BeEzrat HaShem

STUMP THE RABBI (121) Give For Yourself, MEANINGFUL MINUTE, Golem of Prague, MUSIC, Saving Money

4 years ago
Transcript

0:15we're back to uh our Wednesday night Stump the Rabbi, where after a few divrei Torah, you guys will, b'ezrat Hashem, uh, ask some questions, and we will give you the answers. Tonight's shiur will be for a refuah shlema for Rabbanit Levana bat Sarah, Avi Mori David ben Asria, Doris bat Jora, Rav Efraim ben Shulamit, Rabbanit Sarah bat Anat, Orit bat Ilana, Leora bat Liel, Ezra ben Batya, and also for Hatzlacha Rabbah, Marsha bat Julia, Ayla bat Marsha, Samer ben Marsha, Cephas ben Marsha, Alexander ben Marsha, Louis ben Marsha, Shaul ben Farzani, Yitro ben Avraham, Oshri ben Doris, Gavi ben Doris, Elad ben Doris, Amir ben Shahin.

1:24all of Am Yisrael and all of the righteous Noahides that continue to do whatever is necessary to do the will of Hashem. So we have in front of us Parashat Terumah. We have a parasha that, more or less, when you first look at it, you're trying to figure out, how is this parasha relevant to my life? I understand it's part of the Torah. I understand we need to build the Beit HaMikdash. I understand we need to do a lot of different things, but what about me? I'm not building the Beit HaMikdash. I'm not building the Mishkan. How can I take something from this parasha? So, of course, anyone that read Rabbi Ephraim's book, the Asicha HaShavua, knows that he has several ideas on every single parasha in the Torah. For anyone that knows how to speak Hebrew, they should definitely order these books from the website; it's free. Go to kiruvstore.org and get yourself a set of these. You can give them out and do chesed l'Am Yisrael by giving them some books for free.

2:29kiruvstore.org and get yourself a set of these. You can give them out and do chesed l'Am Yisrael by giving them some books for free. So, he has a bunch of ideas over there and of course, one of the things that a person needs to understand is that the Torah an endless ocean, and there's something to learn from every single pasuk in the Torah. Every aspect of it, every parasha, has prophecy; every parasha has secrets that are not only relevant to you but relevant to you now, right this second, this week. And when you read the parasha, one of the Mekubalim—I heard this firsthand from Rav Shani... who is one of the Mekubalim of this generation. He says that when you read the weekly parasha and you fulfill the mitzvah and the obligation that the Shulchan Aruch paskins, that every Jew has to read the weekly parasha twice and once with commentary, preferably commentary by Onkelos. But if you don't have Onkelos, you can read Rashi, and that's more than enough.

3:38But nonetheless, Rav Shani says that when you read the weekly parasha, you're in essence creating specific angels that will give you certain strength for that week and in your life that you can't get any other way. uh, there's an extraordinary amount of kedusha that is generated from reading the weekly parasha, and that's why we mention it on a regular basis. Because I know that there's a lot of people, Baruch Hashem, that watch our shiurim, that have done teshuva and are very good at learning Gemara or learning Mussar or learning a lot of different things, but for whatever reason or another uh, put the Five Books of Moses on the back burner as a, you know, "when I get a chance" type of ideology, and it's really nothing further from the truth. In fact, it's more of an obligation to learn the weekly parasha than it is to learn anything else, because you have to learn. Of course, you also have to learn, as we read in last night's shiur.

4:46that a person has to learn mussar every day, and of course, you have to learn halakha because how are you going to know how to apply the mussar if you don't know? So of course you have to learn everything, but for a person to not learn the weekly parasha is, in essence, a person who will never achieve any sense whatsoever of where he came from, where she came from, and where they're going. uh, it's critical for a person to learn the weekly parasha. Of course, the obligation is on men. You know, women are not obligated to learn the weekly parasha, although it's definitely very good, but they don't have that same obligation. But I would say women that are single or women that have less responsibility, more time on their hands, instead of chit-chatting a bunch of Lashon Hara on the telephone and going to coffee shops, surely it's much better for you to read the weekly parasha and know where you came from. One of the very successful segulot that's already from yesteryear, it's from many, many years ago, but had a rebirth.

5:58in our generation, by this generation, I remember when I first started doing teshuva, I used to go to shiurim every Tuesday night, and Rav Pinto gave a rebirth to a very famous segula to learn sefer Devarim, the book of Deuteronomy, the entire book on Shabbat. and many people have taken it on to learn this sefer. Why sefer? This is the sefer that has a lot of mussar in it, a lot of kedusha in it. But again, even this segula, I hear that there are certain people that take on this segula, and they read the book of Deuteronomy, sefer Devarim on Shabbat, and sometimes they read it in sections during the week, and that's all great, and it could definitely be an addition and a benefit to your life. But it is not as important as reading the weekly parasha. As great as reading it is, it's not as important. It's not an obligation. It's a segulah.

7:07obligation is what comes first, and a person is obligated to learn the weekly parasha. As I said, the mekubalim specifically say that when a person reads the weekly parasha and really delves into it—not just reads it superficially to get finished—reads the commentary, knows what's going on, connects to it, tries to figure out who's talking, what, where, and how, toils in it and toils in it because everything is in it, says the Mishnah. And a person such as this will end up having a lot of chiddushim and, of course, have an opportunity to potentially become a talmid chacham one day. Because there is no such thing as a talmid chacham who does not know Chumash. No such thing. So that reality does not exist. so the parashat, although it talks about the Mishkan and all of the different intricate details of building the Mishkan, building the Menorah and all the keilim and everything else, surely it has an enormous amount of teachings in it. First and foremost is the popular teaching where it says, "and they take for Me a..."

8:23a portion. They take for Me. I mean, usually, you would say they would give. When you give, you know, when the issue is tzedakah, you give tzedakah; you don't take tzedakah. No, no. When you give tzedakah, you're really taking tzedakah. Why? Because anyone that understands even the basic minimum requirement of what it means to believe in God knows that no matter what you do, Hashem opens His hands and feeds all of those that want life, that need life, Hashem feeds all of His creation so whether you give somebody that needs the money or you don't give it to them doesn't need you. In essence, when we give, we're taking, and that's what we're doing. Since Hashem is going to give this person, this animal, this entity whatever it needs based on, of course, calculations

9:27when we decide to donate money, when we decide to donate our time, when we decide to donate our, uh, our skills, or anything else that we decide to give, in essence, what we're telling you is that we want you to use us as the vessel that you're going to give to this person by That's an aspect. I know you're going to give this person food or money or whatever it is, with or without me. You don't need me to run the world. You don't need anything. And anyone that still has doubts or confusions about whether HaKadosh Baruch Hu needs something or not, as I said last night, another reminder, read the commentary by the Rambam on Perek Chelek, his commentary on the Mishnah. And Perek Chelek, it's right before he goes in there, there's a whole elaborate... well-known section where he talks about how there are different types of heretics who think that God needs something. But the point is, when a person gives—gives money for kiruv, gives money to a kollel, gives money for the sake of Torah,

10:33that person is, in essence, taking. Why are they taking? I understand Hashem is, you know, going to give one way or another, and I'm asking Hashem to use me. I'm giving, I'm going to donate a few dollars for the sake of Torah, so I want to be the vessel. But how is that taking, really? Because when you decide that you want to be the vessel... then, in essence, what are you doing? You're taking merit for yourself. You're guaranteeing yourself one thing: you're guaranteeing yourself that Hashem is going to reward you when you give to the right place, you give for the right cause, and you give the right amount too. you're guaranteeing yourself a blessing. There isn't really much that's guaranteed in the world, other than perhaps dying one day. Some people say taxes, but I don't think that's necessarily true. There are a lot of really wealthy people that avoid paying taxes. But nonetheless, there is not much guarantee in the world of money. People that are rich today don't necessarily have a promise that they'll be rich tomorrow. They don't even have a promise that they'll be alive tomorrow.

11:46but when a person gives for the sake of Torah, they are, in essence, taking an insurance policy that they're going to have something when Hashem looks at their account and sees if they have merits or not. So who says now, another thing that we learn from here is that there are different types of givers that exist in the world. We know that there is the giver that's symbolized here of different types of givers. First and foremost, who says I don't want everybody to give... i only want the people that their heart motivates them to give. As he says here, "Take for me a portion from every man whose heart motivates him; you shall take my portions," meaning...

12:48When a person gives, many times people give, but they give with conditions. I'm going to donate X amount of money if you give me a blessing, if you put my name on the shul, if you show me a lot of respect every time I see you, if you stand up when I see you, if you tell everybody that I gave. And they, in essence, you know they give, but they're giving as a transaction, as a business transaction. It's not really giving for the sake of giving, and that's unfortunately a very bad way to give. Who says when you're giving for my Torah, when you're giving for my Mishkan, when you're giving to be partners with me, give only what you have a serious motivation in your heart to give. you know, they give, but they're giving as a transaction, as a business transaction. It's not really giving for the sake of giving, and that's unfortunately a very bad way to give. Hashem says when you're giving for My Torah, when you're giving for My Mishkan, when you're giving to be partners with Me, give only what you have a serious motivation in your heart to give. Give only something that you're seriously, you know, you want to give this. Don't be one of these people that says, oh yeah, here's $20. Okay, if $20 is a lot of money to you, then yeah, of course, give it. But if you have tens of thousands or hundreds of thousands or millions of dollars and you're giving $20, don't think that this is something that's going to be viewed as a good thing. There are many people, the Chafetz Chaim says, that will actually get punished.

14:01this is mentioned by his talmid muvhak, where he says that there are going to be many people that are going to get punished at the time before Mashiach, and he says that the people that will be punished the most severely are the wealthy people the wealthy people did not give enough for the sake of Torah. You know, talking about right now, you have people with an enormous amount of money, all types of people have made money over the last 10 or 15 years. where you have people that had no concept of investing, all of a sudden became, you know, billionaires. They put ten thousand, twenty thousand dollars into some idea that their friend told them about and just wanted to speculate. It ended up being Bitcoin, and that ten thousand dollars could literally be worth a billion dollars right now. and you have other people that got into a business at the right place at the right time, and HaKadosh Baruch Hu decided to bless this business. The business went from being a mom-and-pop shop to being a conglomerate that has offices in almost every state, and they're bringing in literally millions of dollars every single month.

