YouMustSpeakOut
YouMustSpeakOut 00:00:00 Intoduction 00:00:00 Divine Justice and Accountability 00:00:18 Pharaoh's Dilemma and Advisers 00:00:59 Yitro's Righteous Path and Reward 00:01:47 Bilaam's Wickedness and Demise 00:02:15 Iyov's Silence and Suffering
Transcript
0:00My dear talmidim, we've been delving into the profound wisdom of our Chazal, particularly in the Midrashim that illuminate the narratives of Sefer Shemot. As we mentioned, the Midrash in Pirkei DeRabbi Eliezer and elsewhere teaches us about the figure of Iyov, Job, and how our Sages, zichronam livracha, explain his unique role, even among the advisors of Pharaoh. Now, let us reflect on a deeper concept that often arises in these discussions of divine justice and individual culpability. Often, when confronted with suffering, a person might ask, 'Why me? What have I done to deserve this?' But our Sages present a much more nuanced perspective. So, let's look at this, let's see the magnitude of your single sin, not even considering a previous gilgul or your entire life. Just one single act that you did, and compare it to the punishment that you're receiving. And of course, everybody that has read the Midrash, or has read the Gemara, understands that sometimes the reckoning for an action is far greater than we might initially perceive. It's not always a straightforward one-to-one correlation in our limited human understanding, but rather a profound manifestation of HaKadosh Baruch Hu's perfect justice, which considers the full ripple effect of every choice. This understanding gives us a deeper appreciation for the warnings of our Chazal regarding even seemingly minor transgressions, and reinforces the importance of teshuvah. We continue our shiur on Sefer Shemot, delving into the early chapters of Exodus and exploring the events that led up to the enslavement of Bnei Yisrael. We're discussing what happened beforehand, providing a commentary on Exodus and the historical context. You know that Iyov was one of the three generals of Pharaoh. When Pharaoh asked for counsel regarding the Israelites, as the Midrash teaches us, Pharaoh convened his three most trusted advisors. One was Yitro, who had the moral courage to tell Pharaoh to leave the Israelites alone, acknowledging their goodness and their contribution to the land. The second was Bil'am, who gave the wicked advice to drown the male children. And the third was Iyov, who, rather than speak up against the wickedness, chose to remain silent. This silence, unfortunately, was interpreted as tacit approval of Pharaoh's malevolent schemes, leading him to conclude: "What should we do with these Israelites? Let's fool them."
0:31We are learning about the period leading up to the Exodus, the oppressive decrees Pharaoh placed upon our ancestors. Pharaoh was deeply troubled by the growing number and strength of Bnei Yisrael. He gathered his advisors and pondered, "What should we do with these Israelites? Let's fool them! Let's fool these Israelites! What should we do? How? Who? What? When?" How did Pharaoh arrive at this conclusion, this idea of fooling the Jewish people? Why didn't he simply say, "Let's leave them alone?" Because, as the Midrash tells us, Pharaoh had three primary advisors. He asked one of these advisors, "What should we do?" That advisor was, of course, Yitro. Yitro responded, "Leave them alone! They are good people; they helped build this land, this great empire!" However, Pharaoh, in his stubbornness and cruelty, was not swayed by Yitro's plea for justice. We see this truly remarkable phenomenon: even someone who initially faced challenges, perhaps even persecution, or had to make a difficult choice that seemed like a setback, can ultimately achieve greatness through Hashgacha Pratit. We learn about a particular individual who didn't like that advice and had to run away. For this, he merited becoming a Jew, and his children became righteous Jews. They reached such a point that when they arrived at the Midbar Yehudah (the Desert of Judah), they actually learned Torah from the Chachamim, and each and every single one of them ascended to a tremendous spiritual level. This highlights the incredible potential within every neshamah, for when one truly desires to connect with HaKadosh Baruch Hu and His Torah, the path is opened, allowing for spiritual growth far beyond what might seem possible at first glance.
1:26...allowing for spiritual growth far beyond what might seem possible at first glance. And it is in this spirit that we are talking about tens of thousands of people whom he brought to the Midbar and learned Torah. They didn't even know Alef-Beit, but they knew that they feared HaShem. That was enough to teach them the rest of the Torah and get them to a level where they literally ascended. On the other hand, you also had Bilam HaRasha. And what was the agenda of this wicked individual? "Indeed, our Sages teach us about the profound wickedness of Bilaam HaRasha, describing him as the most wicked person on earth. He misused his prophetic gift for malevolent purposes, and his counsel against Am Yisrael was devastating. He advised Balak to cause the Jewish people to sin through immorality and idol worship, saying, 'Let us cause them to stumble,' and so on. For his wicked counsel, Bilaam was eventually killed by the Jewish army during the war against Midian, and thereby lost his eternal share in Olam HaBa. While Pinchas ben Elazar ben Aharon HaKohen, who eventually becomes Eliyahu HaNavi, performed a zealous act to stop the plague, he did not kill Bilaam HaRasha. As the Gemara in Masechet Sanhedrin explicitly states, he has no portion in the World to Come, despite having been a prophet and having spoken directly to HaShem. Our Sages teach that he is in the deepest levels of Gehinnom and will never be released. His terrible end stands as a profound lesson on the immense power of speech and the grave consequences of using it for evil, especially against Am Yisrael."
2:15My dear talmidim, we often discuss the critical importance of speaking up for truth and justice, and the grave consequences of silence. Our holy midrashim teach us about the fateful council Pharaoh held regarding the Bnei Yisrael. Three advisors were present: Bilaam, Yitro, and Iyov. Bilaam, as we know, advised Pharaoh to drown all the male Jewish infants, Rachmana litzlan. The most wicked person on earth, that was Bilaam. Now, the third person involved in that critical decision was Iyov. Iyov was a righteous person; indeed, he was a righteous Noachide. However, Iyov was afraid to talk. And because he didn't speak up, the weights, so to speak, remained balanced. One side argued that the Jews, the Bnei Yisrael, were good; the other side contended they were bad. So the tiebreaker, the deciding factor, was Iyov. Since Iyov chose to keep his mouth quiet, the scale tipped towards inaction, allowing Pharaoh to continue his evil decrees, and for this, Iyov was later made to suffer the terrible travails detailed in Sefer Iyov, a stark lesson for all generations on the responsibility of the righteous to speak truth to power. We've been discussing how individuals can deviate from the proper path and the severe repercussions of such choices. And this is exactly why what happened, decided, 'let's go and build on' a new foundation, because Sha'ul HaTarsi himself was, unfortunately, a wicked person, so of course he was going to lean towards the wicked side naturally. And, for that, Iyov — Iyov HaTzaddik — who stayed quiet, got all of the suffering, all of the yissurim, that befell him in the entire Sefer Iyov, for anyone who wishes to delve deeper into this profound narrative. This teaches us critical lessons about the importance of adhering to Torah and not allowing external influences to sway our path, always striving to understand the divine will as expounded by Chazal.