BeEzrat HaShem

Wigs (Sheitel) versus Tichel (Head Scarf) A New Perspective

9 years ago

Rabbi Yaron Reuven discusses the debate over wearing wigs (sheitel) versus head scarves (tichel) in Judaism. He highlights concerns about wig origins from temples associated with idol worship. Rabbi Reuven emphasizes the importance of adhering to Jewish law and moral integrity, urging women to consider the source of their wigs. He questions the desire to emulate immodest figures and encourages adherence to traditional values. Full Shiur: MUSSAR Pirkei Avot (12) Valuable Words Priceless Silence https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aBTyeombSVg These Indian Women Thought Their Hair Was Going To The Gods.But It Ended Up In Wigs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eQiFpNKgGTk&list=PLfeqUDL5aojb62wRko79TIJLC7U4NAOEY&index=73&t=0s The WIG DEBATE 2019/5779 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o4Ibb6CtXus&list=PLfeqUDL5aojb62wRko79TIJLC7U4NAOEY&index=70 To Support our KIRUV and Torah Teachings work please DONATE at www.BeEzratHaShem.org If you'd like to invite Rabbi Yaron Reuven to give a lecture at your synagogue, home or office. Rabbi Reuven is based out of Florida but travels to give lectures to different groups. Join one of our interactive "Interesting Torah" Whatsapp groups to get daily updates and short Torah clips that can uplift your day by texting 1.917.468.2324 or +91 93236 69880 Click here https://soundcloud.com/yaronreuven/se... To Listen to our very popular "Daily Chidush" short audio series on SOUNDCLOUD or the Podcast Channel at https://beezrathashem.jewishpodcasts.... Born in Netanya, Israel, Rabbi Yaron Reuven began his American Dream as a little boy, when his family immigrated to the United States. He went from a newspaper boy at the age of 10, to a well-known self-made Wall Street multimillionaire by the age of 23. During his time in Wall Street, he owned his own private brokerage firm, a hedge fund, and an international insurance agency. He was featured on CNBC, Bloomberg and Chinese NDTV due to his success in the financial industry. At age 26 he faced a 7-year battle for his life when a simple surgery went wrong. From that moment his life would never be the same. This moment marked the start of a series of miraculous events and an exciting pursuit of truth, ultimately resulting in Rabbi Reuven renouncing his lofty position and success in Wall Street, after 16 years, to become a full-time KIRUV rabbi. His Teshuva story is sure to catch the heart of every listener.​ Rabbi Reuven’s shiurim are in English and Hebrew. His classes are focused on spreading the truth and divinity of the Torah through MUSSAR, scientific proofs, and many other methods to reach each individual listener. Rabbi Reuven is the leading educator on the topic of wasting seed in the English language with over 30 hrs of content published online. Rabbi Yaron Reuven is a proud member of the Igud HaRabbonim (The Rabbinical Alliance of America), a national rabbinic organization founded in 1942. Today, our 900+ members are congregational leaders, religious teachers, chaplains, heads of Jewish organizations and communal leaders united in their commitment to traditional Orthodox Judaism. For more information please visit: https://rabbinicalalliance.org/ #wigs #sheitel #tichel #judaism #jewish #rabbiyaronreuven #headcovering #Wigs #Sheitels #Modesty #Judaism #Jewish #RabbiYaronReuven #Torah #Kiruv #Tzniut #JewishLaw #JewishTradition #OrthodoxJudaism #JewishOutreach #JewishEducation #TorahLearning #JewishPractice #JewishCommunity 00:00:00 Intoduction 00:00:02 The Wig Controversy in Judaism 00:00:30 Misinterpretations and Sephardic Views 00:01:11 Rav Tzion Abba Shaul's Opinion Clarified 00:02:02 Hair Covering and Mixed Prayer Settings 00:02:56 Conflicting Interpretations & Family Practices 00:03:55 Following Hashem vs. Following People 00:05:05 Ashkenazi Poskim and Modesty 00:06:09 Historical Wig Appearance vs. Today's Wigs 00:07:04 Majority Opinion Against Wigs & Consequences 00:08:40 The Problem of Avodah Zarah 00:11:36 European Wig Myth & Hair Source Investigation 00:13:22 Wig Processing and the Reality of Origin 00:15:13 Benefiting from Avodah Zarah is Forbidden 00:17:14 Idol Worship vs. Kosher Standards 00:17:41 Seeking Truth, Wig or No Wig 00:18:34 The Sotah and Hair Covering 00:19:32 Inspiration for Covering Hair

