righteous, they can't do that stuff for people every day; it would literally waste their entire life. Also, arranging 180 coins is, in itself, a process. and you have to donate these coins to specific poor people and so on, and you know, so it's a whole process. I've done it, I've had a couple of people that have helped connect with someone that, you know, is a friend of mine, is a, friend, you know, whatever, somebody I know that's a mekubal that does it. But many times people have asked me about it and I tell them right up front. I don't even ask him because I know that, you know, most people are not willing to pay for stuff like this. They think that it's like the rabbis are supposed to like work for free, like it's some type of charitable cause. They don't realize how much this stuff involves. So many times I don't even tell them about it because I tell the people, listen, if you do this, it's going to cost you, you know,

1:38:52$500 to $1,000, maybe more even. So, if the person says, "Oh, no, no, I think I have something else," okay, great, thank you very much. I don't have to waste my time making calls, making arrangements, and then you just simply waste his time. I tell you it costs money. If you want to do it, great; if you don't want to do it, please don't waste anybody's time. But as far as does it work, it can work. it can work. It's not something that's guaranteed. Nothing is guaranteed because, again, sometimes it's not the Pidyon Nefesh that would help, but rather the Teshuva that would help. If the person is doing everything possible to fix themselves and they do a Pidyon Nefesh, then it's good. But if the person is doing a Pidyon Nefesh but he's still wasting seed, he's still going out with different girls, he's still stealing in his business, he's still dishonest, he's still doing all types of sins, a Pidyon Nefesh is not going to do anything for him. So it's something that you do for people who are, at the very least, doing something for themselves unless there's literal life on the line, and then you pretty much just try anything anyway. But again, there's no guarantee that it'll work. It can work. It certainly has worked. But it's not something that's guaranteed.

1:40:11by no stretch of the imagination, and if I can tell you from experience, if somebody tells you, "Listen, yeah, no problem, we'll just do the pidyon nefesh for you. Give me 50 bucks, 100 bucks," you can be sure they're not doing it. Not because it's anything else other than the fact that it just takes a lot of time. It takes a lot of time to do it. It's not, uh, it's not five minutes. So anyone that does not value their time, uh, you know, it's, it's, it's... I wouldn't want them to do a pidyon nefesh for me. and you know the Torah people that do it usually are serious Torah scholars, people that value every second. So they're not going to do it, you know, for nothing. Now, of course, there are some tzaddikim that will randomly do it for specific causes, for specific people, and so on, but usually, those people don't deal with the general public. During the times of the Beit HaMikdash During the times of the Beit HaMikdash, is every male or family responsible to bring appropriate offerings on Shabbat and Rosh Chodesh, or does the Temple just use their animals? No, everybody has to bring their own. Everybody has to bring their own animals, or they buy it at the Beit HaMikdash.

1:41:24If you ever look at different teachings about the Beit HaMikdash, you'll see that the Beit HaMikdash was like a city of its own. The Beit HaMikdash wasn't just a building; it was like a city of its own. There was a haircut area, a fruits and vegetable area, a place for sheep, a place that made leather, pools—there were a lot of interesting things in the Beit HaMikdash. Uh, and certainly, they had a section where people would buy the korbanot there because it wasn't possible for them to bring the different animals from wherever they were. They came from far away, or they simply didn't have the ability to bring it, so they would buy it over there. I saw many people that talk about near-death experiences; however, these people report that they see heaven. how can this be true if most of them are idol worshipers? Is this some trap of the Satan when these people experience these episodes? Okay, so when a person makes certain sins,

1:42:42The Mishnah in Masechet Avot says that a person creates different mazikim. Mazikim, you can, I guess, translate to demons. It's not the perfect translation, but it's a translation. Mazikim are demons. When a person does good deeds, according to the Torah, they create angels. Angels that help them. Those angels, the good ones, give them strength to encourage them to do more good deeds and also protect them from whatever demons they already have. Needless to say, they try to entice them to not make sins and to do mitzvot. The demons do the exact opposite. give them strength to encourage them to do more good deeds and also protect them from whatever demons they already have. Needless to say, they try to entice them to not make sins and to do mitzvot. The demons do the exact opposite. When a person commits sins and acquires demons, those demons will make that person more inclined to commit more sins and thereby acquire more demons. The more sins a person commits, the more they are surrounded by literally millions of demons. Especially if they waste seed and are immodest and immoral, then each act could literally be creating not just one demon, but millions.