15:10Then you have certain people that started all types of networks on YouTube, TikTok, and Instagram, and all of these social networks, where they actually made a business out of it. They have subscribers, donors, and all types of things. Literally, people have made millions and millions of dollars from all types of ideas that have developed in the world over the last decade, actually, especially in the last five or six years. An enormous amount of money has been made by a lot of different types of people, both young and old, people who were in the software and development business. Some of them made a fortune by developing the foundation of something and then selling the business for 100, 200, or 500 million dollars to a Google or a Facebook or one of those companies, where to that big company it's literally not even a reportable transaction. You know, it's such for them; they have grown so much. They've become trillion-dollar companies, but they don't even have to report that they bought this hundred-million-dollar company. And two, three, four years later, when they develop it to be something significant, they could pretend as if they created it out of nothing. But the point is, for that person that developed that idea and sold it for a hundred or two hundred million dollars, or even a billion dollars, that was a life-changer for them. And a lot of that has happened over the last several years. And of course, everyone knows that the market

16:34is closer to its peak than it is to its bottom, meaning closer to the end of the bubble than it is to a higher level. But nonetheless, there are a lot of people who have been given a big fortune but have not taken that to heart, meaning they have not really thought about who is the one that gave all of this to me, and do I owe something? do I owe something because Hashem gave me this responsibility? When HaKadosh Baruch Hu gives you money, He's not giving you money because He wants you to buy 14 cars. Even if you like cars, you can only drive one at a time. He didn't give you all this money so you could buy 15 houses, even though He wants you to enjoy the world. There's no need for you to own so many houses. You can't go to more than one bathroom at a time. You can't sleep in more than one bed at a time. You're allowed to enjoy life. You're allowed to have a good time. But when people make their whole life into something that's materialism, where it's one vacation after another, one steak after another, they start getting to a point where they forget that anybody else in the world exists.

17:46that they actually have been given a responsibility to help those who are in need, especially those who are in need in the Torah world, whether it's the Torah institutions themselves or it's the Avreichim. Many times, people don't give, or they give to the wrong places, or they don't give enough. know he gives, he got a billion dollars and he figures that he is good because everyone gives him respect because he donated a million dollars. I'm sorry to tell you, you gave a million dollars; you're gonna get punished for it. You're not gonna get rewarded for that million dollars. Why? Because according to what you have, you were supposed to give a whole lot more than that. Add another few zeros to that. that's how much you were supposed to give when you have that kind of money, and that's why it's a very, very confusing world where you see certain times people get so much respect for the little bit that they give. Because the perspective of people is that this is a lot, but of course, Hashem has His own calculations. So what HaKadosh Baruch Hu, in essence, is telling us here in the beginning of the parasha is that a person is going to invest in the Torah, make sure

18:54that your heart is what's motivating you. What does it mean that your heart is motivating you? You're really into it. You're not just writing a check and thinking, "Oh, okay, I just wrote this. Okay, go, go, let me just, you know, move on with my life." No, I want you in it. I don't need your money; I want you in it. I want you to be involved. I want you to give because you thought about it, you thought about the significance of it, just like before you're going to invest and buy a 10, 50, or 100 million dollar business. You're going to do all the due diligence you have to before you give that $10 million, that $1 million, that $5,000. Make sure you do the calculations. Listen, I'm going to invest here. I'm going to put this money here and this is going to grow for me. I have an assurance it's going to grow for me because this is going to help people do teshuva. This is going to help people. Get involved in your spiritual investments. Put your heart into it. unfortunately, it also tells us there are different types of givers. This is the portion that you shall take from them: gold, silver, and copper. Those are the first three things that HaKadosh Baruch Hu says that they should give. But then, of course, there are other things. But the Chachamim teach us, and the first time I heard this, I heard this from Rabbi Ephraim, that there are different types of givers. This gold, silver, and copper is actually symbolic of the three different types of givers. Gold is, in Hebrew, spelled zahav. Zahav is zain, hay, veit.

20:22And it's an acronym for Zeh Noten Bari. that, uh, this person that's a gold, uh, giver, this guy is a — he's the best type of giver. Why? He's healthy, everything is good, and he wants to give anyway. Why? Because he really puts his heart into it. He cares about the cause, he cares about Torah, he cares about the future, and he gives not because he's expecting anything in return. He gives for the sake of giving. That's a golden giver. That's the best type of giver. I have a few of those people that I know — and not many. Literally, less than a handful. Less than a handful. We have tens of thousands, Baruch Hashem, tens of thousands of people that watch our shiurim, and Baruch Hashem, thousands of them, you know, give and help us and help us do a lot of the things that we do, but... There's a few of them that are unique. Why are they unique? Because it's not just about that they give a significant amount of what they make, but they don't ever have to be asked. They don't even need a reminder. They simply make it part of their life that they need to give. They need to give for the sake of Torah.

21:29it's amazing to see these people really put themselves out there and invest in the Torah because they know this is the right thing to do, and they're not expecting anything in return. Of course, everyone would love to have blessings and success and so on and so forth. But the Golden Giver is not doing it for that. The Golden Giver is doing it because he knows Hashem gave me and that's he gave me a responsibility with that gift. He gave me a responsibility, so that's the Golden Giver. Then there's the kesef, the silver. Kesef is silver; it also means money. That's also an acronym. that's also an acronym that is an acronym where it says when he sees danger, he opens, meaning a person had money all along and he would give. You know, he signed up for, he makes fifteen thousand, twenty thousand, fifty thousand a month.

22:30he signed up, you know, to give 50 bucks a month or something that's not really appropriate, or he doesn't give at all. But the moment he sees the tables turn, he sees that some of his investments went down. All of a sudden, his investment portfolio drops by 40 percent in a week. all of a sudden he feels pain on his side and the doctor says we have to check you; this is very serious. Stop everything that you're doing—you can't go to work for a week until we get a real diagnosis of why this pain. He gets a scare and then he says, "Oh Rabbi, listen, aren't you building a kollel or yeshiva or something? You're still working, right Rabbi? I haven't talked to you in a while. Listen, uh, where could I wire five thousand dollars?" "Oh wow, thank you very much, but the reality is..." not the ideal giver. It's good that he's giving; it's good that he's getting the sign that okay, who's giving you this pain? Because he's trying to get your attention. But it's not ideal like the golden giver that already gave before anything happened. This guy saw some pain. As soon as he saw some pain, he said, "Okay, okay, let me write a check. God, save me before it gets too late. Save me before it gets too late." So this is the kesef. The third one is nekhoshet. Nekhoshet is copper.

23:49this is an acronym for the gift of the sick who says "give, give already." This is a person that already got sick, he's already sick, he already lost a lot, and he's pretty much at a point where he's lost hope, and he said, "you know what, whatever, listen..." i can't take the money with me anyway. I'm dying. Just give the rabbi a hundred dollars, give the rabbi five thousand, give, give, just whatever, just give something. Meaning, it is one of those hopeless last will and testament type of gifts where, you know, it's like in a game of football I used to play when I was in high school. know anytime you have a close game but you only have a few seconds left to the game, what do they typically do? They throw what's called the Hail Mary. They throw a ball all the way into the sky, hoping that the team catches it and scores. This is pretty much the last chance; we'll give it whatever we can, and whatever happens, happens.

25:03This is, unfortunately, typical of the, uh, copper giver that, uh, gives but really when it's almost too late. Too late would be after he already died, but it's almost too late where, you know, it's, uh, it's not, uh, to say the least, it's not, uh, a person that's the ideal giver. And the question is, how does a person get to understand how to be this ideal giver? First and foremost, we should always be reminded, the Tree of Life, okay, uh, it is given to those that support it, meaning that, uh, that blessing is given to those people that invest in Torah, that invest in kiruv, that invest into, uh, in His business. In essence, those people that want to be partners with Hashem, those are the people that have the biggest, uh, blessing in their life.

26:06Those are the people that will end up being the most praiseworthy. Why? Because HaKadosh Baruch Hu is going to give food to His creation with or without us. And when a person invests, he shows Hashem that he knows what his responsibility is in this world. the other hand, a person needs to know that with or without you giving, it’s not going to change your income for that year. Why? Because HaKadosh Baruch Hu already decided how much income you’re going to make on Rosh Hashanah. ...you decide how much money you're going to make from Rosh Hashanah to Rosh Hashanah. Let's say you're going to make one hundred thousand dollars, okay? So, you're going to make one hundred thousand dollars, almost ten thousand dollars a month. Now, you decide, "I want to give ten thousand." So, the Gemara says, "Oh, if you're going to give ten thousand for the sake of Torah, that ten thousand is not included in that income." why? Who pays for the mitzvot? Meaning, whatever a person uses for the sake of mitzvot, whether it is donating money to feed the poor, for the sake of Torah, or for the sake of a mitzvah for Shabbat, for Yom Tov, and so on, that’s not part of the income.

27:19that's not part of income. In essence, you're putting Hashem on the spot where He has to find a way to give you an extra 10,000 this year because that's what you gave. And the higher the level of emunah, the more a person gives. So now, when a person is the golden type of giver, that type of person is already making commitments ahead of time. making commitments ahead of time, where he's already giving, she's already giving, before she even sees the blessing. And I've seen with my own eyes, I've seen with my own eyes people that do this, and again, like I said, there's only a few that I know that have done this, and I've seen the blessings, the miracles, in front of my eyes of what happens. Because a certain person decided to give, not only to give, but to give a substantial amount and to give without necessarily knowing who, what, when, and how. The amount of blessings this person had over the next few years, they themselves say, "I'm surprised that Hashem is paying me. Is this okay? Am I getting a reward in this world?" I say, listen, if Hashem gives you a gift, say thank you.

28:24Why would anybody be concerned about Hashem rewarding them? If a person is truly righteous and they know that Hashem is giving them a lot, they have to check, is this really what I want? Is this not what I want? Rabbi Shwadron, alav haShalom, used to have some very famous stories that he would give. One of the famous stories that he said, which the first time I heard it was from Rabbi Fein many years ago, was a story about Rabbi Yonatan Eybeschutz when he was very young. Rabbi Yonatan Eybeschutz, alav haShalom, was a Kodesh Kodeshim, and when he was young and just newly married in those days, When someone was already recognized as a true scholar, all of the wealthy people, all of the wealthy Jews, would want their daughters to marry this scholar because it was an honor to have somebody like that in the family. And in order to entice the scholar to marry their daughter, they would promise them a substantial amount of money and give them a substantial amount of money so they could continue focusing just on learning Torah and not have to worry about any money. So such was the case with Rabbi Yonatan Eybeschutz. They recognized him as a diamond, and that's as rare as can be. One of the wealthy families saw this, and the father said, "Listen, you will marry my daughter. She's a good girl. You meet her, and if everything works out and you both want to marry each other, I'm going to give you 3,000 gold coins."

