STUMP THE RABBI (115) Emunat Chachamim, TALMUD AUTHENTICITY, Helping Dead Sinners, NOAHIDE HEAVEN
Transcript
0:15We are back on our Wednesday night Stump the Rabbi. We're after a little bit of Divrei Torah. You guys will ask some questions and B'ezrat Hashem HaKadosh Baruch Hu will give us the answers. Tonight's shiur will be for Refuah Shlema, for Rabbanit Levana Bat Sarah, Rav Efraim Ben Shulamit, Rabbanit Sarah Bat Anat, Avim Uri David Ben Esria, Doris Bat Zhora, Urit Bat Ilana, Sarah Bat Sausan, and also for a Hatzlacha Rabba for Marsha Bat Julie. Eila Bat Marsha, Semer Ben Marsha, Sefas Ben Marsha, Alexander Ben Marsha, Louis Ben Marsha, Shaul Ben Farzaneh, Yitro Ben Avraham, Oshri Ben Doris, Gavi Ben Doris, Elad Ben Doris, David Ben Esria. Amir Ben-Shaheen and all of Am Yisrael will have a Refuah Shleimah, Hatzlacha Rabah, B'kol Ma'asei Yedeichem to all of those that continue to support in every way, shape, and form. So for those of you that have gotten your packages, please, you know, with all of the kiruv store,
1:33Please send some pictures of some happy faces that are getting the books and the CDs and all the other wonderful things that you got. This in itself could actually help people do teshuvah because if you show how excited you are and how excited people are, to get the material to help them do teshuvah, surely that's going to encourage more people to sign up and get material for themselves. For anybody that wants to get it, get some stuff to give out in their community in the United States, go to our website, KiruvStore.org. Kiruv, K-I-R-U-V, Store, S-T-O-R-E, .org. And you can order some stuff for free. We even pay for the shipping. Of course, everybody that has the financial ability, please donate. Aside from that, also a very big update, Baruch Hashem. Anybody that's watching me right now,
2:34From the app, you're seeing that there is a major, major update in the app—an extraordinary update with all types of wonderful new tools. Of course, you can watch the lecture live, but there are also many other new tools on the app. Additionally, for anybody that wants to watch the lecture live, you can go to bh.live. to watch the lectures live and avoid going to, you know, Facebook or anywhere else. There's also another new website that, in essence, houses all of the websites, whether it's BeEzratHashem.org or YHWH.org or TikkunHaBrit.org or BH.live. Go to BHTorah.org. Go to BHTorah and... B as in Be'ezrat, H as in Hashem, Torah, T-O-R-A-H, .org. That's the new website. Baruch Hashem, it, in essence, houses everything. So wherever you want to go, you just go there and press the button, and it'll take you to whichever one of the websites you want to go to, watch things live, watch one of the movies. Baruch Hashem, our team is just getting more and more siyata dishmaya to help more and more people do teshuva. Baruch Hashem.
3:55So with that being said, Baruch Hashem, we placed the order for another 10,000 copies of the book. The reviews, the feedback we're getting, Baruch Hashem, from Eretz Yisrael has been amazing. Still waiting for some feedback from the U.S. since people just got their books over the last couple of weeks, but a few people who were really zealous started reading it and are sending pictures of smiling faces. So Baruch Hashem, if anybody didn't get any one of the books... The United States or Israel, please. Let us know, some of you that are contacting us or even placing orders on the website but are located in different places around the country. You know, you're simply wasting time because, as we said in the post itself, right now we're focusing on the US, and of course, we have some stuff in Israel. Later on, b'ezrat Hashem, if Hashem allows, we'll also do other countries, but... The cost of shipping is extraordinary to ship anything overseas. Even shipping in the US, the average package is costing a ton of money just to ship it without even calculating the cost of material. So anybody that really, really wants it
5:08to come to, I don't know, whatever country they want to go to. If you're willing to pay for the shipping, which is probably going to be at least several hundred dollars, I'm more than happy to do it. It's just that we have to do things within budget, and at the same time, the budget itself is already something that is above and beyond what we thought it was going to be. So with that being said, let's get into the shiur we have, Baruch Hashem. So Yaakov lived in the land of Egypt 17 years. Yaakov Avinu lived 147 years. in this world, and most of those years were atrocious years, full of difficulty, full of suffering, whether it was the life-threatening battles that he had with Esav, his brother, or living in the house of the biggest criminal in history, Lavan, Lavan HaArami, or it was simply fighting for the sake of his wives,
6:17or losing his son for 22 years, Yosef. Lots and lots of suffering in the life of Yaakov. But the Torah says that the last 17 years were the best years of his life, which in essence means that everything that's happening here, Yaakov obviously is... giving the blessings, making the statements under a very clear mind, because the Gemara says that if somebody is in pain, they don't judge them in Shamayim for doing certain things, meaning the judgment is lessened. as there was one of the sages that was in massive pain and another person, another Jewish student, thought that it was wise to play a game with him. And the sage, you know, didn't find it funny at all because the game itself was causing him pain. In essence, he was getting in his way when he wanted to go to the bathroom and relieve some of the pain. And this young man did not think that, you know, his actions were serious.
7:33Game was crossing the line, and the sage, you know, cursed him, and the person died on the spot. The Gemara says that just like Iyov (Job) said some things that could borderline be considered heretical before he did teshuvah, Hashem did not judge him as harshly as He would judge somebody that would be under, you know, normal conditions. Job was under an immense amount of pain, to say the least. Just like the sage was under an immense amount of pain, anybody who is in immense pain and suffering is not judged the same way. It doesn't mean that they're not judged; they're not allowed to simply violate the entire Torah. but in essence, it's already known in the Torah, it's already taught by the sages that when a person is suffering, obviously this can cloud your judgment, this can shorten your temper, and so on. But this was not the case with Yaakov Avinu. Yaakov Avinu has just had the 17 best years of his life, which means that the rebuke that he is giving his children is actually the best of the best. It's not coming from a place of suffering, it's not coming from a place of discontent, it's not coming from hatred.
8:43which means that the rebuke that he is giving his children is actually the best of the best. It's not coming, chas v'shalom, from a place of suffering, it's not coming from a place of discontent, it's not coming from hatred, it's not coming from any place that is inappropriate, but rather these rebukes are actually some of the best blessings that a person could ever get if they would simply understand what it is to get a rebuke from a Talmid Chacham. Just like it was in the previous generation when one of the young men, who was the grandson of one of the Gedolei HaDor, you know, got rebuked for something he didn't do. When his friend told him, "Why didn't you tell your grandfather that you didn't do it? You just sat there and accepted the rebuke, and he just ripped you apart. Why didn't you tell him you didn't do it? I know you didn't do it—you were with me." young men, who was the grandson of one of the Gedolei HaDor, you know, got rebuked for something he didn't do. When his friend told him, "Why didn't you tell your grandfather that you didn't do it? You just sat there and accepted the rebuke, and he just ripped you apart. Why didn't you tell him you didn't do it? I know you didn't do it—you were with me."
9:45grandson said to his friend, "You're right, I didn't do it. But when am I ever going to get another chance to receive such a beautiful rebuke from one of the greatest sages in history? When am I going to get another chance?" Meaning that when a person understands what the value is of a tochacha... and thereby understand the value of a real tochacha, a person would actually look forward to it, even though it hurts, even though it is never fun to get rebuked. Nobody likes to be told what to do. But nonetheless, we see that the rebuke from Yaakov was words of love for his children and his descendants until this day. Now, In the beginning, we see a little bit of a test, a test here of where our minds are, of course, through the words of Yaakov to his son, where Yaakov asks his son for a promise to not bury him in Egypt as it says, "Please, if I have found favor in your eyes, please place your hand under my thigh and do kindness and truth with me. Please do not bury me in Egypt." So first and foremost, we see a few things that are unusual.
10:47in Egypt as it says, you know, "Please, if I have found favor in your eyes, please place your hand under my thigh and do kindness and truth with me. Please do not bury me in Egypt." So first and foremost, we see a few things that are unusual. The first thing is that he asks Yosef to put his hand under his thigh. If you did that in today's world, you would be considered a pedophile, a molester, or something like that. But that's because the world is full of filthy people that have filthy minds. Now, Yaakov Avinu was the head of the Avot, even though he was the grandson of Avraham. He was something... the closest to a perfect human being you can possibly get, and
11:52Yaakov understood the holiness of the Brit just like he learned from his grandfather Avraham Avinu when he made Eliezer, his servant, swear to him before going on a trip to find a kallah for his son Yitzchak. He said, "Put your hand under my thigh," meaning put your hand under my Brit. Why? Because it was customary in those days to hold the most valuable possession that you have. while you are making a promise, while you're making an oath. And Avraham Avinu, the most valuable thing that he had was his Brit, because that was the covenant between him and HaKadosh Baruch Hu. The same goes with his grandson, Yaakov Avinu understands the value of the Brit and mentions it other times in this parasha, where he says, "put your hand under my Brit and swear. This is the most valuable thing that I have. In essence, I'm putting everything on the line here."
12:53Now, of course, when a person sees something like this, or they see different things in the Gemara, if they even have the merit to study Gemara, and they see all types of statements in Midrashim that talk about the erva, which is the male member, different things, stories of how Hashem punished, for example, Nevuchadnetzar, who was a homosexual rapist that raped all of the kings out there, and when he wanted to rape one of the holy Jewish kings, Hashem punished him by making his erva really, really long to the point of disaster and... homosexual rapist who violated all the kings out there. When he wanted to assault one of the holy Jewish kings, Hashem punished him by making his erva really, really long, to the point of disaster and agony. uh, you know, agony and pain. Uh, other times, there are other places in the Torah that talk about the erva of different sages. Now, of course, if people say, "What is pornography in the Gemara and the Torah? Is the Torah pornography?" No, that just simply means you have pornography in your head. That's all that means. It means you have pornography and filth in your head if that's what you think.
14:03so what does it actually mean? Does it mean literally? Yeah, it means literally, but it's actually not supposed to be understood the way you understand it. Why? Because if a person has a clean mind and does not think of all the filth that's in the world, he understands the value of the brit. You understand that it's something holy, a holy person like Avraham. does not see a difference between his finger and his, uh, and his brit as far as a piece of the body. But as far as a piece of holiness, he sees it as the most valuable possession that he has in the entire world because that is, in essence, what's going to determine whether he will be holy and build a holy home or not. Because he can learn Torah and still be a filthy person. He can say nice things and still be a filthy person. He can help a lot of people and still be a filthy person and have no share in the World to Come. Why? The Brit is the foundation of the Jew.
15:04And even more so, even the non-Jews are obligated to a certain extent to not be adulterers and waste seed and things of that nature. As we saw in Er and Onan, before even Judaism began, before Matan Torah, they were killed by Hashem at a very young age because they wasted seed. We saw that the generation of Noach was destroyed because they wasted seed, because they were homosexuals, because they not only... accepted the immorality in the world but actually rationalized and legalized it, similar to how people are doing it today. Because who says, "You shall be holy because I am holy"? And the way that Israel sanctifies themselves and makes themselves holy is in the way that they treat Look at what the brit is. A holy Jew does not look at their brit. When I say look at their brit, I mean in perspective. How do you view it? Is this a tool to serve Hashem, or is this a tool to serve yourself? If you are looking at yourself in the mirror or every time you have to go to the bathroom, you have to make sure that all the parts are there, then you, my dear friend, are very far away from holiness and...
16:23you're very far away from holiness, and it's time to make that change. Why? Because there's no reason to check if your male parts are there. There's no reason to check if your female parts are there. Why? If they weren't, you would know. But we have gotten accustomed to the point of allowing filth into our minds, unbeknownst to us that it's even filth. And thereby, when people learn different lectures about tikkun habrit and the issues of immorality, It's a shock to their entire spiritual immune system because they never viewed things from that perspective. So it's very important to understand that when the sages, when the Torah itself mentions the issues of the brit, of the covenant, of the issues of the male or female parts, they're not talking about it in a filthy, disgusting-minded way of today's society, but rather in a Torah perspective. where this particular part of the body is, in essence, the determining factor of whether someone will ever become a holy person or not, and whether that seed will be a seed that will produce holiness or if it's going to be a seed that's going to produce demons.
17:33The choice is ours. The key is to understand that when Yaakov Avinu is telling his son to put his hand there, that's because they understand that this is the most valuable connection they have to HaKadosh Baruch Hu, and this is what distinguishes them from the Canaanim. Canaanites were also people. The Canaanites also had needs. The Canaanites also put their clothes on and took their clothes off, and they breathed. They were people just like everybody else. So, what’s the difference between the Jewish people and the rest of the people? Why are they chosen? This is the reason why they’re chosen. a Jew wants to sanctify themselves. There is nothing greater in the world than that. Why? Because that is a distinguishing factor that the nations do not have such policies. And even if you say, "Yeah, but some of the other religions also say that you shouldn't do it." Yes, they say that you shouldn't do it while they allow things that are much, much worse and
18:34so to understand what the sanctity is of the Brit is to understand what the foundation of the Torah is. Now, after this, we see that this whole discussion is, in itself, putting us to question what's going on here. Why? Because Yaakov is, in essence, telling son Yosef ben Poeti Yosef ben Poeti. Yosef was so righteous, so beautiful both spiritually and physically, that when he gets the blessing, he gets the most extensive blessing out of all the brothers. But yet Yaakov makes him swear. Why does he have to make him swear? Why not just tell him, "Listen"? Don't bury me in Egypt. The end. Or, just do me a favor. Don't bury me in Egypt. Why does he have to not only make him swear but make him swear with, in essence, everything on the line? Because Yaakov is, in essence, telling his son Yosef, I know that the other brothers will also want to do my will, but you're the only one that has a position of power that can actually fulfill it. The second thing that you have to understand is that you're going to have a lot of
19:56opportunities to not listen to me. One of those things is that Paro, who is an idol worshiper, with a nation full of idol worshipers, they're going to try to turn me into a place of idolatry. They're going to try to pray to me. They're going to tell you, no, no, you can't bury your father outside of Egypt. You have to bury him here. Since he came to Egypt, the famine ended. Instead of lasting seven years, it only lasted two years. Your father is a blessing. But since he came here, every time Paro goes to the Nile River, the Nile River, in essence, bows to him. You know, obviously, Yaakov is a very, very special person. We don't want his body to be anywhere else. We want to pray to him. We want to go sit next to him. We want to draw from him. We're going to do everything with him. So, of course, Paro is not going to want it. So that's why you have to swear. Why do you have to swear? What is it, does Paro care about the Jewish people making any oaths? Does he abide by the Torah? No. Paro abides by his own interests. And the Midrash tells us, it’s also in the Gemara, that when Yosef HaTzadik was in the prison the night before,
21:13The night before Paro called him up, while Paro was having those dreams, Malach Gavriel came to Yosef and taught him 70 languages. In one night, in essence, in one instance, he taught him 70 languages. Now, although Yosef was a genius tzaddik beforehand, now he got to a completely different level. Why did he need to know 70 languages? Now, everybody that was part of the Sanhedrin also had to know 70 languages, but they had a lot more than just one night to learn them. Yosef had a matter of a few hours to know all the languages. Why? Because tomorrow Paro is going to call you, and after you interpret his dream, he’s going to see whether he can prove to the others that you are fit to be a viceroy. This is because the Egyptians hate the Hebrews. In fact...