Transcript

0:02You know, the whole issue with wigs. Wigs. Now, this is a very, very big machloket; it is a very big dramatic issue in Judaism, and it has been for some time, especially in the recent couple of generations, where a couple of Ashkenazi poskim said that a certain type of wig is allowed, And then people translate it to something completely different, where they're pretty much saying that all wigs are allowed, and not only all wigs are allowed, there are wigs that are more beautiful than natural hair, and you can sweep the floor with the wig, and you're a little movie star. This is not what the Poskim said, even the Ashkenazim. Number two, then you have, yeah, but there were also a couple of Sephardim. And one is saying... that one of the great poskim of Rav Tzion Abba Shaul said, yes, you're allowed to have wigs. And he was Sephardic, which is very rare for a Sephardic to say that wigs are allowed. He was like a machmir.

1:11But no, as a matter of fact, my Rav is a talmid of Rav Gidon Ben Moshe, who is one of the main students of Rav Tzion Abba Shaul, who actually wrote the book with Rav Tzion Abba Shaul that provided the halachic response about whether wigs are allowed or not allowed. And he says, no, Rav Tzion Abba Shaul didn't allow the wig. All he said is that a woman is allowed to wear a wig next to her husband inside the house if he's doing Kriyat Shema. Meaning, if somebody wants to do Kriyat Shema, he's not allowed to do Kriyat Shema next to a woman that doesn't have her hair covered. His wife's hair is not covered, even though she's his wife, he's not allowed to do Kriyat Shema next to her. This is also the problem of what, you know, you go to certain shuls, like Reform and Conservative shuls, where the men and women pray together. It's a problem. Not only a problem that the rabbi is usually a woman or a homosexual, it's also a problem because the people are, you know, mixed. So now, if there's a woman that's not covering her hair,

2:31That is a woman who's not covering her hair. You know how to do kriah. So if she wears a wig, that's sufficient for the husband, her own husband, to do kriah. That's sufficient covering of the hair. He didn't say go outside and cover the hair. Right, so now people mistranslated it. And there's even a machloket, even between another student of his, another student of Rav Tzion Abba Shaul, that according to somebody, I never heard it from the actual student himself, but according to somebody, he says, no, he heard differently. He said that it's okay. Because the problem is that Rav Tzion Abba Shaul, his own wife wore a wig. Now, in the book, Ech Tov LiYisrael, by Rav Ephraim Chachlon, He wrote an answer to this that Gidon ben Moshe said. And he said, listen, when somebody came up to Rav Tzion and said, listen, how do you think you're not allowed to do a wig if your own wife wears a wig? Your daughter-in-law is wearing a wig. How are you saying that? And Rav Tzion said, did you come to me to ask me what's allowed or what do people do? You understand? That's smart right there. So just because his wife did doesn't mean that it's allowed.

3:50so just because his wife did doesn't mean that it's allowed. The same goes when somebody came to Rabbi Ovadia. Rabbi Ovadia, zekhuto yagen aleinu, was very, very strong against wigs. Very strong against wigs. He's recorded multiple times about being very strong against wigs, but somebody, one time a chutzpan came to him in one of the shiurim, said, "How is it that your daughter-in-law, your own daughter—I'm not really sure if it was a daughter or a daughter-in-law—wears a wig? And you're saying not to wear a wig?" Vardiya says, yes, there's a place for "haringe no mosso." There's a place for "haringe no mosso." He wasn't joking around. If everyone is not doing good, then... Why should I do it? You know, it's hard. Because you are obligated to do what Hashem says, not what people do. If you were going to just compare yourself to what people do, then, within a week, you're going to stop keeping everything. Why? Because you have 7.5 billion people. Normal religious people do. Normal religious people is what? A couple of million normal religious people? Out of the couple of million normal religious people, not everybody necessarily has the highest level of emunah. Some yes, some no.