29:37So such was the case with Rabbi Yonatan Eybeschutz. They recognized him as a diamond, and that's as rare as can be. One of the wealthy families saw this, and the father said, "Listen, you will marry my daughter. She's a good girl. You meet her, and if everything works out and you both want to marry each other, I'm going to give you 3,000 gold coins." 3,000 is a substantial amount of money, and, of course, everything else was good. She was a modest tzaddeket, everything was great, and on top of it, I'm going to be able to study. Of course, the Gemara in Masechet Sotah says in the beginning of the tractate that a person gets a spouse based on his actions. If he is righteous, he gets a modest woman. If he's wicked, he gets a prutza, he gets an immodest woman. So, of course, Rabbi Yonatan Eibeshitz got a tzaddeket. Not only was she coming from a wealthy family, but she was also a very, very serious tzaddeket, which you'll see from this story.

30:44So, Rabbi Yonatan Eibeshitz married this woman and continued his learning. Now, at the time, they had this Beit Midrash where the Rabbi would learn with his chavruta. His chavruta was one of these really kana'im, these zealous people that really fought for the truth, and sometimes pushed the envelope a little too far, especially when it came to idolatry. One day, these Christians, who of course tried to do everything possible to destroy Judaism in every way, shape, or form, came into town and decided that they're going to build a church right next door to the synagogue. As if there's no other place on earth that they can build their place of idolatry, they have to build it right across... ...street from the synagogue, from the beit midrash that the rabbi and his friend were learning in. Of course, nobody liked it, but the chavruta Rabbi Yaakov, when he saw that, just couldn't stand it. He couldn't stand it. Every day, they would see it out of the window and hear the bells. He said, "One day, I'm going to take revenge against them." Rabbi Yonatan would try to calm his friend down, but nothing, nothing really prevailed...

32:12He hated it with a passion. And really, this is one of the things that the Gemara in Masechet Avodah Zarah says that you're supposed to hate idolatry. But he hated it with a passion, even more than the norm. Now, one day, he couldn't take it anymore. And he decided to take matters into his own hands. Rabbi Yaakov, the chavruta, decided to break into the church. went into the church, saw their huge, disgusting idolatry—a cross with a Yoshke hanging on it. Their god is hanging there like a shish kebab. He decided to start breaking it. As soon as he broke it, it created a big noise, and he started going back, you know, to leave, but there was commotion. The pastors that were living inside there ran outside to see what the commotion was, saw the Jew, chased him, caught him, and beat him senseless. They beat him senseless and put him into one of the rooms. He wasn't allowed to leave until they had a judgment on what to do with him. The next morning, when Rabbi Natanai Bishitz

33:35came to learn Torah. He saw that his chavruta wasn't there. He wasn't too concerned; he figured he was busy or didn't feel well. Okay, but the second day, when he saw his friend was not there, he started getting concerned. He asked around, and no one had seen him. No one had seen him. Meanwhile, the church had their meeting and decided They're gonna burn her alive in the middle of the market on a specific date for desecrating their idol. Such was life in those days; simply, the church took matters into their own hands and decreed the death penalty on a Jew. Imagine living in such a time. Shimshon Schmo saw this and... his friend is missing and started praying to Hashem. "Please help us." All of a sudden, there is a knock on the door. He opens it and sees that there is a pastor from the place next door. "Can I help you?" he says. "Listen, your friend Yaakov—he's with us."

35:03if you want to see him alive, I'm the only one that can help you because in the next couple of days they're going to burn him alive in the middle of the market for what he did. Now, the Rabbi is there with a few other people in the beit midrash to hear this horrible news. He says, "Okay, what do you want?" He says, "I want 3,000 gold coins," which is an enormous amount of money. Enormous amount of money and he said, "Listen, get it. You have your friend. If you don't get it, your friend's gonna be burned. You have until tomorrow to give it to me because after that, it'll be too late." Of course, everybody discussed. I mean, it's a big mitzvah. You know, to redeem captives and to save a Jewish life is a very big deal. So everybody said, "Let's try to get whatever we can get." Rabbi Yonasan Eibeschutz thought to himself, "I..." big mitzvah. It's a big mitzvah that I can do here. But by the same token, it's taking all of the money that I got from my father-in-law and giving it. I don't know if my wife is going to agree to this. Our lives are going to change. He couldn't take it. He said, "I have to do it." He went into the safe, got all of the money that they had—the whole three thousand—and went to the pastor and said, "Here you go."

36:32You get the money so fast. I'll be on tonight because she told them I had this money. I got it as a gift from my father-in-law, and this is all I have. The pastor couldn't believe it. He says, "That's what you would do? You're giving your friend everything you have?" He says, "Yeah, the Jew is worth a lot more." The pastor was so impressed. With Rabbi Yonatan, he says, "I've never seen such integrity, such real love. Never seen anything like this." And he parted ways with him after giving him Rabbi Yaakov. And he told him, "If you want him to stay alive, he has to leave the city forever, never come back." Of course, Rabbi Yaakov fled the city, saved his life, and Rabbi Yonatan... He has to go back home. Okay, he did a big mitzvah, but he has to go back home. But he already planned ahead. He said, "Listen, once my wife hears this, I don't know what she's going to say. So I already told her that I have to leave for a few days. So I have a few days that I can pretend like I'm somewhere else, but in reality, he's going to be in the Beit Midrash."

37:52thinking about, uh, what to say, how to say it, maybe Hashem will open up his mind and give him something good to say to give her a way to justify it. And while he's in the Beit Midrash, his friends come and they say, "Rebbi, we got some money." He said, "Oh, okay, but you don't need to, you could keep it for yourself." "What do you mean? I already gave it to them," and he told them the whole story. "I gave everything I had." He said, "Oh, okay, great that you did it, but we want the mitzvah also. We worked hard to go get money from people. We want the mitzvah also. So at least let us buy half the mitzvah. We'll give you 1,500. You'll get half, we get half." "You think I'm going to sell my mitzvah? You think I'm going to sell my mitzvah? I can't sell my mitzvah. It's my mitzvah. I need my mitzvah. It's my mitzvah. No amount of money in the world is worth this mitzvah." I just got a mitzvah to save a Jewish life. You want me to sell that mitzvah? I can't sell a mitzvah. After back and forth, back and forth, it was decided, no, no selling. He's not selling the mitzvah. Rabbi Yotam was still a young man, a genius, a tzaddik, and very zealous about keeping his mitzvah. So, a few days passed, and one day, the pastor comes to the house of Rabbi Yotam HaMishits.

39:19Of course, Abir Natan is not there. And he tells his wife, he's like, listen, I have to give you something. Me, something? Who are you? Oh, I'm the pastor of this. What do you want? He gives up a whole boatload of money. Everything he has. What do you want me to do with this? He says, listen, the church that I'm part of, they're on to me that I'm the one that freed your husband's friend. And I overheard them talking that they're gonna kill me. So I have to run. But I can't carry this with me, all this money that I collected over the years. And the only person in the world that I can trust is your husband. They're on to me that I'm the one who freed your husband's friend. And I overheard them talking that they're going to kill me. So I have to run. But I can't carry this with me, all this money that I collected over the years. And the only person in the world that I can trust is your husband. What do you know about my husband? He says, your husband is the most honest, sincere, loving person I have ever met. He gave all of his money, all of your money, to save his friend—all three thousand gold coins he gave. And that's part of it also, and all the money that I collected over the years, all of it is here. And I know that your husband is such an honest, good person that if I am able to survive this and I come back, I know he's going to give it back to me. But if I die, it's all yours. She says, okay. So he fled. Several hours later, people found his body under the bridge. They caught him, they killed him—the Christians killed him.

40:29good person that if I am able to survive this and I come back, I know he's going to give it back to me. But if I die, it's all yours." She says, "Okay." So he fled. Several hours later, people found his body under the bridge. They caught him, they killed him—the Christians killed him. And uh His wife realizes how much of a tzaddik her husband is and how Hashem rewarded him. Later that day, he comes home, and he has been trying to figure out what he is going to say to his wife to convince her not to divorce him, to convince her that he's not crazy, to convince her that it was really the right thing to do. He gets into the house, expecting that by now she probably realizes that all the money is gone.

41:31he comes in and he sees his wife happily playing with all types of jewelry. She goes, "Hey, my tzaddik husband! I'm so proud of you." "What, me? You're proud of me?" "Because you're such a tzaddik." "I'm a tzaddik?" "You're the biggest tzaddik in the world," he says. "I know what you did." I know that you gave all of what we have to save a Jew, and I agree with you. You did the right thing, and not only that, Hashem agrees with you. Look at what He gave you! He tells him the whole story of what happened with the pastor, how he gave her, and then the pastor's body was found. He had been murdered by the Christians. Yonatan Eibeschitz looks at all this money and starts crying hysterically. He starts crying uncontrollably, and his wife doesn't understand why her husband is crying. "Why are you crying? Why are you crying?"

42:39Yonatan says, "HaKadosh Baruch Hu rejected my mitzvah. He rejected the mitzvah; He doesn't want it because He gave it back to me, threw it in my face. Whatever reward I was supposed to get, you don't get reward in this world; you get rewarded in the next world. HaKadosh Baruch Hu gave me everything that I gave, plus a lot more, in my face in this world, which means He doesn't want my mitzvah." And he cried hysterically until he fell asleep. That night, he received a message in a dream that he was right. HaKadosh Baruch Hu was not happy with him. He said, "You did good by giving, but you were supposed to share that mitzvah. Other people need to also give. You can't just take the entire mitzvah for yourself." That's why everything was given back to him.

43:40This is the reason why Rabbi HaKadosh, Rabbi Yehuda HaNasi, who was extraordinarily wealthy, had hundreds of horses and properties, and was like a king from the Rabban Gamliel family, one of the descendants of David HaMelech. Extraordinarily wealthy. But yet, he would ask his rich friends to give tzedakah, not because he needed their help, but because he knew they needed it. they need the merits. Who says to us that whatever motivates us, whatever motivates us to give tzedakah, should be the right motivation? It should not be something because we're expecting to get something in return in this world, because we want a certain amount of respect, because we want this, because we want that. Simply because we want Hashem to use us as a vessel to spread His word in the world. That's what we want. The parasha continues, talking about the Mishkan, talking about all of the extraordinary things that HaKadosh Baruch Hu put in this Mishkan, and we see that HaKadosh Baruch Hu does certain things at certain times that we can learn from. For example,

45:02the uh when he tells us the details of how this Mishkan was made and all the material that was made, we see that the uh the cover for the Mishkan was made from the skin of a tachash. Tachash was a deer-like, bull-like animal. was a combination of the two, a decent, you know, very big animal but was an extraordinarily beautiful animal, the most beautiful animal that existed. And its skin was like a rainbow, something out of this world. Perhaps that's where the people got their stories of the unicorn, something similar to that, but it didn't have wings, obviously. Either way, this Tachash was an extraordinarily beautiful animal. And the Chachamim ask, was this animal always there? Why is it mentioned here? Who, what, when? Rashi says this was a creation for its time, meaning that this Tachash was not created in Bereishit. This was one of the later creations. There were a few creations that HaKadosh Baruch Hu made.