1:44:01Anyway, those demons are not just there sitting, playing cards, and waiting for the guy to decide what he wants to do with his life. They have certain rights; they have certain benefits, if you will. And part of their benefits is to mess with the person. to mess with them, is to torture them. Many times they torture people during their sleep. They come to them in the form of nightmares or in the form of false images. They might come to them as, let's say, some grandparent telling them that such and such is going to happen, but in reality, nothing happens. It's not their grandparent; it's some demon messing with them because he knows it's going to wreck this guy's day. He's going to cry for three weeks because he saw his long-lost grandfather. or it's going to come to them as something that's going to make them nervous because it's going to tell them that their, uh, loved one is going to die in three days. So it's going to simply mess with them, or it's going to come to them in night terrors. Anyone who doesn't know what night terrors are... You're very lucky that you don't know what it is. Let's just say that. And they also come to them in different visions. Different visions that could be a near-death experience vision, where a person will see something that would seem to be like heaven, would even seem to be like some false god. They could see somebody that could literally say to them, he is Buddha, or he's Jesus, or he's Bil'am, or he's Par'o, he's whoever they want him to be.

1:45:29um, now why does Hashem allow this? It's not about Him allowing it; there's a cause and an effect. You did certain things; therefore, you created the result. When a person is worshiping an idol Whether it's the idol from Christianity and Catholicism or the idol from all types of religions in India or in different parts of Asia, Buddhism and so on, that person is creating different types of demons. And those demons, some of them have a lot of strength. Some of them are very, very powerful. uh and uh they could do a lot of uh a lot of things to uh cause the people to stay in a direction that they want them to stay, meaning that uh they'll mess with the guy, they'll give certain dreams, certain visions, certain beliefs in order for him to stay on this sinful path. One of the common things now is people becoming Satanists A lot of you are becoming Satanists and, uh, it, you would, I wouldn't be surprised if you told me, "Listen, I know a Satanist and he says he speaks to things and he sees things." That's not a surprising thing. To get a demon to show up, you can do it in five minutes if you want, but to get him to leave, that's a different story. So, so that's the, that's the thing. To get these powers of impurity, uh, to come, literally you could do it in five seconds.

1:46:56It's not a problem. To get them to leave, that may take you a lifetime. That may take you a lifetime. So the Satanists use semen and blood typically to form relationships with these different types of creatures. Like I said, called demons is a general name, but there are different aspects of it. And some of them have very extraordinary powers, like Rav Yosef Ben-Porat recently brought out in a lecture. There are also some books written about it in German and other languages from friends of Hitler. friends of Hitler. Hitler had friends at some point before he became involved in witchcraft, which in so many words, took over. Rav Yosef Ben-Porat actually has a lecture about it, and they recently did a great job on it. They even have English subtitles.

1:47:57uh, in this lecture, obviously, if I remember, I'll publicize it, you know, on the channel. But anyway, they bring all of the unusual things that happened, how this loser named Hitler, who was a complete loser, degenerate garbage for the first 30 years of his life, all of a sudden becomes an anomaly in all aspects over the next, you know, 25 years. uh, the first paycheck he ever got was from being a chancellor. It's not a normal thing. So, the guy was a, uh, how did this happen? Some of his friends from childhood and even from his early stages of being a Nazi leader were very, very close to him. They knew him and they knew that he was involved in witchcraft. and they even warned him about it. They even tried to get him away from it. But in so many words, what was concluded is that certainly he was involved in witchcraft. It's a well-known thing. And so much so that this type of demons, some even say the Satan himself, got the permission to enter Hitler himself. And in so many words, take over.