5:05So the point being here is that sometimes, to go back to the issue at hand, I have an argument with somebody about wigs. And at the end of the argument, listen. If you're Ashkenazi and you want to rely on the Ashkenazi Poskim that say you can have wigs, fine. But you have to look at what Rav Elyashiv, the leading Ashkenazi Posek of his time, Rav Kanievsky, and all of the major Poskim said. Even the ones that said, Rav Elyashiv didn't say it's not allowed. If you're Ashkenazi and you want to rely on the Ashkenazi poskim that say you can have wigs, fine. But you have to look at what Rav Elyashiv, the leading Ashkenazi posek of his time, Rav Kanievsky, and all of the major poskim said. Even the ones that said... Rav Elyashiv didn't say it's not allowed. But even if you look at the couple, the couple that said it's allowed, the couple, none of them, that's not the biggest poskim, but the couple that said that it's allowed, they never said it's allowed that you have to have a wig from your head all the way to your, you know, to your stomach. They said if you're going to have a wig, it has to be short, it has to be modest. That's number one. You can’t make it more attractive. So that's number one. Number two, when you compare the wigs that they permitted in their days versus the wigs of today, the Rabbanim are saying that the wigs of those days, even a blind person would have known it's a wig. Meaning they look like straw. They look terrible. So to say that the wigs of today, they look better looking than the natural born hair, obviously this is not the same wigs that they permitted. That's number two.

6:09when you compare the wigs that they permitted in their days versus the wigs of today, the Rabbanim are saying that the wigs of those days, even a blind person would have known it's a wig. Meaning, they looked like straw. They looked terrible. So, to say that the wigs of today look better than natural-born hair, obviously, these are not the same wigs that they permitted. That's number two. Number three, you have another issue. You have another very big issue. There's only a couple that say it's okay. But one of the Gedolei HaDor said, after doing research, I found there's at least 85 poskim that say it's not allowed to wear a wig under any condition. At least 85 of the leading poskim say it's not allowed at all. So let's say you have two, three, maybe four, say it's okay, five. Those five are better than the other 85 of the biggest giants of the generations?

7:21So your whole life you're going to say it's okay to listen to those five, to those three, to those two, but to go against the 85? You're okay with that? Because the ones that say it's not okay, they're not just saying it's not okay, but you know what, don't worry about it. The ones that are saying it's not okay, like for example, the Baba Sali. Baba Sali says, a woman who wears a wig is... going to see the downside of it when she goes to Gehinnom because they're going to use the wig as material to burn her. They're not very nice about it when they're saying you're not allowed. They're not saying, it's not a big deal. It's a problem. The ones that are against wigs, it's a very, very serious problem. She has 85 at least. So that's number three. Number four. that I don't think is the biggest one. It's the biggest atomic bomb. Because it's the only one that no one's addressing right now. If you want to listen to the poskim, to this one, to that one, fine. Let's say you found yourself an excuse. Let's say you found yourself an excuse that you're going to listen to the poskim and wear a wig. Fine. Ashkenazi, Sephardi, whatever you want to be. Here's the problem that no one's addressing.

8:40after doing some serious research, and B'ezrat Hashem will come out with something eventually, like some movie of some kind or whatever, but after doing some serious research, market research, which is what I did for 16 years for a living, it's almost impossible, it's almost impossible to get a wig that doesn't come from Avodah Zarah. 99.99999% of all wigs come from India and China, and they get their wigs from their temples. People, as a korban to their false gods, shave their heads. They do it every year. And according to statistics, they said that out of the billion people approximately that India has, Every family, every person has donated their hair at least twice. So 2 billion people have pretty much donated just from India, at the very least, the minimum. There are tens of thousands of tons from these temples. To such an extent that everyone knows that the Vatican is the number one richest entity in the world. The Vatican owns more real estate than McDonald's.

10:06Who's the second richest entity in the world? I'm talking about an entity bigger than Apple, bigger than IBM, bigger than Walmart. The Vatican is bigger than all of them. Who's number two? The Indian temple where they donate the hair. Why do they get it? Because there are six people donating their hair? No, because there are lines out the door, out the building, out the street, out of the city. Every single day, people are donating their hair. Pilgrims are donating their hair. So now, there are different shows. You can look up on the internet if you want. You can do your own research if you'd like until we get our research, and it takes some time, you know, to put it into something. But pretty much, you see that all of the wigs are coming from this. But what happened was, there was a big balagan a little over 10, 12 years ago where somebody said, "Look, all the wigs are coming from India." So the Gedolei HaDor made a big stink about it. There was a big thing. They started burning all the wigs in Yerushalayim.