46:14after the original creation because, generally speaking, everything else was created in Bereishit, in the beginning of the world. This animal was created at Mount Sinai and existed at that time when its skin was needed for the sake of the Mishkan, the Beit HaMikdash. But as soon as there was no longer a need for it, that's it, it became extinct because there was no reason for it. But this, again, is symbolic for us to see and understand clearly how HaKadosh Baruch Hu manages His world, where He shows us clearly that He has no limitation. He plays with this world very similarly to how our kids play with putty. He can do whatever He wants, as the Pasuk says, "היד ה' תקצר?"—Is Hashem's hand short? Is there anything that Hashem can't do? This is important for each and every one of us to know when we are giving and when we are doing, because many times people are concerned that if I'm gonna give this and this much, then I'm not gonna have...

47:17if I do this much, then I'm not gonna have this. This is a mistake. When you make Torah your priority in life and you say, "Listen, no matter what, I'm gonna learn my hour or two in the morning, I'm gonna learn my hour or two or more at night," which if that means I'm going to have to work less, then let it mean I'm going to work less. Why? Because when I work for Hashem, when I serve Hashem and I learn Torah, I know for sure that although it may not be easy, although there is going to be some test, I know that this is certainly the right decision. This is certainly the right decision, and I will not lose as a result of it. Hashem is not going to punish me for learning Torah. The same concept applies when a person decides to make a commitment to donate at least 10 to 20% of their income for the sake of Torah. Every time they get a check, they donate. Why? Because a person naturally in their rational mind will think, "Wait, if I'm going to give this money, then that means that I have to live off of 90%."

48:20I have to live off of 80%, and 80% is not always enough. Maybe my business is going to go down. Maybe my competition will this. Maybe that. Maybe this. Don't ask any of those questions when it comes to Hashem. Don't ask any of those. Don't do calculations with HaKadosh Baruch Hu. Why? Is Hashem not capable of doing something? There's no such thing as getting punished for doing the right thing according to Hashem. so when a person makes that commitment, makes that leap of faith, jumps into the water like Nachshon did, sacrifices himself or herself for the sake of HaKadosh Baruch Hu, there's no doubt that that person will end up on top at some point. It may not happen right away, it may not happen for some time—only Hashem knows the calculations—but for sure, you will benefit and see that it was the right decision. And many times when people have the ability to do good, the Yetzer Hara comes to them and reminds them of how bad it used to be or how bad it can be, and maybe you shouldn't do it. All types of calculations get involved, and they end up either not doing as much or not doing at all.

49:29and this, unfortunately, is a mistake that's made often. And many times, people will end up donating to the wrong entity just because of a tax benefit, let's say, or because of a social benefit where they know that this Torah institution is the best one, it's the one that helped them, it's the one that saved them, it's the one that did everything, but they're going to donate to somewhere else because it's perhaps more famous or perhaps it's local, or therefore there are tax benefits, and so on. So a person can make such a judgment like that and think, "Oh, but I'm still giving it to Torah, it's still a good thing." Wrong. Torah institution is the best one; it's the one that helped them, it's the one that saved them, it's the one that did everything, but they're going to donate elsewhere because it is perhaps more famous or perhaps it's local, or there are tax benefits, and so on. So, a person can make such a judgment like that and think, "Oh, but I'm still giving it to Torah; it's still a good thing." Wrong. It's not just about giving it to an institution. It's about giving it to the right one. It's not just about giving. It's about making sure you have HaKadosh Baruch Hu as the reason why you're giving and not your own personal benefits. If you end up getting certain benefits, whether it be taxes or social or whatever other benefits that you're getting as a result of it, no problem. It's not a sin to get benefits.

50:35but when a person makes their giving something that they're already expecting to receive something material from, then it's not really giving; it's more like business. It's more like business. HaKadosh Baruch Hu says, "If I want to make a new creation just for you, then I'll make a new creation just for you. If I didn't make a new creation just for you, that means I don't want to make a new creation just for you." If I want to make a miracle, then I'll make a miracle. If I don't want to make a miracle, I won't make a miracle. Don't ask me to make a miracle. Focus on what you're supposed to do, and HaKadosh Baruch Hu will decide what's best for you. That's one of the things that we have to remind ourselves on a regular basis because many times we feel like we can do more if Hashem gives us more. But the truth be told, this is somewhat of a heretical thought. Why is this somewhat of a heretical thought? Because if Hashem knew that you could do more with more, wouldn’t He already give you more?

51:38Meaning that if He's not giving you more, that's because He wants what you have now. He wants you to learn as much as you can now, based on your schedule now. He wants you to do as much as you can based on what you can do now. Not based on, oh, if you have different circumstances. That's what happens a lot of times, is that people live in an illusion where they say, "Listen, it's okay for me to do almost nothing because I'm waiting for Hashem to open the gates for me, and then I'll do a lot. I'll give a lot once I have a lot, but now that I don't have a lot, I'm not gonna give anything." It's a mistake. It's a mistake. Hashem wants a heart. What does it mean He wants a heart? He wants us to do the best we possibly can with whatever we have. And He will decide if He wants to change the circumstances for us or not. And this, of course, is relevant to our learning Torah. It's relevant to how we manage our marriage, how we respect our spouses, how we raise our kids, how we give tzedakah, where we give tzedakah. All of these different things have a connection. And of course, we can continue going on into every single page in this parasha, but I see that we've already gone to a point where it's almost an hour.

52:53Uh, and I know that you guys have some questions, so perhaps we could already start with the questions. And then, after I get a drink, we'll go from there. One second. Okay, it talks about the side from which the woman was made. What does it mean that the tail was removed from Adam? What does it mean? Okay, so if you look there in the commentary, it says that there are a couple of opinions on how Adam HaRishon was created. and also, in fact, the Zohar elaborates that there was more than one Eve. The first Eve that was created...

53:53left Adam HaRishon. She did not want to be an ezer kenegdo; she did not want to be his helpmate, and she left him. She ended up marrying the Satan and became the Satan's wife, that, shem yishmor, is responsible for all of the immorality in the world. And when... Uh spoke about the issue. He says that he had a dream where he had to fight the Satan, and he beat him. However, when he had to fight his wife, he almost lost. In essence, she is stronger than the Satan himself. So, some speak about the fact that there is more than one Eve, more than one Chava. The second thing is that how she was created and so on. The Gemara talks about how some of the opinions are that HaKadosh Baruch Hu created, where it says in the original verse, it says men and women were created, but then later on it says it differently. So the Chachamim say that initially Adam and Chava were connected back to back.

55:03So Adam was on this side, Chava was on that side, and they were like Siamese twins, but of course different, and HaKadosh Baruch Hu split them. Why did HaKadosh Baruch Hu create Adam HaRishon alone and not create both of them at the same time? because in essence, she came out from him. Why didn't He create them at the same time? Because if they were created at the same time, they would not agree on who the world was created for, who was in charge, and so on. And the woman would never want to submit to her husband. So it would be a nightmare. so HaKadosh Baruch Hu had to create her second, and that's also the reason why He didn't create the woman first, because if the woman were created first, she would never want to submit to a husband. And this is part of the purpose of our creation, as part of being modest, is for a woman to submit to her husband, of course, assuming the husband is a reasonable, normal person. So part of the opinion is that there was a connection, they were physically connected,

56:10uh, and uh, back to back, and in essence the part uh, where the uh, uh, uh, the tailbone is—there is a tailbone, there's no tail—but where the tailbone is, is in essence where that separation was uh, was made. Uh, so that's uh, in essence what the Gemara is talking about over there. Kayin is asking, how is it... ...that Meaningful Minute and other channels support Ephraim Goldberg despite clearly lying. For example, he blatantly says that he would never invite a missionary, even though he has done it on a regular basis over the years. Even Alderstein is caught lying and has gone against the holy rabbis for years. Well, the guys from Meaningful Minute, they're not talmidei chachamim. They're just a couple of young guys that want to take advantage of the social media demand for Jewish programs and rabbis and personalities and so on. So, in essence, they're...

57:22people that are trying to, you know, give themselves a name, like unfortunately the Tower of Babel, so they're not necessarily working off of Daas Torah as far as their decisions and so on. To my knowledge, Ephraim Goldberg is the rabbi of at least one of them. I think the kid Nachi, I think he's actually his rabbi. of course he's going to support him if he's his rabbi; he's his hero. He's going to believe every little bit of nonsense that Ephraim tells him. So when Ephraim tells the world, "Oh yeah, they threatened me. The FBI is investigating it, and that person is going to get caught," and... they should, uh, you know, turn themselves in because we're going to catch you with that ugly smirk that he has, like you really are going to be happy putting people in jail. I mean, it's, uh, you know, kind of strange. I mean, don't get me wrong, I agree that whoever, uh, if somebody actually did threaten him and, uh, crossed that line, and I think somebody called his nine-year-old daughter, according to him.

58:33and threatened her. If somebody actually did that, then they really should be institutionalized. I mean, that's crossing the line. There's no reason for anybody to take the law into their own hands and threaten anybody's life, whether it's Ephraim or his nine-year-old daughter. I highly doubt this actually happened. I highly doubt it happened. But if it happened, then again, it's sad. It shouldn't have been done. Surely it's not coming from anyone that's considered a normal person, and especially not somebody that's actually learning our shiurim. Perhaps it's somebody that's watched our shiurim, but it's not somebody that's learning them, which are two different things. Because anyone that's learning them is going to know that we do not recommend violence under any condition. Even if we say "death penalty" a million and a half times in every shiur, everyone understands that I always say. this is not for you to exercise. We don't have a Sanhedrin. But anyway, some people take matters into their own hands. And perhaps they did threaten him. I don't believe they did, personally, because I already know that he's a compulsive liar. So it's impossible for me to believe anything he says.

59:49but if somebody did it, then of course it's a sad scenario that people have done such a thing. But I still would not say, "Oh, they're going to get caught and they're going to get prosecuted," and be like celebrating it. I mean, there's actually a... Someone that takes honor in the downfall of his friends has no share in the World to Come. So I'm not exactly sure where Ephraim is getting off on being excited to go catch somebody and put him in jail forever. I mean, that's completely stupid. i know that he sent people to my, uh, to my house, and he thinks that I'm the one that did something. But of course, I know what I did and what I didn't do, and, uh, I don't have any, uh, any concerns whatsoever. Uh, and that's why, when the, uh, when the police that he sent to my house, the investigators that he sent to my house, when they came here...