1:49:17He got the permission because Am Yisrael merited certain sins, and that's a different account altogether. But the point being is that it all depends on the level of witchcraft, the level of spiritual impurity a person is involved in. uh and what it actually ends up yielding, some people that are involved in the, you know, basic, everyday, young people sins of, you know, immorality, promiscuity, and things like that, certainly they have certain things, but those things can go away if you do teshuva. other people that are involved in more heavy-duty stuff, where it's like an actual profession, their promiscuity is a profession, then there's a much bigger problem, much more difficulty to get rid of that stuff, but still possible. And then again, if people are involved in idolatry, again, there's a certain amount of difficulty. I have some students that, Baruch Hashem, from all over the world, you know, they contact me and send me messages. "Rabbi, everything you said is true." Now, I know I say everything I said is true because I don't make it up. It's in the books. But they say, "No, no, I saw what you said."

1:50:29And you know, different people, Baruch Hashem, different people that used to be prostitutes, used to be involved in all types of idolatry, used to be involved in all types of garbage, spiritual garbage, that Baruch Hashem have done teshuva through different lectures, either myself or others. And literally, everything we've talked about in different lectures, I've had people tell me, listen, what you said happened to me. What you said happened to me. I don't know why people don't believe this stuff. I saw it. And so the point I'm trying to tell you is that for an idol worshiper or a, you know, promiscuous person to tell me, you know, that they see strange things, it's not a big deal. I mean, I would say I could tell you even righteous people that I know, that they see strange things. There's a lot of strange things out there. Not necessarily everybody has the merit to see them. I know there's some people that, uh, uh, I know I'm familiar with, and, you know, some I'm even very, very close to. Uh, they see stuff all the time. You know, it's, it's, it's not a big deal. It's not a big deal. Uh, my recommendation is, and that's the recommendation from Rav Yitzchak, don't pay attention to it. Meaning, if you see stuff—smoke, stuff moving, all types of creepy stuff—don't pay attention to it. The more attention you pay to it...

1:51:58the more it's going to want to come back and torture you. So my recommendation is to not pay attention to it at all, act as if it doesn't exist, and simply focus on teshuva, specifically with those things that have to do with kedusha. Meaning, eliminate any form of idolatry from your life—that's a given—but even more so, sanctify yourself when it comes to issues of morality. Don't waste seed. Don't be immodest. Try to get people to do teshuva for those things because that's the only fix. That's the only fix to those things. They don't just go away just because you don't like them. And they have permission to go wherever they want, in so many words, while you're sleeping, while you're half-dead, while you're alive, during the day. They can do whatever they want. Again, it all depends on different powers. Some are nothing. Some, you know, don't have any strength. Some you can just say a prayer and they're gone. Others are more serious. I have no idea why you guys ask these types of questions, but maybe I have these types of answers. I'm not sure which one's at fault. But ideally, it's not the best thing to talk about at night. Aye, aye, aye.

1:53:15what age should girls be allowed to wear makeup and get a manicure and pedicure? What age should girls be allowed to wear makeup and get a manicure and pedicure? Uh, it all depends on what you mean by makeup, manicure, and pedicure. If you mean to preserve themselves, wear a little blush, and have their nails painted in modest colors, not like witch nails that are four times the normal size, and then start showing off their feet to everybody that walks by. That's never allowed. so if you mean modest, modest things then, you know, yeah, once she's already getting ready for a shidduch, then that would be the appropriate time. It shouldn't be before that because it could entice her to do sins.

