BeEzrat HaShem

thanksgiving=idolworship

7 months ago

thanksgiving=idolworship 00:00:00 Intoduction 00:00:00 Thanksgiving: A Halakhic Inquiry 00:00:06 Why Annual Celebration is Forbidden 00:00:32 Eating Turkey: Context Matters

Transcript

0:00Good evening, dear talmidim. We often encounter questions regarding our participation in practices of the general society, particularly those that carry cultural or quasi-religious significance for the nations around us. Our Chazal and later poskim have provided clear guidance on the strict separation required of a Yehudi from chukot haGoyim, especially when there is even a remote connection to avodah zarah or specific religious observances of other faiths. Therefore, a pressing she'eilah that many Yidden face is this: Is it allowed to celebrate Thanksgiving? Not for Jews. Not for Jews. As HaGaon Rav David Yosef shlit"a explained in a recent shiur, this celebration, beyond any secular veneer, possesses deep roots connected to Christian religious practices. The fact that it is observed annually at a fixed time, for reasons that are, at their core, religious for the general population, renders it problematic. Our halakha considers such an observance a form of chukat haGoyim and, given its historical background, potentially even hinting at avodah zarah. Therefore, for us, for bnei Yisrael, it is unequivocally forbidden. We must always remember our unique identity as Am Segula and carefully guard our minhagim and halakhot, ensuring we do not blur the lines between sacred and profane, or between our holy path and the ways of the nations. May HaKadosh Baruch Hu grant us the siyata d'Shmaya to always observe His Mitzvos precisely and purely. Moving on from the specifics of kashrut on that particular day, let us address the more fundamental halakhic issue concerning the observance of Thanksgiving itself. As we have discussed, even the lenient poskim who permitted eating turkey once in a lifetime emphasized that it should not become an annual practice or a form of celebration. This brings us to the deeper point, as elucidated by Gedolim of our generation. For example, Rav David Yosef gave a shiur a couple of years ago, explaining that Thanksgiving not only has a connection to Christian idolatry, but it is also considered problematic because its annual celebration for religious reasons renders it completely forbidden. This ruling highlights the grave nature of participating in such a day. It is unequivocally assur for a Jew to celebrate Thanksgiving annually, as it constitutes a clear violation of chukat ha'goy, which we are strictly commanded to avoid. Indeed, while enjoying turkey or other festive foods is perfectly permissible on any regular day, to observe this specific day as a holiday is fundamentally incompatible with our Torah lifestyle and mesorah.

0:32Now, regarding the specific issue of eating turkey on this particular day, even for the Jews, and even the few poskim who said it would be allowed for a Jew to eat turkey, you know, on that day, they only allowed it to be done once in a lifetime, meaning not to be done every year or anything like that. So certainly it's not for the Jews to celebrate. If you want to eat turkey, you could eat turkey any day of the year. So, to be absolutely clear, while turkey itself is a kosher food and certainly permissible to eat, associating it with a celebration that is not rooted in our mesorah is something we must avoid. Our simcha comes from our Torah and mitzvot.

BH Headquarters