1:00:55Within 30 seconds, they knew the whole thing was nonsense. And I invited them into the house, telling them, "Listen, if you want, you can take the computer, you can take the phone, just give me something to use in the meantime while you guys investigate all the files, if you want." They already knew within, they said, "No, no, no, we don't need to do anything. We're sorry, we just have to come here." They apologized for coming to my house. Of course, it was scary for my little kids to see there's police, there's guns, and why are they here, and so on. Of course, Ephraim doesn't care about that, and he doesn't tell that part of the story to his audience. So, when he tells the little Nachi that's looking for 15 minutes of fame, "Oh yeah, they called my nine-year-old daughter. They threatened us." Oh, that's disgusting. So, in essence, what does he do? He makes himself into a victim. makes himself into a victim because he knows he has no halacha to back him. He has no Torah to back him. He has no mesorah to back him. Nobody will back him. The only people that he says are backing him are either the missionaries or the Reform rabbis that he's friends with. No actual real chacham is ever going to back this person, so he has to get Nachi to join him on his seek for public sympathy.

1:02:06so it's pathetic, it's sad, but it's not a new thing. This is nothing new under the sun. It's nothing new under the sun. And also, as a side note for all of you guys that are still bent on this whole letter by Rabbi Schechter... uh and people think that Rabbi Schechter, because he didn't say no, therefore that means yes. Because his sons went to join Ephraim Goldberg, this does not—you cannot make those types of conclusions. We don't make any conclusions on what the Rav actually says based on what his wife is doing. there's no such thing. We don't pasken that way. We don't conclude things that way. Don't rationalize things because that's what Ephraim wants the world to do. He wants the world to say, "Look, I'm hugging these two guys. One looks like a yeshiva rabbi, the other guy looks like, I don't know, a movie star." Like but they're both related, and they're both the sons of Rabbi Schechter. So, if they came to my uh, missionary show, that means it's kosher. First and foremost, you should know that does not mean anything. It does not mean anything. Second of all, Rabbi Schechter did not make a public uh, statement on this particular event because it was not necessary.

1:03:25since the Halacha of Rav Moshe Feinstein and Shulchan Aruch, the Rambam, is all well known. And he himself wrote an article nine years ago for anybody that wants to read it. It's available online for free. So he doesn't need to make a public statement. That's number one. Number two, you cannot conclude anything based on people that are not valid to be witnesses, not valid to take anything from. And unfortunately, if anybody spends some time looking at least into the background or the Facebook page of the two sons, one of them you're going to be a don't know, not exactly so impressed by his lifestyle choices when he's hugging homosexuals and pedophiles and all types of disgusting people for a living. So you know, for everybody that's jumping on the bandwagon of saying, "Oh, because they came to the event, that means that Rabbi Sheik, their father, who dedicated his entire life to Torah, agrees with everything." It doesn't mean anything.

1:04:30Doesn't mean anything. They're adults. They have their own free choice. One of them decides that he's going to work and be, I think, a rabbi or something. And the other one decides that he wants to hang out and rub shoulders with pedophiles and Hollywood stars that are the filth of the sewer. It's cleaner than them. that's what they publicize themselves. It's public now; it's on their Facebook page. So if that's what Ephraim wants to use as his evidence for his actions being correct, he wants to use the guy, these two, and he wants to use Nachi, who's looking for a stage. uh, that doesn't know anything. Somebody asked him recently to join a Gemara program, a Daf Yomi program. Him and his buddy that they do the show, why don't you come join the Daf Yomi program? You're actually interviewing somebody that gives a Daf Yomi shiur that's very famous, very good shiur, very well respected. Why don't you come learn for Daf Yomi 45 minutes? Oh, I don't know if I can handle it. You can't handle 45 minutes? 45 minutes of learning Torah you can't handle, and you call yourself a Jew?

1:05:43you're interviewing rabbis. These are the talmidim of Ephraim Goldberg. They cannot handle 45 minutes. And again, you're not going to say these guys are ba'alei teshuva; they don't know what right or left is. These are guys that grew up in the yeshivot of the Modern Orthodox world, meaning that for them to learn 45 minutes of Torah in the morning should be the minimum of the minimum. But Again, it's the world that's looking for the wicked to be right; they'll find a way for them to be right. The people that are looking for the truth will find the truth. So again, I don't have anything particularly against these two young kids that run this Meaningful Minute and the other one, but I don't think that their opinion is something that anyone should consider. Their opinion is not valid. They're not Talmidei Chachamim. They don't have Da'at Torah. And quite frankly, I'm not even sure if they learn Torah at all. uh, I would not be surprised if, uh, some of my, uh, six- or seven-year-old kids that watch my shiur know more than them. I would not be surprised, and I'm not, I'm not saying this as an insult; I'm saying this because, unfortunately, that's the reality. I'm saying this because that's the reality.

1:07:00So again, you have to understand, just because somebody has a YouTube page or some type of Instagram following does not make their opinion valid. Not in the Torah world. Maybe in Hollywood, maybe if somebody has a million followers, all of a sudden they become a guru. But in the Torah world, unless you have Torah, your opinion is meaningless. Meaningless. so of course Ephraim will take advantage of the people that don't know such things and they think that because, you know, these people show up to a show, other people put them on the channel, that means that he's doing the right thing. And with a few dollars to pay Yeshiva World News, or Yeshiva whatever that website is called, to advertise is a little video, so you can make some fake views as if people care about what he says and why he said it. You know, so you make some fake views as if there's going to be a few thousand views from people who care about what he says. You know, so of course, he's going to say whatever he's going to say. Don't be surprised, don't be surprised by any of it. Why? Because, again, when you have nothing

1:08:16to stand on, you're gonna grab for whatever straw you can get. And if this is gonna have the support of somebody that supports a known heretic like Slifkin, and I'm referring to Adlerstein, who supported Slifkin and does a lot of things that are 100% against halacha, like we showed in yesterday's video. Or he's going to get support from a couple of kids who can't even commit 45 minutes to learn Torah. Or he's going to get support from some guy who rubs elbows with pedophiles and rapists. If that's what people want, then they deserve what they're getting. If people believe him because of those examples, they deserve for him to be their teacher. If people want bad stuff, they deserve bad. HaKadosh Baruch Hu will help them get bad. again, a person needs to be a little clever and realize that, you know, you can't just believe something because somebody says it on a video. It doesn't mean anything; you have to check. How do I know all this stuff? It's part of my work to know who my enemies are. It's part of my work to know who Am Yisrael's enemies are, so I have to know all these things. But it's important for people that are investigating all of this and questioning all of this stuff.

1:09:41Not to fall in love with hating the people themselves or with taking matters into their own hands and threatening people. It's important that people don't do stuff like that. Because with all of the stuff that happened, the key to understand is that their actions, what they're doing, is what we hate. What they're doing is what we hate. The fact that they are bringing danger to Am Yisrael is what we hate, is what we speak against. Their personal lives, their preference of what they eat, their background, their choice of, I don't know, books to read—I care less about all those things. what we care about is their actions. If their actions are good, if their actions are bad, and they're putting other people at risk, then we have to speak against it. But again, it's important for people not to take stuff to a different level and start obsessing over the people themselves and start getting crazy. Why? Because that is definitely a tool that they are using and will continue to use to, I guess, discredit the entire argument against them. They justify their misbehavior through the misbehavior of other people.

1:11:08You know, it's as if their logic is "two wrongs make a right." Two wrongs make them right. They're wrong, and somebody else is wrong, therefore they're right by default. That's according to the logic of the wicked people. So don't give them a reason. They already make enough mistakes on their own without anybody helping them. don't need to, uh, you don't need to help them make any mistakes. They already make enough mistakes on their own. And, uh, Hashem sees everything, and eventually, if they do not do teshuva, He will uproot them from the world in the most public fashion you will ever see, where everyone will know this is the reason why they were uprooted. This is the reason. This is just a matter of time. It's not a, uh, it's not a curse; it's a reality. simply a reality. We don't want them to die. Ephraim Goldberg has kids and a wife. I want him to live to 120. Nachi has a wife. His partner has a wife. Adelstein has kids and grandkids. I want them all to live to a million years old and be righteous and go to Gan Eden. I would love to be, uh, one of their little chasidim if they're so righteous. The reality is it's not the case. It's not the case right now. Right now, they're on the bad side. If they do teshuva, I'll be the first one to be their biggest fan.

1:12:27If they do teshuva, I will be the first one to make a video celebrating their name, showing how great they are for reaching such a level that they did teshuva and literally changed their entire lives and their mentality to go to the righteous side. I'll be the first one to celebrate it. I don't want people to die. I don't want people to go to Gehinnom. I don't want people to be in jeopardy. We're not looking for anyone to die. We are looking for people to do teshuva. Even if that means that it's the very same person that we spoke against. I think anybody that's been watching my shiurim for long enough knows that that's the whole goal of everything. I spoke against a young kid when he said something that was a mistake in one of his videos, and then a couple of months later, I put my life on the line—literally my life on the line—to get him out of prison in Nigeria. Nobody in the world knows, not even him, what we did in order to get him out of that prison in Nigeria. Put it that way, nobody knows.

1:13:28What we had to do and what we did just to get him out of there. He doesn't even know himself. Even though I saw him after that, he doesn't even know himself. What we had to do and what we did in order to get him there. He may not even know that I was involved. He may think that I just made a couple of videos and, you know, to say, "Oh, please help." A lot of stuff went on behind those scenes that only HaKadosh Baruch Hu and two other people know. That's it. That's it. My wife and all the fine. Nobody else knows. So trust me when I tell you, I'm not looking for anybody to die. I don't want anyone to die. I want people to do teshuva. But if they don't want to do teshuva, let HaKadosh Baruch Hu uproot them. Why? That's the reality. That is the reality. It's better for them to be uprooted if they don't want to do teshuva. It's better for them. And this is how the Chachamim write in their sefarim. ...this is how the Chachamim write in their sefarim. Time and time again, we have some of the Chachamim that literally were the most sensitive to people in the world, the most sensitive people in the world. But they see something and say, "Oh, if they don't do teshuva, it's better that there's some type of takala, some type of accident happens, and this person is just eliminated from the world. That would be great for them." Literally, that's what they write in their sefarim.