1:54:23Should be at a time when she's ready to go on a shidduch, get married, then yeah. But if you're talking, if what you mean by makeup and manicure and pedicure is to look like, you know, the Hollywood people, and she has all types of colors all over her face, and all types of nails that are longer than the exile, and toes that are shinier than the sun, that's never allowed. Even after she's married, it's not allowed to do that. attractive, not attracting, that's the key. A woman should ... Okay, I'm heartbroken. I woke up on Shabbat night, used the bathroom door, and found my husband being inappropriate with his brit while watching a filthy video. I'm embarrassed. I asked rabbanim in my community, what should I do? Should I divorce him? Should I forgive him? tried to please him how he wants. I can't believe he did this to me. He claims it's the first time he broke Shabbat. I just couldn't hold back. Okay, so he didn't do it to you. Even though I know you feel horrible about it, he didn't do it to you. He did it to himself. He did it to his relationship with Hashem.

1:55:44And this is something that didn't just happen on Shabbat for the first time. Perhaps he just violated Shabbat for the first time, but what led him to violate Shabbat is that he's been wasting seed for apparently some time. uh, and sometimes when a person gets addicted to wasting seed, uh, it gets to a point where they start losing their mind and lose control. They feel the need to see it, so my recommendation is to have him, uh, and I would say even watch it with him all of our lectures in the playlist that talk about this issue. There's a playlist on our YouTube channel, and there's a playlist on our application for Tikun HaBrit (rectification of the covenant), wasting seed. There are probably around 120 or so different videos. Most of them are short clips of five to ten minutes, some of them are longer full lectures of two to three hours, and there are a few movies, especially the famous movie called Tikun HaBrit. I would have him listen to those lectures in addition to listening to one of our series of lectures that specifically talk about Mussar. There's actually a four-step process.

1:56:59four-step process that I send new people that have this issue and come to me for help. Four-step process of what they need to do in order to overcome this obstacle of addiction to immorality. The first step is to watch the movie "Tikkun HaBrit." The second step is to watch this short clip called "The ABCs of Tikkun HaBrit." It's on our channel. The third step is to watch all of the lectures on that playlist that I just told you about. Obviously, you know, this is on a regular basis, not just one time, meaning that even after he finishes all 150 of them. it doesn't mean that he stops listening forever. What happens is that he has to constantly get chizuk, meaning that each week, based on where he's at as far as his weaknesses and his strengths, he'll still have to listen to it from time to time, maybe once a week, twice a week, but still to keep himself strong. Every guy needs it. It's not just him. It's not just your husband. Your husband is not unique, and you're not the only victim in the world. This is a common thing both for men and for women in the world today.

1:58:00and throughout the generations. So, I would not divorce him under any condition for this specific act. Now, if he tells you, "I don't want to change, I'm going to continue doing it, and I care less," that's a different story. But usually, men are not that stupid. Usually, men, you know, once they show any form of embarrassment, usually that means that they know it's wrong; they just are addicted to it. So, to help him, I would say, do those first three steps and the fourth step is to learn mussar on a regular basis and I believe that our lectures are a very good mussar for people today, whether they are from Chassidish, Ashkenazi, Sephardi, converts, whatever they are. Our lectures have touched many people from all walks of life, but that's the fourth step. If anybody wants the details of the four steps, you could just send me a message on WhatsApp and I'll send you a quick uh, four steps with the links, and you could share it. You could, uh, use it yourself. It's, uh, it's bogus. It's helped thousands and thousands of people. This four-step process used to be three; now it's four because I realized that the fourth step is the continuing education to keep you strong. So, uh, it's helped thousands and thousands of people overcome this sin. I've even had people that used to be homosexuals

1:59:23overcome that sin because of this. I've had people that had all types of horrible, horrible addictions and even some people that used to be prostitutes and all types of other professions that are in that world who literally overcame this insanity by watching those lectures. So it works. It works, Baruch Hashem. I believe that our shiurim about Tikkun HaBrit are better than anything else that you have in the world today. And I'm not saying that because I am smarter than everybody else or anything else. I just simply don't believe anybody else has brought as much truth and clarity on this specific subject as we have in the English language. In Hebrew, there's certainly some great people that have taught this subject over the years. Rav Daniel Zer speaks about it at least once a year, and several others have spoken about it extensively. But Rav Edri speaks about it regularly, so there are plenty of good people in Hebrew. But in English,

