STUMP THE RABBI (117) Daat Torah Re Chaim Walder, KIDS, Amidah, TZARAAT, SEGULA To Make Millions
Transcript
0:15In the name of God, we will do and succeed in the study of the Torah. We're back here, Baruch Hashem, doing the Stump the Rabbi series. We had an event yesterday, Baruch Hashem. For anyone that watched the video we posted this morning as part of the event, Baruch Hashem, we had the merit to have Rabbi Aaron Ze'ev, Shlita, with us, one of the most amazing people I've ever met. Also, not surprisingly but amazingly, he is one of the descendants of both Ben Ish Chai and Rav Kaduri. So, and if you see the picture... Rabbi Aaron Ze'ev, Shlita, with us, one of the most amazing people I've ever met. Also, not surprisingly but amazingly, he is one of the descendants of both Ben Ish Chai and Rav Kaduri. So, and if you see the picture, we have in our house of the Ben Ish Chai, and you look at Rav Ze'ev, it's exactly the same thing. The only difference is the length of the beard. But, Baruch Hashem.
1:26Always great to see him. Always great to see good people. Got to see some faces I haven't seen in a while, Baruch Hashem. So with that being said, we have our shiur. The shiur tonight is going to be a different type of shiur, a very controversial shiur. Not that controversy is something that we're new to, but the whole point of this shiur is going to be to stimulate your mind and make us realize that without Da'at Torah, we simply know nothing. Because our mind naturally steers in the wrong direction. And not everybody has Da'at Torah, even if they know a lot of Torah. And well, today's shiur will be one of those proofs. Tonight's shiur will be for a refuah shlema for Rabbanit Levana Bat Sara, Rabbi Ephraim Ben Shulamit, Rabbanit Sara Bat Anat, Avim Uri David Ben Ester, Yamin Urati, Doris Bat Zohra, Orit Bat Ilana, Sara Bat Susan, also for a hatzlacha rabah for Marsha Bat Julie, Ayla Bat Marsha, Samuel Ben Marsha,
2:46...uh, and everything that they do, especially in their Avodat Hashem... A brief update on some of the things that are going on. We have, Baruch Hashem, lots and lots of boxes. If you've seen boxes in the background and packaging stuff, that's because, Baruch Hashem, the kehillah store is pumping out boxes like it's free. and that's the inside joke in our house that, you know, there are so many boxes, it's like it's free when, obviously, it is free. So, if you haven't ordered some copies of my notebook or
3:48or some of the CDs, or some of the other things, go to the Kiruv store, kiruvstore.org, and get some stuff to give out in your community. We've run out of some of the products we have; as of this time, we'll get more soon. My personal book, we only have a few copies left, maybe a hundred or fewer copies left, so that's almost done. uh, just letting you guys know if the um If the Facebook goes down again, I'm not going to redo it because then I'll be in the middle of the lecture. So, if you want to see the lecture live, you'll have to download the app or go to BH.live and you'll be able to watch the lecture live. The reason why I did the whole Facebook live again now is because we haven't officially started the lecture, so I'm not in the middle of an idea.
4:49uh, but uh to do this whole thing I just did, it took five minutes while the minimal speaking is not going to happen. Uh, visit the shiur. Uh, okay, so uh like I said, the Kiruv store, Baruch Hashem, is going good. We have, b'ezrat Hashem, good news coming next week where we're getting our orders of Rav Ephraim's new book. Some of you guys that have reserved your copies will get them over the next couple of weeks or sooner. So that's one. We actually have a couple of new products that will be added to the store next week. That's one. Second thing, this whole disaster with the Ephraim Goldberg evil empire is continuing. We're fighting tooth and nail. We're trying to do whatever we can. A little bit of a different strategy than we used in the past. We learned from our experience. And tomorrow night we're going to be on a... B'ezrat Hashem... Stay tuned, but it's almost definite that we'll be on a radio show.
5:53uh, tomorrow night, and uh, you'll be able to tune in live. When I get the information, I'll send it out; you'll have it. I will be interviewed, discussing this particular, uh, situation with that Rabbi Goldberg and the whole missionary situation. So that's, uh, that. Also, other things are in the works, but I'd rather talk about them once I have them in my hand, uh, rather than, uh, you know, waiting for them. Many people did not believe what I said about five years ago when I warned the Boca Raton Synagogue by first approaching their leader, led by a heretic named Ephraim Goldberg. You've obviously seen this disaster that's happening at Boca Raton Synagogue right now, where a very big mistake is being made by the leaders to bring the number one Catholic missionary in the world. If you just type in his name, Matthew Kelly, you'll immediately find his whole life mission is to make everyone Catholic.
6:54Make everyone follow what the Torah says is 100% Avodah Zarah. Every single house. Gopal Aton Synagogue neighborhood got a missionary letter with a DVD in it. The very same thing is happening right now. You continue allowing Ephraim Goldberg and the rest of his staff to stay in their jobs. You are supporting idol worship. They're bringing a missionary again. What do you mean? They're bringing a missionary again on January 11th. Boca Raton Synagogue is hosting what they're calling South Florida Night to celebrate Israel. You can find this on their website brsonline.org. You have three keynote speakers. Surely, Efrem Goldberg has to have a stage; it's his place after all. They're gonna give some honor to the keynote speaker, the ambassador, David Friedman, who was a former US ambassador to Israel. So far, not necessarily a problem. I wouldn't necessarily highlight an ambassador in my shul, but if you want to do it, by all means.
8:12we don't have a problem so far. Where do we have a problem? When the other keynote speaker, the other partner in the whole event, is a person that lives in my backyard here, a person by the name of Pastor Mario Bramnick, president of the Latino Coalition to Israel. Pastor Mario Bramnick, for all intents and purposes, seems like a very nice guy. He probably is a nice guy. But unfortunately, to him and to us, his beliefs and his life's work are problematic according to our Torah. Not saying it in a nice way. Why? Mario Bramnick, he is the president of the Hispanic Israel Leadership Coalition. He was a speaker for the Israeli American Council. He's very... Politically connected, he has done a lot of work to connect himself to the Land of Israel. But aside from that, his main gig is that he's a pastor. Pastor Bramnick has a church, and this church is called New Wine Ministries.
9:41And New Wine Ministries does not confuse anybody by making them think that they are your simple Catholic church. Rather, no. They say on their own website, on the welcome page, "We are a church with a divine design to advance the Kingdom of God in our neighborhood, our county, our nation, and the nation of Israel. We are a church with a passion to evangelize, train, and equip believers to attain their purposes and the call of God in their lives. Pastor Bramnick is a missionary." our county, our nation, and the nation of Israel. We are a church with a passion to evangelize, train, and equip believers to attain their purposes and the call of God in their lives. Pastor Bramnick is a missionary. a very ambitious missionary who has his primary focus on the Jewish people. Just like other evangelical Christians, one of their main core beliefs is to evangelize the Jewish people to believe in Jesus. This is the reason why their promotion, their events, and their teachings have become much
11:03more similar, or at least in appearance, to Judaism than they were in the previous generation. Perhaps one example on Pastor Bramnick's website is that he's about to have a Hanukkah Christmas celebration. Now if you ask his great-grandfather if his church celebrated a Hanukkah Christmas celebration, I assure you the answer would be no. if you look up the Christian books from two, three, four, five, or six hundred years ago and you ask any of the pastors, priests, popes, or whoever else, "Did you have a Hanukkah Christmas event?" It's like, what do you mean? Like, a Hanukkah event to kill Jews? That's what you're calling Hanukkah, like a joke? No, no, no, like a Hanukkah, like you're celebrating Hanukkah but also Christmas, like unification of the Jews and the Christians? They'll look at you like, what do you mean? Why? Why would there be unification of the Jews and the Christians? This is a relatively new invention. Now, you would think, oh, this is very nice.
12:13Unity between the Christians and the Jews should be good. We live in America after all. We live in England. We live in Australia. We live in, mostly, we live in foreign lands. Shouldn't there be some type of friendship? Sure. Friendship, yes. Unity, no. Now, Pastor Bramnick, for his beliefs, for his beliefs, he's doing good. In fact, I would love to have Pastor Bramnick on our team. Because if we can find rabbis that believe in the one and only God, and the one and only Torah, and forsake the New Testament, the Quran, and all of the other teachings, if I could have people as passionate as Pastor Bramnick, I bet you, within a few years, Mashiach's coming. Why? Because passion like this, dedication like this, is very hard to find. But what do we have? We have Ephraim Goldberg bringing the spiritual enemies into our own backyards. People whose job is to convert our people to their beliefs, that's who we have on our so-called team. Now, Pastor Bramnick is doing good for himself, but bad for us though.
13:37Problem is that the idolatrous nations are preaching their false beliefs as if they're true, while many of the rabbis that have the truth are preaching it like it's false because they're either scared to tell the truth, or they're simply so confused by money they forgot what the truth even looks like. or they're simply so confused by money they forgot what the truth even looks like, that we have a church pastor in Broward County, Fort Lauderdale area. Years ago, we would always have a night to honor Israel or some special event, and Maybe seven years ago, we partnered with the Jewish Federation locally to do a joint Christian-Jewish event combating antisemitism. That was really the start of our journey.
14:39I invited then Deputy Foreign Minister Danny Ayalon, Robert Stearns, and our Congresspeople. We had pastors and rabbis. At our first event, I think we had about 2,000 people at a university assembly. It was amazing. And it was from there that we had a major event. And then the next day, we had a pastor-rabbi symposium of about 100 pastors and rabbis. From there, I felt was birthed several initiatives that then went literally global since then. We started with South Florida because we have a lot of Christians, Hispanics, and Jewish people. And my main thing is just let's bring everybody together and let's work together. And out of that was birthed our pro-Israel agenda, which now is through the Latino Coalition for Israel.
15:41as well as a pastor-rabbi Torah study. So we started meeting on that every month, one month in a church, one month in a synagogue, really for the most part talking about areas of commonality, on how much we do agree on instead of differences and so forth, and how we can build and learn from each other's communities. and established a great relationship. It was a small group, about 15, and it still meets to this day. I had delegated the leadership of that. And as you know, we actually did two major pastor-rabbi symposiums on theological dialogue, the last one with 200 people. We had different Christian denominations, but we also had rabbis from Orthodox, Conservative, and Reform backgrounds together, studying the Torah together, and it was pretty amazing. And unfortunately, Rabotai, we have a serious problem. Why do we have a serious problem? Because Pastor Bremnick is about to come
16:58to Boca Raton Synagogue, give a nice speech, become friends with some people in the community. Says Rabbi Shimon Bar Yochai, that one who kills a body here in this world is much less of a sinner than one who causes another Jew to sin because he is killing both his body and his soul. Even if the murderer was murdering bodies for 210 years, and the one who is murdering a soul is murdering it after a single speech that could take five minutes. That person who caused another to sin after giving him a speech for five minutes or allowing someone to speak heretical thoughts, heretical ideas, idolatrous beliefs, that person is a much greater sinner and thereby worse than even Pharaoh!
18:18but also for tax purposes. This is a time to donate, and we also have a very big campaign that we're trying to make successful. Unfortunately, a few people have not been able to donate, but this is a time to contribute. You can go to bhyeshiva.com, bhyeshiva.com, and that's the campaign to donate for. Okay, with that being said, we have Parashat Vayera. Parashat Vayera is a continuation of what we started last week, the Exodus of Am Yisrael from Egypt. Of course, Moshe Rabbeinu is someone that we can talk about from the beginning of the world to the end and still not have enough to say about him. He's just an extraordinary person that we really don't have a concept of who Moshe Rabbeinu was. an extraordinary person that we really don't have a concept of who Moshe Rabbeinu was. Needless to say, we don't have any concept of who our sages were. But for whatever reason or another, it's a...
19:25view today that people that perhaps know how to speak, maybe even mention a few sources from time to time, and give some good stories are automatically compared to some of the greatest sages that we've had, either in this generation or previous generations. People that have never even completed the Shas or the Rambam or really anything of significance, you know... could easily find themselves debating the early sages and quoting things and misquoting things in the name of the Rambam and the Ramban and the Ba'alei Tosafot and Rashi, and simply just doubting the sages or comparing the sages to themselves And really one of the things we're going to learn today, B'ezrat Hashem, is how the ideal position for a person to be mentally is to understand that in comparison to Gedolei HaDor, whether those Gedolei HaDor are
20:33the current ones that we have in the world, or of the previous generation, needless to say of five hundred years ago, a thousand years ago, and two thousand years ago. Or, you know, we've talked about our forefathers. Regardless of where you go, even if you're talking about the Gedolei HaDor of today, the ideal a position for a person to be in, as far as mentally, is to understand that they are nothing. They don't know anything in comparison to them, even if you know a lot Even if you know a lot, in comparison to the sages, we know nothing. And the reason why is because they think differently. And today, B'ezrat Hashem, we'll try to show an example of that in a real-life situation that's happening in the world today. The whole parasha about Chaim Walder. and the accusations, the judgment, the suicide that followed, and of course the conclusions that so many have been in a hurry to discuss. And we'll see that if we look at things based on Da'at Torah, based on the opinion of the Torah,
21:52they're not quite so conclusive, in fact. In fact, you may be surprised that the overwhelming majority of the public opinions that have been discussed about this case are outright wrong, according to the Torah. Even if they've come from good people, smart people, people that know a lot of Torah, that have been learning Torah for a long time, and you'll see that according to the actual Torah itself, they're wrong, simply wrong. And again, it's not necessarily an insult to anybody. This is how the Torah works. This is part of it. Now, of course, Everything that we see in the world today is always connected to the weekly parasha. And we see that in Parashat Vayera, We have several places where the Torah talks about fear of Heaven. One time, I remember learning this from Rav Yosef Mizrachi, where, years ago, I heard the shiur where he said one of the things that we learn from the Torah is not just the stories, not just the laws, but also the language of Hebrew.
23:14and uh we learn, you know, everything in the holy language, and one of the things we learn is that everything has an opposite except meaning that if you have, you know, tall, short, dark, light, fat, skinny—all these different things that every language has—but when it comes to the issue of fear of Heaven, if you ask somebody what's the opposite of fear of Heaven, they'll tell you what I, myself, thought and most people think: the opposite of fear of Heaven is no fear of Heaven, lack of fear of Heaven. But that's actually wrong. Why is it wrong? Because we see in this parashah, Parashat Va'eira, that in the plague of hail, it says that Moshe Rabbeinu gave the warning to the Egyptians, and ha-yarei et dvar Adonai mei'avdei Paro heinise et avadav v'et miknehu el habatim, v'asher lo sam libo
24:23it says that whoever among the servants of Pharaoh feared the word of Hashem chased his servants and his livestock to the houses, and whoever did not take the word of Hashem to heart left his servants and livestock in the field. So we see here that this is, in essence, supposed to be a statement where it's supposed to say both sides, so this is a person that had fear of Hashem, listened to what Moshe Rabbeinu warned about in regards to the hail coming, and went inside because Moshe Rabbeinu specifically warned whoever is going to be outside from the Egyptians will die during this plague whether it's animal, man, whoever it is. So, those that feared after already getting hit, you know, six times, those that feared Heaven by now, went inside. They figured, why do I need to be outside? His God has been killing us already. So, I'm going to go inside. They took their animals, they took their servants, and they went inside. But then it says, those that did not take the word of Hashem to heart stayed in the field.
25:47Wait a minute, we shouldn't say those that didn't fear the word of God? No. Why? Because there is no such thing. There is no such thing as not fearing God. Because anyone that knows what God is, immediately fears Him. That's what we'll learn in parashat Beshalach, where it says that Am Yisrael saw the Egyptians dead, and then they saw the the hand of God and how God did these great things. And immediately it says they feared and they believed in Hashem, meaning that as soon as they recognized the significance of Hashem, immediately they feared Him. Then they had Emunah in Hashem, meaning that Emunah cannot come before fearing Hashem because you cannot believe in Hashem, you cannot have Emunah in Hashem without understanding what He is to a certain extent. as soon as a person has any concept of what Hashem is, immediately they fear Him because they understand that this is not your body. This is Someone that's in control of everything, including you, including the cells in your body, including whether you'll succeed, whether you'll live, whether you'll die, whether you'll have kids—everything. And anyone that's normal
27:03and pays attention is going to be afraid. Hence, the reason why there is no such thing as not fearing God. Literally, what there is, is someone that doesn't take things to heart, lo sam lev. What does it mean, lo sam lev? Simply, the only reason why he doesn't fear God is because he's not paying attention to the details of, you know, God being in the creation. He's Blaming nature for it. He's blaming scientific knowledge for it. He's blaming all types of things for what God actually does. Therefore, he doesn't think that God is connected. It's the reason why many times people will say silly things like, "You know, me and God understand each other. He accepts me, I accept Him, but even though I don't fulfill the mitzvot," and they feel fine with themselves. They think that they have this personalized relationship with God and God is simply going to punish everybody else except them, even though they've never read the Torah itself or they just simply decided to do the opposite of the Torah. But God understands their limitations. These are all ridiculous things that nonetheless happen every single day because people don't pay attention; they don't take the word of God to heart.
28:16so this is one of the places where we see the teachings of how significant, how important yirat Shamayim is. In essence, it's either having yirat Shamayim or losing a person's life. Another interesting thing is that at the end of the parasha, it says something very interesting. It says Pharaoh says that I’m the one that sinned against God. God is the righteous one, and me and my nation are wicked. What's the response that Moshe Rabbeinu tells him? He says to him that... he says to him, "And as for you and your servants, I know that you're not yet afraid of Hashem, our God. You're not afraid." He just said he's wicked. He just said that he made a sin, but Moshe Rabbeinu says, "I'm not buying this bluff. I know you're still not afraid of God." Now, the question is, is Moshe Rabbeinu trying to make
29:33Paro, one of the avreichim in his kollel? Is Moshe Rabbeinu trying to convert Paro to Judaism? What does he care if Paro is afraid of God? Why does he even care if he's afraid of God? Say, let's just free us and go live your life, we'll live our life. What do you care about fear of God? The key to understand here is that Chazal teach us that a person who is not afraid of God is always a potential murderer at all times. A person who does not have Yirat Shamayim, you're not allowed to be in a room alone with them. You can't trust them. Why? They can potentially murder you. which is the reason why there are all types of different rules for how to treat certain people, deal with certain people, and stay away from certain people. And the more Torah a person learns, the more they understand that these rules are literally for your own life's sake, for your own protection. Now, see that the parasha, like the rest of the Torah, is constantly teaching the same foundational principle, the same foundational rule, the same foundational mitzvah, which is the fourth mitzvah on the list of mitzvot of the Rambam, uh, lists out of the 613, which is fearing God. It's kind
30:47constantly teaching, but yet you have an endless amount of people asking the same question week in, week out: "Why are all of your lectures scary? Why can't you just teach wonderful things like 'God loves us'? Why can't you just talk nicely like all the other rabbis?" The answer is very simple, and it's always the same: Anyone that does not teach you about fearing God is not teaching you Torah. They're teaching you something that is potentially part of Torah, potentially similar to Torah, or potentially the opposite of Torah. But Torah, it is not. Why? Because as you can see, we're not structuring the shiur. I don't prepare a shiur. I don't have a script that I'm reading. I have some books in front of me; I have some things that I want to say, but I don't have an actual script. I don't even have an idea of what I'm going to say beforehand.
31:48simply put, every place in the Torah that you look, whether it's the Gemara, the Shulchan Aruch, the Rambam, the Chumash, or the rest of the Tanakh, or the Sifrei, anything and everything you look at, if you actually read what's being said, there's constant teachings that are scary. Why? Because life is scary. In fact, Even without the Torah, anyone that has eyes, ears, and is simply a person that operates in the world realizes that life is scary. Reality is scary. But the good news is that once you learn about what to be scared of, then you know what not to do, then you know how to stay away from certain things. But if you simply live in some lala land, ignoring the things that are not making you feel all gooey inside like a Care Bear or something, you know, you're avoiding anything that distorts your illusion. Then what ends up happening is that you become the most vulnerable person in the world. ...then you know what not to do. Then you know how to stay away from certain things. But if you simply live in some la-la land, ignoring the things that are not making you feel all gooey inside like a Care Bear or something, you know, you're avoiding anything that distorts your illusion. Then what ends up happening is that you become the most vulnerable person in the world...
32:56Hence the reason why you have multiple kehillot that consider themselves religious, yet have invited Christian missionaries into their community. And when you tell them this is wrong, they look at you like you have five heads. Like, why is this wrong? Why can't we just be friends with our Christian brothers? it's like saying, why can't we be best friends with Hitler, Eichmann, Himmler, and perhaps even Dr. Mengele? Why can't we just exchange letters? Maybe we should do a yahrzeit for them. And you say, "No, why?" The Christians are not killing us, according to you. They’re not. According to Judaism, they are. But perhaps you don't know what the difference is. These are some of the things we're going to try to discuss today. Why? Because if we are going to continue operating in the world without Daas Torah, without the opinion of the Torah, we're not really going to get very far, Rabotai. We're only going to get to a horrible place, unfortunately. You know, the Holocaust, the Spanish Inquisition, the pogroms, the destruction of the First and Second Beit HaMikdash,
34:08The constant disasters that have happened to our nation didn't happen to our nation because we were doing so great and serving Hashem so wonderfully that He just wanted to give us a massacre. Every single time we went against Hashem as a people, it eventually culminated with a Tragedy, a very, very big one. No nation in history has suffered as much as the Jewish people. Other nations that have suffered typically have been eliminated from the world. No nation has suffered as much as the Jewish people, and the Torah promises that that's what will be if we don't follow its commandments. if we follow the Torah, we will prosper, and we will have great things. But if we don't, we will have disasters unlike any other nation, and this is literally a promise in the Torah. Look at Parashat Ki Tavo—it specifically says these types of things. So the point being is that if we do not go to da'at Torah, we don't go to the opinion of the Torah, we're not really going to get very far. Now, sometimes people think they do have da'at Torah, but their da'at Torah happens to always be similar to their da'at self, their own personal opinion and their own personal preference. So how do you know whether something is da'at Torah or not? First and foremost, that someone that really has da'at Torah actually said it.
35:30And second, and I agree with the halacha, I agree with everything. And second of all, is that even the learning, the teaching, the understanding of it is full, full of Yirat Shamayim. If it does not have Yirat Shamayim, if it does not have fear of Heaven connected to it, there's something wrong. something wrong. Why? Because the foundation of the Torah is fear of Heaven, and anyone that has an inkling of real knowledge that is Torah-based has to have fear of Heaven. it's not a suggestion or anything else, and quite frankly, the more you learn Torah, the more you realize this. In the beginning, you thought it's a good thing to aspire to. As you continue progressing, you realize that you really never had anything until you got to it. And even when you think you got to it, you're not really sure you really got to it, because a week later, a month later, a year later, two years later, three years later, so much has changed that you realize that when you thought you got to it, you actually had nothing.
36:37because there's so much more to fear than you realized a few years ago when you thought you got to it. The more a person knows Torah, the more they know how much they have to fear in this world. Unfortunately, in the world today, there is a lack in many different areas. Our job is to try to bring light to certain issues. Whether those issues are going to tickle your fancy or not doesn't really make much of a difference. Whether it makes us more popular or not doesn't make much of a difference. Like someone made a comment or sent a message saying, "Do you know how much more popular you would be if you did not go and bash other rabbis? You know, this is an interesting comment because it assumes that I actually want more fans. It assumes that I want more likes. It assumes that I want to be liked. It assumes that I need to be liked." what I need is to share, to learn Torah, and do my best to share it with those who want to learn with me. You too will be blessed like the countless people that have been blessed as a result of learning. It has nothing to do with me; anybody can do this job. Just simply dedicate your whole life to it.
37:56know pretty much take every single thing of this world and throw it in the garbage and dedicate your life to helping people and learning. If you want to do it, you can do it. It's really not something that's impossible; it's just that not everybody's willing to do it because most people are addicted to things that I'm not. But it's not something that you can't do or anybody can't do. Everybody can do this; it's just that most people are living a life that is a little bit more, you know, self-centered, let's just say that. So the key to understand is that we're not looking for more students, we're not looking for more fans, we're not looking for more likes. We're looking to learn Torah, to share Torah, and as a result of those things, Hashem will send us an endless amount of people that have similar desires, and those people will benefit as a result of it. Simple. And of course, we benefit as a result of doing kiruv. self-centered, let's just say that. So, the key to understand is that we're not looking for more students, we're not looking for more fans, we're not looking for more likes. We're looking to learn Torah, to share Torah, and as a result of those things, Hashem will send us an endless amount of people that have similar desires, and those people will benefit as a result of it. Simple. And of course, we benefit as a result of doing kiruv.
39:00and the olam and everything else and even this world but the point being is that we're never going to do a lecture just because it's going to get people to like us. This is the world of Ephraim, this is the world of Manis, this is the world of all of the others where they go astray in their Torah career, if you want to call it that is when they start looking for popularity. That's when you see them starting to go off the original good direction they were on. You start seeing them go off the direction, and I could name a million different things that I've seen in my life both in the business world and unfortunately in the Torah world of how people that started off good went in the wrong direction at some point. Why? They were looking for likes; they were looking for popularity. and unfortunately, anytime somebody follows that type of path, they're doomed. They're simply doomed. So what we're looking for is to hopefully, one day, learn some Torah. Hopefully, one day, we'll know some Torah. That's it. That's all we want in life. And there's another if if people want to do with us
40:14Now, of course, part of learning Torah, part of teaching Torah, is defending the Torah. It makes no sense to learn Torah and just keep it for yourself. It makes no sense to love the Torah and let it be desecrated out in the open by wicked people. So, of course, part of it is the wars. That's why the Torah itself is called the Book of Wars. It's a pasuk in the Torah. It's a book of wars. So, part of the Torah is fighting for the sake of the Torah. Not because Hashem needs you to fight for Him, but rather because Hashem wants you to fight for Him. Why does He want you to fight for Him? Because it shows that you love Him. It shows love. Simple. Your wife doesn't want you to go fight another guy that embarrassed her in public. It's not like she needs you to go do it, but if you did it, she wouldn't necessarily go against it. Why? Because it shows that you care for her. A relationship that does not have some form of jealousy in it is a dead relationship. That's what the Gemara says. There has to be some jealousy in a relationship, both from the wife's side and the husband's side.
41:19So, when we look at Torah in the right way, we realize that there is no other choice. This is what it is. And when we see that the Torah constantly talks about fear of Heaven, fear of Heaven, fear of Heaven, punishment, this, that, the other thing, constantly, constantly talking about all these different things. And then you see that you're almost alone in the world because very few people uh, speakers speak this way, and it makes it seem as if you're the crazy one. But then again, you ask big talmidei chachamim, you ask, you read their books, you read the sefarim, and you see, I mean, it's either everybody that's ever been a righteous person is a crazy person or, unfortunately, the opposite. opposite. So this, Rabotai, is one of the beautiful things about the Torah. We have a documented lineage, documented teachings, unlike any other nation, to such an extent that anything you want, any question you can possibly have, there is a place in the Torah that discusses it in detail.
42:31in detail, and if a person really toils, they'll find the answers. Unfortunately, most people are used to, you know, just simply, their level of toil is sending a text message and saying, "Can you show me the source for XYZ?" as if they're going to go look up that source even if you give it to them. The reality is someone who's truly looking for an answer knows that the last thing you want to do is go ask somebody for a source for it. The first thing you want to do is go try to look for it yourself. why? Because on the path of looking for it, you'll find a bunch of other treasures anyway. Rabotai, we have a connection in the parasha with the teachings of yirat Shamayim, the teaching of yirat Shamayim, constant mention of yirat Shamayim. Now, why is the parasha that talks about yirat Shamayim, about fear of Heaven, connected to the whole issue of the Chaim Walder debacle? Because this is what's going to decipher whether you accept everything that I'm about to tell you or not. If you have yirat Shamayim, you will not have any questions at the end of this shiur. Even if you heard the exact opposite of what I just said, you will not have any questions about what the right opinion is. If you do not have yirat Shamayim, you could send us your name and we'll pray for you, maybe because there's something wrong with you. Because it's clear as day.
43:53It's clear as day that this is what the Torah is teaching us. Now, the whole issue that has happened has transpired, and we're not going to go into all the details. I'm sure everybody has heard of this, but I'll give you brief details. He was an extraordinarily successful author of children's books, wrote something like 80 books or more, and was pretty much the top in the market. He was extremely well known, extremely well liked, and extremely well publicized, but over the last year or so, there's been a... was an extraordinarily successful author of children's books, wrote something like 80 books or more, and was pretty much at the top of the market. He was extremely well known, extremely well liked, and extremely well publicized, but over the last year or so, there's been a campaign against him, where something like maybe six or eight months ago, a certain beit din passed out, or at least people in the name of that beit din passed out some type of poster online, saying that his books are no longer welcome
45:02...now when we called that beit din to see why the books are no longer welcome, we, uh, didn't get an answer. The reason why is because nobody picks up the phone in that beit din. I would be surprised if the beit din is even a real beit din. But when people see things on the internet, they assume, especially if it has a logo, if it has Hebrew writing... If it has something spicy, people automatically believe it to be true and they spread it like wildfire. Hence the reason why Hashem turned the staff of Moshe Rabbeinu into a snake. Because Moshe Rabbeinu, in essence, said Lashon Hara unintentionally but nonetheless said Lashon Hara about Am Yisrael. not uh they're not going to accept the uh uh that he's you know that he spoke to uh God so Hashem said this is throw your staff on the floor and the staff turned into a snake uh why why a snake because a snake is symbolic of lashon hara. Snake bites have venom, and that venom is a deadly killer
46:08uh, same thing with the tzara'at, that the second sign that Moshe Rabbeinu got. Tzara'at is the punishment for saying lashon hara. And unfortunately, when people get some of these posts, some of these memes, some of these things that they send out about how somebody is a bad guy according to somebody, people just simply share it, and the public consumes it with no doubts. As soon as there is something out there, they consume it without any doubt. I'll give you a personal example. There was a list of, I think, 10 or 15 heretical rabbis that was published, I don't know, a couple of years ago. From time to time, it was updated, and different names were added to it. Now, I've spoken about some of those, probably half of those rabbis on that list, but I never put together that list. I never wrote that list. I don't have a list. I know who's bad that I've spoken against. I know who's not. I'm not delirious. I have lectures. I'm a public figure, and I speak about these things publicly on a regular basis.
47:18But for whatever reason or another, people assume that I put together the list because I have nothing to do with my life. And I put together lists. And in fact, what the truth is, is that when the list came out, the few people that I know who were sharing this list, I told them a million times not to publish the list. Why? It provides nothing. Other than tension. Other than causing fighting. It doesn't do anything good. There is no mitzvah in publishing that list. But of course, some people will listen. Some people will simply ignore. They'll say, "Ah, the Rabbi is weak. The Rabbi is old. The Rabbi is losing his mind. Ah, I need to warn the public." Everybody wants to be the big chassid all of a sudden. And they publish the list of bad rabbis, as if that's going to create any good in the world. And best yet, they update it from time to time. ...Now again, I don't really care enough about it to do anything, but the point being is that everyone assumed this is my list. Why? Because I've spoken about half of those rabbis that are there, that they're heretics and so on, so people assume. And they assume that even the ones I didn't speak about...
48:21also, even the ones that people add from time to time, whom I don't even know, that's also attributed to me. People just assume that if they see it on the internet, it must be true. So, needless to say, when a poster came out a year ago, I... About Chaim Walder and his books not being accepted in a certain community, as he said, "Automatically, I got a bunch of at least half a dozen or more messages from people saying, 'Look, we have to warn the public, Rabbi, this is your job.' Oh, thank you very much for telling me my job. I really appreciate it. Who are you again? Like a bunch of strangers telling me about my job and how I'm responsible to be the police officer for the world of rabbis and have to warn the public." Ludicrous situations literally happen here on a regular basis. But nonetheless, we looked into it. We made a phone call and found out that the Beit Din doesn't even exist or simply is not really operational. But the post was very operational. In fact, if there was a real Beit Din behind that poster, that Beit Din would probably become very successful. How popular would it become? People would use it just because of that stupid poster.
49:31But nonetheless, this was the first sign we got from this whole parasha about Chaim Walder. Then, of course, something came out a couple of months ago in the most, how could I say this, the most liberal, anti-Torah, anti-Semitic newspaper on planet Earth named Haaretz. It might as well be called Mein Kampf. uh, Mein Kampf for Jews that hate themselves. And, ah, let's publicize a story about how Chaim Walder did all types of heinous crimes: pedophilia, rape, adultery, all types. Like, literally, according to the article, the guy apparently committed all these crimes. And it just got worse as the articles kept being publicized. I didn't follow most of them; I just saw a couple here and there that people would send me, and I couldn't avoid seeing them, just to see what's going on. And literally, they simply turned this person who has written over 80 children's books into Esav's older brother. Like Amalek, I think, was more comparable. It’s unbelievable. I mean, I don't know how a person can commit that many crimes in a lifetime. But apparently, Chaim Walder did. Now again, I'm not defending Chaim Walder. I'm not going against Chaim Walder at this point. What I'm telling you is what happened in the media. Now, of course...
50:58they had a rabbi behind this, a rabbi that's, you know, relatively well-known because of his father, who said, "Yeah, he did this. We have testimony from victims." We have testimony from victims, and that's what they said. Okay, now... This already sounded strange. Why? Because that's not really how the world of Torah works. Like if there's an issue, whether it's pedophilia, or it's rape, or it's adultery, or any of these things, it goes to a Beit Din. It doesn't just go to the media. But that's something we're going to get to in a moment. Never hiding it. You're supposed to go to a Beit Din. You're not supposed to go to the media first. Why are you going to the media first? It was already strange from day one. Then shortly later, when questions started coming up from different rabbis, the very same Rabbi Eliyahu said, we've already known about this issue for years. So then you ask a new question. Wait a minute. If you know that this Chaim Walder
52:07is that's writing books for children is also murdering every single one of them, both according to the Torah and pretty much reality. Then, why are you waiting for years? So, the whole thing sounded strange from day one for anyone that read it. Now, if that wasn't enough, I mentioned to you guys in the shiur, whoever watches them on a regular basis, that a couple of book outlets publicized they're no longer going to carry the Chaim Walder books. They simply decided to ban him. Now, if you are operating based on the laws of the land, the logic of society, nothing seems awry, nothing seems bad. In fact people applaud those bookstores, those publications, and the rabbi that was in the secular newspaper for spreading the word. This sounds like a "wow, finally Judaism is changing, they're not hiding stuff anymore" according to the liberal-minded. But if you're thinking about it in a Daas Torah, not only are you wrong, you've just committed
53:30much worse crime than any of the crimes that he's been accused of. Why? Now, there were a lot of stories that spread, and one of the things that we were looking for, and Rabbi Frey worked on this extensively, is an authentic source. And every time you would get to a place, you'd see that this is just hearsay. No legitimate proof. Somebody said that they heard something, that they saw something. They heard recently after the suicide, there was a recording. Oh, so the recording, according to the Torah, it's not a source. It's not a valid source. And we'll get to that in a moment. But society and most people today are already on the "Thank God he died" camp, already on the "Oh, poor victims, we should start a charity fund for them"
54:41uh, already on a good job for all the people that went against it. Everybody's already on that train and already asking the questions, "Oh, what do we do with the books? On one hand, you know he was a monster; on the other hand, the books are pretty good. What should we do?" Well, that's a question, Rabbi, and I've gotten half a dozen of those questions too. You know what the question is? How do you know he was a monster? I saw it in the media. What do you mean you saw it in the media? You have a p'sak din? Yeah, yeah, now the newspaper said that the Beit Din judged and ruled that he is a monster, that he's guilty. The Beit Din ruled that he's guilty? Well, do you know how a Beit Din works? Well, I don't know how a Beit Din works. I don't know, they just decide something. Well, if that was the case, we wouldn't have Judaism; we would have communism. Beit Din does not work where they just simply decide. There's no such thing as a Beit Din without the person. There's no such thing. And that's one of the things that people are not realizing. Everything that's out there in the media today about this case is not according to Halacha. It's not according to the Torah. In fact, it's the opposite. You're going to say, yeah, but you know what? He killed himself. So that is already admitting guilt.
56:07you'd be wrong. Why? We'll get to that in a moment. So already I'm giving you guys a bunch of different things that should, for anyone who's been following this parasha, drive you crazy. You should already get some feelings in your heart, perhaps some of hate, some of anger. Please do me a favor: invite your friends. Perhaps they could learn something too. Now, we were looking for an authentic source before, during, and after the suicide. during, meaning days before and after we found out about the suicide, we were looking for an authentic source. After the whole thing came out, a lot more information came out after the suicide, where the Beit Din said that they ruled that they have at least 22 confirmed cases, a recording of what they say is Chaim Walder. saying that if this story comes out, he'll kill himself, he'll shoot himself, which again, to society at large that is absent-minded when it comes to Torah, this seems like perfect evidence to convict somebody to simply do everything that happened. But according to the Torah, none of this is valid. We called the Beit Din
57:35The Beit Din doesn't want to talk. Why doesn't the Beit Din want to talk? They want to talk to Haaretz. They want to talk to the secular newspapers. But to a Talmid Chacham, they don't want to talk. Why? I guess they're too busy with Haaretz. They don't want to talk. We called some Dayanim. We called some Chachamim. We spoke to some of the Gedolei HaDor. spoke to people with experience, we spoke to people that have an extraordinary amount of knowledge, and I'm going to tell you some names. Everything is verifiable, everything is sourced, and each and every single gadol that we got to was baffled that this whole thing was even happening. Now, Right now, there are, in essence, three conclusions that people have generally arrived at. Conclusion number one is that he was a criminal of the highest extent: rapist, adulterer, pedophile, I don't know, everything and anything you could possibly throw in there. That's conclusion number one.
58:53Some people are even disappointed in me that I haven't spoken about this already. They're like, Rabbi, what's going on with you? Maybe you should stop focusing on the missionaries. Talk about something really important. What? Chaim Walder is a rapist, pedophile, murderer, killer. Okay, buddy, relax. Quite frankly, I didn't even want to talk about this. But it seems like something needs to happen for the sake of learning Torah. first conclusion: that people have the worst person on the planet earth since perhaps maybe Hitler. Second conclusion: that he was a tzaddik and targeted by people and simply a victim of his own success. That's second. Although not as common, at least it doesn't seem like it according to the media and the general consensus that I see out there, there are some people who say no, he didn't do any of these things; he's a victim. Those first two are not going to like this. The third is someone who simply doesn't know what to make of it. They're going to like this.
1:00:19somebody doesn't know what to make out of it, they don't know whether he did it, he didn't do it, what to do, how to do, they're looking for the truth. They're going to like this. If you're seriously looking for the truth, you'll find a resolution. Now, there is a precedent in Jewish law, it's also in secular law, that is called Chizkat Kashrut. Chazakat kashrut, the original source of it, or one of many sources in the Gemara, Masechet Kiddushin, page 74a, or 74b, or 72a, 72b. You also have it in a few other places. Chazakat kashrut is, in essence, innocent until proven guilty. If you see a religious person, make a difference if you like them or not; you have to assume that they are innocent and not just assume that they're guilty. Assume that they don't have something like someone would ask you, "Listen, I don't know, I saw this person is religious, but I saw them, you know, driving on Shabbat. Can I hate them?"
1:01:41make fun of them? Am I allowed to say, "Because, wait, if they're known as a kosher person, you are actually sinning by thinking those things. You know what? You're supposed to be thinking of different creative ways of why this person is not sinning but actually doing a mitzvah on Shabbat by driving." How could it be a mitzvah driving on Shabbat? Perhaps there's somebody in the back seat that they're taking to the hospital to save their life. Perhaps they are in a major life-risk situation. They're saving a life. Perhaps they're a doctor. If a person is known as a kosher person, you are actually obligated to give them the benefit of the doubt. Oh, but Rabbi, I saw that they eat and... I don't know, I didn't see them do a blessing. If they're a religious person... you have to assume that the lacking is on you, not them. Why? The fact that you didn't see them doesn't mean anything. The fact that you didn't see them do the mitzvah, do a blessing, whatever it is that you think they're missing, doesn't mean anything. If they're known as a kosher person, you have to give them what's called chezkat, they have chezkat kashrut, you have to give them the benefit of the doubt. Now,
1:03:09One of the places that discusses this is the Chafetz Chaim. Chafetz Chaim, people love to talk about, "Oh Rabbi, don't say that, it's Lashon Hara." Quite frankly, I think a very, very small minority of people have ever actually read a single halacha in Lashon Hara. The Chafetz Chaim probably is upset at most of these people that keep mentioning his name in the name of Lashon Hara when they don't even know what they're saying. we'll see how this parasha of Walder is a perfect example of that. Now, um, it says something that we've taught before, which is that The entire prohibition of lashon hara applies specifically to victims
1:04:27The Torah considers your brother to be your fellow Jew, someone who observes the mitzvot. But for those persons who are known as apostates, it's a mitzvah to degrade and humiliate them, either directly in their presence or not in their presence, for whatever sins they were seen committing or for sins that were heard that they committed. So the whole issue of Lashon Hara is only referring to people that are frum. That's number one. Now, furthermore, in the same Klal 8, Seif Zayin, Veda Od, De'im Muchzak Ba'ir L'Rasha, Mipnei Sha'ar Inyanei Aveirot, Shemutar Avraham L'ganoto, Gam Ken Dina Achai, V'eizehu Muchzak. כל שעוסקא מפני אנשי העיר לרשע עד שלא יפול להם בו ספק מחמת שמועות הרעות שיוצאות עליו תמיד מענייני ניאוף וכיוצא בזה דברים שנתפשט לדעת איסורן בכל ישראל. אבל אם יצא עליו כל בעלמא בלבד, אסור לסמוך על זה לגנות אותו חס ושלום, ואפילו להחליט בלב אסור, וכמו שביארנו לעיל בכלל ז.
1:05:53V'af sheharabim yod'im le'atik din hazeh mipnei ba'alei halashon, k'she'yishmi'u al echad shemetz dvar ne'of, tekel yachziku et ha'ishahu lemuchzak beresha v'yiganu oto v'yitlu et ha'heter b'sefer hazeh, im kol zeh lo yishtamtiv, Translation. Understand, even more, if this person is established in a city as a rasha, as a wicked person, variety of other sins for which it would be permitted to denigrate him. The law is also the same. Please see the necessarily relevant details as brought down in the Be'er Mayim Chaim, the commentary here. Now, what's the definition of "established"? Meaning that this person has to be known as established in the city or known as a wicked person and...
1:07:09The answer is... It means that society has concluded that this person is a rasha beyond any doubt because of the many bad stories constantly circulating about this person concerning adultery and other illicit affairs that he has had. Behavior that is commonly known throughout the Jewish society to be sinful. But if there was only a generalized rumor circulating about this person, it's forbidden to rely on it as authentic and to degrade him, God forbid. It's even forbidden to personally conclude an opinion about him inside your heart, as he explained in Klal 7. And then the Chafetz Chaim says, even though I was apprehensive about writing this law, because those people who do speak Lashon Hara, when they hear the least impropriety about somebody, they'll immediately seize it and uphold the victim to be an established rasha and demean him to justify demeaning him, and rationalize and justify their actions by relying on this leniency as a basis for their actions. Nevertheless, I did not refrain from stating this, as the Sages
1:08:34have taught us on page 89b in the Gemara, where it quotes the prophet's words that all of God's ways are just. Righteous people will go in His ways and sinful people will trip and fall. So here we see the giving us some food for thought. What's the food for thought? If the person is known as a Rasha, established Rasha, then go to town on this guy. But how do you know if he's an established Rasha? If it was proven that he is an adulterer, a rapist, all types of immorality. But if there's no proof, it's simply a rumor, you're not even allowed to think negatively about him. Even to think negatively about him, you're not allowed. Why? He's still, according to all opinions in the Torah, still has his chelek. To think anything negatively about him, whether during his life or after, is... not even allowed to think negatively about him. Even to think negatively about him, you're not allowed. Why? He's still, according to all opinions in the Torah, still has his chelek. To think anything negatively about him, whether during his life or after, is
1:09:55all of those people say, "Oh, okay, so that means that he has to be established as wicked." I was worried about putting this law. Why? Because some people are going to say, "Listen, this guy is bad. I just know it in my heart. He's bad. I know in my heart he's bad." Yeah, but you can't say it if you don't have proof. "No, no, no, he's known as a rasha." They're going to actually force the guy to be a rasha. in their mind and in the other people's opinion in order to give themselves a rationale to justify their, uh, you know, their lashon hara. Now, the Gemara in Masechet Shabbat, page 18b, says in the name of Rabbi Yosi says: "May my share be like the one who's being suspected or accused and he's really innocent because his reward is huge." And Rav Papa says, "They accused me, and they didn't find anything because I'm innocent." He was proud of this.
1:11:10he has a share in the World to Come. He has a very significant reward because he was accused. A lot of righteous people were accused, and we're talking about how great the reward is for someone who is being accused of something and is really innocent. Now, they're also teaching us how we know if it's really accused, but it's really legit or it's not legit because you could say, "Listen, we're never gonna know." So, there are a few signs. One thing the Gemara says is if the sound of the outcry, the sound of the outcry, people complaining, people saying all these bad things, if it eventually stops, meaning there's a lot of ra'ash... but whatever, a month later, two months later, a few months later, whatever it is, it stops. That’s already a sign from Shamayim that the guy’s really innocent. Meaning that if the guy is really guilty, it’s just not going to stop. Maybe it will take breaks, but it’s not going to stop. It will keep coming back, keep sending more signs to different people, to rile this guy up, to rile it up, to expose this person.
1:12:36the Sages said that these rules and whether it's a, uh, the guy is innocent as a result of the outcry stopping or continuing This specific, these specific rules are for people who don't have enemies. That's what the Gemara is saying. But with enemies, if people have enemies, then they are the ones that publicize this Lashon Hara be-emtza. It's all coming from them. Meaning, there's a different set of rules for people who are in positions of power, positions of success. there are different rules for them. Why? Because they have enemies. Now, you can say everybody has enemies. Yes, everybody has enemies, but people who are public figures, important people, successful people—every normal person will know and agree that they have a lot more enemies than your average person does. Now, there's a responsa by Rabbi Moshe Feinstein, and he says that a rabbi, a rav
1:14:03a rabbinical position is certainly one who has haters. So, anything that is said about this rav or his wife or anything that's connected to him is typically made up by his enemies, and therefore, it's just hearsay. If it's just hearsay, it needs to be ignored. Meaning, you have a rabbi That rabbi, he's either a rabbi of a community, a rabbi of a city, or a rabbi of a country. He's a very big public figure, successful in one way, an author, whatever it is, and has a pretty large circle of influence. And one day, somebody comes out and says, you know that rabbi, he's cheating on his wife. You know that rabbi, he... one of those, you know, that rabbi, this rabbi's wife and him, they're not really married. They just pretend, like Bill Clinton and his wife. Unless you have proof, it is forbidden to say such things. Needless to say, but even more so, the mitzvah here is to ignore it as if it was never said.
1:15:26if there's no evidence that proves it conclusively, ignore it as if it's air. Surely, it came from his enemies, and that's a second point. It's not a suggestion; it's a guide for life. one of the dayanim that we spoke to about this issue, very extraordinary, at times speaks on behalf of the organization, the Rishon LeZion, Harav Yitzchak Yosef. One of the things he said, and we're going to go into even more things that he said, but one of the things he said
1:16:35if a person brings a Psak Din like a Beit Din brings their Psak Din, their conclusion of some type of case, to the media rather than dealing with the ramifications of this issue, there's something wrong. just not something, there's something fishy here already. It shows clearly that there's some type of bias, some type of obsession, something is not normal here. And clearly there is a problem with such a Psak Din. Now someone sent Rabbi Ephraim the Teshuvot HaMaharam Shik. a section Even HaEzer 133, it asks the question: Is a woman that is accused of immorality, cheating on her husband, all types of horrible heinous crimes against Hashem and also against her family, and she refuses to go to the Beit Din
1:17:58refuses to go to the Bet Hamikdash. They say, "Listen, you're accused of adultery, and in order to prove your innocence, you have to come to the Bet Hamikdash. The Kohen Gadol will give you the bitter waters, and you drink it. If you're innocent, you'll get blessings from the Kohen Gadol that if you have ugly kids, your kids will be beautiful; if you have stupid kids, your kids will be smart; if you don't have kids, you'll have kids, and so on and so forth. You get the best blessing in the world. If you're guilty, then that water is going to make a miracle, a spectacle for the rest of us to watch. You're probably not going to enjoy it so much. What's going to happen? You're going to blow up. Not so much fun. There's a whole process. If you read, it's a whole process—a very difficult process—that takes place before they make her drink the water because they really don't want her to drink the water if she's really guilty. They don't want to kill her. They'd rather just say, "Admit it," and then you can just go on your way. That's it. You'll be released from the consequences, and so on. But the point is that if you admit it versus getting caught, it's two different things.
1:19:19like if somebody stole, if they return the money before they get caught, they just have to return what they stole. But if they get caught, they have to return double. So the question that the Marsham asks is that this woman is accused of all types of immorality, and she refuses to come to the Beit Din. Is her refusal... considered as if she is admitting that she's guilty. And he brings the Maharam, who brings the Rambam. The Rambam in Hilchot Sotah, chapter 3, halacha 2, says that if a woman says, "I don't want to drink the bitter waters," then therefore... no way for you to know whether she is guilty or not a hundred percent. So what does the Beit Din do? What does the Beit Hamikdash do? She's released without ketubah benefits, despite the fact that she never admitted to being impure. She never admitted to cheating, to doing the immoral crime. She still loses the ketubah because
1:20:48because she, uh, she, um, if she was pure, if she really didn't commit any crime, then she wouldn't fear drinking it. So clearly she's not ready for this, and she's not rejecting it for nothing. But you can't say for sure that she sinned, but you can't say that she didn't sin. Meaning you don't have a hundred percent. Why? Because with the bitter waters of the Beit Hamikdash, there's no playing games here this is guaranteed, so on one hand you can't know for sure; on the other hand, you can't know for sure. So the question is: what do we learn from this? We're not going to the Beit Hamikdash to go drink the bitter waters. What do we learn from this teshuva? Why would someone send this teshuva to deal with the whole Chaim Walder case? He says, look at the end.
1:21:51The ending is, okay, this woman potentially cheated, potentially she didn't cheat. We don't really know 100%. But what we do know for sure, she refused to drink the water. That's what we know for sure. She's not drinking the water for no reason because she knows that she's losing. She's getting a divorce without getting a ketubah. She's back on the streets with nothing. So now it's not exactly a great condition. If she was really 100% innocent, she'd just drink the water. She wouldn't be afraid. So obviously there's something wrong here. Maybe this, maybe that, but we can't say 100% she sinned. Either way, what we do learn from this is something that's relevant to the Heinwalder case. Would a normal person go to a beit din if the beit din has already decided that they're guilty? before he even came there. If you had said, listen, we want you to come to court. Why? Because you're guilty of murder, rape, this, that, the other thing. But we need to stamp it on a piece of paper that you came in so we can complete the procedure.
1:23:15Would you go? No normal person would go. Why? You've already concluded I'm guilty. You didn't even ask me a question. You don't have any factual evidence. What do you have? A few people said something to you, or a lot of few people. That's how you concluded? Why would I go? You've already decided. That's in essence what Chaim Walder said. He wrote in the letter that he's going to sue all these people in the Beit Din of Shamayim for all their false accusations. In essence, he felt that the reason why he rejected going to the Beit Din, that they asked him to come, is because they've already concluded that he was guilty before he came there. Now, is that enough to say, oh, he's innocent? No. Guilty? No. No. So where do we go to get that? Chachmei Yisrael. Chachmei Yisrael, we have to go to them. How do they think? Every single one of the sages we've spoken to, whether it's Rav Gidon ben Moshe, Rav Yitzchak Yosef, who spoke to Rav Reuven Elbaz, reading what Rav Gershon Edelstein wrote,
1:24:35All of them said similar things. First, why would Chaim Walder, who was connected to the Haredi sect of Judaism, go to an unknown Beit Din run by a Zionist? Now, there are several Batei Din that are world-renowned, world-accepted in the Haredi communities. these are Batei Din that are Rav Ovadia, the uh, the uh, uh, is one of them. I think there's one by, uh, there's another really serious Beit Din. But the Beit Din that everybody knows, this is it—they don't care about anything other than the truth, recognized by everyone. Why would you invite me to go to some Beit Din that not only is not really known, not really accepted in the Haredi community, and also the leader is very, very well connected to the Zionist movement, which is not exactly an ideal situation to deal with for someone that's Haredi?
1:25:53Why would I go to such a Beit Din? That's one of the questions that the Chachamim are asking. Why would he go to such a Beit Din? Why wouldn't, if you really have a case, go take him to a normal Beit Din that everybody agrees with? That has a similar Hashkafah. That's number one. Rabbi Ben Zakaim had a very serious one-on-one conversation with Rabbi Tzach Yosef. And he wrote exactly what happened. After he told him the whole story with Chaim Walder, Rabbi Tzach Yosef was shocked. Not only shocked at this particular event, but shocked at the low level of where the Hareidi community is today. How there's all these types of immoralities and crimes and accusations. And he said exactly these words. He said, "I'm a small nothing, but..." we must go back to speaking to people about reward and punishment. We have to speak about reward and punishment, that an eye is watching, an ear is hearing, and that all of your actions are recorded. Who will merit
1:27:16...will merit us with such rabbis that have a pure heart who could come and rebuke the community like Rav Ovadia, Rav Yehuda Tzadka, and Rav Nissim again, who spoke clearly about Gan Eden and Gehinom. This is Rabbi Yosef... saying we need to merit people to come speak to us again about the basics like his father did. If you're familiar with these names, because we've said these names a thousand times in our lectures, they spoke clearly about Heaven and Hell. Sean let Cena says we need those people back. No one's speaking about Gehinnom again. No, that's why all this immorality is happening. Secondly, he says we must open a Beit Din that is certified and accepted by all of the main sects of the Haredi community, not because each one has their own. So one Beit Din that everybody accepts and...
1:28:37won't be easy and is certainly not going to include every single type of Chassidut, but it will definitely be preferable over the inappropriate judgments that are happening today in different Batei Din that are not really recognized. Their judgments of obligating somebody or relieving somebody will be the final judgment these new Batei Din and from there they can report these judgments to the authorities, to the police, and help institute the actual law if somebody committed rape, if somebody is a pedophile. All these different types of things—you have to work with the police. You can't just say, "Oh, listen, we're gonna deal with this internally; no one's ever gonna know about it." No, you have to deal with it.
1:29:37he says, but at least now, if we have these types of Batei Din, at least the mainstream Haredim will have some peace of mind that they can rely on it. Surely it's going to have some naysayers that go against it, but mainstream Haredim are going to agree with it and have peace of mind as a result of such a thing. This will also address the unavoidable immorality epidemic that we have in our communities that we cannot ignore. Pedophilia and the like is considered 100% murder according to our Torah. As a side note, much of the former yeshiva boys that end up going off the derech has to do with traumatizing experiences such as these.
1:30:37There are proven statistics for this, but even there, there are false accusations too. This new type of beit din can lower this too—not only the crime but also the false accusations. People say, "Oh, this guy did this to me," and he never touched you. He doesn't even know who you are. Not all of the accusations are true, which a lot of people assume. This case is one of those cases where everybody pretty much jumped on the bandwagon that he's guilty. He's the worst person on planet Earth, but we have to see: do we have acceptable evidence according to the Torah? We are almost there. We're almost there. We're gonna get to that. But I'll be check yourself that's pleading for For rabbis to come speak about Gan Eden and Gehinnom, he says if somebody can speak about Gan Eden and Gehinnom clearly, I'll put him on the levayah with me. He has a station every Motzei Shabbat where he speaks. It's all over the world, just like his father did. So if somebody can speak about Gan Eden and Gehinnom, I'll put him on the levayah with me. That's how terrible the situation is in the world today, Rabotai.
1:32:02He says, "What's happening with the Beit Din, this Beit Din, what happened with this whole story, this Beit Din Sade, that is publicizing to the media, they ended up hanging the accused. And with all respect to this Beit Din involved with this case," are many questionable actions that they did. One, a Beit Din set itself up to speak to the media directly. Already, in itself, that is strange and unusual behavior. We are not a secular courthouse. Beit Din speaking to the media is unheard of, unheard of! But not only that, the Beit Din itself says they speak to the media even after the accused is buried when there's no benefit whatsoever. What's the point of saying he's accused, he's guilty. He's not, he's dead. You don't speak about him after he's dead. How is that going to benefit anyone?
1:33:30showing that just from the fact that they're speaking about it to the lefty liberal media after the guy is dead, when there's no benefit, this is a strange obsession that they had. They were unusually quick to conclude judgment. And when the liberal newspaper Haaretz comes to them and shows fake interest in the religious community, while they really have clear hatred for the religious community, they end up getting to speak with the head Dayan, Rav Shmuel Eliyahu. This must concern us. I know that some of you are not familiar with how the Beit Din in the Jewish world works. Anyone that is, is simply saying, yeah, of course, this is the strangest thing and no one's ever heard of such a thing.
1:34:44No one's ever heard of such behavior from a Beit Din. Forget about what the crime is. It could have been stealing apples from a supermarket. It doesn't make a difference. For a Beit Din to act this way doesn't make any sense. Then we go to another Gadol, Rav Gershon Edelstein, who wrote publicly, the public defacement of Chaim Walder... is going to be judged in Heaven with a much worse punishment than he will get, even if he's guilty of all of the alleged crimes. Meaning, even if he's guilty of all the things that they accuse him of, all of those people that publicized what they publicized, talked about it, and shared it, all of those people will get a much, much bigger punishment than he will get. Why? Because of someone that you know commits a crime. The Torah speaks about it heavily. You go to parashiyot, several parashiyot, that talk about how they treat rape and pedophilia like it's murder, no less than murder. But a murderer still is a person that has olam haba. But a person that embarrasses another Jew in public, that's a nidui. A kosher Jew has no share in the world to come.
1:36:11Again, you say, well, but if he really is raping, he's not a kosher Jew. He's not a kosher Jew in that particular sin. But that doesn't give you the permission to make him not a kosher Jew according to everything. Each crime has certain standards. And when a Beit Din aligns itself with a lefty liberal newspaper that's only looking for ways to destroy the religious community in every way possible to make it look bad, clearly there's something wrong here. And unfortunately, when other religious people and even rabbis speak about this in the same fashion, taking the proofs of a newspaper as the proof that this guy is guilty and we can freely speak against them. But Rav Edelstein says they're gonna get a much bigger punishment if they don't do teshuvah than he will get even if he's guilty. This is not an opinion; this is Torah. Furthermore, the most important thing that every single one of the Gedolim said...
1:37:23all of the crimes—the rape, the pedophilia, the adultery—all of it are only alleged. None of them were proven halachically, not a single one was proven halachically by an acceptable Beit Din, none of them. Which means that according to the Torah, he still has This is why one of the talmidei chachamim that wrote about it said, there's nothing even to talk about here. Not only can you keep his books, there's no reason for you to consider anything otherwise. Nothing happened here. He wasn't proven to be a rapist. He wasn't proven to be a pedophile. He wasn't proven nothing. Nothing was proven halachically. Yeah, but what about the 22 women? So what? It could be 2,000 women. That's not how it's proven halachically. Halachically requires him to come to a beit din. Halachically requires actual evidence. And that's one of the things. One of the things that hasn't been shown at this point. Hasn't been shown. What do they have? A recording. A recording of what they say. He's saying that if this goes out, I'm going to kill myself. Several people
1:38:52several people that we spoke to — well, I should correct, Rabbi Frank spoke to — that were extremely close to Chaim Walder, but several people that knew him, that were very close to him, some acquaintances of his, some just knew who he was, but no one conclusively said, "We have no idea who that person is on that tape. It's not his voice." his voice for 20 years, 30 years, 40 years. I know his voice, it's a nice voice. Now to the general public that's getting it from the media, like, "Ah, see, he's guilty, he wanted to kill himself." Did you ever think for a second that it's not his voice? Probably not. Why? Because the whole way that the story has been presented is that he's guilty before you even completed the story. And also, anyone that spent a minute seeing what technology is available today should already know you can make that type of a video, that type of an audio
1:40:03about anyone, at any moment, you could literally take any person you want and not only replicate their voice saying anything you want. In fact, if you have the equipment, you could even make a video of them saying anything you want. And it's been done before. Not only has it been done in Hollywood for at least 25-30 years. It's also been done in the secular world. It's been done in all types of places, and it also has been done in the frum world. One of the strangest cases that have happened in the last 10 years against a major rabbi is they had a video of the rabbi talking about all types of things that are inappropriate. And people that see, myself included, I saw this video, I said, "Wow, it's crazy. I can't believe the rabbi is saying this stuff." But Baruch Hashem, Hashem had mercy on me. And literally five seconds later, I saw the real video. What's the real video? The real video is somebody else is talking. The rabbi is chewing.
1:41:21Somebody else is talking. Why? Because you hear the rabbi answer him. He's next to him, he's next to him. Both of their lips are moving if you pay attention to it. But when somebody already told you, no, it's the rabbi talking, you're only looking at the rabbi. You're not looking at the other guy. You're not a private detective. You're thinking that the rabbi is talking. But when someone shows you a bigger picture and shows you who's talking, you read their lips, you see that nothing that they're saying is what the other guy is saying. But they pinned this on this guy and they made a very, very clever video showing the two cases, proving it. Amazing job. But you see, mamash, how people can manipulate things in any way they want. Put anything in anybody's mouth. But yeah, no one has thought about this in the media. That maybe the tape is not real. Maybe it's not his voice. Maybe it is his voice, but he didn't really say it. nobody's taking that the fact is, Rabotai, no one even mentioned yet that if there were really that many cases, because they're saying they have 22 confirmed women
1:42:35with multiple heinous crimes, each one of them, and many, many others that haven't been confirmed yet. I mean, this means that this person was literally walking around without any clothes on, just to be ready for the next crime. Like, he didn't have enough time to have clothes on. I don't know how he had time to write books. That many women, that many crimes, Hashem Yishmor V'Yatzil, when do you have time to eat? But anyway, apparently, according to this, you had dozens of crimes with at least 22 victims that are confirmed and many more unconfirmed yet for years. No one's asked the simple question that I asked right away, Baruch Hashem. Number one, why did the Beit Din... the very same Beit Din that concluded what the conclusion is without having all of the halachically acceptable standards, why didn't that Beit Din that knew about this already for many years, why didn't you go to the cops? If you have a murderer in your community, murdering new women and children pretty much on a daily basis, and you know about this,
1:43:55And you don't do anything? You're a bigger criminal than him. How do you know about this? And you know about the victims for years, but you sat quietly like a little nothing for years. And suddenly you woke up two months ago when a liberal newspaper called you. about the community that you care so much about. How come you didn't say anything for so many years while he's murdering people, raping them, breaking marriages? A shemi small kind of criminal you're saying he is. Why didn't you send him to jail? Why didn't you kill him? Why didn't you do something? It doesn't make any sense. That's number one. Number two, this will connect with you young folks. Why? You young folks know how easy it is to have a camera. Today, everybody is a cameraman. Now, for anyone that says, "Yeah, but, you know, Israel, it's like a third world country," you're an idiot. Israel is the most technologically advanced place on planet Earth, even more than America. Even more than America. If there were that many crimes in hotels, in schools, and wherever, not a single footage was caught. Nothing. Nothing was caught. Nothing. You couldn't find a single piece of evidence that you could show the public. The only thing you can show us is a recording that his friends, family, and other people that knew him say it's not even his voice. No evidence, no pictures, nothing.
1:45:14in wherever, not a single footage was caught. Nothing. Nothing was caught. Nothing. You couldn't find a single piece of evidence that you could show the public. The only thing you can show us is a recording that his friends, family, and other people that knew him say it's not even his voice. No evidence, no pictures, nothing. if there was one woman or two, I would say okay, but you're saying there's dozens of women. None of the women have pictures they could put on Facebook? Nobody has a picture on their phone? Nobody has one of those little Kodak pictures that you buy at the store for five dollars? Nothing? Nobody has a picture of anything? How is that possible? Today, people, before they eat, take a picture of their food. How is there no picture with so many victims? The truth is, Rabotai, the whole case doesn't make any sense. The whole case doesn't make any sense.
1:46:43One of the other things that was brought up by one of the chachamim is that, first off, the technology part—the pictures—doesn't make any sense because anyone that deals with technology knows how easy it is to forge these types of recordings. Two, multiple people came up and said that the voice is not his. Three, even if a person comes forward... says himself, "I raped this woman." He's not believed immediately according to Halacha. Why? There are conditions to believing a person. The Gemara in Masechet Yevamot, page 25a, and also as Paskened by the Rambam in Hilchot Edut, chapter 12, Halacha number 2, says an adam nifsal l’averah al pi atzmo—a person is not... a proven, you know, canceled or in essence convicted of a sin based on his own words. Like he comes and says, I killed this one. Oh, I raped that one. Oh, I just committed adultery with this lady. So, why? I need witnesses. Two witnesses, to be exact.
1:48:06Two kosher witnesses. If one of those witnesses is an idol worshiper, a Mechalel Shabbat, you only have one witness. Testimony is garbage. If you're your own witness, needless to say, we can't believe you. Even if a woman comes and says to her husband, "I just cheated on you," he doesn't have to believe her. Why? That's the halacha. If he believes her, he has to divorce her. he doesn't have to believe him. Why? That's not because the Rambam says he's not convicted until he has two witnesses. Ask, why are there so many stories but there's no videos, no documented evidence? Where did all this happen? How come it took so many years to finally get to this point? One of the G'dolei HaDor that Baruch Hashem we were close to, Rav Gidon ben Moshe, says first and foremost, after the person dies, there's nothing to talk about. Whatever happened, happened. There's no way for us to know for sure. But, the Torah considers the actions of rape as murder.
1:49:36yet they all asked the same questions, including saying, "This doesn't make any sense." He says, "Never in history did a Beit Din conclude something without the accused being in the Beit Din. We're not a secular court; it doesn't work that way." He says, "The way that this Beit Din operated, never in history has such a thing happened." and these are people that are close to the issue. These are people that are dayanim, these are people that are experts. These are not just like, "Oh, he read some books and I like it. I follow the news." The Torah treats these types of crimes as the worst crimes, yet they are not jumping on the guilty train. not jumping on the guilty train. They're not accepting the article from Haaretz as legitimate evidence. Why? Because they have da'at Torah. What is da'at Torah? It is knowing how the rules work when you consider everything. We'll finish it off with this: most people say, "Da'at Torah? What's the difference between me and Rav Ovadia? What's the difference between me and the Rambam?" Well, we'll give you a little example.
1:51:03why their minds work this way and our minds work a different way. When you look at it yourself, you think, "Oh, okay, I could do this." The page 63a has a Mishnah, and the Mishnah says that there's a person that wants to marry this girl, and he says to her, "You are my wife on the condition that when I show you to my father, he's going to accept that you give me my life. But if he doesn't accept, then it retracts, and you're not my wife. Okay, that's the condition." says that there's a person who wants to marry this girl, and he says to her, "You are my wife on the condition that when I show you to my father, he will accept you, thereby affirming our marriage. But if he doesn't accept, then it retracts, and you're not my wife. Okay, that's the condition." says, "Okay, now let's go see my father." Now, at this moment, technically they're considered married, but if the father says no, then it's as if it never happened in the first place. If he says yes, then they were already married at that moment. So far, you got me? Okay, so now they get to the father and they find out the father is dead.
1:52:26dead, so you can't give the opinion. So, what happens? What's the conclusion? Conclusion number one says that since it was waiting for the opinion of the father, because he didn't want to upset the father, therefore, if his father is not alive anymore, she's considered his wife. Everything is good, as if the father approved it. Okay, option number two, what if... The son himself dies, the guy that's supposedly married to this girl on the way to the father. He died, and therefore the father never saw the girl while he was with him. He only saw the girl moments after the son died. So what happens to the girl? Is she married or not married? says to release her from all types of complications of the yibbum. What's good is to marry his brother and all types of issues. We teach him, meaning we influence the father to say, "No, no, no, I wouldn't have agreed anyway," and let her just go on her way, go on with her life, and not be stuck in this situation. And she's not mekudeshet.
1:53:39Okay, so in our heads, we can figure out that these are two logical options that can happen from this issue. Let's say we can think of a third option, which is he gets there and he says yes. He gets there and he says no. So already we have a little less than a handful of options. Let's say we're creative. We come up with another option. Somebody looks at this. I learned the topic. I learned the sugya. No, Habibi, you didn't. Why? If you go to the Shulchan Aruch. You go to the Shulchan Aruch. I'm sorry, you go to the Beit Yosef. The Beit Yosef by Rabbi Yosef Karo. Same Baal of the Shulchan Aruch. In the section of Kiddushin.
1:54:41Section of Kiddushin, he goes over this sugya and he gives 567 possibilities based on the words of the sages over the last thousand years. He gives 567 explanations. all of the different possibilities that were brought up by the sages with the reason of why this is yes and this is no and a final conclusion. Now, if Rabbi Yosef Karo went through 567 possibilities, you could go learn it, spend a month, two, three, four, five months, and learn all of these different possibilities. and I don't know, consider yourself as if you know this, uh, one assuming you understood what was going on. On the other hand, if you look at it from the right perspective, you'll know that if he thought of 567, needless to say, the sages before him also thought of them and even more.
1:56:05And the sages of the Gemara, they mentioned this in Masechet Kiddushin. Not only thought of those, but thought of many more. Hopefully, we got to five. Four we have. Hopefully, we can get to five. Rabbi Ovadia, one time, his son tells a story. They were learning Torah on Shabbat. They were learning the Chatam Sofer, because the Rav was writing one of his teshuvot, one of his responses in one of his sefarim. he went over the Chatam Sofer. He said they studied throughout the entire Shabbat, something like 17 hours. They were studying the writings of the Chatam Sofer, and the Rav had many, many, many insights, many things. So he got right into it and went to his book to write. So you'd figure he studied 17 hours of Torah. You had a bunch of different insights. What are you going to do? You're going to write a bunch of stuff. What does he write? Four words. This is what Chatam Sofer wrote. In English, it's five. Four words. So his son, Rabbi David Yosef says, "But Abba, you studied 17 hours. You had many chiddushim. Why don't you write some of them?"
1:57:31Nobody says for what? None of them are really changing anything. What? To show that I know something? If it's essentially the same thing as what he wrote, and it's not contradicting anything, it's not going to bring anything else, why do I need to write these extra words? 17 hours he studied straight for four words to put in his book. The average person is proud if they learned a lecture for an hour and a half. Rabbi, I think I need a bracha. Why? I think I deserve a bracha. Oh, why? Oh, I just watched your entire lecture straight. Two and a half hours, Rabbi. I watched it straight. Nope, nothing. I think I deserve a bracha now. I say to myself, yeah, yeah, probably give me a bracha. Give me a bracha. You watched the lecture for two and a half hours. study intensely for Torah for 17 hours just for the sake of four words. This is what the Chatam Sofer wrote if one were to review for 17 hours just for four words.
1:58:47and his son says there's something wrong with this beit din, there's something wrong with this judgment, there's something wrong with people who don't talk about it. And again, no, it's leading to these crimes, and HaKadosh Baruch Hu is saying there's something wrong. We're not, we're not, we're not doing something good. What does it mean? It means the further we are from Daas Torah the further we are from where we would want to be for ourselves. Rabbi Ephraim wrote about this particular issue. He says there are two possibilities: guilty or not guilty, about this Chaim Walder. If he did it, page 13b, says we learned from that no one is above the immorality; if you don't watch your eyes, you don't protect your brit, you'll fall. If he didn't do it, then it's lashon hara.
2:00:09kills, as the Midrash Tanchuma in Parashat Metzora says. If he did it, Hashem brings down the proud. If he didn't do it, if he didn't do it, David HaMelech says in Tehillim 101, a person that says lies, Hashem doesn't even want to look at them. If he did it, Pirkei Avot, Chapter 4, Mishnah 21, says that jealousy, desire, and seeking honor are what take a person out of the world. If he didn't do it... Hushabha sharing look after the Google look at the Google if he didn't do it and they blame him and the Gemara in Masechet Shabbat page 97 says a person that suspects kosher people is bringing damage to his own body, his own life is in danger. If he did it, mechalei Shem Shamayim be'seter, mefarsemim oto bagalui. If he did it, someone who desecrates Hashem's name behind the scenes, the punishment is in public.
2:01:33This is in Pirkei Avot, chapter 4. If he didn't do it, yadino shefchu et adam hazeh. If he didn't do it, the book of Deuteronomy, chapter 21, says, our hands spilled his blood. If he did it, haba al eshet ish mitato b'chenek, v'yesh lo chelek le'olam haba. did it, page 107 says someone that is an adulterer, his death is by strangulation, but he still has a share in the World to Come. If he didn't do it, if he didn't do it, that same Gemara, that same page, says someone that embarrasses his fellow in public has no share in the World to Come. If he did it, page 107 says someone that is an adulterer, his death is by strangulation, but he still has a share in the World to Come. If he didn't do it, if he didn't do it, that same Gemara, that same page, says someone that embarrasses his fellow in public has no share in the World to Come. Didn't do it, Hashem will take vengeance for him, so a person that's smart, if they can't connect to what Daas Torah is, will do whatever they possibly can to help themselves reach Daas Torah, but in the meantime, say nothing, not good, not bad. Why? If you're not saying what Daas Torah is.
2:02:58didn't do it, Hashem will take vengeance for him. So, a person that's smart, if they can't connect to what Daas Torah is, will do whatever they possibly can to help themselves reach Daas Torah. But in the meantime, say nothing, not good, not bad. Why? If you're not saying what Daas Torah is. bringing a tragedy to yourself, why? For what? You're not going to benefit from it. But this is just a couple of examples of how Daas Torah operates differently than a traditional person does. Just because someone is smart, just because somebody knows a lot of Torah, doesn't always mean that they make the right decisions. It doesn't always mean that they have Daas Torah. Sometimes our emotions... sometimes our perception, sometimes different things motivate us to think. That's why we had to go to mamash serious giants in the world of Torah to confirm, and we got the same exact words, one after another, the same conclusion. And that's why you have the books; you can keep them. There's really no reason not to, and...
2:04:24again, we will never know what exactly happened, but according to the Torah, we cannot suspect that something did happen because there isn't enough evidence to do so. Anyone that does is making a very, very dear mistake and a prohibition according to the Torah. With that being said, we'll take some questions. I know I went on for a while, but okay...
2:05:35Okay, let's get the... All right. A lot of Yetzer Hara in today's lecture with the cameras. All right, let's see, questions we have. Jonah, how do you explain the purpose of the mitzvah to someone who doesn't know much, like a little kid? Are they for Hashem or are they for us? What is the significance in the broader scheme of things? Okay, very good. So the person needs to know that Hashem doesn't need anything. He's the Almighty. He doesn't benefit from us; He doesn't need us. He existed before us, and He will exist after us. We cannot add to Him; we cannot subtract from Him. Anytime we say, "Oh, God was upset, God was angry, God was hurt," these are not real statements that actually happen, but rather something to make somebody understand the consequence of their actions, to make it easier for our ear to understand. Because in reality, our mitzvot, our actions, are to add to ourselves. Our sins are hurting ourselves. "Eichser" means something is missing.
2:06:53we're missing. We're taking something away from ourselves. Now, this goes back to why there are mitzvot in the first place. When Hashem first created the souls, the souls lived in something like a heaven. They had everything that they needed; they were not lacking anything. But since Hashem, He's the ultimate good, and good is defined by creating good, you can't say, "I'm good." all you do is bad if all you do is selfish. So, Hashem created because He's good; He wanted to create good. But when He created us, He created, originally, the neshamot. The neshamot had a similar trait to Him, where they were also good. but they cannot be good without doing good. And since Hashem doesn't need anything, they couldn't do any good. So they suffered as a result of the good that they got because they couldn't do good to reciprocate.
2:07:56So, in essence, the souls asked Hashem for a way for them to earn this reward, to earn this good that He's giving them. Therefore, Hashem, in essence, created this world, and He says: "Over here, you'll go and you'll have a test, and if you pass the test, then you'll get a reward which, in essence, will justify the good that you'll get eternally." so all of the mitzvot that we have in this world are ways for us to not only serve Hashem, do the will of the King, but also to fulfill our obligation for our own journey to get closer to Hashem. With each mitzvah, we get closer to Hashem. This is, for example, like a video game. Each time you complete a chapter, you get closer to the main goal. And each time you get another apple, another banana, or another coin, you get a little bit closer to the destination you want.
2:08:58same concept with mitzvot. Each mitzvah gets you closer to the Creator but, at the same time, also has an immediate benefit to you—sometimes that you see, sometimes that you don't see. So the mitzvot are ways for us to do multiple things in order to fulfill our purpose in the world but also to get closer to Hashem. get closer to Hashem and they're all for us. They're not for God. The Torah that we learn is for ourselves, the mitzvot that we do are for ourselves. All we do is for ourselves. not for Him. He is happy when His children, His creations, are doing His will because the whole purpose of creating us was for us to get good. But since He has rules, He has rules for Himself too, which means that He cannot give us good unless we did good. As a final judgment in this world, Hashem has mercy and He can sometimes give a person good even if the person is bad at this point.
2:10:01but in the eternal world, there is no mercy. There is just judgment. If you did good, you will get good; if you did bad, you will get bad. This means that all of the good, all of the mitzvot that a person did, will be rewarded in an eternal world where there is only judgment. Meaning This is the, uh, there is no mercy, there's no teshuva, there's no fixing things. It’s not like, "Let me get another try." None of that stuff. Once a person gets to that final destination, all of the good that they did—they see how they did all of it for themselves. And all of the sins they did, they unfortunately hurt themselves with them. God stays the same one way or the other. He rewards you because now that you have done what you were supposed to do, you're going to get the reward that you were supposed to get. He punishes you because your sins are restricting Him from giving you the good that He wants to give you because that's why He created you.
2:11:11He's not punishing you because you're hurting Him and lessening Him in any way. He's punishing you for sins because you are, in essence, restricting Him because of His own rules from giving you the good that He created you to give, for the whole purpose is to give you the good. Now you're going to say, okay, so you can just give me the good without me doing good. No, then it would turn the entire Torah into a lie. He can't give you good and give somebody else bad; that would make the whole Torah a lie, and the signature of God is truth, emet. so the point being is, is that when we do mitzvot, when we learn Torah, when we are, uh, uh, praying, all of those things get us closer to God and also serve God. You serve the King, and the more a person dedicates themselves, the more they're going to feel both a spiritual and a physical connection. the less a person does, the more numb they become to both physical and spiritual connections to God, to the point where they can become a person that doesn't care about God's existence so much that they simply stop believing in Him, at least publicly. So, it's important for a person to know what is the purpose of the mitzvot. And again, like I said, the mitzvot are for yourself; they're not for God.
2:12:38To say that anything is for God is actually heretical. That's what Manis the Menace does. He says that God needs us. That's a heretical statement; such a statement at the time of the Sanhedrin would bring a person the death penalty. Because to say God needs something would mean that God is limited. And the reason why many people want to limit God is because they have such big arrogance that they want to compare God to themselves. They figure since they are limited, certainly God is limited. And unfortunately, you see, the result is that people think, "Oh, it's so nice that God needs us. I like that kind of God that needs me. I like to be needed." And people, in essence, humanize God, not like a regular human even. They make Him into someone that's less than them. these are very sick people, these are spiritually sick people. The fans of Manis Friedman are very, very sick people spiritually—some of the sickest people on the planet. You hear some of the garbage they say; it's even worse to a certain extent than what Manis himself says. Horrible, horrible statements, but what can you do?
2:13:58uh let's see, Louis is asking if a Jew can serve or offer kosher food to a non-Jew if that person is not going to pray before and after eating. Uh, yeah, sure, he can. The non-Jew is not obligated to pray for food; they should pray, but they're not obligated to pray. Only Jews are obligated. Charlie, uh, when doing the Amidah during Shacharit... it has to be completed by midday or just started by that time. Also, about Shabbat concerning Musaf, please clarify. Ah, okay, so as far as the Amidah, when you see that there are times, let's say the earliest time to say the Amidah, or this is the latest time... you can say the Amidah so that the latest time you have to be already closer to the middle of the Amidah, not the beginning and not the end, but closer to the middle of it, meaning that you already
2:15:06immersed in the prayer in the beginning, many times we're not a hundred percent immersed, even though we're supposed to have the most amount of kavana during the first three blessings of the Amidah. So much so that I believe it was the Mishnah that says that if you don't have full kavana during the first three blessings of the Amidah, you should do the whole thing all over again. that's how extraordinary it is, but nonetheless, it's important to have kavana during prayer. As far as the timing is concerned, you have to be closer to the middle of the Amidah. Now, even if you are not at the middle... you still continue; you don't stop because if you're gonna pray late, then you say if this is still on time, then it'll serve as the prayer. Whatever it is, and if it's not, then it's going to be a gift prayer. Meaning, it's still going to be a valid prayer, but it's going to be a gift prayer. It won't serve for that particular purpose, but since you already started, you still continue; you don't stop.
2:16:18It'll be a gift prayer. Also, if you can't pray for a reason that is beyond your control, that means you're an anus, which means you can make up for that prayer. Let's say you missed the shacharit prayer for something beyond your control, such as medical reasons—not because you were just lazy, but real, legitimate reasons that were beyond your control—you can make up for that lost prayer. In mincha, you do two amidot, one after another. One would make up the Amidah for Shacharit. The first Amidah is for the prayer that you're currently doing, and the second Amidah is to make up the missed prayer. During the time when you do makeup prayers, think in your mind that this is the makeup prayer. If Hashem accepts it, this will make up for what I lost. If He doesn't, then this will be like a gift prayer. a gift sacrifice, so it is still nonetheless accepted. Now, when it comes to Musaf, Musaf can be said as long as it's daylight. There's no specific time to say Musaf; it's as long as there is daylight. That's the ...
2:17:30general opinion. The first Amidah has limitations in specific times of when you have to say it by. But Musaf can be said later on. Usually, what happens if you're in shul, what they do in shul is they pray the first Amidah. then the rabbis typically give a lecture, you know, for half an hour, an hour, whatever it is, and then they do the Musaf. So they wait a while between the two, not because there's really a need to wait between the two, but rather because you have a while, and they try to take advantage of the fact that people are in shul, so they want to give them some Torah. in between the prayers. But if you're praying on your own, for example, you could do it right away or you could do it later. I would recommend always doing it right away and not trying to spread them out too far apart because you'll end up either forgetting it. Also, now you have to figure out a whole new thing about how to complete the blessing because without the Musaf...
2:18:34point is, don't make things too complicated. Just, you know, pray them in order and you'll be fine. But I still taught you what I just said for the sake of knowledge. Um, we need b'ezrat Hashem yeshiva now, yes, you're right, Michael, we do, we do. There's other shiurim we do. Reuven, uh, in regards to the brit milah question, in places like Florida where it's very hot, is it sufficient to turn off the water heater breaker fuse to take showers on Shabbat? not following, oh, mazal tov, I didn't see the orange things without the blue to be lower. Okay, I missed those two words. Thank you very much. Uh, as far as taking showers on Shabbat, no, you're not allowed to take showers on Shabbat. Now, they've been, uh, poskim on Shabbat not to wash your whole body on Shabbat. You're allowed to wash your arms. You're allowed to wash your face. You're allowed to wash with cold water individual parts if it's absolutely necessary. And you have to be very, very careful not to rip hairs.
2:19:36Long story short, you really should stay away from it other than just washing your face for hygienic reasons. There's really no reason why a person should take a shower on Shabbat. But if someone needs to clean something or anything like that, then again, a shower is not allowed. A bath is not allowed. But you're allowed to wash individual parts with cold water. Zero, zero heat on it. like I said, that's only parts, like you're just washing, I don't know, just your arm or two arms. That's it. You can't do a whole thing on the body. That's not allowed, not with cold water and needless to say, not with hot water. Uh, Misha is asking whatever happened with Moshe's children. There isn't much about what happened to his children's lineage, unlike Aharon's, because Moshe had two children. Um... and, uh, some say that, uh, you know, initially they were both okay, but some say that, uh, one of them became an idolater for a while
2:20:42before, I guess, he did teshuva, and they didn't amount to be as great as Aharon's children for different reasons, which is a shiur for itself. There was also a promise that Moshe Rabbeinu made to Yitro before Yitro did teshuva that kind of put like a... evil decree on the kids to a certain extent. But that's a complicated sugya that I'll reserve for another day. But one thing that I remember reading years ago is that there was a promise made to Moshe that this kid Eliezer and Gershom will be okay eventually, and Eliezer will bring great light. And when did this happen? It happened with Eliezer ben Hyrcanus, who was apparently either a reincarnation or an actual direct lineage to Moshe Rabbeinu. He taught us at such a high level that his face shone like Moshe Rabbeinu's face shone on Mount Sinai. was a promise made to Moshe that this kid Eliezer and Gershom will be okay eventually, and Eliezer will bring great light. And when did this happen? It happened with Eliezer ben Hyrcanus, who was apparently either a reincarnation or an actual direct lineage to Moshe Rabbeinu. He taught us at such a high level that his face shone like Moshe Rabbeinu's face shone on Mount Sinai.
2:21:53was the rabbi of Rabbi Akiva. Yose is asking, with all the lashon hara, why tzara'at has not reappeared in the world, so that might have manifested into another sickness. Uh, no, tzara'at is actually still in the world; it has different forms. Uh, there's different types. First of all, there's also a purely spiritual tzara'at, which is a pain of the neshama, not a pain of the actual body. May you never know what that feels like. It's worse than any pain you can imagine. It's pretty much that there's nothing wrong with your body, but you're in massive pain. And there's nothing you can do about it. It disables you. It debilitates you. It feels like you're on fire. um, it's uh something that you, I mean, you could very easily picture. Again, I'm looking like this, um, I mean, I could give you more details probably for about five hours about this, but the point is that, yes, it does exist. There's also a physical aspect, and there's actually no cure for it, so the people that have it go to a special hospital. There's one, I believe, in Israel; I think it's in Yerushalayim.
2:23:19where they have these people, and some of them you cannot visit because it's an incurable sickness and it's extremely contagious. So, yes, it does exist. It's not to the same capacity as in the past, but nonetheless, it does exist. Alex, Sammy, the Mishnah does not ask for money. Okay, so go to Sammy. Fine. Go to Sammy. Jack, those tenants from hell I told you about yesterday, they left me in the crawl space tons of garbage as well. I don't understand how it's lashon hara. If everyone knows that they are hoarders, Rambam said if three people know about something, they're allowed to discuss it with They're allowed to discuss it. Only you can't further the talk. But as well, maybe people should not rent to Chazerim. I'm saving people a headache.
2:24:30You're not the... You're not saving people a headache. You're creating a headache for yourself. If they're doing something wrong, Hashem will deal with them. Hashem will deal with them. You don't need to... You don't need to publicize it for them. It is lashon hara. It is lashon hara. I mean, it's a... If somebody comes to you and let's say they damage your property and you got a din Torah... confirmed that you're right and they're wrong because remember I told you that you have to get a din Torah, and the din Torah confirmed what you're saying. And either you won and they don't want to pay, or you won and they paid. But nonetheless, they're not changing, they're not doing teshuvah. continue to do it. You have proof that they continue their behavior, and somebody asked you, "Should I rent to these people?" You could tell them that there is an issue here; these people could damage your property, and to take that into consideration. But to just go out there and publicize to the world that these people did this thing to you, there is no benefit for you to do that because you're saying you're saving people a headache, but most people that you're telling it to are not renting them any property.
2:25:49so it's not really relevant for them to know that these people are bad. They're not benefiting from that information; they're getting hurt. You're hurting those people that you're telling because they're going to believe you. You're hurting yourself, and you're hurting the people that you're speaking about, and it's not helping anybody. It's not like someone who's about to rent to them is asking you. If that's the case, then there's an issue; then there's a potential... a more room for you to speak because if you're saving somebody, but to and again, you have to get da'at Torah for that. You can't just assume that you're okay to speak about and pretty much follow these people for the rest of their lives from house to house just to see if they ruined houses like they ruined yours. I would recommend just letting it go because there's nothing good that's going to come out of it. nothing good. Even if they're bad people as you're saying, there's still no permission to talk about them because the people you're talking to have no benefit from it. They’re not renting them any house; you’re not really saving them any headache. It’s just that there’s a little, you know, sometimes it’s pleasurable to say bad things about people because
2:27:02you know, it's almost like commiserating. You tell people about your troubles, they tell you about their troubles, and people, you know, feel better as a result of spilling their guts out. The problem is that it's a sin, so you can't do it. By the way, Chaim Walder only admitted he was cheating on his wife but said adamantly he never slept with kids and killed himself. What a tragedy. Yeah, I mean, it's a, you know, as far as everything that was said, again, it's way that they judged it from the beginning was a tragedy and the way it ended is a tragedy. David is asking if it is okay to have goals and ambitions in the business world in order to serve Hashem more. If so, why is it sometimes difficult to achieve those goals? Is there a reason for it? As far as in business and in Torah, it's not only okay to have goals and ambitions, it's a must. Anyone who wants to succeed in anything in life has to have goals and ambitions. A person who does not have goals and ambitions has already decided they're going to fail.
2:28:18as far as reaching their full potential. They may succeed to a certain extent, but they will fail in reaching their full potential. You have to have goals. You have to have ambitions because those ambitions, those goals, number one, help you stay focused. Number two, they're motivating. Uh, number three, they're simply necessary for other people that want to see whether they want to join your journey or not. They need to know where you want to go, what's your vision like. You need to know where you want to go in order to get there. So having goals and ambitions for business is important. Same thing with Torah. You have to have goals. You have to say, okay, I'm going to learn this masechet and I'm going to finish it in X amount of time. ...and do your best to finish it within the next set amount of time. If you simply say, "I'll just read, and whenever I finish, I'll finish," it's not good. Why? Because you could very easily fall into the trap of thinking that you're learning, but you're learning so slowly, so passively, and so nonchalantly that you're stuck on the same book for three years.
2:29:28even though you should have finished it in three weeks. A lot of times, people fool themselves into thinking that they're actually studying Torah because they watch a lot of shiurim and figure, "Oh yeah, look, I study six to ten hours a day because I watch videos now." it's good to watch videos if it's a high-end speaker who's telling you the full truth and so on. It's very, very good to listen to videos. But assuming you remember what the video said, assuming you're actually applying that to your life, assuming that if I ask you, "What did the video say?" you can give me some answers. the problem is that most people listen to videos in such a superficial manner that if you ask them literally one minute after the video is completed, "So, what did the Rabbi say?" they'll look at you and say, "I don't know, he said Torah." But what did he say? "Stuff." What's stuff? "I don't know, something."
2:30:28that's it, that's two hours. You're listening to it. Was it good? That was amazing. What was amazing? They don't know. So again, you have to have ambitions in order to run away from that where, oh, I'm gonna learn... these two hours I'm going to learn a shiur Torah, I'm going to learn a book, whatever it is they're going to learn, but I'm going to achieve something out of it. I'm going to try to get one new idea, one new thing to apply to my life. It has to have ambition; you have to have a goal. This is very, very necessary. As far as achieving the goals, it all depends on if you're aligning those goals with where you stand, and what you know, and what your capabilities are currently or what your capabilities will be in the future after you've met a bunch of goals. Meaning, if let's say, for example, somebody says, "I want to be a billionaire." That's a fantastic goal, but if all you have in the bank is fifty dollars, that goal is stupid. it's stupid. Why? It's a useless goal to say you want to be a billionaire when all you have is a few dollars to buy yourself maybe some ice cream and a sandwich. That's all you have. So you have to first and foremost get to that first million. Once you have that first million, then you usually have a way to make more. But until you have that first million...
2:31:54Talking about millions and 10 million and so on is delusional thinking and hence the reason why many times people fool themselves into thinking that they're going to get to be a billionaire by doing big deals. What do they do? They simply focus all their attention on fantasy deals. "Oh yeah, I'm gonna call my friend." "Where’s your friend?" "He's in Egypt." "Okay, why is your friend in Egypt?" "Oh, he has family there." "Okay, so what do you need from your friend? Why are you talking about your friend?" "Oh, because my friend is connected to some guy in Saudi Arabia, and I think that I can get some oil from Saudi Arabia to my friend that's in Egypt, and I can get it for probably like, you know, $25 a barrel." simply focus all their attention on fantasy deals. "Oh yeah, I'm gonna call my friend." "Where's your friend?" "He's in Egypt." "Okay, why is your friend in Egypt?" "Oh, he has family there." "Okay, so what do you need from your friend? Why are you talking about your friend?" "Oh, because my friend is connected to some guy in Saudi Arabia, and I think that I can get some oil from Saudi Arabia to my friend that's in Egypt, and I can get it for probably like, you know, $25 a barrel." ...can sell it over here for at least $70. That's what the market is, and I could probably get stuff on credit. They have all these delusions in their mind of how they're going to make this. And you're going to say, "I don't think it's possible." "No, no, forget about possible. Look, if I can get...
2:32:53Hundred million dollars in barrels. All I gotta do is just sell it for one percent more, and I already got a million dollars. One percent more, I got a million dollars. Two percent, two million dollars. Three percent, four million. And they start working on a calculator of how if they sell this huge amount of goods for one percent more, two percent less, all the things they do, all these calculations of all this fake money they're going to make. You know what happens in the end? Nothing. nothing, nothing, nothing. Why? Because they're too busy chasing a fantasy. If anybody wants to learn how to make money, I know how to make money. I promise you, I know how to make money. I've been working since I was 10 years old, made a fortune, made tons and tons of money in all types of businesses, and I can tell you for sure, for sure, all of those people that chased big deals only, generally speaking, never amount to anything. never amount to anything. Guys that go into the real estate business say, "Oh, I'm gonna focus on buildings. How about a house? No, no, no, forget houses. That's not for me. I'm gonna do buildings." He wants to sell a 50, 100, 200 million dollar building. You know what's gonna happen with that kid? He's gonna find a new job at McDonald's. That's what's gonna happen to him.
2:34:07A broker coming into the brokerage business says, "Oh, I want to only deal with clients with $10 million or more." You know what's going to happen with that kid? He's going to work maybe for S&P making reports for $60,000 a year. He's never going to get anything. Why? Because it's not reality. You know how you make money? Grind. Grind is how you make money. You figure out a way to make a little bit of money every day, just enough to survive and give you time to get these big deals. First and most important is to build the grind. That first million is made by the grind. It's not made by the big deals. And generally speaking, the grind is really what makes you the billionaire and the trillionaire and all that other stuff. The big deals, that just take you another leap. But that type of stuff is something that happens along the way. Not for people that focus on big deals. People that focus on big deals never make money. Never. I've never seen it actually work out. I like to say that maybe it worked out for somebody because I don't know, I guess it did. But I've never met anybody. I've met a lot of people in my life, a lot of people that were very, very wealthy. Never met anybody that made those big deals happen. I've met people that are extremely successful, that they made those deals happen, but that's already after they were successful. But somebody that was pretty much just trying to figure out what to do with their life and made these big deals happen, it's always a figment of their imagination. I used to have a kid work for me.
2:35:37He used to chase these deals on his own. Every time he would give me, "Oh, listen, you know, I got this diamond. It's in Nigeria. It's 167 carats. The guy sent me the report," and he gives me all these papers of this... You know, phantom diamond, that's 167 carats, or one time it was like 400 carats, and all these crazy deals that are really worth like $400 million, but you can get it for 10 or 5 or $2. It's all fake. Many times it's scams, other times it's fantasy. Even if you actually have a chance of getting the deal, somebody will steal it from you. It's just, it's just, it's a fantasy for most people. Generally speaking, the rich get richer because they have access to those deals. The people are trying to make it. If you want to become rich, you have to grind. To make the grind succeed, you have to make daily goals, monthly goals, and annual goals, but not spend all your day just charting goals and making to-do lists, because then you won't have time to work. You should have a general plan.
2:36:47every single day of what you're gonna do. Unfortunately, many times, especially in this generation, people just live freely. They have no actual plan unless you tell them what to do. They simply do nothing. They're like, I don't know, like a vacuum cleaner. Unless you turn the vacuum cleaner on, it doesn't do anything. People have turned into vacuum cleaners. They simply, like, unless you give them clear instructions, they just sit there. And like, what are you doing for a week? I don't wait for you to tell me what to do. Wait, so you actually want me to pay you a week's salary for you doing nothing? What do you mean? What's wrong with it? I was waiting for you. It's your fault. You should have told me what to do. A person like that is a tragedy, but unfortunately, many of them exist. If you fire every one of them, you're never going to have employees. Why? Because that's the generation we're dealing with. In the previous generation, my generation, the generation before me, we didn't need people to tell us what to do. You know what we did? We figured out what to do. we woke up and we figured out stuff to do. That's the generation. The generation today, unless you, like, type a text message telling them exactly what to do, how many times to chew, how many times to swallow, how many times to pick up their hand and say hello, when to this, when to that, most times they don't know what to do.
2:38:02so you could have an employee on your hands that literally sits in an office, sits in a cubicle, sits wherever they're sitting for a week, two weeks, two months straight without doing a single thing. And unless you pay attention to them, they're simply just sitting there doing nothing, and they don't think there's anything wrong with it. Why? They figure it's your fault; you should have told them what to do. told him what to do. Why? That's a person that he's an employee for a reason. You know why he's an employee? Because he doesn't make goals. The people that become managers, supervisors, bosses, entrepreneurs, business owners, and so on, those people make stuff happen. They're typically the best employees in the world, hard to keep, and they're a big headache. they're very spoiled, but you have an option. Either you have a "rainmaker" — that's a go-getter that has goals, that he himself or she herself wants to get better. It's not just because of you, it's not just because she wants to make more money; they simply want to get better. There's those, and then there's the rest.
2:39:05The rest, generally speaking, are like vacuum cleaners; unless you press the button, they're not going to do anything. But you need them too. Why? Because there's a certain price for those people that's usually less than the other guy. Usually, if you know how to manage, you could get them to do a lot of good things that the other guy is not willing to do. so again, everybody has a place. There are sheep, there are shepherds, and so on. But if a person themselves wants to succeed in life, they have to know that they have to grind. Grind meaning every day you have to have a plan. This is what I'm gonna do; this is how I'm gonna make money today. Forget about the big idea of making a billion, zillion, trillion dollars before you have a dollar. Forget about all that stuff. How am I going to make $100, $200, $500? How am I going to make something? A lot of guys want to make a lot of money quickly because they figure that if I make $10,000, $20,000, $30,000, $50,000, $100,000, $200,000 quickly, then I could flip that $100,000 and then before you know it, Bill Gates is working for me. I used to think like that too. Then I realized I'm stupid and I went back to work. And that only took me about an hour or so to figure out, but other people usually spend maybe 10, 20 years to figure stuff like that out.
2:40:19and they live in this fantasy where they think that they're going to, uh, take this money and flip it. "Oh, I'm gonna buy this, and every day I'll make twenty percent of my money in some penny stock or some Bitcoin or some other nonsense invention, and I'll do that every day. Every week I'll make twenty percent." Before you know it, they do the calculations. They love playing with calculators do the calculations of how this, you know, accumulates to becoming 10 trillion dollars. Or people do the calculations: what if you double a penny every day? Rationally speaking, it seems like a very simple idea. In reality, if you think this is even possible—why? If you double a penny every single day for 30 days, you now have over five million dollars. You're not getting five million dollars. ...in 30 days, it's just not happening. Why? Because you can't double your money every day; it's just not possible. If you double your money every seven years, you're already a success. But people have this imagination. Where? What do you mean? "Look, I did it for a week straight; I doubled my money." Okay, buddy, let's see you on day 25.
2:41:27So again, it's important for a person to be realistic. Realistic, not pessimistic. Realistic. Realistic also requires optimism. Realistic also requires ambition. Realistic also requires goals. But most importantly, realistic requires a plan. Plan. What's a plan? Not a grand plan of conquering the world. A plan is, what do I do after I wake up? After I pray, after I learn a little bit, after I serve my Creator, what am I going to do? How am I going to get food to eat? How am I going to feed my kids? If I'm single, how am I going to feed myself? How am I going to pay rent? How do I do these things? people are very, very lazy, and unfortunately, this creates a major problem in the Torah world when those very same lazy people are introduced to opportunities that are forbidden according to the Torah, like a cash advance business that tells them, "Listen, you don't need any skills, you don't need any real effort, you don't need really anything other than pretty much just...
2:42:40promising people a bunch of things that you can't deliver on, and "we'll pay you commission; you'll be able to make 10, 20, 30,000 dollars a month without any skills, without anything." Oh, the price for it? Your Olam HaBa. But they're not going to tell you that. I am. You see, these types of scams... ...a perfect tool of the Satan for this generation of lazy, unrealistic, YouTube, TikTok rich people, where people see the celebrities, they see how they made, I don't know, a million and a half dollars making YouTube videos, $10 million making some app, and all types of other strange things. These are delusions. These are not normal things. You cannot compare yourself to a professional athlete. You cannot compare yourself to some guy that has 500 million likes on YouTube or Facebook. These are exceptions. Out of 8 billion people, it's not even 1% of 1% of people who are like these people. Don't compare yourself to those people. Compare yourself to the best you can be. And if you do that, you'll have a much better chance of actually succeeding in anything, including becoming one of these really, really, really rich people.
2:43:53But the key is that people try to get to that finish line without the grind, without really working hard. They already want to say, oh, listen, he made it in 10 years, but since I'm learning from him, I can do it in two years. Okay, buddy, good luck with that one. But when you wake up out of that dream, let me know. not realistic, but unfortunately, people want to think. Last but not least, when you ask people about their ambitions for money, everybody is convinced they are the next millionaire, trillionaire, or billionaire. They're going to be on TV, the whole world is going to know about them, and they're going to donate billions. ask him, "Do you think you're going to become a rabbi? No. Do you think you'll even know the entire Torah by heart? No. Perhaps you'll know your parasha for your bar mitzvah by heart? The whole thing? No. No ambition whatsoever when it comes to mitzvot. No ambition whatsoever when it comes to Torah. Nothing but money. Everything in the world. In reality, it's supposed to be the opposite."
2:44:59It's supposed to be the opposite. Money is gifted to you by God. Torah you earn, Torah you earn. But that's the thing—a generation of lazy people, both spiritually and physically lazy people, creates such a system where crime becomes standard. So all of these get-rich-quick schemes are running rampant. These fake gurus who sell you a $3,000 course that they themselves did not even invent and copied from somebody else are running rampant. People are buying them like it's free. They're borrowing money from credit cards just to buy some course because they figure if I buy this $3,000 course or this $2,000 worth of diet powder or this $5,000 worth of, I don't know, some seminar full of a bunch of people that are also broke, then I'll be rich. They take a bunch of loans and borrow a bunch of money they can't pay back, which is a sin from the Torah. What ends up happening is nothing. They end up being more broke, in a bigger hole than they originally started.
2:46:01why? Because there is no "get rich quick"; it doesn't exist. You want to get rich? Grind. You want to succeed? Grind. You want to survive? Grind. They all require the same thing. Why? Because wealth is decreed by God. grind you up. It's up to you whether you're going to do something to grind; that's up to you. But that's the thing: people want to do a lot of things very, very quickly, and that ends up happening where they end up falling into the trap of either some type of crime where they end up becoming the criminal, like a cash advance business, or they sell used goods or stolen goods, or some type of fraudulent type of business. There's no shortage of fraudulent businesses. they'll go into some investment firm without really caring about the fact that the investments are fake. Really, all the money that they're getting from people, including their family and friends, is simply lining their own pockets. They're buying vacations with it, and it's just a big Ponzi scheme. Unfortunately, many of these are happening every single day. New ones are exposed, where people are stealing from their family, stealing from their friends, and
2:47:11and the name of success. In the name of success, there are people that fall victim to other crimes where they figure that this guy called them out of the blue. "Oh, it must be a miracle! Maybe Hashem is sending me this guy that's going to give me the bracha. Rabbi, wow, what is he selling you?" "He's selling me the scroll that came from Timbuktu in Zimbabwe and in this Pikachu and Ukachu." and this scroll really is worth five million dollars, but he's giving me a really good deal. How much? $1500. Rabbi, I'm good at business, right? I'm good at business, right? Okay, I'll say kaddish on you soon. Hopefully, you know how to put your pants on better than you know how to do business. Why? It doesn't exist. It doesn't exist, but you think that's going to help him? No, he's still going to buy still going to buy the fifteen-hundred-dollar scroll or rock or whatever strange thing that somebody's selling him online because he's an idiot and he thinks that he's going to be rich by giving this scammer fifteen hundred dollars from some country he's never heard of. Why? Because he's lazy and he's a criminal. It's a perfect match. And that is the economic system you have.
2:48:26the economic system you have. You want an economic report? You don't need to go to CNBC anymore. You come to the shiur and you ask me a question like this, and if you get me, like, you know, you get me riled up enough, I'll give you an answer like this. I've seen a lot, I've done a lot, and I can promise you everything. If I knew as much Torah as I know about business, oh, how great that would be. all right, Rabotai, it's two and a half hours already we've been going, and we have to get ready for the next shiur. Okay, let's maybe I'll answer one or two more questions. Let's see. All right, Jeremy, unrelated to this week's parsha, does that make him a Kohen? Okay, okay. Did Nadav and Avihu come back? As, uh, Nadav and Avihu came back as... I don't remember. I have to look at Chacham Ovadia, I don't remember people's reincarnations. No, there's not enough... um... Daniel, that's this lecture. All right, for Brennan to listen to, if you're listening to it up till now, then the answer is yes. If you're not listening to it up till now, then the answer is yes.
2:49:47Uh, David, questions are on Wednesday, okay? Yeah, that's not for me. Okay, uh, okay, I said no. Do I do teshuva if I see immodest women pictures on Facebook while searching for a wife? Do I do teshuva for seeing immodest women? I don't know why you're looking for a wife on the Internet. I mean, it's not usually a good place to find a wife. You don't find wives on the Internet. Usually, you find wives, you know, referred to you by somebody that you know, or you meet them at work or something like that. Finding a wife on the Internet is just as likely as finding millions of dollars lying around in the street. it's generally not going to happen, you know. The stories of finding wives and husbands on the Internet are stories of lust, not love. I don't recommend it. But either way, as far as protecting your eyes, protecting your eyes is not a formal obligation on the Noahides. but protecting your brit means that you're not allowed to waste seed. Generally speaking, if you see immodest women, you're eventually going to waste seed. So, it may not lead to a sin immediately, but it will lead to a sin eventually, and that's something you want to try to avoid as much as possible. Yonah, what's the purpose of the resurrection of the dead? Isn't the primary reward for being righteous Olam HaBa?
2:51:05yes, there are multiple levels of reward. There is this world, where a person could have the merit to go to heaven. But then there's Olam HaBa. Olam HaBa and heaven are two different places. But then there's also a separate merit, which is to live at the time of Mashiach and survive. And then there is a merit where you live in this world... uh, you get resurrected, the righteous get resurrected, so there's different levels of reward. The final, final, final reward is Olam HaBa. The final reward is Olam HaBa, but that's after other multiple levels of reward come beforehand. One main thing that is going to happen in this physical world is that after Mashiach comes and there's the war of Gog U'Magog, major destruction... uh, annihilation of the enemy, all the heretics, all the atheists, all the idol worshippers, all the bad people, and anyone who didn't do teshuva.
2:52:08So now, after that, there's going to be the days of Mashiach, which is after they bury the bodies of all the dead people. I believe it's going to take seven years to bury the bodies. The world will start reconstructing itself in a way where you're still going to have certain traditional things function in the world, but there will not be an evil inclination. ...and the world will continue until the end of the sixth, the 6000, meaning until the year 7000. We are now in 5782, so you have a little over a thousand years left. That's only the last part, the last thousand years, only for the most righteous people. During that time, there's going to be a resurrection of the dead. Some people say it's going to be... 40 years after Mashiach comes, there'll be a resurrection of the dead. Some say we're not going to know until it happens, but there will definitely be a resurrection of the dead. Either way, living in the world at the time of Mashiach for that last thousand years is a certain level of reward. That's still this physical world. After that's done, then there is a spiritual world. There's the Olam HaBa, and there's even more than that.
2:53:30Point being is that Hashem's reward has no limitations, nothing that He does has limitations. Is there a specific area where the Beit HaMidrash will be located? Not yet. Once I have an actual location, I'll tell you guys, but I don't know yet. Unfortunately, the campaign that we're running hasn't really succeeded. We didn't even get to the match. We were expecting to raise at least half a million dollars or more. uh, to at least get to that match of half a million dollars, but we simply didn't get there. I'm not really sure why, but you know, HaKadosh Baruch Hu apparently didn't think we're ready to get it yet. But it's still available for people who want to donate. Okay, um, last question: Are the WhatsApp questions paused? If so, when will they resume? No, WhatsApp questions are being answered every single day. It's just that I have hundreds and hundreds of questions every day. Some things are more pressing than others. Some are less important. Some I don't get to. I try my best. There are literally hundreds of questions. I used to also answer questions on the app. And really, my goal is to only answer questions on the app. I don't think it's a realistic goal. It's a...
2:54:59theoretical goal because there are certain questions that only a person can, you know, ask and answer. But generally, I would like for questions to go only to the app. However, I haven't started yet. There are questions, and I haven't answered questions in the app in a few months. because the questions on WhatsApp are taking so much time, but now the questions on WhatsApp are even themselves. I'm not able to meet up with the demand because a lot of people are watching, a lot of people are asking questions. So, I try. Eventually, I get to it. Eventually, I get there to pretty much almost everybody, but sometimes it'll take me five minutes to answer a question, and sometimes it'll take me three months. Uh, depends, you know. It's nothing intentional. It's just simply when I, uh, when I can, when I get there. I just, uh, one of our Rosh Yeshivas, he sent me a message nine days ago. Nine days ago he sent me a message, and, uh, I only answered him today. And, you know, so it's a, uh, you know, when I saw the message, I realized that, you know, I realized he sent it to me a while ago. I didn't know it was almost two weeks ago.
2:56:07yeah, I answered it today as I was recording, and that's what it is. Anybody that expects me to answer them on demand at all times simply does not watch enough of my lectures and does not watch enough of the work that we do to realize that I promise you I'm not sitting here twiddling my thumbs doing nothing. uh, very busy and I'm trying to help a lot of people. There's an enormous amount of questions, issues, problems, and cases—a lot of stuff that you guys wouldn't even want to know about in your nightmares—that I have to deal with. And there's some things that simply require a lot of time. So, you know, I try to get to it when I get to it, but that's also one of the things that I keep trying to tell people who ask me to call them. I'm not calling anybody. Uh, there's no time to answer. You know, it used to be that there was no time to really have decent phone calls. Then there was no time to have phone calls at all. And now it's getting to a point where there's no time to answer even all the messages. It just is what it is. There's a lot of demand, and we try to do our best. Until my children grow up and become much smarter than I am, I have to answer the questions myself.
2:57:16right, we'll be in touch. Uh, tomorrow we should be on the radio somewhere. I'll keep you guys posted.
3:01:15I bless the rabbis. Wait, wait. I bless the rabbis, Rabbi Yaron Reuven, Rabbi Efraim Kahlon, who live with the help of Hashem. May God bless them. May God bless them. May God bless them. May God bless them. i live all over Israel. This Jew was a millionaire. He ran the business. But I invest here in the world of good. Where does he live? In Florida. Florida. Where is Florida? In America. In America. In Miami. In Miami. Yes, next door. We are going to build a large Sephardic community there.