1:14:55So it's not that you want them to die because that's going to give you some type of pleasure. It's sad. They have kids. They have wives. They have a life. They have people and so on. So again, don't focus on the people and their personalities, actions, actions, the actions themselves. All of them are making very, very serious mistakes. Trust me when I tell you, they're going to regret it. they don't do a lot more than you hate it a lot more than I hate it. They're going to regret it if they don't do teshuva. But it's important for people to know that the goal is to help everyone do teshuva. That's the goal. It's never to be a winner of the argument, to look good, to make money, to be more popular. None of that stuff matters to me. None of that stuff should matter to you. only thing that should matter is to help people do teshuva even if that means that we're gonna get a newswire Manis Friedman

1:15:58decides to do teshuva and regrets every single lecture he's done over the last X amount of years and deletes them from YouTube. Issues a public apology to Klal Yisrael and says, do not believe anything that I said. From now on, I'm going to follow Da'at Torah. Guess what? I will be the first one that says Manis Friedman is a tzaddik. He's a gadol hador. He's amazing. He's the greatest. Why? He did teshuva. But until then, he's a rasha merusha. That's an apikores that goes against the Torah and it says to people that HaKadosh Baruch Hu needs us. But until then, if he does teshuva, amazing. Same thing with Ephraim, same thing with everybody else. Currently, we have to hate them. But not hate them personally, hate their actions. We want them to do teshuva. Is it possible for them to do teshuva? Only HaKadosh Baruch Hu knows. According to the Rambam, it's almost impossible. once a person becomes an apikores, it's almost impossible. But "almost impossible" does not mean literally impossible. It means it's really difficult. They literally have to develop a humility, like in order to do teshuva, because they have to do teshuva in public just like their sins were public. So it's very difficult. So they can do it, or HaKadosh Baruch Hu would not allow them to live.

1:17:21but if they don't want to do teshuva, what can I tell you? But we do not want people to die. Let's not ever make this mistake. I've said this once, twice, several times in the past, and I'm saying it again: we want people to do teshuva. Don't go hunting for heretics. Trust me, if HaKadosh Baruch Hu wants you to know about a heretic, they will come to you themselves. to help people, not to call them out and say, "Oh, he's a heretic, he's this, he's that." Try to help him if you can, but if you see this person is unhelpful, he's not at a stage in his life to be helped, he doesn't want to be helped, he rejects all truth, then you have to run away from him. You have to kick him out. You have to, uh, do whatever you can. If he's a public speaker of some kind or a public influence, you have to protest against him. You have to, uh, speak against him. but it's nothing for the sake of uplifting yourself or for any type of benefit whatsoever. There is, you know, other than doing the will of HaShem, there's no benefit in doing any of this stuff. People think that, oh yeah, it's great. Nothing great about it.

1:18:28It's sad. It's sad to know that there's going to be countless people that are going to go to Gehinom without coming out. Trust me when I tell you it's sad. If you knew 5% of what I know about what happens after this life, you would cry for these people. Not because you have mercy for them now. You don't have to have mercy for them now. You have mercy for them because of what's going to happen to them when they can't help themselves, when they leave this world. And HaKadosh Baruch Hu is going to punish them to no end. To no end, the Holocaust becomes like a kindergarten game next to what's going to happen to these people if they don't do teshuva. Trust me when I tell you, when I think about this stuff, I cry. Because nothing can help them once they leave this world. Nothing, nothing, no Kaddish. Nothing, nothing can help them. Nothing. They can build five yeshivot in their name and it won't help them. Nothing can help them. If they leave this world this way, nothing can help them. And you have no idea what's going to happen to these people and their supporters. The people that donated money and resources to Ephraim, or to Manis, or to Meza, or any of these reshaim. You have no idea what HaKadosh Baruch Hu is going to do to them if they leave this world this way. You have no idea.

1:19:40People have no concept of what happens after this life. No concept of anything. People are clueless. They think we live in some IOU where HaKadosh Baruch Hu owes us stuff. People have no idea. Nothing. No clue whatsoever what happens after this world. And trust me when I tell you, you will not want, even if you end up going to Gan Eden, you will not want to know that there are people in Gehinom once you know what's in it. You have no idea what happens in those places. No idea. There is no reason in the world for anyone to be happy that someone is a wicked person. We have to know that these people are also HaKadosh Baruch Hu's kids, and we want them to do teshuva. But we cannot, under any condition, accept their current behavior as acceptable. We have to protest for the sake of HaKadosh Baruch Hu's name and honor. We have to speak against them. We have to do everything possible that's allowed according to halacha to discredit them in every single way. You're even allowed to say Lashon Hara about people like this. You're even allowed to make up stuff if you want if it's going to help people stay away from them. But it doesn't mean that we want them to die this way. These are HaKadosh Baruch Hu's children.

1:21:04at the same token, who has lost for himself that although they are His children, once they have forsaken Him, once they have gone against Him, He is obligated to punish them, just like a mother who has children that she put her whole life on the line to raise them those kids one day just decide, "We don't want to play with you, we don't want to listen to you, we don't want to love you," and that mother, her heart is broken into 50 million pieces. But at the same time, she knows that if she allows them to continue behaving this way, those kids will become little Hitlers. Those kids will become a disaster and not only a pain for her, but a pain for society. Therefore, she is forced to punish those kids in order to have them behave better. Does she enjoy punishing them? No, she hates it. She suffers more than them, but she has to do it.

1:22:11The same thing happens with HaKadosh Baruch Hu, le'havdil, Melech Elef Avdalot. He has to punish His children. Why? For the sake of the Torah itself and for the sake of His righteous people. And if that means He has to punish His children who went against Him, who caused other people to go against Him, the highest level of punishment, to the point of complete annihilation after the ultimate suffering, to destroy their neshama—things that you have no concept of what they mean—who still doesn't and has to do it in order maintain the honor of his Torah, his name, and of course his other children that sacrificed their lives to uphold both. We do not want anyone to be on the bad side. We want everyone to be on the good side. But that's not a reality. The reality is that there's going to be some people on the bad side. We hope they do teshuva.

1:23:27is asking the gentiles who are related by patrilineal heritage to Bnei Yisrael learned the entire Torah, including the Oral Torah, the Midrashim, the Zohar, and the Kabbalah concepts, etc., during the months in the womb. If a person is halachically Jewish, meaning his mother is Jewish, even if she's secular. If his mother is Jewish, then while she is carrying him in her belly, he's learning the entire Torah. But again, that does not mean that he will be righteous. It does not mean that he's going to follow it because he also has his own tikkun. There's a reason why he or she is coming to the world. everyone learns the Torah because this is, in essence, part of what is instilled in a person in order for them to be able to serve Hashem. If it was solely up to us to learn and love from zero, we would not be able to do it; we would not be able to succeed. So, in essence, when we learn Torah, we're being reminded of what we already know. So, when a person learns Torah...

1:24:47it's good in its essence as a reminder, but because they have a certain klipah due to their own misbehavior in the previous reincarnation, they'll have certain limitations that they'll have to break. This means they'll have to do certain things, take certain actions, in order to overcome certain barriers that their very same neshama that learned Torah... has, you know, before it allows certain things to enter it. So there is a, you know, there's a benefit, of course, for a person to be born Jewish because he has that Torah in him, but it's not a free lunch. Same thing with people that, you know, are born not Jewish. There is a great benefit for them to convert, of course, but it's not easy. But people say, oh yeah, but isn't it much easier for the Jew to do teshuva than it is for the convert to convert? Not necessarily true. It's not necessarily true. For some, yes. For some, no. Some people, they discover the truth and they take it with both arms and both legs and run with it for the rest of their life.

1:26:06a boat on the Jewish side and on the gentile side, and some people see the truth clear as day and stay wicked both on the Jewish side and the non-Jewish side. So, it's being a Jew uh is uh of course there are certain benefits to it, but there are also benefits in being a non-Jew that converts because you have certain merits and certain things that you can never get, you know, for a Jew that who is their father. The convert, Hashem is their father and their mother, which gives them special protection. from certain enemies and so on and so forth. But again, I don't think people need to focus so much on where they started and where they were. I think it's really more important to focus on what we're doing today. What are you doing today? And b'ezrat Hashem, that is the only thing that could help tomorrow. Next question, Nikolai is asking, Reish Lakish says, learning Torah prevents the world from tohu vavohu, from destruction. Rabbi Yochanan says,

1:27:20Oh wait, I just lost your question. What happened to your question? Sorry. Reish Lakish says learning Torah builds the world. It's my second Shabbat, okay. Is it an argument which one does what? It's not necessarily an argument; it does both. It does both. The Torah, there's a verse that is used for it, eliminates destruction. It says that, it says to the prophet, if not for people learning Torah, the rules that I use to run the world will cease to exist. Meaning there's not going to be gravity, there's not going to be air, there's not going to be any, all of the physical and the metaphysical, all of the different things that HaKadosh Baruch Hu uses, the tools that He uses. it says that, it says to the prophet, if not for people learning Torah, the rules that I use to run the world will cease to exist. Meaning there's not going to be gravity, there's not going to be air, there's not going to be any, all of the physical and the metaphysical, all of the different things that HaKadosh Baruch Hu uses, the tools that He uses. to run the world will cease to exist, which in essence would mean that the atoms will stop spinning, the atoms that make up everything. And once they stop spinning, the world will simply disappear. It's not that it will explode or it'll just simply disappear as if it never existed.

1:28:39So in order for the world to exist, in order for the atom to continue spinning, there have to be people learning Torah. There has to be somebody learning Torah in the world. Therefore, that person that's learning Torah has to assume, perhaps I'm the only person in the world that's learning Torah. therefore keeping the world from disaster. In fact, he believed this a hundred percent, and he built his yeshiva in such a fashion where he had multiple shifts of people learning Torah in his yeshiva in order to make sure that there's somebody learning in his yeshiva 24 hours a day. There was always somebody learning, so people would come for one shift, and there was another, like companies today that operate 24 hours a day. You know, they have different shifts. That's how Rabbi Chaim Volozhin operated his yeshiva. Why? Because he took this verse to heart. He knew that it's a reality. It is possible that there is nobody else in the world to study Torah. And it's not like HaKadosh Baruch Hu says, oh, if they don't study Torah for a few days or for a few hours or for a few months, then I'll destroy the world. No, he says, if there's a second, a single second where a...

1:29:50People don't learn Torah, then the rules of the world will cease to exist, the world will simply disappear. On the other hand, one of the things you can look at for Rabbi Yochanan that supports Rabbi Yochanan's argument that he says the Torah builds the world, is first and foremost to know that the world only exists because of the Torah. Where in the Gemara Masechet Shabbat, it says that HaKadosh Baruch Hu said to the creation, on Friday, that if Am Yisrael accepts the Torah at Mount Sinai, then the world will continue to exist and will arrive on Shabbat. But if it doesn't, I'm going to destroy the entire world. This is the reason why in the verses in Genesis, in Bereishit, it says... meaning it was evening, it was morning, it was first day; it was evening, it was morning, it was second day; and so on and so forth. But then, when it comes to the sixth day, which is the day that He made the deal with the two witnesses, which are the heaven and the earth, He says there was an added "hey" to "Yom HaShishi," meaning the sixth day.