2:00:29No one has spoken about it as extensively, as openly, and as clearly as we have on this subject and as often. So more than any institution, including some of the ones that are very popular and get hundreds of thousands of dollars a year in donations for, I don't know what they do, but... Simply put, there's no institution right now that has as much information about the subject as that playlist that you get for free from us. So take advantage of it. The woman is a lunatic who posts things against students of Rabbi Reuven. The question is fake too. She could post things against me. You could say things that make a difference whether a question was fake or not. Certainly, it's real for somebody. Certainly, it's real for somebody. Uh, question: Is it permitted to be a horse breeder, which entails manually getting the male horse to release seed into a bottle?

2:01:52I mean, there's no issue of wasting seed for animals, and breeding is certainly something that does happen in the world. I mean, if you're a Jew, again, it's not the ideal profession for Jews, I would say, but there's certainly some form of, you know, there are things like this that happen. It's not, again, so long as it's not done with different species, as long as it's within the same species and things like that, but... Again, there's nothing that I say is forbidden about it if it's just normal, meaning it's not trying to breed different animals and cross-breeding and things like that. If it's just simply producing better-quality horses or better-quality other animals, there's no problem with it as long as it stays within the same species because...

2:02:52The kilayim, which is cross-breeding, is forbidden both for Jews and for Gentiles, according to the Torah. But if you're talking about just traditional breeding, there's nothing wrong with it. It's obviously not going to be something that everyone is inclined to do or wants to do, but it's a necessary profession in the world. It's not a new thing. uh, everywhere there's a needy person among you, one of your kids. What are you saying here? You're just quoting something from a thought. Okay, also, several of you are familiar with this person or saying what they asked is a fake question. I don't think it's a fake question. I don't think it's a fake question because, number one, like I said, it doesn't matter whether it's a real question for that person or not. That question is very much a real question for somebody today who's watching it, or tomorrow, or next week. I mean, I deal with people all day. I get 500 to 1,000 messages a day.

2:04:10...make fun, you know, there's nothing funny about it. It's a real question that presents a problem, and I could tell you that if you use euphemism and minimize parts of the Torah, then the Torah says we quiet them. Quiet them is not a good thing when it says when Hashem silences a person. ...uh, make fun, you know, there's nothing funny about it. It's a real question that presents a problem, and I could tell you that it says that if you use euphemisms and minimize parts of the Torah, then the Torah says we quiet them. Quiet them is not a good thing when it says when Hashem silences a person... it usually doesn't mean something favorable. So if they're making fun, like what you guys are suspecting, then all they did to themselves is bring a disaster. But still, we benefited from it because somebody needs to learn, so it's no problem. What does it mean that begins at death? Usually, it's said that we can do teshuva only while alive.

2:05:24Also, doesn't someone lose their Olam HaBa for this sin? So how can they get back? Okay, so the Gemara in Masechet Yoma, page 86a, talks about different types of sins that a person does teshuva for. uh, they can't. It's not enough to just say "I'm sorry." For some, it's enough to say "I'm sorry." For some, you have to say "I'm sorry," but also pray extra and wait for Yom Kippur. Yom Kippur is an auspicious time when the sin will be officially forgiven. Some say, no, it's not just saying "I'm sorry" and Yom Kippur, but they have to have some suffering in their life in order for that sin to be erased. And for some, even Yom Kippur and suffering are not enough. Even Yom Kippur. Meaning that sin will still be on their record until they die, and they will have to suffer for that sin in the next world unless they rectify it with Kiddush Hashem.