11:08But then somebody came out and said, no, no, no, no. We're going to get kosher wigs. We're going to go watch. We're going to go to India and make sure that the people we're getting the hair from are not doing avodah zarah. Now, whoever is naive enough to believe this nonsense, good luck to you. What can I tell you? I can't help you. I can't help somebody who's not willing to help themselves. Or they say, no, no, we're getting them from Europe. That's what most people say. No, no, we're getting European wigs. We're getting European wigs. When was the last time you saw an Italian woman shaving their hair? Never. Never. Why? Because they value their beauty more than they value their life. That's true. My wife's Italian, I know. Trust me, they love beauty. My wife is a very beautiful woman. She knows. She's the one that told me this. She goes, are you serious? Do you think that somebody Italian is ever going to shave their head? For a few dollars, for a million dollars, you're going to shave their head. What, are you crazy? Who shaves their head? A European wig? No, no, so that's what we do. So it doesn't make sense that the Italians are going to shave their head. Maybe the French. The French are even worse. No chance they're going to shave their head. They value their beauty even more than the Italians. Okay, maybe the English. No chance in the world.

12:29So we started looking all over Europe. No way, no way, it's not part of anyone's heritage. So then we started doing research. We found this whole video by a big news organization research place. A guy that, unfortunately, a Jewish guy, started the wig business. Like made the whole hair extension business, maybe like 25 years ago. And of course... So this person, they had a whole interview about him. The guy became a billionaire. And at least in this world he's a billionaire, in the next world... But nonetheless... A guy, unfortunately a Jewish guy, that started the wig business, like made the whole hair extension business, maybe like 25 years ago. And of course... So this person, they had a whole interview about him. The guy became a billionaire. At least in this world he's a billionaire, in the next world... But nonetheless... He shows you his whole process of where this European wig is coming from. And you see all of the European wigs, all of the everything wigs, from India. It just says here. Why? Because it goes from India, then it goes for processing in China. So it says made in China then. Then China sells it to England or France or some other place. Then they do the next step of the processing. Once you start touching it, painting it, or do something to it, it becomes yours.

13:46So then somebody asks, okay, what about the blonde wigs? When was the last time you saw an Indian woman that's blonde? My friend, they paint them. And you see in the same movie, they paint them blonde, they paint them red, they paint them whatever color you want. Whatever color you want, they paint them. And they show you the whole process, and it's all coming from India. Now, to say that there's... Why do I say 99.9%? Because it's always possible, unlikely, but possible, for somebody to go to somebody else and say, listen, I want to buy your hair. And that person saying, okay. Some, I don't know, some Israeli... I actually have a cousin like this. Uh... Her daughter wanted to be a hero, and she wanted to donate her hair to some cancer patient. So an Israeli girl donated her long hair to some cancer patient. Okay, but how many Israelis are doing this? Six? Seven? They're not supplying the entire wig business. Or you have some woman in Wisconsin who grew her hair over 20 years and sold it. Okay, that's it, she grew it, she sold it, it's over. How many of those women in Wisconsin and Iowa do you have? They're not supplying the tens of thousands of tons of wigs every year.

14:57So that's why I say 99.9%, it's possible that you may have the one, but it's unlikely. Why? Because the overwhelming majority of them are coming from India. So now you have a bigger problem than all of the poskim. You have a bigger problem than whether it's allowed to wear a wig or not allowed to wear a wig, whether it's long or it's short, whether it's black or it's white or it's red. You have a different problem. Why? Because this specific issue, no one allows. What is this issue? Benefiting from Avodah Zarah. Once something was ever used for Avodah Zarah, you are never allowed to benefit from it. Gemara Masechet Avodah Zarah. There's a whole Gemara about it. You're never allowed to benefit from it. No Posek is going to tell you something different. Once it's used for Avodah Zarah, that's it. You must destroy it. So when Hashem said, Am Yisrael, go to Eretz Yisrael, but burn all of the Asherah trees.

16:02Why burn the trees, mesuken? Why are we going to burn the trees? We don't need to burn the trees. It's hot. We don't need it. It's not New York where it's freezing cold. No, no, no. All of those trees were used for Avodah Zarah. Once they were used for Avodah Zarah, once somebody bowed to them... must destroy them. You can't even look at them, you can't benefit from them, you must burn them, you must destroy them from the face of the earth. You can't even make pots and pans, you can't make anything from them. You must destroy them. Once a wig comes from a source of Avodah Zarah, you must destroy it. So now, who can tell me with confidence, what woman in the world can tell me, or herself really, who cares about me? Who can look in the mirror, what woman in the world can look in the mirror with her nice long wig, And look in a mirror and say, you know what? I am 100% confident that my wig came from a righteous person who is not doing idol worship. 100% sure. It has to be 100%. It can't be 90%. Why? Because if it's 90%, you're actually an idol worshiper. You're supporting idol worship. It's not like it's a small sin. Like, listen, you ate something that's not like glatt. It's kosher, but it's not glatt kosher.

17:14It's not Beit Yosef. It's not Beit Yosef. It's not... Okay, it's kosher, but it's not the highest level of kashrut. No, it's not that. It's idol worship or not. That's a serious problem. That's a serious problem. So now you have yourself a serious problem. So now I have these debates. To go back, do you guys even remember the original argument why I even brought up this whole wig situation? So I said that sometimes I have debates with people, and I know they're looking for the truth. I remember a few lectures that I did in New York. I said something that Rav Nissim Yagen said a long time ago, and he says this: Wig, no wig. Only one question to anybody: When anybody wears a wig, it's because they're trying to fulfill the will of Hashem. They're trying to be righteous. They're not wearing a wig because they want to look like Paris Hilton or some other prostitute. They're wearing a wig because they are trying to do the will of Hashem. They're trying to be righteous, cover their hair. Usually. Wig, no wig. Doesn't anybody ever ask themselves the question: Who's the only person, who's the only woman that we mention in the Torah that showed her hair? The Sotah, the wayward woman, the woman that's being accused of possibly cheating on her husband. Part of the embarrassment of trying to convince her and intimidate her to admit that she cheated on her husband so they don't have to have her drink this water and kill her.

18:34Who's the only person, who's the only woman that we mention in the Torah that showed her hair? The sotah, the wayward woman, the woman that's being accused of possibly cheating on her husband. Part of the embarrassment of trying to convince her and intimidate her to admit that she cheated on her husband is by taking off the mitpachat, taking off the hair covering, and showing her hair. Meaning that even a woman that cheated on her husband, even a woman that's a cheater, even a woman that's a prostitute, still would not go around with hair uncovered if she's married. Right. So here's the thing. So Rav Nisani again is asking the question, why does everybody want to look like the sotah? is by taking off the mitpachat, taking off the hair covering, and showing her hair. Meaning that even a woman who cheated on her husband, even a woman who is a cheater, even a woman who is a prostitute, still would not go around with hair uncovered if she's married. Right. So here's the thing. So Rav Nissan again is asking the question, why does everybody want to look like the sotah? Why does everybody want to look like the sultan? It's not a compliment to look like the sultan. So now you have yourself a serious problem. So sometimes I have this question, and Baruch Hashem, when I said this in the New York lecture, Rabbi Zitron, which B'ezrat Hashem, I'm going to do a lecture at his place tomorrow.

19:48Rabbi Zitron, which B'ezrat Hashem, I'm going to do a lecture at his place tomorrow. Did you have someone argue with you in that lecture? No, no one argued. I just said this during the lecture. And Rabbi Zitron told me that one of the women who came there came to him after the lecture. She said, "Right now, I'm taking on covering my hair. I never thought about it that way. From today on, I'm covering my hair, Baruch Hashem, with a scarf." That's what happens when you say the truth. She saw the truth. She said, "I never thought about it this way. I never thought it's this big of a deal. Cover my hair, wig, this, that. But I never thought. Who wants to be like the Sotah?" At that moment, she told him. And he told me. He sent me a message. He's like, "You wouldn't believe it. The woman that day took on Kisui Rosh." You've just experienced another Torah class brought to you by TorahAnytime.com.

BH Headquarters