1:30:59So the Chachamim ask why there is an added "hey" in this word that wasn't in all of the other days. They explain that this "hey" is symbolic of the deal that Hashem made with, in essence, Himself, with the Torah. The witnesses were the heaven and the earth, and the "hey" is symbolic of the five books of Moses. So the world continues to exist because of the Torah, and the world is built upon it. But needless to say, there is also a Mishnah in Avot that says that if it weren't for the Torah and the laws of the Torah, people would eat each other alive. and we saw that happen throughout history, and we see it today. So, both are right. And so, it's not a machloket but rather it's an essence; these and these are the words of the living God. Robert is asking, and I read about the laws of the primary and secondary blessings regarding food.

1:32:05I became confused about that. I was under the impression that one says the blessings in order from mezonot up to shehakol, with the exception that bread is above all. And we only do hamotzi or birkat hamazon. Please explain and elaborate on the laws of primary and secondary blessings regarding food. I mean, it's written in the article. I'm not really sure what you want me to explain. The article is actually very good. They explain the things you have to... In short, there's a primary food and a secondary food. Meaning, primary food, meaning this is the main thing that's going to satiate you. So, typically it's bread. If it's not bread, then it's something that's mezonot. But there are certain things that are not typically part of a meal. And therefore, even if you've said, let's say, the hamotzi, you'd still have to do a borei pri ha'etz. Meaning, if, let's say, you did a hamotzi to eat bread.

1:33:06uh, and, uh, but, uh, as part of your meal, and you're eating bread, you're eating rice, you're eating everything, but then your wife decides to give you, I don't know, a cup of tea or coffee or, uh, or an apple. Those things are not a typical part of a meal; therefore, you have to do a secondary blessing on those, uh, as if, you know, they're a separate blessing. Uh, so there are things like that that are involved in regards to saying which blessing first. Now, there are different opinions on which blessing is first and which one is second. But generally speaking, it's like you said. However, it depends. There are certain circumstances. I simply can't go over every single possible circumstance because I think it's not feasible. Jeremy, in the story where Rabbi Yishmael said the Shem HaMephorash and traveled to the heavens, how was he allowed to use the name? Isn't the name only allowed to be used during Yom Kippur confession by the Kohen Gadol? This is considered something equivalent to...

1:34:21I guess Kabbalah Ma'asit, where certain people will do certain things for the sake of Klal Yisrael. Kabbalah Ma'asit is the mystical aspect of Kabbalah that very few people in the world know. It's not something you're going to learn anywhere. It's not something that you're going to find in a book either. It's something that you can only learn from a Kabbalist, a real Kabbalist. But that real Kabbalist is only going to teach you after you are already an extraordinary talmid chacham and a scholar and a very righteous person, and after many, many years of toiling and suffering that you bring on yourself, and so on. But in essence, some of these Kabbalists have abilities to say specific names of HaKadosh Baruch Hu in order to change nature. There's a story that Rav Mazuz said that the Rambam used this at least one time where he showed the king of, I think it was the king of Egypt, that he could travel from place to place

1:35:28in an instant. And there are other types of stories where different Chachamim did certain things in order to help Klal Yisrael. They would say something or do a certain type of act, and somebody would die in a different state. in a very unusual way, you know, all types of interesting things. But these types of things are not allowed to be done for an individual, only allowed to be done if it's for Klal Yisrael. So when the Chachamim in the Gemara would do certain things like this, they would do it for Klal Yisrael. But also remember that there's a Chachamim—the word actually, the koran So they would say, they would do certain things, they would go into the Kodesh HaKodeshim. There's Rabbi Yishmael; there's a very interesting story where HaKadosh Baruch Hu came to him. And it's a very unusual story, to say the least. But he was, you know, a unique person, to say the least. So unique that HaKadosh Baruch Hu put the face of Malach Gavriel on him.

1:36:45He looked exactly like Malach Gavriel, Rabbi Yishmael. So, there's a lot of things that... There, I would say that the default that a person should always have is that the sages are right for what they did, and then try to figure out how, versus thinking, oh, maybe they made a mistake, and they're always right, it's just that we have to figure out why. In this particular case, I think it was for Klal Yisrael, and I believe he was a Kohen Gadol anyway. is asking, I have a question about science. I'm not entirely sure how a Jew is to believe, per se, in Hashem. I'm not entirely sure how a Jew is to believe, per se, in Hashem. Does he need to do it your way and Rabbi Mizrahi's way, which is with irrefutable proof, or the Rebbe's way, which is to be simple with God and believe based solely on the mass revelation of Mount Sinai or the supposition in the soul? I don't have a way. Rabbi Mizrahi doesn't have a way.

1:38:07The Rebbe doesn't have a way either. there is no way. You teach Torah, and the person learns Torah and follows it. Certain things affect his neshama; certain things don't affect his neshama. Certain things help him get closer to Hashem; certain things don't help him get closer to Hashem. The key is to make sure that you're doing whatever you can in order to get closer to Hashem, in order to do the will of Hashem, foolproof, without any exceptions. uh, that's the key. You know, so it's not a matter of my way or somebody else's way. It's whatever way is going to get you to serve Hashem at the highest level, where you're going to have the highest level of yirat Shamayim (fear of the Almighty), and you're going to learn the most amount of Torah, and you're going to have the highest level of... And if that's going to come through my teachings, if it's going to come through somebody else's teachings, the key is to make sure that you're going to do whatever is necessary that affects your neshama. Now, as far as the way we teach, we teach different things. We have a different way of communicating. It's not the only way to communicate, but nonetheless, it's an effective way. But not all of my lectures affect all of my audience. Some of my lectures affect some audience. Some of my lectures affect other audiences. For example, the movie that we just publicized with the scientific, "The Signature of God."

1:39:16We teach different things. We have a different way of communicating. It's not the only way to communicate, but nonetheless, it's an effective way. But not all of my lectures affect all of my audience. Some of my lectures affect some audiences. Some of my lectures affect other audiences. For example, the movie that we just publicized with the scientific, "The Signature of God." People that watched it, literally, you know, loved it so much. They started writing me letters, making phone calls, and sending messages. I mean, the people that watched it are enamored by it to the equivalent of how it was like Mount Sinai. I'm sure some people that watched it maybe weren't as enamored by it, but... The people that did watch it, a lot of them, you know, are sending messages of thanks, saying their whole lives have changed now. And these are people that have already been watching shiurim and being part of our learning on a regular basis for years. But this movie had a very, very big impact on them.

1:40:20But surely there are certain things, certain lectures that we'll have, that are not going to affect some of those very same people. You know, some people don't like it when I talk against rabbis because they simply just don't want to hear it. They know we're right. They know that it's the truth. They just don't want to hear it. They want to pretend like everything is okay in the world. Okay, fine, it's their choice. I don't agree with it, but that doesn't make a difference. The point is, it's their choice. Some people don't want to listen to anything but, whatever, specific talks about emunah. So if we're talking about other things, they don't want to talk about it. So different people, different things affect them. But the key is for a person to know that whoever you're listening to has to be somebody that's getting you closer to HaKadosh Baruch Hu. And in fact, there was a chiddush that I got from the Midrash Rabbah, Parashat Yitro, where it says, based on the words "And Yitro heard." So Chachamim say, from there we learn that Am Yisrael said "Na'aseh" — that we will do, and then we will hear. But after they sinned with the golden calf,

1:41:36After they sinned with the golden calf, they ruined it. But not ruined it completely, because HaKadosh Baruch Hu allowed us to do teshuva. So what did they ruin? They ruined half the blessing. They ruined half the blessing, which was na'aseh. not said that we will do and then we will hear that not say it was ruined but what we will have left we have Nishma. So I thought perhaps since we only have, for the last three thousand three hundred thirty-four years, Nishma to hold us up as a nation, perhaps that's the reason why HaKadosh Baruch Hu used, as one of His infinite amount of reasons, the internet as and the media as a way for Him to communicate to His children because the only thing we have left is nishma. The only thing we have left is nishma. The only thing we have left is to hear, to hear, to hear. But a person needs to know they have to hear the right person; they have to hear the truth. They have to be very careful with whom they hear. Why? Because the only thing you have left

1:42:40That's the only thing you have left. So if you're hearing me, or you're hearing Rabbi Mizrahi, or you're hearing anybody else out there, you know, you have to make sure that you're hearing the truth and you're hearing somebody that's getting you closer to Hashem, making you a better servant of HaKadosh Baruch Hu, making you learn more Torah, making you have higher emunah, more excitement to serve Hashem and so on. But if a person is just simply pacifying you, then obviously that's not good. If a person talks about subjects ...that are, you know, disgusting to you or they simply make you more distant from Hashem, then don't listen to them. You know, you have to listen to the people that are helping you, that are getting you closer... But it's not necessarily that the same things that are going to work for you are going to work for somebody else or what works for somebody else is going to work for you. Some people are fascinated, and I can even say addicted, to Torah proofs. They want Torah proofs. They want scientific proofs, medical proofs, physiological proofs, archaeological proofs, every proof they can possibly find.

1:43:46Some people don't necessarily care so much about the proof. They just like to learn about morality, how to be better people, more kind, and more this and more that. Some people, they want to know the divinity of the Torah. They want to know mysticism, all types of different miracles. And some people like to hear stories. All types of extraordinary stories. Everybody has their neshama tuned in a certain way. You have to make sure that you are, you know, going towards where your neshama is tuned. But again, sometimes the yetzer hara tells you that it's tuned towards the wrong direction. So you have to check yourself. have to check yourself because, like I said, you only have nishma, you only have "we will hear" left. You don't have na'aseh; you have only half the blessing that we got on Mount Sinai, in essence. So a person has to be careful not to be a shome'a, not to hear the wrong people, not to hear the heresy, not to hear the apikorsut that's out there. and you have to make sure that you're testing yourself, you're checking yourself, and you're constantly steering yourself in the right direction. That's helping you serve Hashem on a higher level. As long as you're serving Hashem on a higher level on a regular basis, that means you're going in the right direction. Generally speaking, it's not recommended for people to focus all of their energy on any one particular issue altogether.