2:06:32But the point is that it's still on a person's record. It's like a person has a criminal record from 20 years ago. Twenty years ago he robbed a bank. Twenty years ago he beat somebody up. But he's been clean and perfect for the last 20 years. But still, if he wants to work for some well-respected firm and they look at his record and they say, wait, what's going on with you? You beat up somebody 20 years ago? Why would you beat up anybody? He goes, no, I was a different person back then. And even if they agree with him, it's like, ah, listen, we appreciate it, but it's hard for us to justify hiring somebody with that record from 20 years ago when we have plenty of people looking for the same job without that record. So it's still on the record. So in essence, the Chilul Hashem, even if a person did Teshuvah for it, meaning they said, "I'm sorry," they're doing everything possible to not repeat the sin, but still it's on their record until the day that they die because there's a certain type of suffering that they have to get for it in the next world. There's a certain amount of suffering they'll get for it in this world. There's a certain amount of repentance they have to do on Yom Kippur, but there's a special type of suffering for them in the next world.

2:07:47Uh, are you still being a sponsoring Rav for people converting? Only for people that are local to me. Generally speaking, I mean, there's a lot of people that I help. As far as people that are on the, you know, we have a conversion group... And people watch, you know, get updates over there. And they get, you know, like the lectures and different campaigns that we have. And then sometimes people send me certain questions, and I try my best to answer. especially people that are serious and people that I know are, you know, are people that are able and interested to convert in the near future. You know, I usually try to invest more time in them than I do people that may not convert for another five years, either because they don't have the ability to financially or because they're too young or because they're married to somebody who doesn't want to convert. So, I try to prioritize certain things. But as far as actually taking people to the Beit Din, I used to do it.

2:08:52With people regardless of where they were all over the world, but over the recent last couple of years, I've only been doing it with people that are local to me. You know, only people that are living in Florida, and that's the way it's going to stay. I'm not going to continue taking on any new students that are outside of Florida. It's just too much of a headache and ...and there's too much of a problem sponsoring people from afar. You have to rely on other rabbis and whether they're telling you the truth or lies. To be honest with you, once I, b'ezrat Hashem, open up the shul... I'm going to officially stop taking anybody that doesn't live in our community. Meaning that even if they live in Florida, but they don't live in our community, I won't help them. I could send them our lectures, they could join our group, but for me to take them to a Beit Din, it's only going to happen if they live in our community. And the reason for that is not because I think everyone else is bad and we're good, but rather because the only way that I can be sure that somebody is good and is somebody that I want them.

2:10:01and I want her to be part of Am Yisrael. They're not lying to me, and they're not part of the wrong community. They're not going to be part of some idol-worshipping Jewish cult. They're going to be part of real Judaism if they're literally under my umbrella. Now, right now I don't have the capability of having people being next to me because I don't have the shul yet, but once we do... then we're gonna become even more strict with who we sponsor and who we don't. I've helped people from all over the world, but little by little over the last few years, we've minimized it more and more. The only people that I've helped that don't live next to me are people that have already been with me for a few years. So I couldn't just kick them out, so I helped them. They were already with me and I was already in the process. But as far as new people, I'm not taking on anybody already for a while that doesn't live next to me. What Judaica item can they get for a 12-year-old boy that is anti-Torah? The best possible Judaica item that you can get a 12-year-old that's anti-Torah is if you go to bezrathashem.org, you go to the store, you go to the USB section, you order the USB collection, or you go to the kiruv package. One of those two, because the kiruv package has a couple of USBs in it.

2:11:23and some other books, or you can get the USB package. Those are the best possible Judaica items that you can get on planet Earth for a 12-year-old, or a 20-year-old, or a 50-year-old, you know, that is anti-Torah. Best thing you can get them. And in fact, you can even get them for people that are not anti-Torah. It's the best present. Highly recommended. uh, can someone take a non-kosher medication not for an illness but for some kind of beneficial effect? uh, as far as medication is concerned, if it does not have taste, meaning if it, uh, has a bad taste or no taste such as aspirin or a vitamin or whatever it is, but it doesn't have a taste, the pill, uh, or the, uh, the, you know, the liquid, whatever it is, doesn't have a taste or it's disgusting that even a dog wouldn't eat it, then it does not need to be kosher. So, you could consume it for whatever you want, whether it's for medicinal reasons or for beneficial reasons. But if it does have a taste, such as sweeteners, like they have certain things that taste sweet, cough drops that taste good, and whatever, other types of medicine that taste good—especially kids' medicine—if an adult takes kids' medicine, it's a problem.

2:12:43uh, so if it has a good taste, then it needs to be kosher. It needs to be kosher because it's allowed to show a bidder the competitor's estimate before they submit their pricing. It's allowed to show a bidder the competitor's estimate before they submit their pricing. Oh, you mean if somebody is selling a job... and he already has somebody else offering the, uh, you know, to do the job, and then there's somebody else that wants the job, and, uh, he wants to put a bid in, and you want to tell them what the other guy did. If it's full disclosure, where everybody knows that you're going to disclose the bids to everybody, there's no problem, but if only that guy that sees the bid knows that he's getting that bid... uh, then it's geneivat da'at. You're stealing everybody else's mind because they're all assuming that you're not going to give any favorable treatment to anybody else. Uh, so you're going to have fair rules for everybody because if they knew that you were going to give favorable terms, they wouldn't waste their time and put in a bid.

2:13:52So it's called geneivat da'at, it's stealing their mind. So no, you're not allowed to do that. But if it's fair game for everybody, anybody that asks can get to see the estimates and the price of everybody, then sure, no problem showing it. If one forgot to shut off the automatic light that turns on in the fridge before Shabbat, is one allowed to open the fridge on Shabbat? And if one accidentally opened the fridge... with the same situation with the light on, is one allowed to close it? The answer is no to both because if you know for sure that opening the fridge will turn on the light, you're not allowed to open that fridge. So find some cookies and some crackers and live what we've all lived through at some point or another when we had that same screw-up happen to us. Everybody's had that happen to them. And the same thing if the fridge is open. If the fridge is open, you know, they'll be you closing it. You're going to shut off the light. Can't close it. Can't close it. So food's going to get ruined. I mean, if you have a goy,

2:15:00that, you know, you could hint to if you have a child that you could, you know, bring him to the room and, you know, don't tell him to do it, but they do it. You know, that's a... But generally speaking, if it's just adults in there, it's a problem, but it happens to all of us. It happens to all of us. My recommendation, and again, you don't have to listen to me. This is not a halachic recommendation. This is my personal preference. My preference is to eliminate as many responsibilities as possible. that I can, you know, especially before Shabbat. But needless to say, there are plenty of responsibilities that require me to remember them, like to-do lists and things like that. So what we did in my house is, we actually disconnected the light. You know, we used to put tape on the light

2:16:13shut off the light. But you know what happened? At least once, the tape came off; it wasn't strong enough. So, the light went on, which was a problem. So, the best thing that we did is we simply just shut off the light. And, since the fridge that we have couldn't shut off the lights, we just disconnected them altogether. We removed the lights. Uh, so why? Because, number one, I don't want that problem again. It could be a very costly and difficult problem to have this issue happen to you on Shabbat and Yom Tov, especially if it's a long holiday. And, number two, it's not necessary to have a light in a fridge. I mean, how big is your fridge that you need a light? It's not necessary. Uh, so that's the thing. It's just not necessary to have a light in the fridge. You know, it's nice to have a light in the fridge, but it's not necessary. For me, it's not worth it; it's not worth the headache. So we just disconnected it altogether. Again, you don't have to follow what I do; that's what I do. I'm sure that many other people don't do that, but for me, that's the perfect solution. But if, you know, if somebody doesn't want to do that, they simply have to remember to shut off their lights before Shabbat.