22:14they hate the Hebrews, they hate shepherds, and there's no way in the world that they would submit to the laws of somebody that they feel is disgusting. So, we have to prove that you fit. How do we prove it? The way that the kingdom was selected in Egypt at the time was based on the knowledge of languages. Whoever knew the most languages was king. Pharaoh knew 69 languages, and the way that they signified this in the kingdom of Pharaoh is that there were 70 steps to the throne of Pharaoh, and essentially Pharaoh fulfilled 69 of them. And every time that he spoke to Yosef, he said something in a different language. And Yosef had to answer him in that language to prove that he spoke that language. And each time he would go up another step, and another step, and another step. But after he got to the 69 languages, which is the maximum that Pharaoh knew, then Yosef said it again.
23:24...responded in Hebrew, a language that Paro himself did not know, which essentially meant that technically Yosef was supposed to become king, not viceroy. But since only Paro heard this, Paro made Yosef swear, "Swear that you're not going to tell anybody else that you know one more language than me." swear to me, and Yosef swore to him that he's not going to do it. So now, Yaakov, who was a prophet, tells Yosef, "When Paro comes to you and he tells you, 'Don't take your father out of here. We need his holy body in Egypt. What's better than Egypt? We'll build him a whole pyramid,'" Yosef says, "No, I swore to my father." And he's gonna tell you, "Okay, you swore to your father, but I'm still king." you have to answer him, "Yes, you're right, you are king, but of course, if I cancel my swear to my father, that means that I have to cancel all of my swears, including the one that I made to you years ago when we had that little discussion on the 70th step." At that moment, Paro understood that he had no choice. That's the reason behind the swear now.
24:48Interesting thing that I saw today is that Yosef doesn't really ask his father, "Why are you making me swear?" In essence, Yosef hears his father's request and simply says... That's it. I'll do as you say. No questions asked. No discussion. No, why do you want me to do this? Why are you making me swear? Why are we doing this whole thing? Why don't you bring the other brothers? No questions by Yosef. Why isn't Yosef asking questions? because we know that whoever is wise, it's shown by their questions, not by their answers, but rather by their questions. The Chachamim that would hear good questions would take time answering those questions, and there was one Chacham that heard a question from somebody that was in the name of one of the sages from the previous generation.
25:57And they said, "Kvod HaRav, do you know the answer?" And the Rav says to them, "Hold on a second. Let me enjoy this for a while." Enjoy what? The question from one of the Gedolei HaDor from the previous generation. "You just brought me a question. That's what I'm enjoying, not the answer. Yeah, I'll give you an answer, but that's not as much fun as looking at the mind of a Talmid Chacham." Enjoying the question. Questions determine a person's intellect. They see where and how that person thinks. Most people think that if you have all the information, perhaps that's what makes you smart. Not necessarily; it makes you prepared. Perhaps you could prepare yourself for things, and you could answer questions, or you simply have the gift of gab and you could just talk your way out of any hole. Even if what you're saying is wrong, it sounds right because you have confidence. Answering questions does not determine whether a person is smart or not. What kind of questions they ask, that's a different story. Now, of course, answering questions is critical if you answer the questions correctly. But sometimes people are so focused on looking good, they forget what they're even doing. Like the joke that I said once before, but I think it's worth saying again, there was one guy who was a complete idiot but pretended to be smart.
27:17And he says, "Listen, I think I should get the job. I'm better than everybody else you have." "I don't understand. Why do you think that you're better than everybody I have? Do you know all of the people that I have?" "I don't need to know. I know everything about everything. Ask me anything you want." So the guy says, "Okay, listen, since we deal with a lot of mathematical issues and so on, what is the..." Let's see if you know basic math. I don't know. What's 5 times 5? 25. No, no, no, no. Ask me another one. Ask me another one. Okay. 10 times 10. 100. No, no. Come on. Ask another one. Ask another one. Ask another one. Okay. What's 1 plus 7? 8. Hold on a second. You just said that you're smarter than everybody else that I have here. I have physicists here. I have astrologers here. I have people that are mathematical geniuses here. You can't even figure out first-grade math. What makes you think you're better than everybody else? Just forget about that. You're focusing too much on the answers. Did you notice how fast I can answer you? That's an idiot. But unfortunately, the world is full of such people.
28:32world is full of such people who are too focused on looking good rather than whether their content actually makes any sense. Typically, this is one of the habits of the heretics who are always unprepared but unfortunately always look like they know what they're talking about, hence the reason why they succeed in causing people to sin. But if you double-check their answers, you double-check their sources, nine out of ten times, you'll see that it's completely off, completely wrong. And the one time that it's right, typically it's not because they knew it, but rather because they simply, it's the one bit of information they do know, and they simply decide to put that piece of the puzzle in the first place that they saw. Now, here we see that Yaakov Avinu is asking... Yosef has a very big question, a very big argument, and Yosef does not have many questions here. As smart as he is, he's not asking many questions, showing...
29:35that Yosef in this particular instance has shown his emunat chachamim blindly. Blind faith in the chacham. Blind faith in the chacham. Unfortunately, today this is nowhere to be found. Many people say that they believe in the Torah, but they separate the Torah from its sages. They believe that if there’s not an explanation that they understand simply, that means that nobody knows, or perhaps that everybody is wrong except themselves. And when a rabbi tells them something, if they don’t like the answer, they’ll just ask another one. There’s very little emunat chachamim. We spoke about it yesterday in the shiur about what's happening. if there’s not an explanation that they understand simply, that means that nobody knows, or perhaps that everybody is wrong except themselves. And when a rabbi tells them something, if they don’t like the answer, they’ll just ask another one. There’s very little emunat chachamim. We spoke about it yesterday in the shiur about what's happening uh in the world as a result of uh of people falling for the trap of the Satan, they're also showing uh their lack of emunah, and thereby everyone has become an advocate for one side or the other. Some are pushing the vaccine as the cure of all diseases and some are pushing the anti-vaccine as if this is the Angel of Death himself, this is outright poison and everyone who takes it is going to have AIDS and it's going to have uh
30:47uh, you know, problems giving birth and so on and so forth, all types of other crazy things. Now, of course, you have people that have heard the words of some of the chachamim and say, "Okay, I'm gonna listen to the chacham that says take it," or others that say, "I'm gonna listen to the chacham that says don't take it." Fine, but then there are people that... they decide whatever they want to do, and they decide to fight whoever disagrees with them, even if that is so much so that they threatened the lives of many rabbis, including Rav Chaim Kanievsky. They are torturing many other rabbis, showing up to their lectures, insulting them, and distracting them. uh, all types of insults on the internet, literally the sewer that was inside their bodies just being vomited day and night without stoppage. And I've seen with my own eyes people that consider themselves righteous turn into vicious monsters when it comes to speaking about rabbis who are righteous people, yet disagree with their opinion about what to do with this coronavirus vaccine.
32:04and you see both men and women fall into this trap. Part of the reason why these people have fallen is because they don't actually have any emunah. I had one guy who thinks of himself as a tzaddik say, "No, no, if it's not from Moshe Rabbeinu, then we don't have to listen to it." Or, "If it's not from Rabbi Shimon, then we don't have to listen to it." even though the Gemara says that every generation has the Moshe Rabbeinu, every, uh, the generation are what you listen to. You don't need to wait for Moshe Rabbeinu, and there's obviously an endless amount of instructions from the Torah itself. from the Oral Torah, from the Written Torah, from the Shulchan Aruch, from the Rishonim, Acharonim. But no, no, all of that is in the garbage because this rabbi, however big he is, he's an idiot. Why? Because he disagrees with my opinion about what to do with the vaccine. Unfortunately, this is a tragedy like no other that we've seen in recent history. In my opinion, this could turn into something much, much worse than the Holocaust if it hasn't already. Because at least the Holocaust killed bodies and the righteous people still went to heaven, but here you have people killing their neshamos.
33:22And before this whole thing happened, there were, like, 50-50 decent people, some even very good people, who had a share in the World to Come. But they simply decided to throw that share in the garbage as soon as they heard that some big rabbi disagreed with their opinion. and unfortunately, this is a result of a lack of emunat chachamim, of course, a lack of yirat Shamayim, but that lack of yirat Shamayim, lack of fear of Heaven, leads to a lack of emunah in the faith in the sages, where you understand that the sages are saying to you what the Torah is saying they're not saying something out of their own mind, they're not saying something for any benefit of some kind. But of course, the people that disagree, they'll not only mistreat the sages, but they'll literally act just like the reshaim of the time when we were 40 years in the desert who accused Moshe of the worst, most heinous crimes in the world, where they literally say now This rabbi is pushing the vaccine because Pfizer is probably paying him off. He's probably getting paid off for every lecture that he's pushing the vaccine. He's probably getting a few cents into his non-profit organization. All types of mumbo jumbo conspiracy garbage. And literally, you...
34:42You ask yourself, how do these people have enough brain power to put their pants on one leg at a time? How do they have the brain power to take a spoon and feed themselves? They literally should be institutionalized. But nonetheless, these people are walking among us, and there are literally hundreds of millions of them. And unfortunately, many millions of them are actually Jews. The issue here is that you have opinions on both sides from great chachamim. You have chachamim that say take the vaccine, and you have chachamim that say don't take the vaccine. So which one do you listen to? We have said it time and time again that regardless of which side you want to go with, as long as you're doing it because the chacham said it, you have something to rely on. There's another way to put it that I heard from my Rav, Rav Ephraim. simply a story about one of the gedolim from the previous generation, Rav Tzion Abba Shaul. Rav Tzion Abba Shaul was one of the giants of the generation, was the chavruta of Rav Ovadia Yosef, and of course, he understood that there are certain people in the world that are simply wicked. Now, Rav Tzion Abba Shaul was an extraordinary posek, a talmid chacham, an ish emet, and he gave a shiur one time. There were a lot of people there, and
35:59in that shiur, one religious guy showed up and he asked a question. What did he ask? He asked, "Rabbi, what's the halacha regarding such and such issue?" Now, you would think, what's the problem with asking what the halacha is regarding such and such issue? What's the problem? This is really what the rabbi is there for, no? No. ...because everyone in that room, hundreds of people, knew that that week there was another Talmid Chacham, a serious person, who came out with a Psak, published a Sefer with a Psak Halacha about a specific matter that was the opposite of what Rav Tzion Abba Shaul himself published. so, in essence, what is he doing? He's putting Rav Tzion on the spot to what? Go to war with this other rabbi. Why? Because some people, they look religious, they have a beard, they have a hat, they even, you know, have a shtreimel. They even call themselves rabbi, all types of things. But sometimes, all they want is not Torah; they want fights.
37:15They want fights. Since they're not allowed to watch fights on television, they're not allowed to fight in the streets, they're not allowed to do that stuff. So what do they do? They like to watch rabbis fight. That's their favorite. Not fight for the valid reason where you're trying to protect the Torah, but rather fight because they like machloket. There was an extraordinary chacham, who knew what was going on in a matter of half a second, and he answered this person in front of everybody. He says, "Well, it comes to this particular halacha. Some people can do such and such, and they have somebody to rely on, meaning this other chacham. And some people can do something else, the other thing, the other opposite. And they also have somebody to rely on, meaning himself and the people that agree with him. But you have nobody to rely on." why? Because you like machloket; you like fights. There are certain people, literally, they never ask me any questions. But what do they send me non-stop? "Did you see what such and such did? Maybe, maybe we should do something about it." What, you think I do this for fun? Go call out people just because I want to get views or something?
38:35Like, people are sick. They’re sick. They’re looking for something that somebody did wrong, even if nobody in the world knows who this person is, and nobody in the world even agrees that this is wrong. But they'll come to me. Why? They want me to be the police. ...or they themselves do it. "Oh, listen Rabbi, I saw that this guy in some country made a YouTube video, and he said such and such, but there was a picture in the background with his wife in it. So I had to call him out. I made a whole post—87 lines with 6,000 words—explaining to this guy how wrong he is for making such a video. I did good, right Rabbi?" ...that's what you did, but unfortunately, some people like fights; they like action. Unfortunately, this is part of the people that at times like to watch some of our lectures, but usually, they fall off at some point or another, and they end up turning us into their enemy when they realize that the rebuke we have against specific people is for the sake of the Torah, not for the sake of our honor.
39:49And eventually, when a person listens to enough shiurim, they realize that the rebuke also pertains to them. And if they're not looking for the truth, then they'll obviously take it personally, and they'll turn us into Amalek, into Haman, into Nebuchadnezzar, into Hitler, into whoever you want, but we become enemy number one. Why? Because they weren't looking for the truth. The reality is, Rabotai HaKedoshim, if you're going to rebuke people, you better check yourself first. Do you have an interest? what's the purpose behind your rebuke? Who are you trying to help, yourself or somebody else? And it's a very, very tough question at times if a person does not really know how to check himself. But either way, we have here the whole situation with and is putting yourself to the test. Do you have...? I'm asking you a question. I'm asking you to make a promise. Yosef does not ask any questions. Why? Because in another place, later on, we see that you're allowed to ask questions. You're allowed to ask questions. Where do we see it? We see it when Yaakov gives the blessing to the sons of Yosef.
41:12...does something that is not viewed favorably by Yosef when he puts his hands on the heads of the sons of Yosef, Ephraim and Menashe. He crisscrosses his hands, placing his right hand on the younger son and his left hand on the older son, essentially meaning that the greater blessing goes to the younger son and the lesser blessing goes to the older son... uh, Yosef looks at it in a displeasing way and he says, "This is not so, father, for this is the firstborn," meaning he thought that his father was making a mistake. But Yaakov corrects him and says... i know, my son, i know, meaning it's okay, you're allowed to ask questions. But are you asking questions because you're questioning whether I know what I'm doing or if I made a mistake?
42:19where is the question stemming from? and this is really what makes all the difference. You're always allowed to ask questions. That's, in essence, one of the primary purposes of having a Rabbi. You're able to ask questions, get guidance, and so on. But sometimes you give certain people advice, and they don't like your advice. But they are shy to tell you that they don't like it. So what do they do? They ask you the same exact question with different words. They ask you the same question with different words. Or better yet, they say to you, "Listen, I know you said such and such, but Rabbi so-and-so said differently. Can you explain why he said what he said?" Why do I need to explain why somebody else said what they said? I know what I said, and I know why I said it. Why do I need to explain why somebody else said it? Why don't you go ask him? Why don't you go ask them? Why do I need to explain it? The truth is, why do you come to me with questions if you don't trust what I say? And many times it's because the audience, the students, are certain that this rabbi is smart, but not as smart as them. They always believe that, yeah, he's smart in a lot of things, but this particular question, I think I know more than him. This particular issue, I don't think he knows what he's talking about.
43:44He knows a lot. Don't get me wrong. He's a big tzaddik. And they say, listen, he's a great person. He's a tzaddik. He does good things. He's amazing. I can't say enough. But in this particular issue, I don't think he knows what he's talking about. Or, let me say it in a nice way. think he doesn't know all the facts. This is, in essence, the argument that many people use to justify their evil nature when they speak against chachamim in regard to this corona vaccine and so on. Like, yeah, he's a gadol but only up to a limit. When it comes to this, he doesn't know what he's talking about. He's not a doctor. But you're a doctor? You're a diagnostician? You are a biologist? You are a chemist? You are a NASA astronaut too? You're everything? No, he doesn't know. You know. Unfortunately, Rabotai, this issue is not a new issue. It's called lack of emunat chachamim, lack of faith in the sages. Which really means that the person himself does not believe in the Torah itself. You say, no, what do you mean? I believe in the Torah. I know all the proofs. No, no. Part of the Torah is to understand that HaKadosh Baruch Hu gives the Torah to those that toil and toil over it.
44:58And you are not allowed to go right or left against their words. Part of believing in the Torah, part of believing in the Torah is to have emunat chachamim. And a person says, yeah, but I believe in other things, but not this. Okay, so you're a heretic in regards to this particular mitzvah. It's a very serious problem. Why? Because without emunat chachamim, you really cannot move in any particular direction with actual certainty because you don't really know if what you're doing is right unless one of the chachamim says what you're doing is right. "Wow, but don't I have my own mind?" Yes, you do have your own mind, but your own mind is not always going to get you to the right direction. has the Torah as his mind. Why? Because he is deciding based on what the Torah says. His understanding of the Torah, which is 100% divine assistance. The more he is responsible for more people, the more he'll have. If he's just a chacham that’s by himself and doesn't interact with anybody else,
46:07not going to have the same level of siyata. This is why I always tell different avrechim that we work with and different people that I know, the best gift that they can give themselves is to start helping people learn Torah and do teshuvah. Why? Because since you obviously, you're learning all day, you're learning all night, you love the Torah... that means you would appreciate getting more Torah. The greatest way to get more Torah is if HaKadosh Baruch Hu decides that you are a vessel He wants to fill with more Torah. What would make Hashem decide such a thing? Isn't just studying Torah enough to convince Hashem to give you Torah? No, there are a lot of people that study Torah, but they don't reach the shoelaces of some other chachamim. why? Because who will give you the Torah that you need, give you the Torah that you deserve? If your needs are individual needs, if your merits are your own individual merits, then you have a certain portion allotted to you. But if you help other people, if you teach the public Torah, the more you help people get closer to Hashem, the more their merits become part of yours. In essence, meaning when who does the accounting of who should I give more to—more knowledge, more clarity—the one that's going to take responsibility for a hundred people, a thousand people, ten thousand people, or somebody that just wants to write books for himself and perhaps for his family, but really just wants to be—who am I going to give it to?
47:24become part of yours. In essence, meaning when Hashem does the accounting of who should I give more to—more knowledge, more clarity—the one that's going to take responsibility for a hundred people, a thousand people, ten thousand people, or somebody that just wants to write books for himself and perhaps for his family, but really just wants to be—who am I going to give it to? surely it's going to be to the person that is responsible for more people. Even if that person studies less than some of the others, he'll end up getting a lot more. Why? Because when HaKadosh Baruch Hu does the accounting, He sees that here you have a hundred thousand people that need Torah from this vessel, and here you have ten people that need Torah from this vessel. so the calculation is based on the people, that's why people that end up doing very serious teaching, kiruv, and things of that nature get a much higher level of siyata d'shmaya in learning than average people. But nonetheless, the average person out there cannot really relate to this particular issue, or perhaps they could relate to the next part. You see, when a person understands what Torah is...
48:42...understands what siyata d'shmaya is, what divine assistance is, understands what a talmid chacham is, needless to say a gadol hador, they don't have many questions about what the gadol says. They have questions about something the gadol hasn't talked about... Meaning, he'll go ask the Gadol, he'll go ask his rabbi, "What do I need to do with ABC? Where do I need to go to get ABC? What do you think of ABC?" Whatever the issue is. But if the rabbi says, "Go here, go there, do this, do that," generally speaking, they're not going to ask many questions. Why? if he's really a talmid chacham, then surely he thought of the questions that I have, and when he answered my question, he took that into consideration. What are some examples of this? He was not only a very big kiruv rabbi but was also a gaon, something out of this world.
49:57If he wasn't so active in helping people do teshuva, helping people get closer to Hashem, constantly teaching everywhere, there would be no doubt in my mind that he himself would be considered literally one of the greatest, not just in the world of kiruv and helping people, but also literally in every other aspect. Of course, he's considered a giant, but I'm talking about he would be considered even more than what he was. Despite all of this, despite how much of a genius and committed he was to the Torah, never taking a penny for a single lecture, never fighting over issues of money, never chasing money, just focusing on Torah, focusing on getting people to see the truth, telling them the truth to their face, the level of emunah that he had in Chachamim was literally unsurpassed in his bio. which is a fantastic book highly recommended for anybody. You read a lot of stories about him, but some of the most fascinating stories are about his interactions with big rabbis. All types of big rabbis. He was connected to the top of the top: the Steipler Gaon, his son Rav Kanievsky, Rav Levinstein. I mean, everybody.
51:21I mean, literally every gadol knew him and respected him. It was amazing. One time, we're talking about something like 25, 30, or even 40 years ago, he wanted to go ask a she’elah from Rav Kanievsky. Rav Kanievsky was already known as extraordinary, but not to the same extent as he is today, obviously. Many years have passed. He wanted to ask a she'elah from Rav Kanievsky. And when he got there, he saw that there's a line of people waiting to see Rav Kanievsky. So he waited in line. Everybody understood that Rav Spadon is there and said, no, no, Chacham, you go. What are you, standing in line? We're regular people. Rav Spadon says, no, Chas v'Shalom. I'm standing in line, just like you guys. Why would I cut? The people couldn't deal with this. Somebody whispered to the family, "Look, Rav Spadon is here waiting for the Rav. He's waiting for Rav Kanievsky." Immediately, Rav Kanievsky heard this. He himself got out of his chair, came out, and said, "Come, come, come." He goes, "No, no, Rav, he's in the back of the line." "No, no, Rabbi, I'm waiting in line like everybody else." He says, "No, Chas v'Shalom, you wait like everybody else. You come right away."
52:43And he literally had to convince him to come and see him. That's how much honor he had for the Gadol HaDor. Why should I deserve more of his time than anybody else? Also, a kavod for the Bnei HaBliya, the rest of the people. They were there. Another story is that his son says, his son tells a story. when he was four years old, he had a dangerously dangerous cough, a dangerous health situation. The cough was at a point where the doctors really didn't know what to do. No one knew what to do, but it was a very, very serious cough. So Rav Shapira took his son to the Chazon Ish. for some advice and a bracha. Chazon Ish. Here's what Rav Shapira is saying, without skipping a beat or getting confused. He says to Rav Shapira, go to the Yarkon. Go to the Yarkon. Over there, near the river, near the water, there are eucalyptus trees.
54:09And because there are eucalyptus trees there, there's special air that's going to help the boy breathe. Rav Padron, without getting confused, takes his four-year-old son, and they go and find themselves a boat that they can start rowing without any experience or knowledge of how to row boats. And they're on the river. Shh! And the son, who himself became a very big chacham, says the whole time, "My father is struggling with the river, struggling with figuring out how to boat and how to row. He keeps repeating himself over and over again: 'Listen to the words of the chachamim. Listen to the words of the chachamim. Listen to the words of the chachamim.'" a half hour he's rowing the boat, just repeating, "Listen to the words of the chachamim." Eventually, they get to the other side after a half hour of rowing, and they ask a person who was there to help them get onto the bank.
55:34and they asked him if he knows the specific area where they're looking for eucalyptus trees. The person said, "Yeah, yeah, you can go in this particular direction." So, they started walking a little bit through a bunch of different trees, and the four-year-old son, suddenly, the cough calms down. Within one hour, within one hour, he was cured. The little boy says to Rav Shwadron, his father, "Abba, Baruch Hashem, the Yarkon cured us." Rav Shwadron says, "No, no, no. What value does the Yarkon have? What value does the Yarkon have?"
56:36apart from the blessing of the Chazon Ish. It's not the Yarkon that cured us. It's that HaKadosh Baruch Hu listened to the blessing of the Chazon Ish. That's why. You see, Rabotai, when a person has Emunah in a Chacham, They don't ask, why do I need to go to a river? Can I get a pill instead? Maybe there's something else easier, Rabbi. Those questions never come up. Why? If you have emunah in a chacham, you already put into calculation that he already thought of this. Another time when Rav Shwadron was supposed to go on one of his long trips, he went to Rabbi Yechezkel Levenstein. For a blessing. But what happened is that two weeks before that, there was a Brit Milah for one of the grandsons of Rav Shwadron, and Rav Shwadron couldn't go because he didn't feel well. And Rav Levenstein went and he asked, "Where's the grandfather? Where's Rav Shwadron?" They said, "No, no, he doesn't feel well." So
57:58When Rav Shwadron came to Rav Yechezkel Levinstein and told him, "Listen, Rav, I want you to give me a blessing before I go on this trip," Rav Levinstein said to him, "Yes, but your legs. Did you say you couldn't come to the Brit Milah?" Immediately, Rav Shwadron said, "Okay." He turned around and went back to his house. The whole house was full of luggage. He tells his wife, the trip is canceled. Why? It's canceled. What do you mean? But the boat will go, you're supposed to go right away. It's in a few hours. It's canceled. Why is it canceled though? Because Rabbi Yechezkel Levinstein said it's canceled. He said, don't go. He said that I'm not healthy to go. Well, tell me what he said. Well, I went to Rabbi Yechezkel Levinstein to ask for a blessing.
58:58And he said to me, "But your legs." Now of course, Rabbi Yechezkel Levinstein knows that already a couple of weeks have passed since my legs were hurting me, but yet he still felt the need to tell me that my legs. That means I'm not going. Any question that I have is irrelevant because surely he already took it into account. he canceled the trip. We're not talking about a trip that's easy to make like today, where you just go on the internet, press a couple of buttons, and you're on a plane five minutes later. We're not talking about a trip that's easy to make, where you make a few phone calls, they set you up lectures, and you have a bunch of places to go to. We're not talking about an easy trip, where it's easy to pay and these people are swimming in money. We're talking about a major loss, a major hardship. Without a question. Why? Rabbi Chatzkel Levenstein, Talmid Chacham, said no. That's it. Yeah, but he didn't just say no. He said no with reason. Why? He already said, how could I be going if my legs hurt? Two weeks ago. Surely he knows what he's talking about. And as you would have it, Rabbi Shvadron not going, as a result of that, many, many things happened that were favorable to him that wouldn't have happened in any other way.
1:00:24wouldn't have happened any other way if he would have gone. Why? Listening to the Chachamim. So, we see here this letter, this book is full of stories about Gedolim and other Tzaddikim. This particular book is called "The Voice of Truth." Highly recommended. I always recommend for you guys to read the biographies of Gedolim because you'll understand how Hashem truly runs the world much better. if you read the stories of the lives of the Chachamim, then if you look at things from your own perspective. And the beautiful thing here is that we see that in one particular instance, Yaakov does not ask any questions. Why do you need me to swear? Why do I have to touch the Brit? What's all of this stuff about? There's no question. Why? Surely if you're asking me to swear, you thought about it. thought about it. On the other hand, surely if this particular issue is asked and you gave me an answer, your answer did not include everything that I thought of at that moment. But later on, I had some new thoughts. Just because I had those thoughts doesn't mean that you didn't have those thoughts. Just because I had a new thought three days later.
1:01:51that I didn't mention in my question doesn't mean that you didn't think of it also at the time that you answered the question. But the problem is when we compare the Chachamim to ourselves, we also compare our own limitations to the Chachamim. We figure that since we just discovered something new or looked at things in a new way, that perhaps when they give us the answer, they didn't realize what we just discovered. Which means we don't really have Emunat Chachamim. ...and many times this leads to a life of struggle because you cannot live a single day without having more doubts in your life and anxiety because no answer from anyone will ever satiate you. There was one time a woman came to me and said, "Listen, I, uh, have all these difficulties, such and such," and I gave her some guidance... ...mainly she should do teshuva, keep Shabbat, become modest, and so on and so forth. Time passed, she didn't listen, her life got worse. She came back and said, "Listen, can you tell me something new, you know, something about what's going on? I need to talk to a Kabbalist." I said, "About what?" She replied, "It's about my problems." I asked, "Did you do everything that I said?" "No, no, no, I need to talk to a Kabbalist."
1:03:16I said, "Yeah, but the Kabbalist is not really going to change anything. You still have, regardless of who, what, when, and how, you still have to keep Shabbat, keep this, keep that, and most importantly, be modest." She insisted, "Can you just get me a Kabbalist?" A little while later, I sent her a message. I said, "Wow, peleh plaim, wonder of wonders. The answer was the same." have to do teshuva, become modest, observe Shabbat, and so on. He says, "Wow, he's so right. I really need to do it. Thank you." No questions asked. Why? She had emunah in a Kabbalist that she didn't know, and Baruch Hashem, it helped her life. I'm a vignette. You see, Rabotai... sometimes you have to give people an answer with a lot of details, sometimes you have to give people an answer with few details. It doesn't depend on their level of intellect but rather on their level of trust in what you're saying. If a person has a lot of trust in what you're saying
1:04:40don't need to explain too much, just tell them this is A B C, one two three, the end. It's a person that doesn't trust what you say. You have to try to train them, try to help them, try to guide them to get to that point where they understand that what you're saying is what the Torah is, in essence, guiding them to do. And that's it. But unfortunately, this is never an easy job because sometimes you have to get to a point where you realize, I give up. I am not the vessel for you to ask questions. You have to go to a different Chacham. You have to go to somebody else. Why? But I have a lot of questions. I know you have a lot of questions. But you're not accepting the answers that I'm giving you. And what ends up happening is that other people are suffering because of your questions. Why are other people suffering? Because that time could be spent helping other people. Since you're not going to accept these answers anyway, what's the point of asking the questions if it's purely for entertainment? Go smash your head against the wall a few times; perhaps you'll be more entertained. Maybe even the yetzer hara will be entertained when he hears what you did. But the reality is there's no point in asking a question if you're not willing to accept the answer before you ask the question. Meaning, if you're going to go ask a question regardless of who it is... accept these answers anyway, what's the point of asking the questions if it's purely for entertainment? Go smash your head against the wall a few times; perhaps you'll be more entertained. Maybe even the yetzer hara will be entertained when he hears what you did. But the reality is, there's no point in asking a question if you're not willing to accept the answer before you ask the question. Meaning, if you're gonna go ask a question regardless of who it is,
1:06:01have to already take on to yourself, "Whatever I get, that's what I accept." It's like God Himself told me this answer. If you're not ready to accept that, don't ask the question. Why? Because you're only making your life more difficult. You're only making your life more difficult, and many times I try to break my head with certain people. I go here, I double-check, I double-check with Rabbi Frand anytime that I have something, especially if it's a strong opinion about something. Even if I have one percent doubt, I always double-check, always double-check. And when I give the information, I tell them, "Listen, I double-checked. This is what I thought, and Rabbi Frand agreed or disagreed or whatever he said." This is what the information is. And the most frustrating thing in the world is when people go and send you on a goose chase. You go get the information, they get it, and they simply say, "Ah, you know what, I already asked somebody else, and he told me something else, so I'm just going to go with that." One of the most frustrating things in the world. Why? Because it's simply a big waste of time. Unfortunately, this is part of it. You have to continue doing it regardless. But the main thing is, if we, as regular people, are going to ask Chachamim questions, really the onus is on us to already accept the answer before we even got it. In fact, accept the answer before we even ask the question. That's how we know whether we have emunat Chachamim or not. If we're not able to do that,
1:07:30better off for us not to ask the questions because if you're looking for an answer that agrees with your pre-existing mentality, perhaps you can figure it out on your own already. Just like a lot of people have decided what they wanted to do with the vaccine one way or the other before they ask many, they're just looking for somebody to agree with them. that's not the right approach. That approach is an approach that eventually will have a very, very tough bump in the road, to say the least. But here we see that although a person is allowed to ask questions, it's not because he has a lack of emunah. Yaakov put Yosef under the test and told him to do something unusual. Yosef had no questions, but when he saw something else... When he saw, no, this is not something unusual. This is something that perhaps it's a mistake. Why? Because he has his hands crossed. It's something that, you know, it's right there. Maybe he thinks that this son is the older one and this son is the younger one. Why? Because, you know, they're kids. He has many grandkids. That's it. That's why I'm asking the question. Perhaps this is something that's going on. Perhaps the kid's going to be insulted or...
1:08:52maybe you could do it in a different way so you didn't like the way it was, so you asked the question. Comes and says to yourself, "I know, I know why. I know, I know it looks weird, but this is the way I got my blessing from my father, Yitzchak." My blessing was supposed to go to Esav. But HaKadosh Baruch Hu made a switch and I got the blessing instead. So just like I got the blessing from my father this way where everything was switched, this is the way it needs to happen. Why? Because here you have two boys. One of them, the younger one, he's a gibor in the world of Torah. The other one, ball, but in business, in helping his father. The younger one needs more blessing. So how come I'm going to give a blessing later on to your brother that's a businessman before I give the bracha to Zevulun, who is a ben Torah? Why shouldn't it be the same? No, it cannot be the same. Why? Because here we have...
1:10:16two brothers, one is learning Torah and one is financing the Torah. So, the one that's learning Torah is only succeeding in learning Torah with comfort because his brother is financing it. He's a Torah investor; he's a partner. So, all of his Torah is thanks to his brother. Hence, the reason why he deserves the blessing first. That's the reason why the brother deserves the blessing first, because he's the one that's financing it. Even though the one that's learning Torah is fantastic, is amazing, everything is great, we have to understand that there is a priority list. If you're going to help somebody learn Torah, you're going to help somebody do Kiruv, you're going to help somebody do all the wonderful things that they do in the Torah world, then surely you're going to get a blessing. And the one mistake I made was Zebulun. Zebulun is the one that financed the Torah. Yissachar is the one
1:11:22one that learned Torah. So, Zevulun is the one that got the blessing even though he's financing the Torah. He learns Torah, but that's not his priority. His priority was to work, make money, and finance the Torah, donate money, give money to publicize, to build a kollel, to build a yeshiva, to build a synagogue, to publicize more USBs and CDs and videos, and so on. That was his priority. ...gets the blessing first from Yaakov Avinu, from his father Yaakov. The one that learned Torah got the blessing after him because his Torah was, in essence, dependent on the investment of his brother. But in the case of the sons of Yosef, it was different. Why was it different? The one that learned Torah got the blessing first, not second. Why? Because he was being financed by his father... was being financed by his father. His brother, who was essentially helping their father, wasn't financing his brother. So, in essence, that's why the one learning Torah gets the blessing first. He gets the blessing first. So, that's where we see how the Mishnah that says
1:12:34that it's much more praiseworthy, or much more meritorious, I should say. Much more merit goes to the person that helps another do and fulfill a mitzvah than the one that actually does it. Meaning, if you help somebody do teshuvah, you will get more reward than they do for what they're doing. They put on tefillin; you get the merit of them putting on tefillin, but the merit that you got is even bigger than what they're getting. you help somebody learn Torah; they are getting a mitzvah for every second that they're learning Torah. You are getting more. Why? Because you helped them. You helped them, so it's an extraordinary thing to help other people do good things, especially when it comes to the Torah world. because the reward you're going to get for helping another person is greater than what they're getting, and it's even greater than what you're getting for what you're doing yourself. Meaning, you're helping another person do teshuva and because you helped them do teshuva, they're going to keep Shabbat. So now you have three different merits for every Shabbat: one merit you have for the Shabbat that you keep
1:13:42one merit you have is for the Shabbat that they kept, right? They kept it, but the bigger merit, the biggest part, is that you're going to get the biggest part for what they're keeping. Why? Because you helped them keep it. So, in essence, you have three different merits: one they are getting for themselves, one you are getting for yourself, but then there's another merit, which is the one that you're getting for helping them do it. And that third merit, that's the biggest merit of all. that's the greatest of all. So, here we see that the sons of Yaakov, the sons of Yosef, they were good people, tzaddikim (righteous). Yaakov says they're like my sons. Why are they like my sons? Why didn't he make all of the other grandsons also like the tribes? He says, no, no. And also, another question is, why did Yaakov tell Yosef that the rest of the kids that are born to you after these two, if they're gonna be to you, meaning these two kids, they're special, they're becoming part of the tribes, they're like my kids, but the rest of the kids that you have, also the rest of the kids that your brothers have, all of my other grandkids, they're like yours. These two are special. Why these two special? Why not the sons of Yehuda? One of them, one of the sons of Yehuda, the Messiah comes from him. that the rest of the kids that are born to you after these two, if they're going to be to you, meaning these two kids, they're special. They're becoming part of the tribes; they're like my kids. But the rest of the kids that you have, also the rest of the kids that your brothers have, all of my other grandkids, they're like yours. These two are special. Why are these two special? Why not the sons of Yehuda? One of them, one of the sons of Yehuda, the Mashiach comes from him.
1:15:08So why not him being one of the tribes? Why not the sons of the grandkids of Dan? It was Shimshon HaGibor. He was a prophet. Why wasn't he one of the tribes? Why not anybody else? Why isn't the grandson of Levi, Moshe Rabbeinu, one of the tribes? How come just Ephraim and Menashe? The Chachamim say... it's important to know that Yaakov looked at things differently than we do. We look at things as we ask a lot of questions and we say, "Why this? Why this? Why that?" Yaakov says, "Look, you're looking at everybody being equal. Oh, everybody has a son, so all grandsons are equal. Everybody has a son, so all sons are equal. Everybody has a daughter, so all daughters are equal." He doesn't look at... He says, "What is the essence of this boy? What is the essence of these children relevant to everybody else? You see, all of the other sons, all of the other grandsons that I have are different. Why? They grew up in my household. They grew up in a frum neighborhood. So they didn't have the tests like Ephraim and Menashe."
1:16:18Firemen, I say, they grew up in Harlem. They grew up in the projects. They grew up among idol worshippers. They grew up in Cooper City. They grew up nowhere. Nothing to be found. The closest store that has kosher food is 20 minutes away. Nothing, that's where they grew up. And they still, what? Tell me, they ha ha mean, they were still religious. They were still glued to Hashem. Why? Because they're like my sons. They have the strength of Reuven, Shimon, Levi, Yehuda, Yissachar, Zevulun, Dan, Naftali, Asher, Gad, everybody. They're like this, they're powerful people. If they could be... righteous from despite their neighborhood that's full of avodah zarah. These people are special. The rest of the grandkids that grew up in my household, I can't say that they didn't have the same test. What about the other kids? What about the other kids of yourself? Ah, you can't calculate that. Why? Because now we're all here. Your new kids, they're going to grow up in a frum neighborhood just like the other grandkids. Nobody can ever be like Ephraim and Menashe. They were unique. They started the community before the community even knew that it was a community.
1:17:39When Yaakov Avinu gives the blessing to these two, nobody asks a question, how come they got a blessing? Nobody asks the question, why did Ephraim and Menashe get a blessing? Because they know that the Chacham, the prophet, Yaakov Avinu, knew what he was doing. He knew what he was doing. And the only thing that we need to do for ourselves is to figure out. all of the other wonderful things that he already knew just like that. And that's why we toil. We toil to figure out how the chacham arrived at his opinion, not how the chacham is wrong, but how the chacham arrived at his opinion. How the chacham concluded what he said. Surely, he's right. By default, he's right; we're wrong if we disagree. If a person looks at Talmidei Chachamim that way, their life will be much easier. Why? Because they already have a decision for everything that didn't happen before it happened. Because the Torah already has those decisions. But if a person is always going to want the Chacham to agree with what they think, they're never going to get the answers. No answer will ever be enough. With that being said, there's much, much more, but I know you guys have questions. We've already passed our typical amount of time. Let's get closer to the screens, get a drink, and ask and answer some questions.
1:18:55they're never going to get the answers. No answer will ever be enough. With that being said, there's much, much more, but I know you guys have questions. We've already passed our typical amount of time. Let's get closer to the screens, get a drink, and ask and answer some questions. see, I already made a blessing before anybody. Uh, okay, so we have the first question by, uh, Danny. Danny Dodge. Okay, hi, awesome. My brother asked me a question which I didn't know how to respond to. Hopefully, you can answer it today. He asked the question along the lines of: Is it possible
1:19:58of love corrupted any of the Talmud or any other Jewish writing to deceive us from within our own Torah. I said no, I don't think it's remotely possible, but I don't know how I can back this up. Are you able to offer any insight on the matter? Sure, there is no document in the world that has been analyzed by anybody as much as the Talmud has, the Babylonian Talmud. There are literally millions of books that the Chachmei Yisrael, the greatest minds in history, have written about the Talmud because the Talmud is the foundation of our oral Torah. Everything is built on top of it, all of the things that we have, so much so that without the written Torah, without the written Torah, we still have Judaism. But without the Talmud, we don't have Judaism because we won't know how to interpret the written Torah without the Talmud. We won't know how to interpret the laws without the Talmud. Everything is in the Talmud. And all of the books that are written until this day, if they're considered real Torah wisdom, their primary source is the Talmud.
1:21:02we still have Judaism. But without the Talmud, we don't have Judaism because we won't know how to interpret the Written Torah without the Talmud. We won't know how to interpret the laws without the Talmud. Everything is in the Talmud. And all of the books that are written until this day, if they're considered real Torah wisdom, their primary source is the Talmud. anyone that is delving into the world of Halacha has to go into the Talmud, even though we don't pasken from the Talmud because the psak Halacha was already made by the early sages 900 years ago. But you still have to look at all of the different back-and-forth arguments that that were had in order to look at all of the possibilities before you go into and review all of the opinions of the early sages and before you go into the final conclusion. So, the Talmud has been analyzed and reviewed in so many different ways that you literally have millions of books that were written by the smartest men that ever lived.
1:22:19uh, and uh, more than anything else, everything has been fact-checked, everything has been compared. For example, if there were some bad people that tried to change any part of the Torah, whether the Written Torah or the Oral Torah, this would have been discovered throughout the years when the different places combined, when the different places saw each other. So let's say if somebody, you could say the same thing about the rental. If, let's say, they decide to change not the whole Torah but just one sentence or even less, one word. One word, meaning instead of, I don't know, saying Moshe, they'll say Shimon, or they'll say Aharon. Now, at some point, this would show up somewhere else. Let's say the wicked person was in Florida. or in Minnesota when he wrote this nonsense. Okay, now eventually the chacham in Eretz Yisrael is going to get a question that has to do with this and say, "I come and everybody hears in the town their Torah. It says Moshe, but I have what looks like an older manuscript because it has cobwebs on it. Perhaps maybe it’s because nobody reads it, but it says Shimon on it or it says Aharon on it."
1:23:40so can you explain that to me? Sure, and I'll explain and show and prove how what we have is the mesorah, the heritage that we have from generation to generation. And so on, the same concept applies in the Talmud, where everything has been analyzed, reanalyzed, and so on. Of course, there have been printer errors from time to time, but nothing to the extent that it was so material. where you saw that these things were intentionally removed in order to change things in order to deceive people intentionally. The only time such a thing was done was by the Zionists, but they did that with the Hebrew language. Ben Yehuda, who in essence created or popularized modern-day Hebrew. He took many words from the holy language and made that the foundation, but then he took other words from the holy language and gave them different meanings, often the opposite of what they really meant, because he and the rest of the Zionists hated the Torah and...
1:24:53so they did it with this, the actual language. But in our Torah, both the Written Torah and the Oral Torah, all of these things have been studied. So every single word that we have, we know its meaning because we know that it has a source in the Torah itself. We know that it has a source in the Torah. We have to know that this is referring to that. I'll give you an example from, let's say, from this week's parasha. this week's parasha when Moshe Rabbeinu, when Yaakov is giving a blessing to Yosef He is telling them that this is a person that, yeah, here it is. That charming son is Yosef, a charming son to the eye. Each of the daughters climbed heights to gaze, and then it says they embittered him, the owners of arrows.
1:25:55that charming son is Yosef, a charming son to the eye. Each of the daughters climbed heights to gaze, and then it says they embittered him, the owners of arrows what is this "the owners of arrows"? Where are the "owners of arrows"? So, if you're reading it in an ArtScroll Chumash, then typically your English translation is not going to be "the owners of arrows," but rather "became arrow-tongued men." why is it that it says "arrow-tongued men" and not "owners of arrows," which is the literal meaning of this word? Because anyone that reads the Gemara knows that it explains this. We know that when it's referring to arrows, it's referring to people that say... if the Zionist would tell you, "No, no, he was... the people that had arrows were the ones that were embittering his life," so all the Robin Hoods in the world were embittering Yosef's life? Stupidity. No, what it's referring to is people that said so. There are many, many places like that, and when you learn, you also learn what's called Lashon HaKodesh.
1:27:15...uh, and I'm not referring to the Aramaic because that in itself is also another subject and also a very, uh, holy language, but nonetheless, the Lashon HaKodesh is the holy language that's written in the Torah itself. Learning it is critical for a person to truly understand the inner meanings of verses, not just the basic meanings, but the inner meanings. And all of this is in the Talmud. And the more a person learns the Talmud, the more they understand that not only is this authentic, but this is divine. Because there is information in the Talmud that no human being could have thought of. Anyone that wants to see some examples of that, you can watch some of the Torah, Science, and Ancient Wisdom series of films that we made. I believe there are six of them. We bring different statements from the Talmud that no human being could have thought of or conjured up because of their own intellect and so on.
1:28:24So the more a person learns the Talmud, the more they learn how to think like a Jew, and most importantly, the more they understand where the sages stand and where they do. And typically, the people that speak against the Talmud or speak against the Zohar HaKadosh are people that have never read it. uh, and uh, one of the examples is uh, that uh, Meza, who constantly speaks against uh, every part of the Torah because he just simply has created his own religion. But anyway, he thinks that you should view the uh, the uh, sages in the same way that you view your door neighbor who learned some Torah. Like, he doesn't believe that their opinion is any more valid than theirs or his. Of course, this is a deluded person, but nonetheless, when somebody, you know, so you would think, "Okay, so this person perhaps reviewed the entire Talmud, and that's why he doesn't think so much about these sages, and he even speaks even more harshly against the Zohar. He thinks the Zohar is fables, fairy tales."
1:29:31uh, not significant at all, and unfortunately, he's not the only idiot that thinks this way. But nonetheless, what do you see from what's the conclusion of both? What is the common denominator, I should say, of both? That he never completed reading either one of them. In fact, he never even completed reading even half of either one of them. is a complete ignoramus, doesn't know anything. I have talmidim that are 15-16 years old that have already completed the Shas, and this guy, who pretends to be a rabbi and speaks against the sages, admits without any shame or anything because he doesn't think there's anything wrong with him. That's usually one of the signs of an idiot, that he says stupid things and doesn't realize that it's stupid. So he thinks, no, the sages, they're just the same thing as you and me. What's the big deal? So that's the thing. So whoever asked the question, as far as doubting the Talmud, again, I don't think that they necessarily always have evil intentions, but I can assure you one thing: they never actually read the Talmud. They never studied it.
1:30:40when a person studies the Talmud, all of those questions disappear. The questions are found by people that don't learn. When you actually learn from the Torah itself, those questions disappear. Even questions that initially didn't have anything to do with what you're learning, it's just that you see the level of genius. divine genius that's in our Torah, our Written and our Oral Torah, which again, the Written Torah would be illegible without the Oral Torah. And when a person understands these things, they see that there are no questions to be had. Another example I could tell you that also is a great fundamental proof of the Oral Torah is that you can find in this week's parasha is that you see that Yaakov tells Yosef in chapter 48 verse 21...
1:31:50behold, I am about to die. God will be with you and will bring you back to the land of your fathers. As for me, I have given you Shechem, one portion more than your brothers, which I took from the hand of the Amorites with my sword and my bow. Now, which part of the Written Torah does it say that Yaakov ever fought a single battle against anybody? Did Yaakov fight a battle against Esav? according to the Written Torah, did Yaakov Avinu shoot any arrows at a deer? Did he shoot any arrows according to the Written Torah against Lavan? Even when his daughter Dinah got raped, did Yaakov Avinu go and fight him? no, but according to this verse, he did, and that's how he inherited the land. So, what was it? If a person reads the Oral Torah, whether it be the Gemara or you'll find it in many Midrashim, it discusses it. There's an entire section, an entire section there discussing the wars of Yaakov and then his sons, the Twelve Tribes.
1:33:04here he's referring to those wars. This is, in essence, the hint to those wars that Yaakov won land from the Canaanites, from the Amorite nations, so this is part of the reason why when somebody says, "I only believe in the written Torah; I don't believe in the Oral Torah," you really want to make sure that this person is instituted in some place unless they're willing to start learning because you do not understand a single verse in the Torah. Without the Oral Torah, you cannot understand a single verse because it’s just not legible without the Oral Torah. So again, that Oral Torah is constantly connected to the Talmud constantly, and the Midrashim are constantly feeding off of the Talmud. The Zohar is constantly feeding off of the Talmud. Everything feeds off each other and adds to it, and then, because there’s no body of work...
1:34:09aside from the five books of Moses, the Tanakh itself feeds off of itself, meaning that every book that we have in the Oral Torah every book, whether it's the Talmud Bavli, Talmud Yerushalmi, the Zohar, the Shulchan Aruch, the Rambam, the Ramban, the Tur, anybody, any work that you have, none of it, all the Kabbalah books, nothing is just by itself, meaning it's just one sage writing a bunch of stuff. There is no such thing. Every single book that was accepted among Am Yisrael as a valid Torah source is a book that is constantly referencing the other parts of the Oral Torah as their source and you can't just decide, "Oh, listen, I'm going to write a commentary on the Chumash today. I'm going to read the verses of the Written Torah, and I'm going to decide what they mean." There is no such thing. No one with a brain will actually pick up such a book. The Christians do it all the time, but that's because that's how they read everything. They read everything based on logic. That's also the reason why their religion changes every decade.
1:35:28The so-called sages of Christianity that were, let's say, 1,500 years ago were very, very different from modern-day people. Modern-day people think, for example, that Mary Magdalene is a saint, a great person, and so on. The original sages of Christianity, if you're talking about, let's say, the Pope of 1,500 years ago, actually said that Mary Magdalene was a prostitute. was a prostitute and was full of sins. And she is the main one that, in essence, testified to seeing Yoshke rise from the dead. So their entire religion, Christianity, is founded on the premise of some prostitute that saw or said she saw some guy that she was in love with rise from the dead. Nobody else saw it; she saw it. So the whole religion is standing on the opinion or the testimony of some hooker. That's really what you have here. Now, if you ask your local priest or reverend
1:36:38or some missionary out there, what do they think of Mary Magdalene? If they know, she is a saint; she's great, she's amazing, she's the one that shows us that God forgives sins and all types of other stupidity. But the original sages of Christianity don't believe that. why? Because their Torah is based on whoever, whatever, whenever. Our Torah doesn't have such things. Our Torah doesn't have such things. We have a mesorah. So, if somebody wants to know what to write in their book, let's say you want to write a book that's full of Torah, you can't come up with just your own opinion because you thought it. You have to have a source. valid source that itself has a valid source that itself has a valid source all the way to the sages of the Talmud that themselves have their source all the way to Matan Torah on Mount Sinai. That's how our Torah is. If there's a book that's published today that does not do that, it's not considered Torah. It's something that's no different than a newspaper.
1:37:47could throw in the garbage. You could even do other, uh, interesting things in the bathroom with it, like clean yourself or something. You know, it’s not worth anything. Why? Because our Torah has a heritage. The heritage has to connect all the way to Mount Sinai. So, because there is a constant connection to the original source, there is an endless review of the sources. Therefore, there could not be any chance whatsoever that the wicked people corrupted the Talmud that we have today. not possible. There are sections of the Talmud that were taken out due to the fear from the Christian Church, which didn't like the sections of the Talmud that had to do with disproving their idolatrous beliefs. There are sections of the Talmud that discuss Jesus and who he really was. He was a criminal was a rasha; he's in Gehinnom. So, of course, when the Church saw this, they burned thousands of copies of the Talmud and, in essence, killed people, murdered them, tortured them, raped them— all types of evil things that the Church has been doing to the Jews for 2,000 years.
1:39:03nonetheless, what the sages did in order to pacify the evil Christians is that they told them they removed these sections from the Talmud. Some of them are very, very big sections. For example, in the Gemara, there's almost a half a daf (half a page) that has been removed. but we still have copies of the original Talmud. So yes, it became more popular to have the redacted versions, but we always kept the original. Today, if you go to a store to buy the Talmud, you're going to get the original one; you're not going to get a new one. you're going to get the original one. Of course, some publishers still publish the old one. But nonetheless, our mesorah still has all of the originals. There is no body of work that has been reviewed more intensely, with more scrutiny, with more geniuses than the Talmud. There is simply nothing, nothing exists, nothing is compared to it.
1:40:05uh, because every single Jewish book ever written has to use it as a source, uh, and therefore forcing every single person that is a chacham to review and review and many times have to compare, have to compare, because there are times that they found that there was a printer error because the printing machines weren't the same as they are today, back then, there would be printing errors. You will sometimes see commentary at the bottom of a Talmud. If you use ArtScroll or some other publishers, you'll see, "Yes, this is the version we have, but there is a different version that has this specific word on it," meaning that everyone knows what else is there. Since it's not something that... uh, it's, you could just consider it irrelevant. We have to notice, we have to note it. Okay, so the Vilna Shas has this particular word, but the other Shas has a different word, and we know it, and everything is constantly compared, which is, in essence, another testifying evidence that whatever change or so-called corruption could have happened is already discovered and is already well noted.
1:41:21and uh acknowledged and so on, and that's it, that's it, but uh, I think the most important part of this entire answer is the original part, which is to explain to a person that if you really want to question something, the most important part is to first study it. study it. Don't question something you don't know anything about. Question something after you study it. Don't question the Torah if you never studied it. Don't question the Oral Torah if you've never studied it. First, study the subject, then you can question it as much as you want. If you have proofs, but many times people conclude based on something they saw in a video or some short article that concluded somebody's opinion about that particular document. Now, if you're doing, I don't know, what Siskel and Ebert was—a movie rating company back in, I don't know, 20-30 years ago, and... remember, every time they would say, "Oh, thumbs up for this movie, thumbs down for this movie," and so on, people would, I don't know, I guess, listen to them. Now, if it's a two-hour movie and a couple of guys decide they like it or don't like it, you want to listen to them? By all means, it's no harm, no foul. You know, it's better that they don't like anything so no one sees any of these junk movies. But nonetheless, that's not a big deal. But if you're gonna have a 40-minute...
1:42:44video or a 10-page or 50-page article analyzing and concluding that the Zohar HaKadosh, which is thousands of pages, or the Gemara, which is thousands of pages, is not valid. I mean, obviously, you see that there's something wrong with these people, and There's something wrong with such people. It's just, it's not, no one with a brain would believe such a thing. But typically that's what happens. You have some guy making a five-minute video or a 40-minute video saying all types of stupid things, and he gets an audience. Why does he get an audience? Because everybody that's part of his audience is also spiritually lazy. He himself never reviewed the entire Talmud. He just simply saw what somebody else wrote and questioned, and nobody answered, or at least they didn't look for the answers, or they couldn't find the answers, or whatever the case is. He fed off of some other heretic, and the heretic fed off of some other heretic, and really all that happened is that they made the videos more fancy. That's all they did. There's really no new content.
1:43:57And that's why many times in the Torah we have sages that discuss these types of subjects in order to answer the heretics. In order to answer the heretics and show them that their heresy is null and void. It's not the whole thing that all of their beliefs have no real foundation. But unfortunately, there are certain people that it doesn't matter what you prove to them. doesn't matter what you prove to them, they will stay with their ideas because they have an agenda. They have an agenda, so you have to know for yourself. Just like you're not going to go to a rocket scientist and tell him that you think he built his rocket wrong unless you yourself are a rocket scientist. You're not going to go to a well-known, reputable, successful diagnostician or surgeon and tell them that you think that they diagnosed or performed the surgery in an incorrect way unless you yourself are an expert, at the very least, at the same level.
1:45:07Here, we're not even asking people to be at the same level as the sages in order to criticize them. Here, we're simply asking people to read what the sages said and understand what they said before they criticize, before they conclude that it's false or not valid or corrupted. But that's the problem. People don't read. people watch videos, people have conversations, but generally speaking, people don't read. So people like Meza are part of those who popularized it, where they think that they could just read the first line of the paragraph, the last line of the paragraph, and thereby conclude what the Talmud said. they think that they could, you know, hear what somebody else said for a couple of minutes and thereby they already know everything. That's unfortunately a spiritual laziness that leads to heresy, and it's becoming more and more common because people don't want to study. But if a person studies
1:46:11They don't have such questions. The only questions they have are, what else do I need to study in order to understand what the sage said? Not, did the sage say something correct or not? There's no question of whether it's correct. The only question is whether I understand what he's saying. And that's one of the last things I would say about it. The one common denominator that you see among the sages is that among the heretics that go against the sages, go against the Oral Torah, is that they don't have any respect for the chachamim. They don't think of them any differently than themselves. They think that this chacham said it, so what? This big rabbi said it, so what? Among the sages is that among the heretics that go against the sages, go against the Oral Torah, is that they don't have any respect for the chachamim. They don't think of them any differently than themselves. They think that this chacham said it, so what? This big rabbi said it, so what? this sage said it, so what? I said also stuff, so what's the difference between me and them? They compare themselves, they think of themselves as equals, like apples to apples. So that, in itself, already shows that they're donkeys.
1:47:13...you know because the Shabbat says, you know the sages say about the sages that lived in the previous generation to them, comparing themselves to them, saying if those sages that lived before us were angels, then we are men. But if they are men, then we are donkeys. And these are the sages of the Talmud... Surely every one of those sages named in the Talmud was able to revive the dead. That's what the Gemara in Masechet Avodah Zarah says. Surely these people knew more Torah than anyone in the world, or all the entire world that we have today put together. But yet they themselves are calling themselves donkeys in comparison to the sages that lived just 30, 40 years before them. If they are donkeys, what are we? Amoebas? Not even. Not even. So that's the thing. It's that the more a person learns about the words of the sages and even the lives of the sages, the more they understand how different we really are. But if a person just simply wants to conclude
1:48:19Different things because they sound good. They sound interesting. They're mentally stimulating. They're controversial. They're going to get you views and likes. Perhaps even be an interesting conversation over coffee. They're going to put some people to the test. All types of stuff like this. These are people that just simply waste their lives. I highly recommend running away from them. And if a person is one of them, I highly recommend starting to learn and stop wasting time. Next question. Okay, someone is asking, related to assimilation, I have this question. If the Rabbanut wouldn't allow intermarriage between a Jewish girl and a Gentile boy, is it allowed or not allowed for a Jewish woman to marry a non-Jew? I don't understand if it's okay or encouraged. This question was already asked during the last classes, but maybe... If you're asking if a Jew can marry a non-Jew, the answer is no. According to the Torah, it's forbidden for a Jew, whether the Jew is male or female.
1:49:31It's forbidden for a Jew to marry a non-Jew, according to the Torah. Not according to the rabbis, according to the Torah. Now, do Jews marry non-Jews? Yes, but that means that they're forsaking the Torah. Just like there are people who murder and people who rape, that does not mean that what they're doing is allowed. They're breaking the law. Some people break the law of the land. Some people break the laws of the Torah. And some people do both. When a Jew marries a non-Jew, or even when a Jew is intimate with a non-Jew, they're forsaking the Torah and they're going to get a very, very serious punishment unless they do teshuva. But nonetheless, this is forbidden according to all opinions. There is no opinion in the Torah that allows a Jew to marry a non-Jew. No permission whatsoever. Charlie's asking, when cooking, do you do a bracha when you taste things for flavor or being cooked enough?
1:50:31or for being cooked enough. Oh, that's a very good question. No, you don't do a blessing for them. If it's a very small amount, you don't need to do a blessing for it. There are some, myself included, who are a little bit more stringent. Typically, what I do is, let's say for example, if I'm cooking meat, obviously you're not going to taste it unless it's ready. I don't cook often; the only time I cook is if I do a barbecue. ...uh, so if, uh, usually if I taste it, it's because it's pretty much ready or close to being ready, so I'll do a blessing. And if I'm not sure, then I'll do a blessing on something else, like shehakol, that will also cover this particular thing. But technically, if it's a small amount, if you're just tasting it, there's no need for the blessing. But you can be more stringent on something like this if you want. There is actually a write-up on it on Halachayomi... that I remember seeing somewhere that talks about tasting food and so on. You can look that up.
1:51:34Uh, Ricardo's asking if Haman was Mordechai's slave, didn't his fortune belong to Mordechai? Yes, yes, you're 100% right. That's actually what Mordechai kept telling Haman. Each time Haman would pass by, everybody would bow to him except Mordechai. Mordechai would actually lift up his leg straight up. and show Haman the bottom of his foot. Why would he show him the bottom of his foot? Because the bottom of his shoe was the contract between Mordechai and Haman, where Haman sold himself. And Mordechai would tell him that, because that's how they engraved it into the shoe. They were in the field, they were in war. So there wasn't paper and stuff and printing presses. So they engraved it into the bottom of the shoe. uh, this contract between Haman and Mordechai, so Mordechai would constantly remind Haman that he's really a slave and all of his wealth really belongs to Mordechai. Eventually, Mordechai got it after Hashem removed Haman from the world. The wealth and the position went to Mordechai. Good question. One second...
1:52:55Jack is asking a question: heretics like Meza say that rabbis today do not have power anymore. How should we respond to heretics when they say things like this? I think the response that I just made regarding the other person's question really responded to this also because Meza... He does not only disrespect the rabbis of today by saying such things as rabbis don't have power today; he disrespects the rabbis of the Talmud. He says that the rabbis of the Talmud have no power and that it's up to you if you want to listen or not. So, he doesn't respect anybody. He doesn't respect any of the sages; he doesn't respect anyone but himself. uh, he's just so, uh, full of garbage that he doesn't realize it's garbage because he's become part of it. So, a person like that, there's really no arguing with such people because they're just unlearned. They're ignoramuses and heretics, and the Talmud itself says that people that
1:54:07disrespect the rabbis, whether it's the rabbis of the Talmud or the leading rabbis of the generation, are considered apikorsim. They're considered heretics. So that in itself is discussed in the Talmud because it's not a new thing. The only thing that's new about it is that it's being done on video, that's it. But heretics like Meza, unfortunately, have always existed. They're the Erev Rav. They are the Erev Rav that has always been there to cool people off, to distort the Torah, and change things according to their own understanding, even though he is unlearned. He is completely an am ha'aretz. Nine out of ten things that he says are 100% incorrect. He pretends like he knows what the Rambam says, even though if you actually fact-check what he said, you'll see that he's wrong constantly about what he says in the name of the Rambam. And really, what he says in general, he's a complete am ha'aretz. But because he has this false sense of confidence, it sounds like he knows what he's doing. And because his audience is even more clueless than he is, they listen to him. But generally speaking, no real talmid chacham would ever waste the time to speak to him for more than five minutes because he's an idiot. He doesn't know anything.
1:55:29doesn't know anything. I mean, it's literally like my four-year-old son knows more than he does, and I'm not exaggerating at all. I'm telling you, my four-year-old son knows more Torah than Asher Meza could ever know. That's how much of a difference there is, and it's not even a compliment to my son—it's just how little he knows. Asher Meza knows. Now, Baruch Hashem, my son is a genius. So that's a different story, Baruch Hashem. But nonetheless, it's not the reason. It's not the reason. Meza, any one of my students, I have other students. I have students that also have five, six, seven, eight-year-old kids. And they know more than Asher Meza does. But the problem is that people listen to his stupidity because they're Christians. They're idol worshipers. They don't know anything. So his audience is mostly Christian people. that interpret the Torah already through their own heritage of falsehood based on their opinions. As I said before, the so-called sages of Christianity 1,500 years ago believed that Mary Magdalene was a prostitute.
1:56:42The people of today, who are closer to rock stars than they are to sages, believe that she was a saint. So obviously, this is complete stupidity. How do the sages of today know more than the sages of 1,500 years ago if they were closer to the story? Obviously, there's something wrong here. So the point being is that the way Christians read the so-called Bible, which is part of it is our Written Torah, is they look at a verse and they translate it, interpret it according to their understanding, literally. That's not how we interpret the Torah. There are certain hermeneutical rules on how to interpret the Torah and what certain things mean. It's definitely not according to your logic. It has to do with specific rules of the Torah on how to interpret it. So when Meza decides that such and such means such and such,
1:57:44his audience knows even less than him because he is interpreting things according to his likings, but he throws out some names of some sages or some names of some books which are really unknown to his audience. So they automatically assume that what he's saying is right and This is just an unfortunate reality that the spiritually lazy are getting their guidance from somebody that's not only spiritually lazy, but outright an evil heretic. It is what it is. So the thing is, though, anyone that actually learns Torah seriously does not listen to an Asher Meza. They do not spend their time listening to Asher Meza. And if they do, they find that he is wrong so many times that you cannot rely on anything that he says. This is part of the reason why most of the time when he talks, he just talks about his opinion of stuff.
1:58:54talks about his opinion of stuff and not what the Torah says or anything else, and that's also why he doesn't view favorably—he doesn't view Jews favorably; he doesn't view anything favorably other than himself. So, yeah, it's a very sad scenario. So, as far as responding to heretics like this... uh, honestly, I wouldn't respond to people like this. I mean, you could send them this video, you can send them some other videos, but more or less, there's nothing else to be said. A person needs to learn Torah before they can comment on Torah. Next, and I'm referring to the heretics, you know, they criticize it without learning it. So, I mean, it's like talking to an insane person. Leora is asking if I purchased and installed a doorknob for a shul, do I get a reward for each congregant that enters using the doorknob? Do you get a merit for the doorknob? I'm sure you get some type of merit, but I wouldn't build an entire imaginary heaven in your head for that doorknob.
2:00:08If there is a merit for it, I'm sure that some type of merit could count as tzedakah, but I would not bet the farm on it. I wouldn't, you know, let's say, there are greater things that a person could and should do. Uh, with all due respect to the person that bought the doorknob, getting to heaven is not that easy, to put it that way. Rav Yagen, a"h, used to say in his lectures, and every time they would hear it, it shocked me. He would say that there are people that work their whole lives to try to get themselves into heaven. Just like Rabbi Yochanan, at the end of his life, on his deathbed, he was crying hysterically, and the students asked him, "Why are you crying, Kavod Rav? You are the patish, you are the hammer of the nation, you are the gadol hador, you are a tzaddik. If you're crying, what about us?" And he says, "I'm going into a place where I'm not sure whether they're going to decree that I'm going to heaven or to gehinom."
2:01:24i don't know i'm i'm going into a place where it's not like a king of flesh and blood that i can bribe him. it's not like a king of flesh and blood that says a decree that is temporary. i'm going to a place where the King that decrees can decree things that will be for eternity. when He says something, it doesn't change. i'm going to a place, you know, where the King of Kings. And I don't know if I'm going to be decreed to go to the good part or the bad part. And you don't want me to cry and be scared? So this is Rabban Yochanan ben Zakkai. This is one of the greatest sages that ever lived. If he's scared, then the people that are not scared today are deluded. So I'm sure that Rabban Yochanan, you know, did a little bit more than buy a doorknob. or even by a shul, or even by a Sefer Torah. But yet, he was petrified. And I think that's really one of the greatest differences between the Chachamim and the people that are not quite there, is that the Chachamim, whether it was David HaMelech, or Rabban Yochanan, or any of the other Chachamim in recent generations, are constantly scared of the judgment. Constantly.
2:02:49literally every second sentence he would talk about the fire of Gehenom, and you would think, why is he constantly scared of Gehenom? And, you know, somebody would come to him and tell him, "Listen, Rabbi, I got a really big house, but I'm scared that this big house is so much enjoyment for us that it's going to take from my heaven." And Rav Steinman answered him. He's like, "Look at this. You have here a Jew that's in his 90s, scared every single day that he's going to go to Gehenom, yet you have this youngster over here in his 30s that is already certain that he has a place in heaven that he could be lessening that heaven that he has because he got a nice house. See the difference in perspective?" yet you have this youngster over here in his 30s that is already certain that he has a place in Heaven, and that he could be lessening that Heaven that he has because he got a nice house. See the difference in perspective? So a person needs to serve Hashem with all of their heart, with all of their money, with all of their life. That's what a person needs to do. That's what it says in Arizal: if all of your heart, all of your money, and all of your life went into that doorknob, then that doorknob will give you a share in the World to Come.
2:04:02But if that doorknob is, as it sounds, literally just a doorknob that you can buy for $10, then I honestly would not think of it as anything at all. And perhaps you'll get a merit for it, perhaps not, but I would not even consider it in your account or whoever bought the doorknob’s account. I would look to do a lot more things because we're obligated to do a lot more things. So again, if it was all the money that you have, if you put everything in your life into it, and I don't know, you made the best doorknob you could possibly ever make, then yes, surely that doorknob is worth a lot more than anything else because that doorknob is your life. Just like there's a story in the Gemara of one particular person that put everything he had into getting the doors of the Beit HaMikdash. and he went to a different country to get them built to specific dimensions and materials and so on. He put everything into it. On the way back, there was a storm, and they had to get rid of weight. So, they told him, "We have to get rid of these doors." He said, "Absolutely not." So, they said, "At least one door." They threw one door off the ship.
2:05:12The ship was still on the verge of sinking. They said, "Listen, we have to throw the other door. We have to get rid of the weight." He said, "No, no, you can't." So they threw the door. He jumped after the door. He said, "If I don't have these doors, this is my everything. I put everything into this mitzvah of putting the doors to the Beit HaMikdash. That's all I want." Hashem made a miracle that this door didn't sink and actually floated on this door miraculously all the way to shore. And miraculously, the second door also showed up. Why? Because that was his whole life. If somebody did that on a doorknob, then perhaps you know this doorknob is worth a lot. But if it's as what it sounds from the sentence, from the simplicity of the sentence that you wrote, with all respect, you know... wouldn't consider it as anything at all, simply a nice person doing a nice thing, the end. And perhaps Hashem will reward you for it or not, but I wouldn't count it in your bag of good deeds because there's a whole lot more work to do. You can ignore everything that I'm saying if you'd like, but...
2:06:23There's just so much more that we're obligated to do that it's hard for me to tell you anything different. Steve is asking, how can one explain what the Shekhinah is and what type of interaction with Hashem this is in more or less simple terms? There is no way. There are no simple terms for explaining the Shekhinah. There is no simple way of explaining Hashem, and there is no difficult way of explaining Hashem. There is no way to explain Hashem. To... To know Him is to be Him. To understand Him is to be Him. There are different aspects of Hashem that He Himself elaborates on. There are different aspects of the Shechinah that are explained, but in all reality, We do not have full comprehension of what this means because we don't have the capacity to understand something that is Divine. It's just not possible for a human mind to understand.
2:07:36uh and those that do understand it, that are, you know, at the highest level, speak in a language that might as well be from Mars to us. You know, you talk to Kabbalists that speak in regards to different aspects of God, different names of God, and so on. A lot of people like to use those terms all the different worlds and the different aspects, but in reality, the people that mention them so freely don't really understand what they mean. They don't really understand what they mean. I can tell you that the simplest fundamental lesson of Kabbalah is impossible for 99.9999% of the human population to understand. And I'm talking about the first lesson of Kabbalah. The first lesson of just, I don't take any of the names of Hashem. and try to explain an aspect of it is impossible for 99.999% of the world to understand. That is part of the reason why Kabbalah, in reality, is not taught publicly. The stuff that's taught is, you know, the different things that are really more or less gibberish for most people. Or it's words of the sages that people like to call Kabbalah even though it's not really Kabbalah.
2:09:00So the Shekhinah, Hashem, these are all the highest of the high. And there is no simple way of explaining it. Mordechai Tzvi is asking, the Rambam says that one is permitted to emit seed outside of marriage for medical purposes. If a urologist tells you to masturbate due to epididymal hypertensions, would this theoretically be permitted according to the Torah? Well, first off, where does the Rambam say what you're saying? That's number one. Number two, the case of seed in itself epididymal hypertensions. Would this theoretically be permitted according to the Torah? Well, first off, where does the Rambam say what you're saying? That's number one. Number two, the case of seed itself is a complicated one, but nonetheless, to just simply masturbate because a urologist tells you to do so is generally forbidden. It's generally forbidden in the vast majority of cases. And in a case where there is permission to have seed go outside of the female body,
2:10:16It's very, very exceptional cases, very exceptional cases, but it's not a case like what you're saying. I deal with this type of stuff on a regular basis and it's not like this, no. Last but not least, it's not needed anymore because you can get everything that you can get from seed, you can get from blood. So you don't need to use the seed anymore. Uh, let's see, Leah, what should a Jewish woman do when a goy (non-Jewish) man gives her a compliment? Not in a flirtatious way, but as a person who hands out compliments trying to be nice. Should she quickly say thank you, not do it but keep moving, or not give an opportunity to open up a conversation, or ignore it altogether? and put her modesty first. Yes, put her modesty first. There's no reason for her to acknowledge it or respond to it whatsoever.
2:11:23It's not Chilul Hashem for her to ignore a compliment. It's not Chilul Hashem. Chilul Hashem is desecrating the Torah. Him talking to a woman that's not his wife in itself is not appropriate behavior. So we don't have to comply with his inappropriate behavior because we're afraid that his inappropriate mind is going to think less of us. He's already wrong in the first place. uh, it's perfectly fine to say thank you to people that are doing something for you. If you buy something from a grocery store and the teller gives you the groceries, it's perfectly fine to say thank you, whether it's a male or a female. That's perfectly fine. But if somebody goes out there and says, "Oh wow, you look good," to say thank you would be encouraging him to continue. Or if somebody says, "Oh wow, I like your dress," to say thank you would be simply opening up a door to further comments. So, no, you simply ignore him as if he doesn't exist, and don't worry, you will not be the only one that does it. Next question...
2:12:33Where do righteous non-Jews go when they leave this world? What can we do here? What can we do here, if there's anything, to help elevate their soul? Rambam says that we learn from the Gemara in Masechet Sanhedrin, that says that Bilaam is the non-Jewish prophet that has no share in the world to come. so we learned from there that the righteous among the nations have a share in the world to come. They go to Heaven, so the righteous non-Jews also go to Heaven. It's not the same level of Heaven as the righteous Jews. uh, for obvious reasons, the righteous Jews, uh, do a lot more to earn their Heaven than a righteous non-Jew. But the punishment for a wicked Jew is also more severe than for a wicked non-Jew. Nonetheless, there is a Heaven for non-Jews, and there's also a Gehinnom for non-Jews.
2:13:39As far as elevating the soul of a non-Jew, you know, a person can try to do mitzvot in their name, give tzedakah in their name, learn Torah in their name—the same things that you would do for a Jew. uh, you could elevate the neshama of a non-Jew in essence in the same way, by doing mitzvot, you know, publicizing more Torah, helping more Jews become more observant. The more Jews become observant, the more a person contributes to helping Jews become observant the more they're producing a better world and the more merits they're producing for themselves and for anybody else that they're doing it for. But always remember that, as the Mishnah in Avot says, based on the difficulty, such as the reward. Meaning that perhaps this is also relevant to the previous question about the doorknob. The Mishnah says that if a person has an easy time doing a mitzvah, then yes, they'll get a reward for it, but it'll be a reward that's appropriate for such a mitzvah. It doesn't matter which mitzvah it is. If it's really easy for them to do it, then they'll get a reward that in essence coincides with such a mitzvah.
2:14:46then yes, they'll get a reward for it, but it'll be a reward that's appropriate for such a mitzvah. It doesn't matter which mitzvah it is. If it's really easy for them to do it, then they'll get a reward that, in essence, coincides with such a mitzvah. So, for example, if it's easy for a person to give $20 tzedakah, then they'll get a certain level of reward for it that's not so high. Why? Because it's not so difficult for them. On the other hand, if they give... $200 or $2,000 or $20 million, whatever it is relevant to them, and it's really hard for them to give that larger amount of money, then the reward will be appropriate to that. Meaning, the harder it is for a person to do something and they end up doing it, the more the reward for it. So, when a person is thinking about serving Hashem... in itself, a person needs to know that serving Hashem is not something that's supposed to be easy. You're supposed to push yourself to the point of literally putting your life on the line just for the sake of serving Hashem. But that's because you still have a chance to be in this world. Now, a person that has left this world
2:16:03and has left this world in a negative way, meaning they were not righteous, they did not observe Shabbat, they did not eat kosher, or they were a wicked non-Jew. Whatever the case is, that's a person that is in a horrible, virtually Helpless situation they are in Gehinnom. They're in a horrible place. They can't help themselves. They're potentially in a place where there's eternity of suffering. I mean they're in a miserable, miserable situation. So, to understand this, you have to know that for yourself, you have to push yourself to the point of putting everything on the line just to save yourself while you're alive. like you have to push yourself to pray to the maximum, to give to the maximum, to do to the maximum, and that's in essence to save yourself while you still have a chance. So, to go and help, and needless to say, to save somebody that has left this world and has a whole life full of wickedness behind them...
2:17:13just imagine that you have to do at the very least no less than you do for yourself; meaning, if a person wants to show Hashem that he has emunah (faith), then at the very least, 10% of every single penny that comes into their pocket they would use to give for Torah. 10% at minimum, that's showing Hashem that I know You gave me 100%, and this 10% that I'm giving back right away without questions asked is my testimony that I believe that all of the 100% and more is from You, and this is to publicize Your Torah. If a person is already giving that 10%, they are showing Hashem that they obviously believe in the Torah, they believe that everything is from Hashem, and so on. Now, If a person realizes that this is the basic minimum for themselves to show that they believe in Hashem to help themselves, then they have to understand that, at the very least, they need to do as much for this other person. Now, you can say, "Oh, yeah, but that's really hard. Who can do that?" So don't do it.
2:18:26point is that people think that if they, let's say, do this one mitzvah, like many people like to do these yahrzeits, and they say, "Oh Rabbi, can you come speak on behalf of my grandfather and, you know, do a shiur for him? And I'll sponsor, okay, I'll send money." Okay, fine. I'm never really particular about these things even though it's on the website that there's a certain amount of money it's expected for people to sponsor lectures and so on. Sometimes people say, "I'll sponsor it" and then whatever. I just do it. I mention the name because I care less. I just do what I have to do. If somebody wants it, I do it. But what ends up happening is that this person who made a whole big deal about me doing this shiur in the name of some grandfather or some mother or somebody that's important to them ends up sending three hundred dollars. You know? Now again, thank you very much, we appreciate the help, but you have a problem on your hands. First and foremost, you didn't follow the instructions. The instructions say it's a lot more than that. Second of all, if you think that $300 is gonna take your grandfather, your cousin, your brother out of Gehinnom, you are delusional. It's not going to happen. Why? Because for yourself, you have to give more. For yourself, you have to do more during an entire lifetime.
2:19:47...just to save yourself from all the difficult things that you have done, and that's including living a righteous life. So, a person that is out of this world, you have to do, like I said, at the very least, just as much. So, this is not to kill people's hope in helping those who have died, even though there is a Chacham from 800 years ago that says you can't really do anything... There is an opinion out there by one of the Gedolim that says you can't help people that have died already—they're lost causes. And then the Chachamim went against them and said, "Wait a minute, but what about Elisha? They got him out of Gehinom." And then the response was, "Yeah, that's Rabbi Meir Baal HaNes and Rabbi Yochanan did it. Nobody is Rabbi Yochanan or even the shoes under their feet." So the point being is that you have to compare apples to apples. But either way, most of the opinions are that you can help people that have passed away. But it does not come for free. It does not come for cheap, and it doesn't come easy.
2:20:54that is one thing that I don't think people discuss out there, and I believe that the vast majority of people are deluding themselves into thinking that because they're making a yahrzeit once a year, throwing some cookies for people to eat—half the people eat without a blessing—perhaps they invite some rabbi and give him a few hundred dollars or even a couple of thousand dollars, thinking that that's going to take their loved ones out of Gehinnom. i'm sorry to tell you, this is a complete lie, complete lie. If I put it this way, I'll put it to you guys this way: If you can give me any serious, not talking about some guy that just likes to give Torah videos, a serious talmid, somebody that's well respected... Among the people, and I'm not talking about among his friends, Gedolei HaDor respect this person; he is Daas Torah. You can give me a write-up, you can give me somebody writing that you can take somebody out of Gehinnom by simply donating a few hundred dollars or even a few thousand dollars; I'll publicize it everywhere and at every shiur. But it's not possible.
2:22:06It's not possible. Why? Because it's hard, it's expensive, it's difficult. So the reason why I'm saying it, the reason why nobody else says it, is because they think that people are not going to do anything then. Might as well they do something rather than do nothing. That's not true. I don't believe in that. I believe it's better to tell people the truth. and let them decide. If you thought until now that you could save your long-lost grandmother with five thousand dollars of donations a year, and right now you just found out that it's going to cost you an arm and a leg and maybe another foot not going to be five thousand dollars. Now you can say, "Down with it, I'm not doing anything." Fine. Or you can say, "You know what, I have the money. I have 500,000 in my account" or "I work, I make 50,000–100,000 a year. I could donate more; I could do more." Guess what? This is a chance to win. This is a chance to win for that person. Why? Because if on one aspect, if a person doesn't know the truth, it's almost impossible for them to fulfill that truth. Why? Because they think they could do something good for five thousand dollars. They could think they could do something good for five hundred dollars. I even have people that literally sent three hundred dollars because they think that that's going to save their grandmother or their mother from Gehinom with their three hundred dollars. It's a delusional mindset. Now, again, if the person is really, really poor...
2:23:30like poor as dirt, and they just gave you their life savings, and their life savings is three hundred dollars, then yes, that definitely has a lot more value than someone that's a multi-millionaire giving you three million dollars. But that's generally not the case. In general cases, people have a lot more. And they have to understand that it is not cheap to fix problems once a person dies. It's not cheap, it's not easy, and quite frankly, it's at the very least as expensive as what it costs for a person to help themselves. in their own life. So what I would recommend is for people to get a hold of themselves, understand what they're dealing with, and if they're already going to do something, do it right. Do it right, push yourself, don't delude yourself into believing that, "Oh, you know what? I did something good. I made a seudah and 10 people came, and they ate the cookies, and my grandmother is happy now."
2:24:34all right, you, a person wants to believe in such a fairy tale, by all means, you can live in a fairy tale. Please put me in that fairy tale also, where I'm studying with those angels that that grandmother is with. I want to study with them. I mean, it's a fairy tale; it's not true. It's very hard, and anyone that wants a simple proof of some of these things, go buy yourself a book Abiyud Haktaya, he has a book called Ruchot Mesaprot. It's in English. They translated part of that book, and it's called Minchat Yehuda. And he tells you about the conversations that he had with different people who died. Go read that book. See what those people did. See who they are. Most likely, you know a few people who are committing those very same sins. Most likely, some of the people that you're donating money for their sake committed those same sins. And you can see what they're dealing with. you can see what they're dealing with, and that way you can say, "Okay, it's not your own trying to milk people for money. I could care less if people donate. If people donate, they donate. If they don't, they don't. I recommend that if people want to donate, they can donate. It just makes no difference to me. I know because who's going to send the money one way or the other. But I want to tell people the truth because I honestly don't think that this particular issue is covered anywhere in lectures today. People are deluding themselves. Sometimes you'll even have people
2:25:58You'll have like a live video, and you'll see a bunch of people write their names. They decide, this shiur is for the ilui nishmat of my grandmother. This shiur is for the ilui nishmat of my neighbor. This shiur, they give you a list of 500 names, and they decided this shiur is for their merit. And they actually think this works. These are deluded people. Quite frankly, they may need to be instituted. But nonetheless, it doesn't work that way. It doesn't work that way. To learn Torah, to learn Torah, to learn Torah, you have to be willing to die for it. That's what Reish Lakish says. To learn Torah, you have to be willing to die for it. So does anybody think that it's less of a payment to get heaven for eternity? Does anybody think it's less of a payment to get Heaven for eternity? Anyone think for a second it's a cheaper payment than to learn Torah? At the very least, it's the same payment. If you have to be willing to put your life on the line, which means all of your money you will put on the line to save your life. If somebody said, "Listen, you have $100 million in the bank. I know. I saw. I checked your account. And I know you have $100 million in the bank. Either give me all $100 million. I'm not leaving you a penny."
2:27:19i'm going to shoot you in the face. Which person in the world will say no? Nobody. Everybody would give all of that money and say, "Thank you for taking it. Give me my life back." Why? Because you know what your life is worth—all of your money, all of your time, all of your resources, all of the good that you have, you put on the line for the sake of Torah. That's in essence what putting your life on the line is for—for the Torah. So if you are supposed to put all of the money you have, all the time you have, all the pleasure that you have, all the resources you have, every good that you have, just for the sake of acquiring real Torah—I don't mean the scroll, I mean Torah knowledge—you're supposed to do everything possible to acquire that Torah. Does anyone really honestly believe that they can acquire heaven for eternity for any less? At the very least, it's the same price, at the very least. So if you need to pay that much for yourself, and you're still here to do good deeds, which will give even more of a reason to increase your stock price and give you a reason to go to heaven, then needless to say, you have to be aware that it's not going to be cheap, to say the least, to get somebody else to go to heaven.
2:28:40they're already in Gehinom because they live the life of Gehinom, and that's one of the things that I think people need to know. It's actually also in this week's parasha, like everything is always in the parasha, where it says, "So the pshat of the pasuk in chapter 49, verse 25," is simple, that He will bless you with the blessings of heaven from above, blessings of the deep crouching below. But if you read the pursuit differently, same exact words but different separation, it says that God will bless you with the blessings of heaven above, meaning rather than the blessings of Gehinom, because that's what Tehom means. Tell me. is simple, that He will bless you with the blessings of heaven from above, blessings of the deep crouching below. But if you read the pasuk differently, same exact words but different separation, it says that God will bless you with the blessings of heaven above, meaning rather than the blessings of Gehinnom, because that's what Tehom means. Tell me So you would rather get the blessings of heaven than the blessings of Gehinnom. Simple. So a person needs to know. They can get a blessing from a real Talmid Chacham, and they can invest into Torah. They can put everything into it, and it's expensive, and it's time-consuming, and it's hard, and it's tiring, and it's testing. Yes. But in the end, they'll get a blessing of heaven.
2:30:06They'll get a blessing of heaven for themselves, for others, and so on. Or they could continue living a deluded life, thinking that they're getting all of their friends and family and their dogs and cats, too, into heaven for a couple of hundred dollars a year. They can believe that. In essence, in the end, they're just going to get a blessing of Gehinnom. What's the blessing of Gehinnom? When they arrive at the Beit Din of Shamayim, Hashem's going to show them, "Yeah, you remember that dog that you invested like $2,000 for? Yeah, he's in Gehinnom. Remember that grandmother you put like $100 for? Yeah, she's in Gehinnom. Remember that cousin of yours that you put like, what did you do? Donuts? Donuts and, oh, bourekas. Bourekas, donuts? Yeah, also he's in Gehinnom. Look at all the chambers of Gehinnom. Yeah, but what about the money?" They're going to laugh at you in Shamayim. They'll say, "Are you kidding me? You think you can take somebody out of Gehinnom for $500?" You think you can take somebody out of Gehinnom for $500? How about this, guys? I'm going to finish the point with this. If there was even 1% of me that believed, or if somebody could show me a source that shows this, that says you can get anybody out of Gehinnom for $1,000, for $500, for $2,000, anybody could show, for a minimal amount of money. How about this? I will advocate for people to stop keeping mitzvot.
2:31:22Why? You could sin your whole life and buy yourself out for $5,000? Who's better than you? Take the money, whatever a person has, put it in some account, nobody even knows about, that's part of your will, and say, listen, when I die, open this safe. Okay, have it inflation-ready, so it's $2,000 now, but figure by the time, 10, 20 years from now, it'll probably be worth like $20 million you'll need, so figure whatever you need. Anyway, Put the money aside as soon as the person dies. Yeah, don't make this into law. Let's say I'm going to heaven. Yeah, but what about you violating Shabbat? No, listen, the Rabbi told me two thousand dollars, I can get my cousin out of Gehinnom. So surely if I can get my cousin out of Gehinnom for two thousand dollars, I can get myself out of Gehinnom for two thousand dollars. How about this? I was even generous with God, five thousand dollars. If it was really possible to do it that simply, I would tell people don't bother to don't bother keeping anything. Why would you bother to get yourself out of Gehinnom for a few thousand dollars? If any of the sages believed that you can sin your whole life and just get out of there for a few hundred dollars or a few thousand dollars, don't you think they would just tell people, "Listen guys, if you don't want to do mitzvot, how about this: I'll give you a trick. Put some money aside. You're a millionaire, you're a billionaire, you have a nine-to-five job."
2:32:45instead of an IRA that invests in the stock market, have an IRA investing in the Fund of Gehinnom. Get yourself a Gehinnom fund. We'll start a website: getyourselfagehinnomfund.com or .org. Make it non-profit, and that way everybody can put a dollar a month, and by the time they die, everybody has enough money to get out of Gehinnom with their $500. Guys, please be serious, think of things normally, think of things logically, and understand that the world is full of lies. The world is full of liars, and it's up to us as individuals to delve into it in order to find what the truth is. When we see the truth, we fight for it like our life is on the line. Why? Because it is. We cannot continue to be deluded into thinking that life is supposed to be easy and getting to heaven is easy. There's no such thing. I'm not saying you're supposed to suffer intentionally, but to believe that it's that easy to just get somebody to go to heaven is something that I've heard one too many times.
2:34:03And it's literally, it's such an evil lie that people tell others that really, when you really think about it, it removes people's free choice because they think that this is real. So I appreciate that question you asked because it woke up an issue that I've had on my mind for years. It's never really been brought up in a lecture until today. Baruch Hashem, thank you. Ian is asking, perhaps maybe one or two more questions. It's kind of late already. Ian is asking, if I'm busy and my dog starts to need to go out, do I have to interrupt what I'm doing to avoid torturing the animal? Yes. Yes. Unless you want him to relieve himself in your house and you don't mind. But if you're going to hit him or punish him for relieving himself in your house, then you have to stop yourself and go take him out. Tilly's asking, I try to make matches. However, sometimes the man and the woman are not religious. Am I allowed to introduce such a couple? No, you are not allowed to make matches between non-religious people because surely they're going to sin, and that entire sin is going to be on you. And that can get you into a very, very long sentence in Gehinnom, and I promise you, you don't want it for any amount of money. Like all of those matchmakers that make secular people, and I'm talking about specifically Jews,
2:35:29make secular Jews go out together, and they make money out of it. Even if they do it for free, they don't understand that they are getting a literal punishment for every single match they succeed in. It is akin to a personal Holocaust they are buying for themselves because of all the sins that will happen as a result of this. It's a very, very serious crime. Absolutely not. Don't do yourself any favors by making such matches. If they're not religious, no match. Only make matches with religious people among each other. If there's one religious person and that religious person is looking for somebody and the only somebody you have is a non-religious person, don't tell them you have a match because it's not a match. a non-religious Jew is not a valid match for anybody. That's a reality, and I know it sounds harsh and mean and all that, but it's a reality. It's better that they stay alone than they sin with somebody else. I know some of them are not ready to change, so do I set them up? I answered that already, okay?
2:36:43Thoughts on whether women should have pictures of themselves on their profile or not. I have a whole lecture about that. You can look that up. "Should women have their pictures on the internet?" I think it's called. And the answer is no. The explanation is in that lecture. Oswaldo is asking, will Noahides be able to fight alongside Am Yisrael against the Resha'im during Gog u'Magog? Why is Judah Maccabee barely spoken of? Also, with me, okay, you're asking too many questions that are not related. Okay, let me answer that. Your question is in this week's parasha. This is how much Hashem loves us because He makes us look smart. I'm really not that knowledgeable, I promise you guys. It's all Hashem. Your question is in this week's parasha. In the blessing of Yehuda, you asked about the Noahides, Gog and Magog, and so on. It's actually in this week's parasha. It tells Yehuda in chapter 49, verse number eight: "Yehuda, your brothers shall acknowledge..."
2:37:59Your hand will be at your enemy's nape. Your father's sons will prostrate themselves to you. A lion cub is Yehuda, from prey, my son, you elevated yourself. So here is when Yehuda gets a blessing from Yaakov. And then it continues. He says, so then it says, he crouches, lies down like a lion, and like an awesome lion, who dares rouse him? The scepter shall not depart from Yehudah nor a scholar from among his descendants until Shiloh shall arrive, and his will be an assemblage of nations. So here is when Yaakov Avinu discloses to us as the main source that Mashiach will come, and Mashiach has to come from the tribe of Yehudah, which means from David HaMelech and Shlomo HaMelech. He has to come from the tribe of Yehudah. No other tribe could it be. It cannot be from a convert. It cannot be from a non-Jew. It cannot be from a woman. It has to be a son of Yehudah.
2:39:26it also says in the Midrash that Mashiach will come from Yehudah, and Mashiach has to come from the tribe of Yehudah, which means from David HaMelech and Shlomo HaMelech. He has to come from the tribe of Yehudah. No other tribe could it be. It cannot be from a convert. It cannot be from a non-Jew. It cannot be from a woman. It has to be a son of Yehudah. His will be an assemblage of nations. What does it mean? His will be an assemblage of nations. If you look at the commentary on this, you'll see that the chachamim say that the righteous Noahides will fight alongside the righteous Jews at the right side of Mashiach in order to earn themselves a place in the Olam HaBa. they have to be righteous already, they have to be righteous already, but yes, that's actually, uh, your question is in this week's parashah, um Andrea is asking something in a different language. Let's see if I can get a translation. Okay, here we go. Can't these shiurim come with Portuguese subtitles? Would it be possible to send administration by subtitle in Portuguese? Okay, so we actually have, you know, I'm a rabbi, not a minister. A minister is usually connected with Christianity.
2:40:40But either way, we actually have a channel, Rabbi Yaron Reuven in Portuguese, where you have Portuguese subtitles. And you can watch many of our lectures that our wonderful team has put subtitles on in Portuguese. We also have in Spanish, French, and German. So just look up my name on YouTube, and you'll see that we have multiple channels in different languages, and one of them is in Portuguese. Please log on and subscribe. You could also send a WhatsApp message to me or to our website, and we can add you to a Portuguese WhatsApp group that we have. uh, Michael asked, "Can the yetzer hara cause a person to have specific thoughts?" Uh, yes, I mean technically, that's one of the jobs of the yetzer hara, to entice you to have certain thoughts.
2:41:46Remember, the yetzer hara is not just by himself. There's the yetzer hara and there's also his wife. They are going to put different thoughts in your head that are obviously a way for you to go against Hashem. Thoughts of idolatry are common for people who are not careful or people who used to be idolatrous or people who watch a lot of videos about Christianity, like the anti-missionaries. the thoughts of idolatry do pop up sometimes at the worst times when you're praying, and you have to understand that thoughts of idolatry need to be removed immediately because this is the only crime that Hashem punishes for even if a person is just thinking it, not doing it. so typically that happens because somebody did something in order to, in essence, open the door for the Yetzer Hara to come in, as Hashem says to Kayin, "L'petach chatas rovetz"
2:42:51means that if you leave an opening, that's where the Yetzer Hara is going to come in. So if a person does something to leave the door open, the Yetzer Hara is going to bust the whole building down and come in. So if a person doesn't watch their eyes, then the thoughts of immorality have full permission to enter their mind. If a person does not watch their mouth, then the thoughts of nivul peh, of forbidden speech, become a standard in their life. If they listen to inappropriate music, inappropriate language, movies, you know, all types of music with lyrics containing all types of cursing and swear words, or if they themselves are bothered by it, then it's very common that the yetzer hara will have full permission to give them all the reasons in the world to speak like that also. So yes, if a person gives the yetzer hara or his wife an opening, then yes, it will come and, unfortunately, run the house. So, it's very, very important for the person to take that into account. Okay, I believe we answered all of the questions. Thank you again for learning Torah with me.
2:44:03then yes, it will come and, unfortunately, run the house. So it's very, very important for the person to take that into account. Okay, I believe we answered all of the questions. Thank you again for learning Torah with me. for anybody that speaks Hebrew later on tonight uh I want to have a little bit more energy I want to do a shiur in Hebrew uh, so we'll post it later on or you'll see it online tomorrow. Thanks again, everybody, for learning with me. Hopefully, you got some chizuk out of this and a wake-up call. I know I got some chizuk out of this parasha and out of the questions you guys asked. We'll see each other again next week. Amen.
2:45:33I bless the rabbis. Wait, wait. I bless the rabbis, Rabbi Yaron Reuven, Rabbi Efraim Kachlon, the head of the group with God's help. May God bless you. May God bless you. May God bless you. May God bless you. in the whole of Israel. This Jew was a millionaire. He closed all the businesses. He said, "I invest here in the world of Torah." Where did he live? In Florida. Florida. Where is Florida? In America. In Miami. In Miami. Yes, next door. We're going to build a large Sephardic community. A large Sephardic community.