1:45:08It doesn't matter what the issue is. It's bad for a person to focus all of their energy on one thing, and that's the reason why we generally don't focus all of our energy on one subject. We give different shiurim, even though there are certain things that repeat themselves, where we teach morality and the different aspects of how you can learn it in different ways, or we'll speak against the immorality, or we'll speak about wigs, idolatry, you know, and you know, against Christianity, and on and on. There are different things that come up on a regular basis, but it's very important for a person not to focus on one particular issue because typically those people end up falling. They end up falling, unfortunately, and there's actually a masorah from one of the gedolim of Yisrael that says that the people that converted during the time of the Spanish Inquisition, the people that converted to Christianity in order to save their lives, not because they necessarily believed in Christianity, but because they wanted to save their lives, were the intellectuals.

1:46:20were the intellectuals. They were the people that had scientific, medical, physiological, and archaeological proofs of why Hashem is who He is and the Torah is divine. But they still abandoned Him at the moment of truth, whereas the people that either fled, leaving everything behind or the people that were willing and died for the sake of the Torah were the simple people. Meaning the people that had simple emunah, "I believe in Hashem, I don't necessarily need any scientist to show me Hashem, I already know Hashem, I see Hashem." So there is a verse in the Torah that says to be simple with Hashem, but it also means to be complete with Hashem. So to be simple with Hashem is okay as long as you're complete with Hashem. But if you are simple with Hashem, but that simplicity causes you to have doubts, then that simplicity is not complete. So you have to fill in that gap. If the gap is going to be filled through scientific proofs, medical proofs, archaeological proofs, mussar teachings, teachings about reward and punishment,

1:47:27uh teachings of uh different uh sages and how great they are. Whatever is missing in that gap, you have to put it in so as to eliminate any doubt, any doubt in your neshama, and to get you to serve Hashem at the highest possible level. Whether I have the merit to be the one that's going to be the vessel to give you that truth or somebody else will, you have to make sure that you're getting it. If I have the merit, I'll be the one. If somebody else has the merit, they're praiseworthy and they'll be the one. The key is for you to have it. That's really the key. That's the most important part. And anybody that actually cares about helping people get closer to Hashem doesn't really care whether they get closer to Hashem through himself or through somebody else. They just want people to get closer to Hashem. that's really the whole goal. There's no debating because it's not a battle. It's not a battle between people; it's a battle for neshamot. You're trying to save people, so that's the key. Okay, quick question. Chaz is asking, is the story of the Golem of Prague true? Some say it's a Bubeh Maisa. The Golem of Prague is, according to the information that I've looked up, 100% true. And not only is it 100% true, there's actually a place in Prague that has a memorial for this Golem.

1:48:47so it's not like something that you'll just find in books. You could actually go to a place and see the story, see the building. I mean, this is a real event that took place, and it's not the only time that such a thing happened. What they did, what the Chachamim did, because the goyim were constantly attacking and kidnapping Jews, was they took... The name of HaKadosh Baruch Hu, similar to what the Kohen Gadol would have on his tzitz, was placed on the forehead of the golem, and that gave it life. And that golem was operational and protecting Am Yisrael. And once the threat stopped, which obviously took some time, the golem no longer had a use. So the chacham took the holy name out of him, and that's it. He went back to being nothing. But yeah, this is not necessarily the...

1:50:02only time something like this happened and, in fact, the Gaon of Vilna, the Gaon, told his talmid, uh, is it the Gaon? Yeah, the Gaon of Vilna, no, maybe the Arizal. Was it? Where he, uh, uh, for some reason, uh, my brain always confuses the Gaon and the, uh, and Arizal. uh but either way, one of them told his talmid that they already had the working knowledge and were already building a golem at eight years old. They were such a gaon, such a genius in Torah, that they were already building a golem at eight years old. And the chachamim found out about it and came and asked him to stop; they asked him not to do it. And in fact, in one of the sefarim, I believe it's actually the Arizal, now that I think about it, in one of the sefarim, it actually gives the instructions on how to do it, how to build a golem. So this stuff exists. It's not like bubbe meises for people that don't want to believe, but this stuff exists. It does exist. It has existed. There's a lot of interesting things that...

1:51:11Am Yisrael has gone through and has done. One thing that we have as a nation is we have more documented proofs for all of the things that ever happened to us than all of the nations put together. We have more documented proofs for the things that happened to us than they have fictional proofs for their fictional stories. That's just to give you an idea. Okay, one or two more questions and then we're done for the night. I still have to get some energy for the next shiur. Steve, is it appropriate to help a Jew fulfill an obligation in the area of machloket, for example, getting a pair of Rabbeinu Tam tefillin for a Chabadnik that's not married, assuming the giver doesn't hold that position? I mean, I don't see how spending $1,000 or $2,000 or $3,000 on tefillin that he's really, you know, only according to the Chabadnik should be using. I'm not really sure how that's going to help him in his life. If he's in such a kehillah,

1:52:24that they are rebuking him for not buying himself Rabbeinu Tam tefillin, then he should leave that kehillah just because of that. That's a very sick kehillah. But the point is that I don't think that you'll be smart to invest in such a thing. I think it's better for you to use that same kind of money to go give an avreich, money to somebody that learns Torah all day, and have them learn Torah all month. You'll get a lot more merit for that than for this. But as far as your last question in regards to, you know, if the person that you're giving it to has a different halacha than you do or a different minhag than you do, that in itself should not stop you from helping them. You're not helping them fulfill what you want. You're helping them fulfill what they want as long as what they want is good. That in itself shouldn't stop you from helping them. But generally speaking, I don't really think giving him a Rabbeinu Tam Tefillin is going to help him.

1:53:36uh why doesn't Chabad do something about Manis Friedman after it's proven that he supports pedophiles? Ask Chabad. I can't speak for them. Ask Chabad. There's a lot of things that Chabad does that the world doesn't agree with, and they stay quiet about. There's a lot of things that, uh, other people do that is forbidden that the world doesn't speak about. So you have to ask them. So, are we allowed to listen to classical music? How about old Hebrew songs, old French and Persian music, all male singers? If it's secular music that is talking about, you know, the love between a man and a woman and things of that nature, then no. If it's just music, if it's just instrumental, no problem, you can listen to it. Once the lyrics are involved, then it's very problematic because typically what people sing about are things that are forbidden to us.

1:54:39They sing about girlfriends and boyfriends, promiscuity, and all types of inappropriate behavior, and so on and so forth. It doesn't matter whether it's a male or female singer; it's still forbidden. So, generally speaking, the type of music that I could tell you that you could feel safe listening to is either Jewish music or instrumental music. instrumental, uh, like classical music, is perfectly fine, or any other type of instrumental music, regardless of whether it's instrumental Middle Eastern, uh, whether it's classical Middle Eastern, or whatever it is. If it's instrumental, typically, it's okay to listen to, uh, you know, and that's fine. But once there are lyrics, that's where the problems begin, and typically it's forbidden. Uh, based on the Torah, Yosef is asking the Chachamim what is the correct measure of hishtadlut. Uh, the hishtadlut should be determined based on the person's emunah. The higher the level of emunah that they have...

1:55:44meaning the higher the level their faith is in Hashem and how much they believe that Hashem is monitoring everything and is going to help them, that should determine how much effort they should exert. If they believe 100% in Hashem, that Hashem will take care of them no matter what, then they should simply learn Torah all day and never go to any regular job. If they believe in Hashem 90%, then they should work for 10% and learn Torah 90% of the time. If they believe 50%, then they should work 50% and learn Torah 50%. If they believe 10%, then they should work on themselves, but they should work a lot more than somebody else. So the effort is determined based on the belief. And how does a person know if they really have emunah in Hashem? based on how much you're worrying. If you're worried, then you obviously have doubts. So the more a person has anxiety and worry, the more they have to work, meaning exert effort. Okay, last question. Let's see, somebody didn't ask any questions.

1:57:09Okay, okay, so you didn't ask any questions. How much of our tithe should we save for the Beit HaMikdash? Also, will the synagogues be paying a percentage to the Temple when it's built? Uh, save money for the Beit HaMikdash? No, you don't need to save money for the Beit HaMikdash. In fact... There was actually originally a decree that people who converted to Judaism had to save a certain amount of money on the side for when the Mashiach comes. ...uh, why? Because as soon as the Mashiach comes, they would have to complete their conversion that they can't complete now by bringing the sacrifice. In essence, the conversion is supposed to be the same thing that Am Yisrael did. Am Yisrael accepted the Torah, they did the Brit Milah, and they brought a sacrifice...

1:58:14Now, a person that converts today, they accept the Torah, they do Brit Milah if it's relevant, but there's no sacrifice. So, the law was that a convert would have to save a certain amount of money on the side, the Gemara says, in order to be able to buy a cow to bring a sacrifice as soon as the Mashiach comes. But then, comes Rabbi and canceled it. said no, this is not a... the people can't uphold such a law, and he relieved you of any need to save any money for the Beit HaMikdash. Why? Because you can use it right now and need to use it right now to do mitzvot, to serve Hashem better now. Because that's what's going to help you serve Hashem better, and that's what's going to help HaKadosh Baruch Hu justify bringing the Mashiach who will build the Beit HaMikdash. so it's a uh it's it's we have to be worried about today, not worried about uh having money tomorrow. Surely if somebody has the merit to live to see uh and uh the Mashiach and the Beit HaMikdash, surely Hakadosh Baruch Hu is going to make uh everything else that they need also available too. uh it comes as a package deal.

1:59:33Okay, thank you very much for learning Torah with me. Bless each and every single one of you to get closer and closer to the highest possible level, to help Am Yisrael and the rest of the world, including all of the enemies of Hashem. ...of the Torah for them to serve because, at the end of the day, that's all we want. We want the world to serve HaKadosh Baruch Hu. We want the world to praise HaKadosh Baruch Hu. We want the world to love HaKadosh Baruch Hu, to fear HaKadosh Baruch Hu, to do what HaKadosh Baruch Hu has commanded us to do because that's the whole purpose of the world... That's why HaKadosh Baruch Hu created the world, because doing all of that is for our own good, not for His. He's already perfect, but serving Him, honoring Him, fearing Him, loving Him, it's for our own good. So to do all He wants us to do, in essence, in serving Him, is in essence giving ourselves the best gift we could possibly give. Baruch Adonai le'olam, amen ve'amen.

2:06:06I bless the rabbis. Wait, wait. I bless the rabbis, Rabbi Yaron Reuven, Rabbi Efraim Kachlon, the leaders of Yerovam and Yisrael Hashem, that they will be blessed with success, that they will rise to the top, that they will be blessed with success, that they will be blessed with success, that they will be blessed with success, that they will be blessed with success. Yes. I bless the rabbis, Rabbi Yaron Reuven and Rabbi Efraim Kachlon, the leaders of Yerovam and Yisrael Hashem, that they will be blessed with success, that they will rise to the top, and that they will be blessed with success.

BH Headquarters