2:17:34Why does it seem to be a negative attitude towards dogs, specifically among Orthodox Jews? Does the Torah say anything good or bad about dogs? I actually have a short clip about dogs in regard to Judaism. So you can watch that clip. In so many words, there was a... Dogs are... One end called dogs, they're called kelev because they're very loyal to their master, but they're also very, uh, you know, they have no shame. They're an animal that has no shame. So the way that they procreate and so on, they have a certain curse on them that they got at the time of the flood. There were three creatures that made it in the ark; it was forbidden to cohabitate in the ark. The Gemara in Masechet Sanhedrin says it was forbidden; Hashem decreed it was forbidden for anybody to cohabitate in the ark, not only because of room and things like that, and modesty, but also because the world was being destroyed. How could you be celebrating by doing such a thing? But three creatures violated the decree. One of them was the raven, the second one was the dog, and the third one was Cham.

2:18:52Ham, the son of Noach. And from there came Canaan, which eventually also, you know, came a lot of enemies of Am Yisrael. So anyway, the dog got cursed because of this, because they procreated in the ark. But they also got a blessing because they didn't bark, you know, when we were leaving Mitzrayim. Therefore, there's a blessing for dogs that, you know, any leftover meat you give to the dog—meat that's treif—you give to the dog. So how do you balance all of this out? The fact that the dog is not a modest or, you know, not a... is an immoral animal, if you will. It's different than other animals. The way that it procreates is very different. It's an animal without shame. It stays in a position for a while. In so many words, that is a reality. There's nothing we can do about that.

2:19:57Is it a loyal animal? Yes, it's a loyal animal. It could be a very useful animal, a very good animal. So a person needs to know that, as far as Judaism is concerned, it doesn't have a negative view of anything that is not against the Torah. So it's not against the Torah. uh to have an animal. But there are sins that you can commit with the animal. For example, touching the animal and petting it on Shabbat is a problem. Why? Because the animal is considered muktzeh. But it's not just dogs; it's cats, it's ducks. Somebody asked me about ducks today. Ducks are also not allowed to be touched on Shabbat. uh, you know, so also when you walk a dog, you have to be very careful to have a short leash if it's on Shabbat. So, there are specific laws you need to know with dogs. Last but not least, because the dog is an impure animal, it's a very bad idea to have a dog living in your house, needless to say, living in your bedroom.

2:20:57So, you know, many times people have animals live in their bedroom and sleep with them in the bed and everything. That's not a good thing, spiritually speaking. But as far as, you know, are there good things about animals? Yes. I mean, I have a video. I have a video that's a short movie where I talk about my dog that passed away years ago. He was a fantastic dog. I had him for 16 years. His name was Bully. I've spoken about him over the years in different lectures. I think that dog learned more Torah than any other dog in his generation. I think Bully was the gadol hador of the generation of dogs. A lot of times, that dog listened when I had lectures. He was in the room and he was always very quiet and good. So, you know, dogs can be okay; it's just that you need to know how to treat them and how to deal with them. According to the Torah, there's no negative viewpoint against dogs. They're a creation, but you need to know that there are negative things you can do with them and there are also positive things you can do with them. So, with that being said, thank you very much everyone for learning with me. I appreciate it. Bless each and every single one of you. Anyone that wants to donate and support what we do, go to BHtorah.org or to...

2:22:13or you can donate on the YouTube channel. The YouTube channel now has a little money sign or something under the videos where you can support us. You can sign up for a subscription. I think it's like $20, $50, or $200 a month, whatever you want. Please sign up if you can afford it and you're watching us there. It's certainly a good thing to do. Or you can donate online on our website. So either way, Thank you very much. And now also a reminder: anyone that is in the world of technology, especially familiar with things like coding or really anything in technology that you think we can use and you want to volunteer at our organization, please let us know. Or even if you have some unique technology that you think can help us, please reach out and we'd be happy to look into it. We're very, very much into technology and trying to use it for the benefit of Am Yisrael and the Torah. So, thanks again for everything. We'll learn together again next week.

BH